Is Make In India really working? | Geopolitical case study

[@ThinkSchool_Hindi]

👉India’s first ‘learn by doing’ experience for growing your wealth. Imagine being able to build your own personal finance plan while attending a class, live. Apply to this upcoming FREE class this week here on Zerodha Varsity: rebrand.ly/qzsvcbe

[@thewalker338]

Instead of mentioning pass or fail, why don't you Rate it. Like 60% success or 65% success.

[@SooreshKanhaye]

Ĺ

[@thewalker338]

@@SooreshKanhaye TMML

[@abhimanyusolanki6822]

Why you need TESLA, change your western mindset. If Chinese brand BYD can enter easily, If Kia of Korea can enter easily. Also Indian Tata and Mahindra are doing well in Electric manufacturing.

[@chimp7]

Feedback : keep background music lower. At times it is making voice less audible.

[@MrinmayPatra-r3r]

The truth is manufacturing has increased but only few companies have the control of all manufacturing.

[@Commercelaw]

Our Manufacturing is Growing at sluggish rate .

[@yerukantiakash-mf1ws]

Most of the people business me intrest show nahi karte Sarkari naukari k piche bagrahe h

[@Sankkham10]

In Mumbai only 0.04% apply for Govn jobs. It's just north states and rural areas don't have ​much private jobs@@yerukantiakash-mf1ws

[@Commercelaw]

@@yerukantiakash-mf1ws Trend Hai Na Bro Sarkari Naukri mtlb Babu bhaiyya , 4 Banglow , 4 car , kuch bhu kro koi kuch nhi krega , Paisa , Retirement ke band bhu , Retirement ke pehle bhu , Free Medical Insurance, Hr ek chez discounted, D.A , GRATUITY, PF , ESI, D.A IS ONE OF THE WORST THING THEY GOT CENTRAL EMPLOYEE 48-52% OF BASIC SALARY STATE - 40_48% INFLATION IS AT HARDLY 10-12% I AM TAKING AT A INCREASED THAN IT IS . THEY ARE SAVING 36% IN JUST INFLATION. SO YOU CAN THINK HOW THERE ATITUDE HAS BECOME !!

[@Commercelaw]

@@MrinmayPatra-r3r Read CAG REPORT SARKAR KE BAARE ME SB PATA CHAL JAYEGA KON KITNE PAANI ME HAI 🤣🤣

[@Rahulkr00196]

Mindblowing case study in a layman language highly appreciable.

[@cuckoonut1208]

But Laymen don't watch intellectual videos.

[@PoochaSaar]

​@@cuckoonut1208 Then who watches it🤪 Watchmen🤪

[@cuckoonut1208]

@@PoochaSaar Educated English speaking people. Like me.

[@uniquestar1308]

When most of the people in the country are expecting for free bees how can we expect speedy growth in development. When majority of the fund going for free things where is the fund for development. Government alone cannot do every thing. It is responsiblity of each citizens of the country to think and act in the direction of betterment.

[@vivekanandgorle3770]

Government exist because people can't do everything for the betterment of the society. What people can do about red tapism or beurocratic hurdles? Government don't need to do anything, it's enough if it doesn't create the hurdles in the process of development. Can't we expect this much also?

[@drrouf-er2ft]

So andhbhakt why can't govt stop freebies .

[@ssr1857]

@drrouf-er2ft, so pappubhakt, why pappu giving katakat scemes

[@drrouf-er2ft]

@@ssr1857 first tell godi g to stop Central schemes .

[@rudramanudhane3365]

@@drrouf-er2ft bhai dono hi chutiyapa kar rhe hai dono mai race lagi hai kon zyada free de sakta ek taraf ladli bahen hai dusri taraf mahalakshmi scheme ek religion pe baat rha ek caste pe dono kuch sensitive topic utha ke bas backchodi kar rhe hai development pe dhyan dene ki jagah

[@shashiraghuvanshi3344]

for people info-posco came back and is now a joint venture with jsw steel so its a win and that too in odhisha u can check online

[@shobarajesh2724]

Hopefully it succeeds 😢.

