Is Thomas Content Any Good? • Thomas Shorts

To answer your question: yesn’t
This video is a JOKE. The opinions stated by Thomas are not my opinion, I am in fact subbed to most of the people “criticized” lmao.

[@Hacksworth_Sidings]

1:17 As a British person, I can confirm, this is indeed an average British person interaction

[@calebtheoriginalcjc2205]

I HATE HOW TRUE THE UNLUCKY TUG COMMENTARY IS

[@ThomasShorts123]

That's unlucky BUG TO YOU!!!!! 😡😡

[@calebtheoriginalcjc2205]

@ThomasShorts123 He's an unlucky bug cause I'm an exterminator 🗣🗣🔥🔥

[@Dayronthesonicfan]

Maybe you have bad luck from him​@@calebtheoriginalcjc2205

[@stuart541]

THE VICTOR TANZIG INTRO KILLED ME

[@Cnw8701]

That T1E2H3 parody killed me! 😂

[@ThomasShorts123]

Actually it was a Victor Tanzig parody lol, I would never make a parody of the goat

[@ciarandaragh8676]

​@@ThomasShorts123 based T1E2H3 fan

[@swiftengine]

The Unlucky Tug shade is actually so real. This fandom can’t even have an individual opinion anymore.

[@paulleow8017]

As someone who has been in this fandom for a decade (help me), this has always been a problem, but it's definitely gotten wayyyyyy worse within the last 3 or so years

[@Exeller-f1r]

​​​​@@paulleow8017as somebody who has stayed in this fandom for 9 years yeah 9 years and still a kid this is so true and I was one of those people but I learned to have my own opinion and not take anybody else's for fact

[@CadenTheGreatWesternEngine]

First people hated James A Williams for his BWBA review from early 2019, now people are shading on The Unlucky Tug, this fandom does not know how to handle individual opinions anymore..

[@thesudricenginee]

I like Trampy Movies but the constant yelling for 10 minutes kind of annoys me. Still one of my favorite Thomas fan series

[@jaylenware363]

Contrarily, I really enjoy Unlucky Tug's stuff, but then I look back on his Thomas Debunked shorts and recoil at how...confidently incorrect most of them are 😭

[@deadaccountpleasedonttagme]

Answer: Yes and no. They can be good and bad. Simple as that.

[@ThomasShorts123]

I agree with you on that, every fandom has their highs and lows. Most of the people I "critique" in this vid I'm subbed to lmao. Most of them make great content. Thanks for watching!

[@SparklingJam]

0:54 the calmest trampy movie I ever saw

[@PlayDontPause]

I can’t BELIEVE you would besmirch the good name of cereal. There’s nothing wrong with cereal for dinner and/or after binge drinking. How dare.

[@ThomasShorts123]

Whoops

[@CTTE06]

All of these are painfully accurate 😭

[@CTTE06]

LMFAO THE VICTOR TANZIG ONE

[@StumpyFunnel]

4:03 adventures of pooh ass cast

[@makingmemesat3AM]

The fact Trampy is actually American tho

[@ThomasShorts123]

Oh, I didn't know that lol

[@makingmemesat3AM]

@@ThomasShorts123 he speaks normally in his April fools video. I was fooled myself, he does a great accent

[@tudorbrancuturcu5996]

What? How does he do such a good british accent!?

[@AlfredsNumbahOnefan]

If this gets taken down, it’s canon

[@ThomasShorts123]

I hope Unlucky Bug doesn't copyright strike me..

[@ciarandaragh8676]

​@@ThomasShorts123 nah he wouldn't, he isn't the manie show

[@AlgerianGuy-xf9lp]

He knows what it feels like, so he wouldn’t, also can u start trying to respect them pls? ur content isn’t any better

[@ciarandaragh8676]

@@AlgerianGuy-xf9lp its all for laughs, he said it himself

[@AlgerianGuy-xf9lp]

@@ciarandaragh8676 I see

[@KeeganLynch-sn2qu]

Both the Unlucky Tug and the Trampy Movies parts are so true

[@skandto]

I have watched every single Thomas/Pixar related Unlucky Tug video startbto finish...

[@ciarandaragh8676]

How you holding up?

