I Finally Discovered Perpetual Motion

[@rodchallis8031]

Being able to successfully hide the external power source is the key to a really good perpetual motion machine.

[@Angular777]

Hide? They always have the power in plain sight and claim they are getting more power out. No the key to successful perpetual motion machines is getting idiots to believe you!

[@erencansever8464]

True

[@bamanevishwajeet]

😂🔥

[@work2live756]

😂🤜🏼

[@Capt_Chaos_91]

I was so confused at first 😂

[@general_paul]

Rules for creating perpetual motion machine: #1. Always hide the external power source when demonstration is being done #2. Make the fundamental working principle of your machine subtle while explaining it to others. #3. Never forget rules 1, 2 and 3.

[@GraysonQuickBuilds]

Ha... Ha... Ha... I've never heard that one before

[@Hello_there497]

Your rule 3 made this comment perpetual as u added 'not to forget rule 3' also.... lol

[@general_paul]

@@Hello_there497you got it. Rule 3 will compel everyone to remember 1st n 2nd rule and at the same time make them remember rule 3

[@william3371]

@Miles Doyle I will read this later

[@hmrdarkhawk8543]

Also, mind having a decent amount of friction

[@NaptownClassic]

The ending to the egg story is that after he cracked the egg, the onlookers said "Well, anyone could do that!" To which Columbus said, "They can now, once someone showed them how." The story has been attributed to tons of people, many who lived well before Columbus. The point was that something which might seem easy to you, once you've seen someone else do it, might be exceptionally difficult for someone doing it the first time.

[@josephturner7569]

Yep. It ain't magic when you know how it's done.

[@Crazytesseract]

Columbus was a rascal. He ate dog meat from the tribals.

[@Crazytesseract]

​​@@josephturner7569 Any technology sufficiently advanced, is indistinguishable from magic. UFOs are possible duocylinder shaped objects that move into and out of 3D space from 4D and higher spatial dimensions. This is not magic.

[@peterk.4266]

Thanks genious, now I feel enlightened.

[@AnderMartin]

Columbus was definitly not smart enough to come up with that

[@blueredbrick]

"Look, Im not adding any energy to it!" Next shot: shows how he adds energy to it ;). Love this guy.

[@TheActionLab]

I said *I* wasn't adding energy...very sneaky

[@blueredbrick]

@@TheActionLab You are paying for the electricity are you not? ;p equally sneaky..

[@4fr0pl]

He got me there. I was ready to do some party tricks with my ball bearing then man tells me it's actually a magnet.

[@aiiiia9971]

@@TheActionLab 😏 I see what you did there

[@westonding8953]

@@TheActionLab genius!

[@duser]

Leave it to Tesla to decide to one up a historic story by combining two physics principals to create sorcery.

[@gabor6259]

*principles

[@vincentdreemurr]

prips

[@RandomYT05_01]

If Tesla was born a century earlier, he'd've been burned at the stake.

[@Yaswil]

pri

[@binita4672]

That's how every physicist, at the very least has done.

[@declansongxizhevictoriasch2066]

0:15 MADE IN HEAVEN

[@Kodgaming-oh4qu]

💀

[@JamesContos85]

You should have saved this for April 1st! That would have made an excellent practical April Fool's joke!! 🤣 🤣

[@buggmann862]

It's already April 1st Somewhere

[@greego5952]

Technically April 1st in some places. New Zealand Australia

[@alihorda]

isn't this video made for April 1st?

[@bettercalldelta]

@@alihorda it was published on march 31

[@alihorda]

@@bettercalldelta for me it displayed April 1st lol

[@flamingmonkays]

Reminds me of those magnetic "pills" that I used in chem lab to stir certain liquids. :)

[@liamramsay2264]

a magnetic stir bar?

[@flamingmonkays]

@@liamramsay2264 Not quite sure what they call them, but that sounds about right. Put the beaker on top of a rotating magnetic field, drop in a stick-shaped piece of metal (which I believe was plastic-coated), and watch it mix.

[@Water-Wheelz]

Pretty sure it's a stir rod, you place it in a liquid or something you want to mix, put it on a magnetic plate made for it, turn it on then it spins

[@beepbeepgamer1305]

oh yeah the stir bars, we have those in my school lab.

[@nateplumley6821]

You just invented a new kitchen appliance nobody needs. Brilliant!

[@bride4jesus0126]

It’s not a ball bearing, it’s a magnet…..that explained everything right there! 😅

[@taragnor]

The answer is always magnets.

