JACLYN HILL'S MAKEUP - THEN VS NOW | PRO MUA REACTS

[@RobertWelsh]

Hey everyone! I’m so sorry about how loud the audio is I’m this video! I keep trying to get it perfect and missing it! Also thank you all for your feedback! 🖤🖤

[@alvina9693]

You're awesome robert!!! I've been watching a lot of your vids and learning more make up tips from you in order to improve my skills. Please dont stop what you're doing. Lots of love~

[@bluestarzy1767]

I am not correcting at all, but just to add what you wanted to say, and couldn't find the elusive word... I think you wanted to say was: disclaimer. BTW love your channel!

[@arialeblaisdell1082]

I bought eye primer because of you ❤️ thank you, it’s works soooooooooo great. So glad I found you and that you explain why we don’t use concealer on the eyelids. Perfect!!!!

[@alvina9693]

@@arialeblaisdell1082 same! I feel that eye primer makes my eye makeup less prone to smudges and less creasing. A bit of creasing is inevitable for me I guess because I almost have monolids

[@maxinewalters]

You talk about primers for oily skin being watery in texture, but can you please suggest some that are good? I am super oily and not happy with the silicone-y primer I use from Mac (supposedly designed for oily skin....)

[@Nursepractitionerd]

I really love how when you paused the video and her face was not in a good expression, you moved her video forward so it paused on a flattering pose. That is super gentlemanly.

[@Lidia_Es]

Meh not that big of deal

[@sarahanne4]

I was looking for a comment about that! I found that to be such a subtle but kind thing to do. In such an ugly world, I took notice of that.

[@mica8701]

@@Lidia_Es the point that its not a big deal is why people feel endeared by it. large performative acts of kindness and warmth dont feel genuine or real if the person doesnt actually consistently show that consideration in everyday actions.

[@margauxvirra]

I was gonna comment this if I didn’t find anyone praising him but I found you so I’ll just add to the thread I TOTALLY AGREE this is the first video I’ve watched of him and I’m already in love his so calm and doesn’t talk about product as if his life depended on it and it’s lovely ❤️❤️

[@isislee919]

he’s so nice omg

[@xSimranGuptax]

You know Robert is about to critique someone when you hear: “so here’s what I think about this! *rings clinking* “ 😂

[@RobertWelsh]

😂😂🖤

[@ewaszy5513]

Love that sound! 😀😀😂

[@andie5500]

Simran Gupta “so here’s the deal” * cling cling *

[@Similo]

Love the clinking.

[@destynejones3225]

I thought I was the only one that loves the rings clicking 🤣🤣🤣

[@jennacefalu7790]

I started DYING laughing when Jaclyn all of a sudden said, “now pack on that bronzer bitch!!” And Robert just went from🙂 to 😳

[@emt963]

I was looking for someone to comment this😂😂😂

[@masterpeacejr6180]

Me too 😂😂

[@annas4714]

His reactions are precious :)

[@rma8983]

Omg me tooooooo, I laughed so hard 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@farahali432]

I UGLY laughed when he said “no, I absolutely hate it”

[@kathrynwhitbeck9798]

Time stamp?

[@eeeeeeeeeeeeeelli]

Kathryn Whitbeck in the first minute lmao

[@gimletrose1985]

Same LOL

[@ceceliamurphy396]

Me too lol

[@Ms10yearsafter]

You're hair is just fine Robert! Actually doesn't look bad at all 🤗

[@PLuna-gf6sh]

Whoever changed the comment section needs to be fired, it’s so annoying lol

[@livcoombes3413]

Right !

[@angeltangle]

I think this everytime I use it now.

[@lettyt669]

This.

[@claritanox6695]

I like it...

[@simonetiplady5320]

Agreed!!!!

[@bigguisy]

You should follow an influencer’s makeup tutorial (excess product and all) but then turn the lights down !!! Show us the texture!!!!

[@jordiflower]

👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

[@KirstenRietveld]

Yessss

[@sharonw1474]

I think he did it once?

[@sharonw1474]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/l2jPl6N3hJqqr9U

[@pebblesandwoowoo]

Mmmmm cakey 🎂 with alllllll the layers 🤭

[@skinsciencebymira]

“Do I actually really like it?” “NO. I absolutely hate it.” Wasn’t expecting that at all 😂😂

[@ryath1030]

I died! Robert's dry humor is the best.

[@karennunez6915]

Thats me when i dye my hair and look at the mirror to see the result 😔👌

[@boldanabrasevic3020]

@@karennunez6915 Lmao I just died my hair a pinkish red and I hate it 😂😂

[@mdh9247]

Exactly what I was expecting. Lol.

[@samantharausch6842]

@@ryath1030 always have been my favorite type of humor! 👼🙆‍♀️✌💛

[@milanastanar9900]

When he paused the video in unflattering moment, he changed that. So wholesome

[@LCP_452]

I caught that too 💖💖 you can't help but love the guy.

[@TheNudeMaker]

We stan a classy prince ⭐️

[@ytamee5952]

Got that too! I smiled automatically when he did that 💜💜💜Robert is just pure class.

[@angelathompson2569]

A gentleman 💕

[@KichiUki]

Timestamp?

[@bemyaladdin]

I DIED at "let's go crazy, let's do a burgundy lip" 😂😂

[@youngmaraschino]

Same I just heard it and had to look for the comment hahaha

[@nour.m8205]

Today, I mindlessly blew on my eye shadow brush and immediately felt Robert glaring at me and heard the clinking of his rings. Anyways, I'm just here to apologize.