[@pratikguptaji]

This analysis is not complete . 1 Does any of you influencer promotes made in India? 2 apart from bjp does any party promotes made in india initiative ? 3 does congress, tmc , aap, etc has added made in india initiative in their election speeches ? 4 Does anyone raise the voice against the lobbying done by Media houses specially times group, Sony group etc where they charge less amount for Unilever , nestle , but a very high amount to any new local product coming to market ? 5 many local rising brands faces a big issue of getting legal cases for now reason from the established foreign brands. These are backed by china and US both which doesn't want India to have make in india initiative. All questions or points raised in the video are in insignificant if think about the above points mentioned above.

[@pratikguptaji]

Yes you are right ✅️

[@rahul__kryadav]

I think creating DOGE in India is the only solution 🥰

[@Pranav8705]

so, the problem is democracy.

[@johnmathewkarodan1488]

United States is also democracy

[@soumiksarkar7019]

The politician of United State doesn't promise freebies scheme to gain power. ​@@johnmathewkarodan1488

[@heavenlyxtacy]

nope corruption, pm aur adani milke loot rahe he aur kya bole?

[@BharatIndoria]

​@johnmathewkarodan1488 if its good for them, doesn't mean it will suit us.

[@heavenlyxtacy]

@@BharatIndoria filling their pocket not yours, you are still getting a payment of only 15 thousand to 30 thousand, get admitted in a hospital for one day you will get a bill on 20 thousand.

[@saurkashi]

Kothari Commission (1964) recommended GoI to invest 6% of GDP in education & skill-development. The same has been envisaged in NEP 2020 but the joke is that GoI is itself not investing even 2% currently. How shameless one can be! I need not to comment on educational institutions in India because we all have faced it. The curriculum is a travesty on our face. If India has to overcome the infamous 'Middle Income Trap', we must adress & resolve the manufacturing and unemployability issues with immediate effect.

[@knowledge-21234]

Colonial edi action even with 40percent budget cant do anything but produce sarkari slave

[@heavenlyxtacy]

yes so true china is investing around 960 billion dollars on education but our great country just 11 billion, thats almost around 1000 percent less then china.

[@saurkashi]

@@heavenlyxtacy True bhai. We stand nowhere before China. The certified skilled force in India is only 4% out of total work force. The same is 40% in China, 90% in Japan and 96% in S.Korea. Even if we add the non-certified skilled force ( viz. people who acquire skill from father, relative,etc.), it adds only upto 20%. The root of the problem lies in crony capitalism. I'm myself a teacher and after research I've concluded that the governmental educational institutions are deteriorated on intention so that the plethora of students move towards private school's where they can make profit. Now suppose that if indeed government institutions start providing quality knowledge and skill, who will bother to pay hefty fee and go to private instruction. Private education industry is well aware of it, that's why they keep filling the pockets of politicians and officers so that the condition of govt institutions always remain in plight and the fees fill their pockets. As it goes, 'The worse the disease, the bitter the cure', the solution is very strict. It should be made compulsory, by law, that the children of politicians and govt employees will go ONLY in govt institutions and admitting them in private institutions is a non-bailable offence resulting in punishment of 10 years jail, ₹10,00,000 fine and getting removed/suspended from the post.

[@heavenlyxtacy]

@@saurkashi the problem is those pvt institutes are run by politicians like business, not to give education. And also our people vote for criminals and crooks not a clean candidate. In my constituency for the last election there were around 12 candidates, there were some really clean people, but he got 126 votes and those other like thousands of votes. India will never be safe soon, they should give voting rights only for people who are atleast 10th passed.

[@nishantahvan]

Believe me I am in manufacturing, after not bandhi and gst all major local small Kharana had shutdown while mid level and big are running with low capacity. Why? You know the answer !

[@pramodbolsure7114]

Toh system change karne me dhyaan dena chahiye. Every party has to work for system upgrade and not to criticize other's

[@captaingaming5178]

Opposition bolaga ki sangbidhan khatam ho jayga😢

[@ragemahesh6065]

Indian government only works for the elite 5% Indians. Rest 95% are exploited for revenue to keep them and those 5% lavishly happy 😅

[@heavenlyxtacy]

to 12 saal se kay kar rahe he vishwa guru?, bhakto ko khoob chutia banaya

[@paroxymal7688]

Lol 😂 impossible

[@ragemahesh6065]

23:08 will never ever happen.. in 5 years every politian earns money to prepare for next election. And we 95% Indians serve them for their lavish life😢

[@deepakgupta-ri3jn]

Half information is more dangerous. Imports can also grow because businesses are growing and need more raw material....increased export support that fact and also domestic consumption stats are necessary.

