Giant Steps...But It's Played by 8 Legendary Jazz Pianists

[@Jimindorothy]

*본 연주는 아티스트의 연주를 카피한것이 아닌 제가 피아니스트의 연주를 분석하고 편곡한 연주입니다 *This is not a real playing of themselves, I've made arrangements in their style. sheet music : jimindorothy-english.com/shop/?idx=52

[@bleuorb]

you're one of those classically trained jazz pianists that scare the living .... out of me

[@walkercatenaccio]

Astonishing

[@sarahvlo]

And you're like all of these legends rolled into one. Thank you for the inspiration. I'm just here to take baby steps in my journey to learning and appreciating jazz music.

[@manuelm5664]

Well played! Totally oohsome! 🤗👏👏👏👍💕 Beautiful grand piano bass sound on external speakers!

[@travelingman9763]

You are amazing!

[@GeorgeCollier]

jimin has hopped on the giant steps train and it's exactly what we needed

[@Jimindorothy]

Hahahah Can't help it😂

[@junie.l]

George! Surprised to see you here :)

[@Creedgate]

Damn! Still trying to catch my breath. Excellent!

[@cormaccullinane6390]

Oh hey George fancy seeing you here

[@LukeLaczynski]

He knows what's up

[@あけぼの春は-z5r]

亡き人の魂を呼び寄せて、自分の口を通してその思いを残された人に伝える「イタコ」という特殊能力を持つ人が日本のある地方にいらっしゃいます。 あなたはピアノを通じて亡きピアニストたちの演奏を伝えてくれる特殊能力をお持ちのようです。イタコピアニスト。 ビルが最後に降りてきたのは泣けました。

[@m1ro_944]

Me too

[@thexstation1321]

Here’s a little fun fact: Erroll Garner never learned how to read sheet music. When people asked him why, he replied that people pay him to play music, not to read sheet music

[@robertvanruyssevelt7159]

There is a number of top musicians who can't read music but not bothering to learn to read will not make anyone a top musician!

[@jwc1276]

I learned how to read music decades before I didn’t need to anymore : )

[@icedragon9097]

Thats really not special ngl

[@JudgeDredd_]

The thing that most intimidated me during music school was my lack of scale fundamentals. I could play them all with my eyes closed, arpeggios and fifths included but for some reason I got jumbled and really depressed in the practice rooms when I had to sit down and actually KNOW what I was doing. Wow. First time I’ve ever tried to describe that almost a decade later. I miss my reference 36 Tenor so much… worst thing I’ve ever done was give that horn up. I’m in the process of getting a new one. 3K away baby!! Haha. So much lost time to make up for.

[@TommyLikeTom]

it's more common these days for people to learn how to play an instrument without sheet music. In my opinion sheet music confuses people because it's a really non-intuitive way of notating music. Why is C so special, for example?

[@m2j573]

The Bill Evans version and Eroll Garner’s shows proof that even the craziest bop jazz is actually nothing but a beautiful ballad played at a very high tempo

[@HillTeen]

In fact, Flannagan thought it was a ballad because of the Strange harmonies

[@m2j573]

@@HillTeen there you go.. there’s no excuse for people who say i just don’t understand jazz lol you would love it if it’s slowed down

[@coreystark8352]

@@m2j573 🤦‍♂️

[@m2j573]

@@coreystark8352 ??

[@niemand262]

Fun fact, sounds ate also just high frequency "percussion". Jacob Collier demonstrated this in a video wherein he accelerated a polyrhythm and it sounded like a chord because each percussive rhythm gets interpreted by the brain as a tone. It's wild.

[@Roxanneredpanda]

Oscar peterson playing giant steps is the most terrifying thing I've ever thought off

[@jesham7627]

Monk in my book.

[@Caleb-zl4wk]

@@jesham7627 yeah that's fair.

[@manny2092]

you crack me up!

[@oscargill423]

Wish I could leave a laugh react because while I don't necessarily agree, I very much understand.

[@jwc1276]

@@jesham7627 Ives

[@philos9295]

Loved the Red Garland one

[@VinaTropica黄慧娜]

Me too

[@walkercatenaccio]

Wait, does anyone else notice how amazing this is? This lovely lady is a true musical savant - she can see through the surface phenomena to the basic patterns underneath, and then she has command of an essentially limitless technique to realize her understanding. "Giant Steps" is a notoriously difficult piece to negotiate in any one style. As a minor aside, I am still waiting for a Tommy Flanagan lesson. But more to the point, J., please put out more videos of you swinging out with improvisations in your own style.

