I Dunno... FIRST TIME HEARING!!! Pearl Jam - "Mother" (Pink Floyd Cover) Live. REACTION!!!

[@scottderechinsky9896]

I noticed you are reacting to all Pearl Jam covering other bands. Do you know any of their original music? They are up there with the bands they're covering as far as awesome songs.

[@THEDavidHeretic]

Keeeeeeeep watching the channel.....

[@CarlosSierralta]

I like that. shows the respect that Pearl Jam pays to their influences!

[@THEDavidHeretic]

@@CarlosSierralta Always a good thing to pay homage to your influences.

[@christianeflentie1228]

And yes, Boom Gaspar!! They give him shout outs all the time.

[@jimmylee2388]

Pearl Jam is a awesome live band. I wish they did a cover album. They sing other singers songs so well.

[@watchdog3761]

Great reaction on this pearl jam performance, another showcase of how versatile pearl jam is...next you should consider eddie vedder doing Bob Dylan Master of War in 92 during the 30th Dylan Anniversary concert celebration, it was mind blowing and very convincing

[@THEDavidHeretic]

Just added it to the que, thank you for the link.

[@selaimutiara]

@@THEDavidHeretic just to ensure that you got the right link kzbin.info/www/bejne/mqjEY52BZd2aos0

[@pauldocmusic2411]

Amazing how many artists inspired by pink floyd, very very few covers get near the original especially floyd. I just enjoy hearing other artists covering them. I prefer vedder doing masters of war though

[@youravgjoe42]

Boom Gaspar tours with them to play keyboards. You often hear the crowd chant "BOOOOM" after particularly great keyboard highlights. Boom is perhaps featured best in the track Crazy Mary. Pearl Jam has NEVER repeated the same set list. Each show is unique, but Crazy Mary is frequently in the rotation and for good reason. I have a feeling you'd particularly love that one. Thanks again for the solid reaction and for the shout outs.

[@THEDavidHeretic]

I've seen Crazy Mary mentioned a couple times, looks like I'm gonna have to add that one to the que. Link?

[@joecohn8896]

@@THEDavidHeretic I would either review the live version from Santiago Chile (kzbin.info/www/bejne/e2GtqIpsZ5ihZ6M), or the live version from MSG (kzbin.info/www/bejne/hZexnmeDj7GDiJY) . Production value of the video is a little better in the MSG clip, but musically I think the Santiago version is ever so slightly better. Either version is A++++++++++ so you can't go wrong picking either one. Whichever one you don't review on the channel you should listen to in your private time for your own personal enjoyment.

[@jameswisdom1719]

I know you don’t like grunge but you love high energy live music so you will seriously be doing yourself a favor by watching the performance of “Porch” from Pink Pop 92.

[@THEDavidHeretic]

I would definitely consider reacting to this. Link?

[@watchdog3761]

@@THEDavidHeretic i can help you with the link, this is raw pearl jam in their twenties Porch Pinkpop 92...kzbin.info/www/bejne/bZDIdYCgq5V7rbc

[@katenone5562]

Boom Gaspar- the giant Hawaiian- story goes that Eddie met him surfing, they talked surfing and music and started jamming. He eventually joined the band on their tours for many years now.

[@advantagevarnsen7436]

Boom Gasper on 🎹 he really is the unofficial 6th member

[@THEDavidHeretic]

THAT'S the name...yes thank you for the reminder.

[@AllMovies-uo3ot]

Pearl Jam ❤❤❤❤

[@CarlosSierralta]

I agree with you about that sponsor.

[@mickya3011]

Nice... keyboard player is Boom Gasper, joined the band in early 2000's I believe.. solid reaction, and yes it's pronounced "Mickey" lol trying to think of other bands doing covers but I always lead back to Pearl Jam 😂"man who sold the world" covered by Nirvana is great. Pearl jam does a mean version of "masters of war" on letterman 🤙

[@CarlosSierralta]

In the keyboards, the Great Boom Big Kahuna Gaspar, a hawaian Ed’s friend and in the band since 2001 as the 6th unofficial member.

[@tedurbina527]

Thanks alot brother...good reaction really enjoyed it. BTW good job on saying my name..lol.

[@THEDavidHeretic]

So it is pronounced "Ur-Bee-nah"? I want to be sure because I want to pronounce it correctly.

