Idol Judges, pinaalalahanan ang performance ni Sheland | Live Round | Idol Philippines 2019

[@markdavidcaipang5197]

That was too painful. I admire how she composed and kept her knees after taking those shattering comments. Keep it up sheland. 🙂 one day you"ll be appreciated on a much bigger stage.

[@simpforshon]

The painful part here is nag-focus sila s negative side.. No signs of motivation at all.

[@KiyoshiFlores]

Yung sobrang hulog na hulog ako sa perf nya tapos wala man lang positive comment si vice at reg. Siguro may mali na sa tenga ko.

[@saldecabahit]

For me it was stunning, perfect, and sobrang tagos sa puso ang pagkanta nya. Na gulat ako sa mga comments ng mga judges na hinde naman relevant sa performance ni Shelland. Sobrang subjective lang talaga kung sino mananalo dito.

[@femaleg4l546]

may favorite sila ehh si zephanie but si zephanie ihate her voice bcoz mas puro birit siya

[@mercy_ahgastayonce]

Si james lang nga yung nagbigay ng positive comment pero yung ibang judges...... Thank you James sa pagmotivate sa kanya 😊😘 And also Moira

[@nickireginebey9361]

Kasi siya walang alam sa music

[@mhonzregis3649]

respect kay regine . pero ang ganda nung simula ni sheland on record simula palang emotional na *opinion , great job sheland

[@FTReviews]

hindi nya kasi alam ang kanta hahahaha...

[@nickireginebey9361]

F & T Reviews so? Anung connection nun? Kinakain parin nung contestant yung mga words lol sobra emote hindi maiintindihan

[@mrmichaelydia]

She really gives justice to the song... don’t know but the emotions and her diction and tone was very clear like crystal 🤷🏻‍♂️ they just have their favorite already that’s why her outstanding performance don’t matter to them even if it’s near to perfection...

[@heyitsme5904]

*PUMUNTA KO DITO PAGKATAPOS NG PERFORMANCE NI VICE SA IDOL PH...SANA MAN LANG NI APPLY NI VICE SA SARILI NYAYUNG COMMENT NYA KAY SHELAND 😂✌*

[@bassoumnezar8348]

So sad

[@bassoumnezar8348]

I love sheland

[@flakemist9667]

Hndi nmn po sya singer. Performer po sya

[@raymond8967]

@@flakemist9667 haha, which means sana di rin siya pakitang gilas magpuna sa singer 😬😬😬

[@flakemist9667]

@@raymond8967 kaya nga judge diba. Define. Ikaw ba ang management para questionin bakit qualified sya as judge? Eh ikaw nga kahit 1% hndi ka qualified

[@ronnieborlasa2466]

Buti pa si james reid positive mgcomment

[@skyechwhkehbzb123]

A big yuck to judges who don't value how the contestants feel

[@mrmichaelydia]

Sha tatlo sa kanila hindi alam ang sandwich feedbacks .! Para sakin ang mali is yung pandinig nila 😅

[@berneytv2181]

Skl. Manood ka ng Kpop Star. MAS malala comment dun, I mean grabe mga comment haha

[@todorokikun2750]

@@berneytv2181 pero magaling naman si Sheland LMFAO

[@rudzestase7474]

Mga bingi ata kayu....

[@earljavier9560]

Dito ako nagsawang manuod ng idol. After ng gngwa nila kay sheland. after that amazing performance tpos nilait lait lng.

[@jessietu3621]

Ewan ko sa mga judges na to! Grabe kyo kay Sheland! Real talk lng ah.. yung mga performances lng nya ung mga inuulit ulit ko.. 👊👊👊

[@bassoumnezar8348]

Yeh me too

[@jobdizon2339]

Judges have their points. Pero ang galing galing ni Sheland huhuhu. Dipa rin ako makapag move on 😩

[@deymepilon7630]

I'm a big fan of the judges lalo na kay vice pero hindi parin ako maka move on na tinanggal nila si sheland dahil sa performance niyang ito, i love her so much,alam nating lahat na magaling siya at deserve niyang manalo,siya ang bias ko jan,huhu mag 2022 na pero di parin tlg ako mala move on,YOU DESERVE BETTER SHELAND ILY!!😚💗

[@joshl.gcortez3627]

Ouch! Vice... your comments, pwede naman hindi ipoint out ung sa beauty contest nya. Nakakagigil lang kasi mas maganda performance nila compare to Miguel and Elle (sila sana natanggal). May favoritism kayo, for sure si Zephani ang panalo jan, obvious naman kahit may sablay si Zep, standing ovation pa din sa kanila.

