जानिए कौन हैं चकमा और हाजोंग और क्यों हो रहा है इन्हें भारतीय नागरिकता देने पर विवाद

अरुणाचल प्रदेश में रह रहे चकमा और हाजोंग समुदाय और उन्हें भारतीय नागरिकता देने पर हो रहे विवाद के बारे में विस्तार से बता रही हैं द वायर की डिप्टी एडिटर संगीता बरुआ पिशारोती.

[@udhavdanajimangwani1326]

Since they are living in India for long period, they must be given citizenship.

[@pattamchakma3337]

Thank you for your kindness and support 🙏🙏🙏

[@jibokomiuli]

Yes, keep them in your home state You don't right to comment on behalf of arunachal i

[@manishmanish-wn3rd]

We can't make unrest in AP.... And we can't left chakma also... There should be another way to solve this issue...

[@SushilSimplicityCook]

Thank you sir for supporting us

[@laxmikantanayak7118]

Please for God Shake don't compare Chakmas with Rohingyans. Chakmas are genuine people's.

[@gebinkamki2613]

laxmikanta nayak genuine people...??

[@laxmikantanayak7118]

Gebin Kamki Genuine genuine means they are not terrorist. I bet you what ever situations or obstacles will come to their path they will not choose the path of extremism or terrorism.

[@ratansamirchakma8876]

Yes sir! Chakmas & Hajongs are legal migrants, India govt. brought them. But Rohingyans are illigal migrants in India.

[@wilson_itsme2534]

laxmikanta nayak

[@tumkadohu2078]

@@laxmikantanayak7118 bhai hame bhi zinda rehna Hai,

[@urmileshurmilesh2624]

Wonderful. Very informative.

[@suhikoina1]

Very good initiative taken by wire, there is hardly any channel showing the issues of other states. Thanks for the video

[@SushilSimplicityCook]

So many Chakma and Hajong want to do something great for our loving India

[@chohansotawsik8111]

Kuch v sida bholoh na... arunachal k... citizen ship kai liya dialogue faik raaha h

[@shamsansari2061]

Very informative... Thanks #wire team..

[@ArunKumarchakma-kx9sb]

Thank you madam good massage so many problems chakmas & hajong

[@jhunuchakma3383]

A lot of thanks to WIRE for informative and impertial statement.

[@siddharthkashyap4578]

Chakmas should get citizenship they belong to India not to Pakistan.

[@mlplayer7432]

Then take them all to ur state

[@user-zj8zx5jh6w]

Tum aapna home le jaakar rakh lo.Arunachal Pradesh indiginiouse people ke liye protected land hei.

[@manojjdash1901]

Thanks for a detail info on Chakma's & Hazong's.

[@SushilSimplicityCook]

If u go n see Chakma and Hajong people n children how painful life they are living

[@user-zj8zx5jh6w]

Dusra desh mei jeevan bitane se life painful hoga hii.. PRC/RPC toh lakh koshish koro,milnewala nehii hei.Isliye Chakma Hajong bhaiyon ko chahiye ki relocation ko Maan jaye.Arunschal Jan jati bhi madat korenge.Nahii manenge..toh unko refugee bankar rehte rehna podega.Khoon denge,lekin PRC nehii.

[@abdulraja1774]

Thank you mem Bato ko acche se smjhane k liye!!,

[@kesarisingh4273]

Sirf Hajong Tribes Hi Bangladesho se nahi aaye aur bhi kayi jaati hai Jo Bangladesho se aah pohche hai India mai, woh jaati hai Garo, Muslims, Bengali etc. Aur Garo Jaati bhi toh Bangladesho se aaye huye hai toh unko unke Jagaa ka naam bhi diya gaya West Garo Hills Meghalaya aur woh bhi India mai kyun, aur Garo aise jaati hai Jo Christian Beptist hai aur Hajong ko abhi bhi nahi mila apna jaga, unhe bhi toh thoda jaga milna chahiye, unke liye kuch bhi namo nishan nahi dekh paa rahe hai Hindu Ho ke bhi kuch nahi kar pa rahe hai, hamare khayal se unhe sirf nagrikta hi nahi unhe apna Jagaa bhi milna chahiye aur unka Minister bhi Jai Hind....

[@papputalukdar76]

U are rght they hav should gve rght too citizens both chakma and hajongs....not sepicaly garo, khasi n others parts of states

[@gandhijoychakma8972]

Thanks you so much for analysing about chaikmas n Hajongs mam..

[@pritamdada9224]

informationk liye thank u

[@1234jally]

Well explained

[@shakirhussain3650]

Great analysis

[@lalbabukhankhan1105]

कब ये सरहद और जाति धर्म का वायरस खत्म होगा।कब ये मानव स्वयं मानव कहलाने योग्य होगे

[@uffykun2317]

Thanks for the video Nice thought Government should think about it seriously

[@bhok2967]

Very nice information

[@albatross5508]

Thank you so much for analysing about Chakma’s and hajong with finely..