[@AgentAd-if5ue]

लगता है भारत गरीब ही रहना पसंद करता है।भारतको हाथ में सोने का लौटा दिया तो भी ये भीख ही मांगेंगे।😂😂😂😂

[@mohanreddy7874]

💯% true as our people always like to create issue with every new project and additionally corrupt government executives

[@whykoks]

मेक मंदिर इन इंडिया

[@vaibhavsingh9052]

​@@whykoksmandir bhi tax dete h

[@olivia8989]

​@@whykoks पिठमाग्या

[@USDINRWALLAH]

Most of the manufacturing shift from china to east Asian countries particularly Vietnam.. Our make in India policy definitely failed to attract the investments.. reason poor infrastructure and connectivity...

[@3rdeyeindian]

one of my female friend live in Vietnam!! And i have already talk to her on this topic !! About 2-3 days ago !!

[@ThePP1982]

Yahoo friend? I also had one

[@3rdeyeindian]

@ThePP1982 nah , an another application! 👋🏻

[@3rdeyeindian]

@@ThePP1982 what is Yahoo friend?

[@heavenlyxtacy]

male ho ya female, yaha india me to bikari he sub..

[@3rdeyeindian]

@@heavenlyxtacy i have analysed your account and sis you've already been manipulated be on the ground 👋🏻 . I'm wishing for a better future for you. Om Santi 🙏🏻

[@shivam99765]

Mujhe sab pta chal gya ki Ham jaise middle class log sirf yeh case study sunn skte h or kuch nhi Na ham kuch kar payenge or na kuch ho payega 😅 Just see video and start watching latent show

[@FitnessKnowledge_hacks]

Very informative videos all' time thankyou brother show reality 👍❤️

[@rrgitvarun]

There are hardly any videos I have not watched of yours. I really appreciate the efforts of team Think school behind the edifying content and statistics. In this video you have only spoken about the problems or the reasons of failures for make in India. I strongly agree not just make in India but also our development’s biggest hindrance, is Land Acquisition. When a land is up for acquisition the problem is there are multiple people claiming the ownership and delay is because of the Judiciary which takes its own sweet time to patiently here the petitioners to decide the rightful owners of the land. I request you for a video on how other countries like Vietnam (as mentioned by you in the video) are tackling these problems and have streamlined the land acquisition process despite having similar problems (Naturally) like India. Thank you Think school for spreading awareness and keeping me educated. Keep rocking 👊

[@chinmayabhuyan2000]

We can't forget that China and Vietnam are communist countries while India is a democratic country where people choose freebies and leaders choose votes over growth.

[@OkenmangKarpuk]

The number one channel on the World

[@MamataBishnoii]

Sir, Main Aap ki video Pichle Das Din Se Dekh raha hoon Aap ki videos mujhe Bahut Achhe Lagte hain Har video ka wait Karta hoon

[@rahulkulkarni5018]

Very Powerfull Case Study 👏 Please keep it up.

[@fr1zzy300]

To sum it all up "Democracy is the problem".

[@Aditya-wi]

All municipal officer's are corrupt😂😂

[@heavenlyxtacy]

pm hi chor he, marketing manager of adani...

[@BhairavKumar-o1m]

Manchester in india and semiconductors in Balibazzar in town ❤😢😮😊😊

[@marwanabdulla4746]

Can you make a video on war economy and how they can't survive without war

[@Indian.001]

Build wealth run out from India and make more money by living in other countries The best idea

[@SonicMaster-e6l]

10:25-- service company ko scale karna far more easier than manufacturing

[@avinashbiswal2926]

Who will do the solution? Government!

[@sushantsingh1455]

then you missed the whole point of the vid no govt can change this completely unless we take a step cause babus come from our people operates on our taxes until this poor bureaucracy exists these delays are eminent as the result loss of fate of the nation that's the most saddest part. Change is possible only if our society collectively work with constructing mindset.