[@schoolmusic3507]

I agree. It takes genius to do what she does.

[@The-Man23]

U r right

[@The-Man23]

She deserves more subs

[@Dontlook36]

It's a different level

[@knowthyself7884]

"improvisations in your own style" - this is actually an interesting point. I am an amateur piano player so I am not sure I should judge anything related to playing. But as a listener, I was so so positively impressed by Jimin - and I enjoyed it a lot - and I learned a lot. So this is great. Own style (and I am writing generally here now, not in relation to Jimin) is a different dimension. It might be related to understanding other styles but I would (and I hope psychologists or learning experts would agree) like to understand "own style"/ creativity as something which is weakly (co-) related to replication (at whatever level the replication is - I think one can make similar arguments in science)

[@zoulistic]

The amount of musical knowledge on display here is mind boggling!

[@alphabeets]

I would say that any pianist that can accurately recreate these major pianist’s styles playing Giant Steps is ready for the big time. Very impressive.

[@jameswilliamson3481]

I love how she included the great Hazel Scott, well do jimin!!

[@danielm9463]

Me too!!!! That's when I subscribed. This video makes me so happy

[@philipclifford2314]

What an extraordinary imposter! To perfectly inhabit multiple legendary artists like some Uber tribute artist is uncanny, but then to speculate how they would interpret signature works by other geniuses and deliver a convincing performance... Makes my brain seize up, but in a good way!

[@jwaj]

sus

[@icedragon9097]

Ye thats pretty sus bro

[@Scriabin_fan]

I really loved McCoy Tyner, Eroll Garner, and Bill Evans. But honestly I enjoyed listening to all of them.

[@stuartdann1261]

Been playing since 85. Started playing modern harmony/jazz in 93. I'm an old hand. You are my favourite pianist.

[@MartelMartin736]

The fact you play all of these means you have to add an extra number to those legendary piano player

[@skaterhugs1147]

Honestly yes

[@darylmichael7]

Hazel Scott & Red Gardner took me to another stratosphere. They should call you the “Pianist Whisperer”. Words really cannot express how brilliant this is. Really!

[@kingskid1985]

The Red Garland one is so tasty...

[@VinaTropica黄慧娜]

​@@kingskid1985Agree

[@davidarmstrongcharles]

Wow. What an incredible demonstration! As someone who teaches a college course on the history of jazz and works as a professional keyboardist, I must say that the depths to which Jimindorothy must have gone to understand these different styles and execute them with such finesse is amazing.

[@nateE5836]

Why did KZbin take SO long to suggest this video! ...I'm in love...

[@danielcabral6268]

The Errol Gardner version hit the bottom of my heart...

[@iltromboncini32]

This is absolutely wonderful! Almost as if each pianist found the lead sheet on his doormat one sunny morning. You make these legendary players come alive once more. Bravo!

[@theon2502]

I love these annotations of techniques! they are so helpful to understanding what you are playing. thank you taking on board your viewers' comments and making videos :)

[@mytearcobryn6690]

The Red Garland one is unbelievable.

[@VinaTropica黄慧娜]

Agree

[@m1ro_944]

Hazel Scott, Bill Evans and McCoy Tyner ❤

[@KevinBrightman]

Great demonstration of the difference in styles. Was glad to hear Red Garland and Hazel Scott.

[@crazycrocodile740]

2:57 really reminded me of rhapsody in blue by Gershwin

[@_spiritual_music_]

The Garner intro is tops-chef’s kiss

[@JudgeDredd_]

I come back to this video often. Just beautiful. I miss my horn so much. I will get it back one day

[@leofrasionio5290]

Erroll Garner hits different!

[@charmantcoeur]

This was just an absolutely wonderful six minutes. Normally with these videos, I sort of get the idea after 20 seconds, but gosh, I just wanted this to keep going. Wonderful.

[@zivkovicable]

A stunning performance. I keep coming back to this video. To master just one of these styles to this standard represents a lifetimes work for mere mortals..The late British actor/ comedian/ pianist Dudley Moore worshiped Errol Garner, & based his style largely on that of the great man. Dudley was no slouch, but when he heard that Errol Garner was in the audience at one of his shows, he ran out of the club into the night, never to return.

