Julia Hartley-Brewer’s fury at transgender Scottish prisoner row

[@talktv]

Should transgender women be allowed in women's prisons?

[@madjockcam3834]

There's no such thing as a transwoman. There is no transition, there is only self mutilation. After that, you're still a man.

[@UteHeggenTranswidowHeals]

No

[@jan9562]

No. With or without penisses, no.

[@vanhooler358]

Never, never, never, it does not matter what status is declared, a Woman is a Woman, a Man is a Man, can never be changed , ever, ever,

[@steveforster9764]

No

[@seandelap8587]

A man should not be in a woman's prison simple as that

[@madmelwood3778]

This makes the entire justice system a mockery

[@Hava744]

If they let these people get away with this ,it opens the floodgates. My husband should pay single persons council tax because I identify as a dog , therefore I do not need to be named as resident at this house . Where does it stop

[@seyley2901]

Woof !

[@hannahtattoo]

I'm going to try this

[@gailwong9273]

Killers should be identified as killers and they loose all rights after that

[@blondie4]

I identify as someone who doesn’t pay their mortgage but Halifax won’t have it 😢

[@sebastiennesp1978]

Tempted to commit an offense? if caught just say "Officer, I identify as innocent." Hey, maybe I could rob a bank, shoot a few people, and claim I'm a 7yr old. Under the age of criminal responsibility, Whoo Hoo!

[@taranormal11]

So he's a baby now. Would they move him to a childcare centre?

[@janeharrington1757]

Yes! Why is one of his delusions catered for and not the other? Which suggests they know he s not an actual child, obviously...but yet he can pretend he is female and they go along with it.

[@annetteannette9205]

Unfortunately yes

[@nikkioshea4139]

Good point.

[@seandelap8587]

He's a man and always will be

[@angusmacmillan5365]

Great interview! All those MSPs who voted for the Gender Bill in the Scottish Parliament should resign as they have shown they are not fit for government.

[@timwright5466]

I don't know who is messed up more..that person or some of the people who make the decisions .

[@scotlandtheinsane3359]

Sturgeon NEVER cared until she was caught out...

[@blondie4]

I was under the impression that when you go to prison you lose your rights? Putting that aside, criminals who are men should be in men’s prisons and criminals who are women should be in women’s prisons. Feelings should never override facts.

[@fromireland8663]

You lise your liberty, but retain your human rights.

[@jimberry7411]

we seem to be getting more and more better educated politicians with a proportionately depreciated level of common sense and wisdom

[@dermotkelly6946]

Can I identify as a illegal immigrant and get benefits, a house , doctors appointment, dentist appointment and pampered by do gooders , as I don’t seem to qualify for any of these as a native ?

[@geraldcoffey3303]

Men should not be in women's prison full stop .why is it even being justified in some areas Crazy and sick

[@seyley2901]

MORE AMMUNITION: Mridul Wadhwa, a former Holyrood SNP candidate, was recently made chief exec of Edinburgh Rape Crisis - a role advertised as reserved for a woman only candidate. (Check to see if that's the case). An article in 'Insidetime' a National newpaper for prisoners and detainees here in the UK, dated 13th January 2023. which said the following in one of the articles: "Women in prison have described how some transgender prisoners in female jails make little effort to live as women, and go back to living as men after they are released. A researcher interviewed 15 women in Scottish prisons about their experience of living alongside biologically-male prisoners who are placed in women’s prisons because they claim to be transitioning. One woman said of a trans prisoner: “She had a beard and she didn’t try. She basically had a short back and sides, and it was just … she just looked awful. And she didn’t try cover up her … obviously her down-belows or anything like that.” Another woman said: “The last one to get out, back living as a man. The one before that got out, back living as a man, while he was in the hall, was telling people, I’m stopping taking my medication because I can’t get a hard on.”

[@annetteannette9205]

Absolute travesty

[@elizabethh4648]

Utter madness. Thank you for airing this subject Julia...

[@davidrenton]

as a 'baby' they have therefore forfeit their Adult rights, they have no say.

[@radicalcartoons2766]

Exactly. If we accept him as a baby, there's no longer any distinction between children and adults. Children can be therefore be abused with impunity.