[@heavenlyxtacy]

jub leader of the govt pm is a chor, dont expect.

[@JethalalChampaklal_Gada]

Sad part is India need sustainable development but not the Indians.. I will give example do you remember Mumbai bullet train project that project was starting from Gujarat and ending till in vasai (Mumbai) between these Dhanu area comes.. people of Dhanu started to protest for the land.. but actually the land was not taken up.. government told your land will be hold with us for 99 years of lease but peoples were not ready.. so now pillars on that land ready but bridge is not ready ... Now imagine the day dealy government has to give salary and the wages to the workers without any progress also ??? Now

[@chetanc.r.p805]

Jab tak hamare desh me businessman's ko ek villain ki tarah dikhana band nhi hota tab tak kuch bhi big change nhi aa sakta...

[@rohitdhindale1137]

👍 now you cover all of Indians thank you so much team ❤

[@Commercelaw]

I need a case study on Declining share of Maharastra in economics development. ❤❤. Your video are worth watching

[@bishalroy2255]

Great case study

[@anindyaghosh1514]

Jay hind.. Modi is undoubtedly has made his place in the greatest PM of india.... The growth which is silently goin... Will surely be widely visible in upcoming decades

[@prithvipatel2845]

Keep waiting for ache din! 😅

[@Abhi_jit055]

Mera general knowledge ye keh raha hai ki ye problem khatam hone me Abhi bhi 50-60 sal lag jayega …jab humari generation humari ma bap k umru ho jayegi…India ki education me jab economy mandatory hogi tab

[@kunalsatpathy2998]

Absolutely brilliant cover of the real issues. Come to Madhya Pradesh to see the peak effect of this virus.

[@whykoks]

पनौती से तो भगवान भी नही बचा रहे, बल्कि पनौती सामने पड़ जाए तो भगवान खुद ही पनौती से बचने की राह खोजने लगते हैं 😂😂😂

[@rahulsen002]

In Gujarat Modi championed killing red tape-ism when he was CM there .. why is it taking 10+ yrs to scale it nationally

[@rishavgupta7036]

3:27 I want to criticize at this point. Just a thought no attacks😂 There is inflation also from 2014 to 2023 and if you see in terms of percentage the fiscal deficit has came down

[@5656yhhfhjh]

Hindi --- 😊Good

[@zubyr2474]

Tell me the reason to leave India without telling me the reasons 😢. Amazing content, extensive reasearch and really saddening to see how much more we can be corrupt

[@sanjubhagat8005]

sir we also need to adjust inflation because we see the rise in inflation it also shows the wrong representation of value creation but if see in term of value then its islittle goods

[@bhagyamatikumari.doughtero7227]

Thank you Bhai

[@fidatoomintu]

I love all ur case study in hindi language than english bro

[@ravikantrajput2997]

Thank you

[@Jacksscope]

8:11 ad skip

[@ANKITsharma-yz7us]

Half knowledge can be more dangerous than ignorance. give complete knowledge and reason behind why the tesla coming to india and about DFC project to improve cargo connectivity logistics through JNPT PORT ,Nhava sheva port , Mundra sea port india top shipping ports in the world

[@ANKITsharma-yz7us]

clear

[@Jacksscope]

Dhruv Rathi Kabhi yah Nahin bataega

[@akshitraj1019]

Uske ghar me cocroach aata hai toh modi ko gaali deta hai.

[@heavenlyxtacy]

issne b modi ko useless bataya he par tere jaise bhakt ko samaj nai ayi....

[@rohitpawaskar906]

You missed out on the most imp issue because of which all these issues exist. Lack of integirty. Right from peon to pm all are concerned about personal interest and put it above national interest. As long as this aint changed nothing can be done.

[@arunkumarm18]

government should help small and medium scale Companies, that will help more Job Creation. Large companies will not provide more jobs, instead they will cut jobs and invest in Infrastructure and Automation. In India we need more and more Jobs.

[@AbhishekXcricketViews]

Sidha Sidha Bolo,Sambidhan Mai Hi Samsya hai......Samvidhan Mai Badlav Karo.......Babuon Ki Sellary Bahut Kam Hai Desh Mai.

