Is MLB The Show 24 GOOD?

[@cyclone927]

Im buying this cus the last baseball game I had was probably MLB 2003…I think Barry Bonds was in the cover 😂

[@phreekhill1099]

That was a good one though

[@Rodneyuknowme]

Me too bro no 🧢 😂😂😂

[@jaredowner]

Paid $70 for the game. Played for 2 hours and has felt like I have been playing for 9 months. If they could keep all the same gameplay and just update player models and all other graphics. Well it would feel brand new again. And please to god why can’t we have tons of camera angles to choose from besides the same ones every year.

[@pwcorgi2000]

Why did you pay full prices for this game, or any game? I hope you bought the physical version.

[@barryfredericks8134]

Add Minor League Stadiums. At least AAA Stadiums.

[@BK_718]

💯

[@Goosewitdajuice317]

Facts. I wanna play at victory field

[@fredfrederickson]

That would be awesome

[@o.gpeterrabbit9852]

Ngl I’ve been playing 2k and madden yea I’ll pick this game every time had a steep learning curve for me at first but it’s growing on me especially since when I started I didnt know anything about baseball

[@levi8781]

the graphics starting to look real outdated these days

[@kyle2beats]

I agree

[@ThatGuyInPhilly]

@@kyle2beats Yeah, it's sad. This looked amazing 15 years ago on PS3, better when it came out on PS4 10 years ago. I played this on 1 month trial Series X and...eh. (Kinda thought..."is this bad because it's Sony game on XBox??") No, not really. PS Plus full free download on my (now old) PS4 last night...It really does look outdated now. Gameplay is laggy on my end as well, no idea why... All of my other PS4 games play just fine. Ah well.

[@kyle2beats]

@@ThatGuyInPhilly literally just downloaded free PS plus waiting for the ingame download and the gameplay is so laggy for me

[@MrBrooklyn295]

Women in the game of baseball is cheesy.

[@andrewlorton8587]

Typical greedy corporate scum woke crap to make more profits as usual nowadays.

[@timheinrich3752]

Gotta love the X-files reference with your player name.

[@bcgaming_]

👽

[@Braden269]

Idc if it's copy and paste it's fun so I will buy it every year

[@bcgaming_]

That’s pretty much where I’m at with it too.

[@ItsmeGarrett]

I agree.

[@crazyclapz-_-1000]

And because I like games that update and are active

[@LossLeadas]

Let me make a game so you can buy mines every year..you easy

[@akwasiatuahene8433]

@@LossLeadasIt would be terrible lol.

[@tropicnight3166]

I give it 6.5/10 its Literally copy an pasted from last 10 years smh franchise has noting new seems like all we got was new scorebug an new sound effects this company has just went to complete crap an lazy.

[@bcgaming_]

That’s fair. I wish there was more competition in the gaming sports world, since competition breeds innovation.

[@tropicnight3166]

@bcgaming_ exactly man if they had Competition they would do alot more to the game. Tbh I can't see a difference from mlb on PS4 to mlb on PS5 it looks the exact same.

[@w3t_willy]

Thanks for the review. I'll stick to 22. I thought it was interesting that you gave it an 8.2 but still said wait for a sale or skip. What score does a game need to be a purchase in your mind? Seems like a generous rating, given all you had to say and with a $70 proce point.

[@thefox47545]

It WAS until the recent update CORRUPTED all my saves. I lost EVERYTHING!

[@bartonlynch]

PURE ANALOG PITCHING FTW!!!

[@GisherJohn24]

Good review. My only complaint is the clipping you get on tags of mits/arms going through the runners body/arms. Been an issue for about a decade!

[@greymelonreal]

Career mode is so fucking awesome fr who agrees👇

[@TJRacing3967]

Last played MLB 14, thought it was a good time to see whats new. I feel extremely OP in '24 as opposed to '14 RTTS.

[@tommywilson3415]

I recently purchased this game and it feels looks and feels like the last one I bought which was the Show 2020, it’s past time for these games to improve on graphics, I know that would be tough to do every year but how long will they just copy and paste from previous games

[@justinkirschenman2232]

3:23 Its my first crush Dana Scully. I want to believe. Still! "The truth is out there."

[@pepalmieri]

Nice Vid... honest opinion and traight shooter! I like it! Yup... Cheesy... I bought it bc my last MLB was 2019... so I´m feeling good vibes on it... I´m not a Diamond fantasy player nor online player... but I´m having a good time... IDC about the 70 bucks... it is what it is so Irather enjoy what I bought that keep complaining. Thanks for the vid dude! Cheers.

