It's not just Berkey - Betrayed by AlexaPure, AquaCera, ProOne/ProPur, PureWell....

After I did the Betrayed by Berkey video, I wanted to find out if there were a filter I could use in the old Berkey stainless steel containers to replace the Black Berkey elements I no longer trusted. This would be my "ditch water" filter for microbes and pathogens. Well...I found it!
Get 5% discount with code "beaty" at this link: www.britishwaterfilter.com/?c...
Here's a swamp water drink test I did with it: • I Drank a Glass of Dir...
But, dang. It's not just Berkey being deceptive.
The ones I named in the title of this video strike me as deceptive. I also talk about some others in the video that may or may not be outright deceptive, maybe just shoddy. Either way, I am not going to buy any of these for filtering out chemicals from house water nor pathogens from ditch water:
AlexaPure
Gravity Well
JoyPur
ProPur/ProOne
PureWell
WaterDrop
ZenWater
Outback Water
AquaRain
AquaCera* - I've learned a little more about AquaCera, and I cannot tell if they are just shoddy or if they're deceptive. Either way, their test results and advertising leave much to be desired - it's unclear.
I also talk about Mike Adams, the "Health Ranger," and his test on water filters - it was either deceptive, shoddy, or both. Here's the link I mention: stpaulmercantile.com/response.... I've also seen his other video about AlexaPure and glyphosate, and still, he does not test to the advertised life/service cycle of the filter, so the results don't mean anything in the long run.
Here's a link to all of my notes as I researched these companies. Click on "PDF" in the "Download Options": archive.org/details/other-gra...
...
My Berkey water filter videos grouped here:
• Goodbye Berkey - What ...
...
Here are the products that currently seem best to me (some are now affiliate links - more details below):
Counter-top, fill reservoir:
AquaTru
*IS certified to remove fluoride
*I have decided AquaTru is better than AquaSana, mainly because AquaTru is more efficient, wasting less water.
*Get $100 discount at this link: aquatruwater.com/?oid2=50&aff...
Under-sink:
AquaTru
*IS certified to remove fluoride
*This is currently what we use where we live
*Get $100 discount at this link: aquatruwater.com/?oid2=50&aff...
Watts - amzn.to/3SYZYrA
*NO information on Fluoride removal - I've included it because Dr. Knappe said he uses it in his home, it filters PFAS, and it's affordable
Pour-through pitchers and dispensers:
ZeroWater - amzn.to/3SVQr4l
*IS tested, though NOT certified, to remove Fluoride
*Note* about ZeroWater: I recently learned that ConsumerLab.com found high levels of microplastics added to ZW filtered water. They said it could be that the filter needs have water run through it 4x and then the reservoir cleaned before drinking. They also noted that ZeroWater is particularly good at filtering Arsenic, so if that is a concerned with your water, they still recommended using it even with the microplastic issue. My conclusion is still consider using it, but make sure you flush it 4x and then clean and rinse the reservoir thoroughly. I wish all of these companies would quit with plastic and use stainless steel or sturdy glass, but, alas!
Clearly Filtered - amzn.to/3CTuy02
*IS tested, though NOT certified, to remove Fluoride
...
When I made this video, I seriously thought maybe a couple of hundred people would watch it, and I felt uncomfortable trying to make money off of it. More people watched it, and I still kind of feel uncomfortable with monetizing - I posted a video about it - • Should I monetize my Y... . But, I decided that as long as I tell the truth, am as transparent as I can reasonably be, don't hurry, and have people in my life holding me accountable, then it's okay to make some money off of my labor. It's not much money (thus far) compared to how much you need to actually buy food, fuel, etc to live. But every little bit helps!
...
REPLACE your filters on time according to how much water you use. Remember to do it! They are virtually useless if they go much past their life/service cycle. Yes, it is merely an estimate, YMMV depending on your water quality, but it's the best most of us consumers can do unless we frequently pay to test our water. However you choose to time your replacements: Set reminders for yourself and change the filters!
...
I do not expect anyone to pay for my content. But some want to show their appreciation with a gift. If that's you, thank you! Here's how: www.buymeacoffee.com/RobertBeaty

[@dsmith2858]

Keep going brother! BLUF: we are all waiting for the end result of your detective work!!!! You should NOT try to keep your videos short based on a single viewers comment. If your videos are being watched keep going. In the end we want to know your opinion on the best replacement filter for the berkey blacks, ideally at a good price :)

[@lueveniapettiford2626]

You just fine not boring. Keep up telling us what you know. Thank you

[@crystalrussell3979]

I totally agree. We all appreciate you doing the detective work for us. And will be waiting for more results. Thank you so much.

[@musicisbrilliant]

Im with you! I want to find out what good solutions Robert finds. I have a berkey and I want to put filters in there that I know are doing a great job.

[@billgrey]

Someone who wants a shorter video and less info is not that serious. Make 'em as long as you want for people who really want your take on the situation. Thanks much!