[@Chakka_allah_33]

Main infrastructure hi hai but germany k educated log bolte hai infrastructure ki jarurat nahi hai because personal vechile 10% k paas hai but ye 10% 14 crore log hai jo chote mote desh se bhi jyada hai

[@prathameshmestry]

Great enlightenment sir!

[@Petrolhead11]

Protests are very dangerous weapon in democracy which China/Vietnam can avoid easily. Free speech is high on morals but at the same time impose grave danger since it's very convenient to gather 5000 people and create a ruckus.

[@RobanSidhu-o2d]

Jab sarkar tera sath injustice kara tab protest mat karna automobile business bhi protest karta sarkar ka khilaf emissions ki limit bhut strict thi logo ka pass itna time nahi falti protest kara

[@hanshrajmaurya6176]

​@@RobanSidhu-o2d ya bhi sach ha protest isetemal project rokne ka liye kiya ja raha ha

[@kushagra-wq8ts]

You should remove petroleum import because petroleum price is varying very much

[@rajeshpillaik]

Manufacturing is slowly picking up and its difficult to bring back as we destroyed manufacturing for Service industry in 2010.

[@sachinchauhan25066]

Good job ❤🎉❤🎉❤ brother

[@arijitadhikari8074]

Just read last 5 years export data . You will get your answer

[@thaminnaik9747]

Control corruption, and strict work policy in government jobs, give target to all govt employees. 90% problem will solve automatically

[@TEST-dt2yn]

You lost me when you showed Rahul Gandhi (Pappu). Criticism is good; I am with you, but showing the Pappu Clip is unnecessary. What have you guys done to promote Make in India or aa gaye criticize karne k liye , sponsor and youtube ka paisa mila naa enjoy kar . Desh k kaam to tum waise bhi nahi aa sakte .

[@thinkhindi6543]

FDI investment is dependent on whole world condition and check the percentage not number brother. But topic is best ❤🙏

[@ravanasura8308]

Background sound is irritating sometimes can't listen what's the words actually spoken

[@Commercelaw]

I have One Request if you are able to put down the source where To get that information, It will be a great video we will be able to read after listening the video. Can Enjoy Your Video with more Efficient manner.

[@anandgokani6925]

I am a big fan of your work, but the way you presented the export-import deficit can be misleading. We also need to explain it as a percentage of GDP because over the years, our population would have increased, and at the same time, our consumption would have gone up. So it is very complicated to control the deficit.

[@Normy0000]

a Gem on KZbin

[@santanumukherjee4108]

There should be a minimum qualification requirement for being a politician in our country

[@chimp7]

If scaling manufacturing was easy, services(It in general) would not have scaled so fast across world

[@atharvac13]

Funny part politician ke infrastructure projects delay nahi hote

[@TGill22]

NO ruling party has failed, first congress failed now BJP. You said system fail india, and whose job it is to remove that system????? the political that rules it is their job to remove those babus who drag india back remove red tape, babus who sit in AC offices and talk about public, who don't let india be an easy place. and it is government's gob to remove them

[@iamshreyas43]

wait, I've seen this earlier, I guess I think school

[@aruji-sama]

environment ministry cant handle pollution levels of delhi but still delay projects so what is even the benefit of delaying the projects if its not helping environment anyway

[@arjun.islampur]

Puri Tasveer 🖼️ Dkh K 🎯 Aadhi Sacchai Batana Tumhare Target🎯 Ko Samjha Deti Hai ⏳

[@roshansingh9022]

Hoga bhai ye bhi success hoga

[@np2917]

You asking 66yes of before governments job not done, that job done in 10years throught Modi.... Wait.. Bhai.. Wait.... It takes time... 😇 you check election interview of people.. Every one want free money, government job. .... Better help and make videos about Indian people and guide them what study they can do or which skill they need for job and good future... Instead of negative videos..

[@AshikIkbal_in]

10:25-10:40 production theory left the chat. 😂

[@pradeepreddy8607]

It is true that we are unable to keep up with rest of world in trading but it is also true that people are not ready to work hard or do a blue collar job. I have a requirement of 4 CNC operators & 2 helpers as I am a startup. It’s been more than a month people are coming & going but not willing to get on the job. Even though there is scarcity of work, there are jobs which are vacant no one wants to go for

[@bijilijuber]

Indian revenue government should identify government suitable lands for idnusttrialazation And mark some private lands also before investment company shows interest

[@miteyshhshah]

as always best case study 👍 MSME needs out of the way, fast track support of payments recovery. he can create jobs for unskilled by upgrading himself to manufacturer using his yrs of experience in market, but he is afraid to do so becoz no back support for him. so called dept is there but again same taarik pe taarik game 🙂if you allow me to connect you i can present UNTOLD details on this connecting all dots from top to bottom.

