Gilgo Beach Murders Suspect Allegedly Left Creepy Voicemail

Rex Heuermann, the Manhattan architect charged with three of the Gilgo Beach murders, left a chilling voicemail to a woman that she says creeps her out even today. Interior designer Dominique Vidal says she was in a networking group with Heuermann. She says he actually discussed the murders with her. Vidal says Heuermann left her a bizarre voicemail after she quit the group because she did not want to be around him. Heuermann has pleaded not guilty. Inside Edition's Les Trent has more.

[@paulchezkari6952]

She dodged a bullet by dropping out of that group. Women need to listen to your creep meter.

[@aeptacon]

😂

[@Menace2Society9]

Women call men creeps all the time over nothing.. a average or ugly guy could hit on a female. She'll say he's a creep. If a hot guy hits on her, it's fine..

[@paulchezkari6952]

@@Menace2Society9 the dude is married and a lot older than her, not sure about the looks.

[@amylynn831]

​@musicman7935 not true..you can sense someone is a creep. Men that want women to like them use your excuse.

[@Menace2Society9]

@@amylynn831 lmao many females have been asked about this and said yes they call the average/ugly guy a creep.. so you're wrong.

[@angelanderson9515]

Dude has been at this for 13 years 🤦‍♂️ wow

[@janeclayton151]

Could be the tip of the iceberg

[@floodlime8620]

That voicemail is the kind of thing that probably wouldn’t seem out of line to most men but would be creepy for a woman to receive.

[@Hope-xl3qm]

So sick and creepy!

[@mannygonzalez4178]

Not defending him but that was definitely not a creepy voicemail. 🤦‍♂️

[@hydemom811]

attention seeking drama forsure

[@aeptacon]

it actually is. He has no reason tobcall her and leave her a voicemail. and he is pursuing her even after she left the group

[@Googleme10718]

Definitely not

[@KarenPatrol123]

I mean YEAH it doesn’t sound like a bad voicemail but she was in his presence and felt creeped out prior to that voicemail. . . So it got weird when you hear the back story….. but then again he probably wasn’t aware of her feeling that way clearly he was curious about what happened to her. But anyways …. He’s a creep bottom line.

[@aeptacon]

I think he is aware of him creeping her out, but some people like to confront and do that for the sake of it. control like that forensic guy said

[@rubberbiscuit99]

We must figure out how to identify these monsters so we can prevent the harm they do to individuals and to society as a whole.

[@joshuavang5449]

How?

[@zhouzen5172]

White ppl. First

[@manofmystery5709]

Like Minority Report? Arrest people for crime they've yet to commit? Based on the shape of their head or psychic vibes from a clairvoyant?

[@carlose6010]

They tried this in the 1600's with "witches". But more big brother and we can be safer, cameras everywhere does help.

[@kittenpawsbb]

Looking at the list of women he murdered. She does fit right in with the type of women he was targeting. So glad she didn’t stick around him, after getting those creepy vibes. So many women try to please and not come off as rude. You don’t owe anyone the benefit of the doubt. Men as well.

[@JoyfulElephant]

You call the "Creepy Voicemail"? What is creepy about that? Lol

[@elwalker9034]

...& I thought my storage unit was expensive. No more fussin outta me.

[@zoe6723]

Hope police question the first wife. Second wife seems clueless.

[@reviewithme9913]

He's lucky Dexter didn't get to him first

[@jacashalot3441]

Creep!

[@pepsico815]

This is the creepiest news coverage I've ever seen.

[@christinebee9781]

I don’t get what was creepy about the voicemail. Also, for an architect, his home looks pretty low rent.

[@annabanabanana]

No chilling voicemail. Just him leaving a message for her to call him back. Lol. Media misleading as usual, making it seem like he left some cryptic clue or weird VM. 😂

[@Uwolz]

Got make this about herself real quick. That voicemail wasn’t creepy smh.