[@pattamchakma3337]

Ration nahi milta hai madam itna maharbani bolo maat bohut kotinahi samna pada madam main mera education Mumbai si kiya...hum log bohut kottnahi samba par raha hai etna sal hoo gya abi tak hum log stand ho raha hai koi janjati stand nahi ho sakta hai jo hum log stand ho gye aur asa karta hu aap mera duk samaj main ayega mada I'm really appreciated your noble thought. Thank you for your kindness 😭

[@indranilmaity7082]

you are basically Bharatiya, part of Bharat. You are welcome in Bharat , welcome in Rajasthan.

[@mogedini]

Thanks mem, for beautifully and elaborately describing the refugee issues. its a emotional and sentimental issue for the people of A.P.

[@ravidhyani3074]

You explain very well

[@lakhichakmainarunachalprad6258]

I like it's details explain very good....

[@BC87308]

Very nice said..the truth is never hide..

[@arupahajong9095]

Yeh dharti sabka hai kisinevi kandhe pe uthake nahi leke Aya hai madam ji and

[@susantachakma8521]

Perhaps you do not know that the Chakmas are Indigenous people of India. The Chakmas have been living in Assam, Mizoram and Tripura since time immemorial. Please check the Census of India.

[@mlplayer7432]

Lol

[@ravidhyani3074]

You are wrong

[@alokkumar-kd8vk]

Yes they want to become part of India during partition, and they also hoisted flag of India on the day of Independence

[@shivachakma7768]

Bilkul jhut, ration card nahi Diya gaya

[@prahladsingh730]

thanks

[@ravidhyani3074]

India ko Chittagong hill tract le lena cahiye. Kissa khatam

[@gz3096]

👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼🇮🇳 sahi bola bhai

[@alokkumar-kd8vk]

Yes but it falls in sylhet district, and India lost it in referendum

[@imritebelievme7258]

@@alokkumar-kd8vk Nehru traded with Calcutta. Unfortunately chakmas suffered for that.

[@sunilkokrady9063]

I wonder why this man was ever given Bharat Ratna when he has not solved even a Single problem of the Nation ? During partition more than millions of Hindus came to India practically every one was given citizenship by govt. Why these people were not given permanent shelter when that part of the country was uninhabited as per your report? His lethargy agais n comes back when he lid foundation stone of Sardar Sarovar Dam and left in Limbo Why could have even changed the name of project after some of his lovers instead of leaving population of three states in penury for next 56 years.

[@anandxegha2555]

A truth ...no chakmas gets ration card ....but most of the things are absolutely right

[@judishchakma630]

We r not getting any job ,in arunachal pradesh we r survive our life lot facing ,state government, no single chakmas and hajongs intire Arunachal pradesh state no one got job madam,

[@pratikshares]

Extremely important news. Could have been explained more accessible way.

[@shyamalchakma8869]

Thank you mam for making this you are requested to make some more videos about chakma tribe how they are struggling in AP for the long time what are the main problems in ground level.its very unfortunate to after supreme Court judgement state government not giving their rights.where is sab ka sat sab ka vikash.,..,..

[@chohansotawsik8111]

Etna hi struggling krr rahai ohh toh permanent solution diya tum lohgoh..koh ki alak place ship.kiya..jaiga..magar..nhi..tumlok.koh..bass..arunachal.hi..baitna.h..this..is..proctected..land..you.............must..know...since..19..century

[@SushilSimplicityCook]

Mam need you all help to raise questions for Chakma and Hajong n why not giving citizenship are we not human beings to get help from our government Thank you mam for this information

[@dilipkumarhajong5042]

The Chakma & Hajongs suffering since Partition of India ! Now let them stay peacefully in AP. Re-location is not acceptable at any cost. . . Pse let them stay peacefully. . .

[@apnadesh3768]

Yh it's true

[@syd502]

The reporters accent is so cute.

[@JaSa__]

Make a video about the demographic change in Assam and Assam Accord....Let d rest of india know abou it....

[@judishchakma630]

Madam ,nothing got government side ,please clarify that, we r facing a lots Arunachal government not given single ration card ,please visit chakma and hsjong villages then you will be kw what is correct,

[@ajajulalikhan3746]

thank you mam.unique lecturer.regards.

[@19Kumar158]

Reason kart pahala rason milta tha but Manymam 24 years ho Gaya rason kart ban ho ka madam

[@jagdishckz1136]

Mam we don't get Ration card..in Arunachal pradesh

[@learningpoint2580]

madam a video be published on the plight of kashmiri pundits.

