Professor Ming could be expert in political science, however his economic viewpoint could be skewed? Trump lowered the business tax at expense of blue state middle class. The effect of his “tax incentives” has capitulated. The last month service PMI and manufacturing PMI is at 11 years low. (50.9 and 50.6) While 50 calls for recession, US economy is definitely at descending path. Regarding food stamps, Trump increases the difficulty of obtaining the subsidies. The total population of lower income remains steady at 30.9 million. It is the top two echelon,upper middle class and upper class that have seen their wealth increased. Trump ‘s view regarding climate change, woman’s right and race have been very unpopular. The midterm was a warning sign. With the election inching closer, his performance will be examined by the voters.