[@Larreisand]

Personal na masyado yung “background check” na beauty pageant na awrahan. It’s subjective na siguro at hindi na dapat sinasabi in a nakaka-insulto na paraan. Sino tayo para humusga if anu ang fake from authentic emotions/projections. Sana nagfocus din sila sa musicality na nagawa naman ni Sheland.

[@jameswilfreda.corral3679]

Zeph deserves it. Tapos.

[@todorokikun2750]

@@jameswilfreda.corral3679 LMFAO

[@user-pp1it6qh3d]

Si miguel every week palaging inconsistent ng performances pero maganda lagi comments ni regine sakanya lol a big SCAM

[@mariamarisacourtney3455]

Gigil ako ni Regine dito

[@heyitsjuri]

Lol my mom is a fan of Miguel that she told me and Dad to vote for him. Pasensya na po sa nanay ko.

[@bokyo1881]

Sheland is different from the rest. She's like more on theater singer like Lea Salonga that's why Regine is always more negative to Sheland. Lea always said a negative comment at the voice about more on sigaw song which is about Regine. 😄😄

[@ytchannel613]

"Regine is always more negative to Regine?" ANU DAW TEH

[@bokyo1881]

@@ytchannel613 I think your common sense was just very low level or you just stupid for having a youtube account to understand a simple common mistake in comments in social media. 😂😂

[@ytchannel613]

@@bokyo1881 see, you edited and corrected your original comment! I got the point of your message despite broken grammar but you originally typed "Regine is more negative to Regine" so I was like HUH?????

[@bokyo1881]

@@ytchannel613 well, again common sense. You don't have to say " see " because obviously on my comment I didn't deny it. What do you want me to say? thank you? LOL. And don't explain you get it, becuase I reply my comment like what you did. So don't feel bullied on your own way. Haha, wrong gramar? You telling your self, even in tagalog.😂😂

[@talaveramicaela_tm1a422]

As sheland said, she gave her best, she gave it all in her performance last week. But, hindi lang talaga nila na-appeciate si sheland though, may favoritism sila. 'Wag na tayo maglokohan, hindi maiiwasan sa isang kompetisyon na walang dayaan/ magkaroon ng favoritism. Wala kay sheland ang problema, kasi alam ko na binigay niya na lahat. I know sheland. Pero okay nmn na, kasi ganon talaga e. Hindi nmn porket natanggal si sheland sa idol ph, she can't be star or an idol anymore. Sheland doesn't need to prove to everyone that she can be a star. Because since day 1, she's like a star, convert into a diamond. Sheland's shining bright like a diamond. She always make sure that, she's always keep shining. Sheland as it finest!!💙💙

[@imspectator6275]

Normal lang yan kasi nga comment pero ang mali lang sa mga judges puro negative comments wala man lang positive comments. Nung si Dan maraming mga flats pero todo appreciate pa rin sila. Parang pinahiya lang nila si sheland sa madla. Dapat magcomment sila in a nice way hindi porket di nila gusto ganun ganun lang sila magcomment.

[@rickydesuyo5656]

IDOL PHILIPPINES IS A BIG FAIL, compare sa THE VOICE OF THE PHILIPPINES nung unang season

[@heyitsme5904]

True

[@wilhelmmandac9863]

Siyemore The Voice pa din best judges haha

[@RaymondUliamotMonayPutok]

Walang perpektong singers. Kahit professional singers nga, natitinik sa sariling boses nila.. kayo tong over magcomments sa performance ni sheland.. mas deserve pa nila sheland at fatima mapabilang sa top 4..

[@owenopena1334]

yes deserve nila, pero kulang sa support ng mga fanatics.

[@ellieprint]

@@owenopena1334 gurl mababa din binigay sa kanila ng mga judges so wala talaga silang laban kahit mataas ang votes nila

[@johndymalsit7461]

@@owenopena1334 Sobrang bab siguro ng nakuha nilang scores sa judges.

