Mapping Pakistan's Economic Journey ft. Shabbar Zaidi | Junaid Akram Podcast

[@maddyk92]

If this is the epitome of the intellectual class of Pakistan, then i hope many more such small minded people occupy big offices and take their country to exactly where it’s headed.

[@MrRandom-qx7od]

He is finance guy not an intellectual

[@zoropiratehunter4103]

@@MrRandom-qx7od lol..is he ?

[@mindguru22]

@@MrRandom-qx7odnot even finance. He is a tax expert which very far from being good at managing capital and finance.

[@adnanhassan8314]

pajeetsssssss

[@percyzaiwala1370]

@@MrRandom-qx7od Does He know 2 Times Tables ?

[@manishjoshi9995]

Very happy and satisfied to hear such brains from pakistan....now it is very evident why this country has reached where it is....may pakistan be blessed with such great economists, historians, geography specialists, mariners, old trade route explorers.....this country is in safe hands...seriously.

[@dobo1873]

😂😅😊

[@thehuman428]

Kaha se bhai..kitna fenku hai..duniya ki pahali University bagdad me hai..sala apna Jamin ki history hi nahi pata.

[@satyenpatowary6697]

Look at the level of wisdom and knowledge of this Pakistani Scholar. He held Nehru and other educated Hindu class responsible for the partition of India, blaming squarely on their inferiority complex. But this jonab didn't know the simple historical fact that Sir Ahmed Khan raised the issue of a separate country even when Jawahar Lal Nehru was not born. Such is the level of education scholarship in Pakistan.

[@dobo1873]

@@satyenpatowary6697 and he claims, he buys books worth 1.5 lacs every month!!?? I assume he buys comic books that too written by leftist/Islamist and communists🙂!! I say in carryminati style...Paisa Barbaad bhe@#£od!!😂🤣

[@Param.G.C]

Reading and understanding is completely different things. If you read something doesn't mean you have understood. Majority Pakistani scholars are nothing more than a big Joke ( no disrespect here, it's just a hard fact 😔). As an indian, we need a better competitor. If our enemy is strong, then only we can aspire to become strong 💪 Jai hind

[@UmairSKhan]

Impressive how Junaid Akram managed to keep a straight face through the conversation😀

[@jatindersinghpandher]

Pappistan Zindabad, Gazwa Hind Kab hoga 😅😅😅😅😅😅

[@mujeebishaque]

Exactly. Never seen such embarrassment of a human in my life.

[@awaissiddiki1]

This guy is psychotic

[@dobo1873]

Aasmani kitabi keede ne kaata hai...!!🤣

[@satyenpatowary6697]

Deception is an inherent quality of every Momin.

[@monsterchopper1613]

There are so many Jumlas in his talks. 1. Nehru family had no land? Lol they were among the richest of India. 2. Muslims were landlords? No, India was full of Hindu landlords which was abolished in 1950. 3. British replaced sultanate? No, Marathas and Sikhs were in charge on India before the British conquest. 4. 3000 years of Invasions from Northwest that reached Delhi? Delhi was not conquered anytime before 1206, and Delhi is not India. Its just a province in Northern India. 5. Hindu inferiority complex? How am I supposed to answer this, it looks like this pakistani is exposing his own superiority complex in this talk.

[@awaisarshad8503]

Seems like not very stable mentally to me.

[@yugmathakkar4023]

It's not a superiority complex, it's rather an inferiority complex that they've been trying to overcompensate for for the last 77 years. They know that they're probably some of the most cowardly people in the history of mankind. Talwar ki nok pe salwar utar ke apna dharam hi badal diya, aur ab bolte hai ki hum to jazbe wali quam hai 🤡🤡Jabki inhone apni puri history me surrender ke alawa kuch nahi kiya. Aur inko ye baat bohot ache se pata hai, lekin kabhi admit nahi karna chahte kyu ki utni emotional maturity nahi hai inme. These people are very primitive in their way of thinking. Inki baate itni seriously leni hi nahi chahiye. Bas entertainment ke liye dekho lol.

[@abumaaz5768]

نبی صلی اللہ علیہ وآلہ وسلم کے والد کی قبر مدینہ میں ہے

[@yugmathakkar4023]

@@United_states_of_America_9-i1b surrenderistani cockroach appears in the chat 😲😲

[@yashpednekar331]

Don’t take him seriously. Watch him to learn how these Pakistani so called intellectuals are senseless, hence they are suffering 😢

[@asifali6794]

Junaid bhai I used to be a huge fan of your intellect but there's a new addition to that. Hats off to your patience. BTW this is the first-ever podcast of yours I left halfway through.