[@CodyFitzy-ProjectBAC111]

3:50 the only thing missing here is a GoAnimate oc lol

[@ThomasFisher-jr6bn]

I see you also poke fun at Victor Tanzig in this video. I will admit that I like the way his Thomas universe works and Stories of Sodor Season 1-4, Stories of War and SCPs of Sodor are really enjoyable, but I think you missed an oppertunity to poke fun at Stories of Sodor: Season 5 because it is easily the worst of his major Thomas shows yet. Most of it's episodes feel very rushed, the major character deaths felt rather flat (the only exception being Thomas if he really is dead) not to mention Peter's death contradicts the video "Prologue" which shows Peter alive and well in the modern day and the Steam-Diesel Conversion thing feels really silly and I hope it's undone in a future season. I hope Season 6 returns to the slower pace from previous seasons and Victor listens to everyone telling him to take his time.

[@tudorbrancuturcu5996]

I can explain his prologue appearence it showed Sodor over the years and that shot was reused in Goods, taking place before Peter died. Also S5 is my favourite season. Cry about it.

[@superxavxii421]

PREACH BROTHER!! Its like whatever Tug says everyone else in the fandom just goes with. Tug literally has the TTTE fandoms opinions in his hands, you get burnt on the stake if you say you don't love Edward since Tug treats him like Jesus.

[@TheCuteJ50Kid]

I wonder what I would look like in that KZbin content parody website. Also at 0:55 is where I f*cking died 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@HexPerplex]

5:06 Bro spittin’ straight FAX with the HAX!

[@ShortStumpyEngine]

3:50 I lost my shit lmao 😂

[@ThomasShorts123]

I lost my shit too idk where I put it

[@Heliocentricity]

i love this and also enjoy the "criticised" people in this, like in the description.

[@vicktheengine5304]

Thanks, I got so inspired by this that i'll go and open a patreon to release exclusive Roblox models at 40 dollars just to publicly release them the next month

[@granpussforaday]

blue blueberry with amigos

[@TobyOliverHenryFan]

Thomas, I kinda agree with Thomas. (We all are financially broke. How do you expect me to give ya mula?) -James The Splendid Red Bastard

[@StoneTankEngine]

Yea its all spot on😭😭💀 Crazy how things have come in fandom when coming to content and facts

[@ThomasShorts123]

What stupid adventure should Percy drag Thomas into next?

[@RudolphTheRedNosedFox]

The front lines of D Day

[@The_British_Director]

The Russian gulag

[@thomasfan68]

The e2 reskin war

[@XXc-vj1ki]

Talk about how Sodor fallout should’ve never happened.

[@Exeller-f1r]

​@@XXc-vj1ki that's a good idea for one of his jokes videos like this that people like you cry over different universes that are not even Canon to the real show like I get it if you don't like it if it's too scary but still if we're going to get mad over it being not for kids dude not everybody got to do the same thing that the real show or game does

[@clockwork3494]

To be fair to the whole Patreon bit, I really can't blame creators like Tug having a Patreon because _yeesh_ this economy is rough. Unfortunately unless you're one of the lucky ones who hit it big in KZbin's hayday like PewDiePie, Market Pliers or Sean Septic, you aren't really going to be getting much out of YT as a career anymore unless the algorithm decides you're a chosen one, and even then there's no guarantee of YT being a viable source of income now. So I completely understand people who do smaller content like this having a Patreon as another source of income outside of a low paying 9-5 and spending hours on editing a video only to get bonked by the bs rules KZbin estates as a platform now.

[@ThomasShorts123]

Oh I don't blame them for having a patreon lmao, all just played for laughs

[@urtooslow4415]

LMAO THE UNLUCKY TUG SEGMENT

[@ashleygayming]

This video is insane. Never seen someone show such unfiltered opinions about thomas content before not even on twitter! Found myself laughing my ass off on every joke. Brilliant

[@tudorbrancuturcu5996]

The Victor Tanzig one was the least accurate. He is better than that! Though you make a very good point about making Thomas more adult!

[@ThomasShorts123]

That one I wasn't aiming for accuracy, was just making something stupid lmao

[@joshuahill6994]

His patreon is the only one in subscribed to

[@ThomasFisher-jr6bn]

I'll admit, the part where you poke fun at yourself did make me chuckle,

[@SparklingJam]

I love how the roasting isn’t even the unlucky tug personally it’s just roasting his fanbase He really just saying his opinions and people call it fact

[@supermarioewan0865]

“I thought Christmas was about Satan” -Percy the Small Engine

[@SleepDeprivedGinger]

I honestly don't mind Trampy at all. In fact, I'd go as far as to say I like his videos. Sure, the shouting is a little repetitive, but at least the writing is actually funny and makes most of the characters (e.g. Edward, James, Percy, Toby, etc) quite likable.