[@naturewalkchannel]

That voicemail was creepy because he hesitated. He sounded flaky and nervous... Why do they always have beady eyes? His body language and eye movement was suspicious. Good for her she detected it... He has a good head of hair though lol

[@bobert8125]

"This bizarre voicemail" wasn't even bizarre? Like huh? Try harder.

[@jrosina1]

He certainly looks like one ..

[@annmoore8696]

Ohhh My! What a Sick and Evil Person 😢

[@stevemichael9318]

Years ago I heard about these Long Island murders and the killer was never caught. Finally after all these years they got him! Hope he rots in jail!

[@erinboateng5961]

What a sick person. Honestly, you have a everything you could ever want in life and yet you want to torment others. Why?

[@requiem47-hw1no]

Called sadism

[@rocroc]

Interesting. I read about these murders long ago but didn't really know any details. This report says the killer dismembered the victims. It is also reported that the wife and daughter of the suspected killer were out of town when these murders were committed. If that's true, he had to have dismembered the victims someplace and that kind of evidence is nearly impossible to completely dispose of. I would say it was done at the house or one of two reported storage facilities. I suspect they already have the evidence on these killings and perhaps some if not all of the other killings as well.

[@Jesuisderetour88]

You’re a clever one.

[@MissDashwood1]

Keith Morrison's summer vacation just ended

[@danjo8673]

What about his wife's DNA found on 3 of the bodies? I only heard one news agency mention that once & haven't heard anything else about it since.

[@BibleArtFashion]

Apparently she was traveling each time one of the 3 women went missing. What may have happened is the hair from inside the home got attached to the burlap.

[@flameex1708]

Ok, but that voice mail wasn't "creepy"? Like it sounded pretty ordinary.

[@NomadByNecessity]

Inside Edition.. please what is/was CREEPY about THAT voicemail? Christ! Sometimes you can be just outright uninformative.

[@shilohsv1deos]

Idk but just knowing he killed them and hearing his voice “HEY!” Like.. I don’t know it’s just creepy

[@sandravalani359]

I am so grateful that thiS pyscho was finally got!👍👍👍

[@ronstallworth9421]

He is a despicable pos, but the voice mail was very normal.

[@zeloacraft9486]

And a profile of hundreds more. It sounds like he's implying that he would have solved the case solo. I think he means that the killer was confident and knew he wouldn't be disturbed.

[@joegug4751]

Put him in general lock up, give him a taste.

[@GorillaWithACellphone]

He likely won’t be. He’s probably going to be put in 23 hour lockdown for both security and safety reasons

[@Mo-ln6li]

He lured them with money because that's all they care about.

[@joshuavang5449]

Cared

[@MR.GetOVERiT333]

THE TYPICAL BUNCH

[@adamben-shimon7513]

The telephone call was not creepy at all.

[@orangewarm1]

It's not that creepy. It's creepy because he's a suspect.

[@kimberlycornelius7911]

Can you imagine being his wife and kids hearing this

[@albertangeloro5832]

there is nothing creepy about the voicemail.

[@jenniferreynolds9333]

Lucky she didn’t buddy up with him.

[@aililenak]

That profile was from Mr Clement. I guess he didn't copyright it.

[@justhere4721]

They really need to find something more than speculation on him.

[@GolDGreg]

Pretty much all the interactions besides the voicemail were the creepy part. Typical sounding voicemail. That’s perhaps the worst part.

[@SouthernSass51]

How was that creepy 😂 I mean he's a pos, but that call is not creepy

[@sharongibson1161]

Hope he gets all that's due to him

[@mayssaqra3311]

Thank god you got away girl omg

[@jenniferreynolds9333]

Crazy wow.

[@johncollins6437]

I think the parents should give the punishment

[@FretlessMayhem]

That VM isn’t creepy whatsoever.

