Is Make In India Failing? | Case study

[@ThinkSchool]

👉Spam-free Health Insurance - ditto.sh/d4cmdv

[@PikacHu-ey9gp]

Infact, that's true, whatever the title suggests

[@pavang9376]

Hello sir plz make a video on Delhi air pollution solutions and why does it become like this everytime

[@SathyaswamyS]

Along with Make in India, the entire India is destined to stagnate and fail.

[@AtulyaPatel-em6ln]

In my opinion the first problem occurs with accountability of govt to people . If there are land disputes and environmental clearance problem then govt must provide faster compensation and find a way for environmental clearance so that it don't harm our earth as well as grow Indian economy. Second issue is the kind of economic system we used which is mixed economy. It's my thought I don't whether it's right or wrong

[@reardelt]

It's more critical to have good health than to have health insurance. If you keep your sugar intake in check, then you don't need to worry about diabetes.

[@nishant3899]

Men tried. Men failed. Men learned. Men try again. Men succeed.

[@abba747]

In the case of India...the last line should be Men failed AGAIN....and AGAIN and AGAIN...MEN MOVED TO SINGAPORE OR CANADA OR USA

[@tdbhavsar]

@@abba747 then please move. Who is stoping you

[@abba747]

@@tdbhavsar I already did !!! 🤣🤣🤣

[@DuckDuckgo047]

Before 10 years india could not make ammunition for our own weapons but we could send spacecraft to space and not because we are not capable, it is because of the earlier govt not taking interest in the 60 years of their rule. Believe in next 10 years India's defence production would be enough to change all the import export bill. Benefits of the current spending on infra will be seen in long term. And today tata is going to produce AN 392 aircrafts in India which is going to be a game changer. So it requires some time to see the benefits of the policy when we compare instabilities all across the world.

[@Buzyideas]

Defence should not be the only sector India should ace at. Also, Tata-Airbus partnership means nothing until 2026-27 because the first consignment of this factory is India itself. They will be only exporting to other countries only after 2026-27 as per the timeline since our order gets completed during that time.

[@rajeshchaudhari436]

If you go too fast, an accident can happen and increase inflation. It's important to proceed with balance.

[@unknown.m.e]

He didn't say the Govt is the problem. He said people are the problem like you and me

[@DuckDuckgo047]

@@Buzyideas yes this is what iam also saying that it's benefits take time to show their results but not shown in any videos like these.

[@shatzco]

And if our export don't change you will pay to Indian govt?

[@AnkitYadav-vz8gk]

You cannot directly manufactured 100% any product firstly you assembled product then make 10% integers indigenously then share increases with the time initial step taken by the government is very good even I am not a BJP supporter but in this case I support❤

[@maxverstapanfromkerala]

Include 18 percent GST will motivate the consumer for purchase goods and services

[@ssr1857]

im BJP supporter , and i'm proud of that. No scams, no betrayal, no corruption

[@maxverstapanfromkerala]

@@ssr1857 I'm proud of Not reporting any Scam, If scam reported they will join BJP

[@CVESameer]

@@maxverstapanfromkerala Use burnol buddy it helps

[@SumeetMahindroo1990]

​@@ssr1857 Ashok Chavan, Hemanta Biswa Sharma, Suvendu Adhikari, Ajit Pawar, Kripashankar Singh, Naveen Jindal scammers are part of BJP and NDA through Washing Machine.

[@sathyaphaneeshwar]

Even Amaravathi city suffered the same thing, the government announced 2015, delayed due to environmental constraints till early 2019, then the govt changed and the project scrapped

[@SUNs1591]

back in business, baby

[@ssr1857]

CBN on mission mode to built AMARAVATHI a best city in INDIA

[@saibalaji9676]

It will rise like phinix 🔥

[@TaxInsightsbyCAShahid]

It is not the strongest of the species that survive, nor the most intelligent, but the one most responsive to change." - Charles Darwin

[@TaxInsightsbyCAShahid]

..

[@TaxInsightsbyCAShahid]

.

[@djronald27]

A for Apple B for ball

[@wanderer9593]

C for cat D for doll

[@soyanshumohapatra]

E for excellent quote *Most cool quote 👍*

[@kazuma2060]

It's not that india will become self reliant within few years due to make in India. A lot has to be done but it's better to take small steps towards self reliance rather than standing still and doing nothing.

[@maxverstapanfromkerala]

This is Acchedin doesn't spread fake news

[@hepinpatel4028]

This is where too much democracy is hurting us. Good initiatives are not being able to get executed.

