I''M NOT CRYING, YOU ARE!!! (1098 Reaction)

VOD for Chapter 1098 Live Reaction Stream!!
#onepiece #OnePiece1098 #chapter1098

[@GoatLuffy_97]

I don't cry often while reading manga compared to watching anime, but this was one of those times. This was some truly dark subject matter. I'm in shambles.

[@SwaggerIsAVirtue]

Baby ass.. ;)

[@eldrickemc4602]

That's One Piece for you.

[@sarov7658]

Last time I came close to was on law and sanji wci flashback but that's in anime

[@MerchHunterRicky]

Let’s cry together then friend

[@jarvistezeno2449]

Bruh! I was inconsolable

[@DeeeJay07]

Fans: Bonney is a clone, Bonney is actually Ginny Oda was like: Those theories were great but uh, lets go into dark sht

[@Justin-oq3ng]

nah the theories sucked xd i didnt like any of them from the start

[@vongolashodaime1975]

He truly is telling us about the true villains of the story for this final saga

[@Justin-oq3ng]

@@vongolashodaime1975 makes sense :D

[@Suto_Ko]

yes, I agree. Oda is known for his love of unexpected twists and turns, and this is definitely one of the most unexpected ones yet. It's also one of the darkest, and it's sure to leave fans reeling for some time. I'm curious to see how Oda develops this storyline in the future. I'm sure we're in for a wild ride. In the meantime, I'm glad that Bonney has finally been reunited with Kuma. It's been a long time coming, and I'm sure they have a lot to catch up on.

[@christopersantiago6009]

Ginny and Bonney’s sickness makes the SUN poisonous. It’s so insidious that the hope Kuma always prayed to cursed those he loved most, but also, the curse of the sun sickness was literally the thing that liberated Ginny when they threw her away. The symbolism is so heartbreaking

[@majRFan]

damn… 😭

[@Suto_Ko]

yeah, the fact that Ginny and Bonney’s sickness made the sun poisonous is incredibly symbolic. It shows how the hope that Kuma always prayed to was actually a curse, and how the curse of the sun sickness was actually the thing that liberated Ginny. This symbolism is heartbreaking because it shows how Kuma's hope was ultimately misplaced. He hoped that if he could become a weapon, he would be able to protect the people he loved. But in reality, his actions only led to more pain and suffering. The symbolic nature of Ginny and Bonney’s sickness is also a reminder that even the darkest of curses can have a silver lining. In Ginny's case, the curse of the sun sickness liberated her from a life of slavery and oppression. It allowed her to escape from the clutches of World Nobles and live her life on her own terms. Ultimately, the symbolism of Ginny and Bonney’s sickness is a reminder that hope and despair are always intertwined. Even in the darkest of times, there is always a chance for light to shine through. I am curious to see how Oda explores this symbolism in the future. I am sure that he will continue to deliver thought-provoking and emotionally resonant storytelling.

[@Tyrannosaur6265]

Kuma laying waste to Marie Jois, and now hopefully going to save Bonney at Egghead, even despite being turned into a weapon. How strong his conviction must be, what an incredible few chapters.

[@vongolashodaime1975]

I don't think he wrecked Mary Geoise because of resentment, he just did so because they blocked his path.

[@aritrasaha441]

When this is adapted into the anime... This is gonna break hearts. We have to go through this once again.

[@JetsadaKG213]

Agreed man, I cried when Luffy burn The Going Merry 🥺

[@hikari62k]

Kuma's backstory hurts even more than Clannad.

[@nightshadesfunkyvids3812]

Vegapunk: "I'm sorry, Sapphire Scale is incurable at this stage. If I had been able to give her a vaccine when she was younger, before she started showing symptoms.... wait! I just thought of a solution!"

[@dwightsmith1123]

Yoooooooooo 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 Cause i dont think she has her Fruit yet

[@Altario10]

Brother! You are cooking 🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@vongolashodaime1975]

Oda has a habit of making moms suffer but at least these moms are some of the strongest characters in the story. I don't care about the tenryubitos' fate anymore, Oda could opt to reeducate/reform them or slaughter every last one of them and I wouldn't give a sh*t.

[@Poup_o7]

Honestly after this chapter I want all of those things to die. I know there's some good celestial dragons but the last one we knew of was mjosgard and after this chapter I want them all erased

[@angelsambition2179]

Oda had to have shed some tears when he did this chapter

[@savathsan5328]

ODA can’t even finish the chapter. It hurt so much, he must of paused multiple times. I can’t believe my poor boi Kuma world is too rough.

