京剧《二进宫》 于魁智 孟广禄 李胜素

京剧《二进宫》 于魁智 孟广禄 李胜素

[@user-pg2ov5du3w]

L:生于旦李净孟三名角组合二進宫绝配唱演京劇名段影最棒讚…!

[@456qsn4]

这段李维慷夫妇唱得最好。

[@user-sf7qr5je5y]

我多次听外国朋友说起过，中国的京剧相当于西方的歌剧，我认为这个说法很有道理，而且在我看来，中国的京剧一点也不比西方的歌剧逊色。

[@user-hh4zu8yg3d]

歌剧哪有京剧妙，哪个歌剧有那么漂亮，多样的死法

[@user-kh6qt7wp1o]

三位國家頂級京劇藝術家 唱得太好了

[@user-pg2ov5du3w]

L:李胜素為今梅派中嬌々者唱腔吐字美艷表情(大登殿像)無人能及…

[@EdKao-zy5yx]

真的是太過癮了，每位老師都有炫技的段子，只有一個爽字，不知何年何月才能再看到中國京劇院的表演。

[@Lao_tzu5789]

I don't understand chinese language but in my personal opinion everything here is beautiful. This language, this outfits and this culture. Greetings from Poland my chinese friends. 🇵🇱❤️🇨🇳.🙂

[@hongliu3416]

最佳三位好演员！赞!!！

[@deyeyang4203]

这么好的搭档，百年一遇吧？喜欢

[@evelynzhong6065]

三位唱得特棒!每天必聽❤❤❤

[@ellayahyahyahyah8089]

最喜欢这段儿了

[@peterchang7672]

多年前在台北看到他們演出！

[@wmtung]

北京故宮博物院必须收藏這一齣视频！

[@xkiller1968]

绝！！！

[@boungn5952]

好听！

[@catherinexin88]

百听不厌

[@user-ps4rn2pn9f]

這就是京劇的美

[@seagreen6442]

好听好看！大艺术家！

[@chengmr]

清狗最喜歡的大戲！

[@yunxiangyang4023]

真好！

[@eekoontan6387]

yunxiang yang

[@user-jn9rh4ox9o]

真好聽!也是我初學的斷子!從此就迷戀上京戲了!

[@zrb5943688]

初学就学这段啊！那你起点够高的！

[@user-px2do9bu7u]

我以為ㄧ開始應該是學蘇三起解，比較容易些

[@user-pg2ov5du3w]

L:精緻名劇当今三名角合演真乃百听不厭…讚々々!

[@daoshengwang5837]

好听

[@jonyang6828]

太好了！

[@yansun8571]

京剧是我的最爱！

[@kevinzheng145]

胜素姐姐唱的真好！

[@user-rp8fw5io8g]

好聽，我現在早上慢跑，都要聽一遍，好聽，經典。

[@chengmr]

漢奸最喜歡聽！哈！哈！

[@Putin-presidantRussia]

Cheng Mr 你這個傻逼喜歡到處拉屎

[@mikelaw9872]

she's getting older but the voice is getting better.

[@evelynzhong6065]

于魁智李勝素孟廣祿仨是二進宮的鐵三角！看看過他們仨的二進宮版本之後，完全無法聽別人表演二進宮！👍👍👍❤❤❤

[@gql3093]

建议听一听李维康，耿其昌，邓沐伟三人的一段，也是挺好的

[@zzj1998]

词儿简化太多了。。。难度也就跟着下来了。。。不过这三位是目前还能唱的里面最好的角儿了。。。赞👍

[@user-gd6cl4xx3w]

玩)与(樂)！京剧-梅派艺術经典时尚唱段~(大唐貴妃~梨花颂)， 是玖爷晚年所爱，传人第子拿手好戏！唱腔提神，盛聚人氣， （八旬老人）2022年秋天。

[@mingshu8546]

nice ! great !

[@cenkaufa]

说 于 李 孟 这一组唱的好听 可觉得 耿 李 邓这一组唱的更好听 !!! 如果用分数来表示 于李孟 ------- 9，98 耿李邓 ------- 9，99

[@lijunhu1884]

好吗，您这是哪边儿都不得罪，说句实在的李维康夫妇的很多剧目比现在这些人强的太多了，不是一个档次的。

[@adamlapchingcheung7525]

好! 謝了

[@yingguo3501]

这么端端庄庄的三个人，真正是当代京剧的幸事!

[@jamespope1256]

好

[@user-hn6ce5nq3m]

高手过招过瘾！

[@david1234lee]

Through hesitation, indecision and hard struggle the queen here reveals to all of us a truth Shakespeare or even Homer never did have the courage to reveal: a woman's final love is on her son even at the cost of her father's death and the loyalty of the most courtly servant is for himself in the long run! What a grand opera, theme, plot and artistic presentation few today really can understand. This is China's national treasure!

[@sherryyu53]

嘻嘻嘻，前幾天才聽到于魁智、李勝素老師的表演，原本想找大保國回味，沒想到都沒當天的精彩😅

[@david1234lee]

This is really, really good! Beyond the feeling to describe! Western oper singers often torrent out the sound and voice while Chinese opera singers chew and control them and spell them out in perals of music and emotion in the most profound and artistic way!

