Is the US being hypocritical about the Russia-Ukraine War? - Michael Kugelman -

[@itsmeshravs]

From South Asia , think you bring the most logical point of view . It is a logical point of view and unbiased . Unfortunate we don’t have enough of you in india

[@tush991]

This guy is my favourite Pakistani podcaster, as for the missile allegations I encourage you to bring that evidence forward, there are a lot of Indians on both sides of the political spectrum who wouldnt be happy with unchecked military adventurism

[@PK-tt5kk]

India has lot of problems on the Chinese borders, I dont think we would risk raising tensions with Pak because we dont have enough power to defend both the fronts.

[@anshuraj4277]

India has literally no interest in Pakistan except for terrorism and Islamist ideology Baki...Sanu ki

[@beforethebigbang1329]

I have a question why is the world so ignorent about Yemen ? Saudi Arabia human rights violation >>>>>>>>uigur >>>>> Palestine >>>>>>>>>>>>>≥>>>>>>>>>>>> kashmir

[@adeelakif6657]

I appreciate your home work 💞

[@ShehzadGhias]

Thanks!

[@kayaar00]

good job interviewer

[@AliHammadArtist]

Initiation of violence can never be justified.

[@shantanushekharsjunerft9783]

For the next 20-50 years India will be preoccupied with China and building its own economy. I highly doubt India will look for a fight with even China, let alone Pakistan. Furthermore even though Pakistan sees India as its mortal enemy, I don’t think India sees Pakistan that way.

[@muhammadsaimali1066]

It's a controversial opinion but isn't the world more stable under USA as a superpower than under the regin of any other superpower???? I know it's the same argument for country being stable under a dictatorship But isn't it better than constant state of war everywhere in the world like the previous centuries??

[@PK-tt5kk]

its controversial ?? its logical, I wouldnt have a problem with rise of China, if it was also a democracy.

[@prashantp2029]

Every century is different, not comparable at all. But I agree with you, USA is the only best choice we have as chieftain right now, If USA looses against China or even if China manages to match USA that would be end of peace.

[@LovethisLife785]

Yes, a democratic country which has some respect for human rights and has accountabilty for those in power is 100% better than any country which has no respect for human rights and freedom of expression.

[@71espn]

If you listen to the clarification by the defence Minister. The launch was deliberate by a rogue personnel but not something that India was testing

[@PK-tt5kk]

I dont think Defence minister could have said that, it would be a massive embarrassment for us, & it would then open us to flood gates of accusations , that we cant be trusted by weapons. What if some other rogue element does something else ?

[@prashantp2029]

Kaunse universe se ho bhai?

[@sendakan666]

To the best of my knowledge India has never launched a war against any other country. There is just no tolerance among the people for that sort of unilateral aggression. Unless there is a major terrorist attack or another military misadventure like Kargil, there is no reason for friends in Pakistan to be worried. We all want peace here.

[@sulemanyousaf4043]

Even under the hypernationalist govt of PM Modi?

[@sendakan666]

@@sulemanyousaf4043 There are no wars launched by Modi that I can recall since his eight years or so as Prime Minister. Anyway, the culture of a people is not easily transformed by one or two people. As far as I know, India has not launched an attack on any neighbor in the 3000 or so years of known history.

[@sulemanyousaf4043]

@@sendakan666 that is because India has never existed as a single political entity in 3000 years. It was always a collection of different states whose borders were constantly changing. New kingdoms were emerging and dissolving all the time. However of we study the history of those kingdoms that were present in modern day India, then you'd see that all of them were fighting amongst each other for most part

[@sendakan666]

@@sulemanyousaf4043 Assuming you are sincerely interested in the matter of histroy, I shall try to provide some relevant information here. This is going to be long. The Sanskrit texts of India are the most extensive classical textual tradition in the world. In these texts, India (called Bharata) had clear boundaries extending from the Himalayas in the North to the Sea in the South, from the Brahmaputra river in the East to the Sindhu in the West. Moving from texts to recorded history, the picture begins to get clear following the Perso-Greek conflicts of the 5th century BCE. The first Indian Empire that covered most of the country was the Maurya Empire that began in the 4th century BCE and lasted for nearly 500 years. The next major Indian Empire was that of the Guptas which was at its height around the 5th centure CE. To put this in context, apart from India and China, every other country from the classical period has since disappeared. Now, it is inarguable that neither the texts nor either of the two empires showed much interest in the region outside that of historic India. But, as you rightly said, there were constant struggles for power within India. A version of this exists even today in the political struggles within and between Indian states. This, however, is very different from foreign invasions where local cultures and religions are trampled upon and the local population looted of their wealth. Basically, India has always been an inward looking country because it is a primary source of culture and civilization. The outside world was not very interesting to Indians until the Perso-Greek conflicts led to marauding armies successfully breaking into the subcontinent for the first time.