[@shadowguy20004]

I actually like this years soundtrack alot... but i like Hip Hop & R&B, last two years with the negro league focus i feel like the game caters to my demographic better, when in the past there might only be 1 song i liked but at least then i uploaded mp3s to sounds of the show or used spotify... my bigger issue with the game especially for offline players seems that XP and stubs have been totally nerfed compared to older games and the Derek Jeter storylines were incomplete at launch and had to wait over a month for a title update to play the 2001-14 seasons in his career

[@Shad43]

Wish they’d add a way to play online with your rtts player again. Imagine a sand lock, backyard baseball type online mode. Think it’d be a hit

[@phillyscorpio3804]

It’s just amazing that I’m still playing MLB The Show 19 …The last great installment of this series…and MLB 24 looks just like MLB 19. 🙄 I’ll stick to 19 until this game decides to look like a next gen game. At least I still get better commentary 😊👍🏾

[@seaniveroni5579]

Smart man lol I only buy the game when it's 29 bucks 😂😂

[@mikes7446]

no wonder my cousin asked if had 19. i gave it to him because i no longer have a ps4.

[@OhDatsIzzyGaming]

I've been told I have the best road to the show so far! I'm loving it 😂

[@kplayzxp2376]

Which one do you have?

[@OhDatsIzzyGaming]

@@kplayzxp2376 24. I feel like it's really the same as last year. They could've added some more to the male character story

[@GitzenShiggles]

I'll never know if it's any good because I'll never buy it again because it went WOKE!

[@NoMorePodDes]

Fighting wokeness with cancel culture 😂

[@tylerhenley7848]

No one is demanding their company be taken away, or take away their ability to develope a new game. Choosing not to spend your money on a product doesn’t equal canceling someone’s career or platform. Get a grip.

[@anthonychalkley5673]

How they go woke??

[@Zprod93]

@anthonychalkley5673 they didn’t. He’s just mad there’s girl characters in it.

[@PiMpiNx187]

This game is just ugly to look at copy and paste every year ea and 2k are both better and they are the worst

[@Emanny28]

The graphics is ugly thanks to the switch version, i noticed 22 looked far worst than 21

[@ReubenSoulja69]

Well said

[@pwcorgi2000]

What's so ugly about it? I guess you never played baseball on the NES or even earlier consoles. Cut and Paste?complaint What can they do different? It's a freaking baseball game.

[@ReubenSoulja69]

@@pwcorgi2000 they can improve the graphics improvements to dynasty and road to the show like it’s barely touched so u added women big wow…

[@funkyflights]

MLB The Show blows Madden out of the water though … Madden is utter garbage

[@johnfoster2584]

Still playing 20.

[@animalmother53]

I haven’t bought or played MLB the Show since 2017. So maybe that’s why the game feels amazing to me. 😊 They need to retire that one animation where the batter fouls off a pitch and grabs the barrel of the bat. Thats been in the show too long.

[@johngoldsworthy7135]

It’s really good functionality wise and they’ve made the pitching meta better

[@johnmikolajczak8514]

Hey question. With all the years the game has been around why can’t they use old dialogue? It would make the game better.

[@phreekhill1099]

MVP baseball needs to start making games again with NCCA football coming back

[@bcgaming_]

That would be awesome! I’d definitely be interested in a college baseball game again.

[@phreekhill1099]

@@bcgaming_ with all the rising talent. EA would be silly not to cash in on the college trend right now. Getting those 04-05 feelings again

[@raymondjones5909]

The clouds don't move in the backdrop

[@AdubsMMA]

Thanks. I'll be waiting until it's on sale. 🙏🏼

[@Hercccc]

Haven’t bought a baseball game in years , might be time . Love the game in real life so only right

[@mikerubin22]

this is still the best overall game in the sports video game market, period.

[@phillyscorpio3804]

It is…& it has been for the last 15 years but at least in the PS4 era it change from PS3 to PS4…when is it going to change from PS4 to PS5. I blame the Xbox 😂…when it was dedicated to only PlayStation, we got a better product. Now we have to be downgraded to subpar video gaming to please Xbox customers 🤦🏾‍♂️🙄

[@godfreyjohnmaranon7053]

good thing in our public library here on canada,i can borrow it for free and and extendend it after..