[@iamtherj]

I was exactly thinking about this! Democracy comes with some loopholes too

[@abba747]

Are you proposing dictatorship??? 🤣

[@alok.01]

​@@abba747Not a dictatorship, nationalist. It's on this democracy where a r*pist gets to live for years without any consequences and victims suffer

[@SanjuktaSahoo-cm6uh]

Dictatorship isn't good look at lives of chinese people, or russian people I'll gladly take a bit less rate of growth over a Dictatorship that has multiple times of growth.​@abba747

[@ExplorerBhowmik]

The Govt. is taking steps to ensure Make In India goes on to be a success. But it is a slow and steady process. We live in a country where even consumers who can afford slightly costlier Indian products often settles for a chinese product available for even 10 percent cheaper. We can consider those people who are on a tight budget, but if those who can afford still cannot make such a small sacrifice dont deserve to complain. We compare our country with South Korea and Japan, but dont have the same commitment as them.

[@maxverstapanfromkerala]

It's Acchedin don't blame

[@vikkstar01]

well said, such thing require commitment. government will push but people will have to accept.

[@vaibhavgupta20]

Why are Chinese product 10 percent cheaper? Why can't Indians build 20 percent cheaper?

[@12xenn45]

Because Chinese have mastered manufacturing techniques and they can make products much cheaper than Indians also they are very very fast moving always track of the latest trends.​@@vaibhavgupta20

[@AnujDeshmukhhh3010]

Please take a lesson in economics about absolute and comparative advantage before giving such senseless ideas.

[@vidyasagarrvsr3723]

I am happy to see that instead of blame game on parties. One team talks about fundamental problems and root causes. I really want, please if you have potential solutions, post a video on that. Let the our goverment and ministers know about it, if we cant help our govt who else

[@BilalKhan-cq6mn]

Accha😂 har failure pe Nehru ki galti hoti hai. Aur har success pe inka haath hota hai

[@Randomuser866]

​@@BilalKhan-cq6mnHe is talking about ThinkSchool and I don't what you're talking about? And Nehru is criticised by even JRD Tata. What you say about that. He is almost betrayed by Nehru by Nationalisation of AirIndia and ThinkSchool just try to discuss about solutions, and possible measures. Which means as an advisory and aware the youth to held government accountable for their policy executions. This Channel is not a credit claimer

[@alert_indian-x3p]

​@BilalKhan-cq6mn Nehru had said, "Profit is a dirty word". This was when JRD Tata was conversing with him post-independence. His socialist and secularist mindset and politics have completely crippled India until we were forced had to do 1991 liberalization. All of India's initial failures can be largely attributed to the Nehru government after independence.

[@SayElon]

​@@BilalKhan-cq6mnBJP say I want to conserve ancient history. Nationalist Congress say I will destroy the history. Non Nationalist BJP say india should be on top.(Modi) Congress say why we should on top. No need of it just live the life.( Manmohan Singh) BJP say let export the Car. Congress let export the raw and import the car. BJP take tax and build the india strong. Congress give freebies and push india in the loan.

[@priiiithvii]

Pehle mujhe kuch umeed nhi thi but now after all this semi conductor and other manufacturing started i can surely say make in india is working

[@adrika_sharma]

As a businesswoman, I can definitely say "Make in India" has improved a lot.

[@SUNs1591]

Before 10 years india could not make ammunition for our own weapons but we could send spacecraft to space and not because we are not capable, it is because of the earlier govt not taking interest in the 60 years of their rule. Believe in next 10 years India's defence production would be enough to change all the import export bill. Benefits of the current spending on infra will be seen in long term. And today tata is going to produce AN 392 aircrafts in India which is going to be a game changer. So it requires some time to see the benefits of the policy when we compare instabilities all across the world.

[@electrowizard2658]

thats great to know mam

[@MP-gw2ek]

more power to you!

[@12345Kainan]

Modi don't deny the failure, is something congress can never do. He submitted to the will of the farmer scraping his bill. Never in history done by Congress for any protest. The symbol of a genuine person is the ability to rationalise decisions.

[@shsi5246]

Got it?

[@SUNs1591]

but modi laid foundation of manufacturing, he is our priest king, and manufacturing of semiconductor means 7 fab ready by 2028 all and Govt. owned mohali semiconductor also got fund to research, ev manufacturing,baterry manufacturing, energy manufacturing,automobile, smartphone manufacturing but high precision manufacturing is yet to start but it also started and that and then only india will acheive make in india and make in india was true is that not true that they try to make india manufacturing hub which acheive 75% of target but that 25% is important to compete in global sense and modi, the priest king know

[@shsi5246]

Farmers from south,east and west india aren't cheats. That's why they had no affect on farm laws or it's withdrawal

[@shatzco]

Go and marry him lol.