[@mela2939]

🤣🤣🤣

[@emmamcmahon1738]

Wait what’s wrong with blowing on your brush? Sorry I’m new to makeup and don’t really know much about this subject

[@nour.m8205]

@@emmamcmahon1738haha so basically we are not supposed to blow on brushes because and to quote Robert there are all kinds of bacteria that live in our mouths that might transfer to the brush and it's just not sanitary. The best thing to do is to tap it gently on something to shake off in any excess product. You know good habits and best practices :)

[@emmamcmahon1738]

Nour .M Ohhh ok that makes sense! Thank you for the explanation. I’m still learning about makeup and could use all the help I could get lol so this is really helpful. Hope you’re doing well rn stay safe:)

[@lunafranklin7815]

Did she get stung by a bee??? Her face is so puffy compared to her tiny hands/arms I’m so confused

[@kempmcarthur2318]

I love how Robert is so objective and calm in his criticism, it’s quite refreshing.

[@farahali432]

yes!! so refreshing to see a beauty/makeup content creator with 0 negativity!

[@jewelnabq01]

Exactly. He critiques in both positive ways and while some are "don'ts" he uses them as teaching tools and explains why.

[@aprilleerose]

I wish all people were like that

[@Ms10yearsafter]

@@aprilleerose he's special ❤️

a true professional

[@Kissimmeenc]

I’d love to see you do Michelle Phan because she’s like the first og I can think of 😍😍

[@hannie.haneul]

Yess!!! I miss the good old days 😭💕

[@havenloy9468]

Michelle Phan was the first MUA I EVER watched!! She’s the one who really got me into makeup!

[@isaackid09]

YES. I'M A HUGE FAN OF HER.

[@kotaniyumiko]

michelles really come a long a way with becoming more positive, especially after she bought back her brand

[@clareann8912]

Yes! I learned how to do makeup from Michelle, and she was always my fave

[@bernienelson8926]

I've only learned about Jaclyn in recent years, and Ive never understood why her fans are so in love with her. But that first video showed me why she became so loved - she's calm and gentle, gives great tips, and explains everything so that even a beginner could understand. I can see why so many people still want to believe in her and want to see her produce that helpful content again. She's a bit of a punchline now, but she became a KZbin staple for good reason in the beginning.

[@drs2994]

Yeah I agree. I think it's sadly actually changed her. The fame and money. She has done some unethical things and I don't trust her at all anymore. But I still watch her old videos ALL the time. Miss THAT Jaclyn. And I trust those old videos and reviews

[@BrennaByrdx]

Yeah, those old videos are the reason I loved her, and the reason I kept watching her for so long, even after a lot of controversies surrounding her. I love her style of makeup, how she does her eyes is amazing! I miss her. Watching her now just doesn't feel the same, so I stopped. She had this great gift of making you feel like you were watching a friend.. now she uses that to try and get my money, and I don't like it. Such a shame because she's so gorgeous and so incredibly talented.

[@MaggieMay-bc9vu]

She has sooooooooooo changed not only how she reacts to her fans but also in her changes to her face

[@tkmiller_author]

To be fair, we all go through a "sorting" phase at some point. I'm rooting for her to find her footing and do what makes her happy. 👍 Honestly, I'm so tired of the makeup drama and KZbin drama which I used to Live for. Now I'm just all about the makeup which landed me here. Watching Robert absolutely changed how I look at the makeup community. He's so encouraging🖤🖤

[@shannon-fq5gl]

@@MaggieMay-bc9vu u mean her weight gain? It happens. My face goes like that when I gain weight, it looks like I have retained fluid in my face.

[@laust-b33ch1ldd7]

"for a flirty girl effect" that so cute. honestly, the 2011 video is just so sweet and wholesome I really understand why people fell in love with her. Edit: this was not meant to be a way for y’all to hate on Jaclyn. I get that you have an issue with her, but you don’t have to insult her looks her personality because of that.

[@Esoteraeon]

I fell in love with her in the past for that same reason too. I just wish things were different..

[@aprilleerose]

She taught me how to do the perfect Smokey eye :) I adored her

[@deathbeforedecaf7755]

Not so vapid and bubble headed in 2011. Now she is so fake, dishonest and she talks so fast but doesn't really say anything. Her makeup now is so clown like. At least in 2011 it's something worth imitating.

[@NewBeginning828]

I was thinking the same. How sad compared to what she's become.

[@angiepartridge4168]

Her older videos are the best. I loved watching it

[@antaresia1812]

Am I the only one who finds that he has a calm voice, like flight attendants on airplanes?

[@MissJessicaMakeup]

Sarah Aguilera I agree !!

[@nishazed3278]

Omg yes haha

[@jenkenj]

As a former flight attendant, we use calm voices cuz we're trapped in pressurized metal tubes with the general public for hours at a time lol. Although I interjected little jokes into my safety speil to A) lighten the mood for any nervous fliers, and B) mainly to get people to pay attention to what I was saying ha :) hence why delta played a humorous safety video for a while ;)

[@amyfarrelly4580]

Was my first thought when listening to him.. Genuinely like a flight attendant

[@theprodigaljulee]

I love his voice so much. Sometimes I just leave his videos.playing in the background at work to relax me. 😂😂

[@kittyearsheadbands8810]

Back in the day tutorials weren’t makeup brand advertisements ... miss that

[@donnaz7415]

Preach!!!!