[@epilepticatarave]

Magnest is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be unnatural

[@lulz4lulz]

​@jhdhgklfglg It's not, as they don't exist nor are they possible.

[@sjsj4741]

Lmao that got me too!

[@khululyp]

@@taragnor And the question is always "how do they work?"

[@dadrumer]

There is also another point to the egg rising itself up in the air: The flat lying egg has a lot more rotational energy because its moment of inertia is way higher, spinning around that axis, than in the upright position. It still needs friction to rise itself in that position, but the reason behind it is a simple minimisation of energy state.

[@jonathanbreedlove4286]

I knew inertia had something to do with it.

[@coltonsmith3724]

Sounds like word salad

[@SedoKai]

It doesn't actually need friction. Over time, a rotating rigid body will always process to its most stable axis of rotation, even in vacuum with no external fields acting on it. As rotational energy is added to the body, quantum effects in the body will increase at a geometric rate, speeding up its procession.

[@seanmackidd7947]

I like this explanation. However I disagree. I think the friction provides enough resistance to redirect the momentum from its perfect line, and the magnetism causes it to over-correct when seeking to return to the least amount of friction. Then opposite magnetic field sends it back even faster, causing it to over correct. This continues until all the molecules that make up the egg experience the magnetism exactly equally from both poles. At this point the egg appears to be standing motionless at absolute zero between the opposing fields.

[@dazofthemoo1531]

​@@SedoKaiisn't the surface of the flask an external force? I understand the aerodynamic reason for it standing up, and the reason if its on a 'flask' in a vacuum. ( I think)

[@fira2001]

All content on this channel is so satisfying for the dormant physics nerd in us

[@Horus2Osiris]

Physics nerd inside kept alive and awake by ActionLab! Doesn't hurt...

[@123jbuster]

in*

[@axywrll6015]

@@123jbuster dormant physics nerd in us? hmm, sounds about right..

[@roelfjoubert1128]

That's so well put. :)

[@UhKimboze]

Couldn’t have said it better myself!

[@stonetrouble5053]

The egg turned upright not because of friction but because any unrestrained spinning object will spin about its principal axis of inertia. This would also happen with no friction if it was spun fast enough that the torque generated was enough to overcome the force of gravity.

[@kronosx7]

There's no such thing as a frictionless surface. The less friction there is, the more speed is required. Still requires friction.

[@DheRadman]

​@@kronosx7 the frictionless surface is called space and this effect can be shown there

[@random1744]

@@DheRadman isn’t that not a surface tho /gen Like not disagreeing but isn’t a void not a surface 😭

[@DheRadman]

@@random1744 you're right it's not really a surface, but the only reason we're talking about surfaces here is because you need to place objects on something else while on earth. In space, that restriction isn't there so space itself can serve as the location where something is 'placed'.

[@scoopsta6141]

@DheRadman Technically space can be a surface if we’re talking about different dimensions of space-time and/or brane theory

[@MrMindBlow]

*Great* explanation! Love the content! 🧠👀

[@MrMindBlow]

@@TheSummerLab1 LMNOP.

[@amateurishanimation]

@@MrMindBlow QRSTUV

[@ito4167]

@@amateurishanimation WXYZ..A

[@the25thdoctor]

@@amateurishanimation WXYZ

[@kikisstudio4978]

@@amateurishanimation WXYZ

[@SenkJu]

3:33 Looks like the egg was actually beginning to stand up just as he cut to another video, lol.

[@trm4life]

They actually showed us the egg trick in cooking classes in school. That way you could tell if your hard boiled egg was done. If it was still liquid, it wouldn't stand up.

[@scorchedearth1451]

You should tap it hard enough on the table so the shell breaks a little bit. 😂

[@bolwinklemoose1999]

This is how my mom showed me how to tell if an egg I took out of the refrigerator was hard boiled or not (had a messy episode pealing the shell from an egg I thought was boiled). Spin it. If it keeps spinning, it's bouled. If it slows and stops quickly, it's raw.

[@bolwinklemoose1999]

Set a football on the pavement with its ends horizontal and spin it. It will rise up and spin on one end or the other. It's easier than if you try to spin it on one end or the other from the start. Makes a good tailgate beer challenge.

[@NICEFINENEWROBOT]

@@bolwinklemoose1999 Sometimes, especially if you're new to the trick, you don't know whether spinning should be considered fast (boiled egg) or slow (raw egg). But if you spin it, then stop and immediately release it, a cooked egg will remain motionless, while a raw egg will start moving again, just more slowly. That's because the fluid inside hasn't stopped spinning.

[@konoveldorada5990]

Plot Twist: *Action Lab thought that today is April Fools.*

[@an2939]

It was in my country

[@thejadedjester4935]

I've become so accustomed to april fools videos being on a different date usually that it actually threw me off that so many people didn't realise that it was simply a matter of them not being in the same timezone.

[@an2939]

@@thejadedjester4935 same lol

[@jacksonbernardo670]

1:57 so... Nikolas Tesla made that complex machine only for a joke?

[@MlorenDraymeer]

Well to be fair the internet hadn't been invented yet so he had nothing better to do :D

[@MDILeon]

@@MlorenDraymeer there is nothing better to do than that, even with the internet...

[@atnas903]

@jacksonbernardo670 when Thomas Edison interviewed him, he said that he will only recruit Nikola Tesla in his company if he rise up the egg ...

[@DoICareBro]

Every now and then someone discovers perpetual motion 😂

[@Frosty_tha_Snowman]

I accidentally created a perpetual motion machine once. My cousin took a Vyvanse out of a buddy's prescription that he left in my room, thinking it was tylenol because it was blue and white, kind of how tylenol is blue and red.. then he went to the ping pong table that had a wall to bounce it back to yourself, and did that for a few hours.

[@verlax8956]

cool

[@brainupwithmathsbyranon9410]

That's not perpetual motion. Your giving energy to the ball.

[@Frosty_tha_Snowman]

@@brainupwithmathsbyranon9410 are you serious?..

[@brainupwithmathsbyranon9410]

@@Frosty_tha_Snowman yep.

[@Frosty_tha_Snowman]

Who wants to tell Mr. Brain who doesn't know how to use "you're" and "your" correctly how satire works?

[@BadMann3rs]

2:34 "As All Things Should Be" 😂😂😂

[@anurag9477]

🥷

[@JosTheComrade1024]

Thats what she said

[@AshrellStudios753]

@@JosTheComrade1024 e

[@infamousschmuck292]

it be cool if you could make rings out of magnets, put them around each other and then have them on there and have them spin like that

[@castilater]

You mean like a gimbal or aerotrim? (Had to look up the name)

[@Dinnye01]

I love the clickbaity aspect of this channel. With the caveat that it is ALWAYS turns out to be true.

[@brando3342]

@FullMetal This one was not true though.

[@_Belteshazzar_]

Do you know what perpetual motion is?

[@biggerandbetterthings7222]

I was going to say the same thing! I'm upset he didn't use the word 'Angular Momentum' or did he, IDK, whatever that is, well less confusing then entropy!

[@KevinSmith-os5yz]

Now if only he would take the output energy and feed that back to the input, it would be free energy.

[@aphish_n_flips]

I hate it. I’ll be watching something, see the thumbnail and title, say “that’s not possible”, know that whatever is in the title will probably happen, then have to watch the video 😂 normally as part of the “one more video” routine

[@HaloHeathen]

3:50 The boxes are awesome. If you have a young child interested in science, these do the trick! I ordered the first box (vacuum), and the syringe (for creating a vacuum) was broken, so we couldn't use it. I ordered it for my nephews, on Thanksgiving day. It really was disappointing, but in the end it was my fault for not opening the package and inspecting beforehand. I tried numerous times to get ahold of them to get a new syringe, being a newly released product, and during the holidays it took 2 months before I received the new syringe. Satisfied with the situation, I was certainly surprised when I received, months later, the second box (self pouring fluid) as well! I might be a little biased, but I was still satisfied with my original situation being resolved, and the second box to me shows it's a quality company, and product!

[@violetflame6596]

You don't need a vacuum. just an electromagnetic field

[@HaloHeathen]

@@violetflame6596 are you selling one?

[@violetflame6596]

I do not. I am currently working on a bigger project atm

[@HaloHeathen]

@@violetflame6596 where do you get one then? But, really, if you're working on a bigger project, why don't I just get that instead? What project are you working on?

[@grantarmstrong2968]

I was about to through all my understanding of physics out the window until I realized he just used electromagnetic forces to do it

[@S85B50Engine]

I initially thought it was something about the ball bearing having very little friction

[@ranehan7726]

I mean, it would work better in a vacuum chamber.

[@flamingmonkays]

I thought the ball bearing was going to have something else inside, like liquid or a smaller ball with a smaller ball in that. Just kind of reminded me of spherical dice, for some reason.