[@doncorleone1480-h9s]

Joker, congress has done it multiple times. And modi did not do it as a noble task but with the fear of public uprising. How far you andhbhakts will go to support yoour pawpaw. As for modi he has EC and SC in his pockets and continuously winning elections through cheating, and you call him courageous. What a joker you are!!

[@Vijay-oz3sr]

BJP has done more good for India then any other party ever has, infact the opposition has only tried to bring BJP down instead of supporting their great initiatives

[@subuappa4278]

Can you list some of the good work BJP has done for the Country mini 10 plz...

[@saibalsahoo8597]

​@@subuappa4278Just know about new Railway, Metro, Airports, Bank NPA, inflation, Export, Defense export, Home Electricity Water LPG Toilet Concreat Village road for all, Ayushman health scheme, Direct cash transfer.... so so many success 😃😃

[@RealMeOn]

​@@subuappa4278 Go check the government websites

[@navingaikwad4077]

the real problem is locals who are in control of babu, corporator, mp and mla. all these upfront money eating machine will keep india poor. real example i wanted to setup food factory in outskirts of pune, 1st to get all clearance and permission it took 2 months with under the table of 1lac, then local corporator came on visit with his fortuner. i have maruti celerio. after understanding my business demand came of initial of 3lacs to start as donation. then locals of that village with surpanch came asking village improvement fund 1lac. monthly 20 to 50k as protection and safety money. before starting a business 1 + 3 + 1 + 50k = 4.5 outgoing. i ask my ca to record all these with proper entry toh nirmala aunty ko bhi paata chaale paise kahaan jaa rahe hai.

[@TejaswiBhat]

Choose a less dramatic thumbnail This thumbnail makes the video look like a clickbait

[@amitjesur]

It is clickbait

[@saisundaram2796]

Clickbait is fine if the content is good. And the content is good.

[@alert_indian-x3p]

Yeah, I have noticed it in his videos much more these days. For example, his last video on Dhirubhai Ambani had its title changed around 4-5 times. One more clickbait-ey than other.

[@MP-gw2ek]

haha. it IS a click bait. but its alright. TS makes good videos, so I will excuse them this time.

[@businesss_strategy_]

BJP and modi ji was the best because of huge startup Growth after 2014

[@STRIKER_MATCH_REPORTS]

Exactly congress ne pura barbaad kar diya tha business isliye ham aaj bhe china se peche ha kyuki tab congress ne businesses ko grow he nhi hone diya

[@kaaditya]

​@@STRIKER_MATCH_REPORTSBut it is really disappointing to see (whom we assumed) good channels were spineless while awakening them during elections, as a result we see BJP is giving all freebies, u turn in almost every revolutionary Bills etc.

[@gagan2952]

and the issues regarding clearance of papers, delayed our growth

[@kaaditya]

​@@gagan2952I bet even if BJP try to digitalise it CONGRESS will play it as bjp is planning to take SC ST lands

[@STRIKER_MATCH_REPORTS]

BJP Government is necessary for India's growth and back in 2014 we have really less number of business and startup because of congress scams and courruptions

[@rajtheking659]

Congress / India alliance are backstabbers.

[@Agricultureinfo176]

😂

[@hpsangha3404]

Modi ne kya ukhada liya abhi tak?? Ghanta

[@uuuuu9313]

Yep various scams used to happen at central level where you had to count zeroes and by the time you came to last zero you forgot how many zeroes were in total were there 2G scam, scam with midday meal , shikshak Bharti scam , robert wadra land grab , coal scam , liquor scam If you had to make any document charges were fixed which were at least five times original cost now most of the documents can be made online All the money sent out for poor in form of subsidies or compensation never reached to public or lakhs of compensation was turned into few thousands now it is direct bank transfer Land grabs were very common Our PM when went on important foreign policy meeting he would be accompanied by sonia gandhi where she was given importance And private companies could not even sell their businesses without government interference aircel owner wanted to sell his business for 6 billion dollars but he was forced by ministers at centre to not sell leading to bankruptcy of company

[@archupatel5714]

Yes you are right

[@Laxmanca]

make in India become blessing in one sector and just boost it Guess which one? INDIAN DEFENCE EXPORTS increased 31 times over the last decade, from ₹4,312 crore ($500 million) in 2004-05 to 2013-14 to ₹88,319 crore ($11 billion) in 2014-15 to 2023-24, Reflecting the global acceptability of Indian defence products and technologies. [technology imported from france,Russia help us lot, special thanks to (DRDO) focusing on make in INDIA and continue doing manufacturing,assembling and promoting private sector] We today itself achieve a great deal with SPAIN for manufacturing of C-295 aircraft in our NATION : )

[@honeybeee23]

Bro it also became success in electronics sector we are 2nd largest exporter of electronics 😊

[@Laxmanca]

@@honeybeee23 yes bro.

