Indus Civilization: A 5000 Year Old Enigma

[@mateeva1959]

Csodálatos élmény volt néznem ezt a letúnt civilizációból látott képeket. Köszönet az elkészítőnek.

[@chandioanwar1231]

The ancient Sindh are full of Mysteries, Unbelievable, thanks for this video.

[@ENERGIE-CONCENTRATION-PAIX]

Merveilleux. Un régal ! Merci beaucoup

[@chrissyf1295]

This would have been even more amazing if there were english subtitles. Still a great documentary.

[@cmoi613]

@@chrissyf1295 You can use translation in options...

[@SachiJones]

@@cmoi613 the issue is there are no captions or subtitles for Serge Cleuziou's commentaries at all so translation doesn't help @crissyf1295 I posted a comment with time-stamped translations

[@noeraldinkabam]

I have translation on but at 5:27 I’ve been listening to the guy and understand next to nothing. And no caps.

[@naturetubepk4289]

The Epicenter of Indus valley civilization is in Pakistan. Why they talk about India?

[@MarisolMarquez01]

The captions don't work for this video ​@@cmoi613

[@solucoesMA]

A sabedoria dos povos antigos é admirável.

[@fuzzebeara]

I could enjoy these programs more if the producers would caption the French commentaries. In the intellectual world I’m probably considered a Philistine, but an English translation would be greatly appreciated.

[@stargatis]

@@fuzzebeara I thought you meant because it was dubbed :(

[@karenbenning2166]

Me too.

[@SachiJones]

I posted a comment with time-stamped translations. Maybe they'll pin it 🤙

[@skuzzbunny]

@@SachiJones i can't find it.....??

[@edgarmoreno7804]

aprende español

[@GABEUDEU]

Le Gagar akkra est certainement le fleuve Sarasvati mentionné dans les Védas, ce que de nombreux archéologues occidentaux du XX • siècle ont volontairement ignoré , sujet qui me passionne et que je suis de prêt d'une civilisation qui est probablement la mère de la culture "indienne"je suis dans l'ensemble satisfait de ce documentaire qui sont rares , encore plus en langue française !

[@Gary-g4x2q]

@@GABEUDEU Is this documentary in English or French language. I felt I lost out on a lot of detail because so much French was spoken with no subtitles or English over dubbing. I can't recommend this video to non-French speakers.

[@GABEUDEU]

@Gary-g4x2q I agree with you, but at least this documentary didn't felt in too much stereotypes, sure their is some mistakes

[@ConradRaymond]

@@GABEUDEU I'm in

[@ConradRaymond]

Azteca Chingon

[@ConradRaymond]

💯💀

[@adad-nerari4117]

Comme le Docteur Khaled Alsendi , j'espère que l'on trouvera bientôt la "pierre de Rosette" de la vallée de l'Indus. Les Mésopotamiens avaient l'habitude d'établir des contrats écrits ,même pour les moindres transactions ; il est donc fort probable que l'on trouve,un jour, une tablette écrite dans les 2 langues. Merci à imineo pour ce très intéressant documentaire.

[@DharmendraKumar-i4v4k]

A cosa più impurtante chì ognunu deve pensà avà hè cumu investisce in diverse fonti d'ingudu chì ùn dependenu micca di u guvernu. In particulare in cunsiderà l'attuale crisa ecunomica in u mondu 🌍. Questu hè sempre un bonu tempu per invistisce in diverse azioni cum'è l'oru, l'argentu è e muniti digitale. tutti grazie à Tom Shawn per a furmazione di mè !!!.✊

[@DharmendraKumar-i4v4k]

Telegram hè attivu;( 🚀🚀

[@DharmendraKumar-i4v4k]

@TomShawnTrader✊🤙✍

[@shantoislam8925]

Wow. Sò un pocu perplessu à vede ch'ellu hè statu citatu ancu quì Ùn sapia chì hè statu bonu per tante persone ancu questu hè maravigliu, sò in u mo quintu cummerciu cun ellu è hè statu super.

