It's Topical I Perspective - Why Shivambu left EFF?

[@BotsNews]

Thank you for the insightful conversation, always interesting to follow SA Politics. Love from Botswana 🇧🇼

[@tshepompapho1902]

Me too

[@lindomsomi86]

❤

[@MphelaMakola]

I will borrow Julius words "there is no permanent friendship in politics".😂

[@lebraa9233]

@@MphelaMakola ONE biggest Moppert Show Parade Carnavals Bunch Destroying 🙄🤓🤓

[@tkjudas]

With or without Shivambu, we will rise to the occasion. I'll continue to support EFF.

[@HelloWorld-th9vb]

You remind me of Self proclaimed prophet bushiri’s followers 😅

[@StrikeMathebula]

we will Rise, VIva EFF

[@HelloWorld-th9vb]

@@StrikeMathebula keep dreaming

[@rabbinick8989]

​@@HelloWorld-th9vbthe truth of the matter is that they were not lying. They're still supporting bushiri

[@sifisodube4686]

Are forget eff is dead man

[@BernicePitso-s4z]

Only Floyd and julias knows the true story. Even today No proper reason why Floyd left

[@JohannesRampeng-gz7xm]

Floyd is too wise, Malema is wise too, so the 2 knows the real reason what's going on,,, not 4get ZUMA!😂

[@ElliotMxolo]

Very fishy.Dont believe Malema and Floyd will be separated.

[@MulaloCaswell]

This comment pushed me to skip video

[@eunallmaharaj8583]

Why should one bother ,about a 9 % party ....why is the media ...make a Mountain out of a Mole....

[@NoziHlengs]

These 2 knows what they doing ,trust me they up to something

[@JabulaniMathuthu]

What surprises me, is that everyone except Floyd is given a platform to explain his resignation

[@corneliacoetz243]

He did !

[@kealebogakgatitswe8546]

Thta means you don't know floyd and you definitely did not watch the press conference

[@KaySankara]

​@corneliacoetz243 then why do we have all these conversations trying to analyse the reason for the move???

[@Goldlender]

Floyd was given a platform to explain his resignation because he is one of the founding fathers of the organization. The public deserved a clear explanation

[@kealebogakgatitswe8546]

@@KaySankara Its a big moment in South African polotics so duhh everybody is gonna speak about it. Everyone is coming up with their own assumptions

[@naphtallymohlala4238]

Conspiracy is when men gather to discuss another man's decision without involving the man.

[@Advshongie]

True that😂 they are all busy assuming 😂😂😂😂

[@bonginkosimtsweni8276]

True and they unashamedly do that.

[@thembanipetros3173]

That's how white people undermine us they are using some of us to understand our thoughts

[@Samufacts]

You are absolutely right. everyone talking does not have the facts from the mouth of the horse..

[@williemarthinus9619]

The horse is mute.

[@lwazimofokeng6472]

I didnt know i could love Samkele so fast😮

[@phelelanimafuleka3854]

Loving hogwash and speculative analysis, the guy is blowing hot air and overrating himself 😂

[@NtombiMdluli-wb8px]

Floyd is a wiseman Silence is golden.

[@BruïnGebakken]

17:00 She's a brilliant analyst who provided a comprehensive, impromptu analysis without flinching for a second. Indeed, we have great thinkers in South Africa. Thanks, Blain, for bringing her on your show. To mention that she's a woman would be superfluous. 🎉

[@johannemotlhabane4341]

We will keep on supporting Malema regardless of who leaves or stays.

[@johncaswellsambo699]

The problem is that you are supporting an individual and not the organisation

[@nathanielkgobe427]

Keep it up is a noble idea 🙏

[@lebraa9233]

Malema must be Mopt OUT With his whole members Bunch idioten Rudeness 😏🤣🤣🤣👎

[@mandlamaso2274]

U such a dummy

[@michaelmcilrath9466]

Ag shame

[@Coco-kw3iv]

Well done Khomanda Floyd... For your sanity, growth and peace ✌️

[@BuyileMkhize-ln1lr]

Well said Samkele. Indeed MK needs a politician of Floyd's calibre at this stage.

[@markwinter7511]

His calibre ? A hardcore Marxist Leninist who wants SA to be like Cuba.

