I Ranked EVERY SEASON in a Tierlist…

I loved season 5, why does no one talk about it... season 12 too
Intro (0:00)
F Tier: (0:13)
D Tier: (0:37)
C Tier: (1:50)
B Tier: (4:04)
A Tier: (5:48)
S Tier: (6:49)
Outro: (7:29)
Membership: / @carnagegameyt
Twitter: / carnagegameyt
Discord: dsc.gg/carnagegame
Instagram: / carnagegameyt
#brawlstars #carnagegame

[@adiamon3349]

Maybe you weren’t too invested in it, but I feel like Season 3 (Colette’s season) deserves a lot more recognition. This season introduced Starr Park and started the unforgettable chain of lore that would come later. Colette might have been weak, but Starr park more than made Season 3 an A-Tier season (maybe S-tier)

[@Sh4yd]

I invested in the future during season 3

[@giorgosprokos6761]

@@Sh4yd bro💀

[@stalk9580]

@@Sh4yd LMAOO

[@valtex9038]

Fr season 3 is sooooo underrated, even more than season 5, i remember i was watching the brawl talk at 5 am and it was scary af bro(especially the bear part), starr park is the pinacle of the brawl stars lore

[@Sh4yd]

Why does my username look like a random 9 year olds first account username on roblox I didn't have those numbers there

[@mystic5686]

Dude idk how can pulls this off but he somehow makes more energetic and fun videos with only text and music than people litrelly speaking and shouting. Like how 🤔. Btw we need bot runner series back asap

[@uradumbassmp3]

lie

[@hackermango]

You have a nice point! I also feel the same ... CG is another ERA of BS

[@CarnageGameYT]

@@uradumbassmp3 real 😎

[@TR39.2.3]

@@CarnageGameYT facts

[@DeathwatchBrawlStars]

@@CarnageGameYT subtitles looks ass

[@pfofe]

Season 10 is my favorite. I came back to the game at the end of S9, but in season 10 I started to play more, and bought Fang's pass. I also loved playing duels so much

[@SuperJman1111]

I had enough for Fang’s pass and boy was it the best choice I ever made to buy it. I passed the challenge to get the Tiger pin with randoms only and using Fang only

[@pfofe]

@sleepykid I always thought he was cool and I wanted to unlock him. But they changed his mechanics too much in my opinion

[@Ichigo-gp9vq]

We also got roundhouse kick, it was the best gadget, so people who bought fang pass were having extra fun

[@Ichigo-gp9vq]

@@sleepykid5451 I didn't remember that mb

[@tomic7493]

Season 10 menu music was 🔥

[@Jodio-Joestar]

I hope they don't mess up the next Christmas season. I personally enjoy these the most and they really give me some jolly vibes.

[@Oceanatic23]

True, same here

[@SuperJman1111]

I’m still confused why they went for a spooky season for the November/December season

[@Jodio-Joestar]

@@SuperJman1111 Halloween

[@muhabplays]

Looking forward to omega boxes and omega box darryl which i probably won't use lol

[@belith451]

well....about that...the current season is the winter season aka the halloween season, its still a good season

[@Fungary_WeRN]

Season 13 was a very mid season, I agree, but I liked it pretty much. Mostly it's the menu music, my drippy boi Otis and Bad Randoms event. But yes. Season 7 was gigachad. I still have a poster of Buzz dancing in front of destroyed stuff (Season 7 animation)

[@valtex9038]

otis is the worst brawler ever implemented to the game aside to eve

[@Probe53]

Who tf even cared about otis the challenges and the bad randoms event was the shit

[@Fungary_WeRN]

they are both annoying af but somehow adorable at the same time

[@Ruben99677]

@@valtex9038 otis its so good in this moment

[@Ruben99677]

@@valtex9038 and eve was good at start but noa its not that good

[@austinfofana8468]

I feel like every brawl pass keeps making unbalanced brawlers and gives a free rank 30

[@thelazyy1]

lol fr

[@nerds_lair5543]

What about when otis first release

[@rajusingh.mljtooeu2939]