[@cupidok2768]

y ppl lie so much

[@rachel13935]

You are def not boring. Many of us are looking for this information. Thank you so much.

[@johnsmith22334]

I'm getting the impression from these videos that all these companies are buying generic cheap filters and then just jacking the price up. So Berkey probably wouldn't be an issue if we just replace the filters more often. But the problem is their filters are extremely expensive for generic filters. So is the solution then to buy a generic, cheap gravity fed or under sink system and then just buy and replace cheap carbon filters often? Also, you shouldn't care about that one woman who was going on about not liking longer content. Water is an important topic, the more details the better.

[@michellebanik3689]

I agree. Who is she to decide that anyways... pushy! Who cares what her PERSONAL opinion is? She doesn't HAVE to tune in for Pete's sake!

[@originalbiblestudywithJael]

We installed an expensive $3000 under the sink filter years ago, only lasted for one year. when we replace the filter of $300 for half a year only , the water tasted aweful. then I turned to cheaper filters.

[@shamrock73]

The problem isn't they need to be replaced often more info came out they just don't work that good. They work good enough to fool people with the taste test. But the lab results are horrific.

[@MommeeMadre1]

That's exactly what I think! I bought the exact same filters as Berkey for half the price -same size/weight... the water "looks" the same. I just bought some test strips to see what I can discover.

[@elwingw4321]

Yes, now I want to know what to use in the old berkey containers. I really appreciate your videos on this issue.

[@Robert-Beaty]

Use Doulton - www.britishwaterfilter.com/?coupon=beaty

[@Hannah-rl5lt]

​@@Robert-Beatythat only works if you're in the states😮I'm in Australia

[@kathleensemelbauer2629]

I appreciate all the work you have done to help all of us! Thank you! You ARE NOT BORING!

[@lisastarshine2541]

I am loving all of your videos!!! Thank you so so much. I've been down this same rabbit hole for months. It's crazy to me that this is all allowed. Most people just trust it's all ok and it's not. How scary. Thank you so much for taking the time to share. I hope many more people see your videos!!

[@daphnesupplee9237]

What filter did you decide to use after you came out the rabbit hole? lol

[@4DTravelr]

Seems to me distillation or RODI are purer and less shady options than the gravity fed rabbit hole. I could be wrong tho.

[@emmaevans7896]

What's everyone's thoughts on Kangen?

[@nikkimullis5305]

So glad I ran across your videos. I live on a fixed income and it's very hard to save up to buy these filters. I'll be waiting for your next video to see what you recommend. It's so sad that truth in advertising no longer exists,even for something as simple as a water filter. Thank you for taking the time to help me make a better decision.

[@michellemata2269]

Check out the CWC Labs video on testing water filtration systems for glyphosate.... they tested the berkey and other systems.....they found that Zero pitcher water filter worked 100% filtered glyphosate. If you are looking for a cheaper option....try Zero pitcher filter. If it can filter a water soluble chemical it can filter most of the other chemicals you might be concerned about. And yes the Berkey filtered 100% glyphosate as well if you can spend the money. Just a person that read your comment and thought you might want another viewpoint on the subject.

[@nikkimullis5305]

@@michellemata2269 Thanks for your suggestion. I've used pitchers before,but I use a lot of water every day for myself and my 2 dogs and got tired of constantly filling and waiting for them to filter. Since I've already spent the money on a Berkey,just feel like I need to use it.

[@rachelgoodkind6545]

@@michellemata2269 I got a Zero pitcher at Walmart, is' great to bring if you are travelling and I believe it is better than Brita/Pur.

[@marilynwallace1050]

Your videos are so important especially now. I think you're on to cleaning up deceptive advertisement and bringing truth to the people. We've owned Pro Pur, now called Pro One since the gravity fed became popular back in 2015, (not sure of the date) I think their site says, nfs 43. We got them due to the claim of fluoride removal and back then there were nearly none who claimed fluoride removal. We live in Hawai'i now and brought the tanks with us. Now we don't pay extra for the fluoride filter because Hawaii is smart and doesn't put fluoride sludge in the drinking water. Thank you for your due diligence on such an important subject; and you are not boring, just real and genuine, an attribute we all seek out and appreciate.

[@Latebloomershow]

Agree!

[@pattiannepascual]

Thank you for your very informative videos.I hope to finally find the best filter by watching your videos. I did not run out to buy a Berkey because I did research a couple years ago and found issues. I was going to make my own using stock pots but using Berkey filters. Until i saw the price of their filters. Insane! I subscribed to your channel and will watch all of your videos. You have no clue how valuable your information is. Your extreme work researching all this is very appreciated.