[@shantanushekharsjunerft9783]

@@sulemanyousaf4043 India had powerful central empires that covered from Afghanistan to Myanmar for over 800 years. The last such emperor was Harshavardhan whose empire collapsed around 600s. Only after that India became a collection of small kingdoms. The invasions from the west started 100 years after that.

[@itsmeshravs]

Dude you are a stud, hopefully there are many more of your tribe

[@hmm7783]

ayyyy Colbert's got me in his spell too

[@shanijawakhaniwaja6648]

Dude , It was a genuine mistake bro believe us.We have a hot border with China right now so it's just not wise to antagonise Pakistan as well.Hence, it was a mistake period.

[@trinayanakaushik811]

I think it was a mistake. Initially even I thought India deliberately fired the missile but later I agreed of the mistake because the area has heavy traffic of civilian aircraft. India is not so crazy to fire a missile just for sake of testing Pak's defence knowing the threat to the civilian population of not just Pakistan but also Indian flights. Imagine the backlash India would have gotten if the missile hit a civilian aircraft. So definitely it was a mistake and India got lucky nothing much happened.

[@AvinashPatil-1]

@@ThePakistanExperience Missile could have hit Indian plane on Indian side as well. And, these days Aircraft crash investigation is a very sophisticated analysis. It’s very easy to determine missile trajectory, type of missile. And such investigation is done by IATA and many a times with active participation Boeing/Airbus. We have seen in 2014 Russian missile Buke hitting Malaysian airplane over Ukraine and how investigators nailed it down that it was a Russian missile. So, I don’t buy this hypothesis of India blaming Pakistan for the mistake it committed. Let’s be rational here.

[@maggietop123]

@@ThePakistanExperience GET BETTER SCIPT FROM ISI FATY

[@alpha_november472]

@@ThePakistanExperience BRO THINK YOUR SELF , DO YOU THINK IT WOULD BE HARD FOR PAKISTAN TO PROOVE THAT IT WAS AN INDIAN MISSILE. I am glad it didn't hit civilian areas but at the end it was India now who is facing the heat and applauded the gesture of Pakistan showing great temperament

[@jam-ss2jc]

Arre Shehzad bhai, vo londe (Modi,Yogi) thoda josh mai aagaye the UP election ki khushi mai thode bade patake phod diye the😆😆 On a serious note though, very unprofessional and careless from our side and kudos to Pakistan for handling it nicely.

[@stangerdanger7252]

General Rawat aur 27 Feb 2019 wala helicopter b josh main geer gya tha. Bus ab modi ko koi ya josh na dikha day.. China wali side pr josh nazar nhi aya..

[@prashantp2029]

@@stangerdanger7252 Badi badi baate Vada pav khate

[@lunatic_lad]

@@stangerdanger7252 Pakistanis should keep in mind that they have lost their serving president to aircraft crash before making fun of anyone. Recently Chinese aircraft crashed too killing 100+.

[@stangerdanger7252]

@@lunatic_lad You shot your own helicopter killing 7 when Pakistan jet came, and you were celebrating the day before. Like imagine that. Indian air-force has a history of incompetence and they killed their head like that as well.

[@valadimostok]

#TPE 156

[@AliHammadArtist]

23:36 You are wrong. Potential threat ≠ threat.

[@ShehzadGhias]

All threats are potential threats. Countries need to take into account potential threats.

[@AliHammadArtist]

@@ShehzadGhias Assumed threat ≠ threat.

[@lordvondon]

1:14:35 True af

[@hasnainhyderzardari7443]

What if Pakistan make a missile mistake oops 1 million dead Indians Sorry for mistake

[@GG-ur4km]

It could be wipe out of Pakistan on the map and history, don't worry you get again whole chance to prove yourself after 1971 once again when we will start taking POK.

[@rocketshoot3027]

I strongly believe it was a mistake

[@shauryamalik8473]

@3:54 min- really shezy!? Et tu, brute

[@shauryamalik8473]

@@ThePakistanExperience no, what I'm surprised at is that you too believe in this "deliberately done" theory.

[@ShehzadGhias]

@@shauryamalik8473 we can never know for sure so we have to believe what we think happened. India not following protocol and letting Pakistan know when it was launched and not sharing a detailed investigation report makes me skeptical that it was a mistake. This could have been so much worse. You don't make "mistakes" with missiles being capable of carrying nuclear war heads.

[@afrazahmad6467]

what I will suggest to the host... Dont give your own opinions. you have invited a guest everyone is here for your guest and not for your own options

[@jam-ss2jc]

What I will say to such audience.... Don't give your opinions. You have come to listen the podcast and you listen it and then leave

[@ShehzadGhias]

@@jam-ss2jc nahee nahee comments karay sab log it helps the algorithm 😅 har jaga likha hua hay we do conversations at TPE not interviews.

[@jam-ss2jc]

@@ShehzadGhias okay👌