It took me 5 years to realize I could do this - RDR2

[@emigrant4life]

still the best game even in 2024

[@n67088]

I just started it and am astounded!

[@Garrysullivanjones]

@@n67088mister , you got some fine adventures ahead. You don’t need to read this. Sorry for troubling mister

[@gonzaloramirez2064]

​@n67088 im soo jealous of you

[@emigrant4life]

@@Garrysullivanjones true, man 🤝

[@emigrant4life]

@@gonzaloramirez2064 the same!

[@leesagar8651]

This game is amazing, the creators thought out every scenario and adjusted the aftermath based off what you choose to do as Arthur

[@njmenaceify]

then the horrible "wanted" system ruins the game once again lmao

[@leesagar8651]

@@njmenaceify a small thing all considered

[@rogerironhide4220]

This is truly the BEST GAME EVER!.... Definitely in the all-time Top5😝🤘🏻🤠🍻

[@LeumazDnazor]

@@leesagar8651 A small thing? Brother, this game is about outlaws and robbing and killing, the law system being broken is not a small thing at all.

[@teresa6775]

@@leesagar8651 Not really a small thing when some douche bag screams crap at you or you accidentally just bump into someone and all of a sudden you get 'wanted' for domestic abuse or some stupid sht.

[@terrapinflyer273]

That's one thing that bothers me in the game. After hogtying evil strangers in random encounters, it eventually amounts to kidnapping. Would be super cool if you could take justice into your own hands and earn bounty payments while doing so.

[@Dogpatch0842]

All you have to do is put your bandana up over your face or put a mask on and then you don't get hit with negative honor

[@christhomasson1148]

​@@Dogpatch0842that's completely wrong. Wearing a mask has ZERO effect on your Honor in RDR2. The Honor system represents morality, wearing a mask doesn't make a difference if you are doing an immoral act

[@Dogpatch0842]

@@christhomasson1148 nope you're incorrect I guarantee I'm correct

[@christhomasson1148]

@@Dogpatch0842 doubling down? Haha bold, but still completely incorrect. Masks and bandanas have ZERO effect on Honor in RDR2. Honor is to do with WHAT you do. Do something immoral, you lose Honor. Do something moral, you gain Honor. Wearing a mask while doing something immoral doesn't stop that immoral act taking place. The masks and bandanas are only capable of stopping NPCs recognising who you are while commuting crimes. Admit that you are wrong, or don't bother replying

[@mikeeclipse]

Only amounts to kidnapping if you have them on your horse. A regular hogtie and just leaving the guy won't results in that.

[@bluesea2023]

The details in this game are amazing. This game in 4K Ultra still holds up today, 5 years later

[@BlindingSun_]

Even in 1440 ultrawide in ultra it looks amazing 😊

[@hossprey]

😂still hold up today

[@Garrysullivanjones]

I play it on a 1080 screen, good enough mister

[@bluesea2023]

@Garrysullivanjones I have a 1080p downstairs and believe me, it doesn't even look like the same game. RDR2 in 1080p ultra looks like when you play a PS3 game on a 4K tv. I have never seen a game so different in 4k and 1080p Bring your 1080p next to your 4K and look at the difference. RDR2 in 720p and 1080p is not worth playing since they have put so much money and hours to make that game feel and look like real life.

[@Garrysullivanjones]

@@bluesea2023 I’m waiting for a sale on tvs. Is tcl a brand of tv you’ve heard of? I’d love a Sony but they are expensive . What 4k brand do you have ? TCL has a 144 hz refresh rate for gaming. Anyway, you don’t need to read this, I’ll just move on mister ...

[@filgus497]

you dont have to try and enter the house (and get knocked down the stairs) the 2nd time. i just stood outside and shot my gun in the air. you get a bit of dialogue like "whats that? thats him!" and then they come storming out. this game really did cater for every scenario

[@lumbagoRDR2]

Sometimes it is really planned and it seems that the developers have paid attention to even the smallest details. The result of 8 years of work after the first version was wonderful...

[@jhillert2006]

​@@lumbagoRDR2thats what I hope Gta 6 is like because im scared some people/idiots are trying to rush perfection

[@Therealestrunnerluda]

You obviously don’t watch the whole video

[@TheRealBatCave]

​@jacksonhillert174 just stay away from Mrbossftw

[@gwoody4003]

I never went back, I didn't know it was a dynamic event. I just tied her up and looted the house, presuming I would run into her sons on the road or in a saloon or something later.