[@PianoWithJonny]

Well done Jimin! I really enjoyed these 👏

[@ninidesbois]

I 💓Erroll Garner💓 and also McCoy Tyner, Bill Evans. Bravo Dorothy from Asia.

[@scottvernier8307]

Brilliant work, wonderfully interpreted. Outstanding.....

[@pavelkratochvila6157]

Krásne hranie veľmi talentovanej pianistky, vďaka 🌻💐

[@SaccoBelmonte]

0:55!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :O so much swing! I think you should do a full song of the Erroll Garner version.

[@mojito6629]

Nice. I like all, esp. the Erroll Garner one. Thanks!

[@paulzupan3732]

The Bill Evans version is spot on, love it

[@colinmaharaj]

1:32 Hey my-lady, I totally like the idea that you studied Hazel Scott. In all honesty, I don't think anyone else can. I was amazed when I discovered her some years ago, and also a pretty girl in the office is named Hazel lol. And remember Hazel was a born Trinidadian like me. Cheers.

[@willtownsend1879]

You’re truly amazing, this warmed my soul, thank you 😊

[@bramkevin1987]

Bill Evans drove me crazy🔥

[@jazzypaul75]

I would pay good money for Red Garland Giant Steps. Damn that was fun.

[@kingskid1985]

Ain’t it tho?! I think what really makes this part swing so hard is the sweet combination of the left hand accompanying upbeat of two and four and the walking bass. That’s really all it takes to make you tap your feet! 😊

[@patrickgrandon86]

Great stuff. The best/closest one is Red Garland’s impersonation

[@VinaTropica黄慧娜]

Agree

[@jeshkam]

Would you do a separate video with the full Bill Evans interpretation, please? It's absolutely spot on and so beautiful.

[@InVerSemusic93]

How have I not heard of this channel yet??? You had my attention when you put Oscar in the thumbnail when I was almost 100% certain there are no recordings of him playing that tune. He's my #1 jazz influence on piano and you also nailed his stylistic idioms as well as everyone else you covered. Im blown away, good job.

[@robotprins]

This is amazing! all of them are amazing, and especially like the Red Garland improvisation, spot on!

[@timgelder4263]

Uncle Larry sent me here and he is correct, what a great player

[@brettbreet]

Wow! This is a Master's thesis!

[@robertpowell9618]

That was stupendous and sooo amazingly incredible to hear and watch. I do not believe that I have ever witnessed someone as gifted as you on the keys. I am thoroughly impressed. Unfortunately, it leaves me wanting more. Please keep playing. You are terrific 👏😀😊❤🙂👌!!!

[@evr551]

That Garland version is on point 😂

[@VinaTropica黄慧娜]

Agree

[@lordmusea]

This is phenomenal! I particularly like the Fats Waller and Errol Garner style versions.

[@nigeledwards5713]

This woman is a genius!

[@YoPaulieMusic]

It is quite obvious that you have done your homework on the piano masters.Not just a glance, but an in depth analysis of each of their styles. In this video I love your Errol Garner and Bill Evans versions. Great videos!

[@eriksnip1243]

2 years later, still very nice!! Health and wisdom to all, Erik the Netherlands

[@Oasisbill]

McCoy's right hand touch and detachment was perfect. The whole thing - beautiful playing :-)

[@larry.bailye5510]

THANK YOU!!!!!!!!!!

[@anneonym7346]

Jimindorothy , your mastery is impressive ! Mastery of music, piano, jazz ! For you, the sky is the limit ! Congratulations once again, and thank you very much for sharing your great talent ! ❤️ 🎶

[@BBKeys1947]

what kind of Genius Are you? Amazing.

[@Iduininane]

When I see any of your videos- I just like it even before playing it. Cuz I know it will be good. You are one of my favorite female pianists 😊

[@bryanchandler3486]

This is god tier content like the fact you cannot only play in all these styles but have the knowledge and mastery to be able to reproduce these pianists idiosyncrasies is amazing to behold

[@jazzpiano22]

Incredible.. how is it possible to master all those styles? Genius!

[@USALeonHeart]

The Bill Evans take was, as to be expected, lovely.

[@izzyvulaca]

ughhhh i loved that Eroll and Red Garland

[@VinaTropica黄慧娜]

Me too

[@jamesonrichards5105]

I appreciate the amount of respect you have for all these artists, I can hear it without a single doubt.