[@taringnigpo6267]

Madam chakma or hajung ko Arunachal Pradesh me in case citizenship deta bi ho to hm Arunachalee kha me betega. Ese bi Arunachal bhut chota jaga hai.

[@papputalukdar76]

Go too China

[@gandhijoychakma8972]

I would like to ractify ur analysis ,State govt do not provide ration to the chakmas n Hajongs..

[@SushilSimplicityCook]

There is no any health care center no proper education after writing rights exams also they are fail why because people of Arunachal Pradesh not supporting even pass also they are making fail in the mid way.

[@jakirsayyed9712]

chakma per itni maharbani kyon

[@ravindrathakkar1234]

They are in India for since 1960s i.e. for 57 years. You can't send them back. What should be done keep them stateless and without any rights etc. ? Even the Rohingyas who have entered India will one day have to be granted citizenship, you can't just push them back. Even the deportation attempt by India will never succeed as Myanmar will never accept them.

[@vijayupadhaya8029]

because they are Buddhist

[@SushilSimplicityCook]

Those who are doing unjust they will never go to heaven n not get peace in their house though they have money etc Do u all think that you will live forever in this world so if you don't live forever in this world why should u claiming that this your property as a human beings should understand n think deep down people and government

[@SushilSimplicityCook]

So in this situation no party can't do unjust with the people specially to Chakma and Hajong jati

[@tganshu2955]

Bangladesh ka he

[@mdalipatel6474]

Vipul ji ,him kisi bhi charm ko gaali nahi dete to kyu aap yahi baat simple language me nahi bolte.logo ka dimag divert kar ne ke liye yah mudda uthaya he.

[@subinoysbc]

Kiya baat Kar rahi ha ration card, health care, education, basic right, etc bala bala Realty yei ha brith certificate tak nahi milta ha...chakmas and hajongs are most poor tribes among all Arunachal tribes so they need govt help especially from centre because state govt is not giving any rights, all educated youngs are working either in bpo or daily labours, because all political parties are their people Kiren babu and all.

[@subinoysbc]

This comment showing their reality...lets us grow or if you don't lets others grow.

[@getemmibang9808]

Ashish jat.....tujhe Kuch pata Nahi h to faltu na boley ....aruncahl tibet jese Nahi hai mind it .. ...padha Likha anpad

[@getemmibang9808]

@@ashishkalkal1079 ..sun Bhai China wallon Ka Kam h...Aapne aap ko Shi batana n..unka yhi toh Kam h dusroon Ka ...jegah harapna. .kuki unlogo Ka population bhut. Jada h.....n even tum khud Dekh skte ho...aruncahl ke log Kabhi bhi ...strike ,pattarwazi ..wagerahhh Nahi karte...Kashmir Ka halat dekhooon. Unme Kitna deshbakhti dikhti h. Wow log to Aapne army pe attack karte h. ...n..... Main to Bhai Kabhi khud ko bahar india Ka nhi mana...aur mujhe Garv h k...yha peda hua h ...sayad China main hota to Mera janam h nhi hota kuki main ...teesra beta hu.,🤣😃😃🤣🤣🤣😄😅😆 N wha 2 see Jada ...bacche nhi karskte proud to be Indian jai hind jai Bharat 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@ashishkalkal1079]

@@getemmibang9808 Thanks for information Bhai.....jai hind jai arunachal

[@ramlalgagrai8517]

Partition ke Karan yeh samsahya aaya hai.

[@juntammossang442]

0pp

[@mixvideosongs7821]

Sorry! Madam no state facilities chakmas & hajong are getting benefits like, ration card facilities, proper medical facilities, proper road facilities and proper school facilities..... If government can't solve this chakma hajong small community issue who leaved their country before mrs. Sonia gandhiji How government trying to solve to new comers issues of before 31/12/2014🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔???????????????????????

[@mixvideosongs7821]

If government can't able to solve the chakmas & hajong issues government should take back chittagong Hill track in Indian territory, then only possible chakma hajong issues will be solved out

[@atoratan5790]

If u have no detail knolegde don't talk.

[@mahlawat12]

Chai vala ab agar desh ko chalega to ye hi hoga. 😁

[@mahlawat12]

Nishant B. 😁. Exactly

[@akihitochakma6223]

Ration card nahi milta

[@yashasvisharma7641]

bharat ke darwaze her hindu ke liye khule hain. sab hindu rifugees ko indian citizanship milni chahiye. iske alawa sikhh buddh paarrsi bhi bharat ke hain iske alawa sab ghuspathye ko bharat se baher fank dena chahye.

