Important that both Hamas, Islamic Jihad on board for ceasefire: Marwan Bishara

[@annkristoff4303]

Reconstruction of Gaza back into an open-air prison?

[@JackFieldBand]

The Palestinians need to understand that Gaza is their homeland, not an open air prison. If I walked around thinking that my town was an open air prison I would be miserable too.

[@yulmamunoz9317]

De que habla prisión que los tenía hamas? Israel salió en el 2005

[@geoms6263]

But isn't Israel a big open-air prison? surrounded by concrete walls?

[@ianalan4367]

annkristoff4303 - If Gaza is an open air prison then Hamas is the warden.

[@ntme9]

Egypt could open one side

[@dualquadable]

can you trust Netanyahu? He has to survive politically.

[@stevenschachman7149]

Can you trust Hamas? They break every ceasefire

[@AdamJohnson-h8q]

​@@AY-uf4ozcitation needed.

[@gemmameidia8438]

Melakowski

[@bradchoi662]

Neither trust him, but AL jazeera has any credibility regarding their support of the Hamas terror organisation, simply blaming isreal trying not to lose their job in Qatar; this is a government organisation where ther's no freedom exists.

[@eypu999]

He’s untrustworthy

[@nikkster01]

isnt it more important that for once the warmongers are on board since they have rejected everything so far and isnt it FAR MORE important that Gaza and West Bank get to declare the formation of their state and the occupiers and land stealers leave both forever all I see is a desperate US govt trying to avoid election trouble ahead

[@johnsmith7140]

Gaza was annexed from Egypt; west Bank from Jordan

[@FurianXX]

@@johnsmith7140 : and before that it was Palestine...

[@CALLUMJACKSON-hm7hp]

FREE PALESTINE

[@Chloe12875]

Free from hypocrisy and stupidity 🤣🤣🤣

[@punchthem4582]

There is no such place but nice try

[@Athens0709]

What else you wish for buddy?

[@scarlettkhan9667]

Free Palestine 🇵🇸

[@Athens0709]

@@scarlettkhan9667 free Israel 🇮🇱

[@a.t.6783]

The complete withdrawl of the troops should be included in phase 1, no?

[@JackFieldBand]

Fantasy.

[@Godislove-m5w]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@Xyzxyzxyz-oy7bk]

Yes because the Israelis are not to be trusted they will attack back ones the hostages are released blaming Hamas once again as in the case of Al ahli hospital attack

[@WakumakoKo-zq8vb]

Certainly yes! We used toThis colonialism and imperialism project treachery

[@a.t.6783]

@@WakumakoKo-zq8vb i believe that as long as the total retreat of the occupation troops isn t clearly detailed in the plan, it means there is a trap.

[@naymatunc-rc6vs]

The last time was it also Israël that rejected the seas fire and blaimed the palestian resistance

[@noamto]

No it wasn't. Why are you lying?

[@AmFlstnChai]

@@noamtoHamas literally accepted a deal at the beginning of the Rafah Invasion but Israel declined.

[@noamto]

@@AmFlstnChai no they didn't, they changed the deal that was proposed. And they also intentionally drug it on for 2 weeks. Why are you lying? And why are you supporting them in the first place?

[@AmFlstnChai]

@@noamto But Hamas accepted that changed deal and Israel declined, no? Use your brain please and maybe learn how to read. Nothing I said was false. And no I don’t support them but I support the truth. Throwing blind accusations doesn’t help your cause either.

[@IiyakMolang]

Changing the deal is not acceptance. you are lying.

[@mehruneusufzai2341]

Thank you so much Mr. Marwan Bishara and Ms. Lila for the updates on the Gaza Cease fire deal. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@gemmameidia8438]

Hamas agreed before and it was israel who refused. Now hamas already agreed, what will israel said. Palestine just wanted to be free, these israel should just leave gaza, what is so hard about it? 🙄

[@arcsolomon6360]

they already left gaza 2005 whats your problem?

[@Xyzxyzxyz-oy7bk]

@@arcsolomon6360in your dreams

[@magansingodia8511]

Thank you Al Jazeera and of course Marwan Bishara.