[@pwcorgi2000]

Except for the soundtrack, I'm perfectly fine with it. I just turned the soundtrack off in settings.

[@7777777Beau7777777]

anybody else have random announcer glitches. Like i was in the 7th inning and the announcer said “and we’ll go to extra innings” or something like that then one game i had 2 homers as a guy and the commentators said “she’ll try for her 3rd home run of the game” 😂😂😂 like this game feels rushed and copy and pasted

[@austinroberts6229]

Until they make big changes I just keep buying the previous year.

[@gringobronx7670]

I like the game its pretty good

[@new2guitarplay96]

I have Gamepass Ultimate on Xbox Series X .. and I still am not sure if I want to download it! And as a Gamepass Ultimate subscriber.. we get it for free! 😂 I downloaded last year’s edition and played it for one week! That’s all!! 😅

[@D7311]

I disagree on the soundtrack.

[@franklopez399]

If saying if I like it 2 words hell yeah on both consoles xbox series x & playstation 5

[@jaredowner]

I don’t think I can buy this game again until they move on to next gen. It’s just fucking boring at this point.

[@mikes7446]

Yup

[@mikes7446]

The stadiums look worse in 24 than 23

[@XxXTank9000]

Diamond Dynasty is what I play haven’t played since The Show 19. This game is absolutely terrible. Early swings are Home runs way too frequently. Perfect Pitches are erratic misses the location way too often.

[@guyanaman5472]

I enjoy it.. Even tho i suck at zone hitting.. always slicing underneath the damn ball smh

[@JoshShelton-b3q]

This game is awful

[@chooseForYourLife]

Same old boring graphic and motion…especially pitching motion is dull and not dynamic at all! 😠

[@mikes7446]

Nahh same graphics.. commentary and I saved 80 on an updated roster.

[@seaniveroni5579]

Yea it doesn't look like a PS5 game smh

[@azzurri123]

Yeah I’ll just wait till next year, maybe they will drop last gen consoles but who knows

[@mikes7446]

i doubt they will until they get competition again@@azzurri123

[@mikes7446]

i doubt it until they get some competition again. @@azzurri123

[@seaniveroni5579]

@@azzurri123 hopefully smh

[@dtagonball34]

I haven’t had mlb game since 2018 on ps4 so should I get 23 or 24 for ps5 🤷🏽‍♂️

[@crazyclapz-_-1000]

24 cuz it updates

[@mikes7446]

23

[@DKURTZ97]

I’ve been having a pretty good time tbh

[@bcgaming_]

Me, too. It’s been fun enough thus far.

[@DKURTZ97]

@@bcgaming_ in fact I just got called up to the Bigs today!

[@simondesjardins4085]

I usually wait to buy games, but since game comes day 1 on gamepass I'll be playing it again this year.

[@funkyflights]

Gamepass is a waste, you own nothing, and I like owning not renting

[@codeeast1224]

Enjoying, been playing since Friday

[@ltkillshot85]

Plays fine to me.

[@jonspikes4935]

It doesn't show speed of baserunners when you get on base

[@dabrab6324]

Yes it does you have to change in settings.

[@jonspikes4935]

@dabrab6324 Whats the settings for it you mind?

[@GabeMaterne]

Ronald Acuna needs to be on the cover not this guy

[@-C.S.R]

What score did you give last years game?

[@bcgaming_]

I didn’t do a review of last years game, but I probably would have given it a similar score to this years game.

[@-C.S.R]

@@bcgaming_ Thanks! I'll probably just get last year's game on the cheap. I am a Mariners fan and would love to see the kingdom but not worth the price

[@8325A]

Only thing they change is the menu

[@dallasrocks198666]

And that sucks! Can’t even read it

[@EnjoyerofMiserableMarinersBsbl]

The first clip shows a horrible attempt at Julio Rodriguez’s stance. 😂 He does not close off that much with his front foot. My God…How hard could it be to get the stances right? This game is trash now. They don’t even try anymore.

[@Goro_84s]

I hate this game 😢

[@mikes7446]

OoooooooooOOOO pitch clock! :/

[@reedheath1331]

"Promo SM"

[@mattmatt4344]

No

[@JoshShelton-b3q]

4/10 this is by far the worst mlb the show they’ve ever come out with.

[@abby-xf8op]

Same shit

[@elvisp2684]

Atleast the game is very colorful lol

[@lindseymccoy1633]

hehe 69 klikes

[@trueshitonly]

The game is scripted for certain outcomes