America's Got Nutters - Part 3

[@haosci1]

I think billy did have a special talent -- a man who can sing with a female voice.

[@artofvoice]

Yet a few years later a goth looking guy goes on and sings opera in his countertenor voice and they go insane and LOVE it. I feel bad for the guy. I'm surprised at Sharon telling him to "sing like a man". Thought she was more open-minded than that. It's like they tell the audience to be on their worst behavior too.

[@melaniehamilton6550]

I think the "sing like a man" comment shows Sharon's ignorance regarding operatic voices and music in general. Most people have no idea that there's any such thing as a countertenor. My problem with guy is that he sharped and flatted all the way through his performance. UGH!

[@artofvoice]

Indeed..critique the technique! I look at him the way I would any other singer that goes on these talent shows. It's not about his range, it's about his quality. And a lot of times, people are really impressed by range or by volume(as we saw with that one teenage girl's viral video that's going around) as opposed to technique and skill. I'm really sensitive to pitch as well so I know exactly what you're talking about. But yea...super ignorant of Sharon :/

[@geminikb]

Melanie Hamilton yes he was pretty out of tune. That was the problem. If he had really done a great job they would have been very impressed.

[@melaniehamilton6550]

The opera singer is formally considered a countertenor which is a legitimate voice in the world of opera. The problem with this guy is that he kept drifting off key, not to mention that he hit sharps and flats throughout the piece. Extremely painful listening if you have a really good ear and/or perfect pitch. The creators of the "Polka Today" looked like spastic disco dancers to me. I'm only glad they "accordionized" a song that makes me want to bazooka barf in the first place. Did they wear the bright yellow costumes as a nod to "Walking On Sunshine"? Kind of icky.

[@douglasmarkwith]

Not understanding the hate for the opera dude, who was actually fairly decent. Other male opera singers have performed falsetto and been praised for their performance.

[@SyMoane75]

His problem is he went on America's Got Talent and not in front of someone in Opera. That's what he needs to do.

[@carolinecutler9080]

His voice hurt my ears. I love opera and this guy definitely is not opera material. Men have been on AGT using falsetto and did well but this guy is painful to listen to. My ears still hurt.

[@kikafightstheboredom7029]

He was too ahead of his time. Today it would have been different because it would be insulting and discriminatory to tell him to sing like a man, or ask him wether the piece was written for a man

[@israelcartaya4460]

"this is america come on jonh sing like a man"

[@cressidatroylus1522]

He sang out of tune. That's what they should have focused on, not because he's a male soprano.

[@devonbilodeau8589]

they do not have male sopranos men who can go high are called tenors NOT sopranos

[@cressidatroylus1522]

There are male sopranos too. Every boys choir has them. Usually they are young as boys voices change usually during puberty but this guy maintained his high range over the years.

[@evalu3260]

Israel Cartaya his singing was not that good to WIN.

[@higgsboson9509]

They apparently aren't aware that there's such thing as MALE sopranos.

[@aarondeepchawla]

And I thought British crowds were harsh! Jeez...

[@deborahingle2301]

Can we just appreciate the Hoff dancing that last singer offstage? Brilliant.

[@MrKlausbaudelaire]

wow, that guy singing "Carmen" was a perfect impersonation xD when Pier pressed the buzzer I was like "are you DEAF? that guy could pass as a woman in a radio"

[@corjonbett]

His voice shifted pitch constantly, and never hit the right tone. Listen to someone singing that song PROPERLY and you can EASILY hear the difference.

[@vincevengeance9755]

without simon, american idol or talent or british or etc is meaningless. i like simon. he give professional advices.

[@Domunication]

Jerry Springer is one of the best people to come out of America

[@kingthorusus]

They were too harsh with the opera guy, i think he had pretty much talent

[@rscosworthfan]

he was crap anyone could put an elastic band around their testicles and sound just like that

[@JontyMaster]

Yeah I agree with you! Let's face it....he's a better singer than me!

[@alyxantyx1236]

Dear America, I apologise on behalf of the British population for Piers Morgan.

