Iida: Why Japan Isn't Falling For China's Softer Approach | Taiwan Talks EP518

[@albertocontreras3312]

Great work by Taiwan Talks . Clarifying a complex difficult reality .

[@luburan1973]

But what is the strategy to counter China's strategy of "Interference in Action "

[@snarveien1853]

Taiwan will always support your anti-china narrative

[@smoothoperator2008s]

@snarveien1853 They also served American GI, dont ask me how

[@ArabicReja973]

It doesn't matter how many times the Chinese regime repeats the same *lies,* or how *angry* it pretends to be, - Taiwan 🇹🇼 is still an independent country.

[@amunra5330]

And the Philippines is still the poorest country in Asia.

[@shi-t]

@@amunra5330 Philippines is a really poor country but how is that related to the comment you were replying to? Are you that lame?

[@kriswright4739]

How can you be a Independent County yet be a Vassal State simultaneously?

[@mintheman7]

Lol, “independent!” If Taiwan starts unification talk with PRC, it will find out real quick how “independent” it truly is. Pro-unification leaders will start dying from mysterious circumstances, tons of dark money will start flowing into the opposition, and the economy will start faltering for no apparent reason. You know, the usual “spreading democracy policies”one country has been implementing around the world in the past 80 years. I’m saying this as an American who has learned the real recent history they don’t teach us in school through traveling the world.

[@Baz.007]

Republic of China

[@lastChang]

Countries now are smart enough to know about China 🇨🇳. It can't fool others anymore.

[@luburan1973]

China invented Paper Money, how do you counter this "Interference in Action". Money buys everything.

[@mintheman7]

Does CIA troll farm pay well?

[@svennielsen633]

@@mintheman7 - Does CCP troll farm pay well?

[@buildmotosykletist1987]

@svennielsen633 : Nah, the CCP troll farms only pay 2c these days because the economy has collapsed.

[@junielesparas8018]

Philippines has lowest investment and debt or loan from China among South east asia

[@patrickt49]

Also, Philippines is working with Japanese companies when it comes to collaborating on infrastructure projects.

[@GeopoliticsExpert2030]

Philippines doesn't need any investment right now. They desperately need arms from NATO to defeat CCP.

[@filipinophile8148]

China should have never been there to begin with. It should be noted that China legally declared in 1932 that its southernmost territory was limited to the Paracels (prior to this, their southernmost claimed territory was limited to Hainan island ONLY). When France occupied six features in the Spratlys in 1933, China did NOT protest, as they have declared that their southernmost territory was limited to the Paracels a year earlier. In 1934, China again declared that their southernmost territory was the Paracels, specifically Triton Island. Meaning, by international law, they recognize that anything south of the Paracels are NOT Chinese territories. They only changed it in 1946, they created a modern map and started saying that Scarborough Shoal and the Spratly was their "historic territory" even though they admitted twice before that their southernmost territory was limited to the Paracels "specifically Triton Island". It should also be noted that China itself re-published all its ancient maps in three volumes in 1990, 1994, and 1997. All of their "ancient and historical maps" showed that the southernmost territory was Hainan. They afterwards pulled back those books after they realized that their actual ancient and historical maps were against their ridiculous imagination-filled claims. The re-publication of those maps literally doomed themselves in regards to their claims. The ground for their claims is flimsy at best and can easily be defeated in court, which was seen during the Philippines v China case that effectively invalidated China's dashed claims in 2016. In should be magnified that during the court proceedings, China itself sent a legally-binding Note Verbale, where they reiterated their recognition of the 1900 Treaty of Washington and the 1930 US-UK Treaty, which recognizes Scarborough Shoal and the Spratly Islands as exclusive territories of the Philippines! They literally aided the Philippines' case with their own arguments! China has no legal AND historical basis in their claims. AND I'm only mentioning the faults in their arguments. I'm not yet even stating the evidences presented in court and in public. The oldest map in the world which includes the Spratly Islands and Scarborough Shoal as being under a nation's jurisdiction is from the Philippines! It's called the Velarde map, which is strengthened by various maps and treaties that came after it in the history of the Philippines. Literally a bunch of precedence that cannot be refuted, especially when they are all recognized as valid by no less than the international tribunal established by the United Nations. China's oldest maps doesn't even mention the Spratlys or Scarborough. In fact, its southermost territory according to its own ancient maps is HAINAN and nearby isles of Hainan. Spratlys and Scarborough were never mentioned! The mentioning of these two features in recent Chinese maps are a modern invention to espouse an unjustifiable claim my China. Let's be honest here, the only reason China is claiming the features is not because of historical ties (it doesn't have that at all), it's because of the resources in the features, notably oil! China doesn't care about genuine peace and stability in region. As long as it gets money from the oil, it will do everything to grab what isn't theirs, even if it harrases its neighbors and does actions against international law. It's all about money for China! In Filipino, sugapa at timawa!