[@tedurbina527]

@@THEDavidHeretic yes sir thanks brother I really enjoy your reactions

[@THEDavidHeretic]

@@tedurbina527 Thank you Ted I do appreciate the words of encouragement. I will continue to strive for improvement while maintaining the honesty and integrity of the channel and myself. Thank you for watching, I hope you enjoyed the show.

[@sarahdaw6648]

Boom!!!

[@ilachow]

Did you catch the measures of 5/8, 6/8 and 9/8 in the verse? Very cool!

[@christianeflentie1228]

The lower range is where Eddie lives so I doubt there's much strain there. In my opinion which is only mine folks, he sounds better in his lower registers. Except for maybe Oceans on MTv unplugged. 😁

[@katenone5562]

Check out either Corduroy from their 2016 Let’s Play Two documentary or Release from the same show- 2016 Wrigley Field but it’s a fan video- they’re original songs.

[@THEDavidHeretic]

I did Corduroy from the Let's Play Two documentary....it got immediately blocked. I'm actually gonna risk a copyright strike and dispute it....hopefully they'll see that I am actually reviewing it as well as reacting to it.

[@gregarcher6580]

Pearl Jam - Masters of War on Letterman

[@THEDavidHeretic]

I've seen this one mentioned a couple times....looks like it's gonna have to go into the que. Thank you for watching, hope you enjoyed the show.

[@FeelItRising]

@@THEDavidHeretic don't pick the Letterman version (they had to neuter it, make it shorter, for tv). They did this song a million times better other times. Bob Dylan 30th anniversary for young Eddie or Fenway Park 2016 for new Eddie.

[@tedurbina527]

You gotta do Grand Funk Railroad "Inside looking out" live 1969...knowing your music knowledge you will enjoy this one.

[@christianeflentie1228]

I agree with your review cuz I'm not crazy about that song either. I remember being disappointed when it aired because I knew they did a good job but I was just not thrilled.

[@mikeclare1625]

Yeah gotta do crazy Mary masters of war and I believe in miracles covers by Pearl Jam

[@THEDavidHeretic]

I've seen the Crazy Mary one mentioned a couple times in the comments....looks like it might have to go in the que. Link?

[@kimberlybretkertz1258]

​@@THEDavidHeretic Here's a link to a famous all acoustic concert they did, with some really good covers of Masters of War, Crazy Mary, I Believe in Miracles, and Johnny Cash's 25 minutes to go, basically all the stuff people are requesting. Consider this one stop shopping! The video's not the best, but what ya gonna do, the audio sounds good. kzbin.info/www/bejne/m5ycdJKsftiaeJo Location on the Set list: I Believe in Miracles - 51:32 Masters of War - 1:25:58 Crazy Mary - 1:39:40 25 Minutes to Go - 1:47:21

[@tdirstein]

Check out in my tree from madison square garden 2003. But first.....do your homework and listen to studio version from no code. Then you can do your reaction to live version from msg...as far as i know only show to do that version.

[@lesliewoodley2384]

Eddie can sing anything!!! Check out Eddie Vedder doing All Along the watch tower. Eoic

[@THEDavidHeretic]

Great song....love Jimi's version of it over SRV's...I know that's kind of blasphemous but I don't care I like Jimi's version better. I'll definitely consider putting that in the que. Link?

[@FeelItRising]

Jimi's version is epic. Listen to PJ's version, but no video needed. :)

[@christianeflentie1228]

Love Reign o'er Me.... VH1

[@THEDavidHeretic]

Already did that one, you should definitely check it out. Thank you for watching, hope you enjoyed the show.

[@christianeflentie1228]

@@THEDavidHeretic how did I miss it?!?! Saw your EVH tribute one but it was on my TV where I can't respond. They played around here constantly when I was too young to even pretend to get in. I loved the band, honestly. I admired them but I loathed their front man. I'm so sorry EVH is gone so young. Even though not my style of music I could appreciate his talent.

[@rmyikzelf5604]

Not a bad version at all. Vocals, keys and acoustic on point. But to me, the 1980 live version of Floyd themselves remains the best. And the solo in this is... lacking a lot of the details and nuance. Especially the second part. Where are the rakes and slides? And where's the volume!

[@Esl1999]

I think Pearl Jam chose Mother to cover because it’s a simpler song to perform. Pink Floyd’s 1980 live performance is superior in almost every way to this but whatcha gunna do, it is what it is.

[@jmurray2018]

Didn’t like this one- thought it was boring his vocals to me sound off or were in the wrong key I’ll give it 3.5 hope there’s better pink floyd songs out there

[@soocurtin1207]

Sorry, but i think its awful.