J.S. Bach: "Tilge, Höchster, meine Sünden" BWV 1083 (nach Pergolesis Stabat Mater)

[@karstenbiastoch2606]

Ein Traum von Harmonie und Frieden...🌺🎻...Bach

[@ad-min]

Beeindruckend wie ein 26 jähriger geniale Pergolesi genialen Bach inspiriert hat.

[@ralphschrickel4695]

Gänsehaut Danke Euch für diese Momente

[@franciscojoseguerolablay4973]

El mejor reconocimiento y cordialidad de Bach a Pergolessi. La interpretación magnífica y con una valiosa coloratura de las cantantes y la simbiosis de la orquesta. Perfecto, me gusta vuestra versión. Enhorabuena👏👏👏

[@tiagomichel]

That church is really amazing

[@jkhalsa]

Lovely! Lovely church and great balance in the audio. I can hear every word you sing.

[@jean-yvesPrax]

C'est très beau, très belle interprétation, sobre et élégante, les deux voix sont magnifiques ; je suis un peu surpris que l'on ait attribué un BWV à cette oeuvre et de l'appellation "Bach, d'après Pergolèse" : le texte est changé certes, mais Bach n'était pas librettiste que je sache, en revanche la musique (je n'ai pas vérifié partition en main mais je reconnais chaque note de cette partition) me semble être à quasiment 100% du Pergolèse. Les seules différences par rapport aux autres me semblent être du registre de l'interprétation (instruments, tempi, pulsations). Peu importe, c'est beau et je suis content d'avoir découvert cette "curiosité" - merci.

[@Pouffecal]

Ces retards et ces frottements de secondes mineures ne pouvaient que plaire à Bach ! Il a du se dire: "ah, ça c'est pour moi, ça !!!"

[@jean-yvesPrax]

@@Pouffecal Haha, En effet, j'ai d'ailleurs le sentiment que JSB traitait la seconde mineure non pas comme une tension (avec attente de résolution), mais au contraire comme une caresse, une infinie tendresse, une plume qui frotte une joue. C'est manifeste dans la 2 partie (en ré majeur) de la chaconne en Ré mineur : après une série d'arpèges magnifiques et très apaisés (passage que Josha Bell qualifie de "rencontre (de la défunte, cad la première femme de JSB) avec un ange" ) JSB nous offre deux frottements de secondes mineures à pleurer de beauté (et j'enrage car ils sont presque impossibles à jouer correctement avec l'archiluth !!! lol)

[@armonicaorganodebocaysudif6407]

¿Pero por qué el Salmo 51 con música de Pergolesi? La historia dice que Bach la utilizó para esta parodia musical. Sería muy interesante la opinión de un experto.

[@francoisbloch7772]

Magnifique ! C'est superbe.

[@ЕвгенийСупрун-ь7ы]

Danke schon! Beautiful harmony!

[@ruthperon1587]

Vielen Dank für die schöne Musik!

[@gebhards.hopfmuller6505]

Musikalisch einfach wunderbar, keine andere Aufnahme auf KZbin kommt da hin! (Wie schön wäre es, wenn man die Sängerinnen auch noch verstehen könnte...)

[@isaacbenyehoyada1127]

יצירת מופת בביצוע מושלם ! זו היתה חוויה מרגשת !!!

[@Pitborn]

A masterpiece in a perfect performance! It was an exciting experience!

[@fitnessbrotherade2959]

Q asombrosa interpretación, y muy bien ecualizado con el ambiente de la iglesia

[@shin-i-chikozima]

This promotes spiritual uplift and awakening All of Bach's music is a great tranquilizer

[@isabellabatistaribeiro2308]

Uma maravilha! Muito obrigada!

[@rofufoja]

Wonderful performance! Thank you

[@francisfriedlanderou9376]

This is magnificent

[@divinelight777]

ただでさえ素晴らしい傑作の名曲が、バッハ編曲って所が最高に良い。しかもこの映像のアルト歌手がとても美人で可愛くて、尚とっても良い。如何せん但し肝心の歌唱の力量は、今一つ足りない。

[@Pitborn]

如何せん但し肝心の歌唱の力量は、今一つ足りない。What?? Are you serious?

[@СергейЧирков-щ6м]

Elvira Bill, Alt очень яркая артистка!

[@oldrichcepelka296]

The author is of course Pergolesi. In his 26 years, shortly before his death...

[@abdul-hadidadkhah1459]

There are some modifications to the bass made by Bach, hence why this is a parody.