New update i think we will get Edgar rework and the new brawler will be forgotten like when Edgar and Byron relese and people only made videos on Edgar

[@austinfofana8468]

@@nerds_lair5543 I took a break from the game during his season

[@SuperJman1111]

@@rajusingh.mljtooeu2939 Byron was in the background, watching as some annoying, angry teenager got more content than him

[@epicc_3671]

3:27 man forgot the best part about that season. Eve's CRAZY OP starpower, man i mean imagine, small hatchling each time you hit the big egg, that star power was 💀

[@skinsarentskill259]

that would be why i disagree with his opinion there. the meta was absolute crap, some people left, because of Fang-Eve-Spike. Especially Eve, with that sp.

[@epicc_3671]

@@skinsarentskill259 good point, that op sp was only enjoyable to those who got it, and the fact that eve got nerfed a lot of times and she was still good, same with fang

[@andrenuijen8093]

I think season 4 was the most nostalgic one bht not the best, it was the time where all my friends joined back and actually liked the game, gears werend there and it was all relaxing and simple, map maker at the time still gave trophies, so i got my r25s in that season. The good old days

[@raphaeldeppe7434]

Gears were there 😅

[@piratefromwish]

@@raphaeldeppe7434 nope

[@iesn698]

@@raphaeldeppe7434 yeah bro season 4 gears were introduced

[@bornbadbuzz251]

I’m really nostalgic for season 8 for some reason, but it just felt like the perfect season for showdown players. (no gears) also the music was really nice to listen to :)

[@ArbnZ03]

Same. The music is just so nostalgic for some reason

[@justinthyme5263]

Season 8 was actually one of my favorites since the meta was so good. Seasons 6 and 7 I also really liked due to their metas

[@Corescos]

Season 7 holds a special place in my brawl stars heart for being the first brawl pass I got after returning from a 2-year leave of absence from the game. Buzz was awesome on release and it was just so much fun

[@johnoukozzz6230]

Basketbrawl, Volleybrawl, Trophy thieves and hold the trophy were also introduced in season 7. Season 7 easily the best one 🔥🔥

[@lorrygaming1039]

And season 13 WORST OF ALL

[@vegetalno]

@@lorrygaming1039 say that to Pharaotis, most based skin in the game

[@GhostHunterDipperPines]

Yea. Sure Trophy thieves was a reskin and hold the trophy sucked, but vollybrawl was fun and basketball was very fun

[@Groskowy]

5 and 7 agreed 👍

[@josesilva-vp9ey]

I didn't play it so, this is a season

[@TorayNix]

I personally loved the season 13 because of the theme, the music (no seriously, the menu music, we HAVE to admit that this was a banger), Otis (despite being really bad at his release I loved his design) and Penny’s remodel AND rework Sorry for bad english

[@matejanakov9195]

nah compared to season 2 and 7 it was pretty bad

[@TorayNix]

@@matejanakov9195 can I say my opinion please?

[@RealH4RT]

@@TorayNix 💀Can he say his opinion?

[@trbg.]

yea bro I love hunters a lot i got my surge r35 and stu r30 there

[@trbg.]

and the menu theme+music is drippy 🥶

[@The.Sketchy]

I think season 3 has deserved S or A tier since Starr Park was first presented and it was one of the most hyped seasons ever

[@jaycaser2890]

I first started play when Season 5 was going to end so i kinda liled it but man..season 6 litterlly first season and interaction with the community and the devs and everything was..amazing! And i think i got spike (aka first legendary) there too! That season, the buzz one, Janet one and Fang season where my seasons! (The Eve on tho can go straight to the F tier, i hate Eve with passion lmaoo) and another banger video of CG! Nice

[@suprixgamer69]

So we can think that better brawlers means higher tier on the list. Btw: guy "mystic" wrote to record more episodes of Bot Runner. Please record more Bot Runner with subscribers🥺

[@royaleagle-brawlstars6113]

Great concept! This was a really unique ranking video and i loved it. Great arguements and i (kinda) agreed in a lot🙂

[@luxy5863]

Season 1 is so nostalgic to me since i started playing brawl stars there, the menu music theme just brings me back so many memories

[@NoUserU]

I remember quitting at the end of Season 7, I came back at the end of Season 13 and it feels good to be back. In my opinion the most memorable one was Season 3 or 7, but this tier list is definetely based and 100% true.

