Ibn Sina - Master of All Sciences (Philosophy)

[@OasesOfWisdom]

We have recently launched a patreon and KZbin membership. If you enjoy our contend and like to support us follow the links below :) KZbin Membership - kzbin.info/door/R-vnjZ_MmhsecpMqXS3BEQjoin Patreon - www.patreon.com/oasesofwisdom/membership

[@shakhzodbekkakhkhorov9095]

When you said he was persian, I was so enraged because Afshana is in Uzbekistan. I am from Uzbekistan and we were taught that he was Turk like us, not Persian from Iran. I opened comment section to write my long hate speech but I stopped and researched myself. And now I know he was indeed persian. I guess I can't rely on the government textbooks. Anyway, thanks for the video

[@mashhurarahimova6000]

Yea but we bukharian tajik are closest people to him not afgans nor iranians

[@ShokhrukhShukurov]

Rubbish all Bukharian not Tajik and we know he was Turkish ​@@mashhurarahimova6000

[@thecrimsondragon9744]

Turks weren't always there. Indo-Iranian peoples used to be the dominant peoples in modern day central Asia and Xinjiang. Then the Turks came in and 'turkified' them. If you look at the ancient mummies from that region, they have blond and red hair and what we would now consider European features.

[@BloggingTheology]

Very nice video.

[@thephilosophermma8449]

Please continue the series with following Suhrawardi , Ibn Arabī , Ibn Rushd , Mulla sadra and other Islamic philosophers .

[@OasesOfWisdom]

We plan to include many more philosophers (including those on your list) in the series.

[@jaanjaani726]

@الأزدي he is from khorasan before khorasan was big country 120 years ago Russia and English make part part for example Tajikistan Uzbekistan Turkmenistan Afghanistan blochastan of Iran the ibn sina house in north of Afghanistan the city name is mazar Sharif

[@SaeedAcronia]

Persian philosophers.

[@Ali5925k]

Abu Ali Sina was a Persian-speaking scientist... and another point is that great Iranian and Persian-speaking scientists and poets have nothing to do with Islam.

[@lilkurva180]

@@Ali5925k Keep crying.

[@mhw5674]

Iranian scientists are the pioneers of global science!🇹🇯🇮🇷🇦🇫❣️

[@dominioninside2233]

Nationalism is a plauge!

[@KygoCalvinHarris-xu4kv]

Uzbekistan

[@fayzullayev_17fayzullayev25]

Uzbekistan

[@Minichat71]

لا حول والا قوه، باز شما ایرانی ها چسپیدین به شاعران خراسان بزرگ، همه شان مال افغانستان هست.

[@rezamallaika5539]

ایرانی ها بسیار خود خوا هستن دلشان میخواهد که دانشمندان افغانستان را به نام خودشان کنند ولی مهاجران افغان را که سال‌های زندگی کردن درایران افغانستانی مینامند چقدر خودخواه هستن خوب‌ها را برای خودشان وبه نام خودشان بر میدارند

[@mustafakhan940]

Looks like you guys got an Islamic Philosophers cinematic universe with how it was outlined that Al-Farabi inspired Ibn Sina. Looking forward to more interconnected videos.

[@Ali5925k]

Abu Ali Sina was a Persian-speaking scientist... and another point is that great Iranian and Persian-speaking scientists and poets have nothing to do with Islam.

[@thecrimsondragon9744]

​@@Ali5925k Yes, I read some of these prominent scientists, philosophers, writers etc during the so called 'Islamic golden age' were Persians who preferred Persian to Arabic but were compelled by rulers of the time to write in Arabic.

[@fionaknaus6973]

🇮🇷❤ Sina or Poor Sina (in Persian), is the most famous Iranian scientist in the world. his book called 《Ghanoon》, in the field of medicine was taught in universities around the world until the 19th century. In the West, it is known as AVICENNE. There are many hospitals in the world or department in the faculties of medicine in the world in his name. In Iran, he is a national pride. His tomb is in the city of Hamedan in northwestern Iran.

[@endpc5166]

He was pers𝜖cuted und𝜀r Islam: _"Like his predecessor AI-Kindi, Ibn Sina was a fiercely independent-minded philosopher who insisted on the primacy of reason, although he had disputed the Mu'tazilites on various technical matters. For a time he was vizier to the emir of Hamad an. Here he got into a religious argument with strict believers of the army, and they soon called for his ex𝜀cution. Soldiers came to his house ,but, not finding him, plund𝜀red it and then called on the emir to b𝜀head him. Ibn Sina was warned in time and hid at the house of his friend Abu Said Dafdaq, where he worked on his masterpiece AI-Qanun. Ibn Sina fled p𝜀rsecution and the wrath of rulers several times. With his books banned, and powerful enemies plotting against him, his friends counselled moderation. To this he replied: 'I prefer a short life with width to a narrow one with length,' and continued his work undaunted."_ - Hoodbhoy, Pervez , _Islam and Science_ (Chpt 10).