[@mariocanfora9117]

​@@abdul-hadidadkhah1459It's not a parody, it's an homage

[@francescotrevisan4453]

​@@abdul-hadidadkhah1459 The definition of "Parody" is - an imitation of the style of a particular writer, artist, or genre with deliberate exaggeration for comic effect. - Stabat Mater by Pergolesi is a great piece of music that out or respect Bach wished to interpret.

[@martinvanheusden9832]

Herrlich!

[@danielwestra8127]

Very nice Covid-19 performance. Excellently done !!!

[@MatthewBluefox]

Elvira!

[@paulojorgecruz6768]

Bach hat keine Maske, außerdem ist die Leistung gut. 20:20, (kleine) Fuge, nicht genau in Pergolesi. Wie einige "Details" auf dem Basso continuo zuvor, "al gusto Bachs"

[@중선-l5k]

엘비라 빌 너무 예뻐요

[@danielquynhhoang1616]

😍

[@papamoto3369]

Todo increíble, pero no le pongáis mascarilla al padre de la Música.

[@HuaHinTakiap]

Thank you for an Inspired performance of this exceptional 'collaborative ' work. Sublime.

[@sylvainmagne158]

@ Papá Moto. Moi aussi je trouve cela pénible. On n'a pas le droit de manipuler l'image des défunts pour le rendre ridicules.

[@luckyluciano3287]

29 : 00 min ❤

[@이상호-y4v]

stabat mater....(^^)

[@kevmetala]

Bach with mask really??? by the way wonderful permormance Danke!

[@Aleksandr.Dmitriyevich]

Yes, quite irritating and irrational. Anyway, the performane is great.

[@tiagomichel]

9:07

[@PetrosiliusZwackelmann-oh1lj]

Was fällt Euch eigentlich ein, Bach mit Maske und umgeben von Viren darzustellen - und damit für dieses völlig evidenzfreie Narrativ zu mißbrauchen? Das ist wirklich respektlos! Schade um die gute Musik, die mit solch einer Bezugnahme verhunzt wird!

[@AndreVonKugland]

My dislike was because of the masked Bach.

[@korhonenmikko]

Wow, triggered much, snowflake?

[@rofufoja]

Masked Bach is quite humorous 😁

[@Olbemor_III_the_emperor]

This shows the inferiority of Bach respect to Pergolesi

[@abdul-hadidadkhah1459]

Not really, Bach was a better keyboard player than Pergolesi and his St Matthews Passion is by far superior to anything Pergolesi could write. Bach's guilty pleasure was Italian music.

[@Olbemor_III_the_emperor]

@@abdul-hadidadkhah1459 You don’t know Pergolesi’s music: Bach was great armonist and theorist, but his music lacks melody. The sensivity of Pergolesi make him better. St Mattews passion is a masterpiece, but can’t equal Salve Regina and Stabat Mater.

[@abdul-hadidadkhah1459]

​​@@Olbemor_III_the_emperor I do know Pergolesi, how presumtious of you to even suggest that. There are plenty of melodic Bach pieces, it just shows you have a very one dimensional perspective on what good melody is. Furthermore it is wholly subjective to say that just because you don't like Bach's melodies that his music is inferior. Also simply copying a piece of music doesn't suggest that his music is inferior either. Granted they are two different styles and eras of music, but that doesn't make either composer better. Bach has stood the test of time unlike Pergolesi who hasn't because his music has no relevance outside the classical era in which he essentially started, along with the other Neopolitan composers. The St Mat. Passion surpassed Stabat Mater and Salve Regina in that it put Bach back on the map in the 19th century and revived his name. The same can not be said of the Stabat Mater or Salve Regina.

[@Olbemor_III_the_emperor]

@@abdul-hadidadkhah1459Indeed I spoke about my personal opinion, but there are also facts that cannot be denied: almost every composer after Pergolesi agreed to consider him one of the best, or the best composer of all time: Pergolesi in 4 years changed an entire musical style, and his influence on vocal music was enormous: he inspired the intere classicist style; in France his music was worshipped by the most importants philosophers, and his Stabat is recognized as a masterpiece even now: Bach’s fame instead is recent: as you say, before 19th century he was forgotten, and however, if a composer is considered important now, it doesn’t mean that is superior to the others. Pergolesi deserve more relevance than Bach, and he will be reconsidered in the future. So, you can prefer Bach to Pergolesi, but doesn’t make it better. However, @leodepuydt308 could explain you the question better than me

[@des4993]

@@Olbemor_III_the_emperor objectively wrong, but ok

[@mariocanfora9117]

Bach plagiarizing Pergolesi

[@ksseit1987]

Die Maske ist eine unglaubliche Frechheit!

[@barbarasakowitz]

Banned.Video