History of China and neighbor (18000BC - 2024) Countryballs Best version

[@iron_8453]

For who don't understand timeline of China 👇👇 - Xia - Shang - Zhou 🔴 Warring states of China - Qin 🔴Chu Han war - Han 🔴Three kingdoms - Jin 🔴16 kingdoms 5 Tribals - Sui - Tang 🔴10 kingdoms 5 dynasties - Song - Yuan(mongol) - Ming - Qing 🔴Opium war 🔴Taiping rebellion 🔴Boxer reble - Republic🇹🇼 🔴World War 1 and 2 - Communist🇨🇳(present)

[@BrazilMapping]

9 likes and 0 replies? Let me change that

[@Mongolia1991]

Yuan (mongol)

[@LLENN0420]

Republic：Republic of China 🇹🇼 1912 ～ 1945 “China” 1945 ～ 1949 “China and Taiwan” 1949 ～ Now “Taiwan” Policy：Democracy、Freedom and Human rights Communist：People's Republic of China 🇨🇳 1949 ～ Now Policy：Communism、Totalitarianism and Dictatorship

[@RaulDIOS]

14:41

[@Malayballs69]

These are correct orders: Xia Shang Zhou Sui Qin Han Tang Jin(three kingdoms) Song Yuan(mongol puppet) Ming Qing Republic china 中国 china

[@wanliu1867]

There‘s a saying in China:"Long unite must divide, long divide must unite”

[@user-N3M2H1]

是的

[@Tsukino_Usogi]

分久必合，合久必分😂

[@曹非未]

讲的非常对 兄弟

[@유우카는정실2다]

천하대세 분구필합 합구필분

[@cheehengchye9543]

okay i also speak chinese but im using pc

[@yanliu3650]

做的相当不错，作为外国人做出这样的还是相当可以的，大方向没有任何问题

[@商博俊]

支持

[@高用-x2y]

对虽然有些字错了，但老外弄成这样真的很佩服

[@高用-x2y]

对虽然有些字错了，但老外弄成这样真的很佩服

[@eternal12716]

古代的领土范围错的一塌糊涂

[@NL_Channel_-TW]

反觀BiliBili上的中國人欺騙中國人版本😂

[@saqima]

I am your Chinese audience, thank you very much for creating a historical video about our country! It can be seen that the author has consulted a lot of information and spent a lot of effort. The video is generally in line with historical facts, but there are some minor problems in the size and location of the territories of some dynasties, but overall it is very good! Keep it up!❤

[@wenbozhu-ep2ni]

符合西方观念里的历史吗？

[@澡称冯]

​应该是不符合的，他们不承认夏朝的存在

[@黄菊-v6l]

6 2022香港澳门还是英占葡占呢

[@ytRichardOfficial]

​@@黄菊-v6l视频里港澳回归之后是用的区旗表示，不是没有回归

[@JiachengXu-u6r]

If you were a citizen of China, I would be the first Qin Emperor. However, anyone who understands history thinks this is an absurd and ignorant animation.

[@mohanjiang7621]

虽然有一些细节上的错误，但是整体上看还是花了心思去了解的。

[@AnikoBarti]

确实，不过最后新中国成立那会西藏那边是没有藏南地区的，导致在对印自卫反击战那里看起来就像中国侵略了印度一样，看得我很恼火(　‾᷄Δ‾᷅　) ₎₎

[@MichaleBickerstaffg-j4u]

毕竟是外国友人做的，有些细微差异挺正常

[@張超凡]

错的太多了，容易让外国人误解！

[@gaius8129]

@@張超凡 这可以了，不能太苛

[@cherin7671]

一般来说这里画的都是实际控制区 看着奇怪也正常

[@mcheng7190]

I'll give the Jasmine soundtrack at the beginning of the video a favorable review good👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@南屿-q3v]

Reminds me of the days when I played Civilization 6

[@alptekin6299]

@mcheng7190 where can i find the soundtrack?

[@frankzheng1998]

@@alptekin6299 you search “shenyang”

[@JiachengXu-u6r]

Jasmine, the jasmine of your immortal board, is not the right way to look at history, okay?

[@NMSL_780]

很喜欢❤👍🏻

[@MGZetta]

As a Mongolian, I can confirm we used the Shadow Clone Jitsu.

[@kollaryung6222]

😂😂😂

[@Elias_Harrison]

real

[@苍白且狗蛋]

作为一个蒙古族人，我认为蒙古正统在内蒙

[@秦泽暄]

It's a very good vedio if you are interested in Chinese history. However, I have to say that there are lots of mistakes and could be a little confusing sometimes. For example, after the collapse of Tang empire, there are successors that claims themselves to be "Tang", which didn't have much relationship with Tang empire. But they are using the same ball in this vedio. I don't think that it is correct. And the "Tang" in north (which is known as "Hou Tang" 后唐) is actually founded by the kingdom of Jin, instead of annexing it. And this kingdom of Jin is totally different from the latter Jin (known as "Hou Jin"后晋), which is one of "the Five Dynasties".

[@HeartIron-m7w]

🤓

[@陳梓霄]

@@金小木-p8s in fact they are the same character, because those who use 唐 as their name thought they are the heir of the first 唐. in historian's view, they might be named in後唐、南唐or something else, but formally they all named the same word at their time. btw, the last name of leaders of these dynasty is 李(Lee).

[@金小木-p8s]

@@陳梓霄 I disagree with your idea. The ancient Chinese history I have studied does not propose a direct relationship between the rulers of the Later Tang and Southern Tang dynasties and the rulers of the Tang dynasty. As for surnames, they can be changed. Of course, the father and son of Li Cunxu and Li Keyong in the Later Tang Dynasty may have a blood relationship with the rulers of the Tang Dynasty

[@陳梓霄]

@@金小木-p8s hmm, u can keep your opinion, but after all, they are same character.

[@그남자그여자-p6d]

Oh this is correct, I was waiting for this explanation!

[@whjrksushw]

做得很不错，作为一个外国人竟然能做出这么好的视频，虽然有一些小错误 但不过还是支持一下

[@yellowwbunny]

8:43 One of my favourite parts (and only history i can remember), the mogols attempting to invade japan twice, but hurricanes protected japan. After the second attempt, the mongol leader gave up and said “Japan is protected by the gods”. If i can remember correctly, the hurricane was called Kamikaze

[@newname3718]

I think same thing happened when Japan invade China too 😂 god of wind just doesn't like war

[@柴犬丸s-o1v]

確かにハリケーンがモンゴル軍を退けた決め手になった事は事実ですが、当時の日本の軍事権力を握っていた鎌倉幕府に雇われた侍たちはモンゴルの兵士を凌ぐ程の非常に強力な力を持っており、実力でモンゴル兵達を船に撤退させ、さらに夜襲によってモンゴル軍に壊滅的な被害を与えています。

[@jzisn]

有些地方错得很明显，有些细节又把握得很准，挺有意思的😮

[@8910H]

同意

[@JiachengXu-u6r]

有你丫的意思啊，还细节，这画风就特么抹黑，不懂历史和文化还在这作妖

[@W5TGLOCES]

@@JiachengXu-u6r 這畫風很早已經出現在4chen了...

