Irving in Birkenau - Red house

The red house was located to the side of the camp. After the destruction of several nearby houses, this house was converted into a gas chamber for the murder primarily of the Jewish population of Europe.
In 1942 the Nazis began to murder people here by transporting them from a railway siding near the camp by lorry to this house.
The bodies were initially disposed of by burial, but the Nazis found that there was a problem with ground water. The kommandant Rudolf Hoess went to Chełmno nad Ner to find out how bodies were there being destroyed by fire. On his return a system of burning bodies in open air hollows was devised.
From testimony given by former Nazi officials it would appear that usually only one gassing per day occurred in this building and that the bodies were left in there for some time - although at peak times there could have been more than one gassing.
After the construction of the gas chambers at the head of the railway line in the spring of 1943 the red house ceased to function for mass murder and it was pulled down.
It is believed that around 100,000 people were murdered on this site, giving a daily average figure of around three hundred deaths.
This film has not been censored in any way, it is what I filmed, nothing added and nothing edited and that is why it is so amateur. It will be noted that David Irving is not denying that mass murder was perpetrated on this site.

[@ryang790]

Mr Irving was universally regarded as the number one historian of the 2nd world war, until he questioned the the actual number of Six million . All he does is question statistics and reality, as he's job as a historian 🤷

[@keithad6485]

In one of his videos, he shows he must have revised his opinion on the six million, cos he says this figure is about right. Pity David is now very ill and needs constant care and is bed ridden. His life's work has ceased.

[@ryang790]

@@keithad6485 Really lol. Show me where he says this

[@keithad6485]

@@ryang790 Ryan, I will get back to you on this. It was several months ago that I saw the vid and it may not be on KZbin any more, but I will find it for you. He goes into more detail and acknowledges that 1.1 million plus jews were murdered in the death camps in the Baltic states. Sobibor, Treblinka, Mydenic, Belsech. He found confirmation of these murders, in of all places, Bletchley Park decoding of enigma messages, though MI6 at the time did not know what the figures were referring to. MI6 decoded figures exactly match the figures of those, 'processed' submitted with monthly reports to Berlin by enigma coded radio transmissions. Irving states that he has come to believe 'processed' means murdered or liquidated. Also talks about how these death camps were rehabilitated afterwards so that no one would know what occurred there. I guess similar to mining operations today in first world countries where when the mining is completed, the landscape is kinda returned to its natural state. This leads me to being curious on why no one has proposed doing an archeological dig of these Baltic mass graves and reburying the victims in a decent manner. Irving has found diaries. letters, etc describing what occurred, the hapless jews disembarked from the train enmass, marched straight to the camp and murdered with no delay by shooting. Others were rounded up from a nearby town and the same happened. Local German commandant was incensed when he found out what had happened to 'his jews' and send a young officer to go to the camp and compile a report so he could send a complaint to Berlin.

[@keithad6485]

@@ryang790 I replied to you but it appears my reply suffered an auto censorship action by youtube. I will find the video and get back to you without mentioning his name as this seems to cause youtube to react with deleting the comment.

[@ngabushallday6642]

​@@ryang790 Irving is a nazi sympathizer.

[@erasedfromgenepool.4845]

God bless you mr Irving your a true English gentleman and A scholar. Wise beyond your years O'l chap!

[@AltF-dl2ks]

Honorable man

[@Marcosnationalistos]

​@@AltF-dl2ksWhy?

[@keithad6485]

It is a pity David is now bed ridden, needs constant care, and has reluctantly ceased his life's work. He is very ill.

[@markdemeza2840]

Irving is the ONLY historian with this view - Here is the detail of the court case he lost - " Irving's reputation as a historian was further discredited[Note 2] in 2000, when, in the course of an unsuccessful libel case he filed against the American historian Deborah Lipstadt and Penguin Books, High Court Judge Charles Gray determined in his ruling that Irving willfully misrepresented historical evidence to promote Holocaust denial and whitewash the Nazis, a view shared by many prominent historians.[Note 3] The English court found that Irving was an active Holocaust denier, antisemite and racist,[8] who "for his own ideological reasons persistently and deliberately misrepresented and manipulated historical evidence".[8][9] In addition, the court found that Irving's books had distorted the history of Hitler's role in the Holocaust to depict Hitler in a favourable light."

