I NEED A NUDE COMPARISONS // Glam, My Dream + Star | Alicia Archer

[@sh8kit]

I like the Glam side better on the first look.

[@KB0101]

I have heard that the new Starlight mini contains shades from both the Star palette and Lila. I’m thinking that that might mean we will get a Starlight midi palette that would combine the vibe of Star and Lila. Can you imagine how smoky, gorgeous that would be?

[@aliciaarcher]

I do hope she has that planned for the holidays!

[@stateofhead5262]

Oh I thought Starlette was the mini I need a Nude, given the co-ordinated colour stories. ND mostly but not always does corresponding minis and midis… Edit: It seems she has trademarked a Rose&Wood palette on Justia! Good news!

[@angyeliz]

Ohhh yes!

[@mapleleaf1956]

Those star and dream looks were so great!

[@realpixiestix]

@@stateofhead5262That sounds gorgeous!

[@imanithomas7752]

I’m just waiting on a ND Camel midi palette. She can hurry up already

[@tammyeaton4791]

If the Safari and Gold palettes were offered in the midi size I’d be more interested in trying them.

[@aliciaarcher]

I hope she re-releases those in midi form. I’m waiting for a midi Lila 😮‍💨

[@deborahbather7808]

​@@aliciaarcherI'd love that! I sat on the Lila fence for so long that it disappeared 😮

[@khrystya_v_namysti]

​@@deborahbather7808Lila is in stock on ND official site, by the way

[@ruthm8931]

I think you are the only YT'er who thought, like me, the I Need A Nude reminded me of the original Star Palette! Star and Lila were my fav palettes.. Thx for your always thoughtful review.

[@Kimbyroseh]

This I Need A Nude gives me ABH Sulyry vibes. Not dupes, but definitely some similarities. Definitely similar shades/tones/color families to Glam and Star!

[@fibicakes5478]

There is no comparison for you Alicia. By far my favourite makeup person on youtube ❤️

[@sashaminium]

I love that INAN can pair well with so many of her other palettes. Thanks for this in-depth masterpiece, friend!

[@bach447]

I could listen to her talk through application shades and textures all day

[@LisaF_]

I’ve used the shimmers/metallics in INAN with Biba and My Dream so far. It’s a great palette to pair with others! Mario’s palette definitely was limited edition and I’ve have such FOMO missing out on it😩…but no longer!! 🤗 INAN definitely fills that place for me! Yay!!

[@aliciaarcher]

He should’ve kept that palette 😮‍💨 I think it was one of the best products he released, if not the number one product 😅

[@realpixiestix]

@@aliciaarcherI agree! I love the Mario palette so much but I find I don’t use it very much because I am worried I will hit pan and I can’t replace it.

[@martagarciagallego1640]

​@@realpixiestixEnjoy it! Make up isn't eternal. I used to do the same with my prefer lipstcks and some of them expired and smell really bad and I couldn't enjoy them....I wish I could have bought Mario's palette but that brand doesn't ship to Spsin😢... Greatings from Spain😊

[@LindseyBedro]

I think the Mario palette sold out not too shortly after you’re review on it and that’s why I’m so grateful I gave in after your review. It’s seriously the best! Just searching the two together makes me realize I don’t absolutely NEED the INAN palette.

[@aliciaarcher]

Really?? That’s crazy- it really does look the same. And im convinced after we used both in the live!

[@felicial7628]

Thanks for your honest reflections. I doubt that this palette would work for me because it looks to match my skin tone.

[@brigutierrez5249]

If ND pulled a PML and released a all shimmer, special shades mini pallet it would sell SO well.

[@lamsing6090]

It never ceases to amaze me how nuanced these eye shadow colours can be. Such fun to see your comparisons, Alicia. You said that the INAN is somewhat the same in the eye looks? Glam also seems samey as is bronze too. But they are all beautiful palettes nonetheless. I do not have glam so INAN really feels more up my alley. Havent seen it yet in the UK except at Selfridges...sold out already there! ❤❤❤

[@Tseana1]

I am so glad ND came out with this palette. I’ve been chasing after the Mario palette for months and it’s sold out everywhere. eBay wants a million dollars for it as well. I got mine and have already worn it. It is beautiful.