[@truthsurfer6062]

We are so surprised by this information. We just paid 175 for two black berkey filters and have used our berkey for many years thinking we were drinking safe water. Thank you for this show. We are now buying a system for our whole house to filter our water and we are so disappointed

[@nojustice8353]

i have an old berkey from 1999 and just had the water tested and the filters are doing their job...cant understand what ya'll are cryin about

[@suzannehartmann946]

@@nojustice8353 WHERE did you have them tested and for what? Might want to use your state's lab

[@killough71010]

This guy is just complaining about the gray areas of certification. But one thing that is clear and certain is these filters do work. I used a burkey you for about eight years for dispersed camping in national forests getting lake and river water. Never once did I, or my family ever get sick. I've had the water tested as well, these filters do their job period. Sold my smaller burkey to my brother who now uses it. And I got a larger alexapure, and same thing, works as it should.

[@MichaelMerritt]

@@killough71010where did you get your water tested and what did they test for?

[@cloliflornc2793]

Thanks for the info and your postings, Robert - may many blessings come your way for your honesty and your willingness to not only help yourself but others.

[@rumdog117]

Thank you for your videos. You have done more than anyone on KZbin making videos about this subject. I've spent hours upon hours watching videos and going to web sites trying to find this. The fact that your videos are still up and you are not being sued by any of these companies, show that you are correct. Waiting for the next video on what are good replacements for my Berkey.

[@lisalisa3652]

Thank you! This is disheartening but I appreciate your time and information.

[@omavicmcmurray2893]

Thanks, I wondered about switching filters from the Berkeley I’ll keep watching. No need to keep it super short just keep the integrity of your work, thanks so much!

[@bethcollier3789]

Thank you for your video, I was going to purchase one for myself. Your care and compassion for us out here outside of the best testers, has given me an insight and more respect for my own intuitional guide.

[@barbaralallegranzi3791]

Robert, I would listen to you as long as it takes you to make your point...hours if you required it. It is my opinion your messages are delivered with both clear sincerity to share injustice and deep honesty about your findings. It seems to me you do not want to "have" to discuss matters such as this but, are led to do so for the betterment of all who would be fooled. I have both Berkey and Alexa Pure Filters in my survival gear and always had the sinking their advertising is hype and their products are basically B.S. It is so frustrating. Even the most savvy of peppers recommend them. Thank you for doing your due diligence and presenting to us your fact-based findings. Your efforts whether OCD or more likely...simply thorough are very much appreciated. Your one of the best, Robert. Keep shining your light!!

[@barbaralallegranzi3791]

Pardon the typos

[@MsRexsmurphy]

Not boring, very informative. Ty.

[@tobapearl8612]

Been using Berkey for years. Darn. Waitirg for you replacement suggestions. Thanks for your meticulous work. Hang in there

[@7hilladelphia]

Mike Adams is such a sensationalist. I side stepped his stuff ages ago. I appreciate your direct info, no fear mongering, no drama bs just plain good down home info sharing. Subbed & big thank you from Gold Coast Australia, Australistan lol 😂🎉

[@pattiannepascual]

I always kind of liked Mike Adam's articles but recently getting fed up. Not long ago i read an article claiming "they are sneaking crickets into our food". But all I found crickets in,seem to proudly list and boast their food has crickets. I did find one company that listed the bugs scientific name in ingredients instead of "cricket flour" but that's on you if you buy something without researching ingredients. The biggest problem I have is carmine red,red # 40? that has been used for decades in many sweets and foods,yet never labeled as coming from crushed bugs.I don't think I will be reading too much more Mike Adam's as he seems to be joining the "fear mongering" community. Seriously, if you claim they are SNEAKING bugs into our food, at least have lab tests showing they found bugs in the foods that were not listed on the label. I save crickets from drowning in outside dog and cat water bowls of animals I rescue and watch over, so no way in hell I will be eating crickets or any other bugs.I sure do want to know of any and all products that contain any bug so I can avoid them completely, but can't just take someone's word for it, not even Mike Adams.

[@foxyauragems6146]

He still sells and promoted Very high oxalate foods so I wonder why 😮

[@JackieKay11]

Was searching through my emails for something Berkey related and as I used to get Mike Adams’ newsletters, before I went off him, a few of his newsletters showed up in the results and at the bottom it stated ‘ Sponsored by Berkey’, so there you go 🙄

[@Coconutoilcrazy]

Never boring! You are giving us alot of important information, this takes you time to find truth and then share with us. I subbed and look forward to more videos.

[@jmo2104]

Man I worked hard to be able to afford my Alexa pure. This disgusts me. It's criminal. Thank you so much for sharing your information.

[@richardvargas3983]

Rather than mentioning all of the filters that DO NOT have NSF certification why don't you just tell us the filters that DO have NSF certification. I appreciate your thoroughness and desire to find a reliable means of gravity water filtration.

[@laceywhite4380]

It’s in his description dude. Try looking

[@richardvargas3983]

Thank you. I appreciate your reply. There seems to be an emphasis on fluoride removal being mentioned with NSF certification.

[@baffledbybullshit-]

Maybe he like some others are exposing the fraud of these companies and the channels that promote this bullshit. And of course all the channels get their cut.

[@katie7748]

​@laceywhite4380 You'll catch more flies with honey.