[@omerarfan]

Season 2 actually also only had a few skins, a new brawler, and the only big thing was second gadgets and the new PvE mode, which got removed later on

[@skinnymemegod856]

When you realise stu was released in season 5:it's hard being old

[@Nickk898]

Yeah I agree with everything except one thing...the season of fang. I really love that season and I immaginate it on e the tier b or a, but is ok. And i love that you put the season of Buzz first BC it was my first Brawl pass and in that pass I found like 4 new Brawler...Griff,amber,Spike and obviously Buzz. I've loved this season!

[@godnoobbrawlstars6409]

Ah yes, We love season 6 knockout, winning cause you dealt 1 damage more than the enemy team :)

[@Droboticlol]

I recall starting brawl starts basiaclly around buzz's season (just at the end of belles) and I will say it was a great season, my only complaint are that the recent seasons teir 70 skins... like... janet, otis, buster, and sam, they arent exactly my favorites... but buzz has to be my favorite teir 70 skin

[@pigpig5600]

My bottom tree are 11 ,7 and 13 in this order. Reasons: Season 7: At the middle of the season out of nowhere I started feeling burned out but I didn't wanted to stop playing the game so I forced myself to do it. I had this feeling for one whole year. And now I associate this feeling with this season. Season 11: Due to the after mentioned feeling, my pure hatred towards the skins and the environment(The biodome could have been such a nice, green and relaxing place but they had to ruin it with the purple mutating liquid). I almost stopped playing. I hated every thing about this season. Season 13: It was actually fine, but I finally lost it and took a break.

[@bobthen00b2]

2:57 alright guys, it's time to bring our pinch forks

[@ProPPlayer]

2:00 *brought, not bought

[@thelazyy1]

🤓

[@ProPPlayer]

@@thelazyy1 get real first

[@ProPPlayer]

heavy agree, would move season 5 a bit down tho. i really stopped playing brawl stars all day after season 8, because it was getting stale and boring

[@Swordkid669]

This is a good tier list . From this amazing creator 🔥

[@mr.noobplayz259]

Season 2 was my favourite

[@ashazmohammad212]

I agree with you abt season 7 Let's not forget the new gadgets, new tiles in map maker, and the 4 new game modes! Love your content! Hope to see better vids!

[@ahmed4363]

While i didn't get stu until after his breakthrough gadget nerf. He is a very fun brawler to play, it is also the season where Navigator Colette was introduced, which is one of my favorite skins. But Season 3 should be in B or A tier, although Colette is like the weakest chromatic brawler on release (I still remember the emergency buffs lmao) it's the first season i bought (was around before brawl pass was a thing) and it not only introduced the best feature in the game (map maker to some and disabling bots in bot matches to others) but it was also the most hyped because of Starr Park.

[@arhamawan2269]

LETS GO!!! Another Buzz fan! I LOVE YOU BRO, all my friends said buzz isnt that good, he gets countered by edgar the worst brawler and stuff like that, but I love buzz. And I agree this was the best season, also my first season (technically) i started when season 6 had like half a month left. And this was the first brawl pass I ever bought! Keep up the good work man! 👍

[@doom2263]

Thank you for recognizing Season 5!!! Has got to be one of, if not my favorite season!

[@chrisbsgr.383]

I like Stu

[@theboss95s70]

For me S tier season is season 2, it's absolutely goated. That's the only change I'd do. Epic vid as always, keep it up Carnage!!

[@bonucci74]

For me S or A tier seasons are belle and ash seasons, i loved the theme on both of them and it was very fun to play with them.

[@ezwinlovesgoats]

Honestly if Otis' season had a animation where Otis and Colt have a rap battle and fang sits there and watch would be cool.

