Josh Shapiro | Full Episode 10.18.24 | Firing Line with Margaret Hoover | PBS

[@rhyothemisprinceps1617]

Thanks to Gov. Josh Shapiro and Rep. Charlie Dent for supporting Vice President Harris and for working hard for the people of Pennsylvania!

[@richardmatthews8683]

I just watched this and I’m very impressed with our governor Josh Shapiro. The fact that he got upset with what Trump said about Charleroi shows that he cares. Charleroi is my home town, it’s not perfect but it’s peaceful. This man is a great statesman, with common sense. He would make a great president one day. GOD bless. P.S. Margret Hoover is magnificent!

[@suannecaccamese8805]

I grew up visiting family in Charleroi. I have wonderful memories of my youth playing with my cousins. The economic decline of this Mon-Valley community started when the steel mills began to shut down in Pennsylvania….it has NOTHING to do with the immigrants who now live in this community. I work at a thriving independent community hospital near this region. I have seen an increase in Haitian and Nepali service workers in our hospital. They are filling the needs to have housekeeping and service staffe positions filled in this hospital. They are contributing to the workforce in this community. Thank you Margaret Hoover and Gov. Shapiro for bringing this to light and setting the records straight. Proud to be a Pennsylvanian under this leadership!!!

[@LibertyWines]

@suannecacamese8805 Having to come to PA at age 2 from NJ and as a student of history & economics, you're right, PGH & NEPA's steel mills closing in the 70s/80s started a 40-year economic reshuffle that still going on as we re-orient to a more knowledge, service, high-tech & healthcare economy. Your data & experience is on the money in 2024.

[@jakebe4915]

I'm from Pennsylvania, and Governor Shapiro is a marvelous public servant. Harris Walz 2024..

[@ayandanxumalo961]

Future President 🙌🏾🙌🏾🙌🏾

[@beagleman123456789]

Is America 🇺🇸 ready for a Jewish ✡️ President ?

[@twd6568]

Doubtful. He should have been the her running mate but the machine still won't allow it.

[@ScrubberSlave]

@@twd6568 The "machine" wanted Shapiro to be the nominee. The optics of passing up a black woman wouldn't allow it. When it became Kamala she didn't want to piss off Michigan by picking a jewish VP.

[@thomasw.5344]

Very cool, thank you! I like him

[@DIYcraftdepot]

He was my choice for VP but, maybe he can be President someday. He is fantastic, and I say that as a republican!

[@RichardTaylor-y3n]

At first glance, this man appears to be finest talent , not only in the field, but overall, in politics today. Head and shoulders above any That we have seen, Maybe in a long time.

[@KhoiNguyen-uw3jh]

Love Gov Josh Shapiro ❤️ 💙 💓

[@patrickmc3827]

I have to respectfully disagree with Josh Shapiro's take on Bob Casey showing courage for changing his stance on abortion. Senator Casey's father was a pro-life hero, and he spat on that family legacy if it meant cruising through a Democratic primary. Watching Bob Casey dishonor his father's good name made his subsequent election loss to Dave McCormick all the more satisfying.

[@mjc63]

Governor Josh Shapiro definitely has a bright future among a deep bench of many well qualified Democrats, however, I am glad he opted out of the VP slot as he can still help deliver Pennsylvania whether his is on the ticket or not. Shapiro impressed me by getting I-95 operational in about two weeks and not taking months or years. This clearly required focus by a very capable executive. Pennsylvania is a vast state with large cities and suburbs, along with swaths of rural areas and will provide an excellent training ground for a future Presidential run in 2028 or 2032! Cheers, Michael Albuquerque NM USA PS I really admire your tenacity Margaret yet you remain civil, engaging, and keep your guest comfortable and continuing to open up to you!

[@bjv2323]

Pa women wake up you got 13 days wake up!! There is no way in hell trump cares about you or those country!! Just watch his speeches and here his lies This shouldn’t be close in PA wake up

[@GABABQ2756]

Great interview, Margaret!

[@johndeere1951a]

Excellent guest and sober honest discussion 👍👍👍👍👍

[@lorischneider7100]

I feel blessed to have Josh Shapiro as my Governor of Pennsylvania. He is practical, has common sense, does not mince words, , did a great job by picking Al Schmidt, Republican, to oversee that the Pennsylvania elections are honest, and there was no fraud in the Presidential election of 2020. Joe Biden and Kamala Harris won Pennsylvania fair and square. Thanks Governor Shapiro and Al Schmidt!

[@kennethwilson8633]

Love your show you are so non biased and ask what I would if I could.

[@Atom63-f3y]

Love both Margaret and Josh! Great interview! Kamala is lucky to have him in her posse💙

[@pamlewis1183]

He would make a fabulous Attorney General of the US

[@LibertyWines]

Much looking forward to hearing our PA Governor with Margaret. Margaret is my favorite PBS journalist & host - she's super intelligent, highly informed, on point, creative - simply the best upcoming journalist!

