I Solved The Whitepine Mystery

[@ultg7]

didnt expect my theory to get anywhere lmao

[@dumb_m1k0o.35]

Yoooo

[@plantlover3741]

Respectfully disagree, because of two things. 1 Why doesn't Clown Have any blood on him? 2 the staff in the background right before the body was discovered seem to be making lunch, (we can see light outside the windows, and the shadows we can see aren't very long so its not sunset) Let me elaborate. Based on the fact that Mysti was in uniform and we see Pyro in normal clothes when the body's discovered, we can guess that she was able to attend to him that day. Assuming that Pyro woke up as early as possible, around 10:00 according to Seraptor, and that the Hemlocks eat lunch around 1:00 (Clown says the staff eat lunch around 2:00 but the Hemlocks probably eat first). Since they're preparing lunch, this would have to happen a little after 12:00 giving the murderer a little over 2 hours to pull this off. Plus according to the newspaper clipping in the trailer, Mysti was stabbed so brutally that parts of her body were "severed" and in multiple places. Stabbing someone that viciously takes a lot of time. Given how brutal the murder is, there'd be a lot of blood for Clown to wash off. But he's head of staff, he'll just head down to the laundry room and wash it all off! Problem, Clown is the head staff member, so odds are someone would notice him if he was missing. Even if he could dodge his co-workers, washing blood out takes even more time that our murderer does not have. Personally, I have my own thoughts on what killed Mysti, but its a bit of a crackpot theory. I'm sorry if any of this came off as mean, but I just don't think any of the staff had enough time to effectively commit this murder.

[@nobody-qv9cn]

These are really good points.

[@thepeeps5943]

I think Clown Pierce orchestrated the murder but Ross carried it through and actually killed her. I don’t have evidence I’m just spewing up random bs

[@Crashed-s9e]

Well, now I'm curious. Are you saying that something, not someone, killed Mysti? If you don't mind me asking.

[@NewPerspectiveVFX]

disagreement is not a crime, no need to apologize - i love your theory as well! obviously we have to go off the only information we know because that’s the whole point of the whitepine mystery, i think this video did a good job at piecing things together but we won’t know for sure until more episodes (and context) are released

[@lazy3912]

I would love to hear your theory on what killed Mysti

[@artisticloko]

clown and Ross working together would be so funny since they both mess up ivory’s name calling her “ivy” and then framing her for murder like damnnn

[@ComplexlyRoss]

oooooo inch resting theory!! i really like the direction of trying to understand the relationships and power hierarchy of the characters!!!

[@BeeHive5]

Also, he immediately took the HELP (Honors Emberton Libertarian Party) note, presumably so nobody else could see it

[@tjgdddfcn]

oh my god im so stupid I thought that politics was going to be relevant to the story

[@ubnominal]

I honestly thought Ross killed Ivo by making him swallow a dangerous pill. Then asking Ivory for a shovel to dig up a hole for Ivo’s corpse Imo, it feels like Ross is climbing the ladder for a higher position

[@supuhmon3217]

Ooh, or maybe Ivo knew too much, so Ross was sent to covertly take him out? That’s a good idea!

[@shoeboi4596]

I can only see clownpierce in shimmering, purple and blue diamond armor along with a shield and sword in hand, hunting. That face has only been a sign of death for me.

[@Flunium]

fr

[@Kody465]

I don't think clown going to talk to ivory would mean he walked past the body, or killed mysticat because of the time differences. We see clown going to talk to ivory, suspectedly walking through where mysti was later found dead because of the screaming we heard. The reason i think it WASN'T clown, was because we hear the screams AFTER the scene of clown going to talk to ivory while the two are sorting mail. The first scream has to be mysti being knocked down the stairs, and the second has to be someone finding her, or her being killed after she had fallen down. We hear both screams while we can see Clown and Ivory sitting in the staff room. This prooves that it was not clown, BECAUSE there were TWO screams. If it were one scream of a person finding Mysti, it would make clown the main suspect. But, the second scream we hear prooves it was not clown, because nobody would scream TWICE after seeing a dead body.