[@Dogpatch0842]

You guys need to loot the crate and the chest in the bedroom there's jewelry and a bunch of other stuff. Also hop on the donkey. It's literally the fastest horse in the game

[@Turco949]

It ain't no donkey, it is a "Dronkey"!

[@ScreamingReel500]

The loot is random, at one time I got 2 gold earrings which can be used to craft at the fence, most of the time the gold earrings are not there. The Ginseng Elixer is always there on top of the chimney....

[@SPTX0907]

That donkey couldn't outrun a snail

[@thrashwerk]

Regardless of speed, I wish you could keep the donkey permanently.

[@Dogpatch0842]

@@SPTX0907 I beg to differ it's one of the secrets of the game it's as fast as the white Arabian which is what I use right now

[@costanzafaust]

if you're stealing from the house and won't leave, she gets on the mule to ride in and report you, if you steal the mule beforehand she cusses at you for that too.

[@Cognitoman]

😂 for real haha

[@zeddthegypsy]

😂😂

[@TrustTNToo]

Lmao

[@ceejaycuevas6652]

I just played this game for the first time and whoa I was missing out hahaha. I was rocking a ps3 for the longest and was ok with it since I dont game much. That was until my buddy sold me his ps4 with a memory card full of games but this is the one that brought me joy again!

[@LyudmilaRGVK]

This is one cool video. The first time I went there I walked in got the Shotgun. Then I heard her say that her boys would hunt me down. She ran out the front of the Cabin jumped on the mule and rode off through the front gate. I went back later and her and her sons were inside. I took cover near the Door. when I opened it they came out knocking me off the Porch. I threw a Stick of Dynamite which went off in the door way, and that blew 3 of her sons back into the Cabin, and one of her sons, still on the Porch had one leg blow off.

[@maximevanvynckt3748]

hello @lumbagoRDR2 , this is a reference to a Belgian comic book: Lucky Luke. one of lucky lucke's many enemies is the Dalton family. This lady is a reference to Ma Dalton, the mother of the four brothers. Joe, Jack, William and Averell. In Europe, this comic strip is very well known. RDR is so rich in winks. It's always a pleasure to watch footage again.

[@lumbagoRDR2]

Hello dear friend, you are probably right. This story is very similar to Dalton's story 🙏

[@matthewpaul526]

Or they are based on the real Dalton Gang, which is what the comic is drawing from.

[@samuraidoggy]

I wish someone would make Lucky Luke open world game, I would want it soo much!!!

[@samuraidoggy]

@@matthewpaul526 Well, Mam Dalton in the Lucky Luke comics is an angry woman, and has this same hat and similar dress. She is fictional character and the looks of her and style are from Lucky Luke.

[@matthewpaul526]

@@samuraidoggy And she was based on Ma Barker. It's a reference to real people, all of it. Your little cartoon isn't original.

[@thedutchfisherman7078]

6:53 Ain't so tough now are ya! 🤣🤣

[@Daniel-qp8ro]

Always gets me

[@gz219]

Spamming the 6:53 😂

[@nobody5277]

@2:50 "If you try to enter the old ladies BUT, her sons will fight you" 😂😂

[@JPColter]

I used the old woman for the 80ft tomahawk challenge 😂

[@jaymac7203]

Lol

[@brianmurphy250]

I used the whole family for one of the dynamite challenges.

[@op3nmind3y32]

I stopped buying guns because I found this toward the beginning, and started to realize that every gun would eventually be available to you for free. Minus a couple I never found/had access to for free.

[@scoobertdoobert1355]

Literally one of the best, most detailed games ever created.

[@Sioodie]

6:52 "Ain't so tough now are ya!" Got me rolling 😂😂😂

[@jaymac7203]

To a frail old woman 😭😭 lol 😂

[@taski1]

got her rolling too

[@angels77100]

You don't shoot Ethan. Why you choose to take EIjah I will never know. The clue was on the wanted document. It's Ethan you should have taken into Stawberry.