[@RameshwerlalPrajapat]

Sò cuntentu di vede Mr.Tom Shawn mintuatu quì, a mo zia m'hà cunsigliatu dopu avè investitu $ 60k è ci hà veramente aiutatu finanziariamente✊😊

[@HerajRam-u4t]

Da veru voi u cunnosci ? Pensu ancu ch'e sò l'unicu chì hà aiutatu à marchjà à traversu i timori è i caduti di u cummerciu.

[@DD-vx7vp]

Es un docuental esplendido da gusto verlo arriba España.

[@jeannettejimenez5228]

Muchas gracias por su gran colaboración con esta información tan bella❤❤❤❤

[@LylyMarch-dm2vi]

Merci pour le partage 🙏🕉 pour vous éclairer il y a aussi bluette diot, le chaînon manquant, satanama yuga, enki satya, vidgita investigation, louis galador, Julie couvreur...... ☯️

[@mohammadahmadnaz9232]

Great Documentary. Both governments in India and Pakistan could get together and solve this enigma. our roots. Our ancestors rather than fighting like dogs. so-called civilised people, they are not !! I live in London, England.

[@PietroColombo-em5mz]

@@mohammadahmadnaz9232 Wise words. Greetings from Italy.

[@TheRotnflesh]

There are 12,000 year old petraglyphs in India showing the Master of Animals: something we have seen across the world, something thay all ties together about civilization...a savior type of man, a giant.

[@railwaymechanicalengineer4587]

12,000 year old petraglyphs puts this into the time before the "Cataclysms" (or even the time of the "Garden of Eden") when the sky was red 24/7, and the Sun never fully set. Indeed the Sun was NOT the Sun we see today. Earth was tidally locked to its small red/brown dwarf star, today known as Saturn. (Reference: The "Heretic" Professor Velikovsky & his science publication "Worlds in Collision" in our Electric Universe !)

[@eudeslaize8721]

@@TheRotnflesh c'était une marmotte qui mettait le chocolat dans le papier d'aluminium ? On a tous entendu parler de cette formidable légende 😂

[@eddyr1041]

Amazing and smaxingly we still can't read what they wrote😊❤

[@TheRotnflesh]

@@eddyr1041 Sumerian is mostly translated, and by translating it we are finding that cuneiform is a writing style not a language. Some people like Matthew LaCroix feel that original cuneiform may predate Sumerian by several thousand years and that proto-cuneiform Sumerian was rudimentary Sumerian being invented after those people uncovered ancient cuneiform. I like this idea because we know that the Levant and Anatolia have been occupied continuously by pretty much the same haplogroups for over 12,000 years (Turkiye to Iraq to Palestine), and we also know that region has been conquered by many many different people, dynasties, and invaders: from England to China everyone has been conquering the Middle-East (which I find sad). But the reality is: Gobekli Tepe was built by these people's ancestors; so was Jericho, and the original Temple Mount (long before Solomon). Those people cut and shaped megaliths, we just lost the writings of how they did it. And they may have invented cuneiform 12,000 years or more ago.

[@eddyr1041]

These should be a digitizing program to preserve all of these , or maybe there are? If so I would love to get a copy, very intrigued and always interested in language as I often applied it to automaton(programming computer)😊❤

[@kevin-e5h5t]

The land of written language, of 7 day week, of Mathematics. In the modern era, the land of genetic diversity. The home of the urban nomads and gypsy. Long before the Middle Eastern, and Egyptian cultures, the Indus Valley existed 7,000 years ago.

[@philippebruyere7918]

Excellent !!!!! Merci mille fois

[@Tsahalal]

J'aime le pâté de campagne aux champignons et les documentaires sur les animaux

[@edward2175]

Thank you for a fascinating journey through time. India continues to reveal her mysteries, bringing us closer to our brothers and sisters of the past. I will watch this brilliant documentary again and again.

