Is the Taraweeh Prayer 8 Rak'ah or 20 rak'ah? | Shaykh Abdussalaam al-Shuway'ir

#like #share #subscribe
#ramadan #taraweeh #islam #quran #sunnah #fiqh #prayer #nightprayer

[@hrzye]

جزاك الله خير

[@scholarlyknowledge8137]

و إياك

[@scholarlyknowledge8137]

Correction (from minute 1.35 - 1.37): "any (optional) prayers between the maghrib and Isha prayers are considered to be from Qiyaam-ul-Layl "

[@nazmulhuda3262.]

Only between magrib and isha? Then isn't tahajjud Qiam Ul Lail?

[@scholarlyknowledge8137]

@@nazmulhuda3262. yes it is all considered Qiyaam-ul-Layl. The shaykh is just pointing out that even prayers between Maghrib and 'Isha are considered Qiyaam-ul-Layl.

[@nazmulhuda3262.]

@@scholarlyknowledge8137 The other thing is that most of the other Sheikh said Prophet (PBUH) never prayed more than 11 or 13 rakah in and out of Ramadan. And it was referred as Qiam Ul Lail which means it is both taraweeh and tahajjud. But in here the sheikh says that it's witr. I only heard from this Sheikh that it's witr. So which one is correct?

[@FaisalKhan-yt5on]

​@@nazmulhuda3262. I am also surprised at this absurd logic...amma aisha clearly mentioned that out of 11 rakat or 13 rakat there were 3 witr ...and he is saying all 11 were witr perhaps this sheikh was there in huzoor sallallahu alaihi wasallam ' hujra when he was praying..i mean he knows better than amma aisa ra ... strange...so absurd interpretation first time i have heard any arab with such lunatic logic

[@nazmulhuda3262.]

@@FaisalKhan-yt5on True. In another narration(check for more clarity)Ummi Aisha(R) mentioned our prophet(PBUH)prayed 2 by 2, resting after the 4th rakah then again 2 by 2 then prayed 3 rakah witr. But this sheikh is explaining totally different. It's more troubling for us who don't know to get misguided easily by them if we don't try to look and justify.

[@ammarshaikh791]

what about imam bhukari establish a chapter of tarawih on hadees of mother aisha r.a?

[@freddykambata421]

What about the Hadith of Muwatta Malik 8 rakat ? What about the statement of Umar ra that the prayer at home is best

[@abuzar3468]

It's considered to be weak narration.

[@freddykambata421]

@@abuzar3468 According to who ? It's is an authentic report Tell me the weakness of the report In fact your 23 rakat report is weak It is munqati

[@abdul-muhsinmuadth7002]

​@@abuzar3468Akhī, the scholars mention it's from the strongest chains of narration. If you're claiming it's weak, you must have proof with you as to why that it is.

[@vcdrrj]

@@abuzar3468The narration is authentic, and it agrees with the authentic narrations in Bukhari and Muslim. Narrations opposing this are weak, and not these. Those who pray 20 rakat instead of 8 are doing something that the Prophet alayhissalatu wassalam never did.

[@user-rh6eh6bl8m]

Is he (Sheikh) in favor of those who pray 20 or those who pray 8?

[@scholarlyknowledge8137]

20

[@mskpir00]

So taweel of the hadith in Bukhari to justify 20 rakah is not limited to Indian / Pakistani hanafis.

[@POPALZAiii]

It was prayed as 20 in the haram up until covid lockdown

[@FaisalKhan-yt5on]

I am surprised at the absurd interpretation of this sheikh ...amma aisha ra clearly mentioned in the hadith that 11 rakat consisted of 8 rakat of prayer and 3 witr and here this sheikh is saying that all 11 were witr...the india pak diseas has reached saudia as well amazing

[@jabulaal]

Please study more

[@Polster-lx5ph]

Have some shame. Clown

[@aeejazkhan]

It's not absurd but well known interepration I think you are Ignorant about that blame yourself not Sheikh.

[@ayangamer2664]

Pls educate urself and also humble urself before trying to blame a sheikh for something. Those 11 Rakat were in Ramadan and outside Ramadan, but the Prophet صل الله عليه وسلم increased worship in Ramadan. Meaning these 11 rak’at are Tahajjud, and not Taraweeh. And before going against the Ijma’ of the Ummah u should think twice atleast.

[@mikhan5191]

Faisalkhan - you call the Sunnah of rasulullah salallahu alayhiwasallam "a disease"!!!! Do you realise that is a statement of KUFR???