[@GardenerJov]

May I cite your golden words?

[@david1234lee]

yes, you may, indeed! In term of metaphors, similes, symbols and performance sophistication, Chinese opera leads the world. Many Chinese opera singers have gone through decade of training throughout childhood to perfect their art ! Just listen to the sound, the pauses, the winding pitches, the twists and prolongation of their voice you will find they are loaded with meanings.

[@david1234lee]

Lee in her best years !

[@david1234lee]

I have been studying English literature on the Ph.D. .level and listened to music from the east to the west and Lee is one of the few whose voice can shake my soul from time to time !

[@phuclevan5771]

David Lee good learns. Dv Lee understand chinese culture.

[@user-tu2zz5xi1k]

生、旦、凈名角搭配，美滿完整的一齣好戲，傳頌千。昔日的王不見王，也只有在義務戲上看到同臺盛況。臺上的美聲競賽，乃觀眾之福！

[@beeBee-ug6qh]

👍👌👏❤️

[@user-sf7qr5je5y]

强强出阵，珠联璧合！

[@jjfy]

這三個搭檔珠聯璧合

[@david1234lee]

So we have two versions here for Second To Palace by Wang and Lee and by Yu and Lee Shen suh, the latter of whom, in China's modern opera world, have been considered as "institutions", the heir apparent to the Mei school. This one is a recent performance as Shen-suh seems to lose some of her tenderness of voice but still phenomenal! They are all great! But Lee yen has caught my heart on her mannerism and Wang's performance was lso up par.Over all they are both national treasures! Thanks!

[@jienyuan5935]

d ，们，们们 妈妈

[@user-vb1uu1qv4l]

david lee

[@brianwilliams9235]

Which "Wang and Lee"?

[@ccchang-mm2jw]

杜彥澐 鄧

[@ccchang-mm2jw]

鄧麗君唱探情郎

[@phuclevan5771]

David let's talks about this opera (" Two men into the Hall") - please.

[@jessicadakotah179]

我的三个偶像的视听盛宴！ 杨公子是李宏图么？看着也眼熟

[@david1234lee]

If you understand Lee shen-suh's life, then you know that nobody can present this sense of melancholy, anxiety, confusion and isolation than she can in China. But it takes very sympathetic ears ad skill tp perceive and interpret! She is my heroine!

[@aihelulu2168]

david lee 三娘教子

[@Taikai5284]

三人行👍👍👍！好听💐

[@david1234lee]

@@Taikai5284 Thanks ! I love this opera very deeply. It is nice to listen to, indeed ! There was the choice for the queen between her father and her son !

[@joeysun4]

@david1234lee cheers!

[@fuguoliang5450]

😊

[@david1234lee]

@joeysun4 Thanks! Keep up the good work!

[@eekoontan6387]

david lee

[@david1234lee]

The second I have watched from Li Shen-suh. Time does not forget to leave her marks on all of us! Good luck to Li, the heir apparent to the Mei school

[@user-ok5yo2di2m]

😎😂😁☺

[@harbinsleo]

孟广禄嗓子干，越到高音儿越干

[@zhongkuilu9182]

听过耿其昌李维康邓沐纬的二进宫，再听这三位唱的，差得太多，兑水太多，不过瘾

[@bobfeng254]

流派不同而已

[@yuchinglo5192]

比較喜歡 “李维康，耿其昌，鄧沐偉” 的版本，好聽。

[@jessieli2308]

明显不如李维康那三位唱的好

[@WuxiGuo]

最难的是生旦净总体都完美，至今最好的应该还是张君秋，裘盛戎，谭富英版。给人感觉，他们每人都只用了自己80%的嗓子，听众听了只有美的享受，特别是张氏的演唱。

[@brianwilliams9235]

这三位比张裘谭版（简称zqt版吧，手指太懒:))高一个调（一个全音）。论嗓音： 1.老生：谭老板声音穿透力极强，味道浓厚纯正，鼻音稍重，显得很有特色。于魁智属杨派，嗓音确好得出奇，特别是音准之稳尤其突出，可以说这里并不输于谭老板。 2.青衣：张君秋嗓音之美实在是奇迹--丰厚圆润，即使在那时的原始录音技术下仍然好听。李胜素高音很好，但是略显单薄，美感恐怕略输一筹。 3.花脸：感觉裘老录音时也许年龄太大了，不是巅峰时期（谭老板恐怕一样），嗓音已经没有铡美案赤桑镇里面那样震撼了。孟广禄作为徒孙还是对得起师祖的。单比这出戏，孟略胜一筹。 个人感受。

[@user-rv6dl7yz8k]

氐

[@user-mj1li9lf8d]

这位朋友，千万不要乱说啊，于魁智怎么能跟谭先生比啊，俩人都有嗓子，可是你不觉得于在唱歌么？

[@xyu101]

@@user-mj1li9lf8d 不同流派，不好比较。

[@user-yt6bi1lk9z]

只能说一个时代有其代表性.当年在清宮演这出二进宫是：谭鑫培.陳德霖.裘桂仙.三位宗师呀.你能拿來比吗？再早还有程长庚.胡喜禄.何桂山的原始版呢。所以一代归一代.俱皆当时的顶峰组合演绎这出唯一的生旦净对唱名剧！

[@pengzhang7007]

于魁智要是和李胜素结婚多好啊，天天搂着唱24小时

[@stanleychiu8189]

You would not know even if they are already doing that!!!