[@endpc5166]

"Like his predecessor AI-Kindi, Ibn Sina was a fiercely independent-minded philosopher who insisted on the primacy of reason, although he had disputed the Mu'tazilites on various technical matters. For a time he was vizier to the emir of Hamadan. Here he got into a religious argument with strict believers of the army, and they soon called for his execution. Soldiers came to his house ,but, not finding him, plundered it and then called on the emir to behead him. Ibn Sina was warned in time and hid at the house of his friend Abu Said Dafdaq, where he worked on his masterpiece AI-Qanun. Ibn Sina fled persecution and the wrath of rulers several times. With his books banned, and powerful enemies plotting against him, his friends counselled moderation. To this he replied: 'I prefer a short life with width to a narrow one with length,' and continued his work undaunted. Ibn Sina's attempted synthesis of religious beliefs with science and logic repeatedly earned him wrath of the ulema." - Hoodbhoy, Pervez , Islam and Science (Chpt 10). The point: Islamic orthodoxy didn't help but worked against learning.

[@ProLookout]

@@endpc5166 "The point: Islamic orthodoxy didn't help but worked against learning." not really, ignorance did, and not all orthodox people are ignorant and some are extremely intellectual. To be orthodox one has to follow the Words in the Quran to the T or as much as they sincerely can and that would mean that they would have to learn about different things and use kalam. So if it didn't help, how did the ummah get to that point of "golden age"? (by the way, I think they never left it, non-Islamic external sources are the main reason we don't see it. For example, the US and allied forces' foreign policy is built to destroy this ummah just like they did with their own) It's like saying the Muslims before the "golden age" weren't orthodox (if your using the word orthodox as it is defined in dictionaries, they were. Were the Sahaba orthodox by definition?) and that orthodoxy is some sort of phenomenon. This thought is just a classic case of attributing a minority's actions or ideas to the majority because this is what is highlighted the most throughout history. Because it's so outrageous people just can't stop talking about it that everything else gets lost in time or hidden in the "zeitgeist". Orthodoxy or wanting to follow your religion to an extreme doesn't have to be a bad thing if done appropriately, obviously.

[@endpc5166]

@@ProLookout But the orthodoxy of the likes of very influential AI-Ghazli hindered greatly scientific learning. He denied physical causality, Allah did everything, and that belief makes modern science, esp physics, impossible. Muslims had to wait for centuries for "infidel" scientists to set them on the right path. Now Muslim apologists struggle to reinterpret the unscientific verses of the Qur'an in the light of the new modern science. This is why I say the Qur'an could not have come from an all-knowing God. Must go elsewhere for Truth.

[@endpc5166]

@@ProLookout But the orthodoxy of the likes of very influential AI-Ghazli h𝜄ndered greatly scientific learning. He denied physical causality, Allah did everything, and that belief makes mod𝜀rn science, esp physics, 𝜄mpossible. Muslims had to wa𝜄t for centuries for "infidel" scientists to set them r𝜄ght. Now Muslim ap𝜊logists struggl𝜀 to re𝜄nterpret the unsc𝜄entific verses of the Qur'an in the l𝜄ght of the n𝜀w mod𝜀rn science. This is why the Qur'an could n𝜊t have come from an all-knowing G𝜊d. Must go els𝜀where for Truth.

[@gulfamramzan500]

Great work. Thank you guys for helping me in my study of islamic Philosophy :)

[@LukeFromLasVegas]

Wonderful video. 🌍 Informative, well-spoken, and entertaining. Looking forward to more.

[@abdulloxsharipov6569]

I'm a Muslim and Ibn Sina was from our lands central Asia

[@user-zp7fx4gy4u]

He was from Iran and the Middle East

[@DigoronKavkaz]

@@user-zp7fx4gy4u LOL. His mom is from Bukhara and his dad from Balkh. CENTRAL ASIA. Irooniye ahmagh

[@Muhammadali12244]

​@@user-zp7fx4gy4uIs Bukhara in Iran? Bukhara is a city in Uzbekistan. Ibn Sina was born in Bukhara.

[@HajiTech-or3pf]

@@DigoronKavkaz Before many considerable regions of central Asia were part of Greater Iran (Persia), Then the Turks pushed the Iranians out of Central Asia to today's Iran They went further and conquered Azerbaijan and Anatolia (modern-day Turkey)

[@AmirAmiri-nj7xh]

​@@DigoronKavkaz He is completely Iranian and belongs to an Iranian country, but the reason he was born in Afshanah or Balkh is that at that time there were no countries with these names and these countries were considered part of the Iranian Empire. Please don't steal our culture, America and Israel have commissioned countries close to Iran to steal Iran's culture by falsifying its history, for example, Azerbaijan is trying to name our polo sport, which is for us, in its own name, and our Shirazi salad is a terrorist gang of Israel and Or Avicenna our Spain and Maulavi our Turkey, India and Afghanistan. Please research first and be alert. You are also considered to be part of the historical scope of Iranian culture, not Russian culture or English culture. Be careful not to be deceived.

[@furrowsan]

the last quote was so inspirational!

[@masterronaldbutler1614]

Finally, a video on Ibn Sina. Lets gooooo!

[@mistermkultra3114]

Hi , great video , lately I like the philosophy of religion and theology and make me curious the thoughs of islamic thinkers , amazing channel .