[@neelamshahwar4137]

We want immediately permanent ceasefire.

[@GreatOga]

Not so fast

[@myrtillesm3532]

And reparation for Palestinians land as a whole

[@neelamshahwar4137]

@@myrtillesm3532 I couldn't understand , what are you saying reparations for what ?

[@abubakarbetts7906]

Few hours later Netanyahu said no ceasefire because his political career is on the line

[@Joyce-zl4qd]

Or he is protecting Israel

[@robinuk1949]

@@Joyce-zl4qd lMAO

[@malusa9508]

The problem is not Hamas is the IDF and Netanyaho trying to stay in power.

[@ALLAHSHAHAADA]

Exactly I don't why some people don't understand that 😡

[@77kromah]

The problems are ham-as fault

[@ALLAHSHAHAADA]

@@77kromah Let's start from the beginning. Why did your parents flee Europe to force themselves in Palestine?

[@77kromah]

@@ALLAHSHAHAADA haha😂. God give them that land

[@johnsmith7140]

Lol

[@icomment-tq6xh]

thanks for the millionth reminder of why you are not reporting from Israel.

[@robinuk1949]

Some democracy Israel is

[@Mr.BlackSanta]

Hamas has no choice and must leave. Israel has them checkmated.

[@TaraWhelan-v7h]

You clearly have no idea how resistance works!

[@jfern6673]

If Hamas wont accept then the people will keep suffering.. Thats the bottom line, can wish and dream for anything else but it wont happen..

[@jeanneparadise8200]

Free Palestine. Prayers for protection of Palestinians and sincere negotiations. Americans hate the genocide.

[@charlesouma5357]

Just tell Hamas to comply with the UN Resolution. Hamas cannot ammend the UN resolution.

[@andrewparnell6656]

Does Iran agree is the problem !

[@scarlettkhan9667]

I think the colonisation is the issue. You can’t remove people just for oil and land grab. It’s 2024. USA and Isrel are working partners trying to do this. It’s very sad. People should be left to live in peace.

[@Celeblidotcom]

Hamas rejected the deal. Why are you spinning this?

[@johnsmith7140]

It's a fake-news jihad channel, dude

[@kennethdruhan3563]

Exactly right

[@genuineargyle]

Hamas changed the terms of the ceasefire proposal. No deal.

[@ade008]

Lol... Hamas insisted IDF must fight them man to man. Israel rejected. 😁

[@tethergobrrr]

They didn’t change any terms. They are clarifying the timeline of full withdrawal.

[@Xyzxyzxyz-oy7bk]

They want full withdrawal of army which is unclear in the proposal because us and Israeli are hypocrites

[@never_give_up944]

Why do you lot always lie and undertake hasbara? Have some shame....

[@razaneroza2041]

Hamas didn't change anything, their demands is clear from Oct 7, an exchange deal of hostages and the dismantle of the siege on Gaza, this is their goal not even a Palestinian state and still Israel refuse that

[@jeffreyschwarz3699]

Terrible deal to release the terrorists and allow Hamas to regroup. Israel would be crazy to agree to it.

[@SabasitenAkter]

Great coverage thank you

[@johnsmith7140]

Lol

[@neelamshahwar4137]

Free Palestine.

[@daisychainsmusicpublishing4789]

Israel will of course refuse and blame Hamas on key points

[@johnsmith7140]

Hamas/AJ are the nazis of our time

[@arvingascarfamily8647]

Al Jazeera's journalist name is Abdallah Aljamal. 3 Israeli hostages are rescued from his house. Al jazeera is Hamas and Hamas is Al Jazeera

[@johnsmith7140]

Yep

[@TheXtacy78]

[@myrtillesm3532]

Negociation ought to be fair for both side. Equity, justice, respect, humanity for all can generate peace and security only

[@Palestine35617]

How shameless are you? You destroyed thousands of innocent Palestinians.Allah will pay for it one day!!! do not pray to Allah for. May Allah not forgive the sins of the oppressors 😢😢😢

[@lawkid5098]

Remember..remember the 7th of october

[@Unknown-bz1ky]

Yes and also remember the 6th the 5th and all the octobers n 12 months since 1946...propagandanist liars

[@ManawarHussain-h4q]

As usual Anthony Blinkin is pressuring hamas for Israel. No mention of last ceasefire proposal by USA which hamas accepted and Israel rejected. USA played crafty by UN resolution which Anthony Blinkin keeps repeating. Why is USA not pressure to accepting Hamas's proposal.

[@The-Man-Right-Chea]

😮😮😮😮 🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥Does anyone else find it interesting that you cannot spell Israel without the letters L-I-A-R-S 🤔 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔

[@BillsonChikuti]

Tell us about civilians holding hostages

[@tbd-5160]

The lesson we can take home from this is that if you attack another country and take captives, than they may not enjoy it.

[@truestcause]

the only lesson we learnt is who is who

[@MohamedAmin-zz8wo]

We have learnt who is evil

[@battles146]

Never forget or forgive - do the research 1. Haifa Massacre 1937 2. Al-Quds Massacre 1937 3. Haifa Massacre 1938 4. Balad Al-Sheikh Massacre 1939 5. Haifa Massacre 1939 6. Haifa Massacre 1947 7. Abbasiya Massacre 1947 8. Al-Khisas Massacre 1947 9. Bab Al-Amud Massacre 1947 10. Al-Quds Massacre 1947 11. Sheikh Bureik Massacre 1947 12. Deir Yassin Massacre 1948 13. Jaffa Massacre 1948 14. Tantura Massacre 1948 15. Al-Quds Massacre 1953 16. Khan Yunis Massacre 1956 17. Al-Quds Massacre 1967 18. Sabra and Shatila Massacre 1982 19. Al-Aqsa Massacre 1990 20. Ibrahimi Mosque Massacre 1994 21. Jenin Refugee Camp Massacre 2002 22. Gaza Massacre 2008-2009 23. Gaza Massacre 2012 24. Gaza Massacre 2014 25. Gaza Massacre 2018-2019 26. Gaza Massacre 2021 27. Gaza Holocaust 2023-present

[@lawkid5098]

​@@battles146 who started it??

[@Unknown-bz1ky]

Britain when they dumped the zionists in Palestine

[@lawkid5098]

Hamas: Israel should withdraw from the rafah crossing so we can can continue building our tunnels and smuggle more weapons 😂😂

[@BillsonChikuti]

What about civilians holding hostages?

[@alistair1840]

Hamas is not interested in negotiating, they had demanded the same thing since the war started. Negotiating is supposed to be give and take.

[@tethergobrrr]

Hms is negotiating with terrorists- they need to hold the line on certain principles.

[@stevenvanheemst9556]

Come on Al Jazeera ur the best! Support Independent reporter Bisan in Gaza Your a great news out let Just have your Anchors and executives donate to Bisan. We can't count on American Media

[@nathelondon3719]

Mawran a „Palestinian „ Christian living it up in Paris pontificating as usual. Perhaps he can explain why Christians say that Jesus a Jew was born in Bethlehem Judea city of David not Palestine. Or explain why Jerusalem is mentioned 600 times in the Bible but not once in the Koran?

[@jacquelinestapleton1414]

No..

[@neelamshahwar4137]

World couldn't be established the peace write now !

[@antwirosina8969]

If you want idf out.. let all hostages go.. thats why they are there in the first place

[@sayjustwordstome]

Israel will not retreat from Gaza

[@robbieandkimberly]

The captives are military, the prisoners are civilians, stop playing games Aljazeera!

[@koladesholaja8832]

All the children and old women plus little girl they kidnapped are military you are delusional

[@arcsolomon6360]

palestinians wanted this war...they got it

[@manzoor3890]

What a irritating reporter is she !!!

[@buddadavid480]

Free Free Palestine 🇵🇸 ♥️ 🙏

[@johnsmith7140]

Free the hostages, AJ!

[@stan3399]

By Gaza's safety Marwan means Hamas's safety 😅.. Hamas has intentionally caused the deaths of 40 thousand Palestinians and many more in the coming days...

