Is astrology spiritual or scientific? || Acharya Prashant, with DU (2023)

[@AcharyaPrashant]

To contact the Foundation: acharyaprashant.org/en/enquiry?cmId=m00027 For online solutions to life questions: acharyaprashant.org/en/courses?cmId=m00027

[@anukaushal8689]

🙏

[@neilenglishby7914]

Where do you stand on the spinning ball earth

[@avijitmukherjee5766]

Thanks!

[@mohammadahmed3774]

It was such a pleasure to get a chance to interact with Acharya Prashanth. Wish to meet him in person. Hope my questions have helped others too.

[@K-tx2lk]

Was it you?

[@suniltiwari9215]

Surely it helped.

[@nil.nilesh56]

❤️

[@DeepakJAT0007]

You surely asked that question because of some pseudoscientists like Sadguru. Who are ready to mix any superstition with science and declare it spiritual too. I was his victim for a long time.

[@RahulDobriyal]

Bro ye tum ho video me ?

[@Sansarsagar3356]

" Some people will validate your assumption and some will falsify your assumption but very few people will tell you that the thing all you have is assumption"~ AP 🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️

[@music_lover7837]

Bcz they haven't understood it yet. I was the same as them when I had no clue about the advait vedant. But now i got it n I'm keep understanding every single details 😌

[@AMAN-wp8ez]

that was said by ACHARYA SHANKAR

[@Ritam108]

What an answer being given by you acharya ji, Science and Spirituality one is study of objects (Objective) another is study of Subjects, Subjective. Kind love

[@thedebapriyakar]

Whoever is in charge of AP's wardrobe -- your work is highly, highly appreciated! Excellent work, keep going

[@abhinavbadoni7032]

Rightly said...lol..

[@aakashbhardwaj7481]

16:22 to be curious is to not assume anything 👍👍👍

[@vijayyaduvanshi276]

Astrology और Astronomy मे मूलभूत अन्तर है.. कुछ लोग इनको एक समझ लेते है l

[@gurushanthaiahms2121]

Spirituality is the study of subject where as science is the study of object.Both definitions are clear and exclusive.

[@joyetahazra2864]

Gratitude Guruji ❤️🙏

[@devbhardwaj9284]

14:32 ohhh bhaisahab great AP ji

[@yogeshparmar996]

That smile on his face...heavenly😁

[@sneharana462]

I feel psychology as a science is connected to sprituality

[@ravimaan6598]

Yes , psychology when combined with the purpose of liberation is spirituality . That's what I think , u r free to correct if I'm wrong.

[@rvv6603]

How can science study which doesn't exist. Aatma doesn't exist. Spirituality is study of aatma(subject)

[@ThePrasadgurav007]

Yes both are connected somewhat. But the basic difference between the two is psychology doesn't challenge your fundamental identity.

[@raakshas5547]

Yes phsychology is a part spirituality.

[@senseikj1595]

@@raakshas5547 But it's not a real part of Science because you cannot connect science and spirituality together!!

[@joyetahazra2864]

Thought -provoking analysis! 👌 Blessed to hear🙏

[@Sunil-K-Suthar]

Feeling blessed to hear you in the morning 🌞 your interpretation of spiritualism is superb,, outstanding 🤗👌👌

[@rinkadasgupta4069]

Well explained acharyaji.A rational person can't believe in all these.

[@K-tx2lk]

14:28 AP rocked 🔥😅

[@UnfoldingHinduism]

As a curious researcher on Jyotish, I would be grateful to know the Atma karaka, Moon sign and Sun sign in acharya Ji's birth chart. I hope the comment reaches Acharya Ji's team and I am answered.

[@UnfoldingHinduism]

it seems Acharya ji's team is too busy to read the comments.. or perhaps they do not bother to gain some knowledge in a subject before criticizing it.

[@akashp214]

Birth chart! What's that?

[@TanoyMondal-fg2dx]

​@@UnfoldingHinduismthe team doesn't have the time to indulge in bullshit things that you deal with.Go get a life instead of hovering over non-sense subjects.Hope you got your answer.

[@grimmstryke9627]

What does spiritual mean and how is it different from make believe?

[@akshaypratap3366]

Spritual person means one who questions everything rather than just believing

[@Katielomax7]

Spiritual people don’t have a set belief, they’re open to all avenues.

[@_Gondson_750_]

Nice to meet you Sar

[@DeepakJAT0007]

He surely asked that question because of some pseudoscientists like Sadguru. Who are ready to mix any superstition with science and declare it spiritual too. I was his victim for a long time.

[@Edu_BIOLOGY]

Spirituality is the study to subject....arre mujhe toh lga th *having believe in God*

[@K-tx2lk]

With Like button, use that Thanks button also, so that you can contribute to Acharya ji's work and to the foundation. 🙏

[@misbahailia3345]

13:07 "Science without religion is weak, and religion without Science is blind". Albert Einstein.

[@diptyprakashswain1121]

Spirituality is study of consciousness 👍.