[@jundelacruz]

Totally agree, though people could have tried harder voting for Sheland and Fatima last week but failed. Sheland and Fatima were the ones who are very comfortable on stage and on cam. They truly deserved to be in the Top 4, and I made a comment on it a few weeks back together with Lance and Lucas.

[@janameamo6039]

Siguro if yung mga legit na singers at composers ang judges ng Idol ph, mas masayang panuorin. Halatang may paborito. yak.

[@johnrobbyabanilla5593]

grabe kau mga judges..inapload q pa nga video ni sheland dhil napagaling nia..

[@HowTF123]

Magaling si Sheland. Ssshhh mga judges! 😤

[@bassoumnezar8348]

Yeh😔😔💔💔

[@mariannemagadan]

I'm literally crying rn hearing the judgements towards sheland, especially vice.

[@patrome2272]

Tama na po nasaktan na ung bata eh sa mga cnbi nyo....one word is enough! Ang dami nyo cnabi tagos na tagos! 😥😢

[@MarkAndrewAlap]

OBVIOUSLY HINDI ALAM NI REGINE YUNG KANTA. SHELAND IS AMAZINGGGG SHE DESERVED TO STAY

[@nickireginebey9361]

Um so what if she doesn’t know? She’s right respect the queen lmao regine has been reigning for more than 30 years so siya ang pinaka credible mag judge

[@MarkAndrewAlap]

@@nickireginebey9361 pinagsasabi mo dyan?! Don't get me wrong, I love Regine as well pero totoo namang hindi nya alam yung kanta nung time na yan. Sinong may sabing hindi sya credible mag judge? Knowing the song full well makes a lot of difference lalo sa pag judge, basic naman yun at no brainer???

[@-freakingaming-9809]

@@MarkAndrewAlap Uhm I think this was a bit late. But I believe Regine was right. Ang problema kasi, walang earpiece ang mga judges kaya di nila marinig yung umpisa ni Sheland. Kung titingnan mong mabuti sa umpisa, closed yung vowels ni Sheland para nga naman maramdaman natin yung kanta but may tendency kasi na makain yung letra at yun nga yung nangyari. Pero dahil wala ngang earpiece di nila narinig. Iba kasi naririnig natin pag nanonood tayo ng TV kaysa pag nandon tayo sa mismong venue. Ps: Walang kinalaman ang hindi alam ang kanta sa pinagsasabi ni Regine.

[@rockyduck5347]

Mark I think agree ako sa critism ni regine una narinig ko din ang original at ito pero syempre Hindi din ako nagbabase sa original but ang masakit nyan is talagang kinakain nya ung mga words nya sa Simula nakaka relate kasi meron din namn akong musical background sa mga ganito so bilang singer ang diction ay napaka importante yan Hindi lang ung vibrato or flat or sharp pero is a sa mga importante is yung Diction but overall I like her voice tho... So regine is right kasi only mga advance at talagang totoong musicians lang makaka pansin nun amazing job from regine Velasquez talagang veteran sya without a doubt that's my opinion only as a Singer lang.

[@haydieulanimo7446]

oo nga wh parang may problema sa tenga mga judges.

[@karlienmontemayor8813]

Best performance ever!❤️

[@harryjonascruz8103]

Poor commentaries.. esp from Vice, non sense at all.

[@mildreddelrosario4565]

I think the judges were correct but they should tell the advice in a nice way... And for sheland don't take it as negative...you have to make it your strenght and don't stop there because I know you can do more like what they say about you....God bless

[@MsGene38]

I hate your comments miss judges. maybe you guys need a hearing aid lol Grrr

[@jundelacruz]