[@santoshchakma6819]

Madam don't appreciate it to much Chakma didn't get resont card

[@taringnigpo6267]

Jab 1962 war me China ne hm Arunachalee ko pura jala diya ta o bi remote area ko jha jungle under bla ko leken India GOVT ne es chij ko kbi nhi deka ta kiunki . Bas Indian GOVT ne Arunachal Pradesh meti ko interest ta leken Arunachal admi ko nhi. Or eska bat hm Arunachal ko chain se banda hua ta..hm Arunachal kuch nhi kr nhi saka hai kiunki hmlog ko India govt ne apna pero ke niche me raka ta. Kiunki ous samai me na hmlog pas education ta na hm dusra dunya ko linking ta leken hm Arunachalee chilaya roya na koi sunne bla ta bas apna awaz apna pas me rhe gya hai. Eska ouper me chakma or hajung ko hmlog Arunachal me gusa dya or hmlog bohut sa julm krne dya hai or hmlog indigenous larki ko rape krna suru kr diya or murder ,human triffing; drug ,robbery ,es chij ko chakma log hmlog ka ouper me bhut sa kiya hai. Aj leken hmlog bardast ka bhar hai. Agar Indian onlog ko Arunachal me citizenship dyiga to hmlog badla lena suru kr deiga.

[@sarfarazahmed2878]

Ab aise logo ko desh chalane ka moqa diye hai to ye sab jhelna he hoga In logo ko bolna to bohat acha hai par kaam karna nhi Aur jinhe bolna nhi aata tha magar kaam karna aata tha

[@subhambhattacharjee4826]

Sarfaraz Ahmed acha nai toh kya tumhare illegal Bangladeshi immigrants bhaio ko citizenship de ? Waise hi saale tunhare pairokar bahar nikal kar kehte hai ki humare or unka Quran ek hai kaat dalenge hinduo ko. Hum Hindustani baad mai pehle musalman hai. 😂😂😂 sahi kia inko dekar. demography nai badalwani humne. ek Pakistan ban gaya kaafi hai wo 🙏

[@NirajKumar-nd6td]

musalman world ka kachara hai bahar nikalo

[@achintdubey505]

Apani Maa or bhan ka prichay de rahe ho SA

[@sarfarazahmed2878]

Dubey sale Jahil tumlog ho gao mutr pine wale bhagwat ka paida

[@ravindrathakkar1234]

Chakmas are in India for since 1960s i.e. for 57 years. You can't send them back. What should be done keep them stateless and without any rights etc. ? Even the Rohingyas who have entered India will one day have to be granted citizenship, you can't just push them back. Even the deportation attempt by India will never succeed as Myanmar will never accept them.

[@jaysivaram1037]

Assam ka borua Moran ahum taai lag v bangla deshi he brohmon ka hay arnachl ka barime mat sikhau medam arnachalme rahna wale assamis ko suport karke chokma hojongs lag v history gira k mat blo medam ap v bharat ka nahi borua v obc curty ficked hotai non tribel ko v cllasic obc hotay Assame sunuwal bodu dewri lag ST baki sab obc medam ap pehle barth janam huwa ya sansar janam huwa me v shingphu hay mera dada boda he ya ap budi ghodiya hay ka budi ladki hoki v baal kat tay hahahaha 🤣🤣😂😂😁 boor k bal v kata huwa hay kia medam?????

[@mdalipatel6474]

Chakma Buddhist he aur Bangladesh se aaya he to unhe Bangladesh bhejo.aur rohangee ko Burma bhejo.kashmere pandit ko kashmere bhejo.Tibetan ko China bhejo.Lenin waha saanti aane me baad.

[@ratansamirchakma8876]

Don't compare Chakmas to Rohigya, Chakmas are legal migrants, Rohigyas illigal migrants.

[@kamalteiya662]

Why chakma should go back

[@papputalukdar76]

Tab Muslim koh Pakistan bejo khw india mai bitaya hai

[@arslaanmeo7489]

Right bro..

[@gamjasingpho5348]

We beings a arunachalee,, we had never accept citizenship to chakma and hajong refugees.

[@adhichandrachakma4262]

lndia government Arunachale ko beite-beite pal rah hai layken Chakma n Hajong aapna kamai karke jirah hai.

[@WaheedKhanlive]

Hindi kamzor lag rahi hai

[@newbinaimitation3574]

sir sayed kamzor hai but kum sa kum paid news nahi ha. just like ZEE NEWS

[@WaheedKhanlive]

Right I agree with you

[@mdja19]

Samajh main aa rahi hai na fir kya problem hai. Mohtarma Assam se hain.. respect the Indian diversity.

[@samratkharvel5361]

ro ro ke mat bataye

[@vipulparmar560]

hindu virodh , hindu virodh , hindu virodh hi karna is the wire chenal ka kam he