[@JoeMama-pk3ew]

Season 7 was when I started to play and it felt so special and I always thought season 7 was by far the best and most fun

[@kravt_tv8937]

For me season 15 is a solid "A" or "S" tear. Buster is a very fun brawler to play, skins are good too, gears got reworked, halloween themed, world finals 2022. Now this is how you do a halloween season. My favorite seasons are 7,12 and 15.

[@ozyisgoated]

Hey CG, I got a question. What’s the intro music called? I always hear it in your videos but it’s never linked anywhere despite being such a banger. Love the vids btw!

[@jo4sh0w76]

I would like to see a pre-brawl pass update tier list. Retropolis update is S tier for sure

[@brunolike8631]

Season 10 should be higher just becouse of Supercell's comunity posts, they were all video game based and made the comunity think "what would happen if brawl stars recieved a spin-off?" and that was great! (Plus, duels should be permanent becouse of how good it is, best gamemode imo)

[@_White_Hole_]

I was playing this game with interruptions because of a bad phone but i got new one in season 4 and i agree with you for season 5 it was soooo memorable, theme, brawlers, EVERYTHING! Now im nit pretty active but i will never forget that season!!!

[@atharvkulkarni7558]

We need him to rate the menu themes ASAP

[@spuuki5756]

You forgot to say in season 7 that a big map maker update was coming (modifier and 5 new objects). That was the favourite part of Season 7 for me

[@bsheepdestroyermakesstuff7222]

Meh, after that update every community map was extra garbage for the next like year, its died down a bit I guess by now

[@irisclawthorn2458]

You could do a video ranking the Best events? (Like Golden week, Retropolis, ETC)

[@duonghoangminh258]

CG: Ranks season based on how much content there was Me: Ranks every season based on how much I like the battle music it offers

[@thenoobs8566]

I think Gift Shop seasonshould be in A tier cause it brought 8 bit mini game a whole deeper meaning and introduced Starr park lore,belle season is placed correctly but hoped you mentioned how paula came and the other guy left,shoot I forgot his name...

[@DIRECTOR_DRAKUL--PCIA]

Ryan

[@AkiDasherr]

Ryan

[@Crisdecris22]

I agree a lot with this, although i would have moved season 2 into s tier beacuse i had the most fun in it by having gale that great was fun since i was a gale main but not everyone is so i understand it Edit:you forgot about the fact that amber was introduced in season 3 and DAMN she was OP, also the second season made us available to get our rewards how we wanted which at the time it was a beauty

[@wayzlikelays]

I honestly think season 3 deserved A-tier because it gave us a lot of information ab the lore of starr park

[@BoomGuys.]

u are EVERYWHERE why do i keep finding u in ethan brawl stars

[@wayzlikelays]

@@BoomGuys. dude im not everywhere, those are just my fav brawl stars youtubers

[@user-qf4jl7cd1g]

I personally love season 2 because it gives so much memories, surge 2 gadget, animations, rampage mode, cool skins, environment, music.

[@chrisbsgr.383]

me too

[@mr.orangegaming1570]

Same, best memories of childhood made during this time, and overall the absolute best W season

[@searmoshawott1731]

it was really good, except for the rampage. in my opinion that sucked

[@cutypie3405]

Season 7 is also my favorite. I bought my first Brawl Pass, and Buzz and Griff are still some of my favorite brawlers. Also, I am a big fan of the bad Randoms, even made in-game videoclips of their songs

[@alberto-279]

the first few season were good cause they were the first fresh ideas if you look at season 10 and forward suppercell are losing ideas so the brawlo pass is worse

[@AdrianBS26]

true since fang season supercell is running out of ideas but they don't want to listen to the community

[@surhytex8280]

the best is when there was no season

[@surhytex8280]

wow im first viewer

[@mectty7102]

@@surhytex8280 fortnite battle pass

[@TernaryCosine76]

I started playing in Ruffs season so im biased but that was so peefect, for the nest few seasons i hated the themes abd tracks in comparrison, really nostalgic, deserves s

[@thelazyy1]

My favourite season was season 5. That music, the broken brawler AND my favourite brawler came out soon after. Stu

[@mk_timegaming5046]

Hii Season 7 was really really my personal favourite and the best season coz like it had everything a season should have.. Or should I say a summer season Just perfect..