[@JoeJoeJoe25]

​@@savathsan5328yeah that's actually might be the reason. Because the part that didn't finish properly is actually around the death of Ginny. After that untill the end of the chapter the art actually improve. So yeah, that part might be too heavy for Oda

[@MerchHunterRicky]

I cried too. This chapter was so brutal. I cant even put words to paper yet

[@polmao]

Oda in that kitchen cookin harder than Gordan Ramsey.

[@SarevokRegor]

Fisher Tigers attack was within 1-3 years before Bonney. She just missed. Feel like Kuma would have tried, anyway.

[@343Sourav]

dragon did not have enough man power at that time. So they couldn't rescue Ginny.

[@Chatedh]

Exactly

[@eloquitodelaesquina]

Imagine the whole Whitebeard pirates were almost destroyed and they didnt take down any of the admirals So you need a big ass army to raid Mary Geoise succefully Unless youre Fisher mothafucking Tiger I guess

[@13edwolf]

The last I cried was in dessrosa. I knew this chapter was going to hurt but... this hurt to much 😢

[@NoOne-ky1er]

Was it Pika's death??

[@13edwolf]

@NoOne-ky1er actually, it was seeing Sabo alive lol. During that time, my older brother passed away. So, to see Luffy reunited with his brother, it just hurt a lot.

[@NoOne-ky1er]

@@13edwolf My bad

[@13edwolf]

@NoOne-ky1er no no you are good lol

[@billnguyen4148]

been a couple days and i still couldnt get over this chapter. few times a day i caught myself thinking about it and i start crying. this is the saddest, most depressing chapter in the history of OP TT_TT

[@lostdoko]

This is the best back story but also the saddest back story in one piece... 😭

[@Doommaster677]

If the manga broke me, then i already know the anime will DESTROY me when this airs... death to the Celestial Dragons, ALL OF THEM (not you, Bonney, we love you)

[@infamous-drive6299]

​​@@youaintknowmebutIbespittinfrshe is half celestial dragon, at least it is heavily implied that was the case, but she is a literaly infinity times better than any of them

[@blank3914]

This is the reason. Think that's why kuma surrendered himself to world government to become them human weapon to cure Bonney :(

[@blank3914]

This is the reason why Bonney is not capturing by akainu that time

[@bryebaker3343]

Bonney will be the “princess” for taking down the world government before going to laugh tale. And what if that makes luffy the last one to reach it, opposed to how roger was first. I think that would be awesome

[@alexgallardo3213]

This is why I love one piece. It's made cry as many times as it has made me laugh

[@eloquitodelaesquina]

This one made me cry fam... Im allways a radical when it comes to the tenryubito issue but this kind of chapter reminds me why

[@coronbrown9238]

I was like yoooooo joy girl called it!!!!!!!!

[@bakshev]

Ginny got the Casca treatment.

[@majRFan]

It is amazing we understand things that is not explicitly mentioned in the chapter, like: - His belief in Nika makes me emotional, now knowing it’s Luffy whom he saved before… maybe he knows luffy is joyboy, or maybe he saved him because he is dragon’s son… - now we know why Boonie is known as Jewellery Boonie.. - and vegapunk has the cure. since Boonie said she was in egghead when she was young. - but since vegapunk is now with the government, Kuma must join the govt😢. - since it is govt, they probably made a deal in exchange for the cure, like kuma’s life. - basically Kuma suffered it all for Boonie, and he was always ready to take others suffering from the start to begin with😢… what a legend..

[@ae-sera3406]

i cried too, so sad

[@catriamflockentanz]

Oda sure threw us a Curveball with Ginny being Bonney's mother but Kuma _not_ being her father... (At least not biologically anyway.) Also: An important detail but probably lost in the sadness if you didn't read it more than once: The upper large panel of page 8. The Cross in Kuma's church has a large Sun Symbol in the center. So this is a Nika Church. And yet this very Sun Kuma prays to took away the love of his life and threatens his daughter daily... This chapter hurt me on a very personal level too. Because I have seen a grief struck man standing over the corpse of his wife and just kinda collapsing before in real life. Seeing my father's reaction to the death of my mother was even more heartbreaking than her death itself. Also I learned the word "cot" yesterday when I read it the first time. Page 13 lower panels And here we see why Bonney is known as "Juwelry Bonney". To be fair: It makes sense that the "Sapphire Scales" would eventually grow larger even if you prevent exposure to natural light as best as you can. -> The light inside is just a reflection of the sun anyway. Bounced umteen times but still the same. Last page: I still don't understand how the Shit King of Sorbet _can_ return. I thought Ivankov and/or Dragon _killed_ him.