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Thank you for your support. Watch out for more videos on our channel!

[@mistermkultra3114]

@@OasesOfWisdom I also wanted to ask you something, what editing software do you use to edit your videos ?

[@OasesOfWisdom]

@@mistermkultra3114 Adobe Premiere Pro

[@manog8713]

Islamic thinkers? What does it mean?

[@SoldierOfAlIah]

@@manog8713all of these were Muslims

[@ftahmasebi9059]

Iranians have enjoyed a long cultural continuity, something that distinguishes them from other Middle Eastern neighbors. Avicenna's presence in Iranian landmarks not only serves as a reminder of his remarkable achievements but also fosters a sense of national pride among Persians

[@Ofoqwhite]

He was from Afghanistan, stop calling everyone iranian, wth is wrong with you guys.

[@Ghos7town]

This is very well done. Thank you for making this!

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Thanks so much! Stay tuned for more

[@user-wb2fi6xq1s]

Ibn Sina was born in 980 in Afshana near Bukhara (now Uzbekistan, then Persia) as the son of an Ismaili scholar from Balkh (now Afghanistan) and died in Hamadan, then Persia (now Iran), at the court of the Persian Buyids. He is originally from (Balkh) now Balkh province Afghanistan 🇦🇫

[@mashhurarahimova6000]

He was bukharian tajik

[@AmirAmiri-nj7xh]

I tell both of you He is completely Iranian and belongs to an Iranian country, but the reason he was born in Afshanah or Balkh is that at that time there were no countries with these names and these countries were considered part of the Iranian Empire. Please don't steal our culture, America and Israel have commissioned countries close to Iran to steal Iran's culture by falsifying its history, for example, Azerbaijan is trying to name our polo sport, which is for us, in its own name, and our Shirazi salad is a terrorist gang of Israel and Or Avicenna our Spain and Maulavi our Turkey, India and Afghanistan. Please research first and be alert. You are also considered to be part of the historical scope of Iranian culture, not Russian culture or English culture. Be careful not to be deceived.

[@SubAnima]

Your channel is amazing - hardly anything quality on KZbin on Islamic philosophers/scientists … until now! Can’t wait for you to explode. Keep up the great work.

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Thank you for your support!

[@manog8713]

What is islamic phiospher/scientists?

[@shizukuchan4836]

@@manog8713 go google

[@ThatBlueCar]

Best video to date. The quality, pacing and visuals just keep on getting better, keep up the great work!

[@Creepzza]

Great stuff. I have heard of Avicenna, was very delighted to finally get to know more about him :)

[@khizzard_069]

ما شاء اللہ جزاک اللہ خیراً

[@proverbeseticonesarabes-ar5221]

Very resourceful. Thanks for sharing all this knowledge!

[@mastanshariff4582]

Please do more videos, upload more. May Allah reward you for your great work.

[@Saint718]

Amazing ! He is truly an inspiration . Ibn Sina

[@hashmiuk]

So proud of you Ahmad

[@MohammedJomil]

Thanks Allan. I'm very happy to find a Islam scientist

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Thank you Mohammed. Glad you enjoyed the video :)

[@Ali5925k]

Abu Ali Sina was a Persian-speaking scientist... and another point is that great Iranian and Persian-speaking scientists and poets have nothing to do with Islam.

[@lilkurva180]

@@Ali5925k Keep crying bro. Arabs conquered your lands and now your muslim :) and so was he.

[@mattski1979]

Great job making this.

[@OasesOfWisdom]

We are thrilled you enjoyed it :)

[@faysal8597]

Love this channel, keep up the great content !!

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Thanks so much! Will do

[@mhw5674]

Iranian scientists are the pioneers of global science!🇮🇷❣️

[@DigoronKavkaz]

He's not from Iran. His mom was from Bukhara and his dad from Balkh.

[@pooya4434]

@@DigoronKavkaz bukhara and balkh both cities of The Samanid Persian Empire. His mother was from Bactria, an ancient Iranian region.

[@DigoronKavkaz]

@@pooya4434 Both his parents are from cities that belonged to Bactria and Sogdiana. I don't know why Persians try to claim everything as their own. It's so annoying.

[@pooya4434]

@@DigoronKavkaz and do you know what is Bactria right? An ancient Iranian region. Persian is just the name for all Iranic people in the West. And for fu*ck sake he was speaking Persian what is wrong with you... He even tried and used some Persian equivalents in his books in order to revive the language after getting heavily Arabised. Why would you get offended by the fact? Just because a lot of these scholars are Persian, doesn't mean it's a lie and you should claim it for yourself.

[@imadina31]

Great video ! ❤️ Thank you ! I would love to learn more about Rumi also

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Yep! Rumi will be covered eventually. We are covering our thinkers in chronological order, so stay tuned.

[@imadina31]

Can't wait 😊

[@fhh43]

Er wurde in Balch heutige Afghanistan 🇦🇫 geboren und in kunia heutige Turkey verstorben. Seine stammfamilie waren aus Afghanistan.