[@MrCarolineiscool]

Remember back in the day where most beauty gurus just described the shades they were using by the color instead of the brand and would tout “it doesn’t matter if you use the exact same products, use what you have that’s similar!”

[@somnolentverve2183]

@@MrCarolineiscool That's why I like a lot of Kbeauty artists and makeup "gurus". The tutorials are straightforward and they don't shill the hell out of the products.

[@randomnotimportant9607]

@@somnolentverve2183 and the products aren't usually too expensive either. There is nothing in this world that is going to convince a 60 dollar foundation can radically be better than a 20 dollar one when it is literally possible to get a good one under 10 dollars. It's one thing to shill products, it's another one to shill products that are way overpriced.

[@dg4f__]

☝🏽

[@izabella4823]

The fact that you still look gorgeous with that haircut says something.

[@RobertWelsh]

Thank you 😂🖤

[@crystalsankar3844]

Robert is gorgeous with any hairstyle. 🤗

[@Jabx84]

😂😂😂 you have to take chances in life, ok?!

[@reginaegut1119]

“Stunning” in Robert Welsh voice.

[@MamaElephant16]

For real! First, it was the hoodie, then this haircut. Like, we can’t handle it.

[@hudanassiri]

He criticizes people in the most polite way. You can’t even be mad at him. 🖤

[@ayehartewe]

I totally agree! The difference really is that he is not criticizing the person, he is critquing the technique and artistry. His professional approach with his 'grain of salt' humor and genuine interest in education really sets him apart. I love the positivity of this channel!

[@Lizzypoohxo]

Constructive criticism is what it is. No bias, no judging, no being a petty person, just pure information

[@ayehartewe]

Elizabeth wofford absolutely!

[@mainerfreebird]

Because he’s a proper adult.

[@vhernandez4792]

@@mainerfreebird yes! We disagree cool be an adult about it. No need to be rude.

[@ambular1304]

Oh my do I miss the old KZbin. Bad camera quality from your laptop, no set ups or backgrounds and real tutorials. The simple time before trying to sell everything and morphe morphe morphe

[@monicaa2176]

Back then we still had the star rating system

[@asashiarangel6048]

Mia P. Can you explain the star system?

[@monicaa2176]

@@asashiarangel6048 Back then there werent the thumbs to rate the video, but Stars. I think it was five.

[@Eeeeeeeeej]

I have such nostalgia for the old KZbin culture... I started following jaclyn and a couple others in like 2013 because I wanted to learn makeup for my wedding. Jaclyn in particular really changed a lot (in my opinion for the worse). Just my opinion. She has seemed so shallow for the last few years.

[@missjewells5063]

Amber Gifford morphe just sucks! I’m over it. But yeah, I miss the good Ol tutorial days, before “selling & monetizing” became the purpose for videos. Greed set in, and now KZbin tutorial artists have become a bunch of ugly, petty, bitchy, argumentative gossip Channels. I’m over that too. I usually just watch Bailey Serian now, she’s amazing, and she tells stories while doing amazing makeup.

[@nikitamoore7357]

i think you should do tati next in this series! she’s also been on this platform for forever xxx

[@marygracemcgrath]

^^ love to see that! I love Robert and Tati both, so it would be cool to see what Robert thinks of her techniques from a professional MUA standpoint

[@dramaqueen9891]

Yes yes yes!

[@heidil.256]

This is a great idea but Tati rarely does tutorials anymore. She’s more about product reviews. 😕

[@zocava90]

Heidi L. And her lighting and filters make it impossible to know what anything even looks like in real life. I stopped watching her years ago for that reason.

[@definitelynotalizard]

@@zocava90 I agree with the lighting issue, but now she's in Seattle she's using more natural lighting and her videos are returning to that original "sitting with your friends on your bedroom floor playing with makeup" vibe. It's quite refreshing and I recommend checking out one of her videos from the last month.

[@jenniferkelly2661]

Literally this introduction is everything. “We’re not gonna Bitch and we’re gonna learn from each other.” 🙌🏼

[@Somecallme.V]

Jaclyn used to be so calm and relaxed and casual it truly felt like a friend teaching you some tips, now she’s all “ OMG HAI GUYZ LOLOLOL HAHAHAHAHA 🤪”

[@SpaceDementia_]

How KZbinrs evolve in a nutshell!

[@doubleyouexwhyamzed]

Anxiety. She's lowkey scared because she gets so much hate and fears responses.

[@MissJessicaMakeup]

Lysol Disinfectant Wipes Absolutely. I suffer anxiety disorder and I’m like that as well . You’re so right on .

[@theonlychild4719]

@@doubleyouexwhyamzed it's quite sad 😣 ik how it feels... She used to be amazing in teaching how to blend eyeshadow... Miss those days

[@MadisonFalcoFoods]

My fav JH was 2016

[@lilg540]

Baby jaclyn is so sweet and innocent. Felt no nostalgic watching. She taught me everything back in the day!

[@lilg540]

Oops *so nostalgic lol :)

[@aerryn420]

Yes! She’s the reason I got into makeup, KZbin, photography/videography etc. I feel like OG subscribers still see her as she used to be just matured! Despite the drama (not defending or saying anything is okay) she is still my favorite.

[@sleepygirl96]

and she taught you well, your makeup in your profile pic looks gorgeous

[@alienmatsu156]

Saaaame! She was one of the first beauty you tubers I ever followed

[@annacabana12]

Do you feel like she’s still genuine? I used to follow her but had to unsubscribe because I just can’t with her anymore. 🤷🏼‍♀️

[@iLeaveYouWithHugs]

The first video was during the era of actually trying to learn makeup. Nowadays, everyone either assumes you already know how or they don't want to zoom in that much because it ruins the illusion of perfection.