[@dwightalexander2648]

That explains why akainu knew about bonney escaping mariejois. Maybe she's a child of one of the gorosei? 👀

[@user-sx7lp9op1m]

Peeps said oda wont go down berserk R word route..oda: challenge accepted

[@danielkeis8388]

Your reactions are always so raw and realistic. I love how honest and in the moment it feels

[@michaelcheung1693]

Nothing but pure unabridged pain

[@Shanks6039]

Almost cried only cried from one manga and it was Kingdom never cry during movies or anything 👍 Except: For the one piece anime Laws backstory Senior pink Sanji whole cake saying he doesn’t care abt luffy No other tv show or anime made me cry

[@saistark6899]

Oh wow you were really balling your eyes out, this is what Oda is great at, capturing our emotion I read this chapter anticipating pain...

[@callanevermelt6392]

*comfort hugs* you deserve it and this was a sad chapter...thank you Oda for this

[@juancarloscampos1616]

Bonny being twelve broke my heart.

[@leonardoloves6247]

Oda took of his gloves and hit us so hard…it made you cry too. Hope you recover soon too.

[@rali00]

damn, this one hurt.... 🥲

[@kevingaliza5742]

Pretty sure Oda is implying Ginny was made a sex slave of Celestial Dragons. Damn. 💔

[@kura4674]

I hate the idea of it.. but given what we have seen from the story so far, the panels of Kuma as a slave being ridden by Roswald.. That man clearly has staked his claim on Kuma, and I think it may be very likely that he claimed Ginny as well.. However, to work against this idea, the mark under Bonney's eye, her scar/ piercing, its kinda shaped like a moon, she might also be a Figarland.

[@reapingmonkey2526]

I can believe that oda did what he did with Bonnie's birth. This was the last final thing missing in showing how depraved the celestial dragons are. I can guess that the father was figarland.

[@Mr_D_Artist]

And thats why she called jewelry bonney

[@amirulhareez6937]

cried w you

[@willbrashear]

I hate having called that she was someone else's kid. I mean atleast technically she got married... we know it was rape but still. Atleast we get to see one of the saddest backstories in literature.

[@eloquitodelaesquina]

Lets not say marriage when its kidnapping and slavery..

[@willbrashear]

@@eloquitodelaesquina then take issues with the author. We know its kidnapping and slavery. However, it is how he wrote it.

[@eloquitodelaesquina]

@@willbrashear yeah sure But the story says it in a way that implies it tho I only felt like clarifying because you said "at least"

[@FrarmerFrank]

Why would someone like Vegapunk lie about there being nothing but pain in that bubble?😏

[@Orbitalbomb]

Don’t count out the clone thing. Bonney is severely sick and we know who helped Kuma and Bonney in the end: Vegapunk. There is a high possibility that Bonnie was born normally originally, but given the fruit powers of Kuma, combined with the help of Vega punk, they might have cloned her before she died.

[@wahyukurniawan592]

the manuscript is not finish, oda need rest...

[@ramonavila3847]

Kumachi 😢😭😭😭

[@May_Green]

Kuma's backstory is worse than reading Bible's Book of Job... T___T

[@benreguiaabderahmene4941]

Sadest back-story

[@XTheCrystalBeastGuyX]

I would love it if Kuma was secretly a Trojan Horse designed to murder and make sure every Celestial Dragon perishes the same way Ginny did. He's a cyborg now so what if, that same disease is secretly being carried by him and he's infecting EVERY last Celestial Dragon with it to ensure that they'll all get a slow and painful demise? If it were me, I'd surrender my humanity to make it happen. Nothing they could do could hurt me more than what they already did and I'd want to make sure they'd pay for everything tenfold. Not only that, being a Cyborg would mean I'd get to stick around and watch it all happen before my very eyes, record it with a camera eye and rewatch it over and over and over and over again like a lullaby.

[@Problemsolver434]

Come on Oda. Give Kuma a break I'm speculating that Imu has the same disease. Which is why he covers himself. And Bonney has a cure in her blood. Which is why the government wants her.

[@ifantsaurells3014]

Amber White Sapphire Blue What next, ODA

[@OXR1200]

This one was hard read

[@tobiaswedin]

I do not think anyone excepted Oda to actually make Bonney a rape baby, damn... That's the darkest thing One Piece has ever done. He must have forgotten that he's writing One Piece and not Berserk, Redo of Healer or some other fucked up shit like that. Am I the only one that thought that the chapter was released unfinished? A lot of panels are still nothing but scribbles.

[@ethans5198]

I thought this is a new channel, missing JoyGirl name :)

[@diegod.waterliaw7840]

Celestial dragon AIDS 😢

[@anime_enjoyer5507]

p a i n

[@albarhimsite6653]

The Current Bonney is only a clone then?