[@ray_light44]

I miss the videos of this channel I hope you post a new video in the future Inshallah

[@OasesOfWisdom]

New videos are on the way! They take months to research, write, edit and produce so please be patient. You can look forward to videos on Imam Abu Hanifa and the Brethren of Purity in the near future

[@ameragha2005]

Videos just keep on getting better! Keep it up!!!

[@herospark1]

Hello I love your work! Would appreciate a video about Ibn Arabi!

[@zakyzayn5361]

Great video on hujjat ul haq shaykh Al reis

[@ababouh.5540]

Great video, God bless you

[@bobachan211]

i really liked this video! very informative. You should do a video on Al-Biruni next time

[@rufaiguruboy7677]

Ibn Sina was a Persian from Uzbekistan (Central Asia), not a Turk as some in the comments. Before many considerable regions of central Asia were part of Greater Iran (Persia is the dominant tribe of Iranian people), Then the Turks conquered and pushed the Iranians out of Central Asia to today's Iran They went further and conquered Azerbaijan and Anatolia (modern-day Turkey). The original Turks originate from the west of Atlai mountain, and their closest cousins are Mongols. The original Turks are "Chinese looking" not "arab/Persian looking" though they are they are totally different from Chinese just analogous to Persians and arabs. The arab looking Turks in central Asia were Turkified Iranian people (of course they were intermarriages with the Turks too) And the White looking Turks in Turkey were Turkified Greeks

[@rafiq786uk]

Fascinating. Thanks for sharing!

[@nailaaziz1992]

beautifully explained

[@wildedibles]

The use of American Gothic is a bit creepy in the context of the video. The subjects of the painting are father and daughter...

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Yikes! Had no idea. We cycle through about ~200 paintings and images per video to create the collages, so much of it is bound to be out of context. Thanks for pointing this out though, we should defo be more cautious in the future.” - Wikipedia, American Gothic I also found an article online claiming Wood’s mother was chosen to pose for the painting but declined and that a popular caption for the painting is “An Iowan with his wife”. In pop culture satires of the painting also seem to depict husband and wife which probably explained my subconscious attraction to use it for such.

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Your comment inspired me to do some more research and the rabbit hole goes deeper. This quote is from the Wikipedia article for American gothic: “In 2005, art historian Sue Taylor suggested that the figures in the portrait may actually represent Wood's parents. She claimed that due to Wood's father passing away when Wood was only 10 years old, Wood did not develop a close relationship with him but noted that he did spend the rest of his life very closely attached to his mother. She theorizes that Wood may have developed an Oedipus complex and subconsciously expressed that in the painting. Taylor cites the lack of warmth between the two figures as well as Wood's classification of them as “father and daughter” was a way for Wood to remove any sexual connotation so that Wood wouldn't have to face his own fears and insecurities. Taylor also points out similarities between other portraits of Wood's mother and the woman in American Gothic, including the brooch that she wears.”

[@orbiteflow8909]

Middle eastern world and western world evolved from each other.

[@MrSuresh1904]

Thank you very much. Now let us have an article about Tbn Rushd

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Ibn Rushd will be covered in a few episode’s time. We are doing a series on Islamic Philosophers, beginning with Al-Kindi and ending with Muhammad Iqbal

[@kingasmind5175]

Best video

[@endpc5166]

That impressive age of learning occurred under very tolerant caliphs in spite of orthodox Islam, not because of it, and it finally died due to persecution by orthodox Muslims. Ibn Sina ws an example. "Ibn Sina acquired a reputation for heresy by the orthodox both in his own time as well as in later centuries. The most influential of conservative theologians, Imam AI-Ghazzali, declared him to be an unbeliever." - _Islam And Science_ by Prof. Pervez Hoodbhoy.

[@mariahanano8357]

Thats the beauty of religion and Gods word! Islam is a philosophical religion in its nature. He tells us he created us to worship and think. He orders us to think, so, its only natural that these philosophers challenged themselves, each other, and tended to disagree. In my opinion, those tolerant caliphs are the essence of Islam. Abu Bakr el Razi was also called a heretic for his disbelief in the idea of prophecy, yet he proclaimed himself as a muslim. People dont get to decide if your beliefs are in line with islam or not, you get to decide that.

[@endpc5166]

@@mariahanano8357 N𝜊, the Qur'an essentially says it created man to subm𝜄t to Allah's will, and the Qur'an was hardly conducive to free intellectual inquiry that modern science demands, which is why modern science developed in the West, not under Islam's oppressive rule that ended that Golden Age.

[@sadish4819]

what a voice❤

[@batosato]

Quantum mechanics and string theory is speaking the language of Ibn Sina

[@jaanjaani726]

Great program about abu sina 🌹🌹👍👍❤

[@muhammedanwaaraziz2463]

ماشاءاللّٰہ

[@shaxriniso.]

Ibn sina ,he is our generation

[@AmirAmiri-nj7xh]

He is completely Iranian and belongs to an Iranian country, but the reason he was born in Afshanah or Balkh is that at that time there were no countries with these names and these countries were considered part of the Iranian Empire. Please don't steal our culture, America and Israel have commissioned countries close to Iran to steal Iran's culture by falsifying its history, for example, Azerbaijan is trying to name our polo sport, which is for us, in its own name, and our Shirazi salad is a terrorist gang of Israel and Or Avicenna our Spain and Maulavi our Turkey, India and Afghanistan. Please research first and be alert. You are also considered to be part of the historical scope of Iranian culture, not Russian culture or English culture. Be careful not to be deceived.

