J.S. Bach: Two-Part Invention No. 13 in A minor │ Classical Piano Lesson #2

[@blankroyai]

If you can play it slow you can play it quickly haha love this vid thx!

[@Noone-gn7ov]

blankroyai I’m playing the first and sec line SUPER slow LMAoooo

[@paolofranzoni440]

it's not about how fast you can play it. Technically this piece is quite simple, the difficulty lies in the dynamic execution: play as it should be played.

[@pianohelper8873]

@@paolofranzoni440 I'm pretty sure what he said was a meme

[@anonymoususer2271]

LMFAO I love twoset

[@Sofia-un2hn]

Ling ling

[@uchigasaki]

I am freed from the uneasiness of my life only when I listen to music of Bach.

[@petrusmalk]

I love Bach's music so much! Is Bach's music sounds like the jazz from the baroque period.

[@dwagonyt]

Absolutely phenomenal job, I love Bach’s pieces, they are true demonstrations of art. He is the kind of the baroque period; hence the name baroque

[@astridpardew]

Thank you so very much for this. I particularly appreciate the fingering numbers as I do not have it on my own score. Fingering is crucial in such a piece.

[@nadiasativa]

Thank you sooo much! 😍

[@arthurlima4626]

Wow this is amazing. Congrats. You can make a video of Tchaikovsky. Dance of the litte swans plese? I need learn this song

[@alexandershaneyfelt4386]

For people who want sheet music, just google “invention 13 in a minor Bach”

[@blogleftbanker]

I am slowly working my way through the Inventions now and your videos are a big help. I started piano late in life and gave it up once, back before KZbin and the internet. Now I have the huge benefit of great teachers like this channel. Muchas gracias de España.

[@blogleftbanker]

So are the Sinfonias the logical next step after the 2 Part Inventions? I don't find them nearly as charming for some reason, but perhaps they are fun and instructive to play.

[@with_jelly_22]

I am learning a lot from this movie.Thank you for the good video.

[@yvesjeaurond4937]

@@blogleftbanker Transposing the inventions in different keys helps. Try some of the _Little Preludes_ (BWV 924-938).

[@alexpianoplayer15]

in fact the Play along version is the right tempo version (as it is a contemplative invention) and performance version is TOO fast

[@김은하-m2q]

2:17 3:17

[@RaptorT1V]

1 minute OMG

[@yvesjeaurond4937]

There's a typo in your score in bar 15: the top R.H. note is A natural (not A flat). This isn't a lesson? It's a demo (maybe)? Why mislead by calling it a lesson? (sigh) . As for hyperspeed à la Glenn Gould :-) check out Wim Winters' ideas on Cserny's suggested speeds.... Hope this helps.

[@jimtsitsos]

1:44 isnt it F sharp and not A?

[@thuriyaz4973]

right!! he had another mistake before that i was going nuts 😟

[@m0ment219]

Finally someone who follows the rules of Bach like the 'staccatos' or 'non-legatos' as some people call it. Nice job 👍

[@jasonyuan9085]

I'm not sure what score you're using, but the one I have doesn't have an A-flat in treble clef bar 15.

[@IvorPresents]

I have practiced this all my life and not once played it perfectly, not even close. I had no teachers to guide me. My bad fingering is already a habit. Now at last. a new approach. Maybe I can do it.after all.

[@Cookerab]

Love this, but on the slow version the last note lh of measure 9 should be an a and not a d correct?

[@wertherland]

This is one of my favorite inventions... but let me ask you something... what is the right way to play it? what speed? I've heard so many versions, the notes are so beautifully placed that I enjoy every finger stroke... but honestly... Gould has a recording that it totally ruins it, like light speed... makes look your "pushing the limit" as slow. I am a huge fan of Glen, but I hate what he did. The question is, how did Bach intended it to be played? can anyone answer this? Thank you!

[@v.duskren8819]

I, personally, prefer slower tempos.

[@agusallende3753]

I would say follow your heart? Don’t go too slow or too fast, and try to somehow respect the time that is written in the score. Also, always try to respect the dynamics, staccatos etc. One thing that my teacher taught me is to not mark the staccatos a lot in bach music, cause us was not made for piano and the staccatos weren’t that “strong”. Just play how you feel you should play

[@yvesjeaurond4937]

See Andras Schiff and/or Wim Winters talk about "tempo ordinario" during Bach's time.

[@pietro3948]

Very nice ! A goldberg' variation tutorial would be great too

[@pietro3948]

Merci beaucoup !

[@kieuthanhpham3855]

AMAZING 🤩

[@beth-wf5ld]

İ want to notes

[@thewalks3]

I made my own version of this piece with an orchestra if your intrested

[@lavens7062]

I want see

[@baduk5707]

ME: Bach, what your strong hand? right or left? BACH: yes

[@chryssasagopoulou5015]

HAHAHAHHA I LOVE THIS

[@marcmeyssonnier5568]

C'est magnifique et d'une modernité incroyable ! On pourrait croire que cela a été composé hier matin !

[@ARGON023]

Thank you, Thank you for this recording. Best Regards

[@tomarmstrong1281]

The slow tempo sounded more musically attractive and receptive to dynamic nuances than the faster tempo version.

[@pattheisen1788]

In the 10th measure you play a D and not an A and in the next measure you use finger 4 and not 3. which is it 1

[@cormacmcgale7139]

Fingering is usually just a guide and is open to interpretation

[@not2tees]

This particular 2-parter is a gem amongst gems!!

[@franckranaivo666]

💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦🌿🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦🌿🇻🇦💞💐🧖‍♂️🐇💐🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💞🇻🇦💮💒💮⛑🇻🇦✝️🇻🇦⛑🌿💞

[@jazzmine9673]

Too fast😓

[@simonpeberdy]

In case anyone's interested in music for 2 pianos... I've just completed writing arrangements of all of Bach's 2 part inventions. One piano part remains as Bach's original, whilst the other plays a new additional piano part. Available via my website: www.simonpeberdymusic.com

[@口天自由人]

Brilliant It helped me a lot

[@F4sT]

Where is the lesson?

[@똥꼬발랄지우개]

덕분에 보고 잘 익혀갑니다~ 항상 피아노 소리가 예쁜 것 같아요.

[@StephenFasseroMusic]

Really nice man!

[@pierreduchene-marullaz8463]

Wunderbar mein Hern ,ici bin gluglich wenn ich hore hieren musik

[@lijunfu4053]

Congratulations. You have found and seek me. The secret commenter...have a great day and Jesus bless you

[@Tommy-fd2rs]

I have to ask what bpm is the performance version

[@tincho827]

107 i think

[@kinguniteds8469]

Love this thx

[@inabruesuig]

Bar 15 RH the A is natural

[@maranocna369]

That is really helpful!

[@juanatarazzona1873]

Gracias por compartir tus enseñanzas estoy justo en esta pieza

[@pattheisen1788]

In the 10th measure you play a D and not A and also in the next measure you use finger 4 and not 3. which is it

[@pattheisen1788]

eric shaw Back at you

[@pietro3948]

( I have the sheet music if you want 😁 )

[@ricardodofunil]

coul you send to me please [e-mail]

[@petrusmalk]

Send to me, please: [e-mail]

[@camillanilsen9854]

can you send to me too! my Email is [e-mail]

[@Pakorro68]

Bonjour Pierre: Will you be so kind to send me the sheet music please. Thank u. My e-mail is: [e-mail]

[@hanoveroro9233]

Espectacular.

[@РусланУтйук]

chopin polonaise opus40 1 please

[@sebastiansanchez2001]

Where is the voice direction?...

[@MezasRealm]

no trills ....!!!?????'

[@klopidac]

Is metronome

[@vfx7t]

i have not problem with note , i hope one day will arrive to read a partition because , i can not arrive to remember music thank's

[@Sofia-dy2ld]

Hola!! Tengo entendido que en el compás 12 (si es que conté bien xd ) Donde está marcado un B, ese 'sol sol - sol'midomi, ese sol ligado a la semicorchea se tiene que cortar antes del midomi, no se liga!! eso

[@rinaldisign]

This piece harder than chopin fantaisie impromtu.

[@nicobuet3792]

gracias!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@12345Spiffy]

So cool

[@yanyingluo8064]

Ama zing

[@derekarsenault1046]

that was awesome

[@душабомжа]

Too damn fast.

[@美股向前看-v7i]

You’re wrong it’s so slow

[@pianoforte17xx48]

Then you should hear Glenn Gould.

[@fishmoon5155]

0:31

[@viniciusvasconcelos.m5348]

Sinphoy mozart

[@williamsackelariou1860]

Listen to the Harmony NOT the metronome otherwise you will end up delivering clueless unmusical rubbish like this