[@wangyideng]

明显偏西方

[@Borneo-c9l]

@@JiachengXu-u6rHey, this Chinese netizen, what you said is wrong. Why can you ridicule foreigners at will? If we ridicule them, you will be in a hurry?Can only you China have the right to ridicule other countries? It's not fair. You have it. We should have it.

[@Caraful]

i love the face expressions on these circle faces

[@Palaksan]

Those are countryballs

[@lumonnierxiuhua]

So hilarious😆 and efficient to show the history of China and around neighbor countries! Wonderful job!

[@Toshi-ju1om]

すげ〜細かい。これは徹底的に勉強してる人の制作だ。世界史を専攻していたので物凄く細かいところまで再現してるのが分かる。高校生の授業に使うのもいい。そして人類はずっと戦争していて野蛮なんだとよく分かる。

[@cauchycauchy9404]

@Toshi-ju1om 戦争を始めたあの人類たちは野蛮だ

[@kritsadachanthes4325]

How long have you produced this video. I appreciate your patience.

[@시바사키-y9v]

Istoria da Mongolia 🇲🇳 1:57 Oryatia Emirat ☯ 221BC-93 2:54 Xianbei Dinastia 🇺🇳 93-238 3:46 Rouran Royalia ♈️ 329-552 4:31 Dongol Imperia 🐺 552-744 5:52 Uighuren Imperia 𓂀 744-840 6:27 Norde Yang Mongolia 🦟 919-1125 7:25 Yuan Dinastia ☯ 1120-1221 7:29 Naiman Royalia ☯ 1125-1203 7:29 Khereid Royalia ☯ 1125-1203 8:11 Mongol Imperia ☯ 1221-1279 8:50 Yuan Dinastia ☯ 1279-1380 9:23 Norde Yuan ☯ 1380-1634 11:04 Qing Mongolia 🐉 1684-1912 13:16 Bogd Kania ☯ 1912-1919 13:30 Chine Mongolia 🏳️‍🌈 1919-1921 13:45 Russien Mongolia 🇷🇺 "1921" 13:51 Mongol Soviet Socialiste Republik ☭ "1921" 13:52 Bogd Kania ☭☯ 1921-1924 14:00 Volkers Republik da Mongolia☭ 🇲🇳 1924-1992 16:14 Zustvo da Mongolia 🇲🇳 1992-Current

[@yufengTang-z3g]

虽然视频有很多错误的地方，不过也看得出来作者是真的用心了，加油

[@reginoi6290]

没必要这么挑刺吧 特意把二战远东战场抗日的部分细节都画出来了 我觉得作者挺用心的

[@朝阳-d4v]

已经很好了

[@Hiiragi611]

なんやこいつ

[@千賀-f4b]

In reality, the Mongol invasion was largely repelled by the Kyushu samurai through sheer force, and the kamikazes were the final blow. In addition, since reinforcements from Kamakura had not yet arrived, it did not become a full-scale battle, and Kamakura had plans to invade Mongolia from the Korean Peninsula as a counterattack.

[@九绫樱]

看见1840年，不禁涓然泪下，那一段先烈们用血与肉换来的来之不易的和平啊

[@leol228]

1840 年不好。

[@朱挺-q6c]

有什么不好，不然现在还在磕头呢

[@TheRoblox140]

I‘ll estimate it for you, brother. Have you added oil and vinegar?

[@yo-yohuang7110]

Thank you for respecting China which means that you respected me cause I’m from China!!!😊😊😊😊😊

[@justinlink-tb8bm]

但是也有许多错误

[@aaronyue8146]

黑中国的看不出来？

[@Stay-hard6]

Love China from India 🇮🇳

[@Dangerskull3]

Free Tibet and Ladakh

[@莫等闲-t1v]

@@Dangerskull3 自由印度每个邦！

[@あいうえお700-j5v]

16:19 北朝鮮だけマスクをつけていない😂

[@zjt110]

是这样的😅

[@peisi-bv9yd]

因为朝鲜发现一例，直接枪毙了😅

[@zzZHua]

会被枪毙的 哈哈哈哈哈哈哈

[@Weeping-Angel]

lol I didn’t even realize it 😂

[@36661]

太细节了

[@chisaki703]

This is a lot of work and was interesting to watch, I wonder why Kazakh khanate not show up it just makes it seem like Kazakhstan spawned out of nowhere But all good keep up the awesome videos!!❤️❤️✨

[@КосмонавтПетрович-м5к]

Плюс минус так и было. Казахское ханство ждала бы судьба Синьцзяна, если бы Россия вовремя не подобрала эти земли

[@文-b9b]

​@@КосмонавтПетрович-м5к新疆怎么了？哪点不比俄罗斯强？

[@命运-r1t]

@@КосмонавтПетрович-м5к 苏联管理下的中亚也没多好，你也配嘲讽中国？

[@王小宝-n1s]

There were no Kazakhs before the Mongol invasion of the West. After the Mongols killed all the Khwarezmian men, most of the young women were taken to the grasslands and assigned to the Mongol army, which gave rise to the Kazakhs.

[@新时代五好青年]

新疆的乌鲁木齐是中亚第一大城市😂比哪些斯坦国首都还繁华😂​@@КосмонавтПетрович-м5к

[@papillonl8768]

영상에 문제가 있네요. 조선왕조가 청나라에 망하고 수백년간 왕조가 사라진 것 처럼 나오는데 사실 동북아의 조공체계와 책봉에 의한 외교는 국권과는 별개였습니다. 당시 일본이나 베트남도 청나라에 조공을 하고 책봉을 받았고 이건 청나라 만이 아니라 여러 왕조에 다 저항을 하고 독자적인 왕조가 유지되는 형태였지요. 차라리 몽골의 지배기간에는 왕실에 혼혈정책이 가해지기도 했지만 명나라도 청나라도 주변국에 조공외교와 책봉으로 형식상 지배권을 과시하던 정도지 주변국들은 다 독자적인 왕조가 유지되었고 조선왕조 역시 500년간 그대로 대를 이어 유지되었습니다.