[@Factsbody]

A major misconception today is that all Persians have converted to shi’ism, which absolutely shameful and false. After the creation of modern Iran the term Persian has been hijacked by Iran and all Eastern Persians were named TAJIKS. Which effectively would make all scholars of Khorasan Tajiks despite being historically identified as Persians. Tajiks of Afghanistan, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, Tashkurghan (uyghur),… are all mainly Sunnis. Also ibn Sina is originally from Balkh (Afghanistan) as his name suggests: Abu Ali al-Ḥusayn bin Abdullah ibn al-Hasan bin Ali bin Sina AL-BALKHI al-Bukhari In Khorasan region specially Iran and Afghanistan we call him Abu Ali Sina Balkhi.

[@AmirAmiri-nj7xh]

He is completely Iranian and belongs to an Iranian country, but the reason he was born in Afshanah or Balkh is that at that time there were no countries with these names and these countries were considered part of the Iranian Empire. Please don't steal our culture, America and Israel have commissioned countries close to Iran to steal Iran's culture by falsifying its history, for example, Azerbaijan is trying to name our polo sport, which is for us, in its own name, and our Shirazi salad is a terrorist gang of Israel and Or Avicenna our Spain and Maulavi our Turkey, India and Afghanistan. Please research first and be alert. You are also considered to be part of the historical scope of Iranian culture, not Russian culture or English culture. Be careful not to be deceived.

[@TheDeathopper]

We need a video on Al-Ma'arri, the medieval islamic version of Schopenhauer! Or maybe Schopenhauer was just the 19th centruy German version of Al-Ma'arri? 🤔

[@ikhwan1537]

I heard a legend that he had a sweet tooth despite living a healthy lifestyle :)

[@user-im7if5pd2h]

As a generation of his, we feel so proud of him. Abu Ali ibn Sino was uzbek man. When we look back history , we can know it. He was from Uzbekistan 🇺🇿

[@AmirAmiri-nj7xh]

He is completely Iranian and belongs to an Iranian country, but the reason he was born in Afshanah or Balkh is that at that time there were no countries with these names and these countries were considered part of the Iranian Empire. Please don't steal our culture, America and Israel have commissioned countries close to Iran to steal Iran's culture by falsifying its history, for example, Azerbaijan is trying to name our polo sport, which is for us, in its own name, and our Shirazi salad is a terrorist gang of Israel and Or Avicenna our Spain and Maulavi our Turkey, India and Afghanistan. Please research first and be alert. You are also considered to be part of the historical scope of Iranian culture, not Russian culture or English culture. Be careful not to be deceived.

[@Brainles5]

"Cogito, ergo sum" has nothing to do with what Ibn Sina was talking about. Also, Plato wrote "But if life itself is good and pleasant…and if one who sees is conscious that he sees, one who hears that he hears, one who walks that he walks and similarly for all the other human activities there is a faculty that is conscious of their exercise, so that whenever we perceive, we are conscious that we perceive, and whenever we think, we are conscious that we think, and to be conscious that we are perceiving or thinking is to be conscious that we exist..."

[@OasesOfWisdom]

I would respectfully challenge the notion that “Cogito, ergo sum” has nothing to do with Ibn Sina’s “Floating Man” thought experiment. Both ideas allude to an argument for an immaterial soul (mind-body dualism) via a type of cognitive self identification or (for Ibn Sina) in the Illuminationist school of thought “knowledge by presence”. Indeed, it’s common in the literature about Ibn Sina (and the floating man thought experiment) for Descartes’ work to be referenced due to the underlying similarities in the structure of their argument. Check out the paper “Avicenna's 'Flying Man' Argument and Descartes Cogito Ergo Sum: a Comparison” for a comparative report on the two ideas. To your latter point, you are definitely correct in pointing out that past writers and philosophers have understood and implied the existence of the soul. Indeed, in the last two video of ours we have explored as much. What Ibn Sina was a pioneer in, however, was creating a thought experiment and systematic rational argument for the existence of the soul, namely the “Floating Man” thought experiment. Importantly, it’s the structure of the thought experiment that matters here.

[@Brainles5]

@@OasesOfWisdom Plato and René are talking about consciousness or sentience. Not immortal souls in this scenario. Altough Plato did also write about that subject.

[@Hibbi83]

Very good 👍

[@ikinci4473]

Thanks.

[@semichasemicha1078]

It couldn't be possible that Dr. Ibn Sina had an extravagant life. Cause someone who is genious and wise like he was wouldn't drink or love parties cause those things would have influence his mind. He had divine insights. Divine insights wouldn't be possible with an extravagant life. If you read about Nicola Tesla you find out that he didn't marry and was vegetarian. It was known that he even didn't have an intime relationship. For me it is clear Dr. Ibn Sina lived the divine rules he was a great Sufi Master and healer may Allah/ God have mercy on him. Better to tell about his work as to present such things about his private life.