[@rysdananurkhalid1153]

O my god hes even on the google earth Man 😂

[@snowbunny426]

He is sick

[@nonamenoone1484]

Wow that sure was one hell of a “creepy” message… 🫢

[@naomiortiz5143]

Even the universe is giving clues. These girls clearly want to be found or have justice ❤️‍🩹

[@AlexLopez-bt7vd]

For years us from Long Island wondered about this killer. I remember driving past the crime scene trucks when they first discovered bodies not knowing more were going to be found. To know he lived only 15-20 minutes from me.... Glad they finally nailed this guy!

[@MR.GetOVERiT333]

THE REAL CULTURE OF NO ACCOUNTABILITY

[@napoleonbonerfart278]

A

[@bmc868]

Life is so boring in Long Island so Rex found a hobby.......

[@angelboogers]

Craazzyy they can get anything from anything google? Dammn

[@clairey6407]

It must feel very surreal. I remember watching a documentary about this case, years ago, and it stuck with me. I'm really glad they have caught this man. I hope the other murders will also be solved one day. I can't imagine living so near to a mystery like that. I hope his arrest brings some measure of relief to the families and the affected communities.

[@element720]

$600/mo for storage unit?? Now that’s criminal!

[@macnchessplz]

I don’t hear creepy in the voicemail.What I DO find creepy and disturbing is Rex discussed the LI murders with her and believe her when her intuition and gut feelings came about. Thankfully,she listened to those and left the group.

[@tee8839]

He’s never called her before and he’s calling her after she went out of her way to not see him again. You seriously don’t hear creepy knowing the context?

[@Thyunknownrising]

@@tee8839it just sounds like a business call

[@Vamatt99218]

Yup it doesnt sound creepy at all

[@alliechotikul1621]

it doesn’t sound creepy to me, in fact the opposite which i think is almost scarier. he’s so calm, an everyday average joe. any of us could’ve walked by him, held the door open for him, even had a conversation with him and we would’ve never known about his past. scary scary scary.

[@spacemanspliff7983]

​@@tee8839Nothing creepy about it except what you've now heard about him. If this came out 2 years ago its a normal voice mail. Get over yourself.

[@leokimvideo]

This monster needs to be thrown in jail for life and only fed burnt pizza crusts. What's scary here's a busy normal guy, hiding in plain sight yet had a completely secret other life. Very similar to the Killer Clown JW Jacey. I guarantee there will be many more victims connected to him.

[@kenstro216]

*Gacey

[@DangerousMoonlight]

@kenstro2269 Gacy**

[@stevenmurray7014]

Gacey.

[@scholaroftheworldalternatehist]

Sad thing is he gets to live while his victims have already rotted away

[@MR.GetOVERiT333]

👌👌👌👌THE GUY WHO BLAMES EVERYTHING BAD IN LIFE AND IN SOCIETY ON IMMIGRATION AND BLACK PEOPLE......BIRDS OF THE SAME FEATHER FLOCK TOGETHER 👌👌👌👌

[@painkiller7172]

He also searched for Gay Asian Males as shown on court filing page 18 document. One of the remains found near Gilgo Beach Matches that description.

[@JacobNightingale]

What, seriously? He's into Oriental males?? So he's bisexual? Holy phugg, this keeps getting better. Dahmer also offed an Oriental male, as I recall. I suspect Dahmer and this fella did Oriental males cause they're feminine and passive and remind the serial killers of women.

[@ThatBurnedCoconut]

That’s horrifying, my condolences to the families

[@kitkat3155]

He sounded friendly and professional on the voicemail, so glad this woman followed her gut instinct. 😨

[@CobraR1993]

Not to me. He said he had a question and wanted to "touch base " but he could have said what he wanted over the voice mail. He was vague on purpose in hopes that she would be curious and call him back.

