Is This What We Want the Transfer Portal to be?

instagram- mattbegreatyt
twitter- mattbegreatyt

[@natestyron4830]

If you're taking money from the school collective or have a NIL agreement with the school, you have to sign a minimum 2 year contract and be available to play (unless injured) and maintain academic eligibility, or suffer repercussions. They want to be pros treat them like pros.

[@williamverdell8856]

Amen I agree 100! If this was in place maybe the goat might still be coaching.

[@mark_kline]

No

[@23-n-1phitness6]

Yeppp

[@Dickson_Mayaz]

Treat them like pros then the ncaa needs to pay them like pros. NCAA only allowed them to be paid by other brands but they don’t actually pay the players

[@MonsterMeatMac]

@@Dickson_Mayazyou want the NCAA to w9 every college football player? 😂

[@jimgallagher2979]

I'm convinced the crazy NIL and transfer portal are the main reasons Saban decided to retire. He didn't want to have to deal with this disaster.

[@22s22a]

*Didn't have advantage anymore

[@streakydrip8792]

You don’t have to be convinced, Nick Saban came out and said that this was the reason he retired.

[@JustinPitts-fu7uk]

It was only fun for saban when he had all the power and unlimited access to 5 star recruits and paying players.

[@Messup7654]

Ohh so saber couldn’t handle the heat when it got to his temperature??? I mean I can’t say it’s unlike him, when has he not taken the easy way out

[@BRlGADE_KINGPIN]

Looks like it’s not just a “Colorado” problem after all.

[@Cooljohn760]

Blame the NCAA since they approved the new rule of Unlimited transfers. 1 to 2 transfer is the max limit. Plus limit the NIL to at least $1M max.

[@Ramen_Hibachi]

You should have only one free transfer and if you transfer again you must sit out and lose a year of eligibility

[@dorianvick8932]

How many times can a student that isn’t an athlete can transfer???

[@joshuafinn6038]

​@dorianvick8932 the same amount as any person who is paying for school and not being paid tens of thousands by the schools...

[@Messup7654]

⁠@@joshuafinn6038first of all not every player is being paid tens of thousands not even 30% of guys are. Second the schools are profiting off the players who are risking and losing more than they gain relative to the gains and losses of the school that simple go look at the revenue these schools bring in and how the sport affects a university in whole

[@Messup7654]

Oh but coaches can recruit kids pay then then leave them for money from a different school?

[@elibrooks1662]

I think athletes should be allowed one transfer and a graduate transfer totaling in a potential of playing for/committing to only 3 teams. Otherwise the LOI is a joke. I hate seeing Money ruin the college football I grew up on. I really can't believe how much it's changed in just 6 years. With the Big Ten and SEC having all the relevant schools and then the NIL giving millions to athletes; this is just gonna get weirder and weirder...

[@WilliamJohnson-lq7bd]

1. Each player gets one transfer per year, regardless of whether or not money changes hands. Once the player signs on the dotted line to transfer to the school, they owe one year of play. Player MUST be eligible to play (barring injury) the entire school year to fulfill this requirement. This will automatically reduce the amount of money schools are offering these players if the school knows they might/probably will lose the player after one year. There needs to be many other rules, but this would be a great place to start. Maybe introduce contracts that stipulate how long player must commit, as in, "We are offering you x amount of money, and in return you, the player, agrees to play x amount of years." More money means more years committed, less money means fewer years committed.

[@ronaldbargain4925]

Whether or not money is exchanged??? So we can just finesse players and keep them locked down then I guess

[@WilliamJohnson-lq7bd]

If the player feels they're worth more money, then don't sign. As someone else in the comments said, if the wanna be pros, teach them how it is in the pros.

[@drumagus2258]

as a fan of both pitt and oregon i find it funny that people have problem with players leaving but coaches do it all the time, in the slimiest ways possible and nobody bats an eye. forcing players to stay at school is illegal. thats why judges keep striking this shit down. every other student can transfer schools when ever they want, you cant change rules just because the kid makes money for the school.

[@jonahmays]

I think people have been saying “this will ruin the sport!” Forever. However, the overall culture of the transfer portal is disgusting in my mind. I’m used to the dominant, committed, honorable, powerful college football ideals and I don’t like the way CFB is trending

[@mark_kline]

Cry about it

[@jonahmays]

@@mark_kline he told us to give our thoughts in the comments. Go be negative somewhere else

[@samierking2256]

He wasn't figuratively or literally crying bruh you need a lap and a nap 🤦🏾‍♂️​@@mark_kline

[@isaiahvalach6835]

I think that the NIL and transfer portal are great, especially for certain players, but you are right what's the point of "committing" to these schools if you don't actually commit, you have to have some follow-through. Then again I'm not being offered hundreds of thousands of dollars to go play at a college of my choice. But there should be a window of time for when a player can enter the portal because entering the portal right before or after most teams spring games is just odd and really not helpful to players or teams, as well as limiting the number of transfers allowed I'm sorry Tate Martell you can't transfer 3-4 times, and have it so players have to follow through on their commitment, such as if you transfer to a school you have to play out through the following season. Otherwise, we are gonna have Armageddon within the transfer portal over the following years.