[@papillonl8768]

같은 나라가 아닌 이유는 성씨가 다른 왕조가 별개로 있고 인종이 다르고 언어가 다르고 음식이 다르고 복식도 다르고 대대로 이어온 영토도 다릅니다 당시 동아시아의 속국체계는 지금의 미국과 캐나다나 멕시코와의 관계와 비슷합니다

[@lingshandaohuang]

yes, belong but not role or control

[@lizhong-p8s]

不，韩国和日本越南是不同的，日本继承了唐，越南就是分了家的儿子，但他们都没有韩国的迎恩门。所以不同哟

[@Worldstreet3]

1

[@Coffebean-q1w]

그냥 속국.

[@jie0330]

I'm chinese and i would say There are many things wrong.😂 Thank you for the video.

[@doge_it_self]

但已經很厲害了

[@stella-lj3ly]

还是很有科普价值的

[@Elizavetta-v5i]

Western propaganda It's always wrong about any country

[@miku-r4q]

甚至把义和团当成了国家😂

[@琛-w7o]

@@miku-r4q 应该是表示势力

[@НиконЕрмаков]

做的挺不错了，就是有一些细节错了❤

[@九霄-f3n]

比如藏南

[@三张-b1f]

这种东西很难做细致了，在我看来已经是做的比较好的了，没有什么明显的错误

[@周新茗]

也是看到国人了

[@zzy-200]

错的有点多了其实😂

[@maccj-12]

@@周新茗很难看到中文评论😂

[@5362o-a]

12世紀くらいまで 大陸の国々：うおーーー！😠⚔️😠 日本：😶

[@Digizzzzs]

kamikaze word was made from mongolian invasion

[@5362o-a]

The Mongol invasions are famous,but "Kamikaze" appears in poetry collections from the Nara period, which is part of the 7th century.

[@woahmilll8200]

Every other conflict and invasion seemed nothing compared to what Mongols did in such a short period of time.

[@yumetoko1705]

There are few historic recordings of acceptable credibility about Japan before around 8th century, so we have no way to know wars in Japan before that time.

[@姬林易]

I must say that your production is so interesting and accurate ，as a chinese ，i am very greatful to you for giving the world such an aplendid animations

[@pauluspaul127]

Man chinese history lesson is probably the hardest subject in school 😂

[@zhang凯-j9w]

不不不，在中国英语与数学才是最难的😢

[@onionhappiness]

实际上大半篇幅都在讲第一次鸦片战争以来的历史

[@yuxincui6427]

We mostly learn those failures and their consequences in the history, to remind us the necessity of being strong😢

[@曲石头]

@@zhang凯-j9w英语和数学是最简单的，历史是最难的，那些日期总是记不住

[@jojo4061]

最难的永远都是数学

[@Mjanja]

Why 730AD Japan dead and change his flags? There weren’t major political changes or something in Japan at that time

[@一之木武則]

そうですね。というか2600年間ずっと菊の御紋でいいんですけどね。

[@そいす]

この時期に、国号が倭から日本に変わったからだと思う。 菊の御紋から日の丸に変わるのは、天皇家と豪族による私的な性格を持った連合政権が、古代中央集権国家に変貌したという扱いのつもりかもしれない。変な話だけど。

[@gunsoviva1633]

​@@一之木武則平家が台頭して源氏が鎌倉幕府を起こした以降はなんの力もないただの飾り😂 厳密には藤原氏の摂関政治が始まった時点で天皇なんてただのアイテムだけど🤣 力無き権威に価値など無し

[@xenon441]

対外向けの呼び名が倭から日本に変わったところかな？少し遅いけど

[@AA-ux6gg]

@@一之木武則藤原氏と将軍がずっと支配してたのでそれは無理笑😅 天皇なんて歴史上のほぼ全てで傀儡人形に過ぎなかったんだから (但し後醍醐天皇の建武の新政1333-1336は除く) 因みに今やってるアニメ逃げ上手の若君はこの時代

[@黄金のオルダ]

ローマ帝国は異民族が侵入し分裂した後に二度とその版図を取り戻すことはなかったが、中国は五胡十六国時代の後に統一国家の隋唐が戻ってきた。驚くべきことだ

[@lxr-zzz]

不仅有五代十国 近代还有别的国家入侵过我们 你知道是哪个国家吗😊

[@LUSHIRUI]

哈哈哈，中国的一个朝代被推翻后就会迎来下一个朝代

[@kpkyoumu]

@@lxr-zzz他说的五胡十六国不是五代十国 你在干嘛

[@lxr-zzz]

没仔细看​@@kpkyoumu

[@StarrPark_Colette096]

@@lxr-zzz蘇維埃社會主義共和國聯邦 屬 中華蘇維埃共和國

[@bmiadmin5784]

THE BEST OF BEST YOUR PRESENTATION!!! I AM IMPRESSED!!!

[@-nf9vt]

I recommend generation of subtitles since some of us really find them useful. Immersive translate is incredible for the generation of subtitles

[@부계정-v5i]

A view of history that no one in China, Korea, or Japan can be satisfied with XD

[@鞠京儒]

Because the world is Korean, and Korea is the center of the galaxy.

[@ottogibob]

​@鞠京儒 Yeah, Confucius is Korean. Is this what you want me to say?

[@鞠京儒]

@@ottogibob Yes, yes, yes, the US troops in Korea are also Korean

[@阿飞-v8f]

韩国自古以来都是中国的附属国！

[@thomas-p6o2e]

​@@鞠京儒 You are just believing propaganda of chinese fake news There are little Koreans saying like that

[@rkogrimes4355]

The video is very well done. I would like to add two more points: 1. Hainan Island has been under the jurisdiction of the Central Plains since the pre-Qin period of China; 2. Taiwan Island was first sent by Sun Quan, the Emperor of Wu during the Three Kingdoms period, and it belonged to the territory of Wu.

[@fsadf9339]

三國時期的吳國記載到現在都還是有爭議，主要是他記載的琉球到底是不是台灣，至少在台灣沒有找到這類文物，澎湖明朝倒是有直接統治過澎湖，也知道台灣的存在，但沒有認為台灣是明朝領土所以跟荷蘭的東印度公司說那邊有島你可以去那邊設立據點，別來澎湖這裡

[@cauchycauchy9404]

@fsadf9339 You have no evidence of this.Taiwan is never an isolated island of Main Chinese territory history.

