'I'M SPEAKING': Kamala SNEERS At Pro-Palestine Protesters

Support The Show On Patreon!:
/ seculartalk
Subscribe to Krystal Kyle & Friends On Substack!:
krystalkyleand...
Follow Kyle on Twitter:
/ kylekulinski
"The first time I ever really listened to Kyle Kulinski’s show was in the back of a cab last summer. The driver had his phone hooked up through the stereo and was pumping out an episode through the car speakers - loudly, as if looking to convert a captive audience.
“Do you like Kyle Kulinski?”
The driver, Ahmed, was a recent immigrant and apparently a die-hard fan of Secular Talk, the political talk show that Kulinski broadcasts on KZbin. I told him, yes, in fact. I do like Kulinski, had come across his show several years ago, and, all things considered, he seemed pretty good.
“He understands what we’re up against,” Ahmed said. “Like Bernie.”
But I was surprised to hear Kulinski’s name mentioned in the same breath as Bernie Sanders, particularly with such adoration. Because what I did remember about Kulinski’s show struck me as mostly capital-P “progressive” takes on the news - the left wing of the Netroots crowd more than the democratic socialism Sanders has popularized.
It’s an impression that wasn’t entirely incorrect.
“I have no time for philosophical, airy bullshit,” Kulinski tells me from his home in Westchester, New York. “I don’t want to hear about Lenin. I don’t want to hear about Marx. I just want a super plainspoken, straightforward agenda with a straightforward way of selling it.”
With over 800,000 subscribers and nearly 670 million total views on KZbin, selling a progressive agenda is clearly something Kulinski knows how to do - even Democracy Now, the long-standing flagship of progressive media, cannot match his reach on the platform. Chapo Trap House can certainly boast a wildly devoted fan base (and a not insignificant degree of media influence), but their audience is roughly half the size of Kulinski’s.
While Secular Talk might be more likely to be looped in with the progressive networks around Air America and Pacifica alums like Sam Seder than the more resolutely socialist world, Kulinski’s fiery rhetoric, razor-sharp class instincts, and knack for withering takedowns sets him apart from his peers. Judging by his rhetoric alone, he’s closer to a Eugene Debs than a Chris Hayes.
But unlike Hayes, Amy Goodman, or his friend Cenk Uygur of The Young Turks - who began airing Secular Talk on his web network seven years ago - the thirty-two-year-old Kulinski is virtually invisible in the mainstream media. Despite his enormous fan base, his show has never once been mentioned in the obligatory trend pieces on “the Millennial Left” pumped out by the prestige media. Nor has Kulinski’s name ever popped up at all in the New York Times, Vox, the New Yorker, New York Magazine, or the Washington Post, despite his leading role in cofounding Justice Democrats, the organization widely credited with sweeping Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and the rest of “the Squad” to power.
Just last week, his Wikipedia page was deleted. The reason? “There is very simply no [reliable source] coverage of this person,” according to one moderator. In new media, he’s king - the Sean Hannity of the Berniecrat left. In old media, he’s nobody.
I suspect there are a few reasons for that. There is nothing “cool” about Kulinski’s show. (As a friend put it, “‘Welcome to Secular Talk’ sounds like something you’d hear on Egyptian radio.”) His no-nonsense social-democratic politics won’t get him much cred with the Full Communism crowd. He records his show not in Brooklyn or Los Angeles, but in a studio he built himself in his modest Westchester home. His hair is too groomed and his taste in clothes too preppy to qualify as “Dirtbag Left.” Nor has he ever attended an n+1 release party. “Not only have I not attended one,” he says, “I have no idea what that means.”
And yet he’s astonishingly plugged-in for a young man in the suburbs. Wondering how Sanders ended up on the Joe Rogan Experience? Kulinski, a frequent guest on Rogan’s wildly popular show, introduced them. “You make the most sense to me,” Rogan told Kulinski on a recent episode. “You’re a normal person.”
Much like Sanders himself, Kulinski’s show has a massive audience that just doesn’t compute with our media’s understanding of “what the kids want” or even “what the left-wing kids want.”
It’s probably for the best - the very woke and very WASP-ish decorum haunting much of the media world is nowhere to be found in Secular Talk. “Corporate Democrats over-focus on identity as a trick to divert you from the issues that unite us all - class issues,” he said on a recent episode.
Read More Here!:
jacobinmag.com...
#KyleKulinski #SecularTalk #news #politics #youtube #biden #economics #left #progressive #viral

[@Kathleen-Mariam]

She’s not gonna stop Israel she will support them.

[@halaalqudsi66]

Free America from AIPAC

[@yvonneplant9434]

Free America from Jew hating antisemites who think the Holocaust as fake.

[@micahr9255]

IfNotNow has a "Reject AIPAC" project.

[@Iguana-Power]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXnEk62BfJVsgJosi=fd3oBA1gNhdkcNWd

[@UnknownChocolatiering]

Fuck the American war machine.

[@NkenKenY]

well normie liberals only care about having eace in their world but not around the world they have a very selfish narrow mind and closed minded mind

[@janmortimer1758]

👍💚☮️2024

[@Cheesesteakfreak]

This is misguided. It's amazing how Kyle Kulenski has no argument whatsoever against those who make the case for Israeli self defense and destroying Hamas. It blows my mind how extreme Kyle is on this. I'd love to see him actually engage with Destiny or Sam Harris's argument on this.

[@Gaff.]

@@Cheesesteakfreak But Kyle is correct. If anything he's not extreme enough, and Destiny is an absolute hack. If we're going to the 'experts', try actual experts like Rashid Khalidi or Ilan Pappe.

[@Golden284-fan]

So what do y'all think will happen to Isreal if we stop weapons shipments?

[@h9081]

That incident showed her true face, i would never vote for harris.

[@GenocideJoe-xv8oz]

Free Scott Ritter from Illegal FBI harrassment

[@A.O.1982]

Free him from political persecution The ones that sent him the dogs

[@dwr4992]

I thought they were chanting "we won't vote for genocide". She didn't handle it well, especially considering Michigan is the focus of the uncommitted movement.

[@italianstallion389]

"Kamala, kamala , you can't hide, we won't vote for g" can't type it out, youtube censors.

[@Novusod]

Harris can't win Michigan without the Muslim vote. She won't win the national vote if Michigan goes to Trump.

