Germany went from being the oppressors to supporting and arming the oppressors. Such progress.
@yaarghmaargh27 күн бұрын
Germany managed something truly amazing: to get another people to pay for its crimes.
@rimacalid655727 күн бұрын
Germany didn't change a bit, it just hiding its true colors. Remember most of hitl@r cabinet worked for German government and state and military untill the 80s
@thesystemera27 күн бұрын
Exactly!
@jaadhiljain362427 күн бұрын
Germany has and will always been on the wrong side of history since the turn of the century.
@Human-Failure26 күн бұрын
Colonial power supports colonial power.. what a surprice
@octopusvulgaris241026 күн бұрын
Where sanctions against Israel?
@sovankhadka582625 күн бұрын
only russia & iran.
@nisahmed912124 күн бұрын
Cncntration c4mps were moved to Pal.!
@laminsanneh9127 күн бұрын
Israel 🇮🇱 is doing everything they want because the U.S.A and EUROPEAN stand for them.niw EUROPEAN are happy what Israel is doing.
@sami411427 күн бұрын
How about Germany stops arming them and stands on the right side of history for once!
@GolDRoger-fx2fp27 күн бұрын
What is the right side of history?.
@sami411427 күн бұрын
@@GolDRoger-fx2fp The fact that you're asking and the history of your comments says it all! Never forget that fascism is always defeated!
@yaarghmaargh27 күн бұрын
@@GolDRoger-fx2fpthe non-rape side.
@brezza689227 күн бұрын
History is written by the victors. Humans are fundamentally flawed. If you think every great war or movement is free from exploitation, murder and or terror you are so lost. There is no right side of history in this war.
@thiphan26427 күн бұрын
Hamas is an autocratic organization of terrorism. Israel is a democratic country with freedom of press. The Israeli Arabs in Israel can critize the government of Israel. It is wrong to be on the side of Hamas. The Palestinians never critize Hamas but it doesn't mean that Hamas is the right organization for the Palestinians.
@GleichklangTeam26 күн бұрын
I must say that I virtually do not see such reports in prominent German spoken media. While this report is for an international audience, the media in Germany in their German spoken program for the German population very rarely report about this systematic torture on a giant scale which affects virtually everybody of the thousands of Palestinian prisoners. While Germany's official call for the release of the Israeli hostages is absolutely necessary, morally imperative, and correct, I am missing any official call of the Germany government for the release of the Palestine prisoners (of whom many are like hostages) and the termination of their systematic torture. As a German citizen, my impression is that the German government and most media do not regard all people as having the same human value and the same right to life.
@jaisso75893 күн бұрын
Es ist traurig das uns bewusst Informationen enthalten werden.
@mrchoudhury661127 күн бұрын
Gaza and west bank infact biggest open air prison... Germany can never be in the right side of history... Once carried a genocide and now arming a genocide !!
@nisahmed912124 күн бұрын
Concentration camps were moved to Palestine!
@nisahmed912124 күн бұрын
Cncntration c4mps were moved to Pal.!
@rizwansuleman505027 күн бұрын
Germany is always on the wrong side of history. The German people have the strength to change that if they cared for humans as no human should ever go through that
@rimacalid655727 күн бұрын
The majority of them are hostages not detainees, a big number of them are women and they have young kids amongst them too. This is reported by izraelis groups too
@henriettemcpartlin864026 күн бұрын
That’s shameful.This needs to be investigated!!
@nisahmed912124 күн бұрын
Cncntration c4mps were moved to Pal.!
@Tribuneoftheplebs27 күн бұрын
Germany has blood on their hands for this
@PPpaladin27 күн бұрын
Isreal learned well from the germans
@lilyayusupova293227 күн бұрын
And from putin's regime
@AroojBokhari27 күн бұрын
Ironic but true! What a shame
@nanucit27 күн бұрын
And from their USA friends, probably got the instructions booklet from Guantanamo torture camp 😒
@emamshaon58127 күн бұрын
@@nanucit Dont forget about Abu-Gharib. This is more closer to germans though
@kakkik375627 күн бұрын
@@lilyayusupova2932you mean nato
@BMsei27 күн бұрын
It's no longer possible to ignore the obvious.