[@sebastianspecter8843]

I appreciate that he was not demonized in these videos.

[@perceptionmanagement2116]

God bless David Irving

[@amhunter9619]

God ROT him, mate!

[@ShlomoEden]

He always asks "Where are the bodies"? And never anyone came up with an answer...just saying...

[@VanlifewithAlan]

No - you can't be bothered to listen to the answer - which incidentally is utterly clear.

[@williemays2]

Evidently it was about 150k.

[@colina4778]

they examined the ground with sonar at Treblinka back in 99' where they said the mass graves were....the ground was never disturbed. shocker.The scientist was jailed for "holocaust denial" Germar Rudolf. "The truth stands on it's own merit..it does not need laws to protect it"

[@garysmith5641]

Kitty Hart moxon confirmed this location in her trip back , she said constant pistol fire could be heard the closer you got to the building she passed it on a trip to the dentist from a kind Kapo who gave her the papers

[@moesypittounikos]

Irvin admits that it happened but he says the numbers have been blown up. Its people like Cole who argue that it was tea and biscuits and swimming pools and theatres who are the crazies!

[@alextrevino3713]

@@vnurcombe Sure he received numerous death threats that couldn't have had anything to do with it right.

[@vnurcombe]

@@alextrevino3713 Abject nonsense. He was so afraid, he went on all the US talk shows and continually reneged in public. Yeh, right. Death threats. I can see you're a real intellectual.

[@vnurcombe]

@@alextrevino3713 You obviously haven't read "Republican Party Animal", his book. Or see any of his interviews post 2013. Or any of his recent films and interviews.

[@vnurcombe]

Tweet Protocol both contentions are absolute nonsense. The so-called “Swimming pool” is a reservoir of water that sat next to the camp fire station. The “theatre” was in the SS staff camp, as were brothels for the camp Guards. The Guards were given also large amounts of alcohol so they could get through the day. All this is clear from the plans in the auschwitz library archives, viewable on site, and as detailed in the exhaustive history “KZ” by Antoni

[@vnurcombe]

As well as in Wachsmann’s brilliant and authoritative history “ KL: a history of the nazi concentration camps”

[@theredbaronlives9889]

The place looks like farms in Kentucky it's kind of peaceful looking actually.

[@BlackDogOriginal]

She wouldn’t shut up

[@peterpedant]

That very same spot in which they are standing is where they made sausages out of the human flesh of jews, mostly children. My best friends, father-in-laws great grandfather saw it he was an eyewitness so it definitely happened.

[@redbaronreborn3372]

Bullsh*t.

[@freckleheckler6311]

@@redbaronreborn3372 that was sarcastically said..

[@motoxrider4life745]

My Best friends grandmother's cousins 2nd Uncle was there also!!! Come On man. Get Real!!!

[@AdamAdam-vr8yi]

The human skin lamps turned out to be bullshit

[@nicolelehmenkuhler8474]

Liar

[@johnphelan7403]

Did the video end here or go further,Alan?

[@VanlifewithAlan]

john phelan That is it John. Now I have around one hour filming or more but then I did not!

[@johnphelan7403]

***** It's kinda sad that Irving's ideological leanings have prevented him from becoming the historian that he might have been.

[@VanlifewithAlan]

john phelan I agree. He has a brilliant memory and mind for details.

[@severusfloki5778]

@@johnphelan7403 Haha. I’m late, but what you said makes no sense. Ideology? What ideology? Couldn’t the same be told about mainstream, liberal historians?

[@colonelsmith7757]

@@johnphelan7403 I see you trust your TV.

[@noticingpatterns5923]

Watch Europa the last battle part 8 and it will open you’re eyes

[@VanlifewithAlan]

I wonder if facts would open your eyes.

[@noticingpatterns5923]

@@VanlifewithAlan that’s why I’m telling you to watch Europa the last battle because it’s facts that don’t care about you’re feelings lol

[@timvella1817]

What facts?

[@VanlifewithAlan]

@@timvella1817 Yes, what facts?

[@VanlifewithAlan]

@@noticingpatterns5923 The only two facts I see here is that you cannot name any facts and you cannot write English.