[@nobody-qv9cn]

Good catch!!

[@SlinkyCorn]

EXACTLY!

[@ollie_lost]

That's exactly what I was about to say!

[@multifriskyyy]

so do you think maddy did it? because in her interrogation she mentioned that she didn’t hear any struggle or thudding. if the first scream was the sound of mysti falling/being killed and the second scream (very soon after the first, implying that maddy came very quickly upon hearing the screams/thuds) was maddy finding her body, why didn’t she mention that in the interrogation? tbh, when i first heard the screams and found out what happened, my original thought was that the first one was a scream of general surprise and the second came after she realized and processed what she was looking at.

[@catincake3467]

We need more Whitepine content like this

[@cchihiroo]

This is genuinely really interesting and I didn't even think of this while watching. I personally hope that Clownpierce is not the villain in this series because he already is in EVERY OTHER ONE. I mean his nickname is literally "Minecraft's DEADLIEST player". I feel like this might be a play on that, like Ivory wants you to believe that because it's so predictable if you know who Clownpierce is. I'm also just coping because I want minutetech to be the villain VERY badly even though I know that is also predictable in its own right. Regardless, I love all of the creators and would be excited to see who the villain is no matter who they are. I can't wait for more episodes to come out and the story is revealed more. :)

[@Im_batman-p3y]

My theory is that when Zombies son said that"ever since i outed" it meant smt like he was admitting thst he was gay so the father kept assigning him maids to prevent him from falling inlove with the butlers but he didnt want that or smt n asked clownpierce to kill off mistycat so like..(doesnt make sense rly)

[@Cefedabomb]

In the 2nd episode serapter was very anxious when ivory was talking about the murder and that makes him a suspect in my eyes

[@ThisIsAHandle-xz5yo]

Being anxious makes sense, Mysti was implied to be his friend, the murderer is still out there, Serapter could be next, another of his friends could be next, that would make anyone anxious

[@radtheterminator7624]

“Part three is probably coming out at 2028” is the funniest shi ever

[@theunited7star423]

Great theory! But I don't think clown did it, or ivory. When you said Clown was blocking off Ivory, another person walked past the both of them into the place where clown was blocking ivory from. This doesn't really debunk anything your saying, just an observation lol.

[@theunited7star423]

Also is there a way we can identify the person who walked past them?

[@NewPerspectiveVFX]

@@theunited7star423 that wasn’t the only point to the theory - that girl that passed them was (probably) the one that ended up screaming

[@theunited7star423]

@@NewPerspectiveVFX ohhhhhh

[@theunited7star423]

Makes sense

[@plantlover3741]

@@NewPerspectiveVFX Can't be her, she's seen in the kitchen with Ivory and Clown at 28:03, just over Ivory's shoulder Edit: you can see them more clearly at 27:55

[@doornumb]

No Minutetech involved? He, who hired Ivory for the job under Clown's command right before the murder? Ivory, who replaced Mysti's job? See how that connects?

[@quinn3301]

0:42 I also noticed the figure and zoomed in to see who it was. When I looked at it, I noticed that there was a skin jacket that stocked up on the very top left of the back of the head. So I compared the skin to the employees and noticed that Div has a skin jacket and that their right side is mostly black. So I thought it was Div. Also, if it was Clownpierce, I think we would have seen the red on the back of his head. Edit: I don't mean to try to say it was Div and not Clownpierce. I just think it could have also been Div. Nice theory!

[@surpreemleadernoot]

idk why but I just have a feeling the murder could be supernatural but I'll wait and see till the end

[@Flunium]

This makes sense tbh since Clown has a reputation as a ‘deadly clown’ lol

[@chopstick3555]

Great video and theory!

[@aultex]

Suprise, suprise, "Minecraft Deadliest Player" is a murder ._.

[@SlinkyCorn]

Why is everybody pointing at Clown?! This is called a Murder Mystery it could be anybody! It could be Clown but it could also not. I mean Ross dose seem quite suspicious too. We currently don’t have enough information to start pointing fingers.

[@hayashi15]

This guy is underreated as F

[@xxalekfumantexx8737]

Ivory woldn't make it so obvious, the murderer is Ivory I call it now.

[@xxalekfumantexx8737]

she has some sort of brutal second personality and has terrorized clown to make sure he doesn't tell anybody, he's actually triyng to frame ivory indirectly because he is scared, also ivory says she was found in the woods??? Maybe she has trauma and doesn't want to talk about it, or she for some reason doesn't remember everything she does.

[@nipzio]

Isnt Ash also pretty close with Clown? Honestly he's pretty suspicious to me and maybe he was the one to actually kill Mysticat on Clown's behalf.

[@KwikBR]

what makes him suspicious to you?

[@nipzio]

@@KwikBR idk, it's just a gut feeling. and if this theory is right, ash might be apart of this since clown trusts him so much. clown lets him drive, clown made ivory help ash in the kitchen, clown told ash specifically to tell the hemlockes about the murder. clown TRUSTS him, so logically he would trust ash to successfully do the job of murdering mysticat if not something else for him.

[@KwikBR]

@@nipzio that's true actually, i only remembered the kitchen part

[@than0shark]

if ivory sees this and it was right please do not change the ending. ive seen it happen with multiple series where the users figure out the ending prematurely and the developers rush to change the ending

[@rodrivazquez1590]

and also when has clown not been a villain

[@fallen_moons]

If it really is Clown, well, props to Ivory for doing that traditional "get the deadliest assasin and make him the flipping antagonist".

[@ThisIsKio]

ClownPierce is always suspicious not gonna lie HAGSHHAHAHA

[@MS_SHRIMPI]

LIKE, DAMN IT! WHY THE HELL IS 3 EPISODE COMING OUT IN 2028?!?!?! 😢😢

[@zane5810]

I hope it's just joke

[@GachaJuno]

It's an exaggeration joke because the second episode took a month to come out, lol. Ivory said at some point that the third episode would come out sooner than the second one because the second one had issues lol TL;DR it's a joke lol

[@zane5810]

@@GachaJuno thank you for info(⁠•⁠‿⁠•⁠)

[@ever-dusk]

@@GachaJunoyou are a freaking life saver. i almost unreccomended ivory and forgot about the series in a rage of grief and frustration tbh

[@Flunium]

calm down bro he obviously serious

[@sackofremains]

the manor has many servants and people in general; if mysti was killed in the main foyer and wasn't found moments after her death (my personal theory is that the screams ARE mysti being killed) the body would've been found even earlier. i don't think mysti could've been killed and NOT found almost immediately.

[@SuperDuckyWho]

Ooooh and him bringing Ivory to do work with him in the kitchen gives him an alibi...

[@SuperDuckyWho]

Bot there's no blood on him... that's the confusing part.

[@selevercodmobile761]

if clown did it, it matches his way of playing the game

[@officerjungle2564]

why is clownpierce always the villain💀

[@_ChatSoCute_]

I’m loving this so much

[@G3N0C1D33]

Dun dun dunnnnn, the truth comes out lmao

[@Remisan]

i find it weird that the forest is always so eerie and looks like theres something in it at all times and the fact that clown would have enough time to brutally stab someone on the stairs or push them off the stairs without screams being heard from the person that was killed and with washing off all the blood in time? it sounds impossible to me. this theory is really good though, but why is ivory always staring outside in the forest, and why was she found there by minutetech? so many theorys r in my head rn 😭🙏 also the guy that offered some sort of medicine to swallow for a butler being in that one scene made me wonder alot idk why tho, and the shovel for cobwebs? whitepine has so much to look into its so exciting.