[@ThomasShorts123]

Yeah I like his vids too

[@DENVERRIOGRANDEMAN21]

4:02 oh gosh oh gosh this gave me bad memories

[@davidwhiting1761]

I'm glad I'm more of an observer than a direct participant in the Thomas fandom because man is it all kinds of messed up when you think about it.

[@toastrave7820]

where did you get that image of a spongebob train? i'd like to know as my autistic brain wants it as my PC wallpaper

[@ThomasShorts123]

I think what I did was either look up "SpongeBob diesel trainz", or "SpongeBob f7", hope this helps

[@pennsy6755]

This is accurate to a T. Holy hell hats off to you

[@jamesdaredpandaoffical]

4:24 THAT FACE KILLED ME

[@sonicdrew]

0:57 These pictures made me laugh so hard

[@SonicJrandSarah]

I wonder how Thomas will react when Percy shows him Ludo the Tank Engine. A parody of Bomas that was created by Telix Fang back in 2007 about various KZbin users as Bomas the Tank Engine characters and how after Telix stopped making the original Ludo the Tank Engine videos, his best friend, Levi K. Swown made a generation 2. I bet the conversion would be like. Thomas: So this Levi K. Swown made this Ludo the Tank Engine series that is parodying Bomas? Percy: Not exactly. It was originally created by Telix Fang, but the series ended so Levi made a reboot. Thomas: So why are all of these KZbin users Bomas characters anyway? Percy: Well, some of them were trolling Telix while others asked to appear in the series by request. Feel free to give a response on how the conversation continues.

[@ThomasShorts123]

Interesting

[@Pooperman-k6x]

Bro is the realest thomas content creator oat

[@ThomasShorts123]

Thank you but HOW ABOUT YOUR REAL PROFILE PICTURE 🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@ciarandaragh8676]

Grafield pfp = BASED 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@aem2984]

When I bought the DVD it sounded just like that

[@SuperGibaLogan]

as someone who watches thomas content, i can confirm this is true

[@muni_Thomas_boi]

6:05 what version of ladyfingers did you use for this I need

[@thepurplemyth]

Who does the voices (i love them)

[@ThomasShorts123]

First of all, thank you! All the voices are done by me. It's definitely not because I'm too poor to afford any extra actors i swear

[@thepurplemyth]

@@ThomasShorts123 no problem man and dang that's impressive and also that's understandable (hear me out, I could voice some if you ever want me to)

[@paulleow8017]

Thomas fans are the textbook example of "that's a cute opinion, did a KZbinr give it to you?"

[@Nooks_Rails]

what more people need to understand is opinion ≠ fact

[@somerandomfan2012]

4:24 You should've added the O' Face, But Hey, Just Like TheUnluckyTug Said: Beggars Can't Be Choosers.

[@muni_Thomas_boi]

0:52 I didn't know Thomas took part in this brain rot

[@wyattm6782]

0:53-1:18 Got Me Dying 💀

[@muni_Thomas_boi]

This just give me a reality check

[@lordofchaos1845]

I haven't watched too much of Unlucky Tug's stuff. I've only seen like a few long videos.. so I'm not sure if I should be concerned..

[@ThomasShorts123]

Nothing to be concerned about lol

[@niceeli2749]

4:09 hey wait I think I know who's oc is that

[@SaxonIVKGames]

fr tho oh and idk what other people think but that ww2 series is unrealistic af

[@Southtexasrailproductions]

5:19 had me dying

[@JamzManz777]

Stories of mediocre really went downhill after season 4 can’t believe he killed Bomas

[@TB-fe4up]

Now I wonder how many Thomas's money Percy spent on every patreon he heard of. I watch unlucky tug and some others thomas creators (idk how but i realized today that Cosmic was mostly content farm) but i have my opinions on the show and I watch some of them to see their opinion. And i watch some thomas creator that make thomas episodes in trainz like epiclafiteu.

[@Kermiboi]

Bro made fun of trampy but in a good way

[@JacqueTheInsaneEngine]

Can we get a reupload of the old videos? I never watched them

[@ThomasShorts123]

Buddy I told you numerous times I ain't gonna upload the old vids, sorry man

[@TidHarbourWorks]

@@ThomasShorts123old vids?

[@SnazzyGoober]

This feels disrespectful tbh

[@ThomasShorts123]

The entire video is just played for laughs, as I've mentioned in the video I don't hold these actual opinions against the KZbinrs mentioned. But believe what you wanna, I'm totally chill with that.