[@ChuckeeCheeser]

Any Wheeler Walker Jr. Fans catch that from granny? 😆

[@StonerFred]

I scrolled through the comments to find this 😂😂😂

[@hrdman2luv]

I tried a different scenario with the Odriscoll house. I went there before the mission where I go with Sadie. Then went to Sadie and the mission didn't change. The O'driscolls where all there, as if I hadn't killed them the day before. I was thinking, (hoping) that by killing them first, I could've told Sadie I did her a favor. Or even maybe the gang could've used the O'driscoll place as a hide out.

[@stevenjimenez4034]

Im just happy to see thst this game is still being played.

[@Voodeville]

i think this game are played A LOT last year or 5...approx like GTAV i think

[@jasonwillis7961]

@@Voodeville I wish it was being played as much as GTAV. It is a very successful title for Rockstar though, probably the most successful after the GTA series. But for example, GTAV came out in 2013 and still has roughly 100,000 to 150,000 average daily users in GTA Online, whereas Red Dead Online has about 800 to 1600 average daily users. Some of that has to do with Rockstar ceasing to update RDO in order to focus on GTA6, but its just not in the same ballpark. It still sells well, especially during sales and I only hope that people continue to add to the player base of this fantastic game to encourage Rockstar to both make a sequel and more games like it. Near perfection if you ask me.

[@ralfybaby]

​@jasonwillis7961 off line rdr2 is great best game ever, on line not so much.

[@peo4989]

Why, did you make it?

[@VL1975]

Why the hell wouldn't it be!?

[@Hoxson1]

wow, I'm heading back. Looks like a good spot to try and get that disarm three guys challenge

[@craigslaunwhite579]

Did you ever disarm them.

[@Brandyalla]

The sons are Ethan, Edgar, Ezra, and Elijah. I have just named their parents Elisabeth and Evan.

[@Chronix-]

Could be a reference to the real life Barker gang said to have been led by their mother, "Ma Barker."

[@ChingChangWallah.]

I watched a John Dillinger video and apparently Ma Barker had nothing to do with their robberies, as the FBI led everyone to believe. Still left you a like for the observation though.

[@Deathunter761]

It's at the same time a reference to the Dalton brothers and their Ma in Lucky Luke.

[@Inkslinger123]

Boney M song

[@PatienceKiss]

I love how they tried to give you the illusion the game has some dynamic rpg elements but almost every time you try to do something a little outside the box, like trying to return the wanted bandit to a jail for a secret bounty, or throw the serial killer to a croc for your own frontier justice, the game just screws you like "Really, you thought this was a crpg or something, boy? Get outta here"

[@Turk_2023]

Compared to GTA V what they did with NPC/environment interactions was highly improved. We will see the future in GTA VI of how you can interact with the environment. Maybe we will be able to cuff and kidnap NPC's, put them in the trunk and feed them to gators.

[@Nevertroon]

@@Turk_2023 GTA VI you'll be able to sit there and be lectured by sweet baby inc since they're helping work on the story for the game, it's gonna be woke and gay af.

[@robbieharmon3628]

Not sure what you mean because you can 100% feed people to gators😂

[@Turk_2023]

@@Nevertroon If you listen to Dutch's dialogue in San Denis and Rhodes Dutch is pretty freaking woke.... He is constantly bad mouthing the south and he was for sure a Yankee.... Calls everyone from the south dumb and trash basically just like modern libs today.... Guess that is why he ended up being such a hypocrite and horrible human.

[@DarshRS]

​@@Nevertroon If Baby Inc is involved, My wallet stays closed 😅😅 There's not a single game they didn't fuk up 😂😂😂😂

[@Syntax_Error_404]

Just took me 250 hours and I'm finally 100% through the story. Considering how many outcomes there are to A LOT of encounters, this game EASILY has three more playthroughs more, giving it ca 750 hours of gameplay. Wow.

[@gigliowananomacon]

Just got to epilogue one and I agree I would save periodically to do things different from time to time I recently discovered there is a lot of unique dialogue when drunk so I think I have 3more play through a planned I did sober good I’m going to do sober evil next then drunk evil amd finish strong with a drunk good play through to end on a good note lol think I will take a break to check out Red dead online

[@Syntax_Error_404]

@@gigliowananomacon Wow, didn't know you could get extra dialogue options when drunk! Got to try that out too!