[@snowlee-ml7rr]

@@cauchycauchy9404 u fake history

[@Hannah-hg9rx]

Goryeo wasn't defeated by Yuan. Although Yuan tried, they failed to defeat Goryeo, so Yuan's prince/princes married Goryeo's prince/princes. That went until king Gongmin. Since I am Korean and I've studied Korean history I know about this. From now on please fact-check it on Google or Wikipedia.

[@отгонтогтохшагдар]

Хаха чад судлаад байх тийм арвин түүх байдаг гэжлү солонгос бол Юуан гүрэнд 100гаран жил 100% боолчлогдсон юм хааныг нь хүртэл Монголчууд сонгож суулгадаг байсан юм жил болгон олон мянган эмэгтэйчүүдийг зарц боол болгон авдаг байсан үлдсэн эмс охдид нь үр суулгаж өгөөд татвараа аваав явдаг байсан. Энэ үйл явдлаас болж солонгос хүмүүст Монгол гень илэрч бөгсөндөө хөх толботой болсон гэж үздэгийн. Бусдаар бол Монгол улстай түйч хамаагүй хүмүүс

[@mandalmeteora9458]

Then why they used to pay tribute to Yuan empire?

[@Elly-k9o]

これはすごく参考になった！ ちょいと細かいことを言うと、日本は国家元首が1500年くらい天皇の家系が変わらないので国としてはそこからずっと日本のままです(国旗？アイコン？が変わっていたので一応…) 鎌倉時代(大体1200年から)～江戸時代(大体1870年まで)の間は幕府の方が朝廷より力を持っていたのでこんな感じになってるんですかね ((日本史選択の日本人の独り言です…うるさかったらスルーしてください…))

[@kongklnm]

日本人对天皇的看法是什么？ What's your opinion about your emperor?

[@H0y0-mix-c7b]

​@@kongklnm古代最流行的看法是：天皇是日本的天子，授权国王（幕府将军）统治日本；就像古代中国皇帝说天子，并授权朝鲜和越南国王统治他们的领土。只不过中国皇帝除了授权给朝鲜和越南国王统治的领土以外，自己还有其他直辖领土，而日本天皇的所有领土都授权给幕府将军了，自己没有直辖领土了。

[@H0y0-mix-c7b]

​@@kongklnm当然那是古代的看法，自从进入民族主义时代以后看法基本上不一样了

[@cuocsongquanhta5398]

China, Vietnam, Japan, Korea 😂😂😂😂They bump into each other all day

[@evanfeng520]

“East Asian Culture”

[@cuocsongquanhta5398]

@@user-sh4rm1mp2e ベトナムの歴史を知らないのですか？かつて、白越族には現在の中国南部とベトナムが含まれており、北方からこの地に侵攻してきました。それ以来、ベトナムと中国は1,000年以上にわたり一つの国として続いてきました。そして西暦1000年以降、ベトナムは中国から分離しました。ベトナムの建国の歴史は日本や韓国よりもはるかに長く壮大です。 ベトナムは2000年にわたり中国と戦い、また日本や韓国とも戦った

[@노보트]

VIETNAM IS SOUTH ASIA GO BACK TO EAT ANT RICE LOL

[@PangWP]

China is a collective term, and dynasties represent the governing period of a certain political party in China

[@TheRoblox140]

If you don‘t go to the second platform, I feel super praised. Well, the mock test actually promotes the Russian Oang welfare candidate in March...

[@CodeZero587]

Hey what's the name of the Chinese theme? Nice video btw

[@顺心晟-v9l]

这个视频错误百出，有的历史事件颠倒，有的地理位置错误，有的细节错误，只能看个大概。

[@yfayf597]

its names “茉莉花”You can try searching for 《China (The Industrial Era)》

[@itz_CooL._.0804]

@@顺心晟-v9l有稍微讀過中華文化的就知道

[@hellosurvivor97]

Jasmine flower

[@逓信]

history of china be like: civil war unify war collapse

[@pzwang4109]

Repeat

[@myrrha7417]

It’s a huge land, and millions population If you compare the timelines of cold periods of earth and Chinese dynasties changes You will find out the timelines are almost same When cold periods came, foods incomings reduced, lower level people will fight for living It’s a obvious logic for people of every regions

[@ZEK-uu1qh]

Да, Кыргызстан - это результат войны между древним Китаем и Россией

[@YurinKawasumi]

There is an old Chinese saying that the world divided for a long time will be united, and united for a long time will be divided.

[@commentorsilensor3734]

History of China, many respected n praised leaders were good in birth control, population extermination.

[@るん-i7r]

島国ってずるいよな。攻め辛いから。 細かい地域が変化する前に視線誘導してくれるから見易い。 もう十分争ったよ。もう誰とも争いたくないよな。アジアの皆も、そう思っていてほしいな。

[@蔡徐坤の犬です]

外蒙古が欲しいのですが…

[@M783hsjsksk]

@@蔡徐坤の犬です外蒙古是一片贫穷的土地

[@aporz]

​@@蔡徐坤の犬ですしかしその前に、ユーラシア大陸への足がかりとして朝鮮半島を征服し、ロシアと中国という2つの大国を潰さなければならなかった。そして最後に、モンゴル人の抵抗の意志を手なずける必要があった。でもね、中国は決して抵抗をあきらめないように生まれたんだ。

[@阿訇-k7g]

中日之间的血海深仇，不是你几行字可以敷衍过去的

[@欧毅-k4x]

希望中日友好，别在仇恨了

[@Kot_Yabloko]

Well done! Just what is the music at the beginning?

[@nerol27]

Jasmine

[@Kot_Yabloko]

@@nerol27 thanks

[@NhựtVũ-t5q]

1000 years being "Chinese" us Vietnamese still keep our language is amazing

[@williamchang4599]

这并不奇怪，事实上中国也是到1980年代才统一语言。中国各地都有不同的方言，尤其是南方，广西话和北京话的差异比广西话和越南话的差异还要大

[@hzyckming呆蛙蟾蜍汁哪]

可是你们所谓的越南语就是中文的一部分….

[@loading_notfound]

Vietnamese learnt a lot from Chinese

[@wuzhishen]

​@@williamchang4599广西话跟普通话有什么区别？你在这瞎说

[@東皇太一-q3e]

亂說，桂柳話明顯接近川滇黔口音

[@АртурСБогомМариненко]

История китая:❤💔❤️‍🩹❤💔❤️‍🩹💔❤️‍🩹💔❤️‍🩹💔❤️‍🩹❤ Поймут только умные.