[@SnazzyGoober]

@@ThomasShorts123 well u accomplished ur goal i certainly got a good laugh

[@Swag_K1RBY]

4:04 Pooh’s Adventures

[@mrgeebers]

Don’t forget music makers

[@MultifandomMF]

Why

[@mlgodzilla4206]

I like the Lucky Mug more than the Unlucky Bug

[@thomasfan68]

New sub, this video made me laugh!

[@EthanTheEngine7]

Bomas & Friends' best episode was Cheerless Cheedar.

[@ThomasShorts123]

Hot take, I like it

[@tankenginefanaticstudios]

4:10 what am i doing here, lol.

[@ThomasShorts123]

Jumpscare

[@Swag_K1RBY]

Your OC Is so peak Tictor Vanvig Stole it

[@tankenginefanaticstudios]

@@Swag_K1RBY why would he steal it? It's a piece of shit, lol. (i know its a joke.)

[@Paper246]

Always in videos like these there are just random people that agree for like no reason

[@ThomasShorts123]

I agree

[@granpussforaday]

3:56 THE LAG IS REAL

[@22former]

This feels like an attack on these creators and personally I’m not here for that. “This is brain rot” is…wow, a bit hypocritical unless ironic

[@ThomasShorts123]

As I mentioned I'm subbed to most of these creators because I like their content lol, all just jokes that have zero truth to them. But you are right, my content is brain rot so good eye there

[@22former]

@@ThomasShorts123 I must’ve not caught that mention of the sub in there. Thanks for clearing that up

[@fairlyoddenginecreations]

When are we getting the new season of bomas

[@ThomasShorts123]

When Unlucky Bug tells Battel to get to it

[@banjoseph1]

unlucky tug reference yes

[@MaxwelltheE4]

You just earned a new sub lol

[@ThomasShorts123]

Thanks for the support 🙏

[@TidHarbourWorks]

HI MAXIE ITS ME ALEX

[@TTTEoliverFan]

Average content creator life (these are my daily thoughts being a Thomas content creator lol)💀

[@Northerner_Transport_Hub]

Shame there's nothing about Terrier55Stepney and how much he pushes his damn patreon

[@mulsbaryincorporatedjack3505]

this shit is crazy yet real

[@mulsbaryincorporatedjack3505]

i mean, i still think you can enjoy the stuff these creators push out, but the stuff about patreons is SO TRUE. I didnt even THINK about that! Ever! The stuff about tug is pretty correct, and so is the stuff about Vic to an extent.

[@wandiarapereira7953]

the unlucky tug is here

[@Freddybear437]

Don’t forget about the stories of mediocre shorts that are just straight up short content vomit

[@granpussforaday]

This facts ngl

[@Swag_K1RBY]

1:06 oh no

[@sonicdrew]

i love the Trampy Movies

[@daltondick5223]

Literally read every big Thomas creator to filth! You got balls of steel. I like it.

[@Hudsonelchoche41]

The season 32 of bomas and is friends is the best 👌

[@Percyfan1998]

LMAO. Def one of those vids you have to watch all the way.

[@DieselD182]

3:52 . . . What the hell am I watching???

[@ThomasShorts123]

The stories of mediocre, my favorite series on KZbin ofc

[@DieselD182]

Something’s wrong with you.

[@Angellnerproduction5]

Funny

[@NamcoFanatic2010]

True lmao

[@Beutepanzer]

Eh victor isn't as bad as the others still has problems i mean who doesn't

[@Alby.]

to real

[@DKJ387]

Why just why did you make this

[@ThomasShorts123]

Same reason just about every KZbin creator makes a video, for fun

[@BreakpipeProductions]

this is so fire, and also fact, i now hate every thomas content creator on youtube

[@thethomasman]

Do you like my content?

[@ThomasShorts123]

I have never seen your content

[@MikeyJohnson-xn9qv]

You know your insulting yourself right????????

[@ThomasShorts123]

Yes ofc lol

[@MikeyJohnson-xn9qv]

Bro

[@thesplendidredengine05]

how DARE you criticize the unlucky bug!!!! his content is so amazing!!!!!! all he ever says is truth!!!!!!!!!! i hate you!!11!1!!1!1111!!!!!

[@EerierFish16]

Nope not at all. Only unlucky tug

[@pikmincomidy10]

0:51

[@delticproductions]

Oh NO! Thomas is using Common Sense! NOOOOOOOO… !

[@marioman7315]

How dare you 4:12

[@D.D.D.STUDIO]

Bruhhhhhh first carson then trampy them tug then victor and the you 😂😂😂

[@ThomasShorts123]

Real whopper of a lineup lol

[@D.D.D.STUDIO]

@@ThomasShorts123 question where am I hmmmmm :))