[@clintdaniels4379]

Let's wait for the VBS case to be completed.

[@donaldchikudo1521]

Is it necessary to have this panel. You better just ask Floyd.

[@SolomziZililo]

I don't think so mina

[@NawAwz]

True they wish to know why he. Left that is why all nonsense speaking about him

[@keleohilebonyanaleahdithej7486]

O ba thusitse… seemingly there were news for the week

[@itanetherevivalistrevivali8419]

This Panels were arranged by the SYSTEM in Poland 2023 June by Roelf Meyer and his cronies. Check Solly Mapaila spelling it for you all puppets who were there including this nonsense you see in front of you

[@moragbell]

😂

[@fonkibarah49]

Belief it or not, Samkelo is really the Lord of the Media

[@lebraa9233]

AGREE This guy His intellectuele Reporter salute him speak the truth 👍👍

[@007-bourne]

His reporting is all over the place though. He doesn’t need to squeeze out everything he knows in every chance he gets. Postured responses and only dealing with facts can certainly make him better.

[@4Kenosi]

He is SPOT ON. His investigation Journalism is unparalleled. And he has been on this fallout for almost 2 years now. He did his BEST at every EFF Presser, to let cat out of bag of Factions. BUT Malema dismissed him. Indeed Malema thought he was going to be the 2nd DP of GNU. BUT ANC KICKED HIM IN THE TEETH😂

[@4Kenosi]

​@@007-bourneI think you are wrong. Go and view EFF Pressers over the past 2 years. And listen to Samkelo's Questions to EFF😂 HE SAW THE FALLOUT COMING A LONG TIME AGO. HE IS SPOT ON.

[@lebraa9233]

@@007-bourne These are the Reporter You Needed in the Country Spots on Where the Get happy about His Information 👍👍👌❤Intelligent intellectuele

[@SteppingOut957]

This was the best news analysis show I have watched in a while. Just brilliant. Thank you! We must protect the SABC at all costs.

[@reversewithpoetry4175]

Sandile swana remains the voice of Reason ❤❤

[@puseletsomonnaemang2958]

Always

[@thapelolitlhakanyane9060]

Always emotional. Can’t be true.

[@myriamnguepi8731]

Thank you to DR. VILAKAZI for raising up the most critical issue arising from this Flyod moves 👏. Indeed, this speaks volume about the moral fiber of current South African Politicians. It is now clear that this country needs a new breed of politicians!!!

[@MbongeleniDludla]

It seems as if crooks are clubbing together in MKP

[@ntombirikhotso]

It's a haven.....hmmmm

[@Xamtata]

Don't look at those alleged "crooks" because there are known crooks in the current government already. Just focus on their ideology.

[@HalalisaniMbhele]

Niyahlanya

[@kenzo5255]

Well spoken by Dr Vilakazi

[@teecrush6513]

Wow Samkele you can speak sense wow

[@Abisai9383]

Samkele, I salute your analysis. very informative and intelligent

[@Siyandaskhakhane-i2s]

Samkele is misleading, he only feeding the people negative, why should he not say anything about development done by Zuma in the same area Nkandla? School, tar road, electricity, Samkele only saw that informal home next to Zuma's home

[@WillamShauke]

We dont care about eff affairs we should be discussing about service delivery

[@stevelutambo9440]

Don't follow if you don't care

[@thabomatjiu3473]

@@stevelutambo9440hey wena sabc isn't owned by the eff and mk but south Africans who pay their TV licence s

[@bucksteenasimza8927]

Why are you here? 😮

[@Xamtata]

Thank you. don't waste energy on eff, just do your job.

[@angelinamaake8290]

​Everybody's channel to participate

[@siasmoise661]

Samkelo Maseko is somehow too personal and too judgmental in his analysis and which might be misleading in the outlook.

[@SiyabulelaTheoMathiso]

He's rejoicing...

[@gabrielhambinga6062]

Politically immature

[@luciossithole5487]

Samkele

[@nathanielkgobe427]

Samkele is a white journalist, he hates the EFF and CIC with a passion. This lady who speaks is the EFF enemy number 2 after Samkele, there's totally nothing like revolutionary talk all these African journalists converged here are very happy pertaining to what transpired in the EFF, in fact they want to make sure that they Appease their white masters, you can even hear Samkele speaking that he is greatly thrilled and fascinated about the break up in the EFF.