[@S85B50Engine]

@@ranehan7726 yeah, but they already have a low enough friction that they would spin for a while

[@raphaelklaussen1951]

Actually, when he holds the jar in his hand the ball isn't isolated. The small tremor of his hand (we all have that), or the small movements of his hand due to his heart beat can, depending on frequency, pump (or extract) energy into (from) the spinning ball. With a little practice you can do this creating the illusion the ball moves forever on its own.

[@diamondcreeper0982]

Wouldn't the then lose its energy as vibrational (sound) energy?

[@Thelearner.023]

The hardest part of building a perpetual motion machine is figuring out where to hide the batteries

[@Dragon-Slay3r]

Griffin crown feather

[@Ride-Tahoe]

🐑

[@georgeplagianos6487]

Bro look at the transparent container you can see the green battery

[@wildone8397]

*Cable

[@paul_warner]

"if you don't give it any friction, it can't rise up" that's what she said

[@theadventuresofkentsawyeri5944]

You mean that's what"He" said. Unless it was a transvestite with a pecker.

[@camdenspehl3688]

He*

[@donjamesaikinromblon5145]

@@camdenspehl3688 wow just wow

[@paul_warner]

Come on y'all it's a joke damn

[@normalchannel2185]

Knew it. I knew that a magnet was being used

[@hpottergirl317]

I love your username 🤌🏻✨

[@aboveanonymous4810]

Thanks for spoiling the video😡

[@grannysvids]

Cheers mate, that saves me wasting my time! 👍

[@Gustavo-po9bd]

@@aboveanonymous4810 Bruh it is super obvious that it was magnets, you though it was magic? metal bending?

[@diegocorte-real9249]

Keep your guesses for yourself next time pls

[@danielpalmer643]

I've never heard that Columbus did this with an egg. I've often heard the story that Brunelleschi used this trick to explain how he would build the Duomo in Florence. Vasari gives the whole story. Columbus might have gotten the idea from Brunelleschi.

[@iz0mbie100]

You're right. He's wrong...

[@peterholzer4481]

Well the idiom is "the egg of Columbus", not "the egg of Brunelleschi". The story about Brunelleschi is a few years older than the one about Columbus, so it's likely that the author of the latter cribbed the idea from the author of the former. My guess is that neither Columbus nor Brunelleschi ever used the egg trick, but that doesn't matter. The idiom has entered the English language centuries ago, people know what it means, and whether the story it is based on is true or false is immaterial.

[@danielpalmer643]

@@peterholzer4481 Vasari writes, "It is said that the argument over the egg arose during the meeting in the following way. They wanted Filippo (Brunelleschi) to explain his intentions in detail and to show his model, as they had shown theirs, something that he did not want to do, and he in turn proposed to both foreign and Florentine masters that whoever could stand an egg upright upon a marble slab should execute the dome, since in this way their intelligence would be revealed. Therefore, when Filippo produced an egg, all those masters tried to make it stand upright. Then they asked Filippo to do it, and he graciously took the egg, cracked its bottom on the marble, and made it stand upright." This happened in 1420, but Vasari wrote 100 years later. The story about Columbus was in a 1565 book called 'History of the New World' by Girolamo Benzoni and supposedly happened when Columbus returned to Spain (according to the Wikipedia article, 'Egg of Columbus'). I think that Columbus heard about what Brunelleschi did and copied his idea, but that both stories are true.

[@aeromodeller1]

@@danielpalmer643 A little salt on the table will do it.

[@codis9091]

@@peterholzer4481 it does matter if neither of them did it. would it not matter if columbus is fictional character and never existed? you are living in a dream world peter

[@MiloJadez]

"I Finally Discovered Perpetual Motion" Shows a motor.

[@fluoroantimonic9950]

1:02 *expected visible disappointment*

[@westonding8953]

Amazing content! Perfect follow up from your last video!

[@ToBeeOrNotToBeHoney]

I love these things. I have a miniature top that is basically a brushless motor (magnet in the top_. As the pole passes near the coil it induces current to a transistor which switches on and then adds a tiny bit of power to the coil in the correct polarity for the pole (N/S) which is near the coil. The device is very small and consists of a coil, a 9v battery and a transistor. The battery easily will spin the top for days since it only requires power, and only when the top is near the coil. The top spins in a shallow parabolic dish. electronic are all hidden under the dish.

[@jahazbrooga309]

Understanding spin in macro size shapes is useful for understanding fundamental particles at the quantum level. Keep doing it. Did you like how I put a positive spin on that?