[@mikeyj990ify]

Im playing thru for about 6-7 time.

[@Garrysullivanjones]

@@mikeyj990ifyI said I wouldn’t but here I am collecting trapper outfits in chapter 2. I’m doing as much as can before finishing each chapter . Low honor really interferes with a peaceful animal hunt. Now I’m not sure if bow n arrow kills in wild draw law attention if you’re off beaten track. Too much info. Pfft off to go crazy collecting rock carvings, Aberdeen pig molesters, sonny and cher...

[@LumocolorARTnr1319]

You took the wrong brother to the sheriff! Ethan is the second one you shot in the face.

[@Kwright304]

Wait really?

[@ElPatron42069]

Imagine if they delayed this game 2 more years and added EVERYTHING they wanted to originally, or at least make it available for purchase DLC, hell I’d pay a good $100 USD for that DLC!!

[@scottneil1187]

Don't encourage the greedy pigs at Rockstar.

[@Garrysullivanjones]

@@scottneil1187all the devs are greedy pigs . For example mk11 and hot wheels were cheap base game before I understood their tactics. Dlc is overpriced crap. To this day neatherealm wants 9 bucks for shao Kahn after I’d bought all other dlc , thieves

[@Purpose_Porpoise]

$100 DLC is some EA shit.

[@Garrysullivanjones]

@@Purpose_Porpoise all aaa game companies are greedy pigs

[@ryderrhodes1]

They blew the whole back out the rocking chair! 🤣 6:50 I rewinded so many times

[@tahaniplays]

😅Thanks for trying this out and sharing it now i know which way to do 😂 wish there were more like these videos of the same senorio

[@chriskociolek1830]

“Couldn’t have happened to a nicer lady” lmfao sooo good

[@treycurran23]

2:48 If you try to enter the but, lmfao 😂😂😂😂😂

[@cullensanner8823]

Arthur kills me with these one liners

[@tobysmith5661]

That’s the old woman north of strawberry I’ve been looking for

[@Maximus-z2t]

Thanks for doing these videos and showing the different scenarios. I think that mean old lady is funny. I left her alive after I got the semi auto shotgun. I’ll go back to see her soon. Thanks

[@lumbagoRDR2]

Thank you for watching the video, my friend 🙏

[@amjadalkiswani1995]

I've passed by this cabin long ago before watching your video, but you added quite interesting and new information. 👏🏻 As for me, I shot the door from outside and once they got out, I blew them up with a dynamite and took everything and left with dignity! 😂 Thanks for your efforts. I've recently subbed to you btw. ❤

[@TrexAintaChicken]

The grave is definitely new. I remember doing this several times through my multiple playthroughs, and every time i killed her and came back, I'd just find her body laying in bed, just like when you left her alive. Based on that scrapbook paper, it looks like Rockstar went back at some point and adjusted the encounter to add the grave and scrapbook paper to make the encounter make more sense.

[@cardiaccuse9orng4lf82]

I particularly like scenario #3 when the old woman throws the can at U.

[@eamonlyons8318]

I still think there are hidden outcomes to this day. What if you hogtie her up? What if you never go see her as Arthur? What happens if you don't kill her sons and flee again.

[@FoiledByFame]

And what happens if you follow her to find out where her sons are hiding?

[@ugodica]

10:15 the ease this granny climbs on her horse

[@jaymac7203]

It's a donkey 🫏 😭😭 lol 😂

[@MikeyBAmazing]

Thank you ​@@jaymac7203

[@vinaydavis6786]

I just took the shotgun and ran like a thief 😂😂

[@partlycloudy9443]

Me too...😁

[@eddyhaze8239]

Lumbago is an outdated medical term that describes pain in the lower back region. This region centers around the lumbar area of the spine, which reaches from the lowest rib down to the buttocks. Today, most medical professionals will use the term “lower back pain.” Pain from lumbago ranges from mild to severe.

[@mostafa_abbasi]

I didn't miss this one, i did this when the game was released on pc first time in 2018

[@holeymoley1]

Ah man, you got lumbago! Sorry to hear this, there's no coming back from lumbago

[@TTVBunnyDougie]

This game will never die. Period.