[@johnsmith7140]

They are pure evil

[@scarlettkhan9667]

Huh I thought isrel dropped the 2000 pounders on Palestine? And dropped phosphorus on Palestine. I’m confused now.

[@Bowd-up5bw]

What happens if phase-one lasts longer than 3 fortnights ?

[@shoutoutph5227]

Palestinians and Lebanese are natives in the region while Isarelis are German people kicked out of Germany and brought to the region

[@larsstougaard7097]

The Palestinians have multiple composite ancestry, which does include Canaanite. Amongst their ancestors are the Peleset, Palashtu, Phoenician, and Philistine peoples, some of which are believed to have originated in Mycenaean Greece. So part of the Gaza population is Greek origin so maybe they could get Greek passport, would be beautiful. Ali of Athens bless you

[@genarosalazar2818]

You mess with Israel 🇮🇱 you're messing with God.

[@jerrymiller9039]

Hamas has to cease to exist for a ceasefire

[@johnsmith7140]

Indeed

[@Unknown-bz1ky]

For now looks like the israeli army is diminishing abd becoming handicapped!!

[@jerrymiller9039]

@@Unknown-bz1ky reality says otherwise

[@deadshotsplayground9088]

​@@jerrymiller9039whose reality? yours?

[@eng.reagan9540]

​@@deadshotsplayground9088Hamas is dwindling and diminishing everyday. Whether you like it or not, that is a clear fact.

[@aidenfisher5679]

Hamas has rejected d proposal

[@TheLegionsofScipioAmericanus]

No. You wanted war. You got it.

[@obaid9791]

Israel soldier hamas Islamic jihad?

[@l-uk3xm]

Why is Gaza surrendering? The fight it not over, it's just begun. You guys need to fight, not lay down your weapons and fall to Israel. You deserve the land, not Israel. Instead, you're giving it all to Israel. How is it not a disgrace?

[@johnsmith7140]

👈 obviously lives far from gaza

[@l-uk3xm]

@@johnsmith7140 Who, the guy? He's in France. Of course, not in Gaza. Why would he be there. Much easier to issue rallying calls from the Eifel Tower.

[@johnsmith7140]

@@l-uk3xm indeed

[@zmaschannel4808]

Let me provide you with the actual history and I challenge anyone to make a real argument against anything I say because everything is documented fact. The 1948 war was not one war but two that blended together. The first stage of the war was when indigenous Jews from the Holy Land invited refugees fleeing the aftermath of Hitler’s Europe to live in the country. They were from there and they had every right to invite whoever they wanted. The Arabs who lived there who would later become what you refer to as the Palestinians viewed the newly invited Jews as invaders even though the Jews did not attack the Arabs. (You could also make the argument that the Arabs were the real invaders as Islam arrived in the Holy Land in the 7th century. That is why you can find 3000 year old Jewish temples in Israel but you can’t find any ruins belonging to Arabs from that time period because they arrived much later to spread their culture.). The Jews would go on to defeat the Arabs in the first stage of the war and this is when the event called the Nakba took place. The Nakba is a real historical event that the Pro Palestine side is obsessed with because during this event the Palestinians were expelled from their homes. They never bring up though that the Palestinians were expelled from their homes within the context of war. They make it sound like Jews just went door to door kicking innocent people from their homes. In war when you lose, much of the time you will lose land and resources. Most borders on Earth were formed from wars. The expelled Palestinians would be forced to move to Gaza and the West Bank in where they endured a brutal Israeli occupation. Just kidding 😂 Egypt occupied Gaza and Jordan occupied the West Bank until the 1960s. Most of the Palestinians were actually kicked out of Jordan because immediately after they arrived they tried to overthrow the Jordanian government. The Palestinians were then expelled to Lebanon where they to this day are forced to live in camps they are not allowed to leave under occupation from the Lebanese. Yes, Lebanon ironically occupies Palestinians while claiming to support them. In fact, the only place in the Middle East a Palestinian is not allowed to become a doctor is Lebanon not Israel. The second stage of the war was when 5 Arabs nations declared war on Israel after independence was officially announced. Of the five, three sent armies and all three armies were wiped out. This is how the state of Israel was formed. Since then there has been an endless cycle of Israel’s neighbors and the Palestinians declaring war on Israel, then losing those wars , then acting like they were the victims who did not initiate the war. Restarting a war from the 1940s because you don’t like that your side was on the losing side is not very wise. It would be like Japan declaring war on the US because they lost in 1945. They could make the argument the US committed genocide saying the US military killed millions of Japanese including tens of thousands killed from the nuclear bombs. I think what is the most interesting thing to me about the pro Palestine crowd is the selective outrage. I will use the Syrian Civil War as an example. The Syrian Civil War is a conflict that is going on currently that literally is only a few miles from Gaza. The entire State of Israel is only the size on the US state of New Jersey. In the Syrian Civil war 600,000 people have been killed. The majority of those people were innocent civilians. That is a number that is literally 20x greater than the Gaza death toll but it is intentionally ignored. That example shows my problem with the Pro Palestine crowd … I would like them if they were actually peace activists but most of them are in reality political activists trying to give one side an advantage.