I am and will always be a fan of Sheland. However, I was really and honestly worried with the last performance mainly on how she sang the song as the words were not clear enough from the beginning towards halfway of the song. This was taken advantage by the judges to give their hurtful comments, these are not even constructive at all. These comments would make somebody walk way from humiliation, but Sheland was keeping her composure while you can see from her eyes that she was really hurt. What I still do not understand why Regine really looked and sounded irritated. She did the same to Leann (the same sound saga - edited). I am not 100% percent convinced that she could be a judge as I felt that she is always comparing her younger self to these new young artists. The judge with the white wig even mentioned of beauty contests experience, WTH. He is not even capable of carrying a tune. Can the judges give some (if not more) motivation to these young artists? For cheesecake, she is only 17. They have been conditioning the minds of the viewers that this was Zephanie's win, and to be fair with Zephanie she did an outstanding cover of SG's song the other week. However, Zephanie's cover of Gary V's Huwag Ka Nang Umiyak was not better, it did not suit her voice. I had to agree, these 2 judges Regine and the one with white wig focused more on the negative. You can do better than that. What really bothers me is that this was not the Idol show that most people accustomed to. This is a low budget show with poor lighting, big screen as a backdrop which looks useless, some annoying judges and with foreign songs hardly featured on live shows.

[@elymarbacquiano3005]

Mas overdoings ang mga comments nyu..

[@FRIENDSKEEPER]

Hahahaah oo nga... wawa naman C shelland ,, after sana ng negative a bit of positivity lg sana kahit konti...

[@elymarbacquiano3005]

@@FRIENDSKEEPERnapaka unprofessional kasi.. Tinawanan pa ni song bird. C lea nga international singer, wlang negative comnts pagdating ng mga near to grand finals. Eh sa idol ph? Ews. Paborito baby..haha

[@mia06alerta]

@@elymarbacquiano3005 KASALANAN NYO RIN YAN NA HINDI SIYA NAKASAMA KASI HINDI NIYO RIN BINOTO. HINDI LANG NAMAN JUDGES ANG BUMUBUTO EH. PUBLIC RIN

[@elymarbacquiano3005]

@@mia06alerta excuse me.. Binoto nmin. Syempre malaking bahagi parin yung points na binigay ng judges.. Kung mababang puntos lang binigay nila kay sheland laking epekto yun. Imagine 98% sa 50+%. Nakakasuka.

[@Larreisand]

Ang nakakapagtaka din, musically/technically she served the song well... walang sabit ang mga “birit parts” of the song; pero hindi yun pinansin nung ibang judges. Nag-focus sila sa awra, fake body/facial projection which is subjective. Magulo daw yung atake sa beginning of the song due to over-emoting. Hindi sila natuwa sa pagkaka-awit ni Sheland; pero pag sa iba kahit ma-out of tune, off-key or wrong timing... puring puri paren nila...

[@ronikkacalantog]

Hindi ata nila alam yung kanta. Pero ang galing!

[@nhelmchen7210]

Aminin natin alam ni Sheland na may looks sya. Yung kinapupuri sa kanya mula simula.. nadala nya sa ulo nya. Mas pinag buti ang pagpapakita kung gaano sya ka charming. Na overdo naman talaga si Sheland. The way she smile.. napapa sobra.. lagi kc yun ang puri sa kanya mula umpisa. Agree ako sa mga judges.. may fake na emotions. Let us learn to respect other's opinion.. pagbutihin na lang sa susunod. It's never too late. Goodluck!

[@ry-anneathena154]

Magaling naman si sheland pero kinulang... kung icompare yung performance nila ni zeph mas mgaling tlga yung kay zeph... kaya tama zeph deserves it..

[@admin357]

USE THEIR COMMENTS AS YOUR STEPPING STONE AND PROVE THEM WRONG!!!GO ROCK THE WORLD GIRL!

[@sealed478]

I came back here after Regine and Vice's harsh comments to Elle. Grabe talaga. Pag di nila bet ang contestant, sobrang harsh ng comment kahit magaling naman ang performance. Pero yung ibang contestants, porket "gwapo" daw, kahit weak, sobrang positive.

[@arneljeffreyonate5120]

Napunta ka dito galing Tiktok HAHAHA grabeh comments ng judges juskooooooo

[@romeltolentino1906]

2020 na but im still asking why? hndi ako singer hndi ako magaling kumanta pero bakit di daw nila naintindihan eh halos kahit di ako marunong about music na feel ko yung kanta and that is the power of a good singer.. hndi lahat ng singer meron nun.. haysss Ganda ng perfoemance but nevermind nalang nga nakaka hayssss nalang talaga sa mga comments ng judges..