[@mahmoodhassan392]

Not so called Indian civilization, Indus valley civilization had more connections with Persian Middle Eastern and Near Eastern civilizations than what is today's Endia, It's Pakistani civilization

[@jaychetra3250]

@@mahmoodhassan392 Bullshit, you’re a religious fanatic

[@naturetubepk4289]

Not India thanks Pakistan!

[@kevinildarolu1934]

Super reportage merci ❤

[@luciahelenawfreitas1469]

Muito bom. Documentário excelente. Contudo, há trechos, muito longos, sem tradução, espero que outros sejam traduzidos na íntegra. Gratidão e parabéns do Brasil.

[@jardiniersolitaire7108]

Excellent documentaire. Merci. Je partage.

[@JoségilbertoVasquez-i9k]

Felicitaciones lo explica muy bien y es entendí le ❤

[@Celler2]

this was a great watch, ty for delivering the information as it comes without distorting the facts.

[@montserratserranobanon3789]

Gracias por el magnífico documental. Aunque, debo de decir, que la carencia de subtítulos en las locuciones en francés me han dejado una parte sin saber. El resto, ha sido genial! Gracias

[@maurohari1036]

x2

[@juliocesarsantacruzrojas2319]

X3

[@roberta9833]

Thank you very much! 😃👏👏💐🙏

[@GH-yp3vd]

fascinant en tous points cette civilisation!

[@pathanshajahan4177]

🙏🙏🙏🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳 thanks the great information.

[@nutier]

Amazing video that I like ! Thank you for sharing . Hare Krishna Hare Krishna , Krishna Krishna Hare Hare ! Hare Rama Hare Rama , Rama Rama Hare Hare !

[@leonidsarest165]

Shiva!

[@alvaroborja8077]

Buen vídeo!!

[@12TribesUnite]

How interesting! Thank you!

[@utilisatricectout]

Je ne comprends pas comment pouvons-nous dire qu'on a évolué ? Cela fait 5000 quinzaine population a réussi cet exploit avec des moyens très sommaires. Alors que nous actuellement, nous excellons à nous investir dans des créations qui courent à notre perte 😓😓😓

[@jfk9422]

N’hésite pas à consulter… on soigne beaucoup de névroses de nos jours

[@svanimation8969]

bro indus valley so large this places like financial districts of rich people there where outside vilages too the indus valley spread all over like in milions of square kilometer

[@svanimation8969]

so mostly poor peoples and peasant build it there were ancient universities in india search about them taxshila nalanda after 1200 year ago indian education system got banned by muslim invaders learn about burning of taxshila and nalanda vikaramshila and many more unrecorded places of knowledge

[@alejandrasantos5361]

Magnífico documental

[@jpwski9425]

❤ Dziękuję za dodanie języka polskiego, pozdrawiam

[@NicolasDudic-ph4kd]

Thank you so much Excellent vidéo!!👍

[@eddydesmecht3737]

Ces gens étaient définitivement plus malins qu'aujourd'hui !

[@orlando5163]

A civilização mental, agora totalmente esquecida .ainda existe no nosso cérebro ,como telepatia , telecinesia , os nossos sonhos , movimento de de estruturas a distância etc...isto sem os cérebros terem nenhuma educação nesse sentido . É tão primordial a nossa tecnologia atual , utilização das matérias pelo braço, utilizando máquinas, não deixa de ser transformação primordial. Regredimos no que já tínhamos alcançado. Tudo o que precisamos de máquinas para avançar tecnologicamente. O cérebro só por si chegava .o ser de energia pura.

[@thierrygrimoud4798]

Exactement

[@rafareds7010]

Gracias por un video interesante en lengua castellana

[@Aytun3553]

Ben çok çok beğendim belgeseli,seslendirme tercüme ses harika,emeği geçen yüreğine sağlık teşekkürler Esenlikler BRAVOOO 👏👏👏👍🙏🤗

[@Richardbutticus]

Thanks for the mention!

[@MariosGalvezf]

Precioso documental de una cultura que nos depara grandes descubrimientos quizas en re aus muros esten los codigos que faltan ,quizas el mapa original diga algo

[@Luz-fw1qm]

Que increíbles civilizaciones las antiguas tan tecnológicas y en Europa en la edad media no tenían drenaje y la vida era muy insalubre.