[@swapnilp5774]

Cmon bhai.. on such mindset only, Pakistan was created.

[@ateeqkhan66]

Shabbar sahib is wrong about Hindu inferiority complex - in fact they had acquired and adopted modern education after 1857. Hence by 1947 they were way advanced than Muslims in all disciplines including education. Right after independence they abolished feudal system and princely states, and always kept army in their original position i.e. at the borders.

[@tushar4506]

Also don't forget hindu upper castes were always the landlords and mughals didn't even change that fact they didn't try to change it.

[@AP-do6sv]

Bhai popcorn leke baitho dimaag mat lagao. Enjoy hearing pakistani intellectuals.

[@mithunkartha]

U r the true intellectual 😂

[@santusanturohit4832]

See the time gap between first hindu female graduate and first muslim female graduate.. Around 50years..Two generations of Muslim didnt go for modern education..was hoping some Turks,Mughal will revive Islamic empire once again by dethroning British raj.

[@AP-do6sv]

@@santusanturohit4832 dont behave like a pakistani and quote random facts. The difference is about 10-11 years.

[@atishamathur9014]

This guy talk everything except economy.. so typical of pakstan.. i must say pakstan need more intellects like him.. keep up the good work.. it was entertaining… 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@avtarwasson4875]

India was always rich due to business. That's why every few years Afghans, central Asians, used to invade India.

[@devilmahi8712]

AFTER LISTENING HIM,,,,,NO DOUBT WHY PAKISTAN IS IN THIS CONDITION....😂😂😂😂

[@swapnilp5774]

God is the greatest planner. He has planned this for Pakistan.

[@umumu1481]

Such mindset never progresses. Thank God, Pakistan was formed.

[@DonJuan-b9u]

When you have economists explaining history , you end up having comedy

[@ahmedsohail5634]

everybody have own perspecitve

[@bushanmehra9885]

But yet i found him a thinker,you have a point as far as history concern,during Mughals indeed there no Hindu land lords at least not much,but in 1947 there were lots of Hindu land lords,when we read about Acharya Vinoba Bhave's Bhoodan movement,then we realise how many Hindu land lord were,

[@digvijaysingh2305]

​@@bushanmehra9885chicha learnt history from lal topi zaid hamid 😂😂😂

[@NumberWorld]

He is CA, not economist, he pretends to be one.

[@AvinashKumar-vp8qo]

It was not even economic history, as he claimed. A bunch of BS.

[@mpqw]

Pakistan is the only place where an economist speaks less about money more about religion 😂😂

[@footballworld2023]

India is the only place where people care more about the health and well being of cows than the people of the lower caste 🤣🤣🤣

[@a.s-h1h]

😂😂😂

[@farazibnabbas5675]

Wo khud keh raha hai k i m done with all that economic kaam dhanda, he has started a retirement life.

[@mpqw]

@@farazibnabbas5675 so what am I supposed to do?

[@codifa5847]

so ironic from an indian

[@AlishbaRizviModel]

This was helpful... My perception of this guy was very different. I though he is a professional and an intelligent person. This podcast showed the inherent narcissism and stupidity that I never saw earlier.

[@krishnkant9477]

I always considered him an idiot

[@AbdullahShahid-zz1hw]

Kiya h is podcast mein ???

[@PanksB]

We should thank Junaid for bringing this joker to forefront 😂

[@AlishbaRizviModel]

@@PanksB Absolutely!

[@shd_khan]

What is he saying wrong?

[@lincabe321]

"Hindus weren't the largest landowners in UP, bihar and Bengal". Yes because muslims invaded the native hindu lands and stole it from them. Speak clear facts.

[@_shadyy]

uncle that's not the point. how they got it was irrelevant to the point being made.

[@hawkingdawking4572]

There was no such thing as native Hindu lands. The word 'Hindu' is Persian. The owners of Hindus - Brahmans- are Persian too.

[@yashpednekar331]

@@hawkingdawking4572😂😂😂 very funny. Madarsas me Padhi kya?. I am a Brahmin and I don’t have any Persian DNA . My DNA matches with the rest of Indians and also pakistani

[@yashpednekar331]

And converted Hindus to Islam

[@hawkingdawking4572]

@@yashpednekar331 You are Iranian colonist. Your DNA is a proof of it. The so-called Hinduism of the 19th century is a repackaged paper convert scheme to continue the slavery system.

