ROGAN JOSH | Naseeruddin Shah | Short Film Reaction!

[@1702deepak]

Rewatching this videos gives entirely different feeling. For example: Nas- "I am not a coward , I mean I was not a coward".

[@qwerty11222]

And also when the son was talking about his wife, he said it’s ok coz she has someone else at her office who takes good care of her and his son also needs a father.

[@tattaiyyabhattacharjee4308]

The clock wasn't working in the beginning. In the end they showed it working. It gives you the idea in the beginning itself

[@joshua_deepak]

idea of what? that clocks dont work when ghosts are around? yeah, well we didn't read the 'ghostly' laws of physics

[@tattaiyyabhattacharjee4308]

@@joshua_deepak I don't happen to know the ghostly laws of physics, and I feel that since they died in TAJ, their ghosts would be somewhere around there. It was just their souls who got freezed in that moment hence the clock.

[@joshua_deepak]

@@tattaiyyabhattacharjee4308 I'm assuming by 'moment' you mean a time point, of zero time duration, because otherwise the clock should move. But at the end I can see the ghosts looking at the lady who was walking from the door to kitchen to dining table doing her things which clearly isn't one 'time-point' but a finite duration of time period. So, how do you explain this? Did they loose their powers on the clock? Did they have their powers on the clock? Did they do this on purpose? Do they always do that to clocks? why clocks? Why not a stove? Oh no, they have to eat human food, so leave the last one. I'm not saying it has a meaning, just don't find explanations for ghostly acts. It's just a good plot overall, that's it.

[@vimalahospital7698]

@@joshua_deepak it was a loose connection with the battery

[@RANJEETKUMAR-yg1qw]

Nice observation

[@underdog4412]

13:55 Jaby: Oh they all died? I'm confused Achara: Just watch. Jaby: okay 🤣

[@A-G-23]

This reminds me of the Narang family who lost their life in the 26/11 attack at the Taj. They were celebrating a birthday and only the daughter and daughter-in-law survived.

[@myrcellabanelightwood9773]

It is based on them

[@gauravmishra8561]

we Indians are lucky,good content is basically free for us from tvf to youtube. we are nailing drama genre but dint have budget for science fiction. hopefully in the future we can also try science fiction.

[@gauravmishra8561]

@Mein Apna Naam Nahi Batunga very high risk. Cinema Audience also not mature enough.

[@gauravmishra8561]

Bhavesh joshi and tumbaad tried par koi dekhne nai gaya, kisi ko reality nai dekhni. Total dhamaal type sab dekhne jaate

[@gauravmishra8561]

@Mein Apna Naam Nahi Batunga i am not talking about online audience i am talking about cinema going audience and they are not matured yet otherwise tumbaad and bhavesh joshi would be hit or average but they didn't recovered 20% of their investment

[@shubham4038]

Filmfare best short film award winner - Rogan Josh..

[@abhishekchandel8896]

Wow.

[@AliShah-yw4xp]

But wasn't it bhuvan bam's short story?

[@halovee.n]

I always love when Achara's reacting with Jaby!

[@gurtej5821]

I am impressed that you predicted Mumbai attack reference in advance. It shows how sincerely you are knowing about India, as compared to other foreign youtubers

[@mohit0953]

Its a shame that best stuffs of 80s and 90s haven't an English subtitles and no trailers, Like the old classic movies of 'naseruddin shah' when he was young and many more great actors, There was some bunch of people like director "shyam banegal" who made so many great classical films in his days and naseruddin shah was one of his jems

[@bambi274]

I found a lot with english subtitles

[@weirdverma]

Some fans can try to cut interesting trailers

[@mithunpv662]

Did anyone noticed Max's expression after @20:30 , something came to her mind. Maybe something related to car accident . Someone close to her...🤔 she almost cried 😭

[@hemanshubangera5121]

Even I noticed it.

[@zarinsubah6049]

Yesss! I noticed also! And came to comment section to check if anyone else noticed it or not.

[@nickfoory5662]

Thats when you ejacualated.

[@AshishKumar-eg8dt]

Maybe she was just rolling her eyes....just pointing the fact that it was obvious what jaby was saying was correct

[@ananyabhagat7052]

It's based on the 26/11 Taj hotel terrorist attacks and when I realized that while watching the video , I broke down , because i still remember the day when as a child i was sitting in front of the TV seeing all the videos from the attacked location and I started to cry after listening to ppl scream and seeing the graphics , my mom had to switch of the TV to make stop crying. If me as a person sitting miles away from the actual location felt it , I can't even imagine what the people who experienced and saw it up close would've gone through.