[@jackgrove4621]

Actually she handled it very well.

[@elephantwildlife8567]

Harris met with Uncommitted president's back stage. She asked aides to meet with them. Then protestors begin their chant, she politely says USA is a democracy with free speech, we hear you and I am speaking now. The protestors continued, became heckling as voters came to hear Harris and how she would help them, Michigan, USA. Harris is not running for office in Dearborn Michigan. She is running for office for all of USA. Ppl came to hear Kamala. She met with them backstage, she scheduled follow up meetings with aids. She was polite initially to recognize them but when they continued to drown out Harris and ppl came to hear Harris, she said enough. LET ME SPEAK AND YES WAKE UP, TOU DONT VORMTE, TRUMP GETS IN, TRUMP UNITES WITH NETANYAHU TO EXTERMINATE PALESTINIANS AND TAKE RHEIR LAND. TRUMP PROMISED TRUMP TOWER PROPERTY IN GAZA WEST BANK. HARRIS push for ceasefire, 2 state solution with Palestine as a sovreign state. Protestors are sabotaging themselves. Don't vote Trump in Frankly the abortion issue is hot. You have Taylor Swift Beyonce do concerts for her. She has momentum. She may not need Arab vote and that is relief as Arabs pretty much say they won't vote for her, she needs to turn to youth abortion, housing, etc. Protestors are alienating other voters, hope they don't alienate Harris who is really trying to help them. She decline tompreside over Bb speech. She met with Bb and said to his face before announce to world, end war, sigh ceasefire, stop suffering, stop starving and bombing civilians, end this. Two state with Palestine as sovreign nation. She caught hell fot that from elites but voters love her for it as 85% democrats want ceasefire, aid, hostages, 2 state. Then protestors bash Harris like are you kidding?????

[@SUFFICIENCYtoLIBERTY]

They’ll all vote for her and the Israeli boot licking will continue.

[@avtircaritas8229]

Votes are EARNED, not owed.

[@carrite]

Disruptionists are cleared away, not heeded.

[@H-no2fk]

@@carrite Spoken like a true authoritarian.

[@nicksgottalent]

Whenever I hear someone say Israel has the right to defend itself, I think about someone saying that about a bully at school and acting as if the bully is a victim and dismissing the actual victim

[@Icemann89]

Did you forget it was Hamas who started this war by massacring over 1000 civilians? How do you think USA would react?

[@nicksgottalent]

@@Icemann89 No Hamas came from decades of Israel ruling over Palestine essentially. Israel started it and Hamas essentially came out of rebellion. Israel and Palestine have had conflict since dating back to biblical times. Obviously, killing innocent Israelis is bad but when Israel has killed, since October 7th, a minimum of 49,000 people and a maximum of 186,000 people and over 90% of them being killed are innocent civilians(i.e. Not Hamas), it's very clear they're committing a genocide. Not only that but systemic rape is being carried by the IDF as well and there's literally no way to defend rape. The US probably would react similarly considering the fact that the three main candidates all support Israel so that's indicative of what they believe in. This is what fascism looks like and yes it is fascism it's the 4th characteristic in the 14 Characteristics of Fascism

[@aekelly]

​@@Icemann89 Netanyahu's reaction has been way out of proportion. They're decimating Palestine and it's not ok.

[@Icemann89]

@@aekelly Which is exactly what Hamas wanted.

[@Carlin2810]

Oh hey we do that in the UK because actually diciplining a child is considered a form abuse & could upset them. Instead we ask the victim to think about what it was they did to cause someone to act out against them in such a way.

[@bikerd12]

Does not matter who is in charge of our government. When Israel says, "jump", American politicians says, "how high?".

[@BrettHanna-pv5xg]

Didnt Noam Chomsky make the stupid argument that "America controls Israel" not the other way around.

[@internetera1523]

Even Reagan told them to cut the crap at one point tho.Israel is good for US interests,but politicians knew that what the're doing now is going to have bad consequences for everybody.

[@user-di6pk8ez2y]

@@bikerd12 Everyone has a “BOSS” and when you accept DONOR BRIBES, even if you pretend to legalize it systematically and give it a legitimate name, with corporate errand boys called “lobbyists” micro-managing all LAWS and BUDGETS WASHINGTON votes upon, this is a SUPERFICIAL FORM of the government represented by the Constitution.

[@NotStanley-td5nn]

@@internetera1523 what political interests does Israel provide to the US? killing prominent political leaders all over the Muslim world whenever they feel like it? i believe that's called "terrorism". George W. Bush Jr. coined the phrase "War on Terror" but he really meant "War by Terror"

[@whichgodofthousandsmeansno5306]

That needs to end but for many it comes down to Judeo-Christian issues and that is a tough nut to crack. Especially in the USA where many think we are a Christian nation founded on Christian principles and Jews get a free pass because evangelicals tell them they are the chosen ones and collect that ca-ching from them. Granted many Jews are against the genocide in Gaza they are a small voice in the reality of things. Next consider how much money is donated to these Politian's from pro Israel factions. We are talking big bucks. That needs to end as well but no one is willing to end it and they don't see it as corruption.

[@Genocide2024]

Vote against genocide. Vote jill stein.

[@forthepeople5]

The only moral choice.

[@coolfool147]

She had 4 years to speak as a VP. Theres not 1 thing i remember she did, and she want to speak? I dont want to vote for trump . Kamala never took action.

[@novideostoday]

MAGS 2024 it is then 🤡

[@janmortimer1758]

Jill stein 2024

[@coolfool147]

@novideostoday that isn't the 2 options out there. You need to brake through that propaganda gang "democracy " crap and look over other candidates.

[@novideostoday]

@@coolfool147 Voting for Jill Stein is like donating money to the Trump campaign.

[@hurricanemarigolds2818]

She spoke quite a bit actually, the media just didn't cover most of it. I'd suggest looking through her twitter sometime. Also, Kamala is the VP, she doesn't have enough power to fix the genocide or even cut their arms funding. While she is still VP, she is obligated not to stray too far from the current administration's positions too.

[@dfreeman13]

See, she opened her mouth. That's her problem.

[@janmortimer1758]

😂😂😂

[@SergioLopez-bd9gt]

“…we don’t vote for genocide” was what they were chanting

[@bigstuff52]

Thanks for pointing that out..