[@jamesdickson8956]

God bless y'all

[@Hoku12]

I'm holding off purchasing for my cabin until you release what filters you think are the best you have found so far. So thankful I saw your video before I purchased. Thank you for your research!!

[@RhinoDNA]

SAME HERE!

[@FORUIDIG]

I purchased mine BEFORE knowing this! Looking forward to hopefully swap filters. Thank you for this!

[@gisela1074]

Aquacera

[@Adentalgrl]

Thank you for sharing!!🙌🏼 I only use APEC RO. Glad to know they are as good as I thought they were. I got really sick from my tap water 4 years ago and that’s when I found this filter. I rent but still put it in. The portable thing is difficult so I’ll definitely check out your other videos and links. Greatly appreciated!!

[@jeffreyheuser9503]

Thank You Robert: A comment below asked actually which filter/filters have been certified and could be recommended by yourself, instead of listing the fails. Sounds like you have done an admirable investigation here!

[@sjf67gto]

Okay so everybody's just fake, so my question to you is what do you use?

[@postscript5549]

This is a very odd coincidence. I was briefly looking for a water filtration system TODAY for the first time in my life. You are doing a service.

[@Silenceisconsent]

New subscriber! Whew ! Glad I found you ! I’m saving to buy a filter bc I feel shtf is around the corner!

[@lindapeterson5810]

I appreciate all the research you have done, and bringing the issues the public. Contemplating van life, now looking at the royal doulton system.

[@michellebanik3689]

Not boring. Don't worry - you're FINE! Thank you from making aware. I DO want to know what IS trustworthy to use as I've not bought one yet becuz I don't know which to buy, so this really helps A LOT! Will be looking for you next video! Thanks again!

[@susancarmona36]

Feeling your pain. I appreciate these videos and making your “notes” available to your subs. Appreciate (so much) the painstaking efforts that went into your research, so THANK YOU. Ok, so I’m in the market for a ‘gravity fed’ (non-electric) filtering system and keep going back and forth on which one. Needless to say, video #2 halted the decision making process, so I am patiently (yet eagerly, too) awaiting video #3, before I take the financial plunge. Sounds like maybe the right approach is to acquire the Berkey unit without the filters and then buy (based on your upcoming research and recommendations) compatible filters. Wondering if buying a Berkey unit alone is even possible.

[@gyorgyjakabjulia]

Why would you give money for a shady company, after all this info? These companies need to be boycotted and held responsible for their lies. We sustain their lies when we buy from them.

[@J_LOVES_ME]

Why pay so much extra for the Berkey name though. Waterdrop makes the same thing, but it's much less. After realizing the filters were essentially the same, I went with the Waterdrop.

[@andibourne8755]

I appreciate you and this info sooo much. I've been wanting to purchase a Berkey due to all my Homesteaders I watch have and use them faithfully. Most have sicknesses that water contaminants increase the symptoms so they 'LOVE' their Berkeys I'm trying to contact them to get your videos in their eye sight. God bless you!!

[@gardengal9478]

Appreciate your information and research. I hope you can give recommendations after all you have done.

[@yfa6244]

wow! A lawyer could make a name for themselves on this!

[@lucasdog1]

You have to understand, when a lab tests to 200 gallons, that means the amount of water they ran threw the filter for that test, NOT that the filter was done and couldnt filter any more. If the claim is that it will filter up to 3000 gallons, it may only clean 2000 gallons if the water was exceptionally bad. If you ran pristine distilled water through it, it would never need to be replaced. Manufacturers recommend time based intervals because components in some filters are time sensitive, like activated charcoal.

[@Listen2me400]

That makes sense. I’m not sure they would test a filter like Berkey that supposedly lasts for years.

[@lisacarden1309]

Thank you for your hard work and time! 🙏❤️🙏

[@heatherpoirier6351]

Your videos are great. Pls don't shorten your videos anymore. I would have liked to have heard the remaining stuff on this one.

[@cynthiaharding9536]

Thank you for your extensive research and truth finding! I wish you much success!

[@flowerpt]

Thanks. If we ever need them we will darn well need ones that work. You're doing a great public service.

[@foxyauragems6146]

If we ever need them ...? I’ve never NOT needed them. That well water is contaminated too

[@rosemarythyme8595]

I never bought into Berkey because it just never made sense to me. That and the ridiculous prices! I have been distilling my water for years and adding liquid trace minerals to it. That said, recently I have been looking for a way to filter that water that doesn't need electricity. That's how I found your videos.

[@jenbaer6455]

It took about 20-30 gallons and a lot of time just to prime the Berkey filters with the accessories that came with it and then had to purchase the one they didn't include. for 200 gallons, the filters would last less than 6 mos per person. $25/month and not totally sure what it's not filtering out. Sorry that I bought back up filters during scare tactic sales. Thank you for doing this work!

[@CC-lv1ox]

Thank you for sharing all of your research. You are wonderful for helping others. Despicable that a water filter company would be deceptive, and not just one of them. Like big pharm,it seems.