[@racharina]

I missed the first Etheral sale. By a struck of luck I found out this past Sunday it was back. I purchased it right away. I had bought the Nude ND a week prior thinking it would be the closest to Mario's. Well, I don't like the shimmers at all. Since I am still on time, I am returning and getting my money back. Etheral will be here tomorrow. I can't wait!

[@c.j.minster4292]

Such a great video. Thank you so much for making it! I mashed up most of my ND midis and put them in color order which… leaves me totally uninspired and focusing on PMG. There’s something about my hooded lids that ND shadows fade over time in a way that I don’t notice with PMG. Maybe I just need to use stickier primer….but I love the shinier shades in Yucca, so I caved and bought INAN. There’s also something fascinating about ND’s new “everyone gets 15% off on our website” promo that makes me wonder why anyone other than a YTer buys it at Sephora or Ulta.

[@Imelda47]

I experience the same problem with ND, marked creasing and fading after just a few hours regardless of the primers used. PMG or even ABH tend to last a lot longer on me, and so do the larger 28 pan palettes that ND released years ago. This is why I skip most of NDs new palettes, however, I am quite tempted to try this one.

[@nykka3]

A good eye primer has been helpful for me

[@RaelNikolaidis]

I am deciding between Glam and INAN palettes. Since I’m older with hooded eyes, I prefer metallics that give a smooth effect, rather than highlighting any crinkles. So, I think I’m buying the Glam palette after all.❤

[@baneshamiller1734]

Im going with the My Dream Palette. Makes more since for my medium deep skin tone.

[@nellyferguson8120]

I just got My dream and love it! (Im medium skin toned) INAN is pretty but I feel like itd be TOO light on me

[@ashleywillard3033]

Yeah, the Make up by Mario palette was LE and sold out super quick. I've been seeing them be resold on resell sites for over $200 used! I'm thankful that ND came out with an alternative that you can also add those Urban Decay single shadows that are also the wet looking formula.

[@kathleenkaffeine8696]

this was great and so so much appreciated! ND has some wonderful shades in so many palettes and I just love playing with our makeup and enjoying the nuances 🙂

[@aliciaarcher]

Yes! Hopping back into Star was a lot of fun 💫

[@jackandlill]

You are the literal Encyclopedia of the best eye shadows on the MaRkEt Ms. Alicia Archer!! The language spoken is one only those of us in the Passionate About Makeup tribe can truly hear! lol! You really are such a wealth of information Alicia & I truly appreciate all of the work you put into your channel! Thank you! I know this video is already a month old as I finally get the opportunity to watch - so you probably already have your answer as far as the pronunciation of Travertine - Trav - er - teen would be the phonetic spelling & correct pronunciation. I keep convincing myself I don't need this palette, especially due to some dupe like shades even within the palette - but it just looks so pretty! The only ND palette I own is the My Dream. So, I'm here to figure out if it makes sense to get it...And with your percentage off....I could um talk myself in to it....

[@Sbannmarie298]

What a great channel you have! And excellent video- love the depth and comparison you get into. AnnMarie in Calif.

[@amandapatterson1695]

I want Natasha to bring back all her 129$ (+Star) palettes as midi's with her updated formulas. Well, mainly gold, triochrome, circo loco, Loco, biba, & Lila.

[@xine1996]

Thank you so much for the comparison. I'm now sure that I need a nude is not 100 % my cup of tea. I would have loved the matte shades from glam withe the shimmers (wet effect shades) from I need a nude.

[@americaconstantine]

I missed out on the Makeup by Mario palette but I’m glad I got the Natasha I Need a Nude. I’ve used it every day since I got it ! ❤ And yes we need a midi Star!

[@katherinekelly9689]

Hi Alicia, I love all the eyeshadow looks from all of palettes, I now have” I need a nude palette “ it was out of stock in Australia it’s that popular, thank you for doing this video, it has given me lots of inspiration with creating looks with this palette. Love Katherine xoxo

[@harishnacatuncan9006]

I agree with you, My dream is better than I need a nude palette. I feel like u can get more looks from it. Big bang for your buck. People are just blown away including myself with her foils and metallic eye shadows on the INAN palette but like u said u can create a neutral look still with her other palettes. it just has a slight difference with the sparkle/ shine. I also love the contrast (peachy transition and a cool cool toned topper) u are talking about, good points. and i agree even more that the INAN feels monochromatic and i feel like the metallic/ foils will look just about the same on your eyes.

