I made a Gameshow to expose who's the FAKE gamer among us...

[@KarmaKins]

Scarra spending half the game at 0 points and missing both League of Legends and World of Warcraft only to shoot to second place at the last stretch is the comeback story we all need.

[@StochasticUniverse]

Although it was still pretty hilarious that the actual LoL screenshot that he missed HAD HIS FACE IN IT, lol.

[@Rorschachqp]

Shiphtur blocking for him at the end!

[@GrumpyPerson]

facts

[@josefkaras7519]

scarra got bonus points, without them he would lose, he is the fake gamer.

[@nicolama99]

V😅😅t TV t😅TR FTTZ😅😅

[@blaedus5318]

13:50 Gotta love Toast's smile knowing that Rae figured out that the answer was Among Us.

[@kiidkif2009]

Yup

[@breawen]

i hate that i guessed that at the first clue

[@galileodirectio]

@@breawen do you mind letting me know what wall was it? Or eas it just a gut feeling

[@blaedus5318]

@@galileodirectio, it's not a wall, it's the floor of one of the stages. It's shown in the pic as Toast confirms the answer.

[@enchantedxo]

fr tho, he was so proud lool

[@catjayp]

In the persona 5 one I saw the first picture and instantly thought "Man that wall looks like the walls in the school in persona 5"

[@Legendary_Detective-Wobbuffet]

Me too.

[@blaquephyrekendra1779]

The fact that I was confident it was the p5 bulletin board for grades concerns me. I've played that game too much. Nah 🤣🤣🤣😭

[@averyvukelic6236]

Bro Ive played like 5 hours of persona but I knew instantly what it was

[@rami9274]

it was persona or yakuza for me. i knew by the 2nd pic tho

[@twilighttricksterXXI]

Me too.....then we saw sojiros butt and then Life Will Change started to play so it was pretty obvious

[@xF3arl]

I agree with Rae, do this again. This was some of the most fun content I've seen in a minute from anyone.

[@clarkflorendo4415]

But now, actually with terraria 😂

[@xF3arl]

@@clarkflorendo4415 Now ONLY with Terraria.

[@madhattey]

Would be fun to have Jack guess in this one cause he's very good at noticing details especially if it's his favorite game

[@jenesselleynes3119]

@@madhattey 100% agree with you he likes details and he’s so fun to compete with

[@madhattey]

@@jenesselleynes3119 Give him something Shadow of the Colossus related and all you'd need to give him are a specific audio and/or literally a picture of just the salamander or something xD

[@landon_mccall]

The fact that Rae just yelled out Pacman... that would've been me everytime I knew it, xD

[@agnes3370]

Rae and lily interrupting toast's intro is always a classic 🤣

[@mathijsrikken]

Genuine question... why does Lily and basically every other female asian streamer put on a very weird fake little squeeky voice? And why does no one ever say anything about it?

[@clara0_0]

@@mathijsrikken cuz it's not fake and maybe you should check ur misogyny and leave women be?

[@mathijsrikken]

@@clara0_0 I guarantee that if they speak normal they will just a have a normal female voice with maybe a bit of an asian accent. The fact that most female asian streamers want to sound like anime characters because of the amount of simps for that shit weirds me out really.

[@mathijsrikken]

@@clara0_0 I also have no idea how you think its misogyny to say something like I did. If there were dudes that put on some weird fake anime voice I would hate it just as much😂

[@clara0_0]

@@mathijsrikken??? what constitutes a "normal female voice" to you? the amount of mind gymnastics you're going through just so u justify hating on them just bcz their voice is slightly high pitched which a lot of people have, women, men, or other

[@kayleenaraullo3094]

I wished I believed in something as much as Lily believed in Terraria.

[@elbooow]

Classic toast being interrupted by lily 😂

[@SheraXGD]

@[卐]Lakehuntist ⸜⁄ trash that was once used by someone and ended as a trash. But how about you? A floor, ground or rock that people will always step on and was useless.

[@fj6889]

@@SheraXGD why u mad its a bot dawg

[@SheraXGD]

@@fj6889 doesn't care if it was a bot. The bot was made by a user, isn't it?