[@TheLastSongbird124]

ALL BRITS should send letters/emails to local Councils/Parliament saying they 'IDENTIFY AS ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS' and demand their free accommodation, free food, free health care and weekly cash in hand....that would shake it up :)

[@wayneevans5023]

Brilliant idea.

[@sandrastewart2450]

Fabulous idea free gym your own pool everything found for free money put in your bank acount free fags and drink

[@benrutter1746]

Typical idiot in the comment section 🙄

[@TheLastSongbird124]

@@benrutter1746 sorry Einstein, you above flippancy then? or just above everyone & everything?

[@benrutter1746]

@@TheLastSongbird124 just above your casual racism and typical bullshit in the comment section .

[@howardmcclellan2022]

Does anyone remember the scene from George Orwell's "1984" when Winston Smith is being interrogated? He was told at one point (by his interrogator) that "I can order you to believe that I can fly and you have to believe me..." It's some years now since I read the book so my quote may be a little inaccurate but it is close enough.

[@steviechat]

We seem to be working hard as a society to destroy ourselves. Stop capitulating to these lunatics.

[@charleshart6992]

How on earth is this allowed to happen?

[@topquark6919]

Political Correctness. Can't tell people the truth, for the fear of 'offending' them. It's the 'woke' culture. Feelings BEFORE facts.

[@paulredhead8603]

Stop the world, I want to get off.

[@Requestioner]

How long before a prisoner identifies as a free person and gets released?

[@DavesGarden1714]

No one should be allowed to transform while they are in prison

[@elizabethmcgeachy1001]

Where are the funds coming from for prisoners to go through the transitioning process...is this done on the NHS? Prisoners should not have any special treatment or consideration particularly when there is such a backlog of people with diagnosed or undiagnosed illnesses that are going untreated.

[@lucyallsop8946]

Those enabling this nonsense are the problem.

[@michaelcram8923]

We are being taken for fool's simple as that x

[@josephocallaghan3000]

this is just the start - the high academics back it to the hilt, even R Dawkins -- thus producing deluded students

[@JohnThomas-hv3nd]

Lead by fools..

[@jedburghpear9633]

The r ace comparison is a legitimate argument, if you can change sex, why not r ace? I agree with neither, a MAN is a MAN and your race is your race.

[@josephocallaghan3000]

nay, i am 5ft and 13 yr old girl, a bairn = that's ma TRUTH, an I am entitled to all the hormones and operations at NHS Tavistock House, Lunnon. I am not - not - a 6ft tall and 5 and 50 guy nay, I will breast feed with ma tater tops

[@cherylcallahan5402]

Talk TV with Julia Hartley Brewer appreciate your videos Listening 🌼From Mass USA TYVM 🇺🇸 Julia Hartley Brewer Blessings to all

[@tomkemp9465]

If they still have dangly bits they do not enter women only prisons

[@alphonsemoonflee299]

If they remove dangly bits they are still men...but without the dangly bits

[@janeharrington1757]

@@alphonsemoonflee299 Yes but it might put a few of them off...

[@moraymac2922]

Even men who are surgically castrated are still men.

[@tomkemp9465]

@@moraymac2922 I agree absolutely. However, they will find it more difficult to assault the real women in the prison.

[@blondie4]

@@tomkemp9465 men shouldn’t be in women’s spaces. Chopping off your penis and having a boob job doesn’t change the fact men are still men.

[@paulwhisker5863]

It's no wonder Lee Anderson wanted to bring back the D penalty for these animals.

[@alberttickle1106]

Whilst in prison they decided to transition..... No!!!

[@simon2knine]

I used to get a slap if i told lies, so he is a Man and always will be a Man. No Man should be held in a Woman's prison.

[@carolM9]

Unbelievable that this is happening

[@andrewb2475]

Good old Julia, she's a superstar she ain't gonna let this Trans lunacy die....good for her!

[@Pipsicle330]

I self identify as a loud proud hater of the SNP

[@St-lan]

they need an asylum

[@jerry4580]

To even talk about this lunacy shows how sick parts of society has become

[@tomf4547]

What's more hillarious is I bet the management take HIM seriously 😅

[@tommyhughes2264]

I identify as a Honey Badger, so what happens to me if i commit a crime, do i go to prison or a Zoo.

[@gabbsdad]

I’ve got blond hair and blue eyes but I’m black. Straight up!