[@milivapakovc4776]

​@@CobraR1993👍

[@cradohaps-bb5nd]

that was a decent voicemail nothing creepy about it

[@pearl3026]

@@CobraR1993not to me either .. if I was her id be wonder WHY he’s reached out after I’ve LEFT the group id find that rude and very arrogant of him as if I didnt like him I’d have let him KNOW in little ways I disliked him and id have been raging and disgusted he would just leave me a voice message telling me to get intouch 😖 🚩

[@Romulan2469]

He looks like an ogre or something. Andre The Giant's long lost son.

[@jeanneobbard]

That’s a very unsettling voicemail; it’s smarmy, fake, overly familiar, and sounds like he’s hitting on her/trying to get her to date him. It indicates he was paying close attention to her membership in this professional group, and he literally chases her after she left the group. As for all these people who can’t hear what’s wrong with it, I think their compass is broken, and I wonder what other bad behavior they’re ignoring. 👀

[@hodaka1000]

I heard when he shakes your hand he tries to crush it, I hate that

[@maritascoonbee8285]

It sounds creepy because we now know who he is, but I did pick up in his voice that he wants something from her - also unsettling is the way he said that he found out she is no longer working there.....a bit snarky though well masked.

[@bobert8125]

Huh? It's literally just a regular message any normal person would send. Nothing creepy about it. She's just tryna get clout even tho she has nothing to do with it. Is his baby sitter from when he was 9 gonna come out with a story next? Lol.

[@AAALLDAY07]

He is a real life monster, he should’ve been caught sooner

[@SimplyRaecosmetics]

man he's huge! very scary for those woman my god

[@ezzb]

Right? My exact thought. A Witness described him as "ogre looking", an interviewer said he was very strong, but I didn't realize how big he is. Those poor women.. who were petite btw.

[@lastpme]

I hope she saved the first voice message…also glad she dropped that group. Bringing up the murder case could have meant she was his next target.

[@marinda3262]

Exactly. Especially as he preferred blondes

[@keagan7538]

Inside edition played the voicemail... clearly she saved the message.

[@Saywahz]

@@keagan7538 Lmao for real 🧠

[@jiggnorth3593]

Oh, she was most definitely on his hit list.

[@diddyfaplord]

@@jiggnorth3593no. He targeted sex workers. Highly doubtful he would have harmed her being he could easily be linked to her.

[@shipwreck8847]

One of the creepiest things is the police found a painting of a blonde woman who looks like one of the victims but in the painting she is bruised with black eyes. So creepy gross.

[@hollymartinson-ui1ks]

Geez, i bet his wife must of loved that painting. The fact he was allowed to have that in his marital home shows she had no say or power in the marriage.

[@fartemisfartmallow8647]

I love how one of the witnesses from 13 years ago described him as an “ogre”.

[@Romulan2469]

It's a pretty accurate description. He is an oversized beast.

[@c.w.simpsonproductions1230]

He probably watched the Netflix film and laughed the whole time.

[@janetpattison8474]

Rex sounds completely normal, & friendly in his voice mail, but the woman knew more was going on with him. Clearly he had his eye on her and she knew it! Thank God she didn’t befriend him.

[@badazzbarbiePOV]

nah . considering the context clues . For him to call KNOWING she dropped out because of him and then to call and leave that message is creepy and kinda threatening

[@pearl3026]

That good old GUT INSTINCT again ladies always LISTEN TO IT .. and never apologise for saying the word NO , you shouldn’t feel guilty of bad for turning someone down or rejected them watch their actions when you say no , and be confident in your first decision 🙌🏾

[@ryv2484]

A photo of him talking to a stranger on the street and a not all that creepy voicemail? None of this is newsworthy.

[@robinkhalawan3564]

Because of her previous interactions with him, the voicemail would indeed sound creepy to her. She was disturbed enough to drop out of the meeting, because she considered him a weirdo and didn't want to be around him.

[@TeenWolfLore]

And she never said anything before, clout chasing

[@GorillaWithACellphone]

@@TeenWolfLorewhy would she say anything before? We only just recently found out he’s a suspect. Otherwise its just some random guy leaving a creepy message. Its different now knowing what he did and thats why its creepy

[@royalzak2670]

If he looked like Patrick Bateman she would be dead rn

[@timberline1487]

I think she was just creeped out by the attention from a menacing size older man who was married, unattractive and obviously sexually interested in her. Probably concerned about him making moves on her, not ending up in a burlap sack at the beach.