[@lauremurkuns7059]

And I apologise for our overly rude judges & the audience.

[@wolfmomma2118]

And we, America, apologize for the rude behavior shown. I promise you, not all us behave so obscenely.

[@TheKilroyman]

The Opera Singer was by far the funniest in this compilation! I always laugh when he starts singing! XD

[@KaraokeQueenOfficial]

"Nutters" is such a....generous...word

[@johnalang]

That ventriloquist obviously did not know what ventriloquism was.

[@i40329]

Ursula's voice is great

[@dancer3205]

It does take talent for the guy to sing in that high pitch. And he wasn't bad at it. It's unique - isn't that what the show is looking for? Unique talent?

[@corjonbett]

They're looking for people WITYH talent. Being able to sing like your (Censored) are in a vice isn't talent. Being able to keep the pitch consistent is, and he was NOT.

[@nukaghoula]

Wtf the opera dude was amazing

[@SEVENTEENCINEMA]

I admit that the crowd can be a little harsh, but this is a talent search, not a kindergarten talent show. Besides, most of these people deserved to get booed offstage.

[@timoteez]

The judges and the crowd are so mean to everyone!

[@juliaculloden]

I thought the polka dancing.couple was adorable. And how much fun would it be doing that with someone you love? Looks like a blast. Gotta love love!

[@SargentandGreenLeaf]

the look on the hoff's face at 1:00 is great

[@bodhixxx1]

The audience is so distracting I wish they would not be so loud

[@MetalSmasherGaming]

In this video, David performed his most heroic rescue ever. He rescued the audience from a horrifying singer who doesn't know when to stop.

[@TsarIvanIV]

The opera singer had a really good falsetto, thought he wasn't half bad really. But I have to say i lold when Jerry was like "....not the voice I expected."

[@linepenciloffice4007]

They should be called ”Polka 50 years ago”

[@linepenciloffice4007]

DAVID HASSELOFF Bounnavong what?

[@Radvox.]

HassleHoff is a legend

[@dreamera1]

for the camp counselor i have a eerie feeling one of her campers heard her singing and joked "YOU SHOULD GO ON AMERICAS GOT TALENT!!" and she took it literally. LMFAO

[@Edgebotv4]

America truly has the best nutters, i am in awe. USA USA

[@crpsaiyan]

1. Corky Duke?! I think you should call yourself "Corny Duke" after that kind of dancing. 2. I just received a call from RuPaul, and even he wants you to "sashay away." 3. If that's "polka today", how much do you want to bet that "polka tomorrow" would be the exact same song and dance routine? 4. Mr. Phil, please don't jump up and down. We know what your last name is, but we don't need to see it should your pants happen to fall off after all that jumping. 5. you don't belong on a stage. You belong in a mental institution, and take that rag doll with you in case you get lonely. 6. ... No comment. 7. Are you drunk? You must be considering that you're jumping all over that "shard-onnay". 8. See, the way it works is, when 3 buzzers go off, it's your cue to Ski-Doo.

[@slinkiwaffel]

"yes - we fell in love on the dance floor" *awkward somehow robotic stare at each other*

[@Captureitall]

The opera singer was AWESOME! :O

[@ffragsks]

Tip toe through the tulips!!!!! greaaat voice, why did he get voted off...

[@jaerirob644]

LOL the last lady is the funniest. It's like she's saying "I don't give a shit that you buzzed me out, imma gonna keep on singing >:D"

[@dra353]

Hi im an american and i like all genders of music because im always on the road. i like to listen even to foreign music.

[@phoenybean]

Billy Dodson reminds me of all those little face pictures on the Internet.

[@ewcynka90]

" When Amaerica sees Polka Today deffinetly we will win America's got talent" hahahah

[@libblyster16]

"It kind of looked to me like you were in a blender." ROFL oh David you make me laugh

[@Profidelis]

@waddlepenguin1 they understood that he was just making fun of them and that this was not his real voice, so they told him to sing like a man , that means that he has to sing with his OWN voice and not cheat like a little girl. That's what they mean.