[@k.t.5423]

“Baking” is literally just creating a problem with excessive concealer, and fixing that problem with another problem by setting it with excessive powder. (Wish the old me knew this, so thankful for Robert for really showing me the truth)

[@doeb23]

Aaaand then fixing the problem of excess powder with a spray :) (I do NOT understand what is the purpose of overapplying powder then wetting the dry powder with a spray. It literally defeats the purpose of powder, it just creates another foundation-like layer)

[@AJ17_]

Unless you're a drag queen, or performing onstage under those bright, hot lights, baking is totally unnecessary.

[@katiearcher4475]

If im in super humid places, find it helps soak up extra moisture. XD But if im in a dryer location or normal moisture location its a hard pass

[@biancapants]

I only set just under my eyes and that is all I need...it was almost freeing when I heard Robert say that I don’t need to us powder if I don’t need to.

[@zosiabialowas1675]

Same, i hate baking especially under the eyes. I only bake my nose since i wear glasses and i need some extra help with foundation right there. Sometimes i bake only my more oily zones when i go to the party or something like that

[@Myxer2110]

Robert: do people still put highlighter under their brow? 😊 Me, who does: oh no

[@RobertWelsh]

😂😂 it’s cute I like it!!

[@ptaryndacty1]

I totally do too 😂😂

[@alatharrii]

I do it when I don't want to apply eyeshaddow and bring a look together quick Either highlight under the brow and use the same highlighter for the cheeck and mascara OR go in with the blush that i'll use on my cheeks in my crease and finish with mascara and boom! complete look with no effort

[@prismicalx]

I always do too 😂 my eyes are very hooded so I think it helps add dimension? I hope?

[@alatharrii]

@@prismicalx yes yes! I'm hooded too! hooded with not alot of space to work with under the brow!!

[@amberskye290]

Young Jaclyn was giving me major Audrina from The Hills vibes

[@OoMASEoO]

"Why do we bake?" Because women are watching makeup application for, and by, DRAG QUEENS. They're doing stage makeup for every day wear. YOU'VE BEEN LEAD ASTRAY, LADIES!

[@TheJulieVirgo]

THATS EXACTLY WHAT I WAS SAYING!!! Preach

[@emo-slime-mold]

Exactly

[@RachaelTheRed]

I grew up as a competitive dancer, it's take a LONG time to learn how to reel it back in.

[@RachaelTheRed]

I grew up as a competitive dancer, it's take a LONG time to learn how to reel it back in.

[@definitelynotalizard]

Yes! I was so confused when all these techniques for stage makeup were becoming popular, because during a show we look like nightmares close up 😂 If you bake you're going to get cake!

[@Liam-mv9zi]

21:00 Oml I love how Robert noticed that he paused at a bad time and unpaused for just a second to make Jaclyn look better. It was so funny to me, but also incredibly respectable because he never wants anyone watching to laugh at anyone else. This is exactly why I love him ❤️

[@SX_Tifosi16]

Robert is the king of kindness 💕

[@Cesia_B]

I didn't even noticed. Sweety!

[@sarahmason1093]

So nice that he shows her this kindness and doesn’t think twice

[@adelaguelfo]

The man is a pro👏🏼fe👏🏼tio👏🏼nal👏🏼!!! No nasty business, only there for the teaching! He's a gem!

[@janeses]

A big time sweetie pie

[@Lizzypoohxo]

9 years ago I didn't know anything about KZbin except that I could listen to any song at any time for free!

[@belleanna365]

Anyone else have a mental moment where they were like 2011 wasn’t that long ago and then you realize oh... that was 9 years ago... never mind

[@theonlychild4719]

🤦🏻‍♀️🙋🏻‍♀️ I'm like I haven't even moved from 2011 yet 😂

[@sparklewithmuskan3890]

Just had it reading your comment xD

[@Juju-l3o]

YES and then also realized 9 years ago from 2011 was 2002 and I'm like how did time skip by so fast lol mindblown😅

[@kali7906]

Time has flown by wayyy too fast 💨 since then!

[@Juju-l3o]

@Anna Baylee Seriously 😭

[@peachy7690]

I love how Robert didn't criticize her personally and just her makeup techniques! I feel like I'm more aware of where I apply my makeup because of Robert. Btw I recently tried some Korean skincare products and they are absolutely amazing! I'm so thankful for Robert's skincare videos!

[@matcha_]

Do you mean James's skincare videos? Robert mainly sticks to makeup. James Welsh, Robert's twin, does the skincare videos. 😂

[@peachy7690]

@@matcha_ Robert did a video about Korean makeup and recommended some skin care products as well and yes I am well aware of his twin brother James. Thanks for reminding me

[@drs2994]

@@peachy7690 dang girl. **Snaps finger. I Loved that Suttle read.

[@kavyasindhuri4546]

That quiet little shoulder shimmy you did at 13:24 was soo cute!

[@elinav8089]

“No, I absolutely hate it “ every time any girl cuts her bangs 😂

[@laurenskee2665]

Omg I felt this!