[@racheal74]

Wow very good to know this is mind boggling. We really need to research everything

[@stacey9003]

I was in Guatemala for humanitarian medical work and drank water from a silver impregnated terra cotta water filter. The water tasted very good and I didn't get sick. Water from the tap in Guatemala isn't considered safe and a couple people we worked with became ill from tap water, but we filled the terra cotta filter from the bathroom tap in our room. I can't find such a filter for sale in the US. I would buy one if it was available here.

[@deweyory1635]

@ Stacy there is a video on KZbin where a man made his own terra cotta pot water filter. It might be that if you can get pure Terra Cotta then you could possible add in Colloidal Silver or use Pure Silver bars or coins. Sailors have been known to use their silver coins to preserve their water. Something to look more closely into. Pure copper is another to look into…although, too much copper has been said to create ill-effects. I would also look into pure gold just to research.

[@flowerchild777]

@@deweyory1635 TinyHouse and Offgrid Resources 👍

[@naturheilkunde-kanal9814]

I am in Guatemala and we used this filter for ½ year. No problems. But still I am not sure about the quality of the filtering and of tap water. I actually should do a test of the tap water for toxins and bacteria & co before and after filtering...

[@pattiannepascual]

the silver may just be good for killing bacteria but doubt it is eliminating lead and all the other hundreds of toxins in the water

[@GarlandFarms]

@Stacey You should try searching the internet for " silver impregnated terra cotta water filter" as I believe there are water filters for sale in the US that fit that description. These days, if you limit what you purchase to just those items you can find on the shelves in brick-and-mortar shops, you're going to find your selections to be painfully lacking.

[@BB49]

OUTSTANDING WORK!!! Thanks for doing all this, I have a deep well that's unfiltered, I was considering the Berkey system until seeing your videos, since then been looking at the Zero filters, however I do not like the fact they're all plastic and BPH is a concern, this is the primary reason for considering the Berkey system, stainless steel, no plastic,,, Keep up the most excellent work and keep fighting the good fight!!!!!

[@autumnisnothere]

Thank you for doing the work on this. I have been disappointed with my last filters from Berkey so was starting the search for a replacement. You've saved me a lot of work. How very upsetting! Well, for now, at least the water tastes better after having been filtered through the Berkey filters.

[@deborahnarendorf7106]

Wow I just considered buying a big Berkey water filter set. You saved me! Thanks for this!

[@cynthiaharding9536]

I appreciate your research. Thank you.

[@WonbyGrace2]

I literally just bought berkey filters again. I listened to so many reviews many years ago and scientists uncle looked into them and at first thought they are great but noticed it was turning water very alkaline? Could not find anything I thought better. Looking forward to next posting thank you for posting

[@bettymcclellan2164]

Have you looked at other people that have been testing to Berkey and they're coming out fine? Or you just listening to this guy who seems to be angry at all filters? Is he getting paid to bring up all this bull crap I don't know just seems a little weird that now it's coming out by one person

[@TameTheMind]

@@bettymcclellan2164 Have you checked out the legal documents on this suit against Berkey? --- If not, then what you're spewing is UNinformed comments mixed with Anger.

[@user-pb5vp8gf4z]

I appreciate you sharing this information and calling them out. I distill my own water (add my own minerals, homemade "sole" from real salt) but have a zero water as back up if needed but wanted a bigger option that doesn't need electricity....guess I'm out of luck.

[@joelharris6403]

Thank you for this, you doing us a real service.

[@Lambchop59]

Superb superb Sir, how quickly you tell us but ALL those hours of study and research. GOD BLESS u and thank u so very very much

[@DesertPackrat]

I have news for everyone: all purifiers don’t filter as long as they claim, and they don’t filter as much as you like. But then again your tap water is likelier shittier and you survive. The point is that these purifiers are still a good thing for prepper survival. I would buy not buy them for everyday use. It is futile to take contaminants out of tap water and still have a retirement savings. Short term survival is the only place where these costly so-so purifiers can help. And even then I would still boil it.

[@gemini4life851]

There is no need to keep your videos under 5 minutes to appease a few complainers. First off… they can watch a 10 minute video in 5 if the increase the speed to 2x. Secondly, this is your channel. Run it your way. Thankfully I stumbled across your channel while researching water filters. It’s one of those items I’d like to have but the funds aren't available. I appreciate the time and effort you put into researching this and I’ll be following you for updates.

[@christinenatvig2313]

This was not boring. Thank you so Much.

[@The_Tool_Scoop]

Thanks for your research and hard work. What a murky world water filtration is. I recently purchased a waterdrop lucid pitcher which I watched a youtuber get lab results on. It's supposed to only be good for roughly 200 gallons but water definitely tastes better and the results were good. I came to the conclusion that I may aswell buy lots of new pitcher filters instead of buying an expensive water filter that probably lasts the same amount of time. I think that there needs to be a fresh lab test done on each filter so that we know the truth and everybody should stop buying them until then. Many years ago I worked for a filtration company called Pall Filtration and they did lots of beverage filters. I don't know why I don't hear that name mentioned ever.