[@gonzaloandres8971]

La escritura del valle del Indo parece coincidir con la escritura Rongo Rongo de la Isla de Pascua.

[@kevinshamrok]

Why is the English narrator given English subtitles but not for the sections in French?

[@WeTheLittlePeople]

Please allow subtitles for other language speakers -- cant subscribe until you do.

[@joselreyes1127]

Que suerte de hablar ingles español y frances para entender toda la informacion tan interesante

[@sathi6320]

One of the best utube on this topic but a bit of translation on French expert speaking would hv gone the mile. A bit weak on the identity of its people which was alluded by JM the Brit-India archaeologist credited with its discovery who was the head of IAS of India in 1924. And also on why and how it ended which was alluded to by a few of Brits in this field. Thank god for them. The single most brilliant point in this utube was the stamp. But you omitted to say it was as tiny as 1x1 in square stamp. Bravo the "holder" of the stamp was shown.

[@WeTheLittlePeople]

Hope you connect the dots to Jiroft, and the archeological evidence that ties Harappan to Jiroft culture -- to Uruk. These were the West, Middle and Eastern worlds.

[@Kel-d7v]

You guys are going to have to hire an interpreter because even the closed-caption can't pick up what the French man is saying. It, like me, only recognizes the accent. Other than that, great video, though. I really enjoyed it, and I will probably watch it again

[@wilmerbecerra4812]

Muy, muy bueno este documental. Sabía de Harappa y Mohenjo Dharo, pero no de Dholavira.

[@vickieselep9725]

I liked this video and the voice-over was English and there were English captions for the most part, but there was these sections with a French expert that had no captions and were not translated. I think they were important sections, so why not have captions or a voice over that matched the rest of the video

[@ceciliacotta5035]

La civilización del Oxus también contaba con estanques en sus ciudades, creo. Posiblemente en un comienzo estos estanques sirvieran para cría de peces, que los habitantes cuidaban en común y pescaban según la necesidad para alimentarse, y también para cultivar vegetales en balsas, como las chinampas americanas, teniendo cada familia su furnte de alimentos asegurada con poco esfuerzo y evitando la descomposición del agua quieta así como reduciendo su evaporación mientras se dota al entorno de frescura y oxígeno con las plantas exhuberantes gracias a la abundante disposición de agua... un jardín edible, el Edén!

[@HebeBonelli]

Interesante video😊 lástima las partes en francés no traducidas!!

[@sobennymariablandonromana9093]

Excelente información

[@cattymajiv]

Long sections in French with no subtitles make it impossible to understand a lot of this show! Why did they translate some of it, but leave large areas untranslated? That makes no sense!

[@SJking-gk4go]

Awesome, this valley is an extension of Ancient Khemet and Mesopotamia. Would have been great to have lived there. But of course some catastrophic events drove them away from this site. 😊

[@thehawkseye3412]

Extension? .. They were different civilizations.. Quote below "The Indus Valley Civilization (IVC) was much larger than Mesopotamia, covering 1.2 million square kilometers compared to Mesopotamia's 65,000 square kilometers. The IVC was known for its towns and citadels, while Mesopotamia was known for its religious temples and art.The Mesopotamians practiced polytheism and built temples for worship, while the Indus Valley people may have practiced a polytheistic religion but no special places of worship have been found...."

[@SJking-gk4go]

@thehawkseye3412 no one is talking in terms of distance. Learn to read and understand.

[@thehawkseye3412]

@@SJking-gk4goBack at you sir. Learn to read and understand better. I don't know why you are talking about distance when no one brought it up Also learn to pick your words more carefully. Extension has a specific meaning.

[@SJking-gk4go]

​@@thehawkseye3412you clearly don't understand my comment, or the meaning of the word *extension* How unfortunate for your pride.

[@organik1535]

🖖😘merciiiii

[@oO-_-_-_-Oo]

I left my heart in India and I've never even been there.