[@merlinsmama1600]

So true!😂

[@himetsu7594]

Lmao me 2 weeks ago when I was bored

[@jeannettep-w2135]

I was JUST thinking about cutting side swept bangs 😂😂

[@elinav8089]

Jeannette Pierrepont-Weber don’t 😂

[@kufresh1988]

“I wanna go crazy. Give me a burgundy lip!” 😆

[@EK-dt4cp]

I laughed so hard 🤣

[@kristenwinegar9327]

Came for this comment. That had me cracking up!

[@Claire-td1ng]

Burgundy lip was my go to 😂 If I wanted to go crazy, I went with purple highlighter (Purple highlighter didn't even exist at the time so I just wetted my brush and applied my MUF diamond powder, good times 😅)

[@arianamoskwa6531]

We dont know her personally were just going to critique her makeup constructively. 👏👏 THIS IS WHY I LOVE YOU. You're such a refreshing presence. Keep being amazing 💜

[@gowrieeyres5720]

I swear Roberts menacing cackle & clanking of the rings is an absolute mood he’s like a little Disney villain 🦹🏻‍♀️

[@Muslimah33]

The kindest villain.

[@killjoyer]

His black shirt and purple backdrop reminds me of Ursula hahahaha

[@gowrieeyres5720]

Killjoy yes that’s it!

[@isabellascuotto1451]

I feel like the evolution in lighting and cameras has also made a huge impact on Jaclyn's technique. I believe the makeup from her 2011 video would look extremely different if she was recording with today's technology, even if it'd still look super nice in person.

[@supreme_aset777]

Awww I miss the old Jaclyn. She was so wholesome 😭

[@dianaberlin4767]

She was professional

[@kelseybrice2169]

Robert is so kind that he realizes when he paused the video on jaclyns face that it wasn’t the most flattering look and he unpaused to get out of it and to a better place. ❤️

[@hamstarpwr]

Omg I went back and watched and he TOTALLY did!!!

[@Pa-gy5vh]

It should be illegal to post a comment like this without a time stamp

[@MsGlitterBombz]

@@Pa-gy5vh 21:00

[@MISayera97]

@@Pa-gy5vh yessssss

[@jgzaz]

He is truly the makeup channel that never lets us down. A very considerate, thoughtful, and honest makeup artist.

[@captaincmorgan]

Robert is the standard we all need to live by. I know I need to practice this more myself, constructive criticism without getting personal. Love it!

[@RobertWelsh]

Thank you! I think we all, as humans naturally do it, sometimes I have to think before I speak also!

[@lkaur6970]

Robert Welsh I need to learn that from you - how to think before you speak. Sometimes I just forget that.

[@lizregan8195]

I love your channel Robert. No drama, no bitchiness, just genuine advice for people who want tips on makeup, using proper makeup techniques instead of jumping on an Instagram trend bandwagon. This channel is a breath of fresh air.

[@lipstickrebelle1760]

Hey Robert, could you possibly do a video on „iconic“ hyped up makeup products of the 2010s and how they hold up today? Like hoola bronzer, orgasm blush, the naked palette etc. Love you 🥰💕

[@shell2835]

Ooo good idea

[@ChristinaWoodall]

Def great idea 💖💖

[@NOMAAM1970]

You've got the most adorable laugh.

[@RobertWelsh]

Thank u! 🖤

[@jwhisten]

I love his laugh!!!!

[@tanyaflynn4908]

He seems so sweet. I like the way he keeps it professional and fun without throwing shade.

[@mandyblack2636]

Mee too! His laugh makes my day! 🖤

[@Rara-ds1hu]

I know right! Love your laugh!!!☺️

[@MakeupMobster]

Jacklyn then : mac, mac, mac Jacklyn now: morphe, morphe, morphe

[@dananezat]

The difference is back then Mac really was some of the best

[@aprilleerose]

And sigma before mac lol

[@Abbymiller91992]

I think she was working at Mac when she first started making videos so that’s why she was using so many of their products

[@SussexSandra]

I’m actually really impressed with her teaching skills and how clearly she spoke. Now, she speaks in warp speed and I can’t understand a word she says. But maybe that’s because I’m old. 🤗🤗

[@PB-xr6yi]

Sussex Sandra tbh I think she developed anxiety 😢she been through a lot of social media bullying

[@stellar7760]

No, girl, it’s not us, it’s her...

[@MissJessicaMakeup]

It’s definitely the anxiety . I suffer major anxiety and I’m the same . At least it’s not James Charles speed lol

[@dianam8690]

Jessica Reeves I do the same thing when I’m nervous but hearing someone else speak in the same way makes me so anxious!

[@MissJessicaMakeup]

Diana M agreed ! Same here

[@mckoala6181]

2011 when beauty guru drama wasn’t really a thing ☹️😒 also it wasn’t all about getting a brand deal and doing advertisements

[@camillemoyer937]

And they actually were doing videos to help people learn how to do something rather than just say what they are doing and not REALLY show or explain where or why they are doing it rather than try and just show off how well they can blend something

[@mckoala6181]

Camille Moyer excatly man

[@deathbeforedecaf7755]

Money really changed her. It does for many unfortunately. The difference for me is in her look. Don't care about that. She explained more in 2011. She babbles and says a lot but doesn't really say much at the same time

[@hannaween]

Loved this video Robert. You're so professional and not 'spilling tea' or 'throwing shade' and you expect the same of your followers - it's refreshing. I personally am a huge fan of light coverage makeup and I use mostly glossier but I've seen you're not a fan of some of their products 😅 I would love to see how you would do a light coverage glowy/dewy look

[@fabjpg]

"did i cut my own hair? yeah do i really like it? no, i absolutely hate it, but * nervous laughter * " that was such a big mood

[@RobertWelsh]

😂🖤

[@Julia-qd6mw]

Robert:*cringes at a two in one eye primer/concealer* Me:*glares at the two in one shampoo/conditioner in my shower*

[@lotosczerwony8659]

Omg me too 😅😂

[@faq462]

Does that mean you were on the toilet while watching this?🤨 Bc same 🤪

[@oliviajeanette1065]

🤣

[@tkmiller_author]

😂😂😂 girl, I have one too. 🤗

[@dianaochoa4263]

f aq I am lmao

[@dishashah5539]

I have a theory for excessive product trend- 4-5 years back there was not much of product release. Now new products are coming out everyday. Beauty KZbinrs get so much product. Hence more product use- just to finish up and/or buy more.