[@Gu0xy]

yeah we call it 分久必合 合久必分

[@yxeanget-any]

everyone understands bro

[@大树-q4r]

中国有句古话叫，分久必合。合久必分

[@炳轩无名]

The inevitable trend of the feudal dynasty is that if it divides for a long time, it must unite, and if it unites for a long time, it must divide; but it does not apply to today's system😮

[@massachusettscham3454]

You're all right bro

[@rodrigoh1025]

Very good greetings from Brazil

[@津軽-y5e]

元の時代になるまでずっと傍観してるだけの列島くん かわいい

[@若其一]

其实是因为元代以前跨越这么远的海洋实在是太困难了

[@ベストテン動画]

海洋救了你

[@nirvana4165]

百済は660年に唐新羅連合軍に滅亡され、旧百済の地で662-663年には大和王権を巻き込む大戦がおこり、668年に高句麗は唐新羅連合軍に滅亡させられました。

[@lei3324]

再后来，唐朝又与新罗交恶，我曾看到过相关的史料是在说，在双方交战期间，唐朝也有来自西部“吐谷浑”的压力，为了避免两线作战，唐朝与新罗在半岛的争夺方面做出了妥协……

[@lei3324]

在下也比较热爱历史，欢迎讨论😂

[@hzyckming呆蛙蟾蜍汁哪]

新罗就是韩国

[@hzyckming呆蛙蟾蜍汁哪]

@@lei3324唐朝帮新罗灭了高句丽 新罗统一朝鲜半岛！最后新罗全面唐化！所谓的妥协就是让新罗有更多的自主权 其实政治文化全面唐化

[@iviingivia4158]

@@hzyckming呆蛙蟾蜍汁哪it's hard to say though. From my point of view, the Korean peninsula doesn't have a continues history at all.

[@上帝最腐败]

From a long time ago, most of the world's population was in China. China's civil war history, almost half of EQUIV.'s civil war history.

[@Jacky-so2gm]

@ritedw 最早的时候两河流域和埃及也很多人口

[@J.Wolf90]

India has always been heavily populated too. I wonder how humanity grew so quickly in that area in such early human infancy..

[@Umuthanp]

I subscribed and liked it in return for this effort.

[@TheRoblox140]

One for you. Year after year? I love to enjoy it.

[@anniemeridian270]

The US just randomly swam to Asia😂

[@newname3718]

They feast on blood 😂 just remember that.

[@드라방송]

Although Korea is not the main theme, I think the situation and map of Korea are a little wrong. In the early north of Korea, the state was Gojoseon. And the territory of Gojoseon was bordered by the Yan Dynasty of China, based on relics and dolmens from the Gojoseon period. Usually, Gojoseon's territory was bordered by the Yan Dynasty to the west and occupied about half of the Korean peninsula to the south. Gojoseon lost the war against the Yan Dynasty and lost the area of Liaodong, but succeeded in recapturing the Liaodong Peninsula again when the Qin Dynasty was destroyed and China was confused. However, before long, Gojoseon was destroyed by the Han Dynasty. And the map from AD268 shows that the Wei Dynasty occupied the northern part of the Korean peninsula, which is not true. The Wei Dynasty actually attacked and controlled the Liaodong Peninsula. That was the same with the Qin Dynasty in AD280. At that time, China didn't enter the northern part of the Korean peninsula. It's just the Liaodong Peninsula. On the AD475 map, Goguryeo, a country north of the Korean peninsula at that time, was in its heyday of expanding its largest territory and marched further north and south to pressure neighboring countries. The Korean peninsula is very strange in the AD562 map The green country in the south of the Korean Peninsula is Gaya. However, the green country on the previous map was originally Silla. Gaya had existed since around AD 200. However, only three countries are displayed on the map, and suddenly a gray country appears on the AD562 map. This may be seen as wrong. Originally, the Silla country in the southeastern gray country of the Korean Peninsula should be a green country. And since the heyday of the Silla country begins and destroys the Gaya country, there should be three countries on the Korean Peninsula instead of four. Also, after the heyday of the Silla Dynasty ended, Goguryeo moved back to the South and reclaimed its existing territory. Before the Tang Dynasty destroyed Goguryeo in AD668, an alliance of Silla and Tang Dynasty destroyed Baekje in 660. However, since it was 738 AD that Baekje disappeared from the map, this is wrong. Munron: While the alliance of Silla and Tang Dynasty attacked Baekje's capital and destroyed Baekje, the map was not wrong because Silla had not yet been able to subjugate all of its territory, it is officially said that Baekje was destroyed in AD660. And in 993, the Khitan (Yo Dynasty) invaded Goryeo, the state on the Korean Peninsula at the time. However, after being defeated in the war with Goryeo and losing its national power, the Yo Dynasty was destroyed by the newly emerged Yeojin people. And in AD1270, the Korean Peninsula was attacked by the Mongolian Empire, but the strange thing about the map is that Goryeo was never occupied by Mongolia or incorporated into its territory. After 50 years of resistance to the Mongol Empire, Goryeo exerted its diplomatic power on the succession to the Mongolian throne, forming a friendship with Mongolia and forming a marriage alliance with the Mongolian imperial family. Mongolia recognized the Goryeo royal family and guaranteed their autonomy, so it can be said that it is a little wrong for Mongolia to conquer Goryeo and mark Goryeo as Mongolia's territory.

[@wang_cn368]

North Korea was a vassal state of China for most of its history, so there is nothing to worry about.

[@dafeimao111]

历史上就没有古朝鲜！也没有檀君！那时韩国小说！ 韩国人的历史观与世界严重脱轨！ 与正常历史爱好者无法沟通！让人想笑

[@mohanjiang7621]

麻烦你们韩国人不要把小说当成历史好吗？

[@드라방송]

@@mohanjiang7621 那是我想对你说的话。 对不起，古代韩国历史记载的史料大部分都是中国人记载的。 不相信你祖上记载的历史资料，你到底相信什么？ 中国共产党洗脑的歪曲历史？我想，如果你看过那么一次古代的书籍，就不会像你一样说话了。 我建议你看中国史记朝鮮列傳，诸葛孔明的心書東夷篇。 啊，当然不是中国共产党歪曲历史而新编的书，而是原版书。哈哈 或是这个 漢書朝鮮傳, 後漢書東夷列傳, 三國志魏書東夷傳, 晋書東夷列傳, 宋書夷蠻列傳, 南齊書東南夷列傳, 梁書東夷列傳 魏書列傳, 周書異域列傳, 南史東夷列傳, 北史列傳, 隋書東夷列傳, 舊唐書東夷列傳, 新唐書東夷列傳, 舊五代史外國列傳, 新五代史四夷附錄, 宋史外國列傳, 遼史二國外記, 金史外國列傳, 元史外夷列傳, 新元史外國列傳, 明史朝鮮列傳, 淸史稿朝鮮列傳。 你真心的认为你读的中国历史书比我多吗？ 中国的学者也知道所有真相。 但是，由于中国共产党的威胁，中国不得不听从中国共产党的话。 那是我与中国多位历史学家直接见面时听到的真相。 我最尊敬的中国学者曾说过这样的话。 "你爱中国共产党，我爱中国"

[@드라방송]

@@mohanjiang7621 那是我想对你说的话。 对不起，古代韩国历史记载的史料大部分都是中国人记载的。 不相信你祖上记载的历史资料，你到底相信什么？

[@tonyyang855]

The way the China ball suddenly stare at The US ball in 2024.