[@hectorcontestabile]

es muy interesante el documental, pero faltan subtitulos para entenderlo por completo. muy eurocentrico. si usaroa IA, muy mala o mal utilizada

[@thelastaustralian7583]

As our current 'World' Civilisation is evolving, as other 'Primal dominant Civilisations came and went .....

[@ziekassoumcoulibaly1952]

C'est simboles signifie :l'entré de l'HOMME et leurs protecteur !❤❤

[@danielurvoy433]

Symbole

[@Cryptidfinder]

🙋🏼‍♀️ can anyone tell me how they managed to make water fountains I think that would be an interesting video too 💭

[@theobolt250]

Please can you provide english subtitles for the french spoken parts? I don't speak french!

[@richardhuin3201]

@@theobolt250 you have it !

[@jnswarrior]

Muito Top!

[@veralpereira]

Vídeo muito bom

[@Khagun_Kalki]

Wider if they found any mummies or bodies of humans and animals that could be dna tested, would be cool to know which people and animals were there ❤

[@joe8256]

estupendo ; pero ¿ porqué no se traduce lo hablado en francés y otros idiomas ?

[@Trinath_Narayan]

0:48 500 years ??? Its mature phase alone is approx. 700 yrs..

[@Hallands.]

Fascinating, but why would such a well arranged and fertile system of water handling ever be given up? Were the inhabitants killed off in wars, perhaps? Oh, the earthquake moved the Ghaggar-Hakra River! Disaster!

[@mirzaamuhammadmaaazbinshaahid]

Please reupload with English subtitles for french

[@nv9991]

Add English subtitles and English audio files for French-speaking experts.

[@OscarBertola-f4w]

Dans la minute 27:30 vous montrez des images des outils en fer, et peu de temps après, qu'ils maîtrisaient le cuivre et le bronze. Alors, à ma connaissance le fer ne fait son apparition que autour de 1200 aJC, par les Hittites. D' autre part, sans fer, on ne peut pas faire de planches de bois, car avec cuivre ou bronze est impossible de faire des scie à bois, pour y couper en mainces panneaux. Est-ce qu'on a trouvé beaucoup de sel dans les fonds des bassins? Le soleil ardent devait évaporer rapidement l' eau, comme dans les salins au bord de mer, laissant une couche de sel.

[@regentmad1037]

subtitles for frenchy would be nice

[@lindacondray7918]

Please translate or set up subtitles for parts spoken in French.

[@香料國境]

Brilliant

[@JeanReboul361]

Il y a 5000 ans le climat n’était pas du tout le même, sur ces terres le climat ainsi que la végétation devaient plutôt se rapprocher du climat français actuel. De même pour la Mésopotamie et l’Égypte. La vie était luxuriante sur ces terres, comme au printemps.

[@bpmalanadu7136]

They did not come from the border regions of Persia. Manu, the first man/king was from deep south of India according to ancient Hindu texts. If they came from elsewhere then, it would have been kept in the memory/Purana's. There where no such a thing in any Hindu texts instead it speaks mainly of the land between Himalaya and the Indian Ocean.

[@ВладЯкимов-и2т]

Фильм интересный, жаль что так плохо перевели, ни что эксперт говорит, ни что вмпесне поётся ничего не понятно

[@naturetubepk4289]

This civilization was mainly in current Pakistan! Don't associate current India with it, they are just the beneficiary of the expansion of this civilization. India and Pakistan are now two different countries.

[@RONIT848]

BELONGS TO HINDU NOT PAKISTANIS THEY ARE NOT SOUTH ASIAN GENETIC

[@AlfredoEsparza-z2f]

? Y en donde dejas aLos AZTECAS Y MAYAS DE NORTEAMETICA MEJICANA ?? salutez desde Aguascalientes City , ) USMA )

[@wmartin-rk2hb]

China 2! 5.000 Years pottery factory has been found.