[@itanetherevivalistrevivali8419]

Stereotype man who loves n cling to a Content no matter how old or how much it doesn't work. But more so, this special Program is Stellenbosch funded. Well, our Media has elevated in American Style Narrative Pumping sine Elections. And I don't think they will go back. This was planed in Poland to fight Totalitarian and black people's true emancipation. Solly Mapaila says ALL this Media Puppets were there when GNU was planned. Now they own Media and choose who to assassinate when n how. Exactly their new assignment and Poland Planned Approach!

[@tearyb]

Quite right Sisi. The citizens are losing faith in politics, because of the dishonesty and lack of ethics. They will stay away from the polls in future.

[@keithmhlanga9786]

Do not get mislead by these people, their mission is for you to loose faith in politics. Only one Party has been ruling SA for 30 years, how did they come to a conclusion that if another Party rules things will remain the same?

[@MzwandileNdindwaNdindwa-bd4tx]

I think Samkelo is right when he said, this Generation Malema,Fikile, Floyd,Malusi ,Sihle Zikalala,n Ronald lamola who is the first president of the Country,so Floyd see the opportunity with Mkp

[@Mametja866]

It is not a secret that CIC never respected DP 🥺. This is on him

[@Travellersspace-f5h]

Samkele knows he's story and very clear in his articulation

[@phelelanimafuleka3854]

😂😂

[@larencelivers3151]

It really shows that politicians are there for themselves NOT for the peoples they vote for them.

[@thapelow.kekana9783]

Samkelo's analytic skills are superb

[@mdinwamaphosa1211]

Great analysis guys.

[@aarongunnz9513]

Samkelo Maseko is tearing EFF apart , maan 😅😂

[@lebraa9233]

👍👍👍👍👍🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣Violences makers dropte

[@nozinikane6376]

He carries the agenda of the anc

[@zwelethudondi7256]

he hates us. he is too biased

[@mishacknthane1060]

Samkelo has matured in his analysis.

[@bigtree31000]

I agree he lives and breathes Politics.

[@bonganikhathwane5440]

Yoh he's better than that Mashele political analyst yoh

[@thabelofortune]

​@@bonganikhathwane5440 😂😂

[@ONENESS18120]

Shivambu's move to MK party is purely opportunistic period 😮

[@itanetherevivalistrevivali8419]

How does Malema fight for power when he is walking alone?. Why was he supposed to lay down arms when our vision was to make him South African President. Is it not CIC who was saying he needs nothing but Floyd as a Finance Minister?. Don't dream in that Studio, PLEASE!. If Nyiko was gunning for Presidency then he is a careerist. How can he wish to surpass the one in front of him when we had a clear mutual program. Please blame him too. You will destroy him by trying to defend him by character assassinating CIC. You are killers!. CIC is our only way so far. Don't worry about your 2 terms when we are faced with a crocodile 🐊 here!

[@LindilechristopherMgqobele]

His not alone

[@velelambeuralukakevideos372]

Asijiki fighters

[@lebraa9233]

@@itanetherevivalistrevivali8419 Malema He totale failed with His big Mouth also as Pan-Africanism With Shivambu MAKING Disgusting Discussion Rudeness Mantelite Insulting Westerse landen & African Continent Countries NOT one Country waiting for Malema to Come back to those Countries he praise himself as HERO Here NO HERO anymore 👎👎🤓🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@gaopalelwem]

True... These group is assembled to rub soil on wound purposefully to shut EFF down.

[@williamsethunyatlobolho]

Excellent discussion!

[@MikeAlilali]

This should be aVBs feaver

[@bakergovender3291]

Excellent and informative discussion

[@Susan-tq7ir]

Samkele you are wrong, Malema wanted Floyd to be the minister of finance

[@gracenyoni9195]

Dr Vilikazi you nailed it

[@EdwardMyeza-eg1nr]

Some analysts think they analyze sense whereas they analyzing nonsense

[@nkululeko4058]

This people are not dumb , They do it on purpose to push a certain narrative which will cause division among EFF and Mk members ….and it won’t work because we use to these weak tricks the media always tries to

[@norahmolefe3583]

@Edwardmyeza-eg1nr😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅

[@Christiano-fclub]

Samkelo to be specific

[@nicholasntshoka]

It could be said by your thoughts that your analysis too are nonsense.