[@iamnotthejessieyouknow8860]

Is the us stare at china

[@GeminAiDreams]

China stares at Taiwan🤨🤨🤨

[@Redekr]

Lots of tiny mistakes…This vid could get u banned in China Mainland (lol) For the China after 1949,mainly 2 problems PRC actually sent an army in the Korean war,and the NK once pushed to Seoul The PRC government put HK into their management in 1997,same to Macao in 1999.After that they became two "provinces" of PRC,not actually regimes

[@ssol-k3r]

If Goryeo is a vassal of Yuan, why is Joseon a vassal of Qing?

[@yansgod3209]

朝鲜不需要在意朝代，他只是跟着中国的统治者以获得庇护

[@ssol-k3r]

@@yansgod3209 ㅈㄹㅇㅂ

[@楊WWWhaoerd]

事大主义 况且清朝（中国）也继承了汉人王朝的不干涉主义

[@lei3324]

​@@楊WWWhaoerd否则，朝鲜半岛上的人也要被强制留辫子了

[@hzyckming呆蛙蟾蜍汁哪]

朝鲜半岛的国家一直依附中国朝代而生

[@seanburns3862]

The map errors were so obvious that the bloggers deliberately made the maps of each Chinese dynasty smaller

[@楼兰-p8i]

这不算大问题，每个朝代疆域都是动态变化的，比如唐朝，唐朝鼎盛时期占有了东亚几乎所有适合人类居住的地方，普天之下莫非王土，率土之滨莫非王臣，唐朝人走到哪里哪里就是唐朝领土。😂

[@kmmpp9832]

@@楼兰-p8i 我只看先秦的部分已经看出来了，做图的明显是拿着其它来源的地图贴上不匹配的底图。夏商的起源和核心都是河南为主兼现代西安周边，后面的春秋战国的就很明显没看到河流的合理性，例如战国后期赵国和西汉早期的西北突出部那么一条必然是南北都有屏障的，他都捅到大沙漠上了。他们就觉得大河流很重要要标上，却正好变成败笔了，也许是做到后面也觉得不对劲了，1684-1685换了底图，河流和国界的标示相对移位了。

[@MSanchir-w4e]

1245 mongolia empire 🥶🇲🇳💀

[@ErdenebilegTumurdorj]

хэн монголыг дийлдэг байсан юм чингис хаан өнгөрсөн болохоолос😢

[@Enjika_ka]

@@ErdenebilegTumurdorjхарин тийн 😢😢

[@eustna_astraea]

可是蒙古帝国和现在这个🇲🇳只能说除了一个名字，别的没有一点是一样的。蒙古帝国的统治者都在中国的内蒙古，而蒙古族的文化习俗也都来自内蒙古，现在的🇲🇳在过去是流放奴隶的地方。也就是一群奴隶的后代盗用了蒙古帝国的名字建了国而已

[@wifjwifjwi]

中看不中用，元朝在中国历史写的是统治者搞种族等级政策，暴政，频繁收税，屠杀平民，元朝皇帝换的太频繁几个月换一个，不灭亡才怪了，元朝是来自今天的🇨🇳内蒙古自治区，外蒙古据说是被蒙古的黄金家族赶过去的一些小部落

[@Makee-wee]

​​@@eustna_astraea Хятад, Өвөрмонгол 2 хэзээ ч нэг гарал үүсэлгүйг санаарай. Танай улс хүчирхэг байж болох ч танайх бусадын өвөг дээдэсийг булаах өчүүхэн дотортой амьтад гэж зүүдлээ ч үгүй вм байна. Орчин үеийн Хятад хүмүүс Турк ээс ялгарах юм үгүй бололтой. харамсалтай

[@mohammod.bin.Musa.ibrahim]

Love China from Bangladesh 💝💝💝

[@babyhey9352]

thank you❤

[@DIMO-V]

thank you

[@rasalghul669]

Такое чувство,что в Китае своя мировая война была...

[@HySun-st4yn]

中国本来就是一个多民族的国家，目前主体民族汉非常强大，因此能够统一大片地区

[@japhetomari5757]

Because the timeline has thousands of years, in other regions with thousands of years of civilization, there will inevitably be countless struggles

[@Mr梦飞]

在历史中战争才是常态，从中华人民共和国成立到如今也不到100年，然而100年的历史在几千年的历史里只能算很小一部分

[@去去-p7p]

回答的非常对，但是历史上一旦外族入侵中国军阀都会团结起来

[@fsadf9339]

戰爭才是中國的常態，現在和平時代算難得

[@_stree2590]

You omitted half of the history of Chosun.

[@user-tianyouzhonghua]

Does Korea have a history? Chinese characters are used in all texts.

[@sinemnuong]

@@user-tianyouzhonghua The pyramids in Xi'an are the history of Korea.

[@madusvan]

@@sinemnuong yeah yeah Korean creates the universe

[@lumonnierxiuhua]

@@madusvan They even create the univers!

[@喜欢金色胡萝卜]

我是反清復明老兵清軍南下時我退守台灣，我在台灣台北101的西北角的地基下留有一張反清復明作戰圖現在應該被地基埋了，不過能挖出來的朋友一定要在1月14日送到廣東牛牛古玩店，我每年都會在這一天蹲守挖到圖紙的人，等我復興大明王朝高低得封挖到圖紙的人一個大明第一將軍。

[@尹永炆]

我是秦始皇，打钱

[@superitgel1]

Damn. Everybody ganged up on Qing. You did well for holding up for that long.

[@fdgfgb6918]

15:13 ค.ศ.1945-ค.ศ.1949 สงครามกลางเมืองจีน จีน กับ พรรคคอมมิวนิสต์แห่งประเทศจีน

[@騛-z3q]

内战是对的，但你说的内战双方是中国和中国共产党这是错误的，

[@123-dt8ef]

​@@騛-z3q应该是机翻，翻译有问题

[@shulerjordan1957]

中华民国和中国共产党

[@qingque520]

China's website has a video of the same type, and it is very sophisticated.