[@ricardorezende8210]

Top!!@

[@akhil999in]

the end of ivc might have been due to gradual moving away to better places over many generations, due to change in river indus the rain water harvesting, reservoirs and wells would have allowed life of a reduced number, therefore no recording of a catastrophy.

[@dominiquehuot-fp3dd]

Une des 3 premières cités états de ceux qui sont venus du ciel.

[@bh8737]

Subtitles are not right

[@OscarBertola-f4w]

Observations : --celle ci n'est pas la seule disparition mystérieuse d'une ancienne civilisation, sans laisser de motivation compréhensible. La civilisation camboyenne de Angkor, aussi entourée par des grands bassins, et de magnifiques palais, temples, et édifices. La civilisation Maya, disparue déjà à l' arrivée des Espagnols vers 1520. La civilisation de Sumer, d' Ur et Lagash. La civilisation de Indiens Pueblo, et Anasazi, en Colorado USA.

[@FitzHobb]

Eine KI Übersetzung in die jeweilige Landessprache könnte sich lohnen, die Stimmen sind ja inzwischen durchaus hörbar

[@vronski59]

English subtitles please.

[@विश्र्वकर्माजी]

कल का सिंधु आज हिन्दू है Yesterday was sindhu (indus) today called hindu (sanaatan drm)

[@hannaberaja3682]

Mercy 🤗💕

[@Rajput-Sunny-r1o]

Ye Indus valley civilization he hme garv he be hmre purvj thay vanshj he dhanywaad bhut zldi kamyab hoge hm jai shree ram 😊

[@ZeynelKurt-y2o]

Avrupa’da Medeniyet Mi Varmış? Hiç Duymamıştım❤

[@EricDilaj-qb1ep]

Bonsoir, pas quand Europe, le béton... Sans occupe les tentatives d'effacement des mémoires, écocides... Sans nourrissent.( Entre les tribulations) .😢 ( Cité téléphone.) Bonne soirée

[@PietroColombo-em5mz]

Around 2.500 b.c. the Minoan civilization rised in southern Greece. Some centuries before that, unknown peoples built Stonehenge in England. And around 11.000 (!!!) b.c. in Turkey were built Gobekly Tepe and Cathal Huyuk, but nobody knows anything about who made all that.

[@ralphpretorius3617]

🌹great information but a pity nobody could translate french to English,😠😠😠🌹🙏🐶😎

[@youknow6968]

Indus valley is a great Pakistani civilisation. Just look at the map.

[@gcallananpainting]

You know you don't know.

[@capitanovivian2258]

@@youknow6968 στη θέση του σημερινού Πακιστάν προϋπήρχαν άλλοι πολιτισμοί! Οπότε,μόνο πακιστανικός δεν είναι!

[@rohitshinde6362]

There was no partition btwn india And Pakistan in 5000yrs ago. There was akhand bharat 🇮🇳🕉

[@youknow6968]

@rohitshinde6362 😂 there was no bharat at any point in history, it's a religious fantasy based on fanciful stories. No country or nation called bharat ever existed in history.

[@rohitshinde6362]

@@youknow6968 I think you know the right meaning of Indus

[@ziekassoumcoulibaly1952]

Il se trouve a 10km de la ville sur le versant ouest un Domme de forme de pain. Une entrée séjour trouve sur le côté rous. Il peut voir le temps même quand le temps est oublié !-DIEU est grand !: vous lirais le livre du sage qui les a surpris en ses lieux -VIVE le CRÉATEUR !❤

[@thierrygrimoud4798]

Amen

[@MariaGarcia-gj5ie]

I wonder how they became buried under so much sand. Flooding?

[@MariaGarcia-gj5ie]

Never mind, the answer is the flooding 😅

[@ShoeString13]

More advanced than any super chip. SF/

[@rectotexto4586]

De quand date ce documentaire ?

[@eliinthewolverinestate6729]

Yeah as glaciers melted and planet warmed grow zones moved and so did people.

[@RazielEriel]

I didn’t know we had to know french in order to watch this😅

[@jtcizmar]

English translation would be nice