[@dabishilutendo4899]

Samkelo is no different with people who compile different types of music and claims to be.....

[@myriamnguepi8731]

Samkhele, your analysis is Highly pertinent and eye opening! Well done 👍

[@zolamakunga6292]

Shivambu wants someone who can cover his scandal and no one who is opposed in leadership of mk party

[@trishybillion]

well articulated analysis

[@ZamaniGecwa]

Shivambu choose a wrong move.

[@vusiradebe7098]

Just bcs you hate zuma is wrong move.

[@SolomziZililo]

Weleleeeeee

[@JabulaniMathuthu]

Idiotic comment

[@BonguyiseJunior]

Shivambu is being deployed critical thinkers will understand this

[@WillamShauke]

He is making money you busy watching his movement. If anc or pa promise better position better money eventually he will move to new political party

[@lindasitshange6465]

We wish the DP well,as ground forces of the movement we remain dedicated.

[@SfisoMbuthuma-xp3ez]

Samkelo and Prince must start their political party I'm sure Khumalo will b very happy to join them. It's clear they are serving the same muster

[@SthembeleZwide-ei6pf]

This Maseko guy knows what he is talking about

[@bigtree31000]

Samkelo Maseko owned that room

[@khethamkhize5970]

Greate staff Mawande🙌👌big up brother 👌 teach samkelo one or 2 things abt politics, danko👊Mawande

[@africanson1429]

There is no honor amongst thieves......

[@lindayhukutwana3861]

Dr. Vilakazi is on point about morals n integrity of politicians.

[@Mpho-j3f]

The MKP is not a political party, but a liberation movement! Until South Africans get it into their thick skulls. Maybe they'll understand how the MK moves. But because South Africa is for everyone that lives in it, not everyone in South Africa needs to be liberated. So the MK is playing a part of revolutionary politics, not of those who wants to maintain a corrupt system. The system in south Africa was designed not support the natives of the land, and that on its own is corruption.

[@dannym7593]

Maybe liberation of the Guptas, not South Africans.

[@nomatamsanqasopazi352]

Prince' you have said it all. action is the answer

[@lefachris125]

Floyd can move to any party it doesn't change much, he failed with EFF he will fail with MK. Goodluck to him though, asinamona.

[@AltRock0827]

Excellent analysis. Great presènter. Samkele is such an asset to the sabc. So knowledgable. Who can forget his pointed questions to Jesse Duarte which of course she batted away. It earned him the title 'Lord of the media' which he rightly owned. Sidebar: they are right to say the EFF is not truly progressive what with their love of money and tenders. We see through their false concern for the poor black child. Ditto MK.

[@itanetherevivalistrevivali8419]

Lets start here. Samkelo _ CIC Malema built you when he said "Samkelo" you know wena you like to feel like you have a point when you have nothing. From that day you sky 🚀 rocketed

[@poovengounder9722]

you can be intergenr person van be a political anaysts.you have have wisdom

[@mothibeditseladimitloa3147]

There's a word which says " love them all but trust nobody " Julius Malema got a shock of his lifetime that his colleague and Cde have to part ways in this fashion.

[@cefasfah85]

U don't know politics

[@sifisodube4686]

Or yes trust no one

[@mothibeditseladimitloa3147]

@@cefasfah85 I'm not born yesterday and i was in the struggle and politically minded. From 1970's I'm now 64 years old. I did say from 2022 that will Julius Malema be a lifetime President as he never mentioned about sharing power with his deputy, Floyd. I also said Julius Malema will never emulate the late Peter Mokaba as young lion of the movement during apartheid. He's just an opportunist and remember he formed the party after they were expelled and amongst them the late Sindiso Magaxa who was coming back to rejoin Ronald Lamola was more intelligent than Julius and not hungry for power. It's just like Jacob Zuma, both were hungry for power

[@KingdomMAJOZI]

Valid points picked up...