[@TheEddy2211]

It’s not the inferiority complex , we were in this subcontinent even before Islam came here. Iran was Persian, Afghanistan was mostly buddhist and harappan civilisation was in Pakistan. Anyway seeing the internal security issue in Pakistan, i am glad that out we decided for partition and got rid of so many problems.

[@swapnilp5774]

And we,got rid of most crooked people too.

[@ShahJee101]

And now spending 100 billion just to maintain security. Kudos

[@swapnilp5774]

@@ShahJee101 Do you think India wouldn't need to spend on security if pakistan didn't exist?

[@sobanali5690]

@@swapnilp5774 Yes, because you still have issues with China, and then you would have had issues with Iran. You haven't been kind to your neighbours either. You are at war with China and Pakistan. You have a good relationship with Bangladesh at government level but your racist people hate Bengalis. You have invaded and taken over Nepal. Your country is also currently involved in terrorist activities in Pakistan in the North and Balochistan. So, understand that you are not saints either and if you believe that you are, then you are just a delusional nationalist.

[@prithvisingh7469]

I feel so proud to be Indian, thank god we don't have these self proclaimed historian\economists ruling our country. No wonder Pakistan is in a economic crisis.

[@sksumeet2555]

Indian's chief economic advisor Sanjeev Sanyal has written books on history. and there is a lawyer who is writing books on indian history

[@satpalsharma1285]

@@sksumeet2555 bro they definitely not have written book on conspiracies that this guy is scratching

[@sksumeet2555]

@@satpalsharma1285 read churn of ocean by sanjeev sanyal and any book by sai deepak.

[@legendaryhound5261]

Bro that guy reads books on a daily basis...he is just recalling his book knowledge 😂😂...wtf you on😂

[@onemanb8232]

Chutiya pura podcast dekh he was praising india in whole podcast and if you think he is stupid than his analysis towards india is also shit. Do you agree?

[@sahasss7100]

Man I feel so good that men like these are the "intellectual class" of Pakistan. I don't know what sort of Literature you guys read to come up with such explanations but the sort of growth we're making and the sort of "superiority complex" you guys have, as an Indian I'm just happy and assured that Pakistan won't even realise what hit them in years to come. Partition is the darkest moment in our history, it is the final contextualisation of the invasions faced by us in the last 800-1000 years but synthesizing it as "Hindu Inferiority Complex" is just apalling but yeah let's see where our inferiority takes us and your superiority takes you, if somehow that isn't clear even after 75 years of Pakistan failing as a State at every parameter.

[@mianammar2178]

As a Pakistani I'm hurt, but really appreciated the way u put your criticism. Respect and manners u showed in your statement. Appreciated. And yes bro he is just having a casual talk with the host, like what he thinks. So Pakistanis agree with him or not, its on us. Good for India, heading in the right direction but still with hell lot of problems to deal with. On the other hand, we are....😅. Bro there are a lot of problems going on here but remember we are not that much destroyed as media portray. Most of our problems are just a result of lack of governance, nothing else.

[@dlavanya1]

Saare converted log who dont even have any sense of their own identity and roots .. 😂 False Superiority mein khush raho You will perish soon with this attitude… lage raho

[@sahasss7100]

@@sarfarazsiddiqui5885 provide me literature which can substantiate this, you guys don't even know that majority of Mughal Rule was already snatched by Shiavaji Maharaj before the English Colonisation began. Pak Studies jisne padhi ho usse yahi umeed kar sakte hain🤣🤣

[@zainabideen3270]

Bro you took it the wrong way he was saying it for pakistanis in a negative connotation i believe and it becomes clearer around 45 min mark when he talks about Pakistan vs indians nobility. He said it in a casual manner and could have phrased it better but i think what he was trying to say was the difference of mindset between our people which is why India is doing way better then Pakistan rn. All the landlord at that time were muslims and Indians were professionals which is why they had the will to work and run businesses even after but due to our mindset being feudal at that time, we could never get out of it even after getting independence and going broke which is why now wee are struggling still. At least thats my understanding of it from listening the whole thing. I dont think he was trying to shit on Indians or anything

[@baloch5496]

What's worse is the fact that a huge number of Pakistani youth has a false belief that they have had a revelation about army and the truth of Pakistani rulers. This guy isn't even the biggest problem of Pakistan. The youth is.

[@NumberWorld]

*When a CA is pretending to be Economist, but also posing as someone who reads, explaining History, then basically all you get is LOHORI CHURAN* 😂😂😂

[@iamglad1359]

soooooo true bro 😂

[@praasangg]

He never read even a pamphlet for all I can see. Idiots of Karachi.

[@legendaryhound5261]

I mean atleast he reads books and recalling that knowledge

[@AmmarSoni-k1d]

Bakwas podcast

[@HKashaf]

Ray Dalio talks about history and other philosophical discussions. No need to be so close minded!

[@sb9060]

We All Pakistanis are possessed by the *black magic of Pinky Peerni* .... ..... IK Zindabad ...."

[@rajeevm9975]

At least he is true to his word “hum jaahil hai…”

[@swapnilp5774]

Such a honest man..

[@digvijaysingh2305]

@44:30 chicha missed the point, Majority 'Zamindars' in atleast UP and Bihar were Hindus, Muslim Nawabs and Zamindars in this provinces were restricted in certain pockets eg. Western UP and Seemanchal in Bihar. There was definitely a difference in mindset as most Muslim landlords never felt any attachment with folks under them who were majority Hindus. The abolition of Zamindari and subsequent land reforms had brought the change.

[@Mregg110]

This old man has no idea how big india is i am maratha from mumbai and we ruled entire land over here even we ruled in delhi after defeating mughals ye kaunsa superiority complex hai in pakistanio me 😂

[@gnxtpankaj]

Bhai ye sirf accounts ki book india leta hai, History to wo Pakistan ke books se he padhta hai 😅😅

[@sumitnanda432]

​@@Mregg110Bhai chacha sasta nasha islam wala fook kar rakha hai. Main punjab sey hoon wahan sikh raja ranjit singh ka raaj tha to angrez ney muslim ko kyun land dena tha. Nehru ko bata raha hai key inke naukar hain, par woh to kashmeri pandit they jahan dogra raja hari singh ka raaj that. Iski history iski accounts ki tarah hai.

[@Mregg110]

@@sumitnanda432 ye bhikari podcast chalane aur views ke chakkar me scripted fake show banate hai

[@suyashjedhedeshmukh]

​@@Mregg110hi landi yezi zalit bhau

[@qamariqbal4870]

He claimed that he buys urdu books and read them regularly. When Junaid asked please recite one or two lines from an urdu gazal. He took time but then could not recite a single line confidently. This happens when somebody pretends to be somebody else and fails miserably.

[@JohnSmith-sl6eg]

Initially I started listening to this guest seriously, but he lost me when he started talking about inferiority complex. Just reading books doesn't give knowledge or wisdom I think, if one is not rational and scientific everything is muddled up.

[@namansinghnegi8931]

No intellectual person would make sweeping statements about a group of people...also he keeps avoiding talking about the issue of land reforms as hot coal...

[@debamalyadey8904]

Same thing for me...but then I realise that it is his opinion...right or wrong....now if someone take his opinion seriously, then it will be his/her fault...

[@yasirpk2002]

You people still have it. Modi still waves swords to prove Hindus are a warrior race

[@AKumar-co7oe]

@@yasirpk2002 and Captain Safdar talks about Ghazwa-e-Hind. At least Modi is measured with his actual words for the most part. If you really want to compare the actual people making policy compare Jaishankar with Chooza, or compare this gentleman with the likes of Sanjeev Sanyal and Krishnamurthy Subramaniam. Zameen asmaan ka antar hai in their sophistication of understanding about the world.

[@yugmathakkar4023]

@@AKumar-co7oe bhai kyu in madrassachapo ke muh lag rahe ho inko kya hi pata actual sophistication aur intellect kya hota hai. Ye nihayati neech log hai inse baat karke koi fayeda nahi hai. Char Char baar apni marwa ke bhi nahi sudhre. Ye log Sanjeev Sanyal ko sun ke bhi usko gaali denge kyu ki inko kuch samajh nahi aayega wo kya bolre hai. Bandar kya jaane adrak ka swaad.

[@HOG1070]

very entertaining and hilarious listening 🎧 keep it up, very good and hilarious content. A Pakistani never fails to entertain.😂

[@sunilpatil1000]

All muslims were notbig landlords and majority of them were in poverty , best example of hindu class doing well economically before independence is Lahore before Independence all the havellis and businesses were owned by the Lala s and Punjabi Hindus and Sikhs

[@swapnilp5774]

That's the fact sir.

[@gautamsingh8358]

@44:51 when your guest said ki "hindu punjab, U.P, bihar ya Bengal province maii jamindar kabhi nhi tha.. ye baat bilkul galat haii. Hamare yaha hindu jamindar the....even bade bade Seth bhi the. But hamari azadi ke baad aise system or logo pe kade niyam aur strict laws banye gaye, common garib people's ko voice di gayi, jamindari system khatm ki gayii. Ek proper mangement banya gaya jis se jada se jada directