容祖兒 Joey Yung《天窗》[Official MV]

[@glue731]

我是台灣人 但我越來越喜歡聽粵語歌了 謝霆鋒的粵語老歌也很聽

[@gpinvest]

ggsjjuytssuqvrrrrrrrrrrr8

[@glue731]

哈這些我都有在聽 李克勤.薛凱琪.張敬軒軒仔也是必聽

[@lamjacky9449]

側田 才是王道 K歌之王

[@whyhi5237]

衛蘭also

[@leungkinfoon4897]

glue731

[@arhang9525]

成首歌講既故事我會理解做: --喺一個男方主動約女方既約會入面，男方想同女方講分手，原因係佢有另一個，同時女方亦明白男方製造呢個約會既目的同埋原因。 (若是沒要事 你怎會約我相見 分手講到了咀邊) --喺約會既時候，男方唔識得點樣開口，導致約會異常咁靜局，但女方明白再靜落去都改變唔到要分手呢個事實，不如自己開口，快啲離開呢個尷尬既現場。 (讓靜默 去蔓延 救不了你太多遍 逃走 還更方便) --因為女方明白男方唔識開口係因為佢對女方有份愧疚感，好難突然對女方有180度既態度轉變。 (事實上我亦理解不忠的辛酸 不便突然態度變) --於是女方決定唔打開天窗說亮話，寧願扮無知就當係對男方既體諒，男方想狠心咁同自己講分手既原因無非都係想自己可以過得舒服啲，索性就成全佢，令佢再舒服啲。 (毋須打開天窗 能裝不知 也算體諒 狠心揭破真相 無非想扮誠實來換舒暢) --加上自己亦唔想攤牌，為自己留番個份僅有既尊嚴，直接扮做係自己想分手，根本無人對唔住自己。 (自問亦有形象 未願暴露惆悵 我會扮做無人欠我 分開只因我想) --女方亦希望大家好黎好去，就索性要男方埋單就當咩事都無發生過。 (即使分手要有修養 今天晚宴就由你付賬) --女方認為咁樣既結局不論對男方定對自己既傷害都比較少，男方亦可以少一份愧疚。 (這結局美麗過真相 這結局更善良 毫無殺氣 不必心傷) 其實女方仲好愛男方，但係女方知道無論自己點做都改變唔到要分手呢個事實，索性要自己承受所有傷害，包括埋男方對女方既內疚，只要講一個大話，令兩人既結局變得比真相美麗，但係亦改變唔到男方背叛左女方既事實，所以女方既心亦比男方傷得好深，而喺MV入面最後既一下槍聲，正正係女方向自己傷口上再補開既一槍...

[@erikaz6934]

Ar hang 黄伟文睇到你个留言会好欣慰，”终于无白费力气写歌词啦”

[@matthewyip3379]

Ar hang ，

[@lowyben6525]

Amazing!

[@941119yan]

so detailed

[@洪維淇]

1..:.

[@betrue616]

祖祖你靚得太過份，人靚聲甜，心地善良

[@sophiakwong19]

有無人覺得個melody同 “明知苦得很 何必犧牲到那樣深”非常似◎◎

[@mluntom]

sophia kwong 我直頭覺得一樣 XD

[@nemesisleung]

咩歌？

[@mluntom]

+taskmutli 悲哀代言人

[@katharineing]

似到一個點，可能柏豪聽完悲哀代言人然後有靈感作嘅

[@selinawong627]

金曲金獎 實至名歸

[@favouritemay]

一直都覺得chorus好似以前聽開既一首歌 原來係悲哀代言人

[@kkbox-6789]

2021還在聽的請來按讚簽到😎😎

[@yumichung1221_]

Yumi✨💗

[@YinLam-z5g]

祖兒、大美人、優雅、高貴、正

[@YinLam-z5g]

祖兒又靚女又高貴又有氣質、有修養又有內涵、著衫又靚、又識著衫、祖兒有外表(外在美又有內在美，總之、 祖兒就十分之十全 十美、美麗動人

[@lovenowandalways1]

2024年依然覺得呢首歌好好聽， 歌詞好正

[@sungkit1993]

晴天林叫我黎既！

[@YinLam-z5g]

嘩嘩啦！我見到祖兒真係令人眼前一亮漂亮動人，人靚 歌甜、祖兒天后、 聲色藝俱全、天后 實力確實係實致名 歸、非同凡享、一致認同祖兒係偶像實力派級天后冠軍級人馬

[@ko4xin]

我有点吓到，因为有很多留言说词写得很烂。。。我完全就无语了。。。这词明明写得很好，有故事性，比喻也用的很好，密码也埋得好好。点解还会有人觉得黄伟文写得不好呢。。。无语了

[@katezhulynsalvatore717]

果啲人都唔知寫唔寫得出半首詞😒😒

[@raydenhui3142]

因為佢哋唔鍾意廣東話歌

[@taimanchan9210]

我自己覺得你不須要太介意?!這個世界什麼人都有!(持反對意見?)不足為奇!!2020.6.12.3:50pm.

[@chungjack4068]

大陸人的觀點就是 大陸世界最強 其他國家都是廢物

[@matthewyip3379]

@@chungjack4068 你又知佢哋係大陸人？

[@asdevan]

Joey既咬字係無敵的!!! :D

[@jamiericerice]

she's so stunning @__@ and I believed that she's the one who made all these songs more than awesome. She deserves the respect and she deserves the best.

[@chongkawai1241]

聽完yumi再聽joey，感覺好很多，來回地獄又折反人間。

[@mswingwingwing]

歌好聽,MV都拍得幾靚

[@barbiekwok57]

喜歡mv裡紅x黑這色調的配搭， 華麗至極卻充滿濃濃的殺氣， 隨時一觸即發的感覺， 像情侶分手講到了咀邊時，表面平靜詳和， 然而在心中卻各自暗算著誰首先把底牌揭開， 誰首先開槍滅掉這一段感情。

[@kafkawong]

金曲金!!!!!!!!!! 恭喜哂Joey

[@林威-j9b]

恨一個人真係好難

[@khss7a23]

有人在微博說祖祖在這MV 裡拿槍自舉的動作, 和魚鱗網臉罩造型好帥, 所以過來重溫這mv

[@cocktailsinthemorning6468]

比爾賈拍的MV 像電影一樣美

[@senoritaballerinac5747]

個MV超靚

[@白糖糕-t2w]

最喜歡祖兒長捲髮 （づ￣3￣）づ╭❤～

[@vincentliu8825]

English Translation: 別望著 那熱茶 暗中的 計算 茶包 浮起 沉澱 若是沒要事 你怎會約我相見 分手講到了 咀~邊 Don’t look at the surreptitious scheming in the tea cup At the wobbly infusion of the tea bag in the boiling water If it isn’t for something’s happened, darling, why would you ask me here The words of breaking-up are hanging around your lips 讓靜默 去蔓延 救不了你 太多遍 逃走 還更 方便 事實上我亦 理解 不忠的辛酸 不便突然 態度變 Let silence spread I can’t save you from it too many times Running away would rather be more convenient, wouldn’t it In fact, I do understand the agony of being unfaithful, of your being unfaithful I don’t suppose my sudden change of attitude to you would help anyone 毋須打開天窗 能裝不知 也算體諒 狠心揭破真相 無非想 扮誠實來換舒暢 There’s no need to open the skylight (lay bare the truth) then My pretence of not knowing can perhaps count as a sort of understanding Desperately screaming the truth would just be equally a pretence of honesty in exchange for pitiful pleasure from avenge 毋須開多一槍 即使分手 要有修~養 今天晚宴 就由你付賬 There’s no need to gun someone down again Even though we are to part, I still must possess myself Dinner tonight would just be your treat then 自問亦有形象 未願暴露惆悵 我會扮做無人欠我 分開只因我想 Deep down, I just want to appear strong and hang on to my last thread of pride Deep down, I don’t want my sorrow and pain exposed I’ll act as if no one did me wrong I’ll bring up parting as if it were my own idea 毋須打開天窗 能裝不知 也算體諒 狠心揭破真相 無非想 扮誠實來換舒暢 There’s no need to open the skylight (lay bare the truth) then My pretence of not knowing can perhaps count as a sort of understanding Desperately screaming the truth would just be equally a pretence of honesty in exchange for pitiful pleasure from avenge 毋須開多一槍 即使分手 要有修養 今天晚宴 就由你付賬 There’s no need to gun someone down again Even though we are to part, I must still possess myself Dinner tonight would just be your treat then 這結局美麗過真相 這結局更善良 毫無殺氣 不必心傷 Such ending is more beautiful than the truth, isn't it Such ending is kinder, isn't it No hostility No display of heartache 毋須打開天窗 能裝不知 也算體諒 狠心揭破真相 無非想 扮誠實來換取舒暢 There’s no need to open the skylight (lay bare the truth) then My pretence of not knowing can perhaps count as a sort of understanding Desperately screaming the truth would just be equally a pretence of honesty in exchange for pitiful pleasure from avenge 毋須開多一槍 即使分手 要有修養 今天晚宴 就由你付賬 There’s no need to gun someone down again Even though we are to part, I still must possess myself Dinner tonight would just be your treat then 不必送我 大門要 關上 You don’t have to send me off, darling Just remember to shut the door, okay?

[@girlonfire2077]

SUPPORTTTT!! :D 好好聽!!:) forever my queen

[@vmvmv]

Joey is the best!

[@DorothyKolin]

個MV真係拍得好令>/////< 大讚啦~!!!!

最後伸中指好正，個mv真係唔錯 又有意思又拍得靚，仲有晏晏，蝦蝦。

[@chloek.5076]

Wing Lau 是假的嗎？

[@YinLam-z5g]

祖兒咁鬼死靚女、 真係眼前一亮

[@lagwater2023]

2020 都爱容祖儿！

[@yulaiying4120]

聽過好多次啦，副歌真係幾似悲哀代言人，唔通真係似到一模一樣咩，哈哈﹗

[@qiiing_3861]

我是馬來西亞人 我愛粵語

[@lvgo4602]

2024 揮手

[@Mrharry9326716]

又一高質素mv 歌好聽 完美配合！

[@黃寶瑩-q2d]

祖兒，你的美在你的歌聲中：）支持你

[@glorych1168]

+黃寶 瑩 ok what a obzervation

[@betrue616]

祖兒的作品就是excellent

[@s9soshi269]

joey looks so pretty

[@laurietam8084]

I am a huge fan of Joey. Even though I'm a year older than her, I definitely appreciate a lot of her songs. I haven't been hearing her songs for a while now and so glad that she's still making music. I'm Chinese and miss hearing songs like hers. keep it up Joey. Sorry if it's not Chinese. My hon won't let me download any Chinese Word Processor on his computer to use.

[@acemon0]

It's your computer to just tell him he's a jerk and do it anyways, a perry girl like can come and use mine any time she wants.

[@glorych1168]

+Laurie Tam why

[@manfaichu8261]

講乜春呀價？

[@lam.9231]

@@manfaichu8261 🤣

[@yingyingjy]

如果有多啲咁高水準嘅mv就好喇 祖啲演技好好呀 導演果然有料到

[@joeyyung8132]

joey is very best!

[@bongbong1005]

100萬👏👏👏

[@harryhonghong]

金曲金獎!!!

[@heartbeated]

超正，靚歌靚mv,再配合joey呢個驚艷華麗既造型

[@triplec23]

好吧 如釋重負了，謝謝你這兩年。

[@0LoveMyWay0]

我女神太美麗了～

[@applepielicious]

Sang this song at karaoke last night xD love this song

[@emmanuelegbe7643]

CG KAOROKE CG SUPERMARKET COCO &GIRLS COCO &THE BOYS SULLIVAN MINKWON CENTER FOR JUSTICE

[@bubububuuu]

李程彬fans報到🙋‍♀️

[@benyeah]

永遠支持容祖兒

[@sorrowm2048]

其實我覺得天窗同紅屋頂有關 歌詞既關上大門同黃色大門有關. 有冇人明我講乜?

[@stephyspecial2844]

Ya

[@chingmanyuen9499]

突然代入感好強（代入左佢同c的故事……）

[@queenieliu3530]

明……我估都系甘既

[@waikienlim3562]

Sorrow M 琪琪要知道越精彩的伴侣越无情。。。

[@nataliesky1365]

best song ever!!!! love joey

[@Cheung.chk3]

GReat

[@latenews2300]

joey 真係好靚

[@韓佳妤]

回來聽！！2021

[@kckl1234]

跟番首歌 應該係男人有外遇, 約女仔講分手 但係其實個女仔心都知呢樣野, 只係唔想面對 然後就係最後呢餐, 搶先係男仔講之前 自己向呢段感情開槍, 結束呢段感情 等有外遇呢樣野永遠留係"天窗"入面

[@mrplasticbottle]

好淒美.....

[@hoikiu1105]

Keep looping

[@hoic1102]

呢一刻好激動。雖然由細到大一直都好中意聽你既歌，但開始好留意你算係近幾個月嘅事，發覺你嘅歌唔止陪住我成長，原來我亦見證住你由十幾年前嘅o靚妹，蛻變成為今時今日既elegant又幸福嘅熟女。 除夕嘅飛已經買左，好期待同你倒數過年！因為呢個演唱會唔止係你對舞台一生一世嘅承諾，亦係粉絲們對你一生一世嘅承諾！ ps. 快d加場啦!!! 同埋希望我捉得準你嘅尾場 sosad

[@tllaw0502]

本身以為MV應該係一種淡淡然既感覺, 柔和既色彩, 不過用呢種顏色呢種方式去拍呢個MV又有另一種好特別既味道!! Joey係2:38果一下微微嘆氣同埋2:49既苦笑真係好好好好好好睇!!!! :)))

[@Kirisaki_Wataru]

2019仲聽緊~~

[@justinyee4369]

Add oil

[@80sretrocartoonbyvc56]

Fabulous

[@noonephone123]

我針對的是有人把有相似之處的東西看作抄襲,但你卻認為抄襲和相似是同義詞,以這樣的理解能力,你才是高手中的高手

[@keithclyeung]

好靚好靚好靚

[@superstarcatcat]

오 ~ 좋아하네! 잘 노래하네! =)

[@wongking816]

I have shelter a caring family and a trusted optometrist

[@rainbowsiu4501]

MV加埋呢首歌,冇得輸

[@nikekobe0]

MV拍得好美呀~聲音也很美，頗喜歡^^

[@alin9582]

Nice

[@EK-cw5rt]

excellent

[@loisally1]

love this song

[@rovenapang7988]

this is soooo beautiful :)

[@jellymandy]

你等於是在說, 世界上沒有抄襲這回事, 如果有, 那一定是5歲小孩的錯覺, 高手!

[@mikicyk]

高水準MV!!!

[@mingtatma7516]

由於分鐘開始 我唔會再同你說 分手兩個字 你放心啦

[@mintbibi]

喜歡 ~

[@sometime6661]

太靚啦，聽joey就是有品味，賞心悦目

[@t_wai9149]

個mv 令我更加明白首歌想表達d咩 :) 比導演gdgd!!!

[@linglung6132]

拍得容祖兒很漂亮

[@llo_01-v5s]

❤

[@janelui6330]

good songg! u are the bestttt:)

[@lyc-]

又靚又好戲，正呀！

[@kfluk1]

好好聽!!joey加油!!

[@Yellowdoor616]

Good

[@manson2810]

Nice voice

[@kathytse19971212]

好聽到不得了

[@RS-bo6jv]

最后的枪声有吓到我~总结来说，mv很好看！！！祖儿，加油。

[@adwdw4]

超好聽!!!

[@puikima4454]

好靚!!!!!!! 3

[@mingman828]

Diva

[@chuitakfan]

小joey yung姐姐^^”我是jason chui，我跟妳結婚後，只愛妳一個，甚麼也給妳，只對妳一個好！

[@morethanlesss]

原來最後有下槍聲，好震撼

[@mingman828]

Pretty

[@mrphonebreaker6218]

awesome!

[@squarelpy]

我覺得天窗嘅意思只不過係"打開天窗說亮話"到引用嘅，套用落呢首歌，意思大概係女方知男方想分手，其實唔需要對方講得太白，寧願自己揭破真相。

[@chunwingho4607]

jeng arrrr

[@pakfai923923]

要繼續製作高水準mv呀祖兒！加油！

[@johnlaw6155]

超好聽！好感動的歌聲！容小姐唱得超級捧！！！

[@emmanuelegbe7643]

WORLD MALL

[@noonephone123]

把自己認知範圍內相似的東西聯想歸類在一起,是5歲小孩的習慣

[@dunwun2681]

歌好聽，景好靚