[@dineshsharma0019]

The stats have to be looked at with a layer of consciousness and to take regard the different complexities and relative events that affect the overall image.

[@scajej54321]

Main reason is education, unskilled labour,

[@vivekanandgorle3770]

No, it's Red tapism and unnecessary protests

[@arunyadav7467]

super

[@mna9211]

Please bring more unbiased case study on Govt policy. And please provide comparative case study with China

[@Abcdefgxyzhijklmnopqr]

Tesla is not ready to accept terms n conditions ye reason hai gadkari sir ki clip puri dikhao

[@Adi-oc2hd]

Exactly! half baked video

[@Sam_kothari]

Tax , lack of infrastructure of the biggest reasons

[@wgoyt]

3:48 check percentage man, don't manipulate numbers

[@vampyrkiller]

Doesn't make much difference on the ground. Debt is high.

[@shivanshusharma751]

Dude debt is high that's true

[@pragyankh7377]

You have explained why it is difficult to make industries in India, but failed to analyse why existing industries do fail to grow and produce quality goods. One main reason of failure of it is the main essence of "Make in India " itself. A "sanatani " concept that advises people to not use expensive foreign goods but to get satisfied with low quality Indian goods instead. Hence the quality of consumer in India has not improved. They prefer cheap products- not the quality products. Even a rich family in a town who can afford expensive goods do not spend money on goods but saves the money and wear cheap clothes instead. Hence to cater such population, Indian industries make low quality goods which are not competitive in international market. Furthermore it has a vicious effect- industries cannot make much profit from their products so they cut the jobs in their factories. Since jobs are reduced population become poorer and thus they further cut their expense on industrial goods.

[@anubhavpawan9259]

Bhai make video on PLI scheme

[@akshitraj1019]

I think that plan has been rolled back this year.

[@Divinenatureee]

you didnt talk about how product demand has increase from 2014. why dont you consider what trade deficit would been if there was demand that is today in 2014. you are clearly biased towards congress. it is not that there is no make in india. if there was no make in india trade deficite whould have been 200 billion dollors. you dont consider how make in india keep trade deficit from growing uncontrollable. i didnt expact this from Think School.

[@Adi-oc2hd]

He is soft propagandist everyone knows

[@Divinenatureee]

@@Adi-oc2hd he made himself saying i will look into all scenarios in business side then judge how gov policies do than do a informative video on it. but sometimes he becomes biased some what with half the data and do videos. Hope he fixes this. by imposing himself that he is centrist he sometimes ignores facts that are leaning towards any sides.

[@guptasandeep1811]

Main to bhagwaan se wish karunga bharat ka growth ho.

[@Pipsum]

Fail ya Pass ❌️ Timepass ✅️

[@someshthakur5868]

I think Made in India is better the make in India!

[@AsimaMaity-bp8fb]

Make In India 🇮🇳💖💖💖

[@RahulKumar-iy1xz]

Your fact is true

[@beyondgoodandbad7019]

Bullet train is delayed because muslims are buying bullet ,even I have bullet 350 so that's y bullet train in running at a loss of 350 million because of me

[@coolgif355]

Cgina land acquisitionnpolocy have made them a developed nation which they have executed successfully in the 1970s

[@KimVinciguerra-z8v]

Thanks for the analysis! I have a quick question: My OKX wallet holds some USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). How should I go about transferring them to Binance?

[@IntentionQuran]

Bahar wale bhi share bech rahe hai Q or aese bech rahae hai ke pahle 30salme nahi nikale itna Q kiya dar hai pata nahi

[@movie2601]

Why government not fund allocate education systems

[@sdfghjkl-ml1ih]

Check stats they are already doing it but babus are busy eating up funds

[@hanshrajmaurya6176]

Gov focus on infrastructure