[@willgray2000]

Harris’ biggest mistake was not choosing Shapiro as her VP 😂😂😂

[@Tya-8542]

Dam if she does and dam if she doesn’t 😢

[@willgray2000]

@@Tya-8542 it’s the latter

[@Nebula831]

She's intimidated he'd outshine her... obviously

[@ZOELIFE23]

The answer as to why people support trump is because he is the wizard of Oz..a small,old man inside of an image that people perceived him to be

[@track1949]

I'm so old I remember Bill Buckley being the host of Firing Line.

[@milart12]

Haha Me too. I was just watching some of the old shows here on KZbin. Great time capsules.

[@maritzabatista5277]

We need politicians like Josh Shapiro. He seems to care about the people, not just democrats. He's governing for the people, not a party.

[@user-st4fj2ii2h]

Great job as always Margaret.

[@diannasgardenmenagerie967]

Josh is awesome, I wish he was our govenor!!!

[@lisastjohn2076]

The entire world suffers things ripped away, thanks to governments more so than not. That’s why respect is a fight instead of a norm….therefore the vote matters in a step by step hike over a thousand mile journey. Earth is wealthy enough for there to be no hunger, homelessness or blood letting wars. We just don’t collectively get the common sense simple, yet.

[@willgray2000]

This was a softball interview in comparison to Bill O’Reilly 😂😂😂

[@criscross7362]

I watched Bill O'Reilly several times, and he never interviewed people. He confronted his guests and did not allow them to answer his questions.

[@willgray2000]

@@criscross7362 watch the Hoover O’Reilly interview idiot

[@cleansingyourbodysoul3383]

21:30 so we probably won’t know who wins on election night 😢 kind of scary At least in PA

[@track1949]

We did not get the final PA results of 2020 until the following Saturday. The same thing may happen this time.

[@REC2400]

the enemy within, yes, yes, he is.

[@richardstratton]

Fracking may prove to be indispensable to geothermal energy production.

[@jcc9549]

True but….it does create earthquakes.

[@jakebe4915]

Fine...put it near YOUR HOUSE

[@MickeyHughes-c9k]

Well said

[@arussellhart]

So much strength in the Democratic Party; so much weakness in the republic party.

[@susanneryan5727]

I like her interview except for keep repeating the polls add ask why PA people trust Trump on safety…. Him pointing out the clear hypocrisy of this…. Was the only answer anyone can give…… First polls are not the TRUTH So you are making an absolute statement that may be far from the actual truth But you keep repeating it as if it is fact Not your opinion but the true opinion of Pennsylvania So this is part of the problem…. To report the news in this way! To address the issue is important and you did get him to state the facts clearly!!!!! But then leave it there….. Allow those facts to stand Instead of asking why people fall for fascist rhetoric!!!!!! That’s a whole show!!!!!! Bring on guests that this is their expertise!!!!!!! Why did the Germans….. Fall for hitlers blaming others for Germany s problems Screaming lies, and cruelties Being a strong man and saying I’m your savior, I’ll protect you, I’ll save you. You’re the best .. Those other races are bad, Jess are bad….. Why, Why Why….. Why did they believe him !!!!! Same is true for all dictators, The slide from democracy to fascism …. It’s not the first time in history it’s happened…… Ignoring it’s happening now is allowing it to happen….. Let the governor speak to what he can as to best policies that are helping people Including safety issues….. And how detrimental Trump is for this But …. Do your why, why, why questions to experts in the field

[@milart12]

Harris should have picked him for VP.

[@BrianMorisky]

Disagree. This guy sends major careerist empty-vessel vibes. He and Pete Buttigieg need to be nowhere near the White House.

[@milart12]

@@BrianMorisky I like Buttigieg as well.

[@EternalSelenaQuintanilla]

And Biden should have picked Whitmer to carry the torch.. guess we don’t always get what we want.

[@track1949]

Josh is a Jew. For some people having a black woman running for potus is about all they can handle.

[@track1949]

​@@BrianMoriskyBeing in the Cabinet means Pete has been in the WH dozens of times. 😅

[@RaufikTajuddin]

#joshshapiro the best team player's Harris Walz 2024 🎉❤

[@ericbecker710]

Wow--he feels our pain! That's original!?

[@jillfeatherman5523]

I would feel so disrespected that they think legalizing weed is the key to a black man’s vote. Like black men don’t have the same concerns as any other American.

[@Fix_It_Again_Tony]

I think it has to do with the racial disparities for who is arrested for low level marijuana possession violations. It's not that all black men smoke weed, it's that when they do, statistically they have a greater chance of going to jail for it. It's more about criminal justice than weed, but it's just time to legalize it anyway.