[@LadyJoolree]

Cool toned pinks, browns and taupes? Its Divine Rose I... smoking no joking!

[@ZurieRae]

I’ll hold for “ I need a nude 2” 🙌 speaking it into existence

[@greedypanda3606]

I’m low key obsessed with this palette, but really need to see it in person and swatch it myself. Agree that the looks can look the same, unless you consciously use the mattes or the coral ‘warm’ colours. There’s a lot of shine and shimmer in this palette, so I just need to step back and really assess how often I’m going to want my eyes to look like disco balls…

[@melissacallia4230]

Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyes is back! Oct 2023 💕

[@LydiaTarine12]

One alternative I've heard mentioned as a very edited down alternative to this is Wayne Goss's Pearle Palette.

[@Kimbyroseh]

I LOVE how you compared I need a nude to other palettes, one on each eye!

[@BooksNCamping]

Yes, I did get some FOMO when I originally saw this and thought I missed the boat on Ethereal Eyes. It came back, I believe this will be there last production of it, so I broke my no buy to snatch this up. I had to! 😅

[@SharonDJohnson515]

Really love the 18-pan Star palette 🤩 Great comparisons, as usual! 😘

[@thefoxyscentury]

Woot! Looking forward to settling in and watching this one. Your palette reviews are so good.

[@icekitty15]

Hi Alicia, Really good video. I love how you showed us a lot of the palettes we wanted to see. I missed out on the Makeup by Mario palette. And I was so upset. I was going to buy it on Mercari. But people want way to much money. It was already expensive to begin with. Thank Alicia.

[@angelicalovato9120]

I love the I need a nude palette. It encouraged me to finally purchase the glam too!

[@ra.j7210]

I'm so proud of my nd collection. I dont have all of them but the really popular ones like the retro glam, retro, gold, metropolis, safari, circo loco , trichrome and a few minis. They r my most used after my ct quads

[@naomikman]

Thankyou so much for this video!! I'm definitely going to give it a miss seeing these looks with palettes I already have! I love the balanced videos you come out with. I feel youtube is buy buy buy with this palette but I got a lot of value from this video. And now I shall dig out my star palette and get use out of it!! ❤ sending love from Australia 🇦🇺

[@indrasooknanan6618]

Thank you for doing this! Was on the fence as to which one to purchase!❤

[@coribolle6417]

I love the new Natasha palette and I'm happy I picked it up but so far all my looks have been extremely similar. Beautiful but similar.

[@emilyrobbins6214]

Thank you for doing this!! It’s nice to see comparisons on the eyes and not just swatches!

[@m.c.8680]

It would be Really Nice to see both eyes..Not just One. Very pretty, but hard to tell with one eye.

[@meepmoopmeep1]

The shade Amara from the retro palette is great to add in to the INAN palette. It has that warm rose tone that vague and wit have, but with more of the much needed depth

[@angyeliz]

I always forget to pull out my Star palette. It still is so pretty.

[@aliciaarcher]

It’s so lovely 😮‍💨 I would adore a midi size!

[@donnareed73]

She already had a I need a nude mini it was here before the midi so no special shades

[@kathlo22]

The wet effect formula is in the gold palette under a different name. Cava and sparks perhaps have a little less base pigment but are almost the exact same. I don’t buy palettes often but seeing that they were going to be the formula in the gold I ordered the iNAN the day it came out.

[@katrenashaw869]

Love these types of videos. I see the new palette as a companion palette to fill in gaps for other palettes. I’m hoping to get this some time soon.

[@tammyeaton4791]

I’m still debating whether or not I REALLY need the nude. I have Colourpop That’s Taupe abs Stone Cold Fox palettes. Although I think there’s still a place in my collection for the new Natasha palette, because of its unique new textures, and it has a mirror.

[@aliciaarcher]

You definitely have INAN in that palette, but I do feel the Natasha formula is shinier than colourpop because it has more pearl. I could be wrong!