[@literallyAtsushi]

guys in ivorys discord she confirmed that we’ll be getting one ep per month at least the 2028 thing was a joke

[@GenesisLaboratoriesOfficial]

breakcore vine boom at 1:30

[@kantje]

Interesting theory 🔎

[@chlebektv]

honestly, i love whitepine, starting this vid rn, ill love this whatever it contains, gonna write my reaction in replies

[@ArticRave]

I don't have much of a theory my self but what I really want to know is if Clown actually did it some how without being caught with blood all over him and then washing it off, what would be his motive???

[@InfinitiaterYT]

The dark figure could be Ash for all I know :/

[@nekimi__]

Tbh the only thing that puts clown off for me as the killer is the motive, why would he kill mysticat, why would he frame ivory.

[@Gerbaltin]

I'm actually not to sure with this theory. I do think that clown might be involved in the murder, but I don't see how he could've been the one to do it. Clown was helping Ivory sort through papers when the screams sounded. Its to be assumed that this was Mysti screaming and not some maid since it sounded off twice. However, I can definitely see clown teaming up the person (or entity) to help conduct this dubious scheme, Whether it be for money, power, or maybe even for a deal made with whoever is behind this.

[@missfortune4321]

Interesting theory

[@Dr34mC4tch3r]

When I heard you describe how brutally the victim was stabbed I was like “wait really?” I rewatched the ending of the first episode and realized I was surprised because there’s a lack of blood around the body. There’s some, but for how brutally they were stabbed, there should’ve been way more. Though, sadly, I don’t think I caught a detail or anything, and rather the redstone used as blood would just look odd connected. Still, it would thrown in a loop who could’ve killed the victim, as it could’ve been put together as a sort of stage. Again, I honestly don’t think this is the case.

[@zMarsIsCool]

I have my own little horrible theory: Pyro’s father did it. Pyro was apparently outed by his father, and they have a really really strained relationship, what better way to hurt him than to take away his assistant! Other than that i have no evidence, it’s just someone you wouldn’t expect! Pyro got outed because of his “hunting” trips in the forest, Ivory and Pyro must have some connection, Pyro’s father is framing Ivory too, another way to hurt Pyro!

[@ThisIsAHandle-xz5yo]

Really makes me think about how Pyro is constantly called a “Good guy” I have three theories as to what he could have done 1. He did something to Ivory by accident or on purpose 2 He’s going to do something to his father 3. He did something which resulted in his mother dying I doubt Pyro is the murderer though

[@zMarsIsCool]

@@ThisIsAHandle-xz5yoYeah!

[@jordythesheep]

Ima create the best theory even tho it doesn’t make any sense. 1st of all, all of the maids, or workers are teaming up without telling ivory. Mysticat doesn’t agree so they kill her boom. I’m so smart. Also, at the end, they are going to have a final boss battle against Ivory but ivory convinces all of them to join her against clown dun dun dunnnnn

[@ThisIsAHandle-xz5yo]

Honestly if that happened I would be kinda disappointed, it’s a waste of potential

[@NurmikMaa]

Whitepine 3 in 2028? 😟

[@futureofgeography]

Personally I have my own theorem. Bormethius. Is it not a LITTLE bit suspicious that he's just, y'know, THERE? Conveniently by the mansion in the woods? Quick reminder, people are KNOWN to go missing in those woods, why? BECAUSE HE KILLED THEM ALL. And is it NOT a little bit suspicious how he's so relentless in his questions? Is it not a little bit odd that he takes quite literally no effort to connect with anyone he interrogates? Ivory's smart, she knows how an interrogation is done, it's not a bombardment of question, and the fact that the rights aren't at all taken seriously is evidence. I definitely don't think it's JesterPenetrate, I think clown is just there to lead people off course, and yeah, plantlover is right when there's no blood, but there's something else to add, let's be real, are we confident that nobody would go down to the laundry room? Also, given how brutal this case was, are we also going to ignore the fact there would've been blood and screaming? I refuse to believe not a single person heard this, unless it was one big swing to the head which knocked mysti unconscious, something I doubt would even be available for Clown to carry anywhere near this area, and this was untrue anyway, the corpse was bleeding, like, a lot, there was a LOT of bleeding, this was a stabbing, not some guitar to the head, UNLESS a different, more unconventional murder weapon was used, which a 'detective' may have.