[@I_m_4m4n]

I dont know why but in the beginning achara looked little sad or maybe pissed, I may be totally wrong but I noticed that. Stay blessed Achara.I hope you are okay. God bless you all.

[@jimban3573]

She feel insecure around the other girl and jaby continuously flirting with max

[@jimban3573]

The Great Gatsby hahaha

[@chipmunkishungry5237]

​@@jimban3573 delusional

[@prandeeptamuli4013]

The last "two minutes" is actually the most important part of the film. Importance of time taught in an interesting way.

[@RohitKumar-ot3nl]

Jaby if you notice this, Please react to Kota Factory by TVF. It's one of the best show i have seen in 2019. I am sure you will love it.

[@gaurav6398]

Ha free ka maal hey loot lo....

[@RohitKumar-ot3nl]

@@gaurav6398 Jiske ghar mein raashan nahi hota, woh dusro ke khaane mein mooh maarta hai.😂

[@deepanshukaulphilip5676]

@@RohitKumar-ot3nl TVF hasn't allowed it presently. They will do it later

[@RohitKumar-ot3nl]

@@deepanshukaulphilip5676 I hope they will allow that because i can't wait to watch their reaction on that show.

[@deepanshukaulphilip5676]

@@RohitKumar-ot3nl they have provided it free right now so they didn't want the views and revenue to be diverted to reaction videos. Some people watch stuff directly here that hurts the business. I am sure they ll allow it after some time. Hahaha good keep up the enthusiasm

[@milindkhamkar]

This plot is so beautiful ❤. It is one of the best short film on 26/11 tragic attack with full 180° twist at the end moments. Also try to react TVF's Kota Factory if there is no permission issues.

[@aruntyor1267]

Max you are stunning, but our Achara is the best :-)

[@SM-hp3et]

True buddy 😁

[@RANJEETKUMAR-yg1qw]

Always achara

[@qpratan]

Those who disliked this video are innocent, jaby, achaara and max you dont know but this video is very special. It not only represents Taj hotels point of view but it also represents 19crore Mumbai people's views. It gives us goosebumps and sorrow. May God bless the living and take the passed on.

[@mohit0953]

Nothing much left to suggest you guys because you already seen most of them 🙄 😅

[@drvmlk]

Please pass a tissue to Max, you guys. I noticed tears welled up in her eyes while Jaby was mentioning his near death experience. Take care.

[@copycat9176]

Max is recalling something happened in the past I can c she is little uncomfortable that clearly shows in her eyes

[@JacknJill2245]

Yeah, I also noticed that.

[@chiragsharma2902]

she is a fking android wht do you expect from her?

[@deepanshukaulphilip5676]

I had suggested and you did react. Thanks for the thoughtfulness

[@baruntudu5908]

Max and her eyes.... the eye balls grabbing moment of this video. Just pure "REACTIONS".

[@tripleh9935055338]

Max went from review to upset for a while. 1 more thing is that Max can talk with her eyes! Once you look at Max and it becomes really sad when the video ends. Her voice and the way she talks is WOW

[@sadiaraveendran8070]

You HAVE to watch Monsoon Wedding... arguably Naseeruddin Shah’s best and most understated performance yet

[@writetokawal]

Jaby if you have noticed.....at 1:17 the clock had stopped.....at 16:26 the clock goes tik tok tik tok.

[@roshanj18]

Thanks Jaby for Max 😊. You and Achara always rocks

[@phoenix4918]

I have watched all the short movies before but I am watching it again just to see their reaction. 😊💜

[@arkoutsav]

Yay! Max is here.

[@ayushsharma6582]

OMG got stunned thanks jaby for showing me this.

[@starfish0607]

Watch jaane bhi do yaaron! You did a reaction to the trailer I think. It's an old naseeruddin shah movie. Quite a different role than you've seen him in. Also stars pankaj kapoor.It's a classic It's a comedy with elements of a murder mystery

[@cargamer831]

React on nawazuddin siddiqui salt n pepper short film available on youtube

[@prasads2571]

Right

[@sanjitnarayanganguly.5601]

Of course there were the sounds..just not the ones we usually look out for.The whistling of the pressure cooker, the ticking of the clock at the end, the beeping of the microwave, the clinking of the cutlery against the plates..were all very interesting use of sound leading up to the climax and highlighting and engaging us through the conversation.The filming of the conversation would have been totally bland without those little sounds.But again the very absence of using sound as in music, is a very powerful tool in the art of film making as is beautifully portrayed in this short film.

[@dushyantchauhan1197]

Max reeves is really smart! She is intelligent. Good observation. 👍

[@ashrafsongal]

I like the way Max Reeves reaction. Amazing. Please include her in more videos.