[@bober1019]

I almost laughed

[@ashleyfletcher2543]

Love everything you do. I know it inspires me to want to create the ideas locked away in my 50 yr old brain. I think most people with a little intellect have perpetual motion/energy ideas. If only it were not so expensive? Thanks again for inspiring people and I truly hope that there are lots of school age kids being inspired as well

[@shreyaschaturvedi8851]

Just before balancing the egg it looked liked like it was vibing to the background music 2:28 😂

[@brando3342]

The clickiest of click baits... but I still enjoyed the video haha

[@Yarxxter]

2:16 sounds like Mr. Krabbs walking

[@Pinkoshaberibunny]

Feels like what planktons robot mr krabs would sound like if it had legs

[@APOLLO-777BC]

Violating the laws of physics will get you arrested.

[@jameskinder891]

Or get you unalived

[@danielhama4558]

Huh? Initially I was thinking "this is Noble prize level stuff!!!" Now I'm concerned that that is not the case.

[@notsoberoveranalyzer8264]

Supposedly there’s a solid theory of being able to use the gravitational pull of a black hole for a p motion device. But on such a massive that scale it’s I wonder if a PMotion device would even be usable or relevant, or if we could just harness energy more effectively. Always blows my mind how all complex life ( as we know it) is produced by a fraction of the suns energy.

[@iCarus_A]

Isn't that as much a perpetual motion machine as the ISS or any of our satellites? They're always accelerating due to the earth's gravity but it's not really possible to harness energy from it

[@Corzappy]

@@iCarus_A They aren't constantly accelerating they're simply going so fast that the gravitational pull of the earth can't pull then down faster than the earth curves away from them. Also it's not perpetual motion because you have to dodge space debris.

[@Temari_Virus]

@@Corzappy Constant speed doesn't necessarily mean no acceleration. A change in direction counts as acceleration too. So while the magnitude of their velocities remains (roughly) the same, they're constantly accelerating towards the Earth

[@Corzappy]

@@Temari_Virus If they were constantly accelerating towards the earth they wouldn't be in orbit. If you measure their distance from the surface on one side of the earth compares to the other, they won't be any closer or farther away.

[@Temari_Virus]

@@Corzappy if they weren't accelerating, they would just travel in a straight line and get flung out into space. It's their acceleration towards the Earth that curves their trajectory and allows them to orbit

[@peppep1704]

"I'VE DISCOVERED HOW TO SPLIT THE ATOM!"

[@ninjakannon]

3:35 cuts just as the egg appears to be rising up despite the oil...

[@SonakaG]

Honestly my favorite science/experimentation channel on youtube. Super fun to watch every time.

[@marcusgriffin279]

1:34 correction, Columbus didn’t discover America. You can’t “discover” something someone else already owns and is using.

[@thoroughlyunoriginalname]

Who owned America?

[@KebboStar]

@@thoroughlyunoriginalnameI did

[@thoroughlyunoriginalname]

@@KebboStar have you filed a complaint to the US government about it?

[@KebboStar]

@@thoroughlyunoriginalname Yes, they took my skin oils in return

[@LinksQuest]

Sure you can, someone on earth can discover an alien civilization and you can personally discover all kinds of things that other people have known about. Everyone knows Columbus wasn’t the very first person on earth to discover America but that doesn’t mean he didn’t discover it but thank you for in correcting him

[@TheGuyWhoNeverAsked]

Your videos are so amazing, so easy to listen to and you can easily remember what happens because its explained so well!

[@theadventuresofkentsawyeri5944]

Did you not see the part where he just lied to you and bullshited you? He added energy to make this ball bearing spin, so it is not perpetual motion! It's called bait and switch in the business world. You should thumbs down this video since he lied to everybody,,,,, not compliment him!! Otherwise he'll keep making videos where he's bullshiting everybody. And that's not cool!!! If everybody wanted to watch bullshit videos, we would just turn on CNN and keep voting Democrat child sniffers into office.

[@MajikkanCat]

This is awesome! Love the Tesla connection, that guy always had the coolest ideas :-) (Obligatory comment that Columbus didn't discover the Americas, wasn't the first European to visit the Americas, and was objectively a horrible person, but y'all know that.)

[@personeater2664]

First person to get syphilis

[@Mister_Sun.]

yeah it should be called the Tesla egg, Columbus does not deserve to have something named after him, he didn't even invent it

[@ludicrous7044]

Tesla would be ashamed to have a piece of 💩 named after him!!😔

[@paperfoldschannel607]

guy's a good actor fr

[@moakadarkmaster]

I was fooled in thinking this was an early 1st April joke, ... But as always awesome topic!