@nisahmed912124 күн бұрын
Concentration camps were moved to Palestine!
@nisahmed912124 күн бұрын
Cncntration c4mps were moved to Pal.!
@black_forest_26 күн бұрын
Its not a prison if people there arent charged with any crimes. These are detention camps, many of the people inside entirely innocent, many minors. Otherwise they wouldnt have released over 40% of them back (after months of torture)
@fairuzmaileen569127 күн бұрын
This is not new
@NickG-p1h27 күн бұрын
'Most moral', says Netanyahu.
@1Naturalscene27 күн бұрын
Self defense.
@nickorme811227 күн бұрын
@@1Naturalscene Abusing someone incapable of fighting back is not self defense. It's cowardice and petty vengefulness.
@The-Man-Right-Chea26 күн бұрын
Quit calling them detention facilities and call them what they are and thats CONCENTRATION CAMPS
@hanitoma258227 күн бұрын
This has been going on for decades it's just finnaly coming out for the media!
@nisahmed912124 күн бұрын
Concentration camps were moved to Palestine!
@nisahmed912124 күн бұрын
Cncntration c4mps were moved to Pal.!
@guillermotell232727 күн бұрын
Why is the Red Cross not allowed to enter these prisons and concentration camps?
@rachael_grey26 күн бұрын
Because Israel doesn't want anybody to know about their daily abuse of the Palestinians.
@thienson966127 күн бұрын
IDF investigating. What a joke.
@doctorbigsmiles27 күн бұрын
Dw has been manufacturing consent for all of this since the first days. Your hands are not clean
@yaarghmaargh27 күн бұрын
They didn't cover the pro-rape riot in Israel either.
@thesystemera27 күн бұрын
DW has been as complicit as BBC
@marval911927 күн бұрын
Becoming what they have hated the most
@JeffEbe-te2xs27 күн бұрын
Why hasn’t the Red Cross visited the hostages
@rachael_grey26 күн бұрын
Israel does not allow them in.
@kairo00726 күн бұрын
Keep in mind that Israel is also currently holding Palestinian children in these camps. They have been for decades. A 7 year old Palestinian boy was recently released.
@HajroTrades26 күн бұрын
I bought the book "Shadows Over Gaza," with 50% of the Selling going to support Palestine. It would be great if others could buy the book too, as this way we can help to those who need our help
@Liedaho27 күн бұрын
Will the Allies liberate these camps?
@SaUl9595427 күн бұрын
No, it is no good business nor they will have substantially more voters.
@Richard1A2B27 күн бұрын
Britain and America have been enabling the Israelis for decades.
@jimmytimmy368027 күн бұрын
Allies are supporting this.
@emamshaon58127 күн бұрын
Allies never liberated the camps, it was Soviet Union who liberated the camps.
@matthewbaynham628627 күн бұрын
@@emamshaon581nonsense, in World War Two the Soviets only liberated the camps in the territory it captured. There were camps all over Germany, they were liberated by different allied forces.
@TheGreatOrlok27 күн бұрын
This looks like modern ausschwitz
@adamredwine77427 күн бұрын
No. It doesn’t look anything like that. Please learn history.
@patrickstar68627 күн бұрын
@@adamredwine774 cope
@SaUl9595427 күн бұрын
@@adamredwine774true, but still it had resemblance. For that I think what they will do if they don't had to worry about public opinion? And what is it that we don't know?
@bobgonzales968027 күн бұрын
@@adamredwine774 Do you still believe exaggerated figures and stories?
@AroojBokhari27 күн бұрын
Worse than Ausschwitz as now the world knows better!
@Wort.der.Wahrheit27 күн бұрын
Germany never learned and stand for the second time on the wrong side of history.
@canitbethat27 күн бұрын
Are you suggesting that Iran/Hezbollah/Hamas/the Houthis represent the "right side of history?" Do you think Germany should stand with them?
@marilepine127 күн бұрын
@@canitbethatin the conflict Israel x palestinians, the right side is definitely the palestinians. Israel is the opressor, they have powerful weapons, and are massacring a civilian population. It is genocide, the whole world can see It, only germans refuse to see It.