[@keithjohnson5190]

I bought a Brita Pitcher in 2008 and it did a good job of filtering, the new replacement filters they have out now don't filter at all. I have been looking and haven't found anything unless you spend hundreds of dollars for a RO system. Nice video.

[@stevenmiller461]

Lots of people like the doulton sterasyl 7 inch ceramic candle filters which i believe will fit in the berkey systems. I dont know much about them but at least worth researching.

[@Chris-jg3cl]

thank you so much for all of the research you have done! I have been living under the assumption that my propur was doing its job for years. :-(

[@teenermeener971]

your doing a great job. keep up the good work.

[@OvGraphics]

Robert, I learned an early lesson involving politics. It's called 'the brick wall'. Looks like you're running into the same thing with a class of merchant that has an unwritten (or mebbe a written) rule about advertising. Nobody rocks the boat and all sail on unmolested. You used to see something similar in yellow page advertising. The plumbers, for instance would, most of 'em, would all buy the same size ad. Then one day a new jackleg outfit would come along and buy a BIGGER ad which would force the others to follow suit. Get what I'm saying? They'd leave well enough alone as long as possible. That's what I'm seeing after viewing your sterling but unrewarded work. Early this summer using 5 gallon buckets I made a water thingy using the device with the best claim of all...the Sawyer. Luckily the water source that would be put into use here is an eternally flowing nearby underground waterway with good water even before it's filtered. Again I commend you for your super work. It really shouldn't fall to you to have to step in and do the work others are PAID to do.

[@wondering1916]

Thank you so much for your research!

[@crackerjack6075]

Safest drinking/cooking water strategy revolves around reverse osmosis systems, then additional water treatments. We use RO in the lab and test the results personally. The commercial gravity filters have their value, but primarily only a pre-filter. RO doesn't remove some impurities (dissolved gases e.g., hydrogen sulfide, some smells e.g. rotten egg odor. And more importantly, some pesticides, solvents and volatile organic chemicals. So after pre-filter and RO, we test for impurities, then devise additional water treatments to suit the objectives. But if after pre-filter and RO treatments, if testing reveals additional, non-removables..., we usually don't use that water. It's quicker and cheaper to pass and just go get water that RO is effective making acceptable, passing all tests.

[@pimacanyon6208]

I appreciate your videos. As a result of the Berkey vid, we're not buying one. We MAY install an RO unit. Or not. For now--and maybe indefinitely--we get RO water from nearby grocery stores. 25 to 35 cents/gallon. Yes, you have to haul it, but we go to these stores anyway to buy food, so it's not a major inconvenience. We use RO water for drinking and making coffee, tea, etc. and use a Pur pitcher with the lead reduction filter for water for cooking.

[@_JustinCase_]

The issue I have with store produced RO water is, who's maintaining the system? That's a critical aspect of RO purifiers and I guess my trust ends there. I know you can't just remove the initial cost of say, a AquaTru countertop RO device, but if you do and only calculate the cost of replacement filters, the per gallon price is less than 10¢. I look at the initial cost for the device like a one time expense for any other "kitchen" item (i.e. coffee maker, mixer, toaster oven, etc.). If you use the cost of a KitchenAid mixer to get the average unit price of a baked cake... you get the idea. 😉

[@vivianhathaway1163]

Thank you once again 🙏🙏🙏

[@writingforgodot]

I wonder what are the adequately tested water filtration systems and companies. Too many people think their water is purified, but they're still drinking fluoride.... And, yes, it would be great to be able to refurbish a Berkey system with a filter that works..!!

[@jokertim777]

It's not just the water filter industry. I used to work with money counting equipment for casinos, and I beta tested a new product with a customer that was supposed to meet the high accuracy standards listed on all the brochures of their other products. I was the person who was gathering all the raw data and I took the time to crunch the numbers myself before forwarding it on to the manufacturer. Needless to say, they fudged the data to make the equipment seem better than it actually was during my field testing. Everything is a scam nowadays :(

[@katiekane5247]

🎯

[@lindaashbrook6789]

Companies will use any tactic to make a sale. It's greed pure and simple. There needs to be more lawsuits suing these companies that advertise one thing and sell an inferior product. It used be that you could sue for false advertising

[@drala108]

Thank you. I'm not happy to know that I dragged my Berkey all over the world thinking I was getting clean water. My newest batch of filters were carried from Canada to India for me just last week. 😒

[@foxyauragems6146]

Same here dragged that thing Everywhere...

[@joyful_tanya]

I subscribed because of your research. Thank you.

[@KerryBlue72]

What about DOULTON?

[@47retta]

Thank you so much for this research you're doing. I have been on the fence for so long about buying a Berkey. But not any more! Now i will definitely wait to see what you find! I have reverse osmosis under my sink, but my interest in a filter is for a grid down situation. I have a Life Straw and a small hiker Katydyn, but would like a bigger unit for everyday home use. Does the NSF website list the companies they certify? What about Consumer Reports?