[@tirthshah2162]

Scams are everywhere 😔 not just in national politics it's also in corporate politics also in college committee and placeComm toxic culture politics 😢

[@ssr1857]

Can you tell me one scam of national politics???

[@DearX-c3v]

U forgot to maintain school 🙂

[@Techwolf_official_YT]

A few points missing are: 1. Reforms in the education system. 2. The main problem which nobody wants to speak about is the lack of reforms in the judiciary system and its working style 3. Unskilled employees in government offices etc

[@himanshuverma3984]

More than solutions I think India needs to have opposition govt. which are pro-India rather than being anti-India.

[@subramanyamraju9738]

Do not follow media mindset.. do not keep negative thumbnails... now our country need only positivity

[@unknown.m.e]

Yeah we are great we should rule the world okay Go to bed

[@subramanyamraju9738]

@@unknown.m.e what is your problem? Are you not getting sleep?

[@anishmm7104]

People searching for opportunity will surely grap the MAKE IN INDIA opportunity

[@KavyaSoni-ew9il]

Inspite of this much environmental concerns most indian cities are top in pollution. 😢

[@entertainmentdaa7891]

Environmental people only object based on opposite political parties

[@भारतीय-1947]

*"That's why I love watching your videos on important case studies! 🙌 While some focus on criticizing 'Make in India' just to undermine Modi, you bring constructive insights with solutions. Truly admirable - thank you for this eye-opening case study! 👏🇮🇳"*

[@anishag9129]

Really good channel. Aside from the lack of comedy, think school is as close as it gets to Emmy winning show last week tonight with John Oliver.

[@sujaynis3905]

I have a feeling that "make in India" will succeed because people like Sanjeev Sanyal are in power.

[@DuckDuckgo047]

And the reason for FDI decline is India doesn't accept FDI from china, if allowed it would eat up all other things in India. Sometimes i feel, think schools content is under researched when it comes to topics which involves deep understanding of geopolitics.

[@honeybeee23]

Yaa tesla isn't invited in india cause they were selling cars that were manufactured in China and at that time we were facing border issues and the govt. Now reduced taxes on import foreign vehicle if they invest 500 million

[@siddharthreddy2167]

I agree..... Economic policies should augment geo-politics understanding . If we take FDIs without scrutiny that will again make us to dependency rather than self reliance. I feel today's entrepreneur should understand geo politics and long term impacts also before making decisions.

[@RavinderSingh-po2fp]

Make case studies on state economics. Like which state is doing better and what are the learnings other state government can take. I would like see video on Rajasthan.

[@AmanKumar-yj5od]

here is the solution for land acquisition in india - central government should buy and acquire land in every district in advance for potential business to a such extent that even a steel plant can be setup in every states district - by doing this there will be no motive for political ,enviromental concerns at a specific time when a potential corporate buyer wants to buy a land because these issues would have already been resolved . - this a great task but without this in disorganized easily radicalised indian democracy nothing will gonna work in efficient manner.

[@et.social5056]

Shi bola apne wow 🔥👍🏼

[@AmanKumar-yj5od]

@@et.social5056 thanks

[@kzmOP]

Why people look for government jobs!!!! Untill this baby culture is not stopped nothing gonna change!

[@KavyaSoni-ew9il]

Again due to the poor manufacturing sector. Unemployment and exploitation in private jobs.

[@priiiithvii]

​@KavyaSoni-ew9il so you want muft ki roti From tax payers money?

[@vickydash13]

Even the defense projects like border roads which is very crucial is delayed due to environmental clearance 😢.

[@rsivakumar9221]

Unless atitude of people don't change, these are the best results we will get. People in India should be will to work

[@7ssanket963]

And again for that, coming to basics, we need to improve the education system first... And literacy rate should at least be 95% [ And at least a person should be 10th passed (not from our typical govt. schools) for being considered as a literate ].

[@RickNovak-ch4od]

in current situation, bjp, modi, s. Jaysankar are the best for India.

[@siddhantoswal6183]

The high imports are because of purchasing raw materials from other countries. We have started manufacturing a few good products in India, but all the raw material is still sourced from other countries. We need better supply chain of raw material and basic parts that make up the whole product step by step.

[@cahiteshsachdev]

Make in India's results are fine. But showing Rahul's remarks on any economic policy ?? 😅

[@maxverstapanfromkerala]

Yeah, Because Bharath is the world's Number 3 economy with a 55 trillion Dollar. Jai modiji

[@alert_indian-x3p]

Rahul Gandhi will open jalebi factories across India to provide employment for lakes of Indians and will also export these jalebis to US and Japan. His own words, not mine. His vision is very clear and all he needs is to implement the said scheme.