[@betty-boo9821]

You're RIGHT Julia

[@elaine8417]

Man Identified as a baby, gets sent to juvy 🙄

[@misfit2022]

Sounds like this criminal is playing the system?

[@nikkioshea4139]

No man should be in a woman's prison, to not think ahead to the obvious consequences & problems should be a red flag at the efficiency of any politician who agrees with this.

[@hellsbells7271]

What the hell, this isn't a woman, this isn't a baby, it's a fully grown man who murdered someone so put the murderer where he belongs , in a men's prison. Stop with all this bs and start acting like the authorities should, next time this fully grown man wants someone to get hold of his hand , then they should and march him right to the men's prison where HE BELONGS.

[@margaretwyatt6689]

Totally agree with you Taking us for mugs

[@susangunn1268]

Scotland should consider building two transgender prisons, one for transgender males and another for transgender women.. this would resolve putting people pretending to be a transgender individual amongst male/ female prisoners.

[@Mehmehmeh746]

I know people like to make fun of us Americans for similar reasons, but at least we haven’t gotten to the point where an adult identifying as a baby would be taken seriously in any context except a psych ward.

[@jamesmoyes5685]

Straight jackets and padded cells at the ready!

[@niguel4438]

Baby’s? dummies? Figures!

[@chrislyons6692]

Thank god for him for showing the stupidity of it all

[@Mikehunthertz51]

Well i now identify as mike hunt hurtz and i must be addressed in my full name😂😂😂 play stupid games win stupid prizes😂😂😂😂😂

[@rosshempsall1985]

Feed him baby food and baby milk see how long he lasts

[@jedworthy]

I'm so glad I'm 80 and not 18!!!

[@marilyngonella8733]

come off it. when an adult says he is a baby then it obvious a transfer to a mental health facility is what is required,

[@josephocallaghan3000]

thats where Stonewall leaders should be.... the ones creaming of millions from Govt and tax payers

[@dodgynumber7533]

We are expected to accept and believe in this ridiculous pretence ….we have to believe that these male criminals are women. Now we are expected to believe that one is a baby……well…..I believe in Asylums

[@darrenporter1850]

So is it a crime is he has sexual relations if he is a baby?

[@1961-v9k]

Dear God you couldn’t make it up 🤯

[@danielhughes3816]

I am Scottish, stop playing to these creatures tunes & get them into men's prisons......PERIOD, if you do the crime you do the time in the CORRECT biological jail

[@1953streeky]

I identify as a lamp post now

[@barneyrubble8590]

Do you get turned on a lot?!😂

[@1953streeky]

@Barney Rubble Yes every evening which is pretty cool as I'm a non binary lamp post as well 💡

[@stephenholmes1036]

He is a MAN

[@tommyboy8588]

You can identify as anything you want in Scotland under the guidance and support of Holyrood that is anything you want except for a normal straight heterosexual as the SNP are determined outlaw this.

[@stevetodd7030]

Under no circumstances should Men be allowed into a Woman's prison whatever they think they are (apart from visitors that is).

[@gerrywoody4301]

Part of my identifies as Cumberland sausage yet its obviously a Chipolata can it go in the same pan as an egg?

[@ianwhitelaw3066]

Anyone who identifies as something else is obviously off their rocker.

[@barrythomson6329]

It’s only the British public that can stop this. These fools is high positions ain’t gona stop it. We need to rise up against this craziness.

[@stephenm8898]

Meanwhile we all focus on the trans issue while the REAL reason she resigned slips away into the sunset. What missing money?

[@stephenm8898]

It doesn't matter what he has or hasn't done he's a man so he shouldn't be in a women's jail

[@fromireland8663]

I am curious to know which prison (male or female) trans men go to?' We never hear anything about it! I wonder if the stats are being kept from the public because it would show that the whole problem only pertains to trans women prisoners.

[@richardjackson9031]

What happened to punishment ?

[@andykrykant5378]

Is it April 1st already?

[@aaronschwarz7951]

I applaud the sensible approach to this strange new world we live in… very matter of fact, no shame in calling a peach a peach!

[@MrDawson1569]

If that’s the pic of HIM he looks like mrs Doyle from father ted 😂

[@ianpurcell4445]

Get the straight jackets

[@maninst7145]

NO!! Get them out in the yard braking rocks instead of this watching tv rehab rubish. When they go to prison their liberties are supposed to be removed thats what prison is for . Its not a youth club!!. Anyway of he's killed he should be strung up!!

