2. Taraweeh: Umar's Innovation | Night 2 | Sayed Ammar Nakshawani | Holy Ramadan 2024/1445

Imam Hussein TV 3 Presents this Holy Month of Ramadan:
‘Shia and Sunni: Rapprochement & Conflict’
An exclusive lecture series with the world-renowned Dr. Sayed Ammar Nakshawani
Dr. Sayed Ammar will provide an insight into some of the core topics which affect our beliefs, theology and jurisprudential system whilst also analysing the literature and viewpoints of scholars from other sects in the religion of Islam
Join us every night for the first 22 nights of Holy Ramadan, starting at 19:30 U.K. exclusively on Imam Hussein TV 3
0:00 Promo's
7:30 Unveiling the Origins of Taraweeh
13:24 Prayers which Are Obligatory for the Holy Prophet (PBUH)
19:18 Recommended Prayers In The Holy Month of Ramadan
21:05 Disobeyed Propeht (PBUH) Let's Begin with Sahi Muslim
26:11 First Person Who Disobeyed Propeht (PBUH)
26:26 Umar's Innovation
43:41 What Did the Imam Ali do About This
56:43 Promo's
Like, follow and subscribe to Imam Hussein TV’s official KZbin channel here: kzbin.info...
Support Imam Hussein TV: www.imamhussein3.tv/donate
Make sure you're following Imam Hussein TV for all the latest.
Facebook: / imamhusseintv3
Twitter: / imamhusseintv3
Instagram: / imamhusseintv3
KZbin: / imamhussein3tv
Website: imamhussein3.tv
Telegram: t.me/imamhusseintv3
WhatsApp: wa.me/447939917163
Watch IHTV3 using the following methods:
• Website: imamhussein3.tv/live
• Android & iOS App: onelink.to/ihtv
• KZbin: kzbin.info...
• Download on Smart TV's: Samsung TV, LG TV & Android TV
• Also on: Apple TV, RoKu, Amazon Fire & CTV
Imam Hussein TV 1 (Persian) : bit.ly/2zcmtCv
Imam Hussein TV 2 (Arabic) : bit.ly/2TwiXvk
Imam Hussein TV 3 (English) : bit.ly/2vfClRT
Imam Hussein TV 4 (Urdu) : bit.ly/2DvXrRH
AlZahra (Turkish): bit.ly/2ORtYnl
Morning Baraka: bit.ly/2OvrN9Z

[@Webmaster12345]

Being a sunni. Syed Ammar is correct. The taraweeh salah was an innovation of syedna Umar. TarAweeh salah is actually just the tahajjud salah.

[@mhmadbedrddeen3414]

may Allah reward you for your truthfulness and may Allah guide us all to his true path that he designated not the innovated paths

[@A.A471]

I admire your honesty. This is something all Muslims need to do, especially in this holy month. May Allah SWT accept your prayers and dua this Ramadan.

[@user-sd8xp8dk6c]

See honesty brings us together.

[@155stw]

I’ve found Sunnis both agree and disagree with you. Some say that the bidaah part is not the fact that it’s a bidaah in that it was never or only done occasionally and Umar created a new Sunnah. But it was a bidaah in the sense that it was revived by Umar. I feel that this opinion requires a bit of mental gymnastics.

[@A.A471]

@@155stw No there is no need to cause a rift here. We are all Muslims seeking Sirat Al Mustaqeem. The 'mental gymnastics' is what "they" like to use against us. I’d prefer if we don’t fall into the same antagonist tone as some of them do, especially in this month. With respect brother, please try and have a more respectful tone, especially as this brother is doing something difficult by admitting the truth. How would you feel if you had to admit the truth about, for example, Imam Ali A.S doing something wrong, astagfarallah, that would never happen, but put yourself in their shoes, because Umar is a a big revered personality to Sunnis, just like Imam Ali A.S is to us, so we must be considerate for our Muslim brothers who are finding the truth, as are we.

[@BilRas]

I love Shia Islam!!! The Islam of Rasulullah, Salawat!

[@MustafaKhan-qe3tz]

For Shia taraweeh is bidah, but banging head on a Karbala stone, halala, cursing Sahabas while beating chest, making and visiting big shrines, tattoos, Arbaeen Walk are all vey SUNNAH 😂😅

[@Markusdort]

Here more references for the non believers: Taraweh prayed at home: bukhari:2009 bukhari:2010 Omar taraweeh bida: bukhari:2010 mishkat:1301 Malik muwatta 6/3 EVERY bida leads to hellfire: Nasai: 1578 Dont greet someone who did bida: ibnmajah:4061 Sahabas in hell because of Bida: bukhari:6587 bukhari:3349 bukhari:6585 tirmidhi:3616 bukhari:6584 bukhari:6583 bukhari:6582 bukhari:6586 bukhari:6593 muslim:249a muslim:247b muslim:249b bukhari:4740 bukhari:7049 bukhari:7048 bukhari:7050 bukhari:7051 muslim:2304a nasai:2087 bukhari:6576 muslim:2290 nasai:904 muslim:2292 bukhari:6526 bukhari:4625 muslim:2860b Since 1400 years we have this problems with you... Read your own books goddammit And then some of you wonder why we call you ahlul-bida-wal jamaah.. baba wake up

[@Rafida_Twelver_Shia_Muslim]

Great job! Allah bless you my friend! I feel so much joy when a brother of mine posts such a useful comment. Keep doing it.

[@thestrongguy1]

This is great. Thanks

[@xD-Hi]

الله يرزقك يا اخي

[@ahmedhabib442]

"baba wake up" LOL!

[@MoneyEdits2024]

great lies no wonder why shism is declining in iran you just spam quotes the prophet himself prayed taraweeh and the companions did and the prophet say to follow the rightly guided caliphs including umar maybe just be quiet then talking things you have no ilm on rafida shia !

[@ahmedhabib442]

The more research I look into Islam, the more "sunni" Islam begins to look like Christianity with their innovations AlhamidAllah I am Shia Muslim and my leaders are Mohammed and Ahl Al Bayt PEACE BE UPON THEM!

[@haijder89]

What a lecture. Thank you.

[@fouziafyazi5768]

Absolutely mind rocking Sayed Ammar 👌👏💘 u just got the fact chk like no other 😄

[@muniraalqamar]

Thank you Imam Hussein TV3 and Sayed Ammar Nakshawani for dissecting the topic and showing the references.. appreciate all your lectures.. Allah swt bless and protect you always ⚘️❤️

[@davidayoubi1967]

He proved the point beyond the shadow of a doubt. Wonderful lecture. All proofs from Sunni books. The question is why do Sunni folks still follow this innovation and condemn themselves to hell fire?

[@mohamedddd983]

It’s not the eyes which are blind but the hearts

[@Darth_Haider]

We need more people like Sayed Ammar in these fractured communities around the world.

[@shiashameem3545]

I thank Allah for me loving the holy family I found the truth with them and its so sad the lies embedded in the history books about the best servants of Allah

[@saracoble]

lecture starts at 7:30

[@xD-Hi]

tysm

[@saracoble]

well done👏 part of unity is having solidarity with one another in spite of our differences

[@SheFoundAllah]

Great video 🤲🏽

[@bibirose1626]

Seems to be interesting lectures

[@haiderbhogadia4829]

This was very good. Alhumd

[@person_onyt]

Asalam Alikum my dear brother Dr sayed Ammar nafkwani .Maa shaa Allah my Dua is with you . sister khadijah.

[@AsimKhan-if7pd]

Right 💯💯

[@sayedabbas9358]

Mashallah ❤

[@bibirose1626]

أَقِمِ الصَّلاةَ لِدُلُوكِ الشَّمْسِ إِلَى غَسَقِ اللَّيْلِ وَقُرْآنَ الْفَجْرِ إِنَّ قُرْآنَ الْفَجْرِ كَانَ مَشْهُودًا وَمِنَ اللَّيْلِ فَتَهَجَّدْ بِهِ نَافِلَةً لَّكَ عَسَى أَن يَبْعَثَكَ رَبُّكَ مَقَامًا مَّحْمُودًا

[@nowin1804]

BarakAllah Feek Sayedna

[@xD-Hi]

الله يرزقك بالصحة و العلم إنشاء الله

[@firdosRS]

Masha Allah Sayed

[@mahnoormudassar8290]

as far as i understand as a muslim, let alone shia or sunni, ONLY ALLAH orders HIS SLAVES and after That our Beloved Holy Prophet(SAWW) and His(SAWW) Beloved Holy Progeny(AS) , our Beloved Holy AhlulBayt(AS) as They (AS) are The Representatives(AS) of ALLAH . so how can a sahaba add or subtract to the religion , aren’t they just supposed to follow THE ORDER of ALLAH and HIS Beloved Holy AhlulBayt(AS) like the rest of us ?