[@-muthana-]

@@SheraXGD I doesn’t care tbh

[@frankmorrison9143]

@@-muthana- oh, good for you tbh, cause all the replies to the reply are just as useless as the initial bot, including this one :)

[@KiLLKiNDLY]

I really like these kind of videos and hope you do more it was really fun to play along with

[@Izzy711s]

I love Lily. She's so wholesome and adorable

[@Dragau4]

Seeing Scarra miss both games he plays was so funny, I don't play wow and that tree is so iconic

[@MaxedEntropy]

I've never played WoW and that was my first guess instantly aswell, atleast Scarra had quite a comeback at the end

[@h.t.8812]

@@MaxedEntropy exactly the same!!

[@silverwolfgamez]

I do play wow, and immediately guessed it, but then started second guessing myself when I saw the second image and heard the audio.

[@AximusLokar]

The funniest part is I guessed WoW *because* of how confident Scarra was going into answering that.

[@AllieFike1818]

I didn't get the first image, but the 2nd image brought back so much nostalgia and I knew instantly it was WoW

[@perfectfitrecords]

This is why Toast doesn’t need to worry about falling off as long as he decides to stay in the streaming game. He’s just too smart. This idea was good, I’m surprised he hadn’t done it already, it fits his catalog of content perfectly, and he executed/ had it edited so well that this was easily one of the best videos of the week on KZbin- and he’s not even a KZbin exclusive streamer.

[@dum462]

the idea has been done before. hard to follow up when you've already used so many popular games as your first episode answers; repeating games-as-answers in future episodes would be weak. content like this is entirely dependent on collaborating, not "WOW toast so smart."

[@AppleGameification]

What are you, some kinda twitch power rankings columnist?

[@crowlee4511]

This needs to be a series, too cool of a idea to be just one shot thing.

[@548Shen]

Agreed we need at least a rematch or new challengers or something

[@elijahjames6350]

@Joanna-gu5hkthat’s not healthy

[@PersonManManManMan]

Agreement

[@jesuisellee]

24:48 was my favourite moment LOL when you see Toast get backed into a corner hahaha

[@thelittleblackprince3114]

I love it too XD he's like "oop- shi- ok jesus!"

[@ShadowCM]

This is so fun. Definitely needs a sequel where Lily has to redeem herself against three new contestants

[@yumis_cells]

toast strategically including 'among us' in the title lmao we stan a big brain creator

[@Adiforge]

Oh my god How did I not see that !!? We have been played

[@MokuTom]

toast's editor*

[@mikir1741]

I didn't even notice it

[@belgianbonzai]

got to work them youtube algorithms

[@AWanderingSwordsman]

What an ending. This was great, you should do it again. Bring back the last place person and get 3 new people so eventually you can figure out who is the fakest gamer and lily gets a chance at either redemption or a double failure.

[@Dreadnote-pf7of]

And maybe there would be a terraria question... Hope that she wouldn't missed it

[@sendxnoodles]

spoiler

[@justinusis6604]

Love this idea

[@bonk193]

Lily's moments where she's guessing Terraria and failing every time are so adorable, I can't 🤣

[@Twisted_Code]

"is this going to be a video?" Also the comment above mine appears to be stolen.

[@gamerhurley]

ITS A -spaceship- TERRARIA

[@DarcyTheManstop]

Cringe

[@Notathumbtack]

Guys don’t bully her, she likes music!

[@xdragon2k]

She still got a lot of points for not have her game Terraria included in the list of clues.

[@averagecupofcoffee]

The sheer joy and nostalgia I felt when I correctly guess Wii Sports on the first image

[@breelynn2797]

I feel so accomplished. Went in expecting to not get any right only to blow myself away. Would love to see more of this content and continue playing along

[@malexthegreat]

ikr i thought i'm going to do terrible, i got 35. i somehow guessed castlevania and gta and metal gear soild correctly despite never playing them, i missed elden ring and halo 2 despite having over 150 hours in both. i got undertale instantly and pacman instantly and pokemon emerald instantly and the rest added up to a much higher score than i expected

[@annoy4nce648]

getting Castlevania made me feel like a gigachad.

[@jethex3542]

@@annoy4nce648 just the very colours of the character gave it away for me. if i see that kinda grey-yellow-black, it looks immediately like "alucard" to me.