[@aczbdk]

Ignore any info provided by the Communist PRC, they are full of lies. Communism originated from Germany, they occupied China by force and call it PRC.

[@iron-fx7xc]

from bilibili“史图馆”or“一团小红球”

[@AA-ux6gg]

Poor Joseon was invaded by Japan and China 😢

[@seoul_9584]

Japan invaded Korea only once. And China has never invaded Korea after the silla-tang war in 670.

[@answer007-b2n]

@@seoul_9584Poor Korean, I suggest you learn Chinese, so that you can find the real history in the orthodox historical records of your country. Instead of the fake history that is fabricated to enhance national identity.

[@seoul_9584]

@@answer007-b2n so Ghigiz khan was the greatest Chinese leader. Isnt it?

[@seoul_9584]

@@answer007-b2n its really funny to see how u see the history. China was a colony of Manchuria, Mongolia, Europe and Japan. Stop abusing multi-ethnic ideology to justify your nonsensical view.

[@seoul_9584]

@@answer007-b2n 2020 🇨🇳🤓: we declare ourselves that we are now multi-ethnic nation. From now, history of Manchuria, Mongolia, Tibet and Uyghurstan are history of China 2050 🇨🇳🤓: we declare ourselves that east asia has been reunited under the multi-ethnic ideology. Now history of Manchuria, Mongolia, Tibet, Uyghurstan, Taiwan, Ryukyu, Korea, and Japan are history of the SINO EMPIRE.

[@91-ava]

Thank you, my friend, for making our country's history.❤❤❤

[@longnhattran2627]

Another title: history of East Asia.

[@苏夜未央]

fantastic video

[@xuongmvcuawibu739]

Many errors.

[@stevec9470]

Throughout 3700 years most of the badass Chinese warriors seem come from central China like the Shaanxi, Gansu, Qinghai and Ningxia province except Yuan and Qing dynasty. The CCP also "Long March" into this area and start to conquer China.

[@李荟源]

在中国，一直有“得关中者，得天下”的说法，关中指的是中国中部，山西陕西河南河北地区。这些地方有特殊的地理条件和历史，所以很多王朝都是发源遇这些地方

[@M783hsjsksk]

王兴之地，like the king’s landing of Westeros

[@zfxyjx]

Fantastic work!❤

[@TehCapcutSpartaRemixer]

Here is a tip: Japanese empire actually fought against mongolia. At the very border of dornod and half of inner mongolia

[@tianlingchen5523]

On the contrary, the Japanese army did military operations against Mongolia and the Soviet Union, that is, the Battle of Nomenham, but the Japanese failed.

[@lei3324]

​@@tianlingchen5523确实，当时苏联的坦克比较厉害

[@Jacky-so2gm]

@@tianlingchen5523 When Yuan beat Song they forced Song's people to build war ships to atk Japan, but the ships sucked.

[@tianlingchen5523]

@@Jacky-so2gm This is the origin of Kamikaze Special Forces in Baga kingdom.

[@hellosurvivor97]

sunken

[@joonhojeon1262]

This video is wrong. The Great Wall built by Emperor Qin Shi Huang came all the way to Korea? Historically, the eastern end of the Great Wall did not extend beyond Hebei Province.

[@tianlingchen5523]

辽东长城也是有的

[@beeforuever]

The Great Wall was only partially built in Qin Dynasty. Before and after that, Yan, Han also constructed walls that reached today's Jilin Province and North Korea.

[@yyyymmddhhmm]

​@@beeforuever Sources?

[@ZHN0125]

You are wrong. Historically, the eastern end of the Great Wall during the Qin Dynasty extended into today's south Pyongan in North Korea, which is close to Pyongyang. There are maps of Qin dynasty available online; Koreans should stop spreading false information.

[@질문빌런-f5i]

명나라 시절 만리장성을 진시황이 쌓은 만리장성이 넘었다는 얘기를 하고 싶은건가

[@masonlee5410]

Korean peninsula: Leave me alone 😢

[@jordansaidthat6939]

匈奴 xiongnu is The Huns，The Xiongnu were defeated in the war with the Han Dynasty of China and were driven to the north by the Chinese, so they abandoned the land and went all the way to Hungary. They originally belonged to Xinjiang and Inner Mongolia of China.

[@らま-r2b]

I really liked the background music starting from 13:24. Could you please tell me the name of the song? It seems like It's not included in the summary section for the music.

[@蔡哈哈-v8b]

The Descent

[@franklindesanta8031]

好像是游戏文明时代2的背景音乐

[@死鱼眼的喵星人]

2 Suggestions. 1. The status of Choson/Korea in Ming and Qing dynasty are different, in fact from the view of Chinese history they have same level of status (chaogong country). You need to unify the representation. 2. There is no Lewchew/Ryukyu kingdom apperance, which is an important neighbour (at least same level as Choson/Japan) and an active trader and chaogong country in Ming-Qing dynasty.

[@forbora6756]

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ웃기네 중국인이냐? ㅋㅋㅋ

[@forbora6756]

한국역사로 볼때, 중국은 땅은 넓지만 생각은 좁고 마음은 작은 소국이다.

[@forbora6756]

한평생 시진핑에게 조공하며 꽃농사나 하며 살길😂🙏

[@Victorialiu22]

@@forbora6756 韩国人还叫上了，那么点大的国土还不够塞牙缝呢

[@Victorialiu22]

@@forbora6756 不对，应该叫你们南朝鲜🤣

[@ゆゆうり-n1b]

神武が即位したあたり日本だけ神話混ざってるの好き

[@AliGençcan]

1:02 why does black ball have arms💀💀💀

[@号哭的御坂妹妹]

❤优秀的动画，下载了。不知道B站有没有类似的波兰球古代历史动画。

[@苏沐-b9o]

笑死，B站能转这视频我直播倒立吃SHIT

[@rongrong-ki3yi]

​@@苏沐-b9o把臺灣上面的改成五星紅球就可以了😂😂

[@苏沐-b9o]

还有雪山狮子旗和东突呢😝@@rongrong-ki3yi

[@奇奇蒂蒂貓貓]

這中共ㄧ定不給人知道 這中國地方有5000年歷史 但中共沒有 中華民國還存在 人民其實可以選擇 中共給人民欺騙 不讓他們思考選擇

[@我和-t4m]

破案了，真转载了，但是大清之后的就没了

[@fdgfgb6918]

5:17 ก่อตั้ง ราชวงค์ถัง ที่รบเก่งที่สุดฤในประวัติศาสตร์ ค.ศ.624

[@fdgfgb6918]

ราชวงค์ที่ 8 ของจีนคือ

[@fdgfgb6918]

Tang dynasty

[@myrrha7417]

😂 we Chinese usually think the Mongolians are best soldiers in the ancient, which is Mongolia empire or Yuan dynasty

[@CyrusZachary]

The Tang Dynasty is considered to be the peak of ancient China.