[@user-yj5fj9mi9g]

只要有李勝素跟于魁智在場的戲一定好。

[@jen157400]

讓戲劇文化根紮千秋後代---- 如果能有背景介紹---豈不更好!

[@chengmr]

清狗和漢奸最喜歡的大戲！哈！哈！

[@rasyidpamuji7219]

ching cheng hanji?

[@dnranjit]

Is this Peking opera ? Very artistic and mesmerising...is it based on some story..there is a similar art form called Kathakali in South India.

[@phuclevan5771]

Ranjit Neelakandan I am not agree you. This story is from history of China.

[@jessicadakotah179]

Phúc Lê Văn I think he’s talking about the art form, not story this piece was based on.

[@jessicadakotah179]

This is Peking opera and all faces are hand painted. Maybe Chuan Opera (from Sichuan) would be closer to the art form you’re referring to? There’s a lot more emphasis on dancing and lots of masks :) Peking opera has four main elements and dance is only one of them, and characters with heavily painted faces is only one of the four main roles (three featured in this skit). Either way I’ve always found Indian dance extremely expressive and effective in narrating stories. I have lots of friends from South India and have been to a few dance graduation recitals.

[@XW3126]

Yes, the play is based on historical story. Baby emperor is in danger to be deprived power by his grandfather (mother side). Emperor’s mother begs two cabinet members (secretary of defense and chairman of chief of staffs) to kill her own father to save his son’s fate. Full of drama, twist and turns. Very beautiful poetic classic Chinese lyrics with references to historical events. Peking Opera is considered the highest art form of Chinese opera. The fan base are generally highly educated. There are many local operas in every region. Those are considered ‘provincial’ opera because provincial operas lack the sophistication in every aspect from lyrics, melodies, costumes, different role cast specialties.

[@peggydai4033]

A

[@spaceduster5494]

what

[@david1234lee]

Therefore, being good involves not absolute "good" but a large percentage of it in the mix-up. Such perception was only realized in the west in the 20th century in Nathniel Hawthorne's "Scarlet Letter" or Meville's "Moby Dick". The Chinese thinking has become the westerns' mainstream now. Yes, they have learned from us in the culture's deep-core transformation but few realize that unless they have studied the evoltion of consciousness in the west and east.Chinese opera is way way ahead! (2)

[@jessicadakotah179]

I don’t think there’s necessarily one art form that is better than another, but agree with the parallelism that exists

[@david1234lee]

@@jessicadakotah179 But there is a difference between genius and pretender !

[@jimmybai9866]

白蛇传

[@david1234lee]

Then again westerners have learned from Chinese culture and civilization! The Christianity heritage basically involves in good-evil polarities which do not compmise. Western thought has followed this mainstream. Please notice, for example, in Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice, Darcy can not move away from "pride". Chinese culture has stressed reconciliation of polarities, Yin versus Yang, where realities exist in a complex form of co-existence, also representing the modern physics atom theorem.

[@david1234lee]

Friends, this is our national tresure and I hope we can all cultivate ourselves into an understanding and appreciation of Chinese opera. There is no opera in the world that can match Chinese opera in term of sophistication and complication and in the field of artistic ramfications, the use of melody, metaphors, similes, comparisons and contrasts exceed Shakespeare by far!

[@helenwang6641]

8a

[@yiexiaosan]

No

[@yiexiaosan]

CFC

[@user-ov5dn6tt7e]

于魁智唱腔不怎么样！

[@jessicadakotah179]

你行你上☺️

[@mingyingzeng9127]

冫一冻憾一一一一一↗:::{′

[@user-un3sd8fm8p]

请用中文！

[@poir345]

故步自封

[@shuxinli6808]

你只会说英语，那自是听不懂中文了。何苦说这许多？

[@456qsn4]

李炳淑，李维康，李胜素，无论哪位女性都比梅氏唱得好，扮像和表演更是梅氏无法可比的。梅氏最恶心。

[@ax857113]

李胜素就是梅派，师父是梅葆玖。

[@456qsn4]

@@ax857113现代京剧《智取威虎山》,《海港》, 《 杜鹃山》等的唱腔都是于会泳创作设计的，达到了中国京剧的最高艺术水平，但于会泳本人并不会在台上演唱。

[@456qsn4]

@@ax857113 杨春霞在《 杜鹃山》中的成功也完全是于会泳教出来的，但后来她在传统戏中却不怎么样。现代京剧与传统京剧的唱法有很大不同。但于会泳本人从来没上过舞台。

[@olivier828]

于京歌就是一杯饮之无味的白开水