[@plabmadeeasy]

Love how beautifully this has been answered! :')

[@allanxetriya4923]

Sir, first you Explain that Astrology can't be proved with scientific evidence ( by resembling with Newton's gravity law in the video) And then said Spirituality have nothing to do with science, So, my question is - " Can Astrology also have nothing to do with Science? Can it also be independent of Science(Study of objects as you said) ?"

[@saktimaankafan9053]

Love ❤️ from india jharkhand jamshedpur jugsalai chaprahiya

[@pamposhganjoo5330]

Nice explanation given by Acharya ji...But the unfortunate part is that many people believe in myths and astrology and get carried away....

[@creatorsearch69]

First thing first, what is the difference between a belief and truth?

[@Balert-z8w]

✨💯💟☮️

[@atulkulkarni3110]

Observe the way Acharya ji teaches the questioner... indeed he is a great teacher...that's why he is THE आचार्य जी 😎

[@nvnaryan3773]

In some families, women are blamed and assaulted for their bad astrology and bad timing of their birth... It's such a worst blind faith...

[@navjotgour2877]

Lol jab Shaadi Hoti Hai.. Jo kundali mangte Hain, unko ussi time block Kyu nhi krti ya krvati vo ladkia!?

[@secularbanda1808]

Chapter :9 ;Verse 23 O son of Kunti, even those devotees who faithfully worship other gods also worship Me. But they do so by the wrong method.

[@PsyMathRajinderSivian]

A scientific saint Acharya Parshant Ji

[@zumieskitchen]

Beautiful sharing See you around

[@drRealALGOtRader567]

Blessed to hear acharya Prashant sir 🙏

[@ojaspatil4884]

Bageshwar baba ki jai

[@anilsahu3725]

✨🙌 Simple, clear, straightforward 🙏

[@minakshithoughts]

Sat sat naman acharya ji🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@aleccap5946]

Mostly what's inside your head, no believes in a one God, as everyone believes in their own version and yet we're all of the same species ? So how is this possible

[@shashisharma1584]

Gratitude Acharya ji 🙏

[@Swanand...]

Essay : An assumption shouldn't be stamped as a fact....before knowing something..

[@nirajpatil9040]

🙏🙏🙏 gratitude

[@DevD-j9i]

Acharya prashant ji we should not associate astrology with astrologer its a science its beyond astrologer

[@AnusheelSharma]

The DU topper thought I score the highest in my class, hence I am the smartest and now I shall have a discourse with acharya prashant, but a critical thinker who sits at the last bench scores half of that of topper's will never get the centre stage, that's the irony of our education system.

[@suniltiwari9215]

Is he DU topper In which stream By the way, it happens when u get little knowledge and overestimate yourself

[@sanjaypimoli9233]

Prnaam achry ji

[@devbhardwaj9284]

astrology meri life barbad krne wali thi aapne bacha lia achaarya ji

[@rolexsirr]

Astrology kaise life barbaad kar sakti hai? Woh sirf paise barbaad karti hai

[@iiTzKaran_YT]

​@@rolexsirr bhai💀 Log astrology ke basis par shaadi Tod dete h 💀

[@mconnah1]

Brilliant, well said…

[@AP-eb8hd]

Very happy to see this response... This is not confirmation bias, but what I observed is the people who believe in astrology have poor scientific temper..

[@HarshalJaiswal-x8h]

Correct

[@citationneeded912]

Finally, finally a scholar who presented a straight answer rather than beating around the bush and never coming to the point at all. Acharyaji I appreciate your wisdom. Keep growing and help others grow.❤

[@_Shivani_Rajput]

Naman Acharya Ji 🌺🙏

[@AjayDwivedi8]

Gurudev🙇‍♂️

[@PhaniPrasadM]

Spirituality is the study of 'I' the object as per AP but so is the entire human anatomy, psychology, sociology and neurology.

[@g.shankaranarayananil3705]

Astrology is a complete time tested science but today's astrologers are half baked.....

[@samarpatel238]

16:11 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻❤️❤️❤️❤️🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@SatyamAnand-yx9or]

Excellent !

[@MotivationSakhi]

Acharya ji is a renaissance in himself 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@-advaitbipul6633]

Loved it ☺️

[@jitendrakumar-cd6ly]

प्रणाम आचार्य जी 🙏🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🙏

[@CosmoMaximilian]

science=object sprituality=subject

[@manojl3388]

I wonder what would Sadguru's answers about Astrology be????

[@suniltiwari9215]

No wonder 😃 The obvious one

[@RajKumar-ff8ep]

Good morning sir ji 🙏🌅

[@AgapeMinistries54]

Science is only Knowledge, Spirituality is something we don’t know but feel

[@Gamma_educator]

Brilliant ✨

[@thomasmorin749]

Albert Einstein. 'Astrology is nothing more than superstitious nonsense'.

[@devbhardwaj9284]

14:25 sigma smile

[@davidleighton6918]

"Anyone who believes in Astrology cannot be a rational person" - substitute spirituality for Astrology - similar proof basis

[@manojthakur8675]

There is no one like AP In these days 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 keep the great work acharya ji, in these days world needs you 🙏

[@nawangtam3634]

I understood your point sir but when I think about prophecy of the Lord Buddha many other enlightened persona of decades, isn’t that astrology again to talk about their future? It became true as well. I really need to clear the doubts on this now sir. Please enlighten me! Thank you🙏

[@MYSTIC_2911]

This man changed my mind I was brainwashed 🙏❤now I can understand what actually is life 💯

[@FreedomFrom_Known]

Thank You Acharaya ji🙏🙏🙏

[@needbettername8583]

It's spiritual. There you go.