[@loooongneck]

So are these people implying they intend to not vote / vote third party and hand advantage over to Donald “we should let Israel go in and finish the job” Trump?

[@thepeacefulbuddah]

Yeah, and Kyle keeps claiming the activists & protesters were related, when they were not. The activists who met with Kamala didn't plan on protesting her speech, which leaves me to kinda disregard Kyle's opinion.

[@WokeOne75]

....and her response (rightly) was, " If you want to vote for Trump just say that!" Like, this is not the election to play around with! Your choice is Harris or Trump. That is it! EVen if you sit this one out. That is a vote for Trump over Harris.

[@SergioLopez-bd9gt]

@@WokeOne75 Kyle was right, she could have handle it better. She needs to hustle the Palestinian votes. If she antagonises the Arab voters she will be the one helping Trump win the election.

[@avtircaritas8229]

This is just like Hillary's "deplorables" crap.

[@avtircaritas8229]

@@A-Wesker-5 the result is the same. The tone is the same. The patronizing is the same. Kamala realized this and changed her approach in Arizona. She, unlike you, realized that her approach needed to change. Because we are in an election for democracy, and she knows she needs to earn those votes.

[@riadanabtawi5880]

Hillary has been her mentor for years . Voting for Kamala is like voting for Hillary.

[@lanstar83]

Geezus i wasn't bothered til i actually heard her say it. You're empowered by the state to speak. We aren't. The state is us, so you're empowered by us to speak. So we'll let you know when you can speak.

[@H-no2fk]

That's what I'm talking about. The civility politics of the American left makes me sick. We just hand over our power and sit with our hands out begging.

[@atlasmoon5497]

“all she needs to do is lie well enough and we’ll all be good” 🤡🤡🤡

[@forthepeople5]

Exactly. Shameful. ✅Vote for Jill Stein and Butch Ware. ✊People 🌎Planet ☮Peace

[@ilovenyiloveny1140]

You want her to lie? She owes her soul to the war machine.

[@moshpuppy13]

@@ilovenyiloveny1140 boom

[@boeing757pilot]

Exactly.. I'm a progressive, and if Kamala lies better, I can justify voting for her..

[@bloo9699]

Gotta be a weird situation where you need to campaign for your own administration while fulfilling your duty to support the current administration.

[@dirtabd]

Huh? Sitting Presidents do it all the time. The White House is an Admin, a team, not a dictatorship.

[@wearebecomedeathstar2658]

There is no duty to cover for Biden. Silence is complicity, Complicity because your boss says so is "Just Following Orders" and a prosecutor should know better than to use that excuse.

[@WokeOne75]

Yep. These people act as if she has the power right now to override Biden on these issues! She doesn't!!!! Give her time to run the race and win. THEN start the pressure campaign. Doinhg it now is only going tio elect Trump. Then you can forget about any help for Gaza.

[@memebobs9011]

@@wearebecomedeathstar2658 There's a reason she got picked for VP over the basket of democrats that ran in 2020

[@bloo9699]

@@dirtabd Sitting presidents contradict their own agenda in campaigns?

[@user-di6pk8ez2y]

NO COUNTRY is ABOVE INTERNATIONAL HUMANITARIAN LAW🇺🇸🌎🇺🇳

[@greedy3astard270]

Except those countries and no one can do anything about it...for now

[@riiraa881]

Some think they are because they are powerful, but there is a higher natural order in this universe that drives decent human beings forward to topple evil when evil has done too much. We are not time and time again throughout human history. Evil can only win for a short time because in the end, human decency will prevail.

[@Lala-tt5xr]

It seems that IsrealHELL is

[@eternityinyoureyes300]

Israel is though

[@user-di6pk8ez2y]

@@eternityinyoureyes300 The bribed politician “ILLEGALLY” have manipulated our laws, to create the ILLUSION that ISRAEL is ABOVE the LAW. HUMANITY 🌎and the 🇺🇳International Criminal Courts knows very well Israel has gone ROGUE and is being supported for political, military, and economic purposes. There is no way forward for ISRAEL and the USA here. The USA is already suffering economically and can’t sustain WWIII against the New 🌎multi-polar economy of BRICS and the military reorganization of Turkey, Russia, China, and now most of the Middle East rising-up to STOP ISRAEL from it’s harm to humanity and Jews who were radicalized, being left with nothing. War is always an “INSANE MINDSET” by human predators that SOLVES NOTHING.

[@zikemiller1466]

Uncommitted Michigan voter. Now totally committed to voting for Jill Stein.

[@Hatchet_Jack556]

Sure you are

[@stanchpandora3658]

Yea, one mistake means we should throw away our democracy

[@jay31415]

Here's what I would have wanted a president to say in this situation: > "I see we have pro-palestinian protestors. You know what, let's talk about Palestine. Let's talk about Gaza. Right now. Someone get them a mic. What questions do you have for me?"

[@charlesray9674]

Not going to happen. She doesn't know how to read the crowd. She's an AIPAC baby so I'm not convinced that she'll reverse course....

[@threedogzz]

F the war machine. F complicity. Free Palestine 🇵🇸

[@OANNAAS]

And F Hamas .

[@damage4118]

Her mask slipped off

[@ajhwood1961]

Tim Walz record is far from impeccable. Just ask the Arab Americans in MN who had their meeting with him cancelled once he found out they wanted to talk serious solutions instead of crying and giving him sob stories. Jill Stein 2024💚

[@boeing757pilot]

Of course! Glad you're intelligent enough to see through this nonsense..

[@josephcivitano4290]

You mean we can have 4 years of avoiding press conferences, interviews or asking any critical questions while she dismisses anything she doesn't a gree with? Is this the way?

[@janmortimer1758]

🎯No policies on web. Site.just hand out for 💰💰💰cos that’s what it’s all about after all and oh yes lots of merch.😂

[@karidrgn]

@josephcivitano4290 you forget that the last year of trumps presidentcy, his admin didn't even hold a daily briefing. As for that so called press conference trump did a couple of days ago? Softball questions with no followup, abd the few good ones that did get asked he attacked the reporter then rambled into into wierdo land. Heck, even his answer to the Softball questions didn't make sense.

[@F_C...]