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Thank you for your comment. We have already responded to a similar comment on a different thread if you want to check that out. Basically, it is not necessary that someone who is intelligent and industrious will not commit sins such as drinking and extravagant partying. Of course, there are many examples in history of famous thinkers living similar lifestyles, mainly because of the fact that they worked in elite classes, usually within the courts of rich emperors and luxurious aristocrats, as our sources tell us Ibn Sina did. There does not exist much evidence of Ibn Sina being a Sufi healer or master. As you have pointed out, there also existed intellectuals who lived by a much more modest code. We want to show that philosophers, thinkers, scientists were all human after all and differed in temperaments and personalities just as all of us do. This may have entailed the fact that they went against their own religious rules which in itself teaches a lot of lessons. However, this should not and does not take away from whatever ideas, theories or inventions they have aided humanity with. Hope you enjoyed the video!

[@semichasemicha1078]

You have responsibility of all actions with informations you bring out to the world. So can a muslim person who is intellectual and studies think that it is ok to break islamic rules and take this as an excusing example. I agree that you and me are like normal humans who make mistakes but not Dr. Ibn Sina he was more careful than we to follow divine rules and to practise islam in way that Allah accepts.

[@BehruzbekMatniyozov-ux1qg]

Much needed information from 🇺🇿

[@allamamuhammadrazaqadri3759]

Very nice 👍

[@Artberrie_s]

Mere to dimag ke parkache ud gae...

[@zeldaaachen7200]

Thanks

[@zeldaaachen7200]

Great

[@dssrtader2427]

عندما كان العرب يطورون العلم ويبنون الحضارة قبل هجوم المغول على بغداد

[@AmirAmiri-nj7xh]

He is completely Iranian and belongs to an Iranian country, but the reason he was born in Afshanah or Balkh is that at that time there were no countries with these names and these countries were considered part of the Iranian Empire. Please don't steal our culture, America and Israel have commissioned countries close to Iran to steal Iran's culture by falsifying its history, for example, Azerbaijan is trying to name our polo sport, which is for us, in its own name, and our Shirazi salad is a terrorist gang of Israel and Or Avicenna our Spain and Maulavi our Turkey, India and Afghanistan. Please research first and be alert. You are also considered to be part of the historical scope of Iranian culture, not Russian culture or English culture. Be careful not to be deceived.

[@forrestwheeler916]

Very interesting and genius. However the final knowledge is after death . The earth is the school ground .our actions chose are destiny in equal reward or condemnation.

[@zeldaaachen7200]

Very good

[@rogerturner9086]

3:00 What is that painting?

[@yasinbuzoli6174]

SERI ZAKY - SET 7 KOLEKSI DVD

[@ahmedfaisalharis4736]

Why did you butcher the pronunciation of Setara?

[@MuhammadMikailFauzanHusn-ce9cs]

Ya rabb semoga pak agus bisa papanggih sareng ibnu sina di surga

[@baharzia1450]

He was from balkh in Afghanistan

[@AlphaPlanet8]

He was Persian and Afghanistan was part of Iran used to be called khorasan

[@AmirAmiri-nj7xh]

He is completely Iranian and belongs to an Iranian country, but the reason he was born in Afshanah or Balkh is that at that time there were no countries with these names and these countries were considered part of the Iranian Empire. Please don't steal our culture, America and Israel have commissioned countries close to Iran to steal Iran's culture by falsifying its history, for example, Azerbaijan is trying to name our polo sport, which is for us, in its own name, and our Shirazi salad is a terrorist gang of Israel and Or Avicenna our Spain and Maulavi our Turkey, India and Afghanistan. Please research first and be alert. You are also considered to be part of the historical scope of Iranian culture, not Russian culture or English culture. Be careful not to be deceived.

[@HayyanKhan-tk6ms]

Iranian Scientist gone unrecognised

[@pietromaximoff4365]

Love from Uzbekistan 💙

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Love from Australia ❤️

[@AmirAmiri-nj7xh]

He is completely Iranian and belongs to an Iranian country, but the reason he was born in Afshanah or Balkh is that at that time there were no countries with these names and these countries were considered part of the Iranian Empire. Please don't steal our culture, America and Israel have commissioned countries close to Iran to steal Iran's culture by falsifying its history, for example, Azerbaijan is trying to name our polo sport, which is for us, in its own name, and our Shirazi salad is a terrorist gang of Israel and Or Avicenna our Spain and Maulavi our Turkey, India and Afghanistan. Please research first and be alert. You are also considered to be part of the historical scope of Iranian culture, not Russian culture or English culture. Be careful not to be deceived.

[@pietromaximoff4365]

@@AmirAmiri-nj7xh he was sunni not shia. All of turks was sunni

[@noahhelsee1340]

what a prodigy

[@saadmohammadjakaria]

🇧🇩🤲 Alhumdulillah Rabbi-jidni-ilma..

[@meenshneez830]

Could you please share the script of this video? I need it to translate the content in different language for a friend.