[@futureofgeography]

another thing is that, this happened in episode 1, EPISODE. ONE. We also know Ivory likes background characters, and I also don't see any corpses in that room, it'd just be too obvious, ivory's always been a lady of fine mystery, this is no fine mystery

[@ThisIsAHandle-xz5yo]

How would the detective be able to get inside and get out without being noticed, also what would be the motive

[@mooshielove9151]

there isn't a motive for clown to do this, neither ross. I believe ross is a red herring tho

[@p.c.r.4062]

part 3 on 2028? Thats a long time..

[@ThisIsAHandle-xz5yo]

From what I’ve heard it either the end of October or sometime in November They work fast

[@nephalemmadeline]

Respectfully, I don’t think so, because clownpierce is *right* by ivory when it happens. How could he kill misty when they are across the house from each other?

[@adexit9829]

But if it is clown Pierce I think that would be way too obvious because he is the boss so I think ross did it for clown

[@TommasoVivona]

2:35 and what about the person who walks by them ?

[@Toeep]

my theory is rlly bad but i think the dad wanted to kill mistycat

[@youcantfinduni]

Very interesting

[@KwikBR]

was there not a decent amount of time between the scene you mentioned and when mysti was killed, though?

[@ThisIsAHandle-xz5yo]

The motive of Mysti dying is not clear yet, the two most likely theories I’ve heard is A. To rise up the ranks, or B. To hurt Pyro, neither of which really apply to ClownPierce A meta reason is probably just Mysticat having other projects to work one

[@BreBre-x7k]

Part 3 IN 2028!?

[@VEX1NS]

nice theory ;D

[@RoseQuartz-fe4xv]

It was me.

[@sixerTea]

could you try and figure out why?

[@SammyMc55]

Actually it is MinuteTech who killed Misty, i have did my research and it is him

[@ThisIsAHandle-xz5yo]

Two questions then 1. Means? How did he get in and out without being noticed? 2. Motive? There’s little to now reason for him to kill Mysti, why would he have done it?

[@SammyMc55]

@@ThisIsAHandle-xz5yo 1: As you Can see the Black Figure gets out from a door. We Haven't seen what behind the door that he went trough I think, who knows maybe he Jumped out a window or went around the Whole house, theres 2 screams.one is Misty's which is the muffled one and the other Louder Scream is a staff's Scream, Because it looks like Someone bit her neck or something making her unable to Scream and stuff, Also if you look closely at the figure you Can some some white Streaks on the head yes it looks like ClownPierce's Streaks but his are red, The other ones are Some kind of White or grey. And from what I noticed if you look right when the body appears the same grey Streaks on the first character you see, so that Means the Murderer Also came to the crime scene after. From what I see it looks like MinuteTech's skin but im not sure. 2: we Don't have any backstory on Misty and MinuteTech so who knows what conflicts they had, what if he meant to kill Someone else but Changed his mind to Kill Misty, he night have had little to lots of Reasons to kill Misty. But for now until whitepine ep 3 Doesn't appear I don't really have more evidence. this is what I see from the 2 episodes will make more research when the next episode comes but rn my Mind is fixated that MinuteTech is the killer so yea I tried to explain this as best as I can

[@WISP_PRIME]

I mean hes clown pierce, what does you expect him to do other than casually going around murdering ppl

[@Respear]

i am the murderer mb

[@vallidear7344]

Nah it's definitely pyro he seems sus

[@Plasmagirl3000Sam]

Honest W

[@liamcarnahan7744]

wait what is this. and what is whitepine. did youtube give me a video about a series i havent even seen?

[@jaqbs0n]

bro its ep 2 how?

[@leiabitencourtt1108]

Yes

[@ChillingRat]

Sick lol

[@ChariTheAlternate]

Hello

[@nyantacoplayz7493]

Cwazy