[@eloquitodelaesquina]

I think Kuma made a deal with the WG to cure bonney

[@zeekmchole1382]

We can say that Bonney was cured based on the current timeline. However, the way Oda show Kuma's flashback, what if the real Bonney died at 10 and the current Bonney is a clone just to make it more tragic? Hope I'm wrong.

[@UbecTennis]

This episode is too heavy. Especially to dads

[@stard.chaden5695]

When this flashback fully adapt into the anime, I am gonna cry for sure. Damn Oda, why do you have to make this chapter so much heart-breaking and you just make me hate those trash Celestial Dragon more than anything, I don't think they deserve to be forgiven at all. Also DRAGON WTF are you doing? Huh? Why the hell Revolutionary Army not coming thru save her as soon as possible, so dissapointed. My top 3 backstories in one piece: 1. KUMA the best father 🐻 2. Nico Robin ❤️ 3. Trafalgar Law the GOAT 🐏 From here on out, KUMA is one of the best one piece character!!! Love you Kuma, Ginny, and Bonney 👨‍👩‍👧 Knowing this past of Ginny, remind me Boa and her sister. Damn, they are also going the same pattern as her just little bit lucky with Fisher Tiger came to aid tho. LUFFY BETTER BEAT THE HELL OUTTA SATURN AND HIS CELESTIAL BITCHES ASS. DRAG AND MASSACRED ALL OF THOSE CELESTIAL DRAGON FROM RED LINE, SO WE CAN SMOKE THAT CELESTIAL DRAGON PACKS 🤬🚬🚬🔥

[@1WAYNEUzu]

I know how kuma feels when i was 18teen my Girlfriend sleep with guy she got pregnant by him then she told me once she did on my birthday she kill her self i blame self been weak it been 22 years 😢

[@1WAYNEUzu]

One piece help me and I always said I need be strong have to be good

[@eloquitodelaesquina]

Much love bro, keep being strong

[@zikkthegreat]

mic pops were the worst in this video that they’ve been for over a year. did you change mics? might need an external pop filter 😢 really rough loud with headphones

[@Sunlight91]

Some people at the start of the livestream said audio was too low, which it clearly was not. They just had rubbish speakers/headphones or a loud environment. Unfortunately Joygirl listened to them and changed some settings.

[@flawlezzgenocide]

Breaking: Dragon is fraud stock is now rising. But i get why dragon didnt do anything. He aint aizen who can just head straight to marijoise and solo. He only had ivankov and kuma as his strong combatants.

[@eloquitodelaesquina]

The whole Whitebeard pirates were beaten before taking out any of the admirals You need a big army to raid Mary geoise

[@SarevokRegor]

Fisher Tiger : . . . . Pathetic

[@gjulia312]

​@@SarevokRegorFisher the GOAT

[@adrianhartanto5243]

​@@eloquitodelaesquinayou forgot fisher tiger solo and release boa sister and koala and many others

[@eloquitodelaesquina]

@@adrianhartanto5243 No I didnt Fisher Tiger is just that dude

[@HayabusaRyuu]

Ntr!!!??? Best manga ever!

[@wandrr27]

This chapter made me hate Dragon. If Luffy (or Garp) was in his place, he'd definitely try to save her. I hate you Dragon, you weaksauce.

[@aoitsukishiro9926]

I'm not blaming Dragon, but it really feels like he calculating too much when he try to do something, he wastes too much time to decide to save people

[@joshinthesauce4636]

If he attacked Mary Geoise at that point, the RA would’ve been wiped out completely.

[@rendezvousonmemorylane]

Yeah, try and F A I L Dragon has bigger, better things to worry about than some random woman. There's millions of people whose lives are at stake here.

[@SarevokRegor]

Who would win , A Dragon with a massive army OR One FisheyTigeryman

[@Problemsolver434]

They have to sneak into mariejeois, locate her and bring her back. They don't have a huge distraction like the reverie. I doubt that tunnel guy was around yet. How many of them can contend with the admirals. I'd wager, possibly, possibly, only Dragon. The Kuma rescue worked because in addition to the distraction, the tunnel guy and the strength of Sabo, Fujitora also fought Ryokugyu and kept him busy But yeah, Luffy or Garp would have burst in without question

[@daniel.m703]

Kuma is going to to do either one of 2 things once he arrives at egghead: 1. He is going to destroy Saturn with all the pain he collected in mary joise (thats the reason he went there to take as much damage as possible even from akainu but left before he was killed just to give saturn maximum damage). 2.hes going to take luffys damage and luffy destroys saturn. There is no other thing that could happen to be the "egghead incident" mark my words