[@zeldaaachen7200]

Good

[@zeldaaachen7200]

✊

[@DND480]

He was Uzbek

[@mojtabarafizadah7702]

Uzbeks are mongol invaders not Persian not Iranian he was Persian and wrote in Farsi

[@DND480]

@@mojtabarafizadah7702 Uzbek not mongol ideot Uzbek Turks ibn sina was Uzbek

[@user-zp7fx4gy4u]

The Uzbeks are Mongols. Ibn Sina's lack of writing was Persian

[@user-zp7fx4gy4u]

@@mojtabarafizadah7702 👏❤👌

[@halaldunya918]

That's a modern ethnicity, this guy was something else.

[@KygoCalvinHarris-xu4kv]

I recognize Salvador Dali painting

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Yep!

[@kakooly]

One of the many Persian/Iranian/Iranic contributions to the world .. Majority of the great scientists of the so called "golden age" were Iranian/IRANIC/Persians Thank you for this video 🙏

[@ahmadfrhan5265]

not true

[@ahmadfrhan5265]

he is Uzbek a central Asian and not Persian

[@kakooly]

@@ahmadfrhan5265 Oh shut up ! Here we go with the ignorant trolls of the internet 🤣🤣 he's of IRANIC origin ... He was definitely persian his family was from Balkh .. there was no place called Uzbekistan (established I think 1991?) at that time it was ALL IRANIC and language was Persian and Arabic and still today genetically you are at least half Iranian but you lost it all to Turks, moghols and Russians who forced language and some cultural changes on you ... Even back then this area was under Iranian rule and still today all historical signs of many IRANIAN influence is very visible there such as samarqand and Bokhara etc , two thousand years before Christ first people that step foot there were of IRANIC origins and before mixing with turkik/moghok tribes people of that area were all Iranian.. and still many Persian speaking people living there . So don't be divisive Ahole ! We are like brothers .. Mr Sina was just born there to a Persian family from balkh .. there was no Afghanistan or Uzbekistan etc all that area was under IRANIAN rule and influence. If you can't make your own history and identity, don't steal others and don't repeat this uninformed "opinion" among scholars .. Mr Sina is known to the world (to the educated informed society) as a Persian . Best of wishes . We still love ALL IRANIC lands and people, and one day we hope to unite all Aryan people including Uzbekistan! People of so called Uzbekistan are very nice and friendly and love Iranian people as Iranians love them .. I doubt if you're truly from that area probably you're of turkik origin which seems more likely due to your opinions and attitude.. 🤣❤️😘

[@ahmadfrhan5265]

@@kakooly such a pathetic reply with inferiority complex. Persians aren't even majority in their own lands. Uzbekistan is a central Asian Turkic land even before Islam. I don't deny the mixing ,but he wasn't ethically Persian. share your evidences. Was Bakhri persian too? even last Iranian president was of Uzbek background also , why you hate Islam and muslims? why you believe all Muslim scholars were Persians? did the persian ones have the same exact worldview of them being persian and not Muslim? if yes share your evidences and you win and I will apologize. listen, I will say this right now. you have no argument against Islam and I dare you to pin it finally, you are the one stealing other's history. this is Islamic history not Persian and Ibn Sina was not Persian

[@ahmadfrhan5265]

@@kakooly read ^ stop emojis and be mindful and reply with evidences and background knowledge. let's talk and I dare you to prove any of your claims

[@ConfusedCrocodileHiding-tg2kt]

Ibn sina would not have drank because he was a good Muslim as many sources say

[@MehdiProductions]

good stuff

[@thestraightpath.5036]

He was pretty outgoing, he loves to party, drink and be surrounded by women like all elites in that time. It should be noted that Ibn Sina was talented in medicine and tried to invent a particular model of Islamic philosophy. However, he deviated from the right path and became an atheist like all scholars who gave importance to philosophy. This is due to a simple reason, Islam as a religion has answered all hard questions. So ,there is no need to go to philosophy to get answers.

[@powerball200]

wasnt he muslim?

[@zeldaaachen7200]

😍

[@Fawad.ANizamani]

What does it mean "universe was created out of time" ?

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Great question! So, it means that Ibn Sina believed that there was no such thing as time without the universe because if there was time, it would limit God. So, he deduced the universe *always* had existed (it did not begin to exist) but was still dependent on God.

[@Fawad.ANizamani]

Thank you 💟

[@sarasara-yo9rf]

He was Persian first of all, then Muslim because of the invasion of Islam in Iran. Persian people were not Muslim before Invasion of the Arabs.

[@KhanzVlogz007]

So what

[@sarasara-yo9rf]

@@KhanzVlogz007 Muslim people and Islamic countries are lying by saying he was an Arab.

[@pushiman]

I like this channel. Let me know if you need help promoting it. I can give a shout out

[@OasesOfWisdom]

A shout out would be much appreciated! And we're pleased to hear you enjoy our content. Means a lot

[@pushiman]

@@OasesOfWisdom amazing, i will update you on the shout out in short inshallah

[@pushiman]

@@OasesOfWisdom asalaamu alaykum brother. I have good news. I have scheduled a promotional post on the 16th of january at 08:00am London time. It should go live at that time inshallah

[@OasesOfWisdom]

I've added you to the recommended channels on our home page. Thanks for the shout out!