[@greigallan5845]

At this rate Scottish men claiming to be women will soon become an unwelcome national stereotype. I blame the Kilt. (I'm Scottish myself, incase anyone gets sore).

[@5Mariner]

What a joke! I’m actually laughing at the UK. LOL, 🤑

[@jackyhayes8613]

No definitely not

[@petergouvignon8048]

Rom 1:21 Because that, when they knew God, they glorified him not as God, neither were thankful; but became vain in their imaginations, and their foolish heart was darkened. Rom 1:22 Professing themselves to be wise, they became fools, Rom 1:23 And changed the glory of the uncorruptible God into an image made like to corruptible man, and to birds, and fourfooted beasts, and creeping things. Rom 1:24 Wherefore God also gave them up to uncleanness through the lusts of their own hearts, to dishonour their own bodies between themselves:

[@fredbear9073]

People can believe what ever they want but don’t expect everyone else to believe someone’s delusional thoughts. Only the dumb politicians believe in delusional thoughts. Just my opinion

[@josephmaxwell5033]

They are all fucking mad!

[@avgrim7729]

Hey it's a baby and baby's can't be sent to prison so just let it go!!!

[@radicalcartoons2766]

Exactly. This opens the door to no distinction between adults and infants. So infants don't need any safe-guarding, or even need to live with their parents. In fact, "parent" becomes meaningless if anyone can be an infant. We can all see where this is leading.

[@Lrs12359]

I’m a unicorn perfectly at home in Scotland

[@alexispaterson814]

Henryetta Thompson has had to go into protection while in cortonvale after the prisoners found out that This prisoner had groomed a 10 and a 12 year old boys

[@jillsomething1995]

For heaven's sake

[@kaynpaul]

Why the hell are they determined that its the women that have to host these men have a special unit in themens prison let the guys worry about them

[@TheBossUke]

What is wrong with this country when grown adults don't know right from left or up from down, who told the "lawmakers" that the public were ok with their idiotic decisions. Well the public have had enough of this claptrap and governments present or future better take heed.

[@sebastiennesp1978]

Tempted to commit an offense? if caught just say "Officer, I identify as innocent." Hey, maybe I could rob a bank, shoot a few people, and claim I'm a 7yr old. Under the age of criminal responsibility, Whoo Hoo!

[@barrythomson6329]

What’s is goin on ? We need to stop this absolute lunacy. The country is a total funny farm. Turning into America at this rate.

[@pfauniversal1890]

Welcome to Gammon land🤪

[@spookycat8556]

Does a woman prison officer have to change his nappy?🤢😂

[@jacklamat6315]

Don’t they got mental ilness in scotland? 😂😂 wtf this was insane 😂

[@mre7550]

Hard labour is a good remedy for anyone taking the P in prison.

[@cookiesfilmnetwork9937]

Baby he is for sure lol

[@philbrodie-ed7pr]

If in doubt play the "trans your way out of jail free" card

[@Spr87.87]

Stop it now Julia! 😭😂

[@damienadama]

Should transgender men be treated the same as transgender women The transgender argument should be treated like the transrace argument, attention seeking or mentally ill. Also there's a British case of transrace British to Asian Another thing watch the obvert intentional not arguing for (normal) men's rights. As men are being effected and hurt most by these laws and philosophies as well as their rights. Not women Is it really intentionally not mentioning those Sex or Gender facts MRM (Men's Rights Matters) 😂😂😂

[@Truthteller886]

Did you here Sam Smith the other day talking about that fact he likes fishing, he told the interviewer on the program that they aren’t fishermen or woman they called fisherings….don’t believe me ….I promise you’ll find it on you tube the worlds gone completely snowflake bonkers

[@dodgynumber7533]

No…. He called them ’FISHER - THEM’

[@Truthteller886]

@@dodgynumber7533 😂😂 you are correct

[@philbrodie-ed7pr]

Awake. Not woke.

[@ianmcdonald9885]

He obviously got the idea “that he identifies as a baby” after watch the superb Ricky Gervais series afterlife

[@leodoherty5304]

Women/Females do not have Cowper glands or prostates. However Men and ex-Men do as they are not removed along with the wedding tackle. The world is turning into a cesspool!