[@calabrais]

Literally the only perpetual motion video I would ever click on because I knew from you I wouldn't be disappointed. And I wasn't.

[@ludicrous7044]

Except it’s not PM!🤦🏻‍♀️

[@PatrickPierceBateman]

Yo he spun that egg like a Top G. Mad respect yo!

[@zeryez6347]

Thank you for all these unbelievably great videos, just discovered your videos recently but you’re such great at explaining and making it fun to learn. Thank you for this great work keep it up👍

[@daveevans8004]

What if you did that with a symmetrical shape, would it still stand on end? If it's an egg shape then isn't the fatter bottom that has something to do with it standing on its end? I mean, maybe not but that's what I assumed when watching it.

[@connorclimenhaga2379]

as long as the mass above the flat surface isn't asymmetrical, because then it would lead too a tilting effect, or if it had too much weigh pinned on too point. Yes its possible but there are also so many other variables determining whether or not that egg, or what ever other shape you have stays up. Good question though!

[@chrisgann8986]

I made these a lot when i was younger. They are very interesting and fun. We mostly used paper clips. It was part of studying electro magnets. In the lab, I would play with magnetic stir bars like that all of the time. I would the magnetic ball that way too. It is also part of a party trick to do that.

[@pineapplekittycat525]

3:19 "gu-"

[@The_Guy_Who_Asked72]

"gu-"

[@Sh-ro2js]

"gu-"

[@kitsmith1]

"gu-"

[@nit-3patidar848]

"gu-"

[@dezcubing5844]

"gu-"

[@yrburd]

The fly in my bedroo mat night: 0:14

[@DeadeyeDaily]

"I'm not adding any energy," he says 😂

[@DF-bx9hd]

3:14 that's what she said

[@AshrellStudios753]

Shush

[@Pinkoshaberibunny]

@@AshrellStudios753thats what she said

[@tomdeline]

Could the friction be all that it needed to overcome gravity and fall into the center of a toroidal magnetic field?

[@mikelunsford2587]

Liquid breaks down gravity

[@mafialuciano]

if this guy tries enough hes probably going to discover infinite energy at some point

[@sydneysimon7112]

This is awesome and satisfying to watch, thank you for sharing

[@columnfellow7477]

“The ‘spin’ energy Johnny!”

[@Firesprink72]

I would call the title of this video, "False advertising."

[@rh6zner707]

0:44 why you can't get your hands off of it?

[@LycheeShorts]

Because the glass isn't a stationary object, if you let go the glass will wobble and fall over from the momentum of the spinning ball

[@AR17ANA]

Merry Christmas ahh

[@drawer_resp3858]

If you watched for 2 more seconds you will see the beaker wobbles and get your answer. Instead of waiting 2 years for the previous reply.

[@rh6zner707]

So can this make an engine?

[@pebsiburbger]

From 0:55 to 0:58, he isn't holding it, and it starts to wobble about

[@Lara-vk3wc]

I honestly don't know if Columbus did it as well but the egg story was actually used by Brunelleschi, an architect from the Florence of 1420 that managed to built the highest dome in history on top of Florence's Cathedral (and it still is the highest dome nowadays with a diameter of 45m and 116m height). This story has also been illustrated in many paintings where Brunelleschi asks the other mathematicians and architects, who didn't believe his project was possible, to try and make the egg stand on its end but when he revealed how to do it (in the same way as shown in the video) then the mathematicians started to say that anyone could have done it that way to which he responded "the difference is that you could have done it but I did it, and if you wait for me to show you, then you'll be also able to built the dome"

[@worldcomicsreview354]

Puts me in mind of all the "Boeing would have", "Roscosmos could have", "NASA should have" naysayers. Yeah, well, SpaceX did.

[@seanmackidd7947]

It is not friction! It is balance and momentum. The spinning is caused by the Eva’s attempt to succum to pressures from both sides evenly. The ‘friction’ creates enough resistance to make minute changes to the direction of the momentum… as the egg varies from its predictable path, more of its molecules equalize in how they are affected by the opposing forces, and just like a pendulum causes it to over correct and swing past the balance point, where it receives an equal but opposite amount of energy, affecting more of the matter of the egg, at its peak, and providing more energy for it to swing back and over correct further…. This continues until the primary mass of the egg finds the exact ‘0’ balance point between the two forces. The friction just provides enough chaos to create the momentum of the pendulum.

[@daviddavids2884]

oh, yeah? well, i'll raise you a turbo encabulator lol

[@Steve-vf7se]

Awesome. You've discovered gravity too. Looks good, cool. I like science, you learn anything. I love NASA, super cool. A egg standing up, I like that. Nice work my friend, I've learned tons of it. What if you create a running man figure, you make it never stop running. Just wish I see more

[@ThePhihn]

It’s a fun thought to create a PEG but in practice it’s near impossible from what I’ve researched, now it may have changed over the years but you’d need to have a lot of things that we currently can’t achieve with our limitations. Still it’s very fun to play around with the idea, awesome video man! Loved your stuff since I first found your channel!

[@sylvrwolflol]

It's not near impossible, it _is_ impossible. If it was possible to create a device which endlessly multiplies the energy put into it, you'd have a bomb that never stops exploding. No matter what you work with, generating energy requires entropy to function and generating limitless energy from the energy put in would require negative entropy, creating a paradox which cannot be overcome. The closest we could ever get is to create something which lasts long enough that we wouldn't live to see it burn out, like the Sun. But rest assured, it _will_ run out.

[@dielaughing73]

The laws of thermodynamics haven't been updated recently that i know of

[@kcbsuiejd]

Its impossible, not nearly impossible.

[@NICEFINENEWROBOT]

@@kcbsuiejd But what with the atoms? Spin, long time no stop.

[@kcbsuiejd]

@@NICEFINENEWROBOT I get where you are coming from, but they dont literally "spin". its just the name we have to them acting like they have angular momentum despite not having it :) for example, you cant extract any energy from it, like you could with an "actually spinning" object

[@EnergySponge]

It is less about friction and more about the radial symmetry of the egg and inertia. When laying down, the symmetry is not balanced, yet while it is upright, the radial symmetry is perfectly circular. Equilibrium, or we can identify it as efficiency, is always sought, and the upright position satisfies it best.

[@shlok8267]

Sir , all your experiments and lessons are fantastic and easily understandable but WHERE CAN WE FIND THE MATERIALS TO PERFORM THESE ACTIVITIES ? WHICH ONLINE STORE ?

[@jackvessalius7112]

The April fool store

[@loc9588]

@@jackvessalius7112 its not april yet, fool

[@prince32YT]

@@loc9588 tomorrow bro

[@CavemanZerron]

Surprisingly, Amazon

[@ronaldmcdonald6776]

@@loc9588 hey. they could be in a dif time zone

[@greatPretender79]

Please keep the magnetic videos coming!

[@gaekaas]

It was not Colubus that had that idea on how to make the egg stand up. Columbus was not that smart anyway 😂 The expression originates from a widespread anecdote attributed to Christopher Columbus in 1565, but it is believed to have originated with the Italian architect Brunelleschi. In an assembly of architects, which in 1420 discussed whether it was possible to put a dome on the cathedral in Florence, he is said to have proposed that the architect who could get an egg to stand on top of a marble slab should build the dome. When the others could not make the egg stand, he is said to have struck its pointed end against the plate, so it stood. When the others said that they could have done that too, he replied: "Yes, but you didn't!", adding that they too could have built the dome if they had seen his drawing.

[@joeymorris4863]

You can’t fool me…I see the electrical cord.

[@pryingeyes1551]

The centripetal force of the balls in a jar is actually how I used to clean my longboard bearings. They'd race around the jar, with their casing staying horizontal, and all surfaces got cleaned without the use of a brush....plus it was a bit fun changing their rate and trying to prevent them from crashing into one another.

[@jlt131]

here's me wondering why your long board has bearings.... i was thinking of a surfboard, not a skateboard >.< haha

[@vincentdavi3514]

I actually created a prepetual motion clock. I’ll give you some details and see if you can work it out: •Clock; big hand & small hand •Small hand is crooked •Strategically use magnets around the clock and within spots of the face of the clock •Strategically use gravity Once it’s in motion, using a simplistic centripetal type transmission, you can create endless energy.

[@chrismosquad1056]

Love your content! Always educational and fun! Thanks!

[@theNimboo]

Lol the frictionless egg was literally rising up anyway right as he cut it ahahahahahah. Totally made a fool of him

[@unfortunateimperial6019]

That's because there's no such thing as a frictionless system in our known universe, there will always be friction acting on movement. The demonstration is correct, if the world was frictionless, it wouldn't rise up.

[@MrDumonic]

3:27 I believe it would stand up on its end with more power. More power!!!!