[@kate2506]

I’d love for you to do Samantha Ravndahl in this series next, her style has changed massively and I just think it’d be fascinating for you to do one on her ☺️

[@martynkal.1248]

Everybody like this!!

[@marinac2002]

Yesss

[@shelbydavis1818]

Yes!! I love Sam!!

[@laurac86]

Yes please!!!! I’ve watched Sam for years and her style has def changed through the years

[@melaniethetruckdriver]

Yes yes yes pleeeeease 🙏🏼

[@elizabethpowell5638]

She’s so cute in that first video, I can see how she build a following.

[@shannonmorrison5152]

So much more becoming.. now. Not so much

[@elinalukaziak693]

Yeah how hard she's fallen

[@taylordv853]

Literally my favourite youtuber of all time, GET THIS MAN TO A MILLION SUBS !!!

[@benjib0yyy]

I don't mean this to be rude at all, but her voice is so different now. Like WOW.

[@raechel0116]

k3nnny b0y she likes to be loud and obnoxious in my opinion.

[@imjustjules]

She seems to talk faster now too? She’s probably anxious.. :(

[@user-lx2ir2eo3l]

she's alot more comfy in front of the camera and as someone with anxiety sometimes we talk loud and fast to make up for it if that makes sense

[@Prokomeni]

how is saying something is different being rude? did you have a rude thought while you said it

[@ashleyh4699]

I agree. She talks so fast now. It gives me secondhand anxiety.

[@mihlemtshwane3358]

I can’t be the only one who nods every time he says “d’you know what I mean?” 😂❤️

[@hubabaloop]

yes girl 😂😂😂

[@tkmiller_author]

Robert: "if that makes sense." Me, with headphones on, out loud, at work: "it does."

[@msfit23]

I just say "eyup" outloud

[@vixen8054]

Hahahha yaasssss gurrrrrllll

[@melaniemeekermakeupmeeker7878]

Every time

[@bethanyd7216]

Thank you for being so nice and respectful towards Jaclyn and explicitly saying to the viewers that it's not about Jaclyn but rather the makeup techniques over the years. Though there are still some people in the comments choosing to comment on her appearance and whether they like/dislike her, it was very nice of you to make a point that you didn't want this to turn into a "let's roast Jaclyn". You're one of the best and nicest MUA's on youtube in recent years xx

[@solanaseraphina]

The way Robert greeted us in the beginning is a form of therapy.

[@RobertWelsh]

😝🖤

[@alexandrasaadi7149]

I absolutely love that you are demanding “better” from your viewers. More people should should do this. We can always be better. It’s one of the most beautiful qualities that we human beings possess. Thank you Robert, I see you🖤

[@frida3578]

This is such an underrated comment 💜

[@alexandrasaadi7149]

girl.anachronism lol;)

[@alexandrasaadi7149]

Frida thanks💜

[@RodneyAndMeVideos]

+

[@katelyndiaz2940]

“Now I’m taking the color shroom” that took me BACK

[@macymarie9983]

Hi Robert please watch Samantha Ravndahl I think you’d really enjoy her content

[@CarmiMl0v3]

Macy Marie yes! i second this so hard

[@macymarie9983]

CarmiMl0v3 ikr she’s like one of very few beauty gurus I can actually take advice from and product recommendations since we both have really dry skin

[@youreinacultcallyourdad395]

She’s one of my favorites

[@user-ku3to6ou6l]

Yes! I found her about 4 years ago and she's one of the few that I still watch consistently. Her personality is so refreshing.

[@taprgurl]

Yes so good!! Just watch out for major eff bombs 😅

[@KellyeR1970]

This was almost my exact 90's make-up routine just without the bronzer and highlight. It was brows ,blush, lashes and dark lipstick and liner. I actually really love the old the way the old cameras and no ring light shows the actual skin, these days everyone's skins looks abnormally perfect and you don't see exactly how the make-up looks in person. I like the realness.

[@Ehros]

When you said no I absolutely hate it I died 😭😂😭😂

[@RobertWelsh]

😂😂🖤

[@amyquick4543]

Me too! I ugly laugh/snorted. Especially since I was thinking it didn’t look like a bad effort at all.

[@KaPika735]

The under-brow highlight is my favourite place to highlight honestly 😂 just brings more attention to all that hard work i put into my eyeshadow

[@tracyallen7722]

Robert's voice is so soothing and his humor gets to me so much that I no longer listen to podcasts at work. I either listen to his videos or the ones with James. I'm not nearly as stressed most days. Robert's also great at helping with my insomnia when Forensic Files fails me.

[@darienjones1510]

Robert’s gone full Capitol resident from the hunger games with this haircut lol

[@emdoubleyew3788]

I’m living for this comment

[@jessicasebastiao9069]

Omg yeees

[@fran1725]

Jessica Sebastião has

[@fran1725]

Jessica Sebastião has m

[@kalliope8238]

I’ve been thinking for a while now that the way Jaclyn contours her nose makes her face look broader than it is. If you take width away from your nose, it’s GOTTA GO SOMEWHERE.. it makes the cheeks look so much bigger. I know she loves contouring her nose, but as you said, she already has such a great nose.

[@AshleySezRawrz]

Your comment really made me think 🧐 I’ve never thought of it that way before where you said if you take away width it has to go somewhere so it can make cheeks look bigger. It makes sense since you’re changing proportions and especially if you unbalance them by making something too contoured or highlighted.

[@Eeeeeeeeej]

I think she has done a lot of fillers and Botox and things like that, plus a bit of weight gain. No shade but simple contouring isn’t the only factor here.

[@erika-sf6ei]

lip fillers and fillers on the face never goes away and slowly it leaks to other parts of the face and widens your face. :(

[@cyndijohnson8152]

@@erika-sf6ei it does go away & leaves stretched out skin behind to sag & cause this moon face. Its called "Filler Fatigue".

[@brooke5126]

I love how respectful you are Robert. I even noticed how you changed the frame it paused on so it wasn’t paused on her making a silly face. And you are very informative, thanks for your videos!

[@davidanddaniellerosales9974]

I just cannot say enough how refreshing Robert is. His kindness is unparalleled. Lol

[@yoonzino7433]

8:27 I didn’t even realize people don’t put highlight under their brows anymore. I thought everyone still did, I have since I’ve started makeup years ago lmao

[@shireads2954]

I also didn't realize people didn't do that anymore. But I was thinking about it, and it turns out, I don't anymore either. Not because I'm just that on touch with trends, but because I'm too lazy to grab a smaller brush when I'm highlighting

[@sparkybish]

Plenty of people do. I see tutorials where people do it. And if you like it, do it.

[@yoonzino7433]

MissMargaret ^^ right?

[@TheSwauzz]

I stopped when I realized I was going to have to wax much more often than I wanted to. ): I liked the effect though.

[@ThePerfectmercy]

Same!

[@indiemagnetic2996]

2011 - 'I saw this look on all the runways' Now - 'I saw this all over tiktok'

[@nicolesolognier4709]

You’re literally so effortlessly funny 😂🤣

[@littlereddstar5264]

This is how you do a “Then vs Now: X KZbinr” video-Objectively , with opinions about the makeup and it’s technique then vs now. Not about what’s changed with them physically. P.S. Nadi is the lost Welsh hair triplet 😉.

[@e.poetri]

Nadi who?

[@cinnamonraw3590]

elvira poetri Poplux on KZbin. He is called Nadi, and very funny , but not always SFW or around children lol

[@littlereddstar5264]

elvira poetri Nadi is a KZbinr that does reviews under the name PopLuxe (same as his highlighter brand name). Nadi and Robert do a back and forth on Twitter and Robert mentioned he looks like Nadi with his hair cut.

[@e.poetri]

Ah i see, thank you

[@e.poetri]

@@littlereddstar5264 thanks a lot~

[@ThymeofGhost]

As they say in hair school, you need to know the theory before you break the rules

[@kaityr9693]

The fact that dark lipstick was crazy in the early days of KZbin proves that I have always been weird. Edgy 14 y/o me with my black lips is so proud

[@toastiememes]

Same! I had lipstick in every color and often wore my black/purple ones daily.

[@lolaxxx3669]

I bloody love a darker lip, especially in the autumn and winter, my fave is black cherry by Revlon, surprisingly, it has been for about 10 years lol!!

[@kaityr9693]

@@lolaxxx3669 yeah, it's either vampy and dark or a really greyed out color for me. Love to look witchy

[@essie23la]

edgy 14 y/o me WISHED she'd dare to wear black lipstick lmao. I only did the thick attempted-wing eyeliner, and white eyeshadow on the inner corners of my eyes. Use some eyeshadow base as undereye concealer, powder aand done. Awkward goth kid who'll dress gothy, dye her hair hot pink, but be scared of lipstick lol

[@AD_AP_T]

As a person who hit their teens at the start of the 00's and absolutely REFUSED to miss out on 90s grunge, ooooh yes. That dark berry lip, and the smudged black kohl that turned into raccoon eyes on oily teeny skin after about fifteen minutes... Life.

[@KT-ie6vf]

“I wanna go crazy give me a burgundy lip” 😂😂😂😂😂

[@burdeegirl]

*looks at all of my burgundy lip shades compared to the two nudes I own*

[@Claire-td1ng]

I used to wear burgundy shades all the time, and when I went nude, I'd do a bright red eye look and purple highlighter. It was before all those red palettes began to came out. (I was so relieved to no longer have to rely on color pop shock shadows to do red looks anymore 😂)

[@laurac8320]

Just wanted to say... Robert, you’re doing everything right. No explanation needed.

[@77cns]

Omg your DP 🤣👏🏼

[@JuggrnautWraith13]

“Do people still put highlighter under their brow?” Me, who did it today: “Oh gosh. I don’t know, do they???” 👀👀👀😂 In all seriousness, I love your content. You’re so professional, informative, and able to critique without being an awful person. I learn so much from you, or feel confident in what I have been doing, which isn’t what “beauty gurus” do (i.e. baking and excess concealer use)

[@hollienelson6738]

I appreciate your disclaimer 😉 Sometimes, we do need reminders that we're meant to be critiquing, not criticizing. Also, your new "do" suits you. It's unique and exciting.