[@lizethmunoz7368]

It’s creepy after you know what he did to the other girls 🤦🏻‍♀️ thankfully she ignored him.

[@kenderyalclemons7792]

I have a question for you!!!

[@lizethmunoz7368]

@@kenderyalclemons7792 what is it? 🤔

[@sammyurom8399]

​@@lizethmunoz7368you're next

[@henmaidstale]

She is SO lucky. I feel bad for everyone affected by Rex's brutal actions. Glad the victim's families can rest a little easier. Great police work catching and detaining him without any of his 200 guns going off!

[@mauralinaherrera7914]

Evil the message maybe wasn't creepy enough but I think he was trying to get a hold of her.

[@WilliamLyons-ym7ee]

I wouldn’t necessarily say the voicemail was “creepy,” it was more that there was no reason for it. He had no reason to call her, other than the fact he was interested in her.

[@DetroitLionsStuff]

This is the kind of guy Dexter would go after.

[@justinhopper5941]

Uh yes.. he went after serial killers. That’s literally the plot to the show lol

[@DetroitLionsStuff]

@@justinhopper5941 I know.... that's why I said what I said.

[@GorillaWithACellphone]

Too bad dexter isnt real

[@rohmnight7903]

Sad mentally unstable creatures, thank goodness they caught this dangerous clown 😔

[@youknowlos]

He’s a monster, but that was a completely normal voicemail.

[@Pedantic1953]

He’s NOT innocent. I’m innocent. MY DNA didn’t show up anywhere. HIS DNA is on the victims. So how can HE be the innocent one.

[@pamelapamper]

The trace DNA could be matched to maaaaany many ppl and that's why it has never been admissible in court.

[@Pedantic1953]

@@pamelapamper but the news reporter said that the DNA match with him eliminated 99% of the population. Of course 1% of the population is about 78,000,000 people so…… maybe you’re right!

[@pamelapamper]

@@Pedantic1953 they take a tiny sample and "amplify it" with PCR and we all know how well that panned out with the c19 tests where animals and even fruit would give positive... Kary Mullis said it very clearly, if u amplify a sample enough u can find ANY sequence in it.

[@user-ut4zw6so6o]

The DNA ruled out 96 or 99 percent (sorry forgot the number) of the North American population. It doesn’t say it’s him with precision, but he’s in that narrowed down group that still numbers in the millions potentially.

[@axcrosstowne2851]

He tried to sound normal on that voice message.

[@alexisjgallardo]

This guys lives 23 minutes away from me, I’d occasionally go to Massapequa Park too. So sick.

[@invhincible2211]

And to think that he have a daughter...what a monster

[@metalbarbie7226]

Exactly 💯

[@krissykrupski4973]

And to know that he has a special needs son and searched for young Asian men🤢

[@truthtorpedo4068]

*Has

[@requiem47-hw1no]

Monsters still wont hurt their own, some kill their own

[@parker1458]

they really caught dude on google maps lol

[@ibizadreamz143]

That is not a normal voice mail. He shouldn’t of contacted her after she left the group. If he has a question ask someone else. Plus he sounded way to friendly and eager on the VM

[@FunnyTown872]

That voicemail wasn't creepy at all! Wtf is she talking about!!??

[@4-Methylaminorex]

Women 😂

[@Nonameforyoudangit]

​@@4-MethylaminorexIncel.

[@ElusiveVulture]

It is creepy after the conversation they had.

[@TheMajortanner]

$1,200 a month to store things? Must be very important to him.

[@MariahEbrown]

His wife: you don't know like I do him he's innocent 🤡🤡

[@krissykrupski4973]

Let her explain how her hair was on 3 murdered sex workers.