@nickorme811227 күн бұрын
@@canitbethat life is not either/or. You are presenting a false dichotomy, being opposed to Israel torturing in no way suggests you support anyone torturing an Israeli.
@canitbethat27 күн бұрын
@@nickorme8112 I'm pretty sure the OP is criticizing Germany for failing to embargo arms to Israel. AFAIK, Germany has never supported Israeli use of torture, but Germany is allowing the sale of weapons to support the Israeli effort to fight Iran, Hezbollah, Hamas, and the Houthis. This is presumably how the OP considers Germany to be on "the wrong side of history."
@nickorme811227 күн бұрын
@@canitbethat Perhaps, I won't speak for OP, but you are the one suggesting they support Iran and their proxies if they do not support Israel as being on the right side of history. I'm saying there are third choices, not aligning with either and condemning both. Leveraging diplomatic, economic, and political to push for a ceasefire and humanitarian assistance for Palestinians does not require aligning Hamas or anyone else. The right side of history is not on choosing one political ideology, ethnic group, or organization, but siding with our shared humanity. Even when, especially when, any of those groups denies that human dignity to another.
@A.Kanters27 күн бұрын
Germany knows everything about camps, from experience.
@BhaskarRoy-t4w27 күн бұрын
Suddenly DW journalists found something that whole is talking for a long time
@SaUl9595427 күн бұрын
Who his name is "Whole"
@bobgonzales968027 күн бұрын
fearing "antisemitism"....
@markfitzpatrick718627 күн бұрын
I just made the same comment and then saw yours. Spot on. Why are they suddenly allowed to tell this well known truth? Soon, they will start reporting on October 6th.
@luvitluvitbaby26 күн бұрын
@@markfitzpatrick7186It’s because alternative media and social media coverage of it is so widespread that to continue to ignore it undermines this news organization’s credibility. As a news organization, credibility is everything. So they cover it whether they want to or not.
@akeleven27 күн бұрын
Let foreign reporter see these prisons. If they say no then we know the answer.
@adrianacanavati821227 күн бұрын
Finally , true reporting , how come
@jimmytimmy368027 күн бұрын
They learned well from the Germans.
@brezza689227 күн бұрын
What do you think the lesson was? I agree with your statement though
@rippking316727 күн бұрын
hmm where have we seen such camps before? ironic
@markfitzpatrick718627 күн бұрын
Wow. DW is finally reporting this quite well known story. How did this come about?
@yaarghmaargh27 күн бұрын
So this story has been around for multiple weeks. Why not report it when it first broke?
@Freetourforyou27 күн бұрын
When even DW can no longer turn a blind eye to the crimes of the most moral country in the world 😅 They learnt from the Best
@ayadisaif52227 күн бұрын
Is this terrorism by definition ??
@patriciatapia171027 күн бұрын
terrorism is the unlawful use of violence and intimidation, especially against civilians, in the pursuit of political aims
@bannersxyz27 күн бұрын
I don’t know what to say or do. We failed as human beings in allowing this idea of Zionism! How can anyone say this is not a genocide. This is so wrong and these beautiful amazing Palestinian people deserve safety and peace. The world is praying for Palestine ❤🇵🇸
@malcolmcachie611826 күн бұрын
The same things the us did.
@vicenthuerta847727 күн бұрын
Evil is as Evil does
@Munthasir12326 күн бұрын
Wowowowowowow when did DW become antisemitic? How dare they even question Israel?
@samtheresearcher26 күн бұрын
When did Hamas ever investigate any of their officials for their treatment of Israelis?
@Filmmanufaktur27 күн бұрын
Human dignity and human rights are the only possible role models for a world with a bright future !
@AroojBokhari27 күн бұрын
Free Palestine
@IRBry27 күн бұрын
didn’t you guys write the book on this? it’s priceless hearing YOU report it
@andrewlim934524 күн бұрын
Be careful in fighting monsters that you don't become one yourself.
@hajjimubarak27 күн бұрын
Germany always on the wrong side of history
@EsutM27 күн бұрын
the only democracy in the middle east shining in full glory - yet again!
@rmzidann27 күн бұрын
The state of Israel should have been established in a part of Germany.
@adamredwine77427 күн бұрын
The Arabs allied with Germany.