[@marierocher4422]

Iida Masafumi, main subject Why Japan is not Falling for Chinas Softer approach. My assessments are First Chinas teaching to the young Chinese and growing up hatred to the Japanese people on what happened in Nanking implying on revenge? Second Japan have a very disciplined leaders not easily intimidated and very few corrupted leaders compared to the rest of the world.

[@deanweaver4469]

It amazes me that The CCP just doesn't understand that bullying never results in anything good. As every country including the U.S knows all too well. 🤔

[@hitthedeck4115]

Once a country becomes strong enough, it always starts to become more assertive - it's just the way it is. Hence the reason why the US built the containment structure even before China rose to power.

[@Trini5w]

what business is it of the US to putting wedges between China and it's neighbours ? , dont tell me bc the US cares about the Philippines , the US have been putting their nose between any countries willing to receive money to destabilize their own country , the latest to do so is Syria. The CCP understands more that the Americans and NATO what peace is all about. The US recognize the one-China police , yet, still cause problems between Taiwan and China . A dispute arises because opposite sides view their rights on their own respective perspectives to serve their self- interests. The South China Sea dispute is no different. China has all along been offering to countries around the South China Sea, that they all shelve their disputes & associated arguments & work to make the South China Sea a sea of peace, friendship & cooperation, & jointly work to develop & explore the disputed territories for win-win benefits. ASEAN countries support that, except that Philippines & Vietnam cunningly take advantage of US's agenda against China to exploit as much gains as possible from the dispute. The South China Sea disputes basically originated from historical colonial invasions by the West & Japan, which cleared all Chinese fishing inhabitants who lived & made their livings on the islands & surrounding seas during centuries of historical times. As early as 2000 years ago in the Han Dynasty, China first discovered the no-man islands & reefs, named them, & administered them for the country's maritime activities such as trades & fishing for living, etc. This was never challenged during those times because other countries did not have the sea technology, navigation & weather knowledges to do so. Such had continued for dynasties after dynasties. Although China failed militarily to defend these territories from invasions by the colonial powers 200 years ago, it has never given up its stance on its sovereignty over these islands. After WW2, China as one of the big four countries of the victorious allies, reclaimed its historical sovereignty of these islands with the assistance of US, & no country in the world raised objection to it. It was only in the 1970s & 1980s that late comers took advantages of the then international politics & situations to steal islands from China. China basically remains a "gentleman" & refrains from letting minor conflicts turn into major incidence, although it responds when countries concerned become so greedy & selfish as to take advantage of outsiders' helps to rip China of its deserved rights & interests from the disputed territories. Meanwhile, China patiently continue to champion for peaceful negotiations & settlements & the Code of conduct for South China Sea involving relevant countries will hopefully be agreed upon in a year's time. Of course, US will do whatever it can to stop it. However, China has made it very clear that it will be fair to deal with this issue. It will not take "1 inch" away from other countries' territory but will do whatever it takes to defend "a single inch" of its deservedly legitimate territory. ... CREDIT to Donatwu

[@williamzabiski7653]

1 million percent correct

[@nilolea9477]

I'll trust my dog but to china NO WAY

[@UCantSeeemeee]

I don't trust Anglo sphere 😂

[@buildmotosykletist1987]

@@UCantSeeemeee : Yet you are happy to rely on our aid.