[@Daniel-od6ft]

Don't be surprised if at some point years down the road, Shapiro is the Democratic Presidential nominee. Very talented politician in the biggest swing state.

[@Daniel-od6ft]

@@zherin2063 True. I think Shapiro might be more likely if Harris loses and then there's an open primary in 2028.

[@mikerusso7095]

Hopefully our future president. First breakthrough: Kamala. Next: Josh. Diversity is a sign of strength and vision!

[@cheridavis6853]

Would love to see him President one day.

[@dantheman8279]

Interviewer did a good job trying to make him answer the actual question, he cleverly misdirected a lot of his answers, many of his answers contained non-facts. Josh is definitely a people for the sheeple, not for people who are highly educated and aware.

[@jcc9549]

Oh come on, the RATIONAL answer is she didn’t know better before she became VP and NOW that she has had the hindsight of experience, she’s evolved on the issues. Duh.

[@January.]

*Would be a great VP and president*

[@NickPalmisano-yp4qp]

This guy is the future President of the United States of America.

[@jennifierpai4696]

🇺🇸💙💙💙💙💙💙💙💙🇺🇸👍

[@paulsardella9324]

Great interview. Sharp questions inviting well thought out commentary. Josh Shapiro is the kind of stand-up individual I like to see helping our country to move forward in a positive manner. I hope he had written a nice" Thank You" note to D. Trump and his cronies for helping him to improve his prosecutorial record prior to his becoming governor. LOL

[@kenedytran]

Crime???? Trumpet is felony

[@LlyleHunter]

I don’t think that VP Harris was wrong trying to dodge the question when she was asked what she would do differently than President Biden. She’s still serving as his Vice President and it would be dishonorable and unseemly for her to answer the question as it would come off as criticism of the president that she’s currently serving. The press seems to miss the mark as badly as the Trump campaign does in this area where Trump’s campaign is running a narrative that VP Harris was somehow President of the United States for the last four years when she hasn’t been. She’s been our Vice President which means that she can break ties in the US Senate, stand in for the President in some diplomatic capacity and handle public appearances. I think that just as Trump’s campaign the press underestimates the intelligence of the American people in this area and in fact I think they see right through it.

[@babyyoda6549]

I swear this woman was one of the anchors on Fox News

[@Nebula831]

Harris didn't pick Shapiro bc she's afraid he's way more presidential than she is (I'm a minority woman) ... Walz was a 🤡 but thankfully a great gift for us MAGA!!!!

[@ricki-bobby]

Margaret Hoover... wow😍

[@AugustusSherman]

Thank you so much for this amazing video! Could you help me with something unrelated: My OKX wallet holds some USDT, and I have the seed phrase. (alarm fetch churn bridge exercise tape speak race clerk couch crater letter). Could you explain how to move them to Binance?

[@Fister-kw5un]

Pretend you are interviewing a Republican and give him tough questions! Childs play!

[@therationalparty6814]

But republicans pull out of interviews and don’t show up.

[@Miles4912]

​@@therationalparty6814that's true which is why i didn't attend that 60 minutes interview, too many fact checking and i didn't have enough diapers

[@bobyuan1254]

best politician❤

[@Tya-8542]

Now interview a republican with similar questions. Just my view 🇨🇦🇬🇹

[@DAVIDCash-q5o]

GOD HELP US ALL AND ME HOPE AMERICA WILL ALL TURE BACK TO GOD GOD IS GOOD

[@MexiMelt1988]

Chicago’s Biggest Halloween Parade Turns 10 Saturday With Its Hugest Event Yet

[@richardstratton]

Shapiro went 43-0 against Mr. T. Fact.

[@mattfoley6082]

Trump builds walls. Shapiro builds bridges.

[@jps0117]

Build me an island! Or at least a long peninsula!

[@jpgsf1978]

Trump only creates divisions. The classic bully mentality.

[@jakebe4915]

Over I 95 near Philadelphia, in record time

[@wp8286]

Can't wait for Shapiro to be president at some point.

[@Mario500NOW]

(suggesting for any past and future guest of any video similar to this one (along with the guest in this one): no vulgar (or profane) language)

[@appetites_and_delights]

This lady is so biased.

[@bobgarcia2844]

Margaret does reveal her leaning as do most "journalists" right now liked shilling Shapiro

[@evanwalgren9591]

😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

[@jonnanashko5170]

Excellent and straightforward answers to very challenging but valid questions ….. thanks….. the question of “why” is difficult for anyone, even the governor to answer….. better to ask those Trump supporters why to know their true thoughts and feelings….. I suspect that much of it is due to built up resentment or religious beliefs indoctrinated over many years….

[@neil1030]

I suppose he was too polite to say many of them are at best 'uninformed' or detached from reality. Sadly I know a lot of intelligent educated people who support Trump and don't see or care about the danger.