[@teresaoftheandes6279]

I appreciate this, thanks.

[@UngernVonSternberg777]

Thank you so much for your research. I've been using Pro One for years. That is outright scandalous.

[@karen46600]

I am going to return my proone thanks

[@UngernVonSternberg777]

@@karen46600 Same here what the hell!

[@thethingonthedoorstep3464]

Have you researched the Sawyer or Lifestraw? I couldn't afford much so I bought a Sawyer and attached it to a 2litter soda bottle with the bottom cut out. I inverted it on top of a 5 gallon bottle and filter through that. The filter seemed to work well for about two weeks. Then needed to be flushed more and more. I smell chlorine in the water so I'm not sure it's doing much. I've only ran tap water through it. I noticed Sawyer and Lifestraw both list that massive amounts of water can be filtered. Reading the fine print this applies only to tap water and not the outdoor water their adds promote.

[@leastewart3779]

I paid 120 gbp for two lite life straws hope ive not been lied to to.

[@zamis21]

I watched a video from Project Farm "Best Water Filter? Brita, ZeroWater, PUR, Berkey, Aquaphor, AquaTrue" and went with the Zero.

[@ReflectedMiles]

I've used a Zero pitcher for many years through many filters, I have friends with Berkey and others, and I have had the best experience for the least amount of money among those I know. I do keep it refrigerated, though, because that mass of materials through all their filtering stages can start giving the water an off-odor or -taste if it's just left sitting in a warm environment for long periods without much volume going through it.

[@zamis21]

@@ReflectedMiles our filtered water doesn't last that long we're big water drinkers

[@zamis21]

@@ReflectedMiles I wonder if anyone is tested the Nieken gravity filters against like the zero and the Berkeley I wonder how that would test would come out.

[@ReflectedMiles]

@@zamis21 I don't know, but if you use a lot of water as you indicate, I think the Nikken filters are quite a bit more expensive. There are multiple NSF certifications on these filters and I'm not sure how they compare on those, and their relevance in categories to each other, either.

[@carolstraquadine3608]

What are the two you’re testing out? Thank you for your hard work!

[@ziptalia2456]

So what are the top 3 gravity fed filter alternatives to Berkey/Alexapure, etc??? What would be a good substitute?

[@danivani5837]

Ok so which water filter is the best to filer both city water and creek water if needed? I've been a berkey owner for 4 years

[@knittingnovice]

Not boring. Very helpful

[@bjdufus6283]

Just what we all need........anecdotal filters. Can hardly wait.

[@concernedcitizen8464]

QUESTION: were the fluoride filters on the Berkey when these test were being done?

[@debrasonner5970]

Thank you for the information. Now, what can I use to either replace the filters, will Royal Doulton work or what should I get? Sorry if I misspelled it.

[@Latebloomershow]

In CA, I used Multipure under the sink filters for a couple of decades. It made life so much easier than hauling a gallon of water from sink to reach up and pour through my Alexapure here. I did not do a lot of research at the time, but their filter seemed good and compact for what it was. Obviously a gravity fed filter is useful for anything not coming from the kitchen tap. I notice you have not mentioned Multipure. Now that I've watched both videos, I'm going to their site and see if I can learn about their filters. I'm worn out filling up my Brita and Alexapure all day long. Anyone else have an under the sink? Perhaps Aquacera has one.

[@pattiannepascual]

unfortunately most of us live in Apts. and not allowed reverse osmosis or other under the sink units.I can't stand videos that end up comparing every type of filter in one video. It's faulty and unfair because a Brita will never come close to a reverse osmosis so why bother lumping different types together? those of us looking for non electric units that sit on the counter need a video just on those kind. If I were you, I would search for videos that stick to testing only under the sink units. Try Project farm channel. not sure they did one on just under sink units but it's a good channel for reviews. I can't wait for this channel we are on now to come out with the next video.

[@connieroberts4626]

@@pattiannepascual when tn3 grid goes down we won't be getting water from our sinks. The city run water systems are all computerized, if tne grid goes down they won't work. I don't know what the answer is though. It's very confusing because everybody gives us false information.

[@pattiannepascual]

@@connieroberts4626 I think our best bet is to keep researching to find the best filter that we can take with us if we have to flee, Run water first through one of those bucket filters made from natural materials,(gravel, sand, rocks, etc), then run through the good filter and after that, boil the water before using.A lot of people totally depending on systems attached to their plumbing or require electric or batteries to work well be in shock when the power goes out or if they have to flee. I know it may sound rediculous but I have studied socialism/communism and spoken to many who lived it. Even hard core preppers had to run last minute,leaving everything behind besides the clothes on their backs and what they could carry.I keep trying to wake people up but they don't listen. They have ideas and assumptions of what it will be like, ignoring stories and warnings from those who actually lived it, telling them they are wrong. I stress the point that if we network asap and come up with a plan to stop the socialists from taking over in the first place, we can avoid all the other issues, but again, they won't listen. It would take millions of us to stop the evil ones, since few are interested in joining a movement, the most we can do is prepare as individuals for whatever scenario may result.