[@DanielaRobello]

I’m playing this rn I loved this game for 3yrs straight now

[@V4vendettA_A]

What triggers lumbago? Causes of Lumbago Lumbago can be the result of excessive bending or other repetitive motions involving the lower back. Osteoarthritis and spinal arthritis (spondylosis) 😂

[@jeremydeansausages1985]

NO MEDDLING had me laughing. Old ladies like that crack me up. Angry ole bird

[@DanielsWindow331]

The Snake Skin Saddle is literally the ONLY RESONSE I crafted small game arrows, this is BY EFFING FAR THE BEST GUIDE to shorten the sad monotony of hunting perfect snakes in this game...BRAVO Fine Sir, bravo!!

[@regal105]

Throw a fire bottle at the front door and just sit back and watch

[@brianmurphy250]

I learned on my third play through about being able to have two horses follow you for bug hunting trips

[@rockyace1415]

You not cleaning that gun makes my eye twitch

[@bambam6657]

In the 2nd scenario when u fought the brothers. The 4th one behind the door you kept missing the shot on him . Ahahahaha made me laugh so hard. He was playing peekaboo with you lol

[@OKAYIMTURNT]

I love how you tried to take down the gun before killing her

[@andrewboffin3890]

if you free the prisoners that are being carted away on your travels you can actualy activate a home robbery mission and you dont need to kill them

[@joshiecdsxcharlesy2283]

Just 100% this game yesterday was definitely great game still in 2024 need a RD3 asap great story great overall game

[@georgedunnells50]

You didn’t even ride the donkey

[@GradedHigh-io2le]

I think im gonna replay this on my ps5, kinda looking forward to it.

[@IamYasha10]

I realized I already took her shotgun and donkey but never returned to her cabin. Might as well visit her again for more loot. Thank you.

[@lumbagoRDR2]

🙏

[@johnjudd9716]

Best hiding place from the bounty hunters if you got a big bounty on Morgan , plus they will keep coming for you until you get enough loot to pay off the bounty at the closes post office

[@highstakes187]

Anyone else waiting for Elijah to say "shake and bake" !!!!

[@Hokie200proof]

Was lucky enough to have the laaso drag challenge open when i met this charmer.

[@TrustTNToo]

Lmao bro said couldn't of happened to a nicer lady

[@Fademan2182]

I am only playing RDR2 until GTA 6 comes out

[@lumbagoRDR2]

me 2 👍🙂

[@bradfletcher1991]

Looks like you’re playing for a couple more years then lol

[@ralfybaby]

I'll be playing RDR2 until GTA 10 comes out ...

[@LauraNino1990]

Sake lol

[@mjbennett3508]

I'm only playing RDR2 until RDR3 comes out..

[@jorgeomarcosmerivera4871]

When this stop? Every week I learn something new about this game. Really amazing! Thanks!

[@Shadow_Demon-fm9ko]

Rockstar made one of the best games I always enjoy playing no matter how many times I replay it

[@cardiaccuse9orng4lf82]

In scenario #3. When U return and find the grave, what happens if U leave before having a confrontation with the sons? U hear them talking, but don't have the shoot out. Leave and return later.

[@junicohen7918]

If you dump her on the tracks you go back and find her dead in the house

[@jamesvan2201]

the one thing that is really unrealistic about this game is the moment you lasso someone, they instantly drop. their feet are wrapped with the rope, but they just fall down as if their hands were too.

[@HrothgarOdubhghaill]

I remember finding that grumpy old lady, then being highly disappointed that I couldnt keep the donkey as a steed since i could ride it lol

[@Warrior___]

This is the only rockstar mistake / error in the game … there is a piece of journal that says they are in a huge bounty , so I have took them alive to strawberry prison … so everyone started to shoot at me …

[@bigbadsauce92]

maybe they are "wanted dead not alive"

[@Therealestrunnerluda]

It’s on purpose 😅

[@kalenwiley4041]

You know, when I call the cops for help something similar happens to me. I somehow end up getting arrested and charged with some shit.