[@saydulislam4319]

As a Sunni myself this is our view (no intention to argue just telling my undertsanding) The Prophet (saw) prayed taraweeh alone at his house coz he didn't want it to become fardh and burden his companions. However he stopped praying it when his companions started noticing and tried praying with him. Umor (ra) decided to carry on this prayer coz Muhammad (saw) never forbid it, so it's still a optional prayer. Its all about trying to get the most out of ramadan and do more nafl prayers. This Imam, while very knowledgeable mashAllah seems to not believe there is good bidah (bidah that isn't against the sayings of the prophet (saw) and the Quran and is done carefully without making it compulsory)

[@AfG_313]

Thanks brother, I am Shia and I am very happy I am Shia we are frm Afghanistan and very strict Sunni background bt my grandfather became Shia then father then me then my whole family, my grandfather both sides had three wives so Alhamduililah we are huge family, don’t get me wrong I don’t got issue with Sunni at all some my family still Sunni, actually a lot, unfortunately this has brought issues upon us and we don’t chat as much anymore which is sad man I have no anger towards family but seems they do on that side idk man kinda tough

[@A416G]

Bisyar khoobish biadar jan

[@RocketAfriqueZA]

RIP Sunnism

[@martintanjung5540]

The excellent bidáh is gathering the different groups of praying people and individuals into one jamaa', not the Taraweeh itself...

[@Alchemyofautheticfaith]

excellenttttttttt arguement . big fan

[@jawadahmedd6360]

Kindly tell us about Knife cutting mourning innovation

[@RocketAfriqueZA]

Much like followers of God are the minority and the non-believers are the majority, Much like how the Tribes of Judah were the minority and the Tribes of Israel were the majority, Much like how the Jewish-Christians were the minority and the Paulene Christians the majority, Followers of Imam Ali (as) and Ahlul Bayt, the Shia’a, are the minority and the Sunni are the majority.

[@ik7348]

20 nawafil x 20 nights = 400 30 nawafil x last 10 nights = 300 This completes 30 nights of the month =700 nawafil Question: If we pray 100 nawafil each night on 19, 20 and 21st, are they in addition to 20/30 nawafil? If not, then how do we complete the total of 1000?

[@haqqulyakeen4661]

Yes, In the first and second decades of the month of Ramadan, 20 rak'as of prayers should be said (10 prayers each of which has two rak'as): 8 rak'as after the salat al-maghrib, 12 rak'as after the salat al-'isha', and in the third decade of the month of Ramadan, 30 rak'as should be said every night: 8 rak'as after salat al-maghrib, and 22 rak'as after salat al-'isha'. In addition to these, 300 rak'as are recommended to be said in the nights of Laylat al-Qadr.

[@t-zx3qi]

yh 100 each on the 19 20 and 21 would then equate to 1000

[@odacizdnak1136]

Did prophet ever pray Taraweeh

[@Webmaster12345]

He prayed Tahajjud. Because it was compulsory on him but not the sahabas. However when the sahabas started emulating him, he scolded them. As they started praying it as if it was obligatory. The taraweeh is an innovation of Syedna Umar. Islamically there is no such thing as taraweeh, its just tahajjud. Which can be prayed after isha if you have difficulty breaking your sleep.

[@odacizdnak1136]

@@Webmaster12345 did prophet pray Taraweeh Yes he did - when he does something but does not make it obligatory means you can do it or not Some times I pray taraweeh some times I don’t. It’s not a Bidah get over it is it Bidah curse prophets wife and companions. He never cursed them

[@RedA-ld4de]

​@@odacizdnak1136 You absolute buffoon. The bidah is praying salatul layl in congregation. The prophet pbuhaf didnt pray in congregation, thats the whole point of Umar's bidah. So no, the prophet pbuhaf didnt pray tarawih. 💀 Watch and pay attention

[@HR-313]

​@odacizdnak1136 it was umar who called it a good bid3a. For you to say its not bid3a is ludicrous as these hadiths are from your most authentic sources. Wake up to yourself

[@user-sd8xp8dk6c]

​@@HR-313 ya akhi. Its a waste of time. People like this will deny whats in there face. 😂

[@danmandhk]

Why do shia pray eid prayer in congregation if it is not wajib to pray it?