[@connieroberts5397]

@@pattiannepascual ì agree ! I'm 76 so I've been around a while, I've lived and experienced a few things. Most think they know things, but in reality have no idea. you can store food, but if you don't have water your in big trouble. if it comes to radiation because of war etc. it will really affect things in a big way. They have been handing out iodine tablets in Europe because of the scare of war, and radiation etc. Not many peppers touch on that. When I wSin school we had drills to do with bombs being dropped. I know thi gs are much different now but most really don't realize it. As you said I think everyone is going to have to think research and come up with a plan.

[@kristenmarie9248]

@@pattiannepascual Absolute truth. My in-laws from Europe had to leave everything behind during WWII, and escape with their lives. Omg, what they endured. 😔

[@leesasees]

I run my filtered Berkey water through my zero water pitcher. Sad that I have to spend so much to help my body stay hydrated without all the garbage.

[@8Namaste]

Robert, what are the two filters that, while not perfect, are at least okey? (Thanks for your videos! I learn a lot!)

[@motorcitymadman146]

At over 100 dollars per filter that pisses me off. Everything is a scam. Glad to have someone paying attention.

[@shari8]

We distill our tap water. Because the water is heated, I believe it would kill the microbes. Probably not practical for off grid due to the power needs. I'm going to go back through the manufacturer's literature and check for the certifications and lab results you mention. Thanks for the info.

[@ClickyBuzzClick2ConnectBuzz]

You don't need "power" - just a fire and a pot with the lid upside down to collect the distilled water into a separate stainless steel container inside the original pot!!

[@MommeeMadre1]

It's so jacked up!

[@spoonypoon7998]

Zero water is what I use. They give you a water meter to test the water so you know when you need to change the filter..

[@mindyjay77]

It doesn’t filter out fluoride. That just tell you if there are any dissolved particles in the water. A lot of contaminates and impurities aren’t “dissolved”

[@spoonypoon7998]

@@mindyjay77 I don't know I've always lived on well water

[@Jack-bs7cy]

If the water has more contaminates would it filter alot less? Makes me think they filtered clean water. Costco reverse osmosis setup $250.

[@billordianegmail]

Do you know if the Grayl water cup has been tested? It's for hikers it's a two part cup system that also says it's filters viruses, chemicals etc.

[@cheryladams5175]

I love your videos. I am very angry, I have used Berky for years because I have serious autoimmune issues. WHAT filter would you recommend?

[@nancysonnier6605]

I bought AquaRain so many years ago I can’t even remember when. For many years I was sure it was good. I have a deep Well that when checked by well service was told my water was much better that the nearest town water. My main reason for filtering was microbes and iron. Very hard water here. When I would fill the top it took hours to completely filter a couple gallons. Then a couple years ago after receiving new filters the process took less than an hour! The water just flowed through very quickly. I contacted the company and received no satisfactory answer whatsoever. I’m just assuming that the original company probably sold out but I couldn’t even get a straight answer about that. Because my well water is so hard I have to change the filters pretty often. They’re quite expensive but I didn’t mind the cost when I thought they were doing a good job. Now I’m not so sure. I appreciate your research and the information that you share. I’m hoping one day to click on your report and hear you say you found the perfect filter, but knowing the way things are these days I guess that’s not gonna happen. 🤷‍♀️

[@steh79]

I looked thru the description notes and clicked the links but still do not see which filter is the best suitable replacement for the berkey filters. Can someone please point this out to me, I must be missing something. All I see is undersink, pitchers, no berkey gravity style etc. Thanks!

[@vandysmikin848]

I have city water , I want to get rid of - Lime -chlorine - fluoride - chloramine- , I watched many videos, right now I am distilling the water , I want to stop using the electricity it takes , so which one is the best for my purposes,😮thanks val

[@xenasloan6859]

Love your work fella

[@engelneen1686]

I just watched a video from another creator where the berkey filter actually put aluminum in the water to the amount of four hundred times over the limit of what is healthy so I guess while the the filter removed about fifty percent of the fluoride it added a ton of aluminum. The creator did not know if this was a defective filter or not but this freaked me out.

[@Silenceisconsent]

So , my question is … with your research, who do YOU use ? Who would you feel confident referring?

[@gisela1074]

Check out Aquacera.

[@soozinn]

This is all so awful. I’ve been using an AlexaPure in good faith for years to remove fluoride. What do we do?

[@indiasounds1335]

Thanks for your video. What options would you recommend?

[@cloliflornc2793]

I have a ProOne and was wondering if you would know if the filters you plan to use on your Berkey would fit my unit. Thanks.

[@Robert-Beaty]

I'm still emailing with companies to see which ones are legit, or the best option. It seems that any "candle" type filter will fit in any of these generic stainless steel cans. So yes, you can probably reuse them!