[@susankleinman]

I will sort out the shadows I don’t like and add others from retro snd my dream which I have taken out and added to….I will get INAN but on a sale or points 🙋‍♀️❤️🇬🇧

[@sssunicorn412]

My I need a nude comes tomorrow so excited

[@janelle7778]

Good morning friend! Had to support the video early! ❤❤❤

[@aliciaarcher]

Thank you, Janelle! 🙆🏽‍♀️

[@michelledeboer8834]

All the looks you created are beautiful.

[@lulut.6284]

Yeah, but what about Viseart Cashmerie? After buying that, I feel like if I purchase any other neutral then I’m being redundant. Although, the Makeup By Mario is intriguing…

[@andreiabarbedo7009]

Great review and comparisons. helped me! Thanks.

[@michellerocco5073]

YeeeeSzzzz😂🎉❤😂🙏 thank you Alicia !!! U made my day sweetie!! Blessing xoxox Love these videos Sis Chef's Kiss 😘

[@Shellie1913]

Good morning! I didn’t get ethereal eyes and had FOMO so I got this one. I don’t think this is her best palette but it is nice.

[@aliciaarcher]

It’s interesting because many think this is her best, but I believe it’s more for the shine than the overall edit. Because I think the best by far this year is Yucca 🤷🏽‍♀️

[@PanteraBagiraLady]

I agree. I find that looks that you can do with INAN come out all way too similar.

[@cisstar8647]

It's her best palette for me. I think it still depends on self preference. What's best for me might not be for the next person! That's why I love makeup, it can be anything to anyone! 😊

[@trudipatel2198]

Hey Alicia I think I just fell in love with My Dream all over again, and will skip the INAN. Will probably use a touch of Pat McGrath's Astral Solstice or Astral Rose orchid for the added pop. This was very helpful, thanks for the inspo

[@loricanella2549]

I just love you!!! Are you a New Yorker? I just found you yesterday and am so glad I did!!!

[@minastar8602]

💜💜💜✨I Love the My dream Palette I just rearranged it and that was fun. One week I replaced some shimmers with the retro shimmers and that was fun. But I do wish I could get a 5 pan that the midi eyeshadows fit into because I love all the colors on my dream but sometimes I just want to add some other shimmers. I think next I’ll move some glam shadows or get a small magnetic empty to put some shades in for travel . 🤷🏻‍♀️ I think play with it some more until the holidays to see if there’s any other releases.

[@NuschBos99]

Love it. Waiting on my INUN palette. You are always so inspirational ❤

[@aliciaarcher]

Thank you! Hope it arrives soon!

[@canelami1285]

Love your detailed comparsions!!!. I already have Glam and Retro midi so will pass on this one

[@juliadeangelis]

You are fantastic! I don't think I will buy the new palette, because I have "My dream", "The Glam", "The Star" and "The retro palette" (that have other similar colour too...) well... it's enought

[@eringray8026]

I’ve been using the ethereal palette to see if I want the nd one too. This is fantastic!

[@katherineparis8208]

This makes me want the “My Dream” palette, but I just keep reminding myself how I never use my only Natasha Denona palette; “Biba”. On my fair skin, so many of the shades in Biba look the same and the wear time is lacking on my hooded lids. What are the pan sizes in the ND midi palettes like in comparison to the Viseart Slim Pro? If I could swap shadows between two I would probably buy “My Dream”

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

Thank you. This was a very nice way of playing with palettes.

[@sapphoboiliel5887]

😍😍awesome! I wonder how the new glassy sparkly shadows compare to colourpop’s super shock shadows?😘😘🥰🥰

[@eimearinez]

I’m passing on this one as I got the glam n I’ve only used it twice maybe (it ages me I think it’s cause I’m neutral toned) while I think the My Dream would be worth collecting on Black Friday! The Mario palette wasn’t available outside of US either to my knowledge n was limited edition

[@vee7704]

So glad you made this video. Thank you 😊

[@lemperez]

If you had to choose between Natasha Denona eyeshadows vs Viseart, which would you choose?