[@lanfanslostarm9784]

You make science so fun, love your channel and your personality, your passion is part of what makes it fun :)

[@Genetherapy3232]

You are the next best thing to a free energy machine! Love this channel

[@VHavengrad]

Isn't the spinning of the metal egg going onto the other axis more akin to the Dzhanibekov effect where it's trying to find essentially a more stable axis of rotation rather than anything to do with friction? I imagine it would do the same thing in open air in the absence of rubbing the plate, suspended in liquid or perhaps a zero g vacuum.

[@mrxmry3264]

0:46 ok, what is hidden under that table?

[@VidaNeon]

1:17 here

[@RayanBaaqeel]

Your experiments are very amazing … thanks 😊

[@blumobean]

My grandfather was a brilliant man. His 2 sons were also. My father was smart, but very level headed, his brother was a little on the adventurous side. Grand daddy recognized that so he said most everything is possible, but not perpetual motion. He said that it would drive you crazy to start on that road.

[@JahonCross]

Where can I buy one?

[@orid7596]

perpetual motion is possible without any friction or way to lose energy so this isnt technically perpetual motion although I do think this is quite neat

[@imblank6161]

So is it possible to create perpetual motion in space?

[@douglasharley2440]

lol, but there can never be zero friction or energy loss, so perpetual motion *is impossible.*

[@triberium_]

I guess thats another way of saying its not possible

[@douglasharley2440]

@@imblank6161 space is not empty, on average there are a few molecules/cubic meter, and they are usually moving at very great speeds.

[@orid7596]

@@douglasharley2440 in an absolute vacuum there is no friction, so for example you throw a ball in an absolute vacuum than it would continue forever. But as you said I don't think that there are currently absolute vacuums anywhere (even outer space has a tiny density but still not 0).

[@Mbartel500]

Actually Columbus never set foot in North America, but even if he had, it would have been 500 years too late.

[@AtomizerX]

2:05 "alternating AC current" 🤔

[@NC_Isro_64]

Yep

[@wesleyhenderson2621]

I was checking comments exclusively for this

[@AtomizerX]

@@wesleyhenderson2621 I was like "bro, you're a scientist, you should know better!" 🤦

[@nit-3patidar848]

The machine works on 4 electromagnets And the AC current is alternated in those 4 elec. magnets

[@AtomizerX]

@@nit-3patidar848 Ok, since you clearly didn't understand my comment, let me help you out with a question: what does "AC" stand for? And that's a *rhetorical* question, by the way.

[@426F6F]

Are the magnetic poles arranged in that sphere just as two seperate neg/pos hemispheres? Also how would the size of the magnet in correlation with the radius it travels matter? Very intriguing video, thanks for the upload!

[@vinquinn]

It is a simple induction motor. The egg forms the rotor and current is induced in it by the alternating field. This field creates magnetism within the egg. This magnetism will be opposite to the base(stator). The egg now rotates.

[@jopensnewsnetwork]

This is how they power ufos

[@A_Anti-Furry]

"The Hardest Part of making a Perpetual Motion device Is hiding the Batteries (and the motor)" - Elon Musk

[@pritamjyotideka6321]

0:34 -inertia of motion

[@Phoenix_fruit2353t]

Inertia of rest

[@rellikpd]

love this video. However i argue with "counterintuitively" when you say "more friction makes it rise" because.. friction on a moving object causes pull in the other direction. since it's spinning the pull would be constantly to the center (or the outside depending on your point of view) as the object spinning tries to reduce friction/reach equilibrium

[@atomic...]

I wonder what uses there are for something like this would be if there are any real ways of making use of it.

[@clivedavis6859]

As soon as you try to extract power from it, it would slow it down.

[@D-B-Cooper]

They use it to stir beakers.

[@atomic...]

Yea it's probably too good to be true, neat experiment either way.

[@atomic...]

I can see that working.

[@KL_PRODIGY]

Bcse of u i can study Im in class 10 now. Thank u 😍

[@Linkwii64]

what's class 10?

[@amriteshkr8]

Ha ha

[@Heyjudeeeee12321]

friction left the chat

[@-Pot4t0-]

"the hardest part of a perpetual motion machine is where to hide the batteries" -some random guy

[@MAC1978ify]

UFO magnet up arrow? 1:15

[@jayestes_vids]

Friction is a major player on earth, but the axis of spin this starts in is thru the short diameter of the egg, not thru the long. If allowed to spin in space, the egg would preferentially like to stay spinning around its principal moment of inertia. For a perfect egg, that is aligned with the long axis (long diameter) of the egg.

[@mikegamerguy4776]

Of course such a fascinating device traces back to Tesla. Man we could use more people like him and the like these days.

[@user-hv6nl3cz1z]

You mean like elon musk with neuralink etc?