[@frororf5357]

Your Thumbnail / banner pic is making you appear as a Supari KZbinr.. Kindly refrain from such cheap tactics as you know building a brand takes time but it doesn't take time to demolish it.. You are yourself doing such blunder which is surprising.. Don't do such things.. You're better than this

[@unknown.m.e]

It's not Govt fault if the people in India who makes the problem Mainly Govt employees and people who don't want to sell their land for developement

[@arjunssingh6055]

The root cause of all these problems is sedentary behavior that is embedded in each and every Indian, right from the day they are born. The lack of discipline and the lack of fear of punishment is the reason, that when people grow and things have to be done by themselves they majorly try to postpone those things. Until this happens in government departments it affects the willingness of business owners and entrepreneurs. For setting up a mobile case-selling business, I had to spend around a month for just arranging documents, INDIA CAN NEVER IMPROVE UNTIL THE LEADERS DONT

[@latvialava6644]

But, Some of our People are blindly Supporting Wangchuk jii without knowing the gravity & Depth of the situation.

[@latvialava6644]

Land acquisition in India is So annoying that i really admire Communists approach in this.

[@TusharKarki]

I'm not anyone's follower just saying a truth that Comment section is tottally biased towards BJP, guys don't make excuses make in india is obviously not a failure but it is also not successful

[@barathelango267]

we need video on "better easy of doing business lose". i know you have done related video in but we need a complete guide

[@pcaso]

Everyone is busy training for IAS and one who qualifies are busy blocking work

[@Meta-qe7tv]

So just mainly because of environment concern and land related matters most of projects are delayed or closed. Ngo are major factor in environment concern which spread propoganda falsely influenced by foreign money and power 😔.

[@laukikdesai2361]

Many factors play an important role in manufacturing output. People sometimes ignore that geopolitics also plays a major role in making or breaking a nation's manufacturing output. China is a manufacturing powerhouse because EU and US were lazy and outsourced menial tasks to China. The chinese copy pasted their technology and slowly with the price game outsmarted EU and US players from their own market leading positions. We also need to take into account the infrastructure growth needed for fast manufacturing output, we are growing but we have a long way to go there as well. So managing geopolitical shocks, managing infrastructure, managing the freebie population and boosting manufacturing at the same time is a very tricky and a slow process economically speaking. So directly fail hai bol dena thik nahi hoga.

[@subramanyamraju9738]

Administartion from gross root level has to change

[@Randomuser866]

True,no other proper reason than this at all.

[@SaiPraneethMullapudi]

5:15 In the recent years there is a reason for low FDI considering the consistent higher interest Rate regime in US since 2022. Which increased the bond yields. A small suggestion here the better metric would be to look at manufacturing FDI which shows true picture rather than FDI which might even be invested as equity purchases in companies which cannot directly be counted as manufacturing FDI.

[@k.easwaramoorthy1451]

Amazing explanation and we got many information about the why india stil lag in FDI .... And i think if theis are continue we definitely ...didn't achieve the VISKIT BHARAT 2047 ..... And 2047 we fix a next Target 🎯 to DEVELOPED india ... 😢😢😢😢

[@parthprajapati3487]

Hi great insights, can we also see the date of a particular video if you are showing a video from the past ? Again great work and love what you do from NYC!

[@srikarpendem2762]

We need a video on how India can improve the ease of doing business 🙏

[@deepaksrivastav9909]

Ease of doing business plz make a video on this❤

[@anshtyagi8403]

2:15 Smartphones in India are currently assembled, not manufactured. Most components are imported from countries like China or Vietnam and then assembled here. True manufacturing involves building a product from raw materials, starting from the ground up. Additionally, India does not yet manufacture semiconductor chips domestically, though efforts are underway, and it may take 4-5 years to establish this capability. The other points regarding solar panels and electric cars are accurate, so this information presents only a partial picture.

[@neelkamalxxx]

The biggest hurdle for India's development is our pitty politics . Entire year our leaders are busy in planning wining strategy like caste , religion balancing . Solution - one nation one election ,if a state fails to complete 5 years of governance than for the rest duration the state should be ruled under president under Supreme court surveillance . I am sure the remaining 4.10 years out of 5 year governance the country will focus on development like skilling , jobs .

[@DakshaySingh-c4e]

Think school please make a video on how to improve easy of doing business.

[@pranavsinghal129]

11:24 how is it easier to scale manufacturing than services? Infact, it’s completely opposite, right?

[@chandraravikumar]

When did you get subverted Think School? How much did it cost them?