[@TheForgottenMan270]

The problem with how NIL and the transfer portal is set up, there are no consequences. No consequences means no discipline. We can bag on coaches for similar actions, but their contract is written in a way that it either benefits the coach or the school, depending on what happens, so consequences are written within the contracts. The system is set up so that these young men can do whatever they want. So allow freedom to happen with both of these, but have consequences based on those choices. They want to be treated as employees, so treat them as employees.

[@neon_lion8942]

These portal players won't make it in the NFL... and that's if they make it there

[@joeschmo2515]

Life does not have a "Portal". These kids believe they are better than they are and further development isnt needed. Only 1.7% of college athletes turn pro. That means all of the Cormani type of athletes that do not embrace the free education. Statistically speaking are more likely to become a felon, imprisoned, drug addict or homeless.

[@bamtofunnytv6147]

They need 2 chances to transfer schools after the second chance if they wanna transfer again they need to lose 1 year of eligibility

[@Foreign84]

They gave these kids too much power. They should be allowed to do this twice

[@ChickenBoneNews]

It's good to have you back daily MattBeGreat. We have a lot to talk about and nobody does it better than you.Lets get into it 😂🏈🏈🏈

[@22s22a]

Love it, And I love how mad it's making some of you all that kids can decide where they want to go 😊

[@gabrielsoliz8563]

If you fix the Tranfer Portal, you also fix NIL. You have to void NIL deal or find a way to have the school you're transferring offload the money you are owed if you transfer. It looking like we could be possibly heading toward a model like European Soccer which people don't want but they're going to have to deal with it

[@keyvismoore8079]

Matt my brother love your vids watch them as soon as you post. Thank you for what you do. Question What happen Too Wide Receiver Mike Williams From USC?

[@BamaComie]

Coaches have always been doing this and schools have never put the student first. I don't mind 18 year old men getting paid for their blood and sweat and time

[@giovannicarter3076]

A 5 Star doing that is WILD!!

[@dennqw]

Use to work with a guy, he was 45 yrs old at the time, and since he was 18 had 31 places he worked at.. biggest POS ever. Thats who i think about when i see these kids go from school to school to school.

[@marshallsanders-tp9yu]

For loyal fans, free agency ruined the NFL, and now cab is following suit. One time transfer without a lost season! No exceptions.

[@TheBh1989]

I like the portal. Once the other kids realize shi not greener on the other side from seeing MOST of their peers transfer and not perform they’ll start sitting down.

[@CommanderLuke-zm8ri]

Money is more important than football and teammates

[@Brandonruffin]

Why people don’t like the fact these kids can choose their own destiny…I’m all for it ..talent gets passed over way to much and kids get pigeonholed on certain rosters let em go do they thing man …who cares if fans don’t like it …these are men who need to do what’s best for themselves

[@zman224]

Nah, Sam Levitt 4 star MSU transfer is about to be named the starter at ASU. Injuries hurt Rashda's chances for this season. Rashada's Dad playes at ASU, he cared, thats why he chose ASU, but he wasn't gonna play this season. That would have been two years wasted for him. Still has 4 yrs of eligibility though.

[@marcelljackson2868]

I think what will happen is the NCAA may implement a 1 time transfer for players. I could be wrong but if this keeps up I think that may happen

[@georgesouthwick7000]

The Transfer Portal is just another example of fixing something that wasn’t broken.

[@patchgatsby9138]

I'm a college football fan and the players who have left our program this spring have realized that they probably aren't going to play. The younger players at their position are developing faster than expected and a player came in through the fall portal. They left to seek playing time. I don't see anything wrong with that. I love all this talk about loyalty. What world do you live in? My employer can fire me any day for any reason and they will. Loyalty is for suckers!

[@daredevil5072]

Nothing wrong with trying new things matter of fact it is needed cant get nowhere in life without do new things

[@OfficialAD985]

What you think about the new rules from the NCAA?

[@kevinhenderson5928]

Gridiron mercenaries.

[@littlexwolf3829]

We gave them freedom to choose and now we want to take it away. Maybe a kid just wants to live in multiple cities, if I haven't liked a job in life, I changed it.