[@nashdasmurayan1975]

Max got uncomfortable when jaby talked about the car accident. She was remembering something.

[@manishmishraji]

Showing credits prematurely delays the gratification of the reveal... You like the pay off more when the tension is held on a bit longer.

[@meetdomadiya4537]

Hey max. Is here .. man she's so cute 😊😊😊😊

[@CA_Harshith]

Kota factory is so beautiful... Jaby you need to see it on TVF

[@Suiiiii05]

Hey..Max I missed you🤗.

[@rahulkapur687]

What a beautifully crafted film. Max, please don't go to 🇮🇳... you'll break innocent hearts left, right and center🌶️... sea green would look great on you🕉️... Brilliant reactions! Emotional jazz🙏

[@nikxbharali1999]

Another great subtle thing I liked about this film which I realized after watching this reaction is how we get so invested in the dialogues of their dysfunctional relationship thinking that is where the conflict is and that's going to drive the story, until we realize they're all dead, and none of that conflict matters to us any more. And it's so similar to when someone dies in real life; every problem, grudge and anger we held against that person, all start feeling null and void.

[@funboy8175]

13:56 "just watch" jaby got schooled by achara.....the plot will unfold....just hav patience jaby!!

[@ayushidixit5183]

Did nobody notice, in the end she mentions she had asked to switch off the lights! And when they came back they were on. The ghosts turned them on!

[@derickvishal]

Thanks achara and jaby for reaction

[@dianacourtney-smith9633]

Wow - that gave me goosebumps...

[@magic71202]

Rogan Josh is awesome Indian delicacy, you guys should try it some time if you are not vegan! 😉

[@sourabhmohre7209]

That brought back some bad memories for Max. Probably someone really close died an untimely death, probably in a violent encounter.

[@alokgahlot6972]

my eye goes in different directions now....at a time.... because right eye on max and left one on achara..... both are awsome..extra beauty with brains....

[@milestones5007]

what you didn't notice at the beginning of the movie is the clock was stopped but moving at the end shot.

[@gujjuboy1317]

max reeves look like a medison in the duff movie.

[@iridescent9667]

Max smiles you melt...

[@manojachilles3896]

This reaction was amazing. Really i dint understand until u guys explained it. I was thinking just as achara 🤨😐

[@anantsahu4313]

Yay.... Max Reeves 🤩🤩🤩😍😍😍

[@raveena9659]

Achara and Max seemed pissed off in the beginning of the video...was it just me or did someone else think the same too?

[@rituraj5714]

Achara knows everything

[@nalinpandey1128]

Yeah...that Rogan Josh is a dish!

[@prateektandon8747]

I got here to see Reev but now I feel wow to see such a connecting short story again.

[@mihirkambli6879]

Just finished watching your previous Desi Hoppers video!

[@arjunrj405]

Achara always amuses with her knowledge and simplicity about it. Does she know everything? Yet she is always silently sitting and smiling and speaks when she humbly corrects others, even Jaby. 😜

[@nakaptechi8846]

Love u Max-chan 😘

[@thetruthseeker6668]

Jaby when technicality overides your emotions then essence of natural enjoyment is lost. You were looking more closely at editing than story. Come on man, then u guys even did not look at the credits where there is dedication to victims of 26/11 at the end.

[@jabaranihembram9665]

beautiful max reeves

[@roopamenon4751]

Jaby Koay, do you know why they insert the credits in the climax scenes-to heighten the emotion for viewers not directly connected to the tragedy, to decrease or break the intensity of the tragedy for the ones directly connected to it and also to force the viewer to pay attention to what is being conveyed. As for the on the nose conversations seen in movies especially in the south is because people do talk about whatever is on their minds without holding it all in and letting the listener or audience know what they want or think without waiting for the figuring out bit especially if there isn't enough time to get the point across. Lovely reactions... I loved this n the film totally... It literally breaks ur heart into two or a zillion pieces as they get into the climax of the short film 🙏❤️😍💟

[@pubalipramanik2804]

I am so happy you reacted to it 😁😁😁

[@SN-oi4up]

They are not ghosts. They are memories of a dark day, still trying to make the best out of their suffering.

[@raghavsaurav788]

Love you MAX

[@rituraj5714]

Max reeves again 😍😍😍😍😍

[@mithaSantara]

Jaby you are precious for us. stay safe.

[@AshishKumar-eg8dt]

Am I only one who saw a drop of tear fall down from Max's eye at @20:47

[@Ankit_Rawat]

f amazing #nasirSir felt like a movie... still stunned

[@pratyush2194]

We Indians do not appreciate good cinema. This was JUST BRILLIANT and it is sad that I never heard of it before.