[@leonharrison800]

No ceasefire while Israel and America continues to exist.

[@johnsmith7140]

Lol

[@Godislove-m5w]

And who cares😂😂😂

[@leonharrison800]

@@johnsmith7140 Truth telling matters. Learn the history.🇵🇸

[@johnsmith7140]

@@leonharrison800 OK hamas bot 👌

[@leonharrison800]

​@@johnsmith7140 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

[@mariomadrigal134]

He is such a terrible man. Living in Paris and trying to talk about what they should do. Hamas is scared!!! They are running!!

[@truestcause]

First step.. Israel withdraw from Gaza.

[@TURKIYE553]

Hahah never

[@truestcause]

@@TURKIYE553 whats funny?

[@ianalan4367]

truestcause - Israel pulled out of Gaza back in 2005 - Hamas took control in 2006 Hamas attacked on Oct 7th during a ceasefire. Israel leaving Gaza will be the last step.

[@truestcause]

@@ianalan4367 Sure about that?

[@ianalan4367]

truestcause - I am sure that Hamas broke the ceasefire when they attacked on Oct 7th

[@kamranaspasajevas4650]

Free Palestin

[@GreatOga]

If there's no amendment to the proposal it will fly. Withdrawal from gaza is not an instruction hamas can give to Israel.

[@Musa-lr7qw]

😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@Godislove-m5w]

Aj jonourist hidding hostages 😂😂😂

[@ELJason2006]

Oh yea let’s include other bs terrorist organizations on this deal

[@Athiest610]

I believe Gaza should have a port and airport also, they should have their own Passport and the people should be allowed to travel freely, without all these it will still be an open air prision, Isreal should give peace a chance and respect the Oslo accords and 1967 borders dismantling all the illegal settlements.

[@SKk-bg1yj]

The analyst wants another Oct7th?ha..ha

[@Starry_i_CPT]

Reject the plan. Esp if it comes froM uS Gov.

[@Ian.549]

Stop it! Send into Gaza a of coalition of nations to help the people of Gaza now! today! Then they can keep on talking like they have daily for 8 months during witch time thousands of innocent people have died at their hands.

[@SKk-bg1yj]

Ja..ha..ha..palestinian rights to destroy Israel..ha..ha

[@scarlettkhan9667]

Who is doing land grab? Isrel is trying to steal all of palestine 🇵🇸

[@Athens0709]

Why anyone is talking with those bandits of hahaha.mamama.s

[@FarukKhan-fo1dp]

israil will not withraw from gaza.

[@scarlettkhan9667]

Why? They are obsessed with them I think

[@tbd-5160]

The lesson we can take home from this is that if you attack another country and take captives, than they may not enjoy it.

[@truestcause]

pssst... ur not teaching lessons to school children.

[@tbd-5160]

@@truestcause You're* It's a combination of "You" & "Are". Jesus, learn the only language that matters.

[@truestcause]

@@tbd-5160 yea Jesus is the only language that matters

[@ThatGuyOnFireKnownAsAndrew]

@@tbd-5160we still have 7 million up on yall 🔥🔥🔥😂😂😂😂

[@lookbovine]

Wait, there are TWO countries that are involved?