@theresal.howard688227 күн бұрын
Gee, bless their hearts
@yungmo7Күн бұрын
Scholz sollte mal in diesen Kerkers auch reingesteckt werden mit Annalena
@omarid873626 күн бұрын
If in the future the occupiers/oppressors are treated like how they treated the Palestinians; will the Americans and Europeans show the same indifference?
@baimaa26 күн бұрын
Dw news and whole of Germany is allowed this to happen.
@olyakatz258126 күн бұрын
What human rights organization say about Israeli hostages being held in Gaza underground? Any information about that? Anything at all? When was the last time human rights activists visited and checked on them?
@rachael_grey26 күн бұрын
Human rights orgs are not allowed into Gaza. Israel blocks them and journalists.
@TauvicRitter25 күн бұрын
Is the UN already talking about sanctions.? And is there any progress on the arrest.
@trevornewton264627 күн бұрын
IDF, basically what you get when there are a large percent of Uday Hussains running around.
@editablair267427 күн бұрын
Despicable
@peacelove532927 күн бұрын
Free palastine ❤
@jaisso75893 күн бұрын
Den selben Bericht bitte nochmal auf Deutsch oder wird das bewusst vor den Deutschen verheimlicht?
@alexgoslar405727 күн бұрын
Very disturbing news, but believable.
@dubsar27 күн бұрын
WHAT DID THEY DO TO DESERVE THIS?
@MaxGolden27 күн бұрын
Oct 7. What did they do?
@adamredwine77427 күн бұрын
R@ped and t0rtured children? I mean… that’s pretty bad.
@DEonaraR27 күн бұрын
@@adamredwine774. Lieing lier, as usual.
@DEonaraR27 күн бұрын
@@MaxGolden😅.... you think that lie still works?
@bobgonzales968027 күн бұрын
@@MaxGolden +75 years of colonization...You have already harmed peaceful/savior Jesus...
@KeinKommentar-je8yq19 күн бұрын
They seem to have learned a lot of there old oppressors!!!
@Raknidm27 күн бұрын
Yup
@nisahmed912124 күн бұрын
Cncntration c4mps were moved to Pal.!
@AuwalEngineer-fg9eh26 күн бұрын
Free Palestine
@philipeisenberg698427 күн бұрын
DW, কি হলো তোমাদের?
@hookmuiyb27 күн бұрын
What about Hamas tratment of Isreali hostage.. I did not see any condemnation from UN for missles firing from Gaza.. Isreal did not start the war..
@vonnikon27 күн бұрын
That is true. The UK started the war over 75 years ago. But this is of little relevance in the effort to find a peaceful resolution to a war which has raged for 75 years.
@misolo27 күн бұрын
Whataboutism is the last refuge of the supporter of barbarity and dehumanization. As Masha Gessen wrote, it's time to compare: this is the modern day incarnation of the worst of early 20th century European ideology.
@misolo27 күн бұрын
Whataboutism is the last refuge of the supporter of barbarity and dehumanization..
@hadiyahalkauthar27 күн бұрын
None of the Israeli hostages were raped or tortured by Hamas and not one Israeli has reported being raped on October 7. Also, the Israeli military admitted that they killed many Israelis themselves, on October 7, when they implemented the Hannibal Directive. Didn't you see the recent article in the Israeli newspaper, Haaretz?
@user-ek2ik8fs7p25 күн бұрын
Israel sudah memulai dahulu sejak 75tahun menjajah.memguser menguser warga Palestina dari tanah sendiri.membunuh membantai sudah jadi kebiasaan Israel
@shourovhasan148627 күн бұрын
The morality of European
@user-ew3mq3jy4y26 күн бұрын
ช่วยดูเด็กๆด้วยเอาเด็กเป็นตัวประกัน
@GolDRoger-fx2fp27 күн бұрын
How about Hamas how they treat their captives?.
@marilepine127 күн бұрын
They treated their captives Very well. Please do your research and find out what they hostages tell. They were well fed, nobody touched them.
@user-do9le6lc8y27 күн бұрын
@@marilepine1 you're living in a different reality
@jezza419327 күн бұрын
Ask the three Israeli hostages that escaped from Hamas and waiving white flags surrendered to the IDF. Oh that's right, you can't because the IDF blew them away.