It's the same strategy that lead to Biden floundering at the debate. The establishment dems and the legacy media hide their flaws, protect them from scrutiny. And then you wonder why they fall apart the first unscripted moment they face.

[@cheryllynninsananton]

Neither candidate seems to understand that genocide is a big deal.

[@novideostoday]

The protestors don't seem to understand when to shut the fuck up 😂

[@SimpCity2000]

No protester honestly understands what is on the line here, either.

[@janmortimer1758]

Jill stein 2024 ☮️

[@janmortimer1758]

@@SimpCity2000duopoly the same

[@carrite]

@@janmortimer1758 - Let us know how that works out for ya.

[@dougie336]

For a lot of people being complicit in literal genocide is the most important issue, how so many in the comments can't understand that and are dismissing it under a Kyle Kulinski video is truly concerning..

[@thyCarrot]

Yeah. Kyles comment sections are more and more center by the day. If he doesn't personally moderate them, which seems to be the case, it just enables the same DNC and RNC talking points, which according to all my years following him, would not be what he wants.

[@user-di6pk8ez2y]

@@dougie336 I can’t support ANY COUNTRY, including my own the USA 🇺🇸, who commit any phase of ethnic cleansing on civilians to obtain their property, with an agenda of violence and expansion, military/political power and greed. Any American 🇺🇸 who supports a foreign country committing International War Crimes, is putting their own families and NATIONAL SECURITY at risk NOW and in the FUTURE 🌎.✨🇺🇸🕊️

[@milkiway2012]

I've been following Kyle for years ... And on this , he's wrong. Muthafuker cares more about terrorist than saving innocent people

[@boeing757pilot]

@@dougie336 Well said..

[@ArleeStarr]

Vote against genocide and fascism! Jill Stein 2024! Green Party for all other elected offices 2024!

[@katumispencer]

So, what do you do if someone keeps interrupting you while you are speaking?

[@Wakish0069]

Did you see how Obama handled is the numerous times it's happened?

[@RibblesMcSnoo]

Maybe don't support a genocide?

​@@RibblesMcSnoo Why aren't they interrupting the Trumpists? Why is their goal only to try to make dems look as bad as possible? I'm pro Palestine but I'm starting to not trust some of these organisations. It's sus how their only goal seem to be making people be mad at democrats.

[@georgeantonopoulos545]

If you didn't say anything for such a HUGE ISSUE ,then they have the right to demand ab answer!

[@TheFatAssCat]

​​@@RibblesMcSnoo right.. let's re-state the question to reflect reality. What do you do when misinformed people interrupt you while speaking?

[@marieamato1667]

I saw the whole thing and she did not sneer! She insisted for respect. P

[@aFoxyFox.]

Does ahe deserve any respect whatsoever when her whole platform us "well I'm a different human being than Donald Trump"? She has not outlined any policy things on her website or anywhere, there are less than 90 days left. She has been standing by the center of power as American Tax Payer money is being used not towards helping this nation, but rather for arming that nation, with arms they are actively using to harm a non-combatant, innocent, civilian population, over 2 million people squeezed into a 25 mile long and 5 mile wide area they keep attacking and the population is being starved to death, filled with disease, while being blown to pieces daily. She stands next to Biden as he keeps signing off on this and doesn't do anything serious to act against it, and she keeps on nodding and smiling. What respect does a war criminal, complicit with a war criminal, supporting a war criminal, deserve? Your vote with a bloodstained ticket or button on the machine? The people yelling, can they morally justify contributing to helping this go on for voting for either of the people who have done nothing and said that they will do nothing to stop it? Just like all the people crying out for this to be stopped, it feels like it is falling on deaf ears. So they must shout and shout and shout louder and everywhere and not let up so long as ordinary innocent people are being tortured like they are there, and lives are being utterly ruined.

[@janmortimer1758]

😂😂😂

[@user-jk9ok7ub9y]

Hey she had to respond. They were totally disrupting and wouldn't stop. Most of us are proud of her response starting with being polite then when that didn’t get a respective response, she shut them down.

[@user-xj9po6ep9i]

I will say, it sucks she doesnt have a single line about Gaza in her speech.

[@janmortimer1758]

Cos she is also controlled by ISR.Her husband even came out and said as much.

[@user-xj9po6ep9i]

@janmortimer1758 source please? Let me guess stormfront? Gtfoh.

[@gilmartinez2410]

100 % correct Kyle. Reasonless response. No sugar coating

[@50lid5nak3]

She said the same she always says when people interrupt her speaking. I don't really see an issue here.

[@gangofgreenhorns2672]

"Why don't you protest Trump?!" "So you're saying he's more amenable to a ceasefire?" It's such a bad, clearly disingenuous argument.

[@kimberlyjonasen1215]

They were chanting we won’t vote for genocide and no she didn’t meet with these same people disrupting .

[@Shineon83]

***HARRIS NEVER SAID SHE WAS “OPEN” TO AN ARMS EMBARGO!!!***

[@Shineon83]

***STOP LYING ABOUT HARRIS!! HER SPOKESMAN SAID SHE WOULD NEVER BACK AN ARMS EMBARGO!!!***

[@naehalmulazim]

Freedom of speech but I'M SPEAKING

[@newsandpolitics749]

This is possibly the best, most astute, and ethically sound youtube video on US campaign politics I have seen to date. Love your work, Kyle and team. 🎉

[@afterhourscinema782]

*AIPAC:* "You didn't think we wouldn't control them both, did you??" 😂

[@DanA-nl5uo]

American citizens nope that is why we voted Jill Stein

[@thade7062]

@@DanA-nl5uo Piss of Ivan a vote for Jill Stein is a vote for Trump, apparently you want to see Palestine bulldozed into the ocean which is what his administration will support.

[@salahelsharif1513]

not only both of them , but congress with its two parties

[@janmortimer1758]

@@DanA-nl5uo👍💚☮️

[@janmortimer1758]

@@salahelsharif1513yes,😂these people have drank the blue koolaid fast!

[@GambiaAibmag]

I don't think the Protestors were from the Uncommitted Movement?

[@DanA-nl5uo]

So you think the movement against support for Israel is even bigger could be.

[@Mydogslove2laugh]

They were not

[@spencer_jackson542]

I don’t believe that she actually believes that these people are gonna vote for Trump. She practiced saying that and her face and phony eyebrow raise so people like Lawrence O’Donnell and Joy Reid can fawn over her.

[@carolea7158]

@@DanA-nl5uo The anti-genocide movement is indeed not limited to the Uncommitted Movement.

[@NoLoVeLoStNoLoVfOuNd]

Oh know yes they were

[@ugxsan]

Ah, the status quo and "party unity" rears its ugly head.

[@dianedrungelo8269]

She should've said, No I don't believe in genocide.

[@emhu2594]

she obviously does.

[@iaimboti]

That could be interpreted negatively (like as in "I don't believe in genocide" being she don't think it is one)

[@cynthiabragg2611]

​@@iaimboti Kamila knows it's a genocide, you would have to be delusional to not think so.

[@jakegetrost4690]

Who on the left is being paid by future forward pac? Now I’m paranoid about influencers not being honest about what they believe. Literally flat payments for each post that promotes the particular candidate. That is absolutely disgusting no matter what your politics are

[@davidjairala69]

No, she shouldn't have. She has to stay fucking SILENT about it, and then on day one roll the embargo. Of course, I'm not holding my breath.

[@pooyanordoubadi6811]

All she has to say is that she supports a ceasefire? She doesn’t believe in a ceasefire. I am guessing that’s why she isn’t saying that.

[@draculemihawk3123]

Shameful by Kamala

[@samsson6430]

Shameful by the protestors. Do they think Trump will think twice about letting Israel have Palestine? These protestors either don't have a thinking brain, or they are working for the Trump campaign.

[@jacobbennett4074]

Kamala, Kamala, you can't hide. We won't vote for genocide.

[@willweng305]

Your other choice is vote for Trump all the way. Logic is not your strong suite

[@apasolini]

​@@willweng305there are other choices and you know it

[@nicksgottalent]

@@apasolini Exactly. I wish people knew the power we have as people because we could come together to prop up a third party candidate who is actually for the working class and poor people and is also good on foreign policy but none of us want to get educated. We have the power and choose not to use. Too many of us have been fooled into thinking American capitalism is the way when it's not. Fred Hampton once said "You don't fight capitalism with black capitalism. You fight it with socialism." Paul in the Bible said that the love of money is the root of all evil and capitalism thrives off of the love of money

[@BladeValant546]

​@@nicksgottalentokay trump wins and you lost your vote what's your plan then.

[@erictheredguy]

If you don't vote for Mamala then Trump wins and it's 10 x worse. She has to get elected! Remember Lincoln said horrid shit when he was first running to get elected

[@Leathurkatt]

Being intolerably rude during someone's speech does not gain you anything. Waiting for the second meeting would have gotten them way more of what they wanted.

[@Scott-s5j]

People are being massacred in tens of thousands, body.

[@1massboy]

At the end of the day, you have to win people over. Kamala did a bad job in her response to these people. She better do better next time if she wants to win.

[@unholyiiamas]

​@@Scott-s5jYes, but you know what? Americans don't care. They care about the problems we have at home. It sucks, but it's reality. These people trying to impair Harris winning are just going to make it worse for themselves and the people they are protesting for, because Trump wants Palestine wiped out, unlike Harris.

[@Leathurkatt]

@Scott-s5j That is no excuse to be an insufferably rude and obnoxious jerk.

[@user-md3wm7vu1f]

doubt it. it hasnt gotten them anything up to now from the biden administration other than empty words (and kamala's people have indicated to israel their position will be the same as bidens). it does not appear she had any real reason to delay the meeting until after the speech unless it was just meant to placate the protesters until the chance to protest had passed

[@Dave_Langer]

isn't it weird how when Trump does things like this he gets praised fans and the media but when Harris does it, she gets bashed. that being said she should have an answer for this kind of thing already. She should expect its gong to happen.

[@jonsmith9838]

she getting bashed by people not voting for her anyway.

[@Rowsy91]

it depends on how you feel about the people protesting People that dont like protestors typically like when they get shut down. I found this funny, since my exp on both left and right is most protestors are just kids throwing a tantrum in public. I had a couple friens that went through the phase in college the two girls had a new pressing issue every month Trump fans in general like protestors getting shut down. Dem fans are typically pro-protestor (although im liberal and anti protestors ) So its not hard to see why Trump would get praised and Kamala less so

[@jonsmith9838]

@@Rowsy91 always assume The right like the dysfunctional family. In the primary they fight but in the general they come together and if someone from the outside of their group attack one of their own they will fight for them

[@kbadrig]

Thank you for talking about this 👍

[@mehdibencaid6954]

She just showed what she really thinks in a moment of frustration. That woman wont do jack sh!t to stop Israel

[@Arbaaltheundefeated]

Nobody in their right mind should have expected her to be anything other than a continuation of the status quo on ISR-PAL anyway. This is unsurprising.

[@Parallax982]

You're not giving her a chance. Let her win and then we'll find out. Yes, of course I'd rather she break with Biden on this now. But not if it costs her the election.

[@SapientGalaxy]

@@Parallax982 Shortly after it came out that she said she was open to discussing an arms embargo, some one from the administration "corrected the record" and said, no, actually she doesn't support an arms embargo. She will be the same as Biden.

[@Parallax982]

@@SapientGalaxy That's not clear. What is clear is she's trying to say and do as little as possible to tip her hand one way or the other. Which makes total sense since this splits our coalition down the middle. We can't afford that split if we hope to beat Trump. That's just the reality. I wish every Democrat agreed with us. But it makes no sense to sink her campaign. She shouldn't do it and neither should we. She's given off subtle signals that she may shift. For now, that needs to be good enough. I wouldn't say that if a Trump victory didn't guarantee something FAR WORSE.

[@ghostnote1970]

​@@SapientGalaxy We will see. Nobody can know that for sure. Biden is still President, not Harris, in case you haven't noticed. Why are so many Americans so dense? Nomatter left or right, everybody wants it perfect. There is no such thing as a perfect candidate, who pleases Everybody! Grow Up, FFS!

[@SapientGalaxy]

​@@Parallax982 She's doing the same wishy washy, milque toast "Oh, I feel bad for them and what's happening is bad" as Biden has been doing every week while not supporting any of the policies to actually change it. Why the fuck are they trying to appeal to the minority who are Jen s*de supporters while flipping off the people in the majority who have the bare minimum amount of decency? They have been told for months that supporting Jen s*de is a red line by people on the left and that they would not vote for Biden if he didn't change policy. If she continues to flip off those people as well, they won't vote for her either. But instead of trying to reach those people and show a spine, instead we have to only try to appeal to the people on the right. Now isn't the time for "subtle signals". We have been watching a Jen s*de for nearly a year. The majority of Americans are horrified by it. Any one with even a shred of integrity would be very vocally making it obvious this won't stand under them. Instead we have her pretending to be open for change and then members of the administration saying she doesn't support change. And with the A*P*C money she's received? I believe it.

[@donaldcassel400]

In the sheer moment , she did it in a classy but stern way, Can you imagine how trump would have handlesd that?

[@aFoxyFox.]

Maybe not all that differently? Maybe your imagination is a bit more advanced, but this A.I. voice modeling technology can supplement a lack of imagination and make Trump say what she said, and it seems legitimate and possible to me that he would say something quite similar in a similar way, even with the part about not voting or not voting for him being a vote for whatever is "bad" in their view. I can see all the same tactics or very similar ones. Sorry to use your comment to highlight that, I regret it.

[@lucitaferguson1025]

She handled it great

[@katyroseable]

I don't think so.

[@mikeoley13]

She handled this better in Arizona. I’m sure the MSM hated her response.

[@johanvanhecke8583]

Hello. I am from Belgium and I have a question ; I thought Americans can only choose between Donald Dump (:) ) and Harris , but here I hear that one can vote for Jill Stein ( and 2 others)... How is that ??

[@rachelb2464]

Some states will not even have C. West on the ballot. Almost all (or all have not kept up this year) will have the green party or allow people to write that candidate in (Jill Stien). The libertarian party will also be on most states or accept write in, however none of these parties are platformed at the debates. The media will not interview the candidates and almost all voters see them as spoiler candidates that take votes from the Democrat(Green) or Republican (Libertarian)party. The way media ignores them and the amount of money it takes to get a party federal level is a big problem for other parties. Look up USA last presidential election and check voter numbers, you will see how small other parties are.

[@nicollaney]

The people who met with her were with the uncommitted movement, but the people who protested were not connected with the uncommitted movement, so it was two different groups that as far as the reports go, we’re not in contact with each other but our after the same end goal.

[@debh5780]

Well most effective if the goal is the same would have been to meet with her together.

[@grmpf]

This comment is some People's Front of Judea level sheet.

[@6milligram]

She barely met with the uncommitted movement that was an lie by the NYT and Kamalas team has already confirmed it.

[@gagmaloswinger7197]

No one uncommitted attended her rally

[@marcelrobinson]

I'm sorry to say, but individuals outside of the uncommitted movement often lack the nuance and critical thinking that others rely on. Their binary approach to issues can lead to extreme measures, like discarding valuable aspects of a system, simply to make a point and claim the opposition is uncaring.

[@YonieZukowsky51]

In Gaza the people are not allowed to express their personal opinions if it goes contrary to the official Hamas talking points. Many who chant free Palestine are unaware of this. It is important to know that Hamas does not allow freedom of speech.

[@janmortimer1758]

Rubbish!the d@ms don’t!!

[@OGSAFUNKATEER1901]

I will not be voting for Kamala for her stance on the Palestinian genocide. Israel should be held accountable. Kamala feels entitled to get the presidency handed to her. I would rather not vote because it would be a waste.

[@mtdouthit1291]

Why u yelling bro. Chill

[@novideostoday]

What the hell, bro? Let this White liberal tone-police a Black woman running for the office, bro. They have been free since 1834, bro. And look what they have done, bro. They don't even let our people to speak over them, bro. The damn Black people, bro 😂

[@janmortimer1758]

Maybe cos he endorsed j st ein.guilt?

[@zahraabdullahi1601]

You can't rationalize this away. When people show you who they are...believe them.

[@HZ-fg9sf]

Alas you are missing the forrest for the trees.

[@zahraabdullahi1601]

@@HZ-fg9sf No. You are allowing Democrats to do whatever they want out of fear of Republicans. You need to demand better, and be willing to be uncomfortable.

[@davidowens1424]

She's pretty condescending and rude. A woman who 🪛 her way up the ladder, earned nothing, has done nothing, demands respect. No, she'll get neither respect nor support.

[@sanguisbumb6138]

She didn’t screw her way to the top. That’s a flat out lie.

[@kain9407]

You being wrong is you being wrong. Just like when you simp for Rogan.

[@user-ew8mp3oc4n]

Exactly

[@economicsandsociology208]

Joe Rogan is a far right republican now.

[@imfromthecity]

Word, brother. Talks all this shit about him but when he gets on his show there is like zero confrontation.

[@kain9407]

@@economicsandsociology208 Yep

[@lavendereucalyptus3225]

Kyle, you nailed it! Thanks for calling out and be fair with this. 🙏 She could have easily expressed her sympathy and compassion toward the protestors, she will not shut them out, they will keep protesting UNTIL the genocide STOPS with PERMANENT CEASEFIRE! These politicians think they can just pacify their base and the problem will go away?! NO HUMAN should put up with crimes against humanity of GENOCIDE!

[@SimpCity2000]

She did. They ignored her.

[@SeanUCF]

They weren't protesters, they were hecklers. Showing up and accusing someone of genocide isn't a serious way to get what you want. Those idiots were just there to virtue signal and hurt our cause to stop the atrocities in Gaza.

[@lavendereucalyptus3225]

@@SeanUCF They’ve been taking every opportunity protesting on many political platforms, and the Harris/Walz rallies are very important platform to stress their dire concerns that the genocide is going on as we speak. What makes you accuse the protestors’ intentions other than genuine? Why would they spend the money and pay to buy the tickets to participate in the rally, just to harass…?! It doesn’t make sense.

[@shawnh9590]

I disagree that this was a mistake. I think a bigger mistake for her, as a woman candidate, would have been to been passive or come off as weak against such instigators (which Republicans would have pounced on). Also, in terms of campaigning, she is smart to avoid talking about Gaza where possible, as it's a bit of a lose-lose electorally.

[@originalulix]

2/3rds of voters (including a majority of Republicans) support a permanent ceasefire. So you are clearly wrong.

[@haledhajdari1154]

Means she is corrupt .