[@marlagunzad250]

Ito Yong pinakamasakit na comments na narinig ko lalo na si vice bata lang yan wag naman ganyan 17 years old lang yan

[@beybieldyey5754]

negative remarks from each judge: regine - d marinig first part, over-emoting james - she could've done more dw moira - oversinging, she doesnt have to give more dw, wants to see just "sheland" and nothing else in short "fake" vice - wag dw umawra indirectly saying fake ung style nia, nothing remarkable s performance except s birit Kklurkey. Medyo contradicting ung sinabi ni Moira and James dto inferness ha. Tas ngkkaimpluwensyahan na sila ng comments, by saying "i agree with " pero iba iba nmn sila ng pinopoint out. Halatang mema lng uy.. So ano tlg judges? Malamang, nguluhan n ung bata sainyo, pati si Billy na kinilabutan. 🤛

[@FTReviews]

hindi nila alam ang kanta, at luma na ang style ni regine at vice, kaya hindi naka relate...at kelangan nilang tanggalin si sheland para manalo si zeph...i want zeph to win, pero sobrang halata na wala talagang babae na pinasok sa top 5 at top 3, kundi si zeph lang.

[@beybieldyey5754]

F & T Reviews para sure at easy win.

[@reginaneomibuban1408]

loveu ate shelandddddd,nakita ko na yan si ate sheland sa robinsons,sobrang ganda ng boses nya tsaka super gandaaaa din

[@earljavier9560]

Nabingi ang mga judges nung mga time nato. As in anyare....

[@crislerlee6487]

Just be thankful you're better than vice when it comes to singing period. 👌❤️

[@judeamar5212]

Grabe mga judge na to,,, napakaGaling dito ni Sheland tapos on the end of her performance eh parang di nila naappreciate😢😢😢. Syempre tungkol sa HEARTBREAK yung kanta kaya ganun😥😥😥, buti pa sa James Reid

[@steffyiquina2748]

Magaling si Sheland

[@levygeocado1407]

Okay lang mag comment.. Iba-iba rin tlaga ang mga tao. Pero ang natutunan ko pwede ka magcomment or magsabi ng opinion mo ng tama ung pagconstruct. Pano, ko ba sasabihin? Kahit negative sya may mga tamang term na pwedeng gamitin. Lalo na kung nasa national tv. Just saying lang.

[@gailramos2359]

Nakakaasar talaga balikan tong mga comment nila.

[@reginaneomibuban1408]

hahaha 2020 still watching

[@johnmark1264]

D best judges is in tawag ng tanghalan.!

[@Vansrobinson1416]

Asan na SI sheland? Nka subscribed pa Naman Ako sa utube nyA :( . Plss come back we want to hear your beautiful voice sheland :) we love u

[@judefrancisco1463]

Daming magagaling na netizens ah. Sana next season kayo na mag judge wahahaha.

[@avenpelogo2532]

Jude Francisco 😂😂😂😂tama cla nlang mas msgaling yata cla 😂

[@sedatedsound412]

Thrash comments it did not even resonated on her performance at all. All I saw was raw emotions. Tbh, hindi na kasi sakop ng generation nila yung kung ano ang nafefeel natin ngayon.

[@mariamarisacourtney3455]

Ako yong nasaktan sa comments nyo ni Sheland tapos sinabi ko makarma din kayo?so ngayon 🤣nangyari na Vice🤣Regine🤣Moira 🤣wala na kayong trabaho 😂

[@EE-be2jy]

magaling si sheland...deserve nya sa top 4..may mga favoritism tlaga tong mga judges na ito..

[@femaleg4l546]

truth

[@FTReviews]

REGINE!!! Ba't mo naman ako bin-lock sa IG mo. Sinabi ko lang naman sayo na mag-aral ka ng bagong music style at makinig ng mga 2019 songs para alam mo ang mga sinasabi mo pag nagco-comment ka.

[@beybieldyey5754]

F & T Reviews hahahaha d nia matanggap ktotohanan n d nia Kaya appreciate ang current music genre

[@princessb.moratalla2567]

Dapat mga judges na lang nae-eliminate eh. 😒

[@Shirana1Hit0]

Hahahaha true!