[@ThabisoMphuti-wm1mj]

The guy wanted to be a minister Malema refused to join Ginu

[@poovengounder9722]

remember Mandela was asked I what do you want to be remembered one day.This man has given the best reply

[@PhelelaMayekiso]

Samkele Maseko hates EFF with a pension, but am telling you my brother that won't work ,,we see you hater

[@mcebisimbusi7777]

Samekelo thinks he is clever

[@frankmashabela809]

Yeah I agree with you. This boy hates EFF too much because of brown envelope.

[@mosesmkt7561]

Mawande you have touch with reality, continue don’t act like angel when analysing.

[@thusoramakobya7054]

One of the most educated politician in our lifetime ✊✊

[@m.x.refrigxolani8365]

Who wants you to look like Cuba😂. There's a lot of educated fools, English never lied on this one.

[@lebraa9233]

Most idioten Politicians is EFF members 😅😅😅

[@simvuyelefecks4155]

Mawande mphatho wam thank you for ukuphakamisa I sterkspruit

[@mahlodinorah487]

Will a Limpopo an survive in KZN? Like when mara? My poor brother, ba zokuhleba uhlele nabo khona la. Check your back forever bro

[@aarongunnz9513]

They will make a mince meat out of him. They will call him lishangane

[@Dzhambila]

Floyd and Julius had a fall out more than 3 years ago. They stopped being friends and just became political allies. They didn’t hangout together anymore as they used to before

[@kenzo5255]

I am not interested in the hot air being blown by Samkele and his stupid group in studio, i am interested in SANDILE SWANA analysis, the only best analyst

[@RodneyErnstzen]

Hoodlums..

[@RodneyErnstzen]

Malema is crying because Floyd left him for Zuma ...crybaby .

[@Garik_The_Tsunga]

It seems to be a 'long game' that most can't appreciate, let alone understand... I like the natural unrehearsed perspectives of Swana and Maseko in as far as they are still able to be unemotional...

[@sifisodube4686]

Samkele give others a chance to talk please

[@MbuyiseliJacobMjxakilekanogema]

sorry Julias Malema i see from your body i can't imagine what is going on in your mind uMkhonto weNtsizwa ukuhlabe emqolo Ndoda qina ukhumbule enakwenza ku former President Thabo Mvuyelwa Mbeki

[@tinkeletseladimitlwe781]

A whole lot of chisanyama speculation here, nothing to ride home with from this dreamland

[@phelelanimafuleka3854]

Tarven Gossip...😂

[@MT-04]

This is a tactical move. Watch the space 😂😂... I listened to Floyd words very carefully

[@HelloWorld-th9vb]

You remind me of Self proclaimed prophet bushiri’s followers 😅 eff is dying baba😂

[@Mondli2890]

​@@HelloWorld-th9vb you are dreaming 😂😂😂

[@dumisani986]

Were you able to notice or read their body language both Malema and Floyd besides what they said

[@Xamtata]

​@@HelloWorld-th9vbatleast eff stands for something, what do you stand for?

[@kingmelano9882]

Exactly

[@kk35-nif]

We need new policy at eff ,malema is no longer allowed to run eff like mugabe, I think after 5 yrs he needs to allow someone to take over

[@douglasmacarthur4058]

Samkele Maseko💪💪💪

[@mkramawelaking2007]

Shivambu left EFF so what is politics, same as zuma left ANC after he served all his life in that party. I think we should be focused on those 95 Libyan guys would be productive.

[@ABGcanga]

Only Floyd would give us a complete answer as to why he decided to leave. Alot happened in the back doors mostly from the time of elections. Anyway, I think its time for Eff perhaps to have two presidents, a male and a female with Malema as chair of the party.

[@lindiwemhlanga6907]

And he doesn't owe us they must leave him alone

[@Dazzle-pf7yl]

Chest pains Floyd is gone Malema is a dictertor he does not want to be contested in his position as president of the party

[@reubenletsoko2371]

Samkele speaks facts.

[@GwynnethKobokana-z4y]

Shivambo is sick of standing behind Malema's shadow, he needs the Revolutionary stance.

[@mvubu6823]

Zuma and his kids have a much bigger shadow

[@MmeliEe]

Who's shadow is wider between JZ and Malema?