[@fourzerozerozero]

You're an intelligent man. Thank you.

[@LordGoatAlmighty]

On behalf of all the English I'd like to thank the guy at 7:17 . And yes he is. A massive one at that.

[@CreativeUsernameEh]

That night, a forest grew.

[@kyleman82]

i luv the song the polka dancers are dancing to.

[@IvanJacobsvelocity]

It's good to know that I can become a professional line dancer at any moment of my life without any preparation what so ever

[@jongaulthero]

"And what do you do?" "I'm a professional line dancer." "NEXT!"

[@jimanderson555]

Piers just pretending to be Simon !!! Can't quite pull it off or usually agree with Simon anyway not Piers 😝

[@joselara-perez1997]

Fuck yourself

[@DragonPrincessAoife]

Polka today? I don't even want to THINK about what tomorrow will be like.

[@pardwayne]

Man, where were these boos during the '12 presidential debates?

[@-belue-6697]

MR. PHIL got that catchy beat!...GODS DAMNIT! 😒🙄😂

[@egomethods]

lol The hoff "John Wayne would love you sing like a man " lmao

[@EchoEnder]

Nah, he just doesn't hesitate to call out crap when he sees it.

[@iggykidd]

That was an amazing soprano for a man his size! He shoulda gotten something!

[@corjonbett]

He did. He got BOOED off the stage. He apparently thought high pitch was all that you needed to sing opera. Nobody ever taught him that you need STEADY pitch, plus to be coherent! I couldn't understand a WORD of that, except the one where he stopped, he sang WAY too fast!

[@ValkyreBomb]

@OriginalBloodAce i dont think it was an actual act mate i think its just an intro, i was thinking the same thing it looks cool doesnt it? but im almost positive its just an intro piece

[@lululu5631]

3:04 he with she voice was good

[@hydrogenhelium123]

the dancers were kewl...

[@ohhellman]

i liked the line dancing!

[@k5elevencinc0]

Peter McIntosh needs to become a comedy!!! that was funny as hell!!! XD LMAO!!!!

[@Littlehummer8812]

great reps of friggin Staten Island right there

[@kleverrenaeme3538]

All I can think when I see that Phil guy... JUMP THE RIGHT AND YOU SHAKE A HAND JUMP TO THE LEFT AND YOU SHAKE THAT HAND MAKE NEW FRIENDS TIE THAT YARN AND THAT'S HOW YOU DO THE SCARN if you get that, all the beets for you.

Look, what don't you understand: it's Polka today ...polka yesterday and polka tomorrow!!!

[@DragonRadar52]

I appreciated that man's falsetto.

[@i40329]

Was that Fa Diaz?

[@wolfdefender01]

that opera singer made me LOL!

[@louiseviau7926]

The Mr. Phil dance would be useful on a camping trip when you are pooping in the woods without toilet paper and something is stuck to your bum. Just jump up and down and shake. It might work help you out of your dilemma. Useful.

[@poolygirl13]

Sackrace...that's just hilarious...I think I laughed for a good ten minutes

[@GriffinsGalore]

HAHAHA first guy was actually great :D

[@kimmiekkat]

hahah! I liked the Phil dance!

[@riffmagos]

Judging by the crowd, I can say America definitely DOES have nutters.

[@TheOfficialMusicLuvr]

I would have voted yes for the guy that sang like a woman! Maybe his voice wasn't the best one but I liked the singing and the talrnt was unique!

[@tizerspiritualist]

the guy with the opera voice was actually good.

[@Scormac]

Didnt think the bald opera guy dude was bad at all :o

[@rovert40]

*someone God-awful does a routine* Sharon: "It's a 'no' from me, but thank you very much for coming, and it was nice having you. :) " *Mr. Phil does a routine* Sharon: "I think you could go now, BYE BYE!"

[@GDOBSSOR]

@TheEnglishSoccerKid Male high voices are called tenors or countertenors

[@krziga1]

@Zenitune he is fuckin vocal genius

[@bilhernia]

The jury are ignorant, how does they dare to say to a profesional opera singer to "sing like a man"? Their ignorance doesn´t allow them to know that there is something called countertenor, that is a man with the hability to sing like a woman; a person that probably has more talent that those three together. I used to think that Sharon had full knowledge in music area, I´m really dissapointed......