[@markybautista556]

I love watching your videos , it helps me understand each pianist approach I think you should do a masterclass on the type of things and explaining how you do all of them, i am sure there would over thousands of using that would buy the masterclass , I have bought many masterclass similar to what your doing but they don’t explain enough or sometimes they don’t go enough deep in the explanation

[@toogsx6980]

Erroll and Red, easily my two favorites

[@VinaTropica黄慧娜]

Me too

[@joelra3702]

Thought this was gonna be a meme but this just is fantastic content. Really loved the Barry Harris and Mccoy ones. Used to be a massive fan of Errol Garner and Red Garland and your impressions are spot on. Great playing!

[@Thouveninpascal]

Beauty and humour in piano Jazz , by a great piano player.

[@philhayter]

Amazing job. Hazel Scott’s drama and Bill Evans’ colours stand out for me but they are all really beautiful homages.

[@kingskid1985]

That Red Garland one is a real toe-tapper!

[@VinaTropica黄慧娜]

Agree

[@jazzypaul75]

Yup!

[@keytron1391]

Toe tapper? That’s going into my vocabulary

[@PKLO-k5y]

에롤 가너 진짜 미쳤네요 너무 좋아서 기절 함

[@eggmagic3318]

This performance is incredible. Skillful and well-studied. Very impressed!

[@goldenmantis]

As a Pianist this video is incredible

[@cbro777]

This was so enjoyable to watch and listen to. You're an amazing musician. Thank you for sharing.

[@JosSalinas]

The Erroll one is so on point😂 amazing.

[@larrybaby9377]

Oh so wonderful... Your grasp of these giants is both encyclopaedic and microscopic.

[@jeanlucchapelon]

Magnifique Vous êtes une virtuose,en plus !!

[@locrien1]

This is honestly one of the BEST things I've ever scene or heard on KZbin 🙏🏽

[@colinpickering976]

I can't stop listening to the Errol garner part

[@charliecampbell6851]

Yay! Barry got in there. I especially liked the Errol garner and fats Waller- great use of all of those signature stride licks.

[@CellZealot]

An absolutely off the charts stunning achievement, thank you. I am a guitar player, not a pianist, but this was revelatory.

[@ludodoomernik227]

jimmin you play like hell! Very good analisations of styles. Your urge to educate people in playing jazz piano is really fantastic.

[@antonij082]

Thank you for doing that. Your help and work means a lot for us!

[@balletclasspiano]

You analyze and play each pianist. you are awesome! I want to be able to play like you.

[@1392-m4s]

개좋다 진짜 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 재즈 피아노 어느정도 들어본 사람들은 당연하게 존나게 재밌는 포인트가 부분마다 녹아있음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@z-e-r-o-]

4th voicing, 3rd movements and left-hand melodies. Really clear explanation! 勉強になります！ 感謝！ Thanks for your informative instruction videos!

[@juanmanuelalvarezrodriguez84]

Fabuloso video un saludo desde,España. Admiro su forma de tocar varios estilos

[@mjgw]

You have honoured these players beautifully

[@JibsMotoVlog]

Omy, the Eroll Gardner version♥️♥️♥️ you made the scariest song ever to most loveliest beautiful version ever👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼

[@golfnut533]

You have amazing talent playing all the different styles. Thank you 👍

[@TomRivieremusic]

Excellent renditions of this tune. And you are a great pianist yourself.

[@aler8343]

I was waiting for mccoy pentatonics and 4hs, you really nailed his style

[@toneyam3643]

You are beyond gifted.

[@Jazman0959]

I say this in the most loving respectful way, you are a beast at the keyboard. I am humbled and inspired. Thank you for you unique approach and your diligent work. Blessings on you and your loved one. Thank you!

[@블랙-i6z]

얼마나 오랜시간 공부하셨는지 놀라울 뿐입니다

[@roberthelms1737]

Marvelous. Mimicking voices is hard enough. You would have fooled me in a blindfold test.

[@savlecz1187]

I'm sorry, did you just teach me Fats Waller's style in 40 seconds? This is legendary, thank you so much!

[@naj_z]

What a blast it would be be able to play like this! I’m only dreaming… respect

[@SirCommoner]

Erroll Garner was incredibly accurate, and is in fact ready to be sampled for lofi hip hop

[@dtjdoutney]

This simply couldn’t be better

[@perfectbeat]

Wow. To say I'm impressed is an understatement. 😵