[@mitchdeasis8045]

Idol ko si vice at regine pero nung narinig ko kung panu nila laitin ang performance ni sheland na sobrang sakit akala mo hindi bata ang sinasabihan nila,.nakakawala sila ng respeto,jusko awang awa ako kay sheland..until now pagnapapanood ko nasasaktan pa din ako para kay sheland,dont worry sheland may plano si god sayo,

[@maureenjonacoballes5827]

aarrrggggg!!! andami ko gustong sabhin kaso ndi ko masabi hahahahaha mga nyemas!😅

[@simpforshon]

The only good thing here is 3:59 sobrang ganda nia magsmile nakakatunaw. 😍

[@arvieteevee638]

Sheland is verygood singer

[@zynxh9697]

I feel bad coz I see that shaland really hurt to those comments. But for me you did great 😩❤️

[@thalia9291]

memang mga judges

[@anotherbeautifulday_emon]

I don’t agree with regine lol. I could hear her clearly.

[@GinoongLunaVlogs]

Hanggang ngayon naiinis parin ako. 🤦🏻‍♂️ Halatang naiiyak na si Sheland kasi alam niyang binigay niya yung best niya and in-apply niya 'yon pero 'di parin na appreciate lol. 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@arjaycarsola48]

Jusq , si regine kasi mahina pandinig e , si vice naman kabayo kaya ganon hahalol

[@gspotlight04]

Wth is Regines comment 🙄🤦🏻‍♂️.. I felt her emotions singing the song. That cover was the best Ive seen on YT💯👏🏼

[@jamaicagarcia4864]

Ikaw nga puro tili lang na parang naiipitan lagi !!! Hahahah

[@thalia9291]

tas sobrsng sugarcoated ng comments nyo kay elle last week di nyo nga maupload vid niya lOL

[@PolmartPH]

Na upload yun boss. Pero dinelete after an hour.

[@thalia9291]

@@PolmartPH that's even worse HAHAHAH

[@danielajadedetalolancaon3034]

True, they even took down Miguel's video siguro kasi malaki din ang backlash. The problem with the judges is they don't consider the person's talent and they are not very forgiving, pag sumablay yung magaling tanggal agad pero yung mga puchu puchu lang andyan pa din.

[@thalia9291]

@@danielajadedetalolancaon3034 and i think kaya naalis si fatima and sheland kasi alam ng judges na threat na sila sa mga fave nila? kasi pagaling lang ng pagaling si sheland every episode tas si fatima nag eexplore lang ng ibang genre e pero obviously better parin

[@danielajadedetalolancaon3034]

@@thalia9291 yep. Personally, I like Zeph and I like her enough to believe na kahit magtapat pa silang tatlo may ibubuga siya. It's sad lang kasi hindi fair. I hate to compare but if you watch the earlier seasons of American Idol, makikita mo talaga na walang favoritism at isesave pa nila yung tingin nilang talented. Tapos Idol PH nganga hahaha

[@charmainegonzaga392]

magaling si sheland sa lahat in terms of technicality even kay zeph. Pero alam niyo naman ang abs mga bess! Scripted na yan! Haha

[@louielayson22]

hindi awra ang tinutukoy ni regine, vice, yung emotion.. jusko lord.. hahaha

[@Mimi-sb4ex]

She's good

[@FRIENDSKEEPER]

Nagandahan talga ako sa performance clear namn yung lyrics ni sheland baka may problema lg sa audio ng mga judges pero sa youtube maganda namn... maybe iba tlga cguru pag LIVE ... Ganda naman ng emotional singing style nya.. but grabe di cla nagandahan sa performance eh di walang wala na akong K hehe.. my goshhh ..

[@erikavanessapuzon4840]

Sana di na maulit to ngayong season 2

[@nydiavaldez3341]

Anu ba yan regine hindi mu ba ramdam ung emotion ng pagkanta nya she nailed it para saken magaling ka sheland.... Balang araw siaikat ka din

[@ronelquilla5678]

best rendetion ever

[@deanpaule.quirit7438]

Hindi naman kayo sobrang kagalingan. My God! Edit: REGINE, MOIRA, JAMES, AND MOIRA. Wag na kayong mag judge next season, if meron man. Please lang.

[@shellamariemartinitourotga7524]

Galing nmqn po

[@benjamindelacruz866]

I agree that judges have favorites. That's why people say that abs is a biased tv station. Sheland and Fatima is far better than Miguel and Zephanie.