[@NoluJezile]

If our politicians could listen in these analysis could be on top of the game

[@Goldlender]

May those who gather against you to discuss your downfall and promote false narrative about you fall in their own propaganda. The mission of Economic Freedom In Our Lifetime is certain and will surely come to reality. Though it may tarry, but it will surely come to pass!! Long live EFF!! ✊🏾✊🏾✊🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾🙏🏾

[@nellydee3065]

May they gather to scatter and flew with different ways

[@Goldlender]

@@nellydee3065 🙏🏾🙏🏾

[@sinethembagabada265]

It's interesting that these panels are always in agreement...

[@craigclifton7254]

We know why Floyd left.! There is no future working with a dictator.how the mighty fall and when they fall they fall hard!

[@PaulMahlangu-rl5by]

Is it the first time in history that a person resigned from one political party to the other? What's all this fuss about Floyd?

[@JohanHuman-e7q]

My question? Ìf you were a former President of a country and now you are the President of a new Party ,you are now in competent to lead that Party and direct policies in that Party and there for, now need experience people from other parties to come and assist you cause you don't know how to do it yourself. Makes a person wonder how are their voter's are thinking.

[@levikalombo1630]

Thank you eush

[@SfundoDlaminimp5]

It’s not the first time. He is the founder

[@gracenyoni9195]

For the first time in my personal view, Samukelo you nailed it hard here

[@lutendomutavhatsindi8383]

EFF is the only political party that matters in this country, that's why....

[@maburwanemokoena7117]

When Samkelo asked "So you're saying MK ke mokete wa dikatse" I was very impressed that the journalist understood what he meant, he laughed and said "on that note"....

[@Louie-uv7bv]

And they shall speculate and speculate...

[@artiephatlane6409]

Samkile remain balanced on your views... Do not create yourself enemies in the near future where you will be needed the most, rather be patient with the grace of politics upon your life.

[@fxwic5072]

Why is no one mentioning VBS as a cause? It would make sense that them dissociating from each other will lessen the VBS publicity and it will be easier to fight when they have two radical parties behind them.

[@francispheto]

He never leave with the EFF manifesto he left it behind that is what me and other fighters are rallying behind

[@MadingakaMohlaping]

@@francispheto supporting free movement of border posts that influences crime

[@mnguninkosiyabo3216]

MK Party ; President : Jacob Zuma Dep President : John Hlophe N.Chairperson : Lucky Montana Secretary Gen: Floyd Shivambu Dep Secretary: Treasure Gen: Duduzile Sambudla Additionals :

[@mmabakwenampuang-we3zz]

Hmmm what about Molefe and Yengeni

[@leonardojordyn4864]

"The most sound and solid decision he ever made"allow the man to learn and carve his way

[@alexburnside3741]

Actually I think Vilakazi is an amazing intellect. She makes sense on point. Floyd n Malema they called out Zuma to pay back the money n dragged n called him put. Zuma was the reason EFF was formed.🤷🏽🤦🏽 You cant trust floyd to worry about the people on the ground. He's interested in his Pockets. MK as offered him big bucks to resuscitate MK. MK does not have strategies. All the corruption shanigans are in these MK. Floyds VBS Scandal is going to take him down.MK might be his only radical protective shield.,

[@mvubu6823]

Correct He loves money... Easily bought

[@nkundlandeseinvestments9862]

Shivambo has been frustrated by the type of leadership from the EFF.

[@ms_tee]

💯

[@ronaldmamaru4242]

We are members of the EFF not of any leader of the EFF including Floyd.

[@musajohannessithole8970]

These journalists sound like Tavern regulars gossiping about politics.

[@LaBandaMillicent]

😂😂Only after reading this 😂😂

[@aarongunnz9513]

Gossiping when they tear into MK and EFF.

[@PeterChauke-k8n]

It's a strategic move, between eff and mkp , to outshine anc

[@MbongeleniDludla]

I fully agree with Dr Vilakazi politicians are prostitutes cause today they accuse their opponent, however, tommorow that person goes exactly to that party saying I have got a new political home😂

[@JamesMusiime-nn1zo]

Before Shivambu left Eff he had left it in heart already and he had joined the mk party in spirit whether he had signed for eff again he had nothing to add anymore it's everyone's right Malema needs to build a stronger relationship and structure beyond what he sees

[@biko8229]

Yhooooo uSamkele uthi "they are thick as thieves"?????😂😂🤣