[@wilmwilmink6695]

David Hasselhoff was thinking that he "sings" against the Berlin wall, to rear and break it down. That i call sober a nutter !!!

[@StrawberryEyes0]

what was bleeped out that you have no idea of? =P

[@basemjs]

@MsAsianNinja and wht do they get after performing to the queen????

[@S.C.500]

Querkey Duke: 15 years my ass Billy: I agree, sing like a man. Polka couple: You should dance only at home. Mr. Phil: My dad who's not a musician could s*** a better song than you can write one. Peter: You'd be a better ventriloquist if you learned to talk without your mouth moving. The girl after Peter: ?? Glass girl: you got anything better to do? The lady at the end: you cannot sing.

[@KarnRulez]

That audience is a little too fucking harsh. It takes alot of courage to get up on national t.v. to showcase what you can do. Seriously these shows suck.

[@corjonbett]

Courage without intelligence is worthless, and even suicidal!

[@unholyperiodza5442]

That Peter McIntosh has anger issues.

[@patricadyson778]

What state is This at.Remind me neve r to go there..

[@Acerrin]

buzzed before even started, hahaha

[@sendhimtodetroit]

Yes, Euros. It takes a special kind of intelligence to watch a tongue in cheek talent show and take it seriously.

[@ПолковникЗайцын]

"Sing like a man!" "This is America, John Wayne would love to hear you sing like a man!" Good old days...

[@kayraalicek.8264]

Русский Котэ: Good?

[@VictorJv2011]

the opera dude had his testicals removed so he could sing like that... Doctor goes...'' opera voice or balls? '' Opera dude goes...opera...

[@keithterrill2303]

Watching the Britain's Got Nutters vs the America's Got Nutters one major thing stands out: the American audiences are much much ruder, ill mannered, and intolerant.

[@P2000Camaro]

Aww! I really wanted to do the Mr. Phil!!!

[@Nemi246]

Pretty sure that if he combines that song with a cute dance it could go really far, yeah :D would've done it myself if I was anywhere near the music industry haha

[@highroad214]

Not to mention she seems like she is actually having fun and not just phoning it in for TV like most of the other Hollywood fakes they have hosting these type of shows.

[@Synergy1898]

The opera singer, holy shit he's amazing :O

[@MrEgen97]

Sing like a man? I'm sorry, but that was incredibly impressing, he should have gotten a yes!

[@TakerKaneanite619]

There was a guy on Britian's Got Talent, that did a similar thing, and he got 3x Yes.

[@ANDREA-kk2gx]

Ya I thought so too..WTF

[@MrEgen97]

+Andrea Fields Just sad to watch the stupid judges..

[@innocentferret2365]

He had a good voice but was out of tune somewhat. He needs training certainly.

[@WobblesandBean]

Hey, show some respect! Sharon Osbourne is probably the most courteous, patient, honorable person that's ever been on the show, hands-down. She is a sweetheart and has been through a hell of a lot more crap in her life than you probably will ever see. There's no need to swear. And frankly, she's right, Habanera is for a mezzo soprano FEMALE, and he really didn't do it justice at all.

[@dreamera1]

"I am peter McIntosh. And I am a MAC."

[@samlozza2140]

I know! he had a good voice!

[@juliefrantsen78]

In this... Piers is wors than Simon!!!

[@gentrywalker]

Lmfao Philip Weiner

[@MrPiano90]

DAVID: "Thank youuuuuuu,..Corky!" (Followed by LOUD BOOING from the audience.) Funny!

[@bailincen7472]

AUSTRALIA'S GOT TALENT IS DA BOSS! Hehe just wanted to say that ^^

[@kendra9377]

LOL looks like the whole Weiner family auditioned 6:30 and then his wife 8:01

[@29Heloy]

That nutter at 6:17 reminds me of Reuben from the Ocean's films :P