[@Johnbon555]

Me too. I'm not good with knowing newer games but I remembered the older ones before 2015

[@jethex3542]

@@Johnbon555 "older ones before 2015"... sigh.

[@krelekari]

Lily is a true gamer Guessing Castlevania off the tunes alone and not the two pics was insanely smooth, not to mention all her other correct guesses A+ A+

[@Gedaxy_]

SHE SAID MINECRAFT IS TERRIA

[@Vaquix000]

@@Gedaxy_ So what, she was the only one to get Castlevania right.

[@TheRealKaare]

Bruh she forgot persona 5 even though she played it

[@StochasticUniverse]

Also, guessing Dig Dug at all is a win, whether it's a correct answer or not, lol. Anybody who even knows that DIg Dug is is a True Gamer. I bet most of the people in the comments haven't even heard of Dig Dug (because they're like 14 years old).

[@gamerhurley]

@@Gedaxy_ tbf that was the least minecraft-y sky i have ever seen. tho yeah that was obv the dirt texture

[@timluo55]

Had me dying when lily guessed diablo and Toast had to roast her.

[@SheraXGD]

@[卐]Lakehuntist ⸜⁄ said by a ground who was stepped on by other people

[@tonygov]

@@SheraXGD just report all its comments as hate speech It is using a racist symbol in its user name

[@andermium]

@@tonygov Technically the symbol isn't racist at all, it's just been used that way by 1940's Nazi Germany. In context of the channel, though, it's totally being used as hate speech.

[@SDREHXC]

Rae’s little short bit about being knocked out a bunch is kind of relatable. Growing up around me there was this kid that I swear to god got picked up by an ambulance at least once a year for knocking himself out on various objects outside. Park benches, fence poles, playground equipment, walls, trees, literally no inanimate object was safe from the homing potential of this kids head. It was unreal.

[@lime_seed]

cant believe syd doubted herself so much in the beginning, she proved herself to be the ultimate gamer !! scarra getting the only two games he normally plays wrong is comedy gold and rae guessing among us right away is iconic, she truly proved those 512hrs of gameplay to be useful LOL and dont worry lily you may not be the ultimate gamer but youre trying ur best and thats all that matters 👍

[@VijoPlays]

Bro I'm fucking shocked that P5 is so ingrained in my brain that I only needed the random blackboard to know it's P5

[@canonogic]

Rae gets even more chaotic when there's competition loool

[@TheGunzbeep-TG]

and not to mention that her *base* chaos is already high up 😂

[@Maret_]

I like toast’s variety of content he posts, and how he’s used his among us growth to expand

[@ClippedStreams101]

yeah Sherlock its a business its literally his main source of income

[@m1nshr00m]

@@ClippedStreams101 some people just make the same content until it’s dried out and then their channels just die off. He’s made smart decisions and was able to keep his audience. Don’t talk down to others for recognizing that

[@ClippedStreams101]

@@m1nshr00m damn you’re softer than a woman

[@fehiki]

I am so proud of Rae the chad gamer with 500 hours in Among Us for guessing said game with literally "two greyscales and some static noise" 😂

[@itsmaribell1415]

this has been my favorite streamer game show that ive seen so far! Really loved the content and all your guests, and ofc you toast!

[@skyoncloud5180]

I was waiting for Halo to come up that whole time, and when it did and they said subnautica, star wars, and xenoblade, I was in emotional pain. Thank you Syd for pulling one for the team. Also, I recognized it on the first pic. Those covenant screens are iconic in my childhood.

[@gulpin768]

“Scarra what do you look at when playing league? Clearly not the map” “I look at the champion im beating the crap out of!” Best moment lol

[@slyphknttdotdotdot637]

Must be a yasou or a master yi main

[@vcnm2960]

@@slyphknttdotdotdot637 kat main actually so not that far off lol

[@brianadam_s]

Toast always comes up with games that jog your memory or your brain. It's always a big brain move with Toast.

[@moonwatcher3350]

as usual

[@lucaswatts2141]

Was honestly pleasantly surprised to see castlevania sotn and super paper Mario on there but I knew both instantly on the first hint and it had me giddy

[@robe8723]

Next time you should let them lock in whenever they want, and not reveal the answer until all of the clues have been shown. Then give points for the correct answers, based on when they locked in. This allows the players and viewers a chance to guess if they know it after sequential clues.