[@SaiPraneethMullapudi]

Perhaps the biggest of the points you missed is the lack of big FTAs between India and big export destinations. That's where Vietnam is racing ahead of us. Many countries and blocs which India enjoys trade surplus don't have FTAs in Place. Best examples are US, EU, UK. If we exclude Energy purchases like Oil and Gas since we are net energy importers we don't have FTAs with high per capita income markets like Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Oman etc whcih are oil rich. Once FTAs are in place tariffs on Indian goods will be reduced which can increase competitiveness of the Indian products overall this can contribute a lot to Ease of Doing Business. But I still believe the way Make in India changed the approach of policy making towards manufacturing as a whole. Unlike the focus on traditional sectors like textiles and other industries the focus went to bring higher manufacturing sectors like Electronics, Speciality Steel, Li ion Battery cells, Solar modules and cells however wafers and polysilicon should be next area of focus, semiconductors atleast of matured grade etc. Even in electronics gross value addition per device is around 15-20% which is good enough considering that we started assembly of devices in a large scale post 2013 time period. This might soon reach to 30% before 2030. In comparison at present China's value addition itself in electronics is 45%. I call Make in India a partial failure considering the fact that manufacturing push im new age sectors was not there before. Another factor for less manufacturing growth is the Private GFCF in India which was due to the negative credit cycle in India which saw a wave of bankruptcies and piling up of NPAs which made lending institutions too cautious about giving out credit. This resulted in low capex from Private sector right from 2012 itself which is not yet reached it's 2006-10 cycle peak as % of GDP. But situation seems to be changing now corporate balance sheet is strengthened due to less debt, less NPA and provisioning from banks. Private sector capex should pickup which can lead to a capacity expansion due to more number of manufacturing SMEs being onboarded by big industries. Even on infrastructure front core projects are nearing completion like Transhipment port in Vizhinjam, Multiple Expressways like Bengaluru-Chennai Delhi-Mumbai Nagpur-Mumbai, Western and Eastern DFC etc which connect hinterlands to ports. Let's see how it turns out.

[@varunnair3469]

Wow! 🎉 nice explanation

[@tradergig]

Ganesh, this time I am not happy with the way you are showing it to the world, i expected much better analysis. I am not saying whether it is success of failure. Some initial stats which you showed are not how u do a detailed analysis. Let me get to the points. 1. Decrease import dependency - what was the population from 2004 to 2014.. how much was the import .. take the ratio and also find the rate. Now do same for 2014 to 2024. Here the ration and rate is important because if the population has grown imports needed may also be more. for example take the consumption of crude OIL 2004-2014 get the rate and ration with population and same compare it now. (u can also add $$ values if needed because prices may be different) this i am saying because Crude is the biggest part of our Imports and even the $$ to rupee is changed a lot so imports this decade can be normalized as compared to last decade to calculate the fair ration. 2. Manufacturing Growth Rate .- Do same with past decade and this decade comparison. 3. Exports have grown .. but still see the rate at it is grown .. is it good or bad compared to previous decade and this decade. Also if exports are increased then is it ok to have same imports or the ratio at which we doing imports even after the $$ to Rupee is so high. also this can be one of the reason for our import deficit which ur showing on 4.42 . you should also do it as a rate/ration from past decade to this decade. I dont know what is the sweet spot here definitely high exports and low imports is needed. 4. Jobs -- yes this has been a concern but this could also mean even though the industry are up or upgraded.. there is possibility that more and more automated machines have been used. take for example job cuts in IT industry due to AI and automation. I remember I was on a project where AI & automation in the digital processing for Uk based company caused a approx 300 job cuts in the BPO of that company in chennai. So it is tough to find the sweet spot. 5. Setup a company in India -- same compare it for previous decade compared to this decade. there are many such points.. I am not sure whether it is success or failure but definitely I feel in India business have increased, the per capita income is increased and so on. The real problem of India is small land area and huge population, it is also a boon.. infact a nice debate is needed .. Is increasing population of India a boon or curse !! People can commonet

[@Alfred-Bobby]

Happy married life bro🎉❤

[@gdeepak7]

I have been living in the UAE for the last 25 years. I see lot of Make in India products as toys and tools in the market here in last few years. Those chineese monopoly is been challenged now. So definitely Make is India is in the right track!

[@TheFootLooseFlyer]

Modi Government is branding + marketing genius. They've curated their slogans and names of their initiatives quite wisely, which have high recall value and sounds aspirational.

[@Leo_2k2]

Absolutely 🔥👍

[@honeybeee23]

Atleast better 5han every other party let's be honest

[@Gd-jq6mz]

​@@honeybeee23 Marketing genius indeed

[@honeybeee23]

@@Gd-jq6mz huh?

[@unlock01]

One suggestion, please don't have a black background, a brighter background would be much better

[@aditya.k.kochhar]

Please do the video on ease of doing business. Also, the actual need is to look at all the laws and rules and weed out all the roadblocks.