[@eddyhaze8239]

it took me 5 years to see the ghost train

[@jaydee821]

I remember when everyone was mosh pitting for jewelry boxes spawning and then leaving just to spawn into a instant fight lol

[@Metro_gaming95]

This game is seriously one of the best games ever made ! And in my opinion it's number one ! Because I can't think of a game that is better than it there might be one just as good but not better than RDR2 ! All that being said now just imagine what GTA 6 is gonna be like i think it's going to be at least 2 times better than RDR2 and that's SCARY ! 🤯😍

[@zoutsider88]

Nice little nod there to wheeler Walker jr.

[@willwalk2000]

I don't get the reference? Are Wheeler and Walker previous characters?

[@dannydawn]

Just sad that Markiplier never got to savor all these moments and details… 😅 I sure did and I enjoyed these parts almost more than the main story which already was insane

[@kygreenskeeper8326]

Most useful gun in the game

[@SpaceTruckinNomad]

Those weapon icons would show up on the map for on Xbox. Gold colored if I’m remembering it right? Had to be in the minimap vicinity

[@rick1307]

I’ve seen multiple people make this video with differe by nt scenarios, but I’ve never seen anybody actually follow her to see where she goes cause she says you don’t wanna follow her

[@meatymouse9600]

took me 5 years to figure out this video title

[@samurai-slayer]

Trying to enter the but almost ALWAYS results in a fight...

[@antonpokrovskiy9292]

Going to start again for this, i'll chase her mule anywhere!))) Love this game!

[@deerob7431]

Wow this was a time dedicated video. Thanks

[@sepesusi86]

What if u shoot the guns off from the boys hands?

[@Danno5894]

They will try to tackle you I think. One time I tied up a couple of them and tried to bring in multiple bounties lol

[@County_da_kang]

On one of my playthroughs I tied up the old lady and robbed her. When i went back, she was still tied up, but her body was decayed... Didn't get the 2nd cut scene wuth the sons in that scenario

[@johnfowler6004]

I really hated the Exotics mission, trying to find those dam birds,there was never that many going about, and a lot of the time, you started finding a lot of the birds you already had

[@bulkvanderhuge9006]

I kept running into her riding on her mule going to get her Boys, after stealing her auto shotgun

[@matthiaskaun5255]

You named the Horse like me- in honor and deep misrespect to queen consort Horsey :)

[@ayarlett]

2 playthroughs later...im still deciding to do a third but this time be more of a camp type person. Every time is different.. dammit!

[@Rawkwilder]

This is usually where I get my free shotgun

[@artisticmegamok]

Just found this spot I was late to this game. Beat part 1 when it came out. This game is amazing im hooked. 🤠

[@badassuchiha4875]

I've Notice allot with this Game & the Next that RDR 1 & 2 they Recycle each Dialog with each Mission either if your Arthur or John

[@siddhanthta]

Imagine being the lady, chilling in your house, some random guy comes in your house , steals your gun , runs away, comes back, kills all your sons and leaves you to die.

[@L4Disillusion]

Keep face covered when delivering bad guys until you get to the town you are delivering them in go straight for the sheriff office try best not to attract attention. Also when robbing a store act normal as you are about to enter the store put on your mask with item wheel. when you leave act normal and take off mask on way out the door. Get on horse get gone. If you never get seen by the law wuth or without a mask then it didnt happen. Tip on robbing stagecouches. Go to the stagecouch in towns and rob the back of it. The one you can pay to travel on. Use mask and a set of clothes you havent been caught in preferably. What you look like matters especially if you have been seen in the same outfit robbing killing ect.

[@OGSRealmccoy]

And if you enter the but that is hilarious

[@themarlboromandalorian]

First scenario. You killed all her sons, then her. Who buried her? What about her sons? Why would they bury her out here instead of the estate being taken by the government and sold at auction? Why should anyone notice she's dead if her family is all there, dead, with her? Second scenario, how they know he's been near their mom? Feel like it's not thought out very well in the first scenario. And that double swinging door...

[@benelledge6391]

I like the nod to Wheeler Walker jr

[@asmabenoun9484]

Don't forget to loot the unique jewelry for crafts

[@DarkPoetDCLXVI]

The first time i though she saved me from dying. I died on a cliff and respawn outside her house, and i felt welcome😅😅

[@LyudmilaRGVK]

I have the PIGGYBACK Game guide which is for me a pain to read. Now when ever I get near a Cabin, I look for a video about that Cabin or homestead.

[@tomobrien5345]

When you first go, before you go in you can ride the mule.