@GolDRoger-fx2fp27 күн бұрын
@@marilepine1 really? Then why we see beaten Israeli woman that is been captive by Hamas? You don't see that video while she been parade inside Gaza? Is that treated well?.
@nickorme811227 күн бұрын
They treated them poorly. So in what way does your whataboutism justify this?
@livingecology27 күн бұрын
this is the worst title you can give , do you answer the question?? no ! jest let "human rights" activists say what thay want with no counter argument or conflicting information
@robertmusil583127 күн бұрын
Dude, the question mark was DW's way of doing you a favour. Take the win.
@thegenesis547721 күн бұрын
Israel
@sanjeevchauhan52227 күн бұрын
Palestinians are not saint either. International laws need to be respected from both sides.
@firozebukht820726 күн бұрын
Sukti mach flavor???????????
@arjunverma337625 күн бұрын
Hello
@SeniorPanda7927 күн бұрын
DW, make a video about how Israeli hostages treated by Palestinians
@nenasiek27 күн бұрын
They have many times, everyone gets that hamas is mistreating the hostages.
@TheMsDjson27 күн бұрын
Neutral here , I feel they ve done so a few times , however I rarely see a video like this , I m a bit surprised
@adamredwine77427 күн бұрын
Exactly
@NickG-p1h27 күн бұрын
Can you refer? The videos of the released prisoners of the Israeli's speak of abuse etc. The hostages released by Hama's do not speak of the same treatment. Not saying it would be a pleasant experience in captivity, but it has been very clear in the way the prisoners/hostages have been treated..
@bobgonzales968027 күн бұрын
Not hostages; armed colonizers....
@Tuxon8627 күн бұрын
Say DW... How does Hamas care for the Israeli hostages? Do you know?
@eddastrohmayer25127 күн бұрын
And as well interesting how does Natanyahu care for the Israeli hostages ?
@johanness.992527 күн бұрын
This is called whataboutism. Don't forget that Netanyahu likes Hamas.
@avilondon361526 күн бұрын
Hey everyone, I'm asking you to focus on other countries around the world. There are enough countries doing terrible things, so let's leave Israel alone to fight for her survival against those who don’t want her to exist.
@JosephHoggang-bk4bk27 күн бұрын
Israel is the only democratic country in that region where there is free press.
@AroojBokhari27 күн бұрын
What a joke lol!
@canitbethat27 күн бұрын
@@AroojBokhari No, it's true. However bad prisons may be in other middle-eastern countries, you're not likely to see exposés about them. That doesn't mean Israel shouldn't do better, just that there's no way to compare.
@marilepine127 күн бұрын
No there is no free press. People are being detained for protesting against the government.
@marilepine127 күн бұрын
@@canitbethatI mean it's NOT true
@wtrujillo925026 күн бұрын
not anymore..... try and keep up and leave fantasy island behind.
@hericperieraleonce928427 күн бұрын
Is Hamas extremists released all kidnapped and abused hostages from Israel ?
@ForceOfNatureRelaxation27 күн бұрын
I wonder why 400 years of prosecution happened to this groups of small hats. Being kicked out many countries till the boats arrived in Middle East 😂
@adamredwine77427 күн бұрын
Thank goodness Israel is a modern democratic state where abuses can be exposed and addressed. If only Palestinians shared the same values, there wouldn’t be a war.
@TheJorrry27 күн бұрын
Very true
@vonnikon27 күн бұрын
Israel is an apartheid state. Listen to the reporter: Thousands of palestinians are picked up from the street and thrown in prison camps without trial. Not to mention the systematic torture. Palestinians have no judicial, democratic or human rights in this apartheid state.
@AroojBokhari27 күн бұрын
Hoping, this is meant to be ironic.
@adamredwine77427 күн бұрын
@@AroojBokhari it is not.
@nickorme811227 күн бұрын
Except the Israeli government does not accept that, I believe it was the times of Israel, maybe the Jerusalem post, just did piece about government censorship specifically regarding "administrative detention" where most of it was blacked out because Israeli law says its illegal to report on their kidnapping and abuse of detainees without criminal charge or trial. This is the exception to crimes in Israeli prisons being exposed, not the rule.