[@大树-q4r]

​@@myrrha7417那是你认为的，我认为汉朝才是最强

[@Duy1992]

Vietnam của tôi nằm dưới sự thống trị của trung quốc 1000 năm là có thật, sử dụng từ Hán Việt rất nhiều đến tận bây giờ có giảm bớt, chữ viết đã được thay đổi khi pháp tiến vào Việt Nam 1860, nhưng cuối cùng người Việt vẫn luôn giành được độc lập kkk

[@66archangel99]

你猜现在越南和中国什么关系

[@baonguyentrong9178]

@@66archangel99 16 chữ vàng nhé hàng xóm ^^

[@神明-d5t]

​@@baonguyentrong9178Chỉ là một phần của Trung Quốc mà thôi.

[@何家朗]

基本正确，希望作者能多多做这种有意思的视频，传播中华历史需要你！

[@Alastorbaby-137]

捉到你了

[@GetTwo-lz8ex]

Of all the countries except China itself, I think the Japanese know Chinese history best. But they may only have the clearest understanding of the three kindoms history

[@石一-c1o]

No, they don't care about the harm they have done to China.You can search for Nanjing Massacre and Unit 731

[@カリヤドネループ]

日本の文化や伝統の90％以上は中国のものだから…… 中国の歴史を学ぶことは日本の文化を理解することと同義と言っても過言ではないし……。

[@atlas_x150]

Completely inaccurate, but overall correct

[@yunweilee5309]

很有趣的视频，虽然有很多谬误，但是大概脉络是清晰的❤

[@anniemeridian270]

I love how Xia got really drunk 😂 Sad but cute

[@陈一亨]

That is the origin of alcohol. In an era of backward productivity, monarchs were addicted to alcohol and wasted food, so they were quickly overthrown and the Shang Dynasty was established

[@nganhichongphanongcucoan2567]

it's funny that Vietnam is a small circle at the middle bottom (named Van Lang, Van Xuan, Au Lac...), frequently bullied by chinese ancestors

[@lingli5099]

why called bullied,most of time we just has good cooperate.

[@梁淇-w1v]

我们祖先一奋斗，他的祖先就挨揍😂

[@commentorsilensor3734]

​@@lingli5099in Chinese history, the arrogant ones said the disobedient people revolt. The liberal ones said people fought against tyranny. In Vietnam, China and Mongolia were all invaders.

[@lingli5099]

@@commentorsilensor3734 if you in Vietnam,yourself probably a invaders.the native south black people already disappear long ago.

[@喪黒福造-h6u]

いい暇つぶしになりました、サッカーアジアカップ韓国VSサウジアラビア観よ🤓

[@caozijian6]

不准跟我们中国说足球

[@过客-v9g]

@caozijian6 因为中国足球跟屎一样？

[@yuanxigu5112]

@@过客-v9g

[@鄧楠-z6s]

😡

[@michaelzhang-lf7ki]

The video omitted an important aspect of the description of the Han Dynasty, which is that the Han Dynasty had actual control over the Western Regions.

[@タオ-h1w]

中国の南西って小国が常にあるけどやっぱり山脈が多いと統一国家が作りにくかったんかね。 しかし、こう見ると列強の時代に入るまでは、ずっと北東との戦いで中国人にとって国の統治と国防がどれだけ大変だったかよく分かる。

[@kevinwang215]

“蜀道难，难于上青天”------唐.李白

[@골D로저-s3w]

10:32 청나라가 조선을 없앤것처럼 묘사되는 오류와 일본이 조선을 청에게서 해방을 시킨것처럼 묘사되는 부분이 조금 거슬리네요

[@골D로저-s3w]

@@kimhitblue3486 조공국이라고 독립적인 국가가 아닌것은 아님

[@kimhitblue3486]

@@골D로저-s3w 맞네요 제 실수입니다. 아무래도 서양사람 입장에서는 위성국으로 보일 수도 있기에 저렇게 만들었나봅니다

[@guangjunxiao]

很想了解下你们对的历史看法，肯定会很好玩😂

[@골D로저-s3w]

@@guangjunxiao 朝鲜虽然是清朝的朝贡国，但作为独立国家一直维持到1897年 直到1910年大韩帝国被日本强占为止

[@AVGVSTVS-63]

일본이 해방시켜준 거 맞음 그래서 독립문도 세운거고

[@hello-q5u2v]

Contemporary China government needs to recover Taiwan Province and Outer Mongolia as soon as possible.

[@Dog_Knot_]

Don't touch MONGOLIA!

[@luyaoli3239]

@@Dog_Knot_ inner mongolia and outer mongolia as a whole must return to the chinese family

[@Dog_Knot_]

@@luyaoli3239 u'll never have Mongolia inside China.

[@Dog_Knot_]

They already did few revolutions to be independent from Qing dynasty, they don't want to be in China 100%, they are independent!

[@sangwang199]

​@@Dog_Knot_no way

[@Gandhi_Cheder]

Funny video continues to work, love from Singapore❤

[@UlambayarEnkhbold]

Thank you for making this video.

[@user-mi3km6qt6e]

What sources did you refer to for China's eastern border? completely wrong.

[@AlbertLiu-t4i]

这个视频有个最大的问题就是早在夏之前，中原大地包括东北、江南、川蜀地区就是同一文化下的了，而且采用的是分封制，比如商是夏的封臣，周是商的封臣，春秋列国是周的封臣

[@人类黑洞]

夏是一个传说，更别提夏之前了。

[@cockhang1573]

@@人类黑洞 有亚历山大东征传说吗?

[@JaredChan-]

至今没有证明夏的存在，无论国内还是国际上，周是可以确认的第一次封建。

[@AlbertLiu-t4i]

@@JaredChan- 周是商的封臣，是领主，而你说的第一次封建，是周把姬姓子弟分封到华夏大地，而在此之前，这些地方的领主、国主都是当地的人

[@AlbertLiu-t4i]

@@人类黑洞 只是没有发现完备的文字而已，现代考古已经发现了发达的仰韶文化、二里头文化、良渚文化，只是没有发现完备的文字，但是文明已经开始几千年了

[@赵翰卿-c7p]

大致方向没有错，不过可能老外没搞清楚藩属国和本朝的概念，很多把藩属国当独立国家看了