[@rezrunnercl]

@shawnh9590 She deserves to lose if she supports ge-no-cide. Yes, let's go back to 3rd party. Blue Maga is insufferable, just like Hillary in 2016. Arrogance never sells. It's your fault if we get Trump.

[@zemorakeller6725]

She's in MI! She has to address the Gaza issue andic she doesn't it will make her look weak

[@organican]

@@zemorakeller6725 She may be speaking in Michigan, but she is being heard everywhere

[@jay23cr]

She is unbearably arrogant... Never liked her

[@clarity-re3mn]

It wasn't a sneer, she handled it respectfully, because it's true, she WAS talking.

[@ryansheedy5187]

God that look after she said otherwise im speaking is part of why i dont think i can bring myself to vote for her. Wildly unlikable

[@memebobs9011]

I’m not a mind reader and I don’t know Kamala’s true position on Gaza but don’t you think it would be a little weird for her to take the opposite position of the administration she’s currently serving in? It’s a unique political position in American history where the VP is trying to run her own campaign while still representing the current admin

[@Turnsnap]

VERY underrated comment

[@Kry-le3dq]

There is Nothing Unique in funding GENOCIDE - its a War Crime , she Biden & Blinken will all be found guilty by the ICJ in due course

[@williamhammer9649]

I mean she’s not the first VP to run lol, it’s just usually this would happen at the end of the presidents second term, not first. Al Gore was still Bill Clinton’s VP when he was running for president in 2000

[@y.martel842]

Anybody with common sense knows exactly what's gonna happen when Kamala gets in. The very same thing that's happening now is gonna happen again with her as President. This woman is not a leader, she is a puppet just like Biden.

[@boeing757pilot]

Why? That shows a leader. And that administration is months from ending.. Regardless, her campaign released a statement that she's AGAINST an embargo. So, there's the answer..

[@claudiafinelle7252]

She changed her tone the next time it happened in Arizona and handled it well.

[@jefflayton153]

Well it was fun while it lasted. Back to voting 3rd party 😂😂😂😂

[@lilkitkittu2709]

Wow really? That’s all the fight you got? 😂 THAT moment was enough? Man it’s no wonder republicans can still win elections without promising people a damn thing. Look at their opposition!

[@economicsandsociology208]

Third-party has no chance of winning and you know it! You really must want Trump to win! It’s either Trump or Kamala! No way around it!

[@eskimojoe8423]

That was a little glimpse of the real Kamala.

[@thedarknight307]

Honestly I don’t blame her here. She met with the Uncommitted Organizers and based on their statements talks went very well. They felt listened too. These protestors came without either group’s knowledge. Based on what we’ve seen she is willing to at least LISTEN to protestors and hopefully be pushed to be better

[@redeyespyone]

@@thedarknight307 great point.

[@josev4338]

Exactly. What was she supposed to just stand and look weak? They acted like children and got spoken to like children.

[@haledhajdari1154]

She is supporting g3nocide and we are not okay with it. Simple.

[@thedarknight307]

@@josev4338 Id say her and Walz willing to meet with the Uncommitted Organizers is a major step forward. Arguably, even mor thenw what Biden has done

[@onamove70]

She told the protestors basically to shut up because she was speaking. She did not listen to the people in the audience, nor did she try to placate them. She just shut them out, when they are right and she is beyond wrong on this issue. Should protestors get permission to appear and protest genocide? It's our right. Also, the people who met with her should not feel listened to, they should be running things. They are average people who care. She is a wealthy powerful well-connected person who does not care about Gazans, or us. If she did she would have shown it by now.

[@larryhampton6290]

Disagree totally

[@economicsandsociology208]

Kyle is becoming just like Sabby Sabs and Jimmy Dore, who are both Republicans pretending to be leftists!

[@ChrisDaMaddog]

This could be the start of another cycle of "change on the outside, continuity on the inside". Time will tell.

[@Antimonkat]

I honestly expected her response to be worse compared to what I was expecting, she handled it "ok"

[@xAssailantx]

I'm not speaking about Kyle here but I think a huge portion of the online left and tankies were just fishing for an excuse to virtue signal about not voting. Like if this slightly more aggressive than mild tone is getting you to jump off over actual policy then you're fake as hell.

[@johnnydub1985]

I'm still not voting for trump, Kyle. Sorry. Not sorry.

[@FernyCeballos]

Completely disagree. She gave them a voice, met with them and they were still hostile. I have no problem with what she did. Imagine if everyone who is passionate about an issue, did what they did after meeting with them. That's a motivation not to hear people out. Heckling is the most ineffective way to win someone over. Good faith convos is not about heckling.

[@rezrunnercl]

@@FernyCeballos BS They met her in a line and took the opportunity. She surely didn't make the gesture. It's Michigan. It's not like she doesn't know the importance of the issue. What a complete more on. Dies she want to bring back voters or not?

[@BradleyHWrites]

Kamala said to protesters in Glendale, Arizona "now is time for ceasefire" in Gaza. She also said this: “The president and I are working around the clock every day to get that ceasefire deal done and bring the hostages home. I respect your voices, but we are here to now talk about the race in 2024.”

[@yoda4469]

Horrible take by Kyle.

[@Saumie]

Why?

[@benjamincasper7615]

@@SaumieKamala spoke with the protestors beforehand, there was no need for them to interrupt her

[@economicsandsociology208]

He’s becoming just like Sabby Sabs and Jimmy Dore, who are both Trump supporters that are pretending to be leftists.

[@sovereign_888]

She just refused the full arms embargo today

[@reneenyberg4832]

Because it is impossible and will make the situation worse.

[@mohamedhassan9364]

@@reneenyberg4832 you sound stupid doing arms embargo on weapons is going to stop mass murdering women and children

[@salahelsharif1513]

she is walking a fine line , needs uncommitted voters in swinging states , and doesn't want to alaram AIPAC

[@cinemacrayne4933]

​@@reneenyberg4832🙉🙈🙊🇵🇸✡️☮️

[@xAssailantx]

Because its not a good idea. If she commits to an arms embargo and it looks like she is going to win the election that might be the final straw for Netanyahu to fully commit to a war with Iran knowing that the US will have to support them.