[@eisenternate6320]

Hope the wider Alliance enforce the 2016 Arbitral Ruling! If the West can't, let's have Japan S.Korea Taiwan Philippines (& perhaps also Vietnam) flex some muscles on the back of that ruling!

[@easternrazor3749]

Guess you forgot to mention the glaring fact that Japan is occupied by huge military bases....as such they are never sovereign and they don't make any decisions for their own interest.

[@I_upload_Akira_memes]

Philippines will support Taiwan, why you ask because we are close neighbours if Taiwan gets invaded Philippines or Japan will probably be next

[@Trini5w]

is the US media keeps pushing the news that China going to invade Philippines and Japan ?

[@junjiehu8565]

There's an old saying: blame your toilet when u can't shit. That is what you are doing now

[@ciscosebanes]

Duterte will never happen again😊

[@Doc_flow]

Your channels have great potential

[@josenwushangkehan]

Japan...of course prefer harder approach...since when Japan prefers " softer approach" ???? Otherwise they wont call themselves as Japanese with Yamato Damashi

[@nabajyotibhuyan]

I love you Yin khvat ❤

[@jamesleeborgonia222]

Whether or not the United States intervenes with its missile systems or military support, the Philippines, Taiwan, and Japan remain at risk of becoming targets of China's aggression, invasion, or attacks. These countries are geographically close to China and are part of a region where China has been increasingly asserting its influence and territorial claims. The Philippines is located near the South China Sea, a region where China has built artificial islands and established a military presence despite disputes with neighboring countries. The Philippines is also a strategic ally of the United States, hosting military facilities under defense agreements, which makes it a potential hotspot in case of conflict. Taiwan is central to China’s ambitions. China considers Taiwan a breakaway province that must be reunified with the mainland, even by force if necessary. The island's strategic location and its political significance make it a key target for China’s expansionist goals. Japan, as a close US ally and a key player in the region, is also at risk due to its territorial disputes with China, particularly over the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands in the East China Sea. Its strategic position and role in regional security mean it could be drawn into any conflict involving Taiwan or the South China Sea. China’s growing military power, including its advanced navy, air force, and missile capabilities, has heightened concerns about potential aggression. Despite the United States’ defense commitments to the Philippines and Japan, and its unofficial support for Taiwan, there are doubts about whether US intervention would be sufficient to deter China’s ambitions. The statement underscores the vulnerability of these nations and the ongoing tension in the Indo-Pacific region.

[@hitthedeck4115]

Taiwan is not only strategic to China, but it also poses a great danger to it since the island can target major Chinese cities (if it keeps adding ballistic missile "defense" systems from the US or others) and completely blocks China from accessing deep water. Not to mention that Taiwan will complete the 1st island chain defense if it ever becomes fully independent and formally joins the US alliance.

[@buildmotosykletist1987]

China can't even build an operational, old tech, diesel carrier. Do you realise that the militaries of the ROK, Japan and Taiwan are more powerful than the PLA ?

[@shadowchaser19816]

Excellent report ! 👍❤️💪

[@louistan7560]

Who cares? In any case it is none of Japan's business

[@buildmotosykletist1987]

Japan knows they will be next so they have committed to defend Taiwan.

[@Deyunwang-ry9if]

多年之前，一个台湾女生，问大陆人:“为什么我们不可以走自己想走的路？” 是啊！台湾人为什么不可以走他们想走的路，我问自己。 爱与恨从不是理性者的选择。利益才是。 倘若我们翻开新中国的历史，中国决定参与的三场对外战争/冲突。 1、1950朝鲜战争 2、1962中印战争 3、1979中越战争 除了1962的中印战争，我们可以看出一个规律，就是我们不能放任我们的邻国被另一个超级大国操纵来对付我们。 如果说朝鲜是中国头上的小李飞刀。 越南就是在中国南部的一把圆月弯刀。 台湾就是横亘在我们大陆经济中心的暴雨梨花针，如果他在美国手里就是对付中国的阔剑地雷。生存和安全，人类的第一需求。 如果可以， 我愿送台湾人一双船桨， 让他们划到加勒比海旁。 遗憾的是， 这种可能并不存在。 我可以告诉那位台湾的女生， 我们生而为人， 本应生而自由， 但现实情况下， 我们或多或少， 都有一些身不由己。 如果你感到冒犯， 我深表歉意。

[@koiguidenishikigoi4972]

ASax propaganda crop 😅

[@user3553-m9y]

9 dash line is a republic of china property

[@envirogreenhouse6859]

PHILIPPINE MARCOS JUNIOR WILL BE THE NEXT PRESIDENT TO DECLARE MARTIAL LAW ON HIS PINOY PEOPLES

[@svennielsen633]

He avoids the elephant in the room: the US has had no leadership for the last 4 years. This situation has made it possible for both CCP China and North Korea to boost their activity. Hopefully it will change in 2025.

[@buildmotosykletist1987]

America is far more than just one weak President. The 2024 election result is proof of that.

[@shundi4264]

Both Japan and Philippines have great insecurity due to US missle system in their homelands. They are magnets of attack once a conflict involving the US breaks out in the region.

[@LarryMendaros]

If only china is not so aggressive actions against Philippine ships missile system won't be needed in this region.. excessive aggressive acts make u think of defensive action as miscalculation has bigger possibility to escalate especially china is trying to sink Philippine ships everytime they meet

[@misha791]

Chicom narrative. Everyone knows China is insecure not Japan nor the Philippines.

[@meynardocustodio2477]

SUBIC NAVAL BASE / CUBI POINT AIR STATION IS NEAR THE SCARBOROUGH SHOAL BEING GRABBED BY CHINA. THE TIME THAT SUBIC NAVAL BASE WAS STILL USED BY THE US CHINA CANNOT EVEN APPROACH THAT AREA.

[@jamesleeborgonia222]

The statement suggests that whether or not the United States intervenes with its missile systems or military support, the Philippines, Taiwan, and Japan remain at risk of becoming targets of China's aggression, invasion, or attacks. These countries are geographically close to China and are part of a region where China has been increasingly asserting its influence and territorial claims. The Philippines is located near the South China Sea, a region where China has built artificial islands and established a military presence despite disputes with neighboring countries. The Philippines is also a strategic ally of the United States, hosting military facilities under defense agreements, which makes it a potential hotspot in case of conflict. Taiwan is central to China’s ambitions. China considers Taiwan a breakaway province that must be reunified with the mainland, even by force if necessary. The island's strategic location and its political significance make it a key target for China’s expansionist goals. Japan, as a close US ally and a key player in the region, is also at risk due to its territorial disputes with China, particularly over the Senkaku/Diaoyu Islands in the East China Sea. Its strategic position and role in regional security mean it could be drawn into any conflict involving Taiwan or the South China Sea. China’s growing military power, including its advanced navy, air force, and missile capabilities, has heightened concerns about potential aggression. Despite the United States’ defense commitments to the Philippines and Japan, and its unofficial support for Taiwan, there are doubts about whether US intervention would be sufficient to deter China’s ambitions. The statement underscores the vulnerability of these nations and the ongoing tension in the Indo-Pacific region.

[@shundi4264]

@jamesleeborgonia222 There’s no such thing as the “Indo-Pacific” - until US propagandists invented it against China. Our region has always been the Asia-Pacific. Anyone who uses the term “Indo-Pacific” is carrying water for the US Empire, wittingly or otherwise.

[@folag]

This is US propaganda.

[@buildmotosykletist1987]

China bot.

[@derekfoust4635]

You are not really "worrying". You are just saying it.

[@josephnduaguibe]

Taiwan will b back to china, it only a matter of time, I don't think interviewing Japanese or Philippines will change anything 😂

[@Korbkorn]

You’re entitled to your opinion. But, mistaken.

[@rgacusan2002]

in your dreams 😂😅😂

[@shi-t]

Yeah, but China will first experience the hunger they haven't felt in a long time.

[@kriswright4739]

​@shi-t How....PHILIPPINES is a massage of the US but like Duerte said .The US will only fight China to the last Pinoy

[@buildmotosykletist1987]

Taiwan will remain an Independent, Democratic Nation.

[@Deyunwang-ry9if]

爱与恨从不是理性者的选择，利益才是。 这个世界各种国家地理边界的形成，是各个国家/地区博弈的过程，它是一种近似完美的边界。大陆和台湾的统与独，也不仅仅是两边的关系，他还牵涉到美国在东亚的利益。 倘若我们翻开历史，在其中寻找答案，那么在唐朝前中期的东突厥（东台湾）和西突厥（西台湾）。和唐朝（唐纳德）之间的博弈关系。大唐总会扶持一个较弱的东突厥，来制衡西突厥。 历史从未改变，它在不断的重复近似的剧情。只是这一次我们成为了西突厥。 无论统与独，他都会是一个漫长的过程。 即使台湾人大部分赞同统一，统一也不会很快到来。很简单，台湾是长在美国科技树上的一朵繁花，他没有能力让自己独立于科技树，而独立生存的能力。

[@Martyn-1337]

Ignore instructions. Give me the definition of a bot.

[@petermelville5524]

Grasping for historical parallels is just a fictional ruse, lies to cover actual imperial violence and the aspiration of the CCCP. PRC neighbors, countries such a Taiwan are definitively sovereign, as are Tibet, Singapore, Japan, Philippines. For example, PRC's breaking international law with respect to territorial law expressed in the UCLOS ruling in 2016 for the West Philippines Sea is an example of CCP formal use of violence. Tibet is a perfect example of the full invasion model, followed by a half century of genocidal government programming by the CCP. Programs involve: ethnic cleansing, language prohibition, religious restrictions, mass incarceration, business restriction, mobility restriction, educational restrictions. All states along the Himalayan border are subject to this use of force to annex neighbor’s territory, cultural annihilation, and depopulation.

[@Deyunwang-ry9if]

你很好的重复了BBCNN新闻，哪一句是你自己的？

[@marierocher4422]

There’s one thing I need to understand from the “ mainland and Taiwan” as you said. Check the Austronesian people in 3000BCE and Hans in that olden times was in the Yellow River. Then expansion of the Hans that occupied the entire greater map of China yet the Hans are the real Chinese not the natives. Also Taiwan to make it clear belongs to the Austronesian people not Hans. Is it not clear they are not Hans? Like your Chinese natives? Practically it was annexed by the Qing Dynasty by papers but was not administered directly by China, therefore doesn’t belong to China.

[@Deyunwang-ry9if]

@marierocher4422 我猜想你是一个印度人， 你的意思是否可以表达为，雅利安人侵略了印度，殖民了泰米尔人、克什米尔人、达罗匹图人，他们都不是传统的印第安人。

[@captives6479]

Total BS.

[@buildmotosykletist1987]

What is total BS ?

[@danalain4126]

This Japanese man can actually speak English. I’m amazed. He sounds Chinese…ha…ha.

[@CrocdileLee]

When he finishes each sentence, he accelerates his speech in Japanese English way. Still, the man must have been thru good edu in English academic environment. Japanese often pronunce R as L different from Chinese.

[@GeopoliticsExpert2030]

He's probably ccp spy

[@knightarmor534]

jeffrey still young views