[@sanssensei1913]

Season 3 was S tier for me, The brawler was great ( except upon release ) she is one of my favourites till this day, The skins were crazy good and most importantly, this season brought the Starr Park lore with it 👌 CANT FORGET MAP MAKER BRUH

[@Lambodepro]

I love season 5 for two things: one because the music is insane, and second I got like 10 brawlers in that free pass somehow (they were only epics,mythic and legendary and chromatic)

[@real_CalaveraS]

Season 5 was the season that started me off. After that I knew brawl stars was a game for me and also that menu music is 🔥

[@adriano6013]

Season 5 is my favourite, I listened to music all the time until I wanted to play play and only play, my favorite season, I would even put it on S with season 7. 😉

[@Torpando]

Not to mention in season 7 they also added most of the tiles we have today in mapmaker

[@Jeffinently]

Season 8 was great if you look more at it, we got brawloween modifiers that season which was fun

[@MonkeyGotRickrolled]

I would say season 5, 6 and 7 were my favorites because they felt more unique, and I started playing at season 5 and I had so much fun. Brawl Stars still was fun in early season 8. It kind of went downhill after some weeks after season 8, 9, and 10. I didn't have much fun in season 11, but I was still excited to play during that time. I barely played in season 12. And then I quit Brawl Stars at season 13, 14, and 15. I might come back but the chances are low. I just don't have fun playing anymore and I left the community that's why I haven't posted a Brawl Stars video in so long and had one of my last ones the endgame of my Brawl Stars videos in the, "5 types of Brawl Stars KZbinrs" that barely got any views, but was my longest videos ever. I might be switching to another game I like playing right now that my cousin, Liam showed me (Basically the 2nd person with the most screentime in my videos). And I'm doing some meme videos that 1 blew up and got 50k views. Well, I'm done typing and my fingers are burning and if you can, show me new stuff in Brawl Stars that can make me come back.

[@RemyMS]

I agree with the a and s tier you made!

[@princetemoana1322]

:c season 5 song brang back so many memories. ahhh damn that makes me so sad... Looking back onto the seasons especially 5... Like im not kidding. the song almost put me in tiers and makes me wish I payed more attention to season 5

[@Shafz_247]

Honestly, I think just giving season 1 a little pity tier bonus would've been nice, because like you said, it was the pass which all other brawl passes developed off

[@rajusingh.mljtooeu2939]

My favourite music and theme belongs to season 8.BTW carnage if you make a season music tier list where will you put the season 8 music in

[@Ameisenigelytk]

Season 1 OST gives me nostalgia asf

[@mr.orangegaming1570]

Wow. Bought a tear to my eye. I remember the days of the old seasons, where I would hop on and play with my friends after school. So fun we would facetime together. Those were the days. Sadly one died in a car crash and one to lung cancer. RIP josh and shaylin. You will always be in my heart ❤️❤️

[@GabGooDGG]

Funny enough, this is the most accurate Tier List I ever saw on Brawl Stars history And i Also think Season 5 and 4 had great Menu Themes

[@-THANHAN]

Nice idea

[@Xander_X]

Can't wait for the rating on the current season

[@ArbnZ03]

Season 7 was the goat. I started playing towards the end of Season 6, so I have so much nostalgia of the game when I think back to Buzz season. I also enjoyed Season 8 and 10, 9 was pretty good as well. And season 13 is very underrated.