[@eyyy2271]

While she will certainly be better on Gaza and did meet with uncommitted organizers, at the very least just say "we hear your concerns" it wouldn't have hurt. 🤦

[@ChinnuWoW]

Why “certainly”? I think she would’ve done the same as Biden. She’d fund the genocide.

[@janmortimer1758]

No she won’t .

[@pandorafox3944]

She should have addressed their concerns. And it is their first amendment right to protest. Get real Kamala.

[@Lala-tt5xr]

Can she keep "speaking" about the assault on women in jail in PALESTINE ?? Can she keep "speaking" about the schools that are bombarded ? Can she keep "speaking" about the starvation in PALESTINE ? Can she keep "speaking" about the beheaded babies and the innocent burnt alive in the tents ??

[@kristenpham6460]

I think she is indeed more empathetic to the protesters and Palestinians than Biden. In this scenario, she simply wanted to show off her girl boss vibe which is such a turn off. Why do all those politicians like to teach voters how to behave?

[@GOPSlayer]

the girl boss thing is cringy, but it's needed at first. a lot of politics is just optics. and as far teaching voters how to behave, most voters are just NPC autonomous dumb dumbs

[@novideostoday]

Nice to see White liberals tone-policing a Black woman and tell her what she should do and how she should act. We have been free since 1834. You literally can't make this shit up 😂

[@SimpCity2000]

You need to remember who is going to vote in November. If she looks weak here, how weak do you think she is going to look on the border, the #2 issue for voting Americans this year?

[@janmortimer1758]

No she’s not!

[@MattBuild4]

Besides her talking, what evidence is there that shes more empathetic?

[@melbla3609]

Reading the comments, we finally realize how the USA can provide weapons and support, apparently unconditional, to a fascist country engaged for almost a year in a genocidal enterprise. This same country that has been colonizing and guilty of apartheid, ethnic cleansing and a whole bunch of war crimes for decades and always with the support of the USA. Logistics. Military. Politics. (Veto after veto). For those of you who still have some moral principles, I would like to tell you that no; it is not by choosing a lesser evil that we avoid the worst. Please, do not let yourself be frightened by this scarecrow that is waved at you every time the moment of making a crucial decision arises. The scarecrow of billionaires who scream at you "TINA! TINA! TINA!" There is No Alternative. Listen to this inner voice that assures you that there is always a way. Trust and follow your instincts. Keep fighting the fight. Always. Good luck.

[@user-un8tv1pp8m]

As one Joseph Biden said about 15 years back in front of congress? "If israel didnt exist, we would want to invent it." And of course people in the state department did in the nineteen-fourties. As declassified documentation shows. Post WW2 the US wanted to have an armed outpost to project power to the middle east And the brits had the problem of a whole desparate population of fleeing european jewish folks who where already already primed for the idea by Herzl. And highly motivated by the holocaust to create just such an installation if properly eyquipped and financed. So ways where found to do that. Since then not much has changed. Except that US control over its plausible deniability proxy has waned and waxed from admin to admin. Modern US peace advocates seem to misunderstand the power balance here. US isnt used, its the user.

[@nrb1989]

Tina????

[@jamesmccoy8568]

Dead wrong - no substance here. Demonstrate that there will be a better outcome under Trump (you can’t)

[@jackgrove4621]

I will be voting for kamala

[@randomentity6553]

@@nrb1989 There Is No Alternative T.I.N.A. (And I believe there is no alternative.) I don't agree with Kyle here. These kids are screaming to drive the car to hell instead of disneyland because Satan promised Soft serve ice cream. Let's save OUR country before trying to save the freaking world.

[@AlyxCoe]

A prosecutorial attitude isn't necessarily what is needed here. That was a very ugly moment. Right after i saw this, i spoke to a family member about how Obama handled protestors, with grace, respect, often humor, and acknowledgment of the First Amendment.

[@alonso8722]

The leftists have gone completely mad on this palestine position. Optics matter. If they claim to care for the people dying, they should get real and understand this style of protest get them nowhere. Should be more appealing to independents and libs

[@DiamondFlame45]

I heard the same talking points back in 2020. Biden continued to capitulate to Republican demands and now it’s 2024 and we are back where we started. It’s funny how it’s like that every 4 years. Also, this is bad optics for her.

[@samsson6430]

They are not trying to push her. They are trying to label her. I been tired of these protestors for a while now.

[@mika_sky]

I am sure they will send you apologies for being disgusted with starving of children ... Disgusting ...

[@misterx3188]

1:56 - That's incorrect btw, they chanted "We won't vote for genocide."

[@sikavik]

Ewww. I was starting to somewhat warm up to Kamala, but I despise her again. I’m not voting for her, but I’m also not in a swing state 🤨

[@Rofl890]

She could have handled that better, granted, but at the same time, these people are not helping their cause. Dolts.

[@markUTview]

Do you want her to lie?

[@mewimagine5920]

The angry staredown was so cringy. She is rotten to the core

[@Artiej0hn0]

January 2024: " Daily death rate in Gaza higher than any other major 21st Century conflict - Oxfam"

[@sippitsparingly]

This is a lose lose issue. You are either pro genocide or antisemitic. What is the correct way to address this?

[@DanA-nl5uo]

By pointing out that anti Zionists is not anti sematic for starters. When you refuse to accept that pro genocide is the worse evil you are not serious

[@shuric1983]

Kyle you are in a bubble. Only a very small percentage of Democrats are not gonna vote for Harris cuz of her views on Palestine. For great majority of Democrats and independants that issue is like tenth on the list of priorities when we'll be voting this November.

[@DN-nm4rl]

Just curious, what are your priorities?

[@haledhajdari1154]

Important populations in swing state do care for justice.

[@susanferguson5635]

I care

[@KaiserMattTygore927]

"Only a very small percentage of Democrats are not gonna vote for Harris cuz of her views on Palestine." And that might be enough to cost her the election. Continue the 2016 arrogance.

[@thepeacefulbuddah]

Kyle, the protesters and the activists who met with Kamala were not related. And you keep talking about this as if they were. That leaves me to kinda disregard your point. I recommend watching The Humanist Report's video on the event.

[@HorrorGuru407]

She's right these protests are stupid as hell.....

[@jessicaalejandro4116]

Kamala either? What do you want dude?

[@that_heretic]

Kyle's politics are regularly stupid, counterproductive, and feckless. Dude's clueless on winning national elections.