[@gachaanima3686]

Nasa Tao ang final Voting. Respect Judges decision...

[@theborschannel8220]

naguluhan ka sa kanta Ms.Regine?kasi kami alam namin hahahahaa. I really appreciate the song Sheland. Talagang emotional yung Kanta. naku nman. yung mga judges tlaga.....hindi kami nguluhan sa kanta ang ganda nga eh.

[@kapiranggot1339]

Billy: (I should have not said that..) lols

[@maretispapasin516]

Kaganda ng performance ie

[@jessejames268]

Buti pa si billy at james na appreciate s sheland

[@johnmardato-onbaldo1331]

I find it a little bit rude yung sinabi ni Vice Ganda kay Sheland kasi nag judge na wala namang kinalaman sa Reality Talent Competion Show hindi naman ito fashion show or pageant ang unfair lang which is mali to the point na pwede masaktan yung contestant pero I am just sharing my thoughts and not judging him napansin ko lang naman :D

[@emnstatv6772]

Para kasi syang Si Morissette kumanta kung si Morissette Over Sing sya naman ay Over Emotions

[@warish2584]

Ewan ko sa Inyo..sheland is the idol Phil’s for me

[@FRIENDSKEEPER]

Ouch!!!!... c james lg ng positive comment .. kahit papano it helps

[@reynoldi.vicente7770]

Ang galing ni Sheland

[@aljanoticsay7079]

Kamote kayong mga judges...

[@rianrenzo8985]

Hnd lang alam ni Vice saka Regine ung kanta.. Baka sakaling pag nalaman na nya tapos sumaktong nabroken hearted na naman xa, baka xa ang umawra habang kanta ang 'hindi na nga' hahaha Looking forward to it!!!

[@arellanokhalid1622]

IBA TALAGA PAG SI SARAH GERONIMO YUNG JUDGE..MAS MAY MAKUKUHA KANG POSITIVE..PERO PAG NAKIKITA NYANG MAY NEGATIVE.HINDI NYA YUN SINASABI ACTUALLY SIYA PA NGA NAG AADVICE..

[@chrissean4911]

What happened to their taste? For Regine and vice, I dunno if they couldn't catch every word she says. It's even very clear. This competition is all about the voice and personality. She has all of it. Or It's just that they don't want her to be part of the top 4. She's much more deserving than others who stayed in the competition.

[@x3locker2023]

Mas sisikat pa to sa mga singers na iba. Judges don't need to compare sa ibang contestant parang lumalabas na may favoritism kayo. Napaka bias ng judging ni Kabayo letse nag judge ka pa.

[@mariamarisacourtney3455]

The worse judges history of Idol Philippines 2019 😩😩😩

[@renal5460]

ang gagaling naman mag judge ng mga nagcocomment dito..kayo nalang kaya maging hurado at ma bash...ahahHa..kaya walang peace sa earth mga kagaya ng mga ganitong pag uugali...Just be happy nalang at meron tayo pinapanood..kung ayaw niyo sa show e di wag kayo manood..ganum lang yon..kaysa naman magkomento kayo ng hindi kanais nais..

[@robertjamesguina7303]

Bago pa siya kumanta me panalo na yung gusto nila na manalo

[@johndymalsit7461]

What bunch of undeserving judges. Pati 'yong isa diyan akala ko naman maayos. Halatang baseless na ang sinasabi ninyo at naninira na because hindi naman 'yan ang narinig namin.

[@heilined.cabasag9740]

Masama kasi nagmamagaling... Hindi na nga yan...malamang maemote kasi yung style ng kanta... D ako sheland before kaya ngayon ko lang nalaman toh.. Proud dan fan toh..

[@kimloydlogawe4890]

Please what your words judges🥺

[@jigsawgurl559]

Terrible judges. Hindi marunong mag-encourage ng talents. Favoritism talaga. Nakalimutan nila voting system ito. Pag magcomment sila ng negative malaki impact nyan sa votes. Dapat light criticism lang like American Idol idinaan nila sa coaching ang kanilang criticism. Total pumasa naman si Sheland sa audition at pre-live numbers meaning magaling talaga siya. It's up to the viewers na to vote. Na-influence ang mga voters sa mga unfair comments ng mga judges.