[@Dawnetcetera]

Happy Wednesday Alicia. I appreciate you doing this video on the comparisons of this I Need A New Palette with the Glam Palette and some of the other palettes out there. There was a palette no one has really mentioned that made me stop and go through my collection. From 4 years ago January 2019, HUDA BEAUTY NEW NUDES.00 Hooters eye palettes have come such a long way and she continues to be right in the conversation with the top eyeshadow palette produces in the makeup world. YOU TAKE OUT THE TWO GLITTERS WHICH WE'VE ALL LEARNED THEY'RE NOT being used anymore. THAT PALETTE IS VERY SIMILAR TO THE NEW I NEED A NUDE PALETTE. BUT THE QUALITY OF THE HUDA NEW NUDES MATTES WERE DRiER.THOSE MATTES DONT COMPARE with THE NEW NATASHA DENONA PALETTE NEW FORMULAS🎉😢 AND WHAT SHE HAS TO OFFER NOW . I DON'T KNOW I MEAN I THINK I WANT TO GET THE MY DREAM PALETTE BY NATASHA DENONA I NEED A NUDE PALETTE . THAT'S WHAT I'D WANT . THANKS AGAIN FOR THIS COMPARISON 🙏🎇🩶🤎🩷🎇. TAKE CARE.

[@maryeckel9682]

Were you using voice to text? Hooters omg I'm dying here

[@racharina]

I bought the Nude ND cuz I had missed the sale of Etheral a year ago. I figured it would be the closest palette to Mario's. Welp, now that I have it, I do not like the shimmers AT ALL. Then this past Sunday I found out Etheral came back. I didn't think it twice and I grabbed it. It was sold out not too long after I bought it. Since I have only had ND for two weeks, I returned. Mario's is so much better palette. .

[@idaliahernandez1824]

Thanks for a great video! I’m still unsure if I should get INAN. I have the Glam palette but I don’t use it as much because it goes too dark and smokey so I’m wondering if this palette would be a better option for me. 🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️Also, I do hope ND comes out with a midi Star palette!! I would love to see INAN used in conjunction with the retro palette if you want to further play with this palette 😊

[@esthertschwartz]

I don't have Glam, My Dream or Star. Generally I find her palettes go medium to dark shades without very light shades I want. Will this be it? Holding off the hype frenzy. I wish someone would dare to compare to ABH Sultry. My wish for ND is to do a midi version of her original mega palette with the blue green theme 💚💙

[@Kimbyroseh]

I like the new, I Need a Nude palette, but I definitely prefer the My Dream palette. And I’m so surprised how the I Need a Nude palette is so different from the mini nude. The minis that seem closer to the I Need A Nude midi palette maybe would be, Mini Zendo, Mini Biba, maybe mini Retro or mini glam? Oh and the new Mini Starlette.

[@millicentspears]

I legit want the MBM Ethereal palette

[@aliciaarcher]

He should’ve made it permanent 😮‍💨

[@mariagiselle5069]

This has been a long search and I hope the new ND palette is a find. I am still hoping the new ND I Need a Nude is similar to the Makeup by Mario Ethereal Eyes with a good mix of slightly warm and slightly mauvey cool matte shades for my neutral to cool skin tone. The Ethereal eyes, is not only sold out, but it has been sorely overpriced by gauging sellers in Mercari at $500 a pop. On another note, I just realized another potential dupe, Glaminatrix Nearly Neutrals palette, at least the shimmers, are ALL warm. Half of the ND Retro leans very purply and most so called ND neutral shades lean warm as well.

[@larissap.moreno3333]

You are the best!❤

[@LydiaTarine12]

I've been telling myself that I don't need the I Need a Nude palette because I already own the Glam palette and Mini Starlette palette, especially since I can pull in my Urban Decay Space Cowboy to add sparkle and shine where wanting. ... It's still tempting, though, because my taste and skin tone ( _very_ fair) will probably pull the most variety out of this palette.

[@cheila13cya]

Are the shades tones similar to CT pillow talk and/or exagger eyes….I’m sure the texture and shimmers don’t compare but I just get pillow talk vibes from this palette

[@bodey2693]

Yes, yes and yes!!! 😁

[@geniej2378]

Appreciate all the comparisons!

[@TaraK172]

A Nude & Bronze mash up would be fun to see if you need content ideas.

[@sanamansurinagariya572]

I have been wanting dream for a long time but was unavailable in UAE . Since INAN came out I have been so confused between the two. The comparison helped so much . And also I am medium with warm undertone so I think my dream makes more sense. Your thoughts ?