[@pushiman]

@@OasesOfWisdom thats is amazing man, honestly cant thank you enough

[@zeldaaachen7200]

🌄❤️

[@muadhrehman4155]

Al ghazali next 👀 👀

[@OasesOfWisdom]

We are covering thinkers in chronological order so there are a few more to cover before we go onto Al Ghazali. But we will get to him inshallah !

[@muadhrehman4155]

@@OasesOfWisdom inshallah, Any clue what the list entails? You’re doing amazing work btw keep it up, truly informative, inshallah we get to see some extensive videos like the ones on from ‘fall of civilisation’ but with a philosophical Islamic twist 👍

[@ZarasthuraGyattt]

Do Mulla Sadra al-Shirazi

[@stiffy420]

that picture of "a couple" when u say "when your father and mother have met" are siblings. what else are totally wrong in this? lets see..

[@OasesOfWisdom]

We have replied to another commented about the usage of American gothic. The intention of the painted and common caption of the painted was husband and wife. But his mother was too frail to pose for long periods of time so he used his sister as a stand in.

[@Uz_clips]

Ibn Sina from Bukhara current Uzbekistan territory

[@OasesOfWisdom]

Yep :)

[@AmirAmiri-nj7xh]

He is completely Iranian and belongs to an Iranian country, but the reason he was born in Afshanah or Balkh is that at that time there were no countries with these names and these countries were considered part of the Iranian Empire. Please don't steal our culture, America and Israel have commissioned countries close to Iran to steal Iran's culture by falsifying its history, for example, Azerbaijan is trying to name our polo sport, which is for us, in its own name, and our Shirazi salad is a terrorist gang of Israel and Or Avicenna our Spain and Maulavi our Turkey, India and Afghanistan. Please research first and be alert. You are also considered to be part of the historical scope of Iranian culture, not Russian culture or English culture. Be careful not to be deceived.

[@zeldaaachen7200]

당신은

[@5kphz]

do u remember my name :O

[@yasinbuzoli6174]

Jane Addams Takip et (12) ZAKY'NİN MÜZİK MÜZİĞİ (CD) - ONE4KIDS ZAKY'NİN MÜZİK MÜZİĞİ (CD) - ONE4KIDS 0:11 0:12

[@abidalwi1067]

Bug has been compromised at 0:45

[@OasesOfWisdom]

What do you mean?

[@VictorKX]

No mention that he is persian but in your alkindi video you mentioned his tribe

[@AmirAmiri-nj7xh]

He is completely Iranian and belongs to an Iranian country, but the reason he was born in Afshanah or Balkh is that at that time there were no countries with these names and these countries were considered part of the Iranian Empire. Please don't steal our culture, America and Israel have commissioned countries close to Iran to steal Iran's culture by falsifying its history, for example, Azerbaijan is trying to name our polo sport, which is for us, in its own name, and our Shirazi salad is a terrorist gang of Israel and Or Avicenna our Spain and Maulavi our Turkey, India and Afghanistan. Please research first and be alert. You are also considered to be part of the historical scope of Iranian culture, not Russian culture or English culture. Be careful not to be deceived.

[@Mrkabul10]

For your information and for whom they says he was uzbek. he was born in afshona in today’s uzbekstan. He was a dari persian speaker his father was from Old balkh afghanistan. And he is officially belongs to afghanistan 🇦🇫 rumi abu ali sina imam abu hanifa did so much to serve humanity. We had so much big names alongside them in the history of Afghanistan ❤️ The full name is abu ali sina balkhi. He belongs to all world for what he did for medical medical science❤️

[@mashhurarahimova6000]

He belongs to bukharian tajiks not afgans

[@AmirAmiri-nj7xh]

He is completely Iranian and belongs to an Iranian country, but the reason he was born in Afshanah or Balkh is that at that time there were no countries with these names and these countries were considered part of the Iranian Empire. Please don't steal our culture, America and Israel have commissioned countries close to Iran to steal Iran's culture by falsifying its history, for example, Azerbaijan is trying to name our polo sport, which is for us, in its own name, and our Shirazi salad is a terrorist gang of Israel and Or Avicenna our Spain and Maulavi our Turkey, India and Afghanistan. Please research first and be alert. You are also considered to be part of the historical scope of Iranian culture, not Russian culture or English culture. Be careful not to be deceived.

[@user-xh4lx4yz8c]

Ibn sina shei🗿

[@zeldaaachen7200]

🧝🏼🧚🏼‍♂️🙏🏻

[@AmirAmiri-nj7xh]

He is completely Iranian and belongs to an Iranian country, but the reason he was born in Afshanah or Balkh is that at that time there were no countries with these names and these countries were considered part of the Iranian Empire. Please don't steal our culture, America and Israel have commissioned countries close to Iran to steal Iran's culture by falsifying its history, for example, Azerbaijan is trying to name our polo sport, which is for us, in its own name, and our Shirazi salad is a terrorist gang of Israel and Or Avicenna our Spain and Maulavi our Turkey, India and Afghanistan. Please research first and be alert. You are also considered to be part of the historical scope of Iranian culture, not Russian culture or English culture. Be careful not to be deceived.