[@Mundarapilly]

The Central Govt should bring in a new Business Facilitation Dept under the Ministry of Commerce and Industry. The sole aim and work of this dept should be to facilitate the Businesses through the red tape in India. A portal where all documents can be submitted and clearances can be issued. The portal should contain the required documents so that no officer or bureaucrat can cheat the businessmen.

[@Deb-k8k]

Two types of people support BJP- The rich and the andhbhakt Two types of people support Congress,DMK,AAP,TMC-Muslims and seculars Ordinary people like me support-USA,peace

[@prajwal.v.h598]

Plzz can we get the full detail video of how could our government tackle the problem and make easier to make business for international company's in India I love the work you put in your videos

[@jayeshthanmaljain1815]

Everything is so relatable. We were planning to setup a manufacturing plant in Wada maharashtra. However, Every process was so painful. First find a land, then make sure its not disputed. For making it non agricultural Land get clearance from many many authorities. Everyone had their prices. So if you buy 5 acres land, it will cost around 50 to 60 lakhs for their clearances alone. Even after all this you have to go so many places get so many signatures approvals etc. This takes around 2 years to only get the NA. Then u start your factory setup getting machines and everything, by the time we start the factory it takes upto 3 to 4 long years MINIMUM. so whatever you invest you have lost that much in interest alone. Before you start the factory you are in major losses. How do you even sustain that. Also, I your land is claimed by an adivasi after such painstakingly long process you have to vacate it. WOW! Why would I even consider digging my own grace? 😅

[@hariharankumaraswamy6048]

Don’t follow what other country follows. Just be you. That’s the eye opening. Thanks India

[@patel.k0]

Let's not compete with China, because that's never going to happen. We have 100 party systems. Our people like to do politics. So let's be happy with whatever we have. We can never grow that fast.

[@Shhhhh_asf]

I was searching for a detailed video on this topic. Thanks ganesh ❤

[@suryavinayakam]

3:21 - we should look at Imports as a % of GDP excluding oil imports/oil refining exports.

[@Surya-ue3gt]

Great video analysis but what happened to Dhirubhai part 2

[@Swati2403]

Top govt companies failures to innovate has only forced our PM to bring ToT from other countries,which is not the solution for succeeding in make in india

[@namanjain3201]

Make in India 2014 - slight decrease import not achieve growth rate gdp share stagnant increase export but more trade deficit fdi not grow instead of 100mn only 18mn job,manufacturing provide job unskill less prone to shock scale easy,import kill domestic industry kill job decrease value currency make us to take loan,red tapism beaurocracy environment clearance land acquisition port slow rail truck skill problem

[@kallachi729]

Are you joking? If nothing Indian defence now has indigenously made rifles, artillery guns, tanks, helicopters, fighter planes, soon transport. Aircraft’s, naval vessels and ships, other Defence equipment, information systems etc…. Come on ,,,,

[@Marinky4727]

You want to grow flowers in the garden it's very easy but think of it growing on our street. Today India has the largest population in the world but doesn't have the largest Area. Everything become easy when you have resources and land, planning comes next to them.

[@QUICKBIZTALKS-or5zt]

It's look like bro using Ansh Mehra studio 😅

[@ishaantripathi1788]

I think environmental clearance should be tough because on one hand we are saying it's stopping our growth but because of those restrictions ,I think not all but some of our ecosystem is protected.We also cry about climate change so policies should be made in accordance to sustainable development rather than focusing on aggressive capitalism and pleasing billionaires.

[@ruturajyadav5130]

5:15 - how is more money going out of India than coming into India? Isn't 71-44 equal to 27 billion dollars of surplus?

[@gatherkeshav]

"Thank you for your efforts in producing this episode. Could you please share a detailed video on ways to improve the ease of doing business in India?"

[@sujaynis3905]

the government's decision of telling Elon to build a manufacturing plant for Tesla in India is such a big blunder. 1. If the market sales were good, they themselves told they would setup manufacturing here. 2. It is just way too much upfront investment without even knowing how the market will react. That decision may have benefited India slightly, it would be a huge loss for Tesla.

[@ankushdoshi8947]

Don’t know about others . But make in India in defence is definitely a failure

[@udayiscool]

really surprised.. how is waqf board gets so much land when we cannot get land for the development ?

[@Randomuser866]

Before RoyeGa speaks about failure of MakeInIndia He should remember and think about his own government's NationalManufacturingPolicy's success 😂? Isn't it fair ? Tell me 👇🏻

[@balajis3722]

Hi, I would request you to pls do a case study for Tamilnadu state so that we can understand what’s happening in our State in these parameters as well. Thanks

[@saibalaji9676]

Great job 👏🏻, without being bias and showing the reality of today with constructive critisism 💯

[@rishitgarg248]

Our minister surely knows the problems and I don't think they are lazy or unintelligent, so why don't the land laws just be changed? Is it due to population protest?