[@wombatlittle1]

I haven't picked this up yet. To me it's rather meh on the whole and I don't like the really shiny shades at all. What I'm interested in are the mattes.

[@aliciaarcher]

Do you have Biba? I think that is far more diverse with the shades, and has a lot more mattes.

[@wombatlittle1]

Yes I do I need to play with it more.

[@vivianlaw7236]

Thank you for the video. I have the Star palette already and have been wondering if it covers INAN color story

[@MsSavvy9]

I caved. I ordered it. BUT BUT BUT I... wanted it.

[@aliciaarcher]

OOOOOOOOO and I ordered the Chanel mauve rose blush 🤪

[@MsSavvy9]

@aliciaarcher we are all going down together 🤷🏽‍♀️ Oh! I would also love an updated nail 💅🏼 video (now that I have nails). Routines (demo), products, who do follow/watch... that kind of thing. Your nails are my ideal. I had "salon short" coffin shaped acrylics for a while and couldn't thread my machine or open anything. I think I'm at the "just long enough for good pet scratching" length phase of life.

[@foxxyfavs]

Thank you for this video!! I'm also thinking of the Huda Beauty - New Nude Palette 🤔 All around the same price, BUT i need to pick 1! 😅🙃

[@aliciaarcher]

I feel like the New Nude is more like Natasha’s My Dream.

[@rabbiroz3806]

Probably tons of people have let you know, but I don’t think the Mario Ethereal Eyes is coming back. I could be wrong, but that is what I thought I had seen and heard. Overall, I’m not thrilled with the performance of the shadows in INAN - not a lot of pigment, hard to pick up, hard panning . . . IMHO, not ND’s best.

[@marlenmejia6249]

If you have to choose between ND I need a nude and the palette from makeup by Mario which would you pick? I really would love to add one of them but not sure which one :) btw I already have ND the Glam :)

[@Cloudytrees]

Omg...this is what I need today!!!!

[@aliciaarcher]

Hopefully this helps! Thank you for being a close frennnn!!!

[@catharinecowan4514]

I agree the INN palette looks were all very similar on you - swatched and worn on my pale/fair skin, a number of shades were suuuuuper similar on me too, but I’m not mad bc I will wear them all! The thing is, I use only light shades on the daily - no smokey eyes for me (and tender is dark enough to be smokey on me). I LOVE that ella, travertine, delilah actually are lighter on the eye than in the pan bc I can wear them as daytime work shades!! I think this palette is the perfect fair skin work appropriate but SPARKLY FUN palette, and I do think it looked lovely on darker skin too but it seems much more limited for looks on darker skin….but if you love those shades/looks, then you’ll still use them up! I didn’t buy the Glam palette because I knew 75% of the shades would be too dark for me to wear to work.

[@johannahoneyman697]

Great video Alicia ❤

[@angyeliz]

I ended up buying this and really didn’t need it. It really is so pretty

[@aliciaarcher]

It is lovely, yes!

[@bodey2693]

Still on the fence about this one, I might get it on sale

[@aliciaarcher]

Or maybe we can wait until a mini, since I do love those wet effect shades 😮‍💨

[@jinnykim8740]

Thanks for the review!

[@aliciaarcher]

Thank you for watching!

[@kouzelnice]

Thank you for the great comparisons! ❤I just ordered this, hoping this is the perfect work to night palette. Most of the other ND palettes pull way too deep or warm on me, and I have enough PMG palettes for the glam looks...I am looking forward to having a choice of lighter work appropriate shades, even if the looks are all a bit similar on most of the creators I have watched...😊

[@ReemaBenvanshi]

Nice

[@godzandheros]

If she did a Star midi, I think she would keep the same foam packaging like she did for Metropolis because I don't think it would translate well into the plastic because of it's layout ngl ETA I feel the sparkling foiled (that's the new wet gloss formula right?) is very much on par with sparks and cava and even lime chrome and aurora (maybe?) from gold, and I know the newer formulated galaxia was supposed to be like them but it's really not the same imo (I have three different versions from star, mini retro, and starlette) and I can't think of any of her other palettes that contained shades that felt and performed the same as sparks and cava specifically before Yucca and now I Need a Nude. one more thing, cosmo is closer to gigabyte than spectrum lol _especially_ the og cosmo before she reformulated star