[@rhyothemisprinceps1617]

@@neil1030 If they are intelligent then suggest they watch Brian Tyler Cohen's interview of historian Heather Cox Richardson. She explains how in an autocracy, it's not what you know or even how hard you work, but who you know that matters. You won't be able to get anything done without connections and bribes.

[@jillfeatherman5523]

I’m sorry but I did not hear one challenging or difficult question asked of him about Kamala’s platform, like how she intends to fulfill all these promises she is making to the American ppl. Nothing. No substance whatsoever.

[@stevensko9153]

I encourage anyone to watch the TV show Chernobyl about the Soviet nuclear reactor meltdown in Ukraine and the events that followed you see very eerie similarities to how the Soviet party would act and how the Democrats act now.

[@zeitGGeist]

“Did trump lose the 2020 election?”

[@stevensko9153]

@@zeitGGeist is Joe biden president?

[@milart12]

Haha. EXTREMELY silly. MAGA is so full of contemptible morons.

[@Nunya-e4v]

Contrast is simple! Compare the 4 years of Trump to the current state of the country and the world!! A one minute analysis will make only one candidate standout. Everyone knows!! That’s the reason Trump will deliver a land slide victory both in PA and all of the USA!! It is time to end the chaos and bring, peace, love and prosperity to the country and the world!! Vote like your life and your children’s life depends on it!!

[@redhen689]

Trump’s presidency was total chaos. He is unstable and becoming more and more unhinged.

[@jpgsf1978]

The criminal. Too many Americans are obviously morally bankrupt.

[@leannelodata4164]

😊

[@mathtrixmusiclix4248]

QUICK!!! Someone get Margaret some acting lessons!!

[@scorekeepn]

Margaret is firmly planted in the swamp

[@jcc9549]

Charlie Dent is HOT! Lol

[@guile-md6mg]

Trump is a jagoff.

[@chriswaughrealestate]

Shapiro’s smart. But if “get stuff done” is the mantra, he has to also know why Trump is likely leading in Pennsylvania.

[@clarenceboddicker1162]

This guy does a great white Obama impression

[@ehudhaimovic1324]

The ignorance of the rule of law in general and how Roe V Wade was overturned in particular, plus the gaslighting in regards to Kamala Harris and her role in the government for the past 3.5 years is staggering! I did not expect much from Shapiro but M Hoover should have done more to hide her political tendencies. this was terrible

[@jillfeatherman5523]

Thank you. I thought I was the only one. I don’t care who she’s supporting for president. She can support and vote for whoever she wants to. But this is supposed to be an interview to inform the electorate, not a campaign pep talk.

[@marwar819]

Come on PA, save the country, vote Trump. I've always voted Dem. As much as I can't stand Trump I voted for him. It was a vote against Harris, not for Trump. Sad that PA votes for this guy.

[@jillfeatherman5523]

I’m so disappointed in PBS and Margaret. I used to really like her. I understand that she’s allowed to have a personal opinion on who she supports for president, but when PBS is receiving public tax dollars, they must follow "strict adherence to objectivity and balance in all programs or series of programs of a controversial nature". During this whole interview, it doesn’t sound like she’s interviewing the governor, it sounds like she’s desperately trying to brainstorm what more Kamala can do to win over PA voters like he did. Everything he says Kamala will do, Margaret just agrees with, totally forgetting that some voters actually watch because they are interested and want more information. She has zero interest in a substantive interview that could help inform PA voters to why Kamala is the better choice. When I hear a surrogate say “Kamala Harris will restore those rights and freedoms”…I want to know how. Is she willing to kill the filibuster? Does she have promises from 60 senators that they will codify Roe? If not, then it’s just a politician, saying anything to get elected and assuming the electorate is just too stupid to care. She does zero pushback, follow up or factchecking. This interview was to make her feel better, not to inform the American electorate.

[@Alex-lv7mz]

He would make a great President one day

[@January.]

No pathway to citizenship.

[@erniesandoval9669]

When Harris loses in November, she's going to think to herself i should have picked him especially when she loses Pennsylvania.

[@Seekthetruth3000]

He is a typical swampy politician.

[@Camille-v1f]

Nah. He's definately different

[@MrGwen62]

Trump 2024

[@jcc9549]

,,,,for PRISON

[@janetdistler7235]

God bless Kamala and Tim to victory for the people!

[@lembergnative7731]

well, that was less interesting than it could have been because of his shilling for Kamala

[@arussellhart]

Seriously? You mean like how FOX shills for trump?

[@erniesandoval9669]

Totally agree ☺️💯.

[@tombest1495]

get rid of josh shapiro

[@williamg8269]

LMFAO he's going to win by 20 points in 2 years

[@RSAXXX6969]

Definitely president material

[@January.]

*Would be a great VP and president*