[@farhanmallick3962]

Increase tarrif of China products (cheap products) Increase and promote manufacturing hubs / areas locally and connect them internationally, Ease importing of Machinaries and promote increasing capacity of manufacturing, Making finance and rental easier

[@IdleGeniusOffical]

First time i have seen made in India Diwali lights in my home.

[@lobothe13]

This is india.Not china to make the entire population to do that do this etc.Its a democracy.So its an improvement and we need lot more improvement..!

[@thomsonthom453]

Terrible Roads, Terrible Lives: Why Poor Infrastructure Drains More Than Just Our Patience If you’re a part of the daily grind in India, you know the agony of our roads. Terrible, potholed streets aren’t just an inconvenience; they represent a significant and painful issue affecting all aspects of life-energy, time, health, and even the environment. It's a daily battle that steals hours of our time, chips away at our health, and worsens the environment we live in. Our roads are riddled with pits, dust clouds, and constant congestion. Every journey becomes a test of patience and endurance, a drawn-out affair that saps us before we even begin our days. Imagine spending hours choking on exhaust fumes, bracing for sudden bumps, and wasting countless minutes trying to inch forward-all this on routes we must take every single day. It’s draining, both physically and mentally, and it doesn’t just wear down our cars; it wears us down too. How Bad Roads Shape a Strained Society Poor infrastructure doesn’t just harm individuals; it harms the community. People are stressed and irritable, short on time, and tired even before reaching their workplaces, schools, or markets. The impact of this goes far beyond inconvenience-it influences productivity, mental well-being, and even relationships. People who spend hours in traffic every day are bound to feel more frustrated, less optimistic, and physically exhausted, creating a society less connected, more isolated, and often frustrated. The frustration also affects how we interact. People stuck in traffic jams or navigating potholes are often less inclined to show patience or understanding, contributing to a societal attitude that’s more about surviving the commute than thriving within a community. Environmental and Health Impact When cars crawl bumper to bumper on dusty, congested roads, they release far more pollutants than they would on smoother, faster routes. Not only does this worsen air quality, but it also contributes to increased fuel consumption and higher emissions, accelerating environmental degradation. Dust from broken roads fills the air, affecting our lungs, especially those of children and the elderly. And let’s not forget the noise pollution, a constant backdrop of honking and revving engines that adds yet another layer of stress. It’s Time for Change Fixing our roads isn’t a luxury; it’s a necessity. Good roads don’t just make travel easier; they transform communities. They give people back time, reduce stress, improve air quality, and allow society to function more effectively.

[@vasuguvera5912]

I saw and experience such kind of impact on starting a startup. The burecracy really delay and impact business in today technology agonistic phase.Hope things will get better

[@choclate6565]

why would a company invest in india the corporate tax is way high than dubai

[@v.srimanthteja3408]

Govt. could have made at least goods train faster - but they won't Govt. could have made at least ports larger - but they won't Govt. could have made at least tourism development - but they won't despite having rich tourists spots and cultures which are different from the rest of the world. at least tourists will be contributing to our INDIA. Govt. could have made atleast education policy updated and remove outdated once - but they won't atleast graduates can have relevents skills and they could work for our INDIA. At least Adani and Ambani have the capabilities to give jobs to 10 lakh people each respectively, but they won't what's the point of making billions of money and saying they are the richest, though they won't give jobs to people of INDIA. Do they eat all the money while they die ? Actually technology is developing a lot and we the people are giving this credit also to so called BJP, and thinking that we are developing. Actually we are not.

[@AbhishekKumar-ry9ls]

Please make separate video for solutions I would love to hear those ideas backed with data Loved this video ❤ most of the things are backed by research and reports And you tried to explain well Thanks 👍🏻😊

[@Gtfbijg67]

Indias IMF high growth figures are overblown. India prioritises neo-liberal policies that focus on finance and services and not manufacturing and yes the bureaucracy is outta control

[@nikhilharidas87]

I still think 10 years is still not enough time to call it a success or failure.

[@sujaynis3905]

"now is the second best time than before" Just because of this, we will always be in the follow-up phase.

[@rutikpatil7771]

Land accusations & environmental clearance should not eased at a level where it hurts land owner & environment India is solving faster transport problem by building highways,DFCs & deep draft ports like vadhvan India needs to add skill based & up to date education culture in our education system India has exported $15 B I-phones & $2.2 B ammo last year & is 5th largest manufacturer in world Manufacturing sector will take time to expand We need Agniveer type scheme to hold beurocrats accountable