[@maddyl5649]

Literally sweetest youtuber! I love how you unpaused & paused again when you noticed you paused on an unflattering shot. You are such a gem 💖

[@thesunandherstars_3228]

Robert: do people still put highlighter under the brows? Me, who does this every day: 👁👄👁

[@rhichey]

Same lol

[@onthebrightside5400]

I honestly feel like a lot of people still do this?? Lol 👀

[@alisonlee8153]

Yeah but why do it. I don't get it

[@hazel3390]

@@alisonlee8153 brings the brow bone forward, adding structure to the face

[@rosebarnett6970]

Well I wasn't going to cut my own hair but if Robert is... 🤷🏾‍♀️

[@RobertWelsh]

😂😂🖤🖤

[@Cesia_B]

For me it was Michelle Phan ❤️

[@kamlin98]

😂😂

[@brittanys505]

Lets all get the same haircut, I cut mine and was like I'm not doing this again I'll grow it out now.But why not? Nobody's going to see me during quarantine.

[@ilsewatson2284]

You are really SUCH an awesome person because you have respect for people and what they do doesn't concern you - you are just about the makeup. Very professional. Very.

[@sarumatsu3698]

13:23 rewatch Robert as many times as you want. You're welcome.

[@agapelovegirl]

This was the best! I didn't notice at first, so thank you for this! Just watched about 5 times in a row. Robert is so fun!

[@born_confused]

Thank you I missed Robert doing his dance👌🕺

[@ckevorkianxo]

OMG BUMP THIS COMMENT 😭🥰🥰

[@palladium607]

Lol yes!thank you! I just love him

[@shannon2712]

I really miss old school KZbin makeup. When it was all about education, not pushing a product.

[@mackenziesim9268]

I still highlight under my eyebrow. I know it’s now “out of style” and “unflattering” but it’s just something I learned at a young age and never changed

[@arditasulejmani8008]

I do it to because it just feels weird so not do it 😂😂

[@jenkenj]

I do it too! I think it's "more important" if you have smaller eyes/eye sockets... which I do ha so I'm all about anything to brighten and make them appear larger :)

[@bakugotodoroki69]

I didn't even know it's out of style rn lol wtf

[@kadygirlforever]

What do people do now? I’ve always highlighted and didn’t know it was an option not to. That’s kind of like skipping the lid to me, lol

[@audreyfan4ever]

I do too, like, I feel I have to. Many influencers carve out with concealer, but I prefer a bit of a white/nude satin shadow. I’ve been doing it since 2007 and I won’t stop

[@orangesheep73]

Concealer and eyeshadow base is like 2in1 shampoo and conditioner 😂

[@kaylafarrands5546]

Baby Jaclyn Hill!!! How wild is it to see what KZbin used to be like. Love this Robert, thanks as always for your very informative videos.

[@YCLA88]

I’m watching all Robert’s videos (besides ghosts stories, cause I’m 35 and afraid of stuff I cannot see) and really wanted to comment very cleverly.. but I just cannot say anything more than I freaking love this guy. He’s everything this world needs ❤

[@irenef4185]

That throwback video was so wholesome and I think the look would work today without looking dated. I'm looking forward to more then vs now videos!

[@himetsu7594]

Last time I was this early Jaclyn uploaded makeup tutorials

[@abigailpotts8498]

klaudia szewczyk Amazing 😂😂

[@TaterKakez]

21:02 Robert, you are an absolute GEM. You played and paused again just so the pause screen wouldn’t be in an unflattering pose for JH. You’re a doll, I love you 💜✨🥰

[@taylorinvancouver2017]

Wow the good ol’ days when you could actually see ppls natural expression wrinkles on foreheads 😂 🤣😂

[@nina_summers]

Right hahaha! I actually loveeee and adore her old videos

[@frenchfry14595]

I could be wrong, but I don't remember anyone really talking about contouring or highlighting back then, so she was pretty progressive for the time back in the teens.

[@elenapopovic2527]

There werent many of us but professional makeup artists were (I was at Sephora around the time that Jaclyn was at MAC and transitioning to youtube). There weren't many "contour" products on the market for consumers, so if we were selling product we were selling bronzer as contour, but professional makeup artist brands had cool matte contour products (I sold tons of Make Up For Ever back in the day).

[@HELL0NESSA]

They were. It became more popular in the late 00s because of celebs like Halle Berry and JLo.

[@durcheinander5554]

It's actually so nice to see real skin in natural lighting in these old videos. Technology might have moved forward since then but it doesn't mean you can see more detail now. On the contrary, the studio lights blur it out.

[@rebeccabourque7704]

Robert: “Do people still do the highlight under the brow?” Me: shakes head and says “pffttt, no” while discretely pushing the highlighter across the table 👀

[@Marskilius]

I felt attacked! 😂

[@rebeccabourque7704]

Marskilius 🤣🤣

[@blondiiejx]

Same🤣

[@tracy_cakkes]

Lololol

[@CKotaGo7]

This was very interesting. I would like to see more "then" and "now" videos.

[@HannahMusic333]

“Just about the makeup, in a constructive way.” THANK YOU I appreciate it. I think it is important to be positive especially right now. Thank you so much for the creative and constructive content.

[@isidoraspasic6543]

I love how both you and James forget words and then go with a semi-correct word but acknowledge it and make it a thing, it's really kinda cute