[@ramirezzz99]

Where is antohe part of this video???

[@VanlifewithAlan]

In the playlist called Auschwitz Birkenau.

[@ramirezzz99]

ok thanks! if you will be with Mr. Irving in Poland, I can help you, you are very welcome here :)

[@keithad6485]

Unimpressed with the censorship taking place with these comments. My previous comment added several hours ago which was innocuous and only alerted readers that Irv ing is very ill and bed ridden and not likely to recover, and has ceased his life's work, was taken off straight away. Maybe Irv ing has something when he used to talk about the traditional enemies of freedom of speech. Feb 2024.

[@VanlifewithAlan]

No it was not taken off straight away - indeed I have only just seen it. I am very unimpressed by you being unimpressed. You and I both know that you made no such comment several hours ago. More to the point is why are you making this up and then copying and pasting it? Perhaps by the traditional enemies of free speech you mean the Nazis?

[@keithad6485]

@@VanlifewithAlan Interesting that you made no comment on Irv ings health. You are entitled to you opinion, just as I am entitled to express mine. It appears KZbin doing auto censoring if the video presenter did not do it. The rest of your comment, as you are attacking me personally, I wont comment. I only comment on the issues not on the person. Attacking a person shows the commenter has no valid argument.

[@captaintruth]

@@keithad6485 there is censorship at hand. don't ever doubt it, it seems now it is worse than ever!

[@lyndachabane1931]

So the little red house is no longer there ?

[@VanlifewithAlan]

No, it was destroyed.

[@severusfloki5778]

@@VanlifewithAlan why ?

[@bitemebudha8571]

@@severusfloki5778 did you ever get the answer? I want to know too

[@koko2bware]

@@bitemebudha8571 One of his recent videos says that tourists are not allowed near the red house because they don't want them to see the real evidence!! Instead tour guides take tourists to Auwitch building which was built after the war!! Lots of unanswered questions remains!!

[@D.L91]

@@koko2bware Nonsense

[@rodrickspode6366]

De-nazivacation vs a historian

[@VanlifewithAlan]

I think it is most unfair to refer to Mr Irving as 'denazivacation'.

[@rodrickspode6366]

@@VanlifewithAlan Irving is the historian

[@VanlifewithAlan]

@@rodrickspode6366 So what does de-nazivacation mean?

[@rodrickspode6366]

@@VanlifewithAlan "Denazification was an Allied initiative to rid German and Austrian society, culture, press, economy, judiciary, and politics of the Nazi ideology following the Second World War. It was carried out by removing those who had been Nazi Party or SS members from positions of power and influence, by disbanding or rendering impotent the organizations associated with Nazism, and by trying prominent Nazis for war crimes" MacArthur did something similar to the Japanese.

[@VanlifewithAlan]

@@rodrickspode6366 I know what denazification was - obviously you made a type - fair enough given that the f and the v are on the same finger but less understandable given the position of the i and the a.

[@VanlifewithAlan]

I explain this in another film. The bodies were taken from the house and buried in a field. In September 1942 Hoess went to Chełmno nad Nerem where bodies had been burned since April 1942. A system had been worked out there (and confirmed by archaeological digs a few years ago) which used grills and concrete pipes to bring in air allowing bodies to be destroyed continuously. This was used at Auschwitz until the construction of the large crematories, and continued to be used afterwards too.

[@alextrevino3713]

You know NOTHING about cremation of human bodies. To burn bones to ashes in an open air pit? IMPOSSIBLE as described! Eye witnesses are all liars.

[@alextrevino3713]

@capital or labor not possible

[@TheWhiteManSays]

Why are you harassing this old man?

[@luciojaimes4827]

@@TheWhiteManSays Because they are holocaust deniers and he's not.

[@koko2bware]

@@alextrevino3713 Agree💯 These so called "eye witnesses" were all coaxed and coached to fit the official narrative!! To make things worse no mainstream media or publishers will publish the Germans side of the story!! Incredible!!

[@VanlifewithAlan]

You see the problem. He says do something and when you do it, he tries to stop you doing it.

[@Rach84]

I have a question--I visited Birkenau in early April. This may sound morbid, but I swear there were tiny ash piles in different locations, especially in the woods. It was mostly way in the back of the camp in between the white and red house. have you ever heard of anyone seeing anything like this? I took a couple pictures of it in case you want to see what I mean. It would be very sad/creepy if it really was... by the way, your videos are very interesting. thanks.

[@elaineboom7296]

Survivors have made some pits awear.. if you watch kitty when she first returns she points some out

[@colonelsmith7757]

You really think ash piles would last 80 years?

[@VanlifewithAlan]

I am glad they interest you!

[@jamesstewart553]

Irving is clever and articulate and is an expert when it comes to avoiding the answer, dancing away from the point and giving the appearance of having answered.

[@buzznfrog6702]

he has to be careful of what he says or He’ll get locked up

[@stoggafllik]

Go back to your echo chamber retarded nigger

[@timvella1817]

Is he?

[@fendweller]

Bickering with David Irving. A painful spectacle, I'm afraid.

[@nazbites]

its sad to hear ; even if theyre freakin cheap and some racist

[@HouseholdDog]

Test

[@VanlifewithAlan]

I refer you to volume 2, chapter 13 of Mein Kampf. The German version which I presume you have not read but which is available on line. In fact, I suspect that many of these children were not the product of the French occupation of the Rhineland but the product from people from Namibia and Tanganika or other places and a German who returned to Germany with the family after these territories ceased to be German.

[@VanlifewithAlan]

I took him around in my car.

[@skorzalonsdale4426]

You have the patience of a saint, even ignoring his views he come across as a deeply i likeable human being. This video series is fantastic, but a lot of the comments have made me lose some faith in humanity.

[@thecasualfront7432]

Possibly one of the saddest things I’ve ever seen. That poor woman out in the rain to answer “where were the bodies?” From that self satisfied ghoul

[@timvella1817]

Why is he?

[@skorzalonsdale4426]

Even if I ignore his views, Mr Irving comes across as an incredibly unpleasant and arrogant person in these videos. I can’t believe other people in these comments think he came across well.

[@VanlifewithAlan]

@Iceland1944 God did not make anything. God does not exist except in people's minds. Many of those responsible for Auschwitz went to church every Sunday. That is the type of morality that the world can do well without!

[@InhabitantOfOddworld]

Shut up, boomer

[@thomasmccann3679]

It is statically impossible for every event in the universe and recorded history to have occurred without the existence of God. You are not a friend of logic .

[@koko2bware]

​@@thomasmccann3679 You got to remember, most of "that kind" are not!!😜

[@lotse11-ye8rq]

The people in Auschwitz kill the son of the Church..... so.... something gone wrong

[@stoggafllik]

​@@thomasmccann3679You sound like you kneel for BLM

[@VanlifewithAlan]

Here he says very clearly that he is not sceptical about this yet the denier liars living in their crackpot conspiracist world continue to say that he has not said it. This is a video, for anyone but a total nutter this is proof. However when it comes to the likes of Zundel and other fantacists, no proof is needed whatsoever. There you have the denier liar mindset.

[@bradmeeds1226]

Let me know if they find the wmd's

[@NoahBodze]

You’re still a low-IQ psychopath a decade later, aren’t you, stupid?

[@TheWhiteManSays]

You are harassing a 80 y/o man, i consider this direst you buffoon

[@stephendaedalus6192]

You do not seem to be at all familiar with Irving's argument on the topic. Fairly lax, if that's you translating for him. You should have informed yourself. He never denied mass executions of jews, or any other group.

[@captaintruth]

you're as misguided as the next.

[@historicrecord]

The judge summarised his findings as follows: Irving has for his own ideological reasons persistently and deliberately misrepresented and manipulated historical evidence; that for the same reasons he has portrayed Hitler in an unwarrantedly favourable light, principally in relation to his attitude towards and responsibility for the treatment of the Jews; that he is an active Holocaust denier; that he is anti-Semitic and racist, and that he associates with right-wing extremists who promote neo-Nazism...[4][64] therefore the defence of justification succeeds...[5] It follows that there must be judgment for the Defendants.[65]

[@bradmeeds1226]

A Jew judge said that go figure

[@rhysnichols8608]

Yeah an American judge said OG Simpson was innocent go figure

[@severusfloki5778]

Irrelevant I’m afraid

[@jimmorrison2692]

Why use the term racist and anti-semitic? Isn't "racism" enough?

[@koko2bware]

@@k.m.7351 Yes, lawyers who are familiar with the case have said how the whole case was a total sham, and that Irwing had run circles around the witnesses, but they also agree the outcome was expected because of its sensitive political nature!!

[@VanlifewithAlan]

@firemarshall007 Polish

[@VanlifewithAlan]

@Iceland1944 No SS man has ever denied the holocaust. Not one of the thousands possible. As for Jews killing Christ - even the New Testament - which is largely a work of fiction does not claim that. It was the Romans - today Italians who are today Catholics. Therefore this silly Christ killer argument takes an entirely new perspective. As for God calling Jews his people, I scarcely think that an imaginary character calls anyone his people - except of course in the imagination of believers.

[@lotse11-ye8rq]

Whenever I see the almost non-existent interviews of SS men, the questions are unclear and the answers are clear yes, everyone I have seen firmly asserts that there was no Holocaust. They claim that yes, people died, but not from gas. After all, if you have a reasonable brain and analyze all the evidence, what you realize didn't happen, the official narrative is pathetic. Paul Hafner in one of his interviews always said what I heard from an SS man, as well as the millions of documents found by the allies, the SS only monitored basic activities in the fields, Totenkopf barely acted in the internal part and that is very clear in the American claims and various reports from Jews themselves.

[@colonelsmith7757]

Are you aware that the SS tried and executed camp commandants when they used excessive force against prisoners? Your entire presupposition is ridiculous.

[@timvella1817]

New Testament is a work of fiction lol. Now you are a complete joke.

[@alfredroyal3473]

He is a buffoon, writes well, but a buffoon nevertheless.

[@colonelsmith7757]

You're the buffoon m8

[@timvella1817]

Why?

[@VanlifewithAlan]

@SamLuvsJamesDean It is huge disrespect to the victims and I think it is designed to cause them additional suffering. The only explanation I have found is that racism is just a form of mental disease. Nonetheless I think it should be illegal - it is not expressing an opinion, a free speech issue as the denier liars want to pretend - it is a deliberate act to cause mental anguish to the victims.

[@thomasmccann3679]

The truth does not fear investigation.

[@rexel666]

No, sir, "racism" is a word that never existed until it was invented in the 1920s by a mass murdering, Bolshevik Jew called Lev Bronstein who subsequently changed his name to Leon Trotsky.

[@VanlifewithAlan]

@@rexel666 You made this up - the question is why?

[@lotse11-ye8rq]

​@@thomasmccann3679👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@timvella1817]

Is it the same for the people of Europe have multicultural to the point of extinction as a civilisation?

[@VanlifewithAlan]

They have not exposed anything. David Cole has admitted what he did was a hoax and David Irving says he will sue anyone who calls him a Holocaust denier. The denier liars need to lie because that is the only way they can get their racist message across. Incidentally, if you are a native English speaker, you ought to spend a bit more time improving your writing skills and a little less reading racist denier liar materials. Their lack of education has rubbed off on you.

[@AmsterdamagedHQ]

Alan Heath Cole only retracted his statement under duress from Irv Reuben. He also had to pay him thousands of dollars to remove the price on his head. Im not a denier but I find your constant reference to "Denier Liars" juvenile and detrimental to any kind of serious debate. Thanks for sharing the videos.

[@severusfloki5778]

@@AmsterdamagedHQ Hi. Who’s Reuben please? Full name?

[@AmsterdamagedHQ]

@@severusfloki5778 Irv Rubin, chairman of the Jewish Defense League

[@severusfloki5778]

@@AmsterdamagedHQ Cheers!

[@historiented6573]

He certainly has not admitted any such thing. He still maintains that Auschwitz was not in any way an extermination camp but a huge industrial work/slave labor camp. He believes that the Reinhardt camps in the East were extermination camps. I just heard a talk by him on Odyssee he gave in 2021. The Odyssee channel is called "Jerm Warfare." Cole maintains that several million Jews were killed during WW2 of all causes. Cole guesses that about 100,000 died at Auschwitz mostly of typhus.