[@soproprioio622]

I stopped playing brawl actively at the start of season 3, played a bit of season 4, then I played like a little bit of some of the seasons like 7, 10, and 12. I miss the old days, the March 2020 update was goated 😣

[@Squidy-and-speed]

I agree with every single season on its placement and all the memories all of the seasons have had makes me sad because they were all so good 😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@MrFishio]

My favourite seasons are season 7 and 8 just because my club was super active during them and it was just amazing everyone was talking and playing together Also I got griff 5 mins after release from a random big box so I’ll always be thankful for the insane luck I had then

[@TheBingolinbear]

My favorite seasons are Ghost station, Once upon a brawl, Deep sea brawl, gold arm gang and holidah get away! Lou was my 1st chromatic brawler.

[@piotrm5635]

4:25 map maker was intruducent not in the start of season but wich amber update

[@rileybrown9517]

I think season 8 doesn’t have enough credit it was a summer season but they still released 2 incredibly fun brawlers, amazing skins and I personally loved the music overall I think this is an A tier heck maybe even S

[@a_very_random_person1]

I can agree with you on season 7 , it was really good

[@BOT_T]

Hey man love the videos, started making brawl stars videos as well

[@taiscommentingaccountusedf1908]

Season 3 should have been A tier if you ask me The climax of the starr park lore with the investor video was absolutely amazing

[@WAFFLE747]

See like the D tier seasons are some of my fav seasons just because of their themes, I think this video was talking about the content in each season but just for the theme I like season 1, 8, 10 and this one rn

[@hotcocoa2277]

The thumbnail is so GOOD

[@nj_53451]

I hope they will release a kick ass mid season for the brawlidays

[@pedrofsgomes8775]

My personal Tier List before seeing the video: S tier: Summer of Monsters (2), Holiday Getaway (4), Jurassic Splash (7), The Stuntshow (12). A tier: Welcome to Starr Park (3), Once upon a Brawl (8), The Ghost Train (15). B tier: Tara's Bazaar (1), The Goldarm gang (6), Year of the Tiger (10). C tier: The Starr Force (5), The Biodome (11), The Robot Factory (14). F tier: Brawlywood (9), Deepsea Brawl (13).

[@grape7763]

Remember, s13 also had the penny remodel, mystery mode, and hunters.

[@Mlhcnshn_fan]

Im glad that season i bought is s tier Also i got c and a which is pretty good

[@aristidhevangjeli9127]

Season 5 is the best season in my opinion, not just of the huge changes and that stuff, the best part was when they released the 8 bit minigame! Where you tapped at his screen ten times it sent you to the minigame! Sadly it's gone now :(

[@rohamebrahimi7844]

My favourite season has got to be season 3 colette was really high skill and the skin was a chef kiss that was also when starr park was shown and it was the peak of brawl stars boosting a lot of youtubers and a lot of players masked spike was such a unique skin for 29 gems and i think they gave us 5 gems if i recall correctly so yeah definitely my favourite season

[@Javier_Z_NYAN]

La temporada 13 yo la pondría en el tier D o C ya que el remodel de Penne estuvo genial y fue muy bien recibida.Tambien incluyeron muchos desafíos

[@dummyhead7484]

When first time in season 13 and listen to the main menu music. My brain was thinking. Kept play it casually and had fun because it's summer.

[@OOFPlaysYT]

Season 2 was a great season but s5 brings back a lot of memories for me because I heard the music too much xd

[@jenlevangie9897]

2:55 That tick bot should've played in world finals

[@Blubullsbrawl]

We need an updated version of this soon😊

[@stickland5682]

I agree, my favorite pass was the non existing one tho :/

[@frederick3899]

Season 9 deserves a spot in the F tier since that's when lvl11 with gears came along

[@BoomGuys.]

sesn 5 and 4 were my favourite, 5 gave me that viiiibbeee, and 4 had lou, my main who i LOVE

[@That-Romanian-Comrade]

Belle one was a good memory being my first brawl pass ever and it added squeak(my favorite brawler) and belle became the brawler i main😂(i play since 2018 but i had no gems from 2020 to 2021 when seasons 1,2,3,4,5 released) Still season 5 best one

[@RogueSimon]

I play since 2018 The best seasons by FAR! BY FAR are 4 and 5...the periods i loved that game the most and wanted to have fun in map maker getting trophies too