[@miki3135]

It is wajib 😂😂

[@RocketAfriqueZA]

Man I pity you sunnis. Even when the truth is put before you in crystal clarity, from your own books no less. You are still hellbent on performing mental gymnastics to protect your demi gods and have no qualms throwing the messenger of Allah (SAW) under the bus to preserve the isma of your qureysh idols

[@user-ly5jo6rw7g]

Umar😂😂😂

[@zainshafiq7995]

Salat Taraweeh is neither obligatory, nor Sunnat. Its a practice that originated from the concept of " Qiyaam-ul-Lail". During the reign of Khalifa Umar Bin Khattab, it was established to offer it as congregation as an administrative decision. So, those insisting on it are wrong and those who totally call is haraam or prohibited is also on an extreme end. The beliefs and Practices of Islam are based on Quran and Sunnat of the Prophet Muhmmad SAW.

[@tam3133]

Lol evidence is clear as day we dont need your explanation sorry but not sorry 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@haroonramola5983]

What was at stake if the 'administrative decision' wasn't made? What foresight did umar have that the Prophet(SAWW) didn't?

[@zainshafiq7995]

​@@tam3133as per my limited knowledge, it's not a part of sunnah to pray taraweeh nor a part of Religion Islam. Its just a practice (optional)

[@hasanimam35]

Salams to both Shia and Sunni brothers and sisters. You will be interested in my book I wrote about the Sunni-Shia issue, released in 2022. It is entitled, ‘Aisha and Fatima - Ladies of Heaven. A Sunni Response to Shiasim.’ It is available on Amazon Books. It includes a dialogue I had with a Shia brother and questions I asked Shia scholars. The book trailer is here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/ppjMi2OVrrhpg6csi=Gl22PuGiMfqFjBMg

[@user-zo3jj7sv7b]

haahhahaha 😂😂😂

[@ajadfax1798]

Your talking Islam Sunni Shia etc but bro you got tattoos what example you giving got preach then do something talking against

[@Adam-iz5kh]

Appearance is not the only thing that matters. Focus in the content and the knowledge that he is trying to spread, that is the most important thing.

[@rickyalfred9710]

People don’t understand what they are reading. The only “bida “ umar did was to collect people behind one imam. They was already praying In jama. They only people who object to Tarawih are the imami Shia. The zaidis have narrations from Imam Ali praying in congratulations with his family 20 rakahs and their narrations are far stronger than 12rs reagrding the iractuce of ahl bayt

[@A.A471]

Brother, didn’t you watch the lecture, it is clear in Sunni Sahih books that Umar made bidah. First of all, you don’t deny Umar made bidah. Secondly, you make seem as if Umar‘s bidah has had no problematic impact on Muslims today. So many Muslims are under the believe that praying "Taraweeh" in Jammah is valid and highly recommended that it becomes VIRTUALLY obligatory during Ramadan for Sunni Muslims. With that said, if in this lecture, it has been proven by Sunni books that "Taraweeh " is bidah, that means many Muslims are doing something of innovations. This innovated group prayer goes against fundamental religious principles, as proven by Sunni books. The fact that you are trying to attack other Muslims as your argument, shows your weakness to defend the authenticity and validity of the prayer of "Taraweeh ".

[@mohamedddd983]

Please watch the whole lecture. Before assuming that he doesn’t understand.

[@user-np5lk4wx6mofficial]

Actually you don't understand this whole lecture sir please 🙏 watch the full video carefully

[@CITYECOM]

CLEAR AS DAY ITS ALL IN YOUR BOOKS

[@brianmaro1964]

Using Sahih muslim and Bukhari to try and disprove the legitimacy of Taraweh (which is sunnah) while your Shahada (which is a prerequisite of islam) and adhaan are adulterated is hypocrisy of the finest degree. The Prophet S.A.W. prayed taraweh with the sahaba and he refrained from it with fears it will become wajib upon the ummah as the ahadith clearly states which he has done numerous times in his lifetime (i.e. refraining from nawafil so that it doesnt become a burden and be considered wajib upon the ummah). When Umar R.A used the words excellent bid'ah, he was referring to the practice of praying taraweh in congregation which they did with S.A.W and he was restoring it after many years of them not praying it in congregation after the previous ahadith showed the prophet stopped it. Not that he forbade it. And although it is true that sunnah prayers are more beneficial at home than at the mosque, the same is true for woman for fard prayers. That doesnt mean they arent allowed to go to the mosque to pray does it?

[@Adam-iz5kh]

Don't spread false narratives. The Prophet prayed tahajjud not taraweeh. Umar referred to it as a bidah because it was an innovation in the religion. It is as simple as that.

[@shamasetarehvafaipour5597]

Did you even watch the whole video ? Because it’s very obvious that Umar was very clear that it’s a bidah and we all know that bidah is not allowed in Islam . Very very simple .

[@user-zo3jj7sv7b]

haahhahhahhhhhah😂😂😂😂