[@subarnakarmakar1429]

I was surprised after watching this short film... What a twist!

[@harshmehta3087]

9:45...Miss Reaves had some different ideas 😂😂😂

[@RaviShankar-pd3gy]

If you had watched that powerful performance unhindered.. as you said that credit distracted you... I think that much impact could have just demolished everyone.

[@SmartAachy]

MaxReeves impressive observation 👍🏼

[@sagniksarkar2894]

Jaby please react to Officers choice short film "Mukti" starring Milind Soman

[@HardeepSingh-ri7zs]

Finally max is back

[@AshishKumar-lr9vd]

Max Reeves💞

[@rexxbailey2764]

GODD MAX REEVES !!! LET ME COUNT THE WAYS I LOVE THEE !! .. OHHHHHHOHHH :D :P DONT LOOSE DAT SPARK U HAVE IN U EVEN WHEN U GET OLD MAX !! ITS REALLY HIGH TIME MAX DOES SOMETHING IN HOLLYWOOD !!! MAX REEVES SCREEN PRESENCE WAYY TOO HUGE FOR A SMALL SCREEN LIKE KZbin REALLY .. NO KIDDIN. :-I

[@soumyakanti17]

Rogan Josh is a north Indian lamb dish. Very rich and tasty.

[@Blessheed]

I'm here to see the genius side of Max...even though I have seen this video quite a few times, I still wonder why and how sad she looked towards the end of the video. Almost like she was just abt to break down.

[@Loneworksproductions]

Thank you for reacting to this.

[@abhishekchandel8896]

I'm not a fan of short films. But this is the best I've ever seen. I think you guys don't really know how terrible this attack was. You should react on a 26/11 attack video.

[@themistysparrow]

Max Reeves....❤️

[@coollifestyle.01]

beautifull eyes miss Reeves

[@ofloine]

I luv u Achara ❤😘

[@snayak2664]

Jaby love you Achara loveeeee you

[@mziaee]

Dear Jaby and gang. After this ‘feels’ film, and the common refrain that you aren’t able to review songs...if possible pls do a review of an old fantastic song (u may need to get captions), its called “woh hain zara, khafa khafa@ (He is a bit annoyed”...betting you will love it. Pls watch with Achara!

[@niravkapadiya7910]

She is very beautiful..

[@mananpatel5468]

Max Reeves is back.. ❤️

[@arjunningthoujam6611]

Max Reeves ❤❤❤

[@hemantsingh4277]

Achara ❤

[@harshmehta3087]

If you noticed in the 1st shot...the clock wasn't working or we can say..it was stopped where in the last shot..it's real time

[@dreamerachiever2718]

what do u guys have to say about DAVID HEADLY , an AMERICAN who was one of the masterminds of the 26/11 attacks who also happened to be a double FBI agent??

[@vivek27789]

He was a FBI informant not an agent.

[@dreamerachiever2718]

@@vivek27789 he was an agent plus an AMERICAN CITIZEN

[@vivek27789]

@@dreamerachiever2718 Bro when u say he was an agent that is wrong because officers of FBI are designated as special agents which Headley wasn't he was a informant to DEA and FBI which meant he provided information and in his case it was regarding international drug smuggling. CIA uses the word agent for its informants and undercover moles and its officers are called case officers or operations officer. While FBI and DEA uses the word informant for those who provide information or work undercover for them but are not employees or officers. Officers of FBI and DEA are called as special agents. And of course he was an American citizen.

[@backstabbers123]

Remind me of the movie 'Remember Me' which is such a great one if you haven't watched it.

[@sachindevbumbum]

I was literally waiting for you guys to react to this very Short Film. So, I'm guessing the film did hit you hard, right??

[@vampirehunter9303]

At 20:39, Max Reeves went emotional. Something must have happened which made her. like crying a bit.

[@manasioza98]

Watch "Afterglow". It's a short film. Very beautiful.

[@imdibu]

When you will watch ANURAG KASHYAP'S masterpiece "GULAL"

[@dumbduck4u349]

Dibyendu Ghosh I don’t think they will get the context of GULAL .. it’s a really intense movie .. but definitely they should , it’s a great movie ..

[@honestindian9795]

Brace Yourself, its max again, you know who is coming with another cheesy pick up line.

[@dhwanishingadia1093]

Uday 😂

[@skrillex4u]

@@dhwanishingadia1093 whoz uday

[@mohanabraham1178]

Your first time pronunciation of Indian names are always correct than the second and third attempt