[@abhishekanand8288]

What about Biological sciences, Biotechnology, Neurosciences ? These are the studies of subject itself !!

[@abhishekanand8288]

@@Srividya_youtube If mind is object, then what is CHETNA ?

[@ishitasharan8201]

Body is material. Spirituality talks about Atman.

[@ishitasharan8201]

@@abhishekanand8288 find a video on Chetna..there are many videos available on Acharya ji's channel .He will explain you more effectively 😃

[@ppgautam]

@@abhishekanand8288Sprituality is study of I and not biology

[@suniltiwari9215]

All the things you see, read, experience, believe around yourself is object regardless of the form. The subject is the one who experiences all these things/objects ie "I".

[@silverballer7342]

Jab kuchinsaano ko sach pata chal jata hain zyada se zyada aur doosre log ek samaj banake usko tusht karne mein zindagi bita rahe hote hain tab sach sabko bura lagne lagta hain kyuki hazaro saalo se yehi mana ja raha hain. Aur ek jhatke mein jab kisike samne kuch ghat jata hain tab uneasy lagta hain. Acharya Ji ek bohot accha aur nek kam kar rahe hain aur acche kam ke liye kisi ki permit zaroori nahi hota. Acharya Ji ko mera Pranam. 🙏

[@atulsoni07]

My god❤

[@pranavpranavkul]

something which is not science is not rational. then spirituality if is not science then how can it be rational?

[@nandasha001]

Science is about external world and spirituality is about internal world.true spirituality is not against science

[@Tashaaprasad7619]

🎉🎉🎉right thanks

[@pooja5154]

Blessed to hear 🙏❤️

[@ishitasharan8201]

Pranam Acharya ji 🙏🙏🙏

[@renusingh1043]

Spirituality works on the subject & science works on the object it is clear spirituality is not a part of science ☺️☺️☺️☺️ Acharya Prashant clears everything 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@anjalipatel7092]

None can save you Ec Except Acharya Prashant ! 🌸🙏😇 Gratitude sir 🙏 Thankful Grateful to you sir 🙏

[@adroitprojectsolution2245]

From past some years science has already started exploring the study of subject ( consciousness)

[@GiveItaGo]

Neither is fiction based in opinion

[@satya8730]

But Acharyaji i opine that spirituality is a scientific study of the subjects consciousness as it proofs that if our chosen path gets wrong it will result in wrong only, which is a fact of science only sir. Than how is it different from science as you said that it is not science but it is spirituality only , if you pls solve this for me sir🙏 will keep learning from you👌 Thanks.

[@nishantyagi619]

Ab iske kehne se hi astrology scientific hogi

[@kulbhushankumar5457]

Pranam Acharya Ji

[@rajaniramansrivastava8322]

What a magnificent & greater than life personality of Yours Acharyawar delving deep&cutting edges of every faculty of human life. Really an evolving super human of our nation. 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@shivkapoor3302]

Pranaam acharya jiआचार्य प्रशांत कहते हैं कि ज्योतिष को तार्किक या वैज्ञानिक मान्यता नहीं माना जा सकता। उनका कहना है कि किसी चीज़ को विज्ञान माना जाने के लिए, उसके पास सत्यापन योग्य और मिथ्या सिद्धांत होने चाहिए, और समान परिस्थितियों में समान परिणाम देने में सक्षम होना चाहिए। उनका कहना है कि ज्योतिष इन मानदंडों को पूरा करने में विफल रहता है और केवल एक कहानी या सिद्धांत है जो सत्यापन के लिए उपलब्ध नहीं है। उनका कहना है कि लोग चाहें तो इस पर विश्वास करने के हकदार हैं, लेकिन इसे तार्किक, तर्कसंगत या वैज्ञानिक नहीं कहा जाना चाहिए। उनका यह भी कहना है कि आध्यात्मिकता को वैज्ञानिक नहीं माना जाता है।

[@swadipchakraborty1927]

Love you Gurudeb your my Hero

[@Raonishayadav]

🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@PintuKumar-wo9oq]

नमस्ते,🙏🇮🇳🌲🇮🇳

[@beanos_p4136]

Spiritual

[@vinaysharma9216]

🙏🙏

[@reckoner1913]

Astrology is a load of old nonsense.

[@wallikhan]

🎉🎉

[@jagatnarayansingh477]

🙏

[@rajendraprasadrastogi7091]

प्रणाम आचार्य जी

[@tonysingh59]

Well said. One who believe in astrology can not be rational.

[@rishikumar8827]

Results are same bcoz u r performing same action, but people's action changes w.r.t. time and hence results varies. Acharya ji, This time I'm not agree with u .

[@samarpatel238]

13:51 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻❤️❤️❤️❤️🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