[@hollymartinson-ui1ks]

Is that why she filed for divorce as soon as he was arrested? Shes prob happy he got arrested so she can now escape.

[@assss6032]

Look at his face... oh my God.. Crazy man ! I feel so sorry for the victims. 😢😢 my condoleances to the families. 🙏🙏 (sorry for my english, i'm french)

[@iknow2145]

What about his face? He is a typical american man. I meet people that look and sound like him everyday.

[@samiiikpy]

What a sick man!!!

[@LAMETH-ou1xw]

That’s a creepy message?

[@patriotcine7521]

Another reason the country needs immediate death penalties for these criminals

[@Racstacko]

Cyber sleuths can find pretty much anything I’m kinda jealous of their skill

[@roxyj3182]

Right!!! Cause HOWWW

[@justinhopper5941]

lol yes that’s impressive they found that image so quick

[@masonkanterbury3007]

Reaction from friends and relatives: " He was the nicest guy in the world....except when he was berating and threatening people. He seemed completely normal....despite his fixation with rape torture and murder. He seemed like a gentle giant....except to the neighborhood women who complained about him jumping out at them in dark public spaces, scaring the bejesus out of them. I never suspected he had violent tendencies...even though I had the willies for a year after he showed me his arsenal. He didn't seem like the type who could hurt anyone...despite the fact that he enjoyed seeing other people suffering or in pain...it just doesn't make any sense...."

[@yunarukami6161]

Reaction from viewers: blindsided by history and denying every red flag beyond this point won't help the slightest

[@mtaylor7307]

People use that as a distancing technique to absolve themselves from potential blame. It's not their fault he killed people and it's not normal to expect your weird neighbor is a serial killer.

[@y2ksurvivor]

Goofy comment. None of those things or alleged incidents can get a person arrested and/or investigated for unrelated serial killing. Sorry, nobody will be able to tie this story up in a neat little bow. Life is far more complex than that.

[@CC-xu2yz]

@@y2ksurvivor Yep.

[@janelbullock9141]

😂 nicely said!!!

[@andrewliu2526]

" That profile fits Heurmann to a T.".. That's a pretty broad based profile that will fit many white people on Long Island.

[@jewelmathewson2997]

What a monster! Sick, sick, sick!!!

[@ajdarko8531]

Meticulously dismembered his victims and bound them? This guy didn't just wake up in his 40's and start killing. I hope they're able to tie him to every person he killed.

[@localfatty4364]

I am so ready for all the documentaries on this guy!

[@mirrrstery]

He is so tall and burly, how scared those poor women must of been. RIP.

[@angelacruseo8767]

Prison for life

[@shamioshi]

Just an observation here: to me, there's nothing "creepy" about that voicemail in and of itself. its only creepy in retrospect or if there was concurrent concerning behaviour. But independently, the words of that message sound like an email I've sent to a colleague after they left a job or organization and I wanted to still maintain contact.

[@Cell9074]

Nobody would be able to act on that voice mail alone

[@no_prisoners6474]

That's a creepy voicemail to a young woman by an old man.

[@waynepolo6193]

Right... That's part of what makes it creepy. How blithely and innocuously such horrid people can interact with anyone.

[@bobert8125]

​@@124xhappeleshowsdid she or anyone else tell him that? Or did she just leave and he's just suppose to know it was because of him?

[@emmanuelgonzales524]

BTK Killer was also arrested when he was 59 years old. What a coincidence!!!

[@jennifersmith6597]

I think the wife needs to be looked into also since her hair was on the bodies.

[@KennySVG]

I thought so too at first but it is possible he took the women to his home when his wife was not around. Heard on another video that phone records show his wife was away during the estimated time of the murders. That may explain the wife's hair.

[@krissykrupski4973]

Also could have been on his clothing and transferred. I would like to know why a life size human fetish doll in a glass case was on display in a small hoarded house with 3 children. I find that odd.