[@ForeverBlu_Sports]

Can you make a video addressing what happened to my bro Keith Miller 3 Rest In Paradise 🕊️ He played at Texas A&M commerce

[@judithsmith2584]

Do you think the University care about them? The coaches same way. Get these huge contracts, and after 2-3 years they are fired still getting paid or move on to another college or NFL and get the bag. The playing field is being leveled.

[@GiftedDee]

Money is more important then a school who don’t care about you

[@themoneyman1752]

Matt you gotta be a Dylan Edward vid dude tranfered from CU mad random

[@jake02cute]

As a fan we the transfer portal is irrelevant to us, we aren't the ones putting our bodies on the line on the field. So we can hate it as much as we want if it is what the players want then its what they want and that is that.

[@_DB.COOPER]

😆😂🤣😂😂😂😆 whatever kid…

[@Tampafan33]

THIS SHOWS HOW STUPID YOU ARE

[@thecasualatvguy617]

It needs some restrictions though. You have tins of kids who entered who are now in limbo at no school and no scholly. I don't think this will help in the long run. You have a lot of kids that feel they are special too these days. They wil get burned.

[@ryansims8803]

There is a culture in college that encourages disrespect to players from coaches. The coaches will have to learn a new way for sure. Players are still successful after transferring, so there is not a reason to stay if you do not feel valued. No doubt players are sensitive but in this situation, they do not Have to adjust. the coaches will. If "player coaches" have the most success, the system will adjust. If "system coaches" have success then the system will adjust. You can say that players have too much power but is that better than having a coaching staff determine a future for a kid they do not value?

[@Rysofly]

A lot of player should put money first...... they can get their money at their highest marketing peak.

[@JMAN97712]

Your being way to kind with the number of players that don’t care about the programs or compete. The percentage is way high or this wouldn’t be a big deal.

[@terrell757]

Proctor was offered 100k to go to Iowa with no strings attached… so he transfered got the 100k and hit the portal again😂😂😂 do your homework Matt

[@user-yz6xc5kj2z]

Making players sign contracts and making it mandatory for kids to play for schools if they’re paid is dumb. That defeats the whole purpose of letting them run they’re own path. A regular kid can transfer 4x in college, so an athlete should be able to do whatever is best as well. The school is choosing to pay them the money.. it’s not like they have them at gun point. I think I feel people are just jealous of the bag some of these kids get from a sport

[@thecasualatvguy617]

Nobody I have talked to says anything about the money part. The only thing I've seen is collectives not paying maybe. If a kid can transfer 4 times and get paid at each stop I can see issues with this. Lots of kids don't get picked up in the portal too. If they get paid millions I feel a contract like the coaches is a good idea. If say they offer 13 mil for 4 years and you stay 1 year and demand 13 mil thats in a fraud type realm. I think one transfer window a year is good. And I don't think transferring every year is a good idea either. Limit it to 2 maybe and have some in conference transfer rules. Unless your coach is cycled every year maybe. There needs to he a solution for kids who enter the portal and don't get picked up by anyone. They are no longer at that school unless they agree to take them back. I think there's over 1000 kids that are in limbo with no scholarship now.

[@stephenjohnson1318]

This will all simmer down at some point. Things will never be back to normal of course but after a few “bad investments” these boosters make it will slow down.

[@dorianvick8932]

Yup! College Football Players are LABOR! If a coach can leave, a player can leave! The portal is cool w/ me!

[@streakydrip8792]

Limit the amount of times a player can transfer to 2 unless of injury. If a player receives NIL money they sign a 2 year contract with that school. Cap NIL money.

[@King_Cosmic865]

Your not gonna win championships with a team full of mercenaries . Look what happened to Texas AM

[@abnergann8130]

Don't understand why one player gets 2 million dollars some don't get nothing.pay each player 150.000 thousand each that makes the team.

[@themoneyman1752]

Nah this portal ish is outta control, u should at least have to stay at a school 2 full seasons be4 you can transfer, unless a coach leaves or something like that

[@G8trGreat904]

Florida doesn't want jaden he can go colorado or Wyoming or something 😂

[@JimSpinner]

College football is the new upstart NFL -- why go pro if you can retire out of CFB?

[@thecasualatvguy617]

Transfer portal in the video game is gonna be stupid

[@user-sb8bn4vq8e]

Dior Johnson type ⁵😢

[@theodopholous6407]

Absolutely not. The game is being ruined. NIL isn't helping either. It's a shame in my opinion. Not surprising though, everything in today's society sucks, again my opinion. Sue me if you don't like it. 🙄

[@jonathanyuyangpowaliszzhan4726]

Bro why don't we just have youth college age leagues in America for sports like soccer academies in Europe. Universities charging us students Hella high tuition each year to pay for dumpster fire Minnesota golden gophers to last place in the big ten every year

[@kevydeeTV_]

I was cool for the portal and NIL but now it’s trash these kids chasing bags instead to earning their spot those stars by yo name don’t mean nothing once you on campus …. It’s levels to this shhhh they think they gone come right in and play

[@CooperTreptow]

This is just free agency

[@motoreese9431]

Since when has it been anything else...except it was the university

[@javadabaron81]

5:05 bro that is WHAT YOU THINK ITS MEANS. It’s so funny to me that grown men are trying to get in the way of these guys making money off their talent.

[@Funnyman_smoke]

I fw your videos heavy but you didn’t grow up with Henry Ruggs if your from northern Alabama cause he’s from Montgomery

[@richbaritone67]

Make all players employees of the school. Education be damned.

[@folumb]

the university doesn't really care about you tbh... how much you think the power 5 schools care about their non-star players like the 2nd string safety? Yea i'm actually ok with all this. The bad players will bounce from program to program and they won't make a big impact because when you play a team sport and you're an individual that's all about themselves, the locker room will just spit you out. No matter where those guys go, they will have to take themselves and get the same results in a different place. Will guys abuse the system? Yep. But those guys won't amount to much so gotta take the good with the bad

[@mvpsportscenter6172]

I mean I don't get why Rashad left ASU he was definitely the guy the QB for them he got injured n they sucked I mean they sucked with him but still sucked so idk why transfer but he should get offers like Ty Thompson, Maliak Murphy n Malachi Nelson they all probably better than him but they really didn't get much tape or time to play Nelson n Thompson especially.

[@jimschultz2179]

If you are a big school you love the portal. James Madison not so much.

[@HokieGreenbud]

Don’t be blaming the players they didn’t make these rules if you was offered a bunch of money to change schools you would you don’t tell your boss no I don’t want that raise you take it a be happy weather or not it’s good for the company!! If we don’t like this then why did all the adults change the rules for this and now we have the nerve to blame the players come on man ya reap what you sow!! So this is what happens when the people who think they know what’s best make the rules

[@Iwollf74]

RASHADA on his way to UFL or CFL

[@Cooljohn760]

Probably around the year 2026-27

[@croatoan8394]

This is what happens when u let cry babies win

[@Johngabe100]

All of you that keep saying you support the NIL….. your idiots….. or you don’t care about college football….. what did you think was going to happen with 18 to 22 year olds. Come on you really thought this was a smart move. Again college football is gone, It’s NFL JV.

[@Rysofly]

People can make mistakes sir. Geez!

[@DirtyDawg_3zzz]

I like the transfer portal, and I don't like that mf. I wish they'd make student athletes play in their home state sometimes 😂 I only said that cause of Caleb Downs 😅 but I'm not mad about these players chasing their bag 💯 I've been a Georgia fan all my life, but I'm starting to become a player fan as well, if that makes sense. I like a few players, but not their team 💯🤔

[@jstro3136]

Never been this early

[@PeaceFullSpirit8]

These Billionaires owners have been making bank while players starve on dorms, need money for this need money for that evey player that go to college don't have mommy and daddy money so yes they have to look out for themselves first when it comes to that bag i don't blame them at all.

[@javadabaron81]

You guys are crying that athletes finally have a say. Y’all want control like how it was before NIL. Y’all don’t care about these athletes. Full of 💩

[@richbaritone67]

Free education.

[@javadabaron81]

@@richbaritone67 they make these schools MILLIONS. Those full ride scholarships are chump change

[@richbaritone67]

@@javadabaron81 2% of them will make the NFL. Two percent. For the vast majority of those players, that degree should be more important. All any of this is, is legalized corruption.

[@_DB.COOPER]

It’s like voting for biden, you get what you deserve.

[@meekokane9825]

Your stance is so asinine 😂 The actual players participating in the games risking their bodies shouldn't prioritize maximum financial security when football is finite or they should just stay in unfavorable positions and risk their families livelihood out of blind allegiance to a university who will happily replace them with the next 5 star recruit 😂 That's why Saban quit he was the king of destroying 5 stars careers

[@FyurFeelings]

Show no commitment. Show yourself to be unable to handle a problem at more then one college probably shows the problem to be you. Best realize NFL teams will recognize this when making draft decisions.

[@thisguyagain7857]

Whatever commitment requirements that get pushed on the kids should be put on the coaches as well.