@Kohen12427 күн бұрын
"I guess HRW has no complaints about the way Hamas is treating its kidnapped hypocrites."
@nickorme811227 күн бұрын
They did criticize and specifically call out Hamas for taking hostages, in several statements. Hypocrisy would be ignoring this and giving the Israeli government a free pass.
@Kohen12427 күн бұрын
@@nickorme8112 Measure for measure by Yisra'el against its enemies regardless of their hypocrisy.
@nickorme811227 күн бұрын
@@Kohen124 I sincerely do not know how to interpret that comment. What are you trying to say, that Israel's actions are justified because it's them doing it, and everyone else is a hypocrite?
@Kohen12426 күн бұрын
@@nickorme8112 If they wish for the extermination of your people, and the destruction of your nation, what do you think you should do about it?
@Kohen12426 күн бұрын
@@nickorme8112 By the way, the last time we were unable to defend ourselves we lost 6 million of our people, now we can defend ourselves and we are not willing to lose any more from the hypocrites and their critics.
@canitbethat27 күн бұрын
I was disappointed not to see any representative of the Israeli government or military interviewed as part of this piece. I also didn't hear it said that any were invited and declined, so does that mean none were invited? We're told that Israel disputes these claims, so shouldn't we hear them tell their side of the story?
@abdullahsiraj321727 күн бұрын
They say there is a list of
@canitbethat27 күн бұрын
@@abdullahsiraj3217 Sorry, I don't understand your reply. Is part of it missing?
@wtrujillo925026 күн бұрын
Israel's response is that the IDF is investigating......
@canitbethat26 күн бұрын
@@wtrujillo9250 ...but were they invited to be interviewed for this piece, or were only their accusers invited? There's no Israeli government representative interviewed here, nor any mention of this Israeli government having declined to send one.
@MeatballSandwich127 күн бұрын
Well if that guys son wasnt a terrorist,maybe he wouldnt have been arrested. Dont raise your children to be terrorists
@AroojBokhari27 күн бұрын
Wow! How vile to say that! Neither his son nor he was a terrorist. But rapist IDF criminals certainly are terrorists and war criminals. Any words for the rapists?
@tomhenry89727 күн бұрын
Look at Brazilian, coasta rica, Mexican jails
@ardiii74627 күн бұрын
🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
@lilyayusupova293227 күн бұрын
@@ardiii746 you are notorious bastards nowadays.
@hadidza.e.tomic1025 күн бұрын
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
@pbrenzink27 күн бұрын
I had a bruise!!! ooooohhhh poor thing
@maryramos416126 күн бұрын
"An eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth"?
@jfern667327 күн бұрын
They care not what they do to others they only care what happens to themselves., nothing will change until Palestinians understand there actions have consequences
@jezza419327 күн бұрын
Israeli's will always tell you what has been done to them. But never why.
@1Naturalscene27 күн бұрын
Do Islam respect other religions?
@patriciatapia171027 күн бұрын
yes
@tomhenry89727 күн бұрын
No
@josealbertoii466427 күн бұрын
Just to remind you; The Geneva Convention does not apply to terrorists.
@eddastrohmayer25127 күн бұрын
Human rights apply to every human being !
@robertmusil583127 күн бұрын
Doesn't apply to teghoghists? So that's why Israel is ignoring it? Thanks for the confirmation. Or should that be Freudian slip?
@johanness.992527 күн бұрын
The same old argument used against the likes of the IRA, Azov, East Turkestan Liberation Organization etc.
@canitbethat27 күн бұрын
I think the question here won't be whether they're violating the Geneva Conventions, but whether they've violating Israeli law.
@josealbertoii466427 күн бұрын
@@canitbethat As a former army officer, I have read the Geneva Convention. I am referring to the Geneva Convention and not to Israeli law, which I assure you I have not read. I doubt that Israeli law considers terrorist attacks not to be a crime, but it is a possibility that Israel loves to have its citizens killed by terrorists and therefore does not punish terrorists. Read the Israeli laws and confirm that terrorists are not subject to any article of the law. In that case, you will know whether Israel is violating its laws.
@amit4fire27 күн бұрын
I used to think this channel is not biased.... but it is....