[@esfera2181]

They will cheat like sydeon did, she waits till the last moment when everybody said the answer and then she writes it, like the pokemon one

[@uberthegamer8030]

I thought I was too much of a casual gamer but I got 41 lmao

[@Starplagues]

I got 39 out of 75 Points

[@becausewin]

turns out casual gamers ARE the real gamers

[@Freezyloen]

Oh wow, that's impressive. I got 33 and I thought I did pretty damn good XD

[@okjustdont6713]

Damn I thought I did really good at 38

[@Metaphysicaljournal]

This was so entertaining. Toast should just host this as a regular program.

[@1azza141]

The fucking panicked look on toasts face when Rae and Syd started yelling at him 😂😂

[@fosterkitteneos]

This was so fun to watch live. Yes please do more of these or some type of variation of this set up. It hurt when they didn’t know Pong. The ending was a twist.

[@carquest3748]

And wii sports

[@SirGoonsquire]

As someone with almost 1000 hours in Terraria, I can confirm none of these games were Terraria

[@sfbptank]

just finished the 1.4.4 run, I feel sad terraria are not in there...

[@Sebbir]

Thanks for clearing that up

[@SirGoonsquire]

@@sfbptank The new update is awesome

[@vnssn]

get a life bro..... damnnnn

[@hashir9903]

@@vnssn as someone with 2000 hours, I would really recommend you to try out terraria

[@Sweetumsh]

this was so entertaining hahah, please do this with more streamers! i'd love this to be a series!!

[@HighSchoolGhost]

caught offguard by the maplestory bops as bgm in this video, love it.

[@prestonplayz5446]

The way scarra couldn't believe it's LOL and Syd beat him at guessing 😆

[@nateoddy2164]

was anyone else just really enjoying Rae's very visceral reactions for everything? Especially the sound clues. That very first sound clue just watching her face light up was fantastic.

[@denzy3929]

The zoom in her face didnt help the cause xD

[@nateoddy2164]

@@denzy3929 I thought it was great

[@denzy3929]

@@nateoddy2164 me too, i meant that the zoom made it even more hilarious

[@nuru666]

@@denzy3929 should replace help with hurt then ;)

[@larrylobster333]

lmao Rae was so close to the screen trying to get a better look xD

[@seannav8237]

I don’t play too much games but the AUDIO BACKGROUND MUSIC FROM 20:35 - 22:40 is 1000% Wii channel photo background !! I recognized that too fast

[@Venom_1462]

My man said he has been playing LoL and WoW for about 2 decades but fails at guessing them but that comeback was epic

[@SulemanX]

I watched this on stream, this was hilarious, lily was bullied 😂 I love this squad sm 😂

[@symphonixblades]

Just to know, at what date did this stream? Because Toast takes awhile uploading things to his channel since his mainly on Twitch I do enjoy when he posts here because I don't like or use Twitch

[@mr.midnightsky2407]

@@symphonixblades Sep 24, the title is 'Guess the game challenge'

[@branovgerson6375]

I just love how Lily get bullied by Toast but deep down there Toast will always care for Lily. This is so much fun to watch

[@GoodieMobCustomurl]

Whoever the editor is, using Gwyndolin’s theme for Toast’s pain from getting interrupted, was beautiful

[@Lucas_Rangel]

6:47 its cool that i've never played castlevania, but i have watched so many videos on hollow knight, and a lot of them explains what is a metroidvania that i knew that it was castlevania with the first clue

[@beatlemnkyhuman]

A few things: 1st off: go sydeon. I’m a fan now. 2nd off : valkyreas “I ran into a tree” was the cutest thing ever. 3rd off: valid, Lilly likes music. Valid don’t hate guys. Late to the party but love your guys and gals work!

[@kintoljimo4849]

Really get exited when toast uploads as he's not to regular Also toast you should try out the among us fighting game it's funny and I'd really like to see you try it out

[@TetraSky]

Man, Scarra's picture makes him truly look like the gigachad he is.

[@IITANK3D]

I absolutely love how competitive Rae gets

[@LycanMOON]

I knew most of these first clue,seeing them act like “gamers”” is funny

[@SlowV6Mustang]

This show has made me realize that I’m a fucking nerd. I instantly yelled “Halo 2!” When I saw those forerunner screens

[@PowWowChikaBowWow6902]

Damn man, I got it at the shield/radar. I never played 2; only played 3, odst, reach, and 4

[@bigbuffoilymen]

I was on the edge of my seat because I've seen that radar so many times but I couldn't remember which game it was from

[@Speaker264]

never played Halo games before, still somehow I guessed it.

[@PowWowChikaBowWow6902]

@@Speaker264 nice lol

[@PowWowChikaBowWow6902]

@@bigbuffoilymen it happens dude, don’t worry

[@PirateSometimes]

I love his gameshows, Guess that Asian should be a seasonal series as a weekly event for a couple months with a finale like OTK's Schooled

[@Zeracan]

"Chasing that paper mario castlevania high" initially made me think of how good the Netflix Castlevania is. Good high. Great series. And Game Grumps did like a 10 hour playthrough of Paper Mario Thousand Year Door and like, yeah, pretty good time sink.

[@zankaa8031]

This is a genuinely great trivia game. Do it again.

[@Twisted_Code]

8:45 Rachell's hyperactivity here reminds me of Space Core from Portal 2

[@alexspain9103]

You know I'm a real gamer cause that bit of music at 0:54 is the opening of the Moonlight Butterfly track from Dark Souls 1.

[@minfei.]

The editing on this one is really great! Toast should make more game show similar to this one 'cause it's really entertaining. I saw this live and watched it again here. I didn't got bored even once. :>

[@thatbitchashley828]

Guess The Asian! 🤣

[@Maria-bt2hb]

Syd guessing wow and lol and scarra getting it wrong after saying he's been playing only those for years was way too funny

[@breakingbad3995]

This was really fun. I hope Toast does it again.

[@Zarnaken]

When Scarra said Fire Emblem and Toast's reaction, that was my exact reaction as well 🤣

[@noirknight6273]

Cool frame glitch at 29:11 All blue and upside down/mirrored

[@SliCooper]

Felt like I was a part of the gameshow and it was really fun. I'm with Rae, Toast you should definitely bring this back it really hit some of the nostalgia feels

[@anthonypepito6131]

Did they did this on a stream or not it kind of looked like it was on a stream if so do you know where I can find it??

[@SliCooper]

@@anthonypepito6131 I don't think so, what I meant was that I was imagining like I was a part of the show

[@Eliasxofficial]

Toast is a content genius. Twitch with an issue and all my man saw was prime content gameshow 💯

[@bored3760]

I love the bond between lily and toast

[@Third_]

To Anyone else who freaked out because they thought they were experiencing psychosis when you thought ray’s face turn blue and dismissed it at 18:02 : her face did in fact turn blue, you’re not going insane

[@tommydavidson4608]

15:05 pong is the first video game ever! How'd they miss that one lol also cute hiccup

[@NekoKei_FEARNOT]

Sydeon was like I won't be able to guess any and then literally winning the game.

[@duhduckdragon]

i kept track of points and i wouldve crushed these nerds Me: 32 Lilly: 15 Rae: 12 Scarra: 20 Sydeon: 21

[@Gemlover2014]

Me too!! I got 37!!!

[@MysticMicrowave]

I would've got decimated, Ive played on an Xbox my whole life

[@СергейДементьев-ы9р]

@@Gemlover2014 i've got the same score as you, neat

[@xxPenjoxx]

Amazing gameshow, loved playing along. Classic Scarra not getting the 2 games he said at the start

[@asprika9702]

27:32 idk if anyone realized but Lily's guess was ALMOST correct: one of the pictures is from Delfino Square, a track inspired on Super Mario Sunshine

[@tylermac1897]

I want to do this with my friends so bad because they only play shooter games

[@ZykoBlade]

throw in an old cod or battlefield in there

[@KeithSwanger]

24:45 Lily's reveal of Terraria on the Minecraft round was absolutely hilarious.

[@mott411]

I mean tbf those “clouds” look way more like terraria clouds than they do minecraft clouds😭

[@Sapling-ge7hb]

@@mott411 ig but even then terraria looks WAY different (I also have over 700 hours in it soo…)

[@shadowhunter5418]

​@@Sapling-ge7hb if you search terraria clouds on google literally those clouds come up

[@LANGSTONAMADI]

Sydeon doubted herself but came in first place by a nice amount of points. Always believe in yourself :)

[@esfera2181]

She got it easy, being last, she just changed the answer at last moment when everyone already said the answer

[@centraix]

SYD: i doubt my faith to win this also SYD: first place

[@rorre1650]

Scarra: well, I spent my last 15 years mostly in League and WoW... Toast asks a WoW question. Scarra: *silence* Toast asks a League question. Scarra: *silence intensifies* Also Scarra: comes second The man is a legend

[@Logandents.]

dawg the visceral reaction i had to the skyrim audio clip. i have jus under 10k hours in skyrim, 8k on xbox 360, 1.2k on xbox one, and sadly only like 600-700 on pc with mods.

[@Poup_o7]

This was really good, hope toast does more

[@rogerramjet7729]

Lily wanting a hangout was so cute

[@MultiPeyton22]

I can’t believe the leveling screen for wii sports wasn’t enough

[@Mochi-lf5rz]

I got most off these and I haven't even played some of them, also 60% off these games I wouldn't consider to be "Gamer" games that's like saying "I play mobile clicker games I'm a gamer"

[@Squish_Squash]

This video proves I need to go outside more because some of these games (like Sims 4, Castlevania, Elden Ring) I guessed on the first clue and I never played them, some of which I've only seen in clips in random youtube videos I ironically didn't guess Skyrim, which I played quite a bit as a kid, or Minecraft, which I played YESTERDAY

[@jocosesonata]

*[SPOILER WARNING]* Aww, Sydeon thinking she was going to be dead last, and then ending up on first place is a great arc.

[@sendxnoodles]

spoiler

[@jocosesonata]

@@sendxnoodles Sorry about that. Added a spoiler warning now.

[@pea3080]

@@jocosesonata his fault not urs

[@PoiColle]

i literally dont actively watch any of you, but i enjoyed the crap out of this. definitely make another one!

[@pfarabee]

I can't help but wonder how much Terraria has been played by our beloved Lily, since every other game apparently looks like that one to her. 🤣

[@mott411]

Tbf I’m like 99% sure they used a picture of terraria clouds for the Minecraft one. (If not then those are def clouds from a texture pack and not vanilla minecraft)

[@sneakysam6564]

I am ashamed that I knew among us by the second clue without comms

[@ThatDweeb]

8:29 this has to be the most disapointing thing for a persona fan 😂 i saw the board and though persona 5

[@squixiee]

This was so fun to play along, this was really enjoyable tbh

[@1Type9]

Hello Toast!!!! Also by the rules only this games sounds so fun to play. 1:56 this explains so much tho OMG lily’s being bullied .

[@LawlietCTN]

Thanks for the concept dude :) i should have watched it with friends to count the points, and do this seriously. I freakin love the idea, even if the sound clues were really too short to give any clue. (may be except pong ^^') Anyway please do those kind of gameshow again. It was really fun to play with you.

[@Sehrav.]

Love how I either new it on the first hint or didn’t know it at all and I knew the majority of them

[@KentTouchThis86]

I have an idea to make this more fun for both the contestants and the audience. After all clues have been given, reveal everyone's answers, then reveal the right answer.. If a contestant wants to guess, let them message the host privately (their answer and on which # clue). Rest of the rules the same (contestant must declare they'd like to guess, 1 guess per person, same scoring structure) This would also allow the audience to play along with their friends and give the contestants a chance at some points, even if somebody guessed correctly on the first clue.

[@silverleaf15]

I hope you post your Among Us Geo guesser stream! That was so fun to watch!

[@symphonixblades]

Yeah i saw it on Sykkuno stream he should definitely post that one , it was a fun game

[@damiester1]

This is actually really fun since I got 70% of it wrong lol.

[@GeneLagrimasJr]

Rae using a tin food container as her whiteboard lmao

[@MrHermite]

Okay, that video was funnier than i expected, good job, i would watch another one.

[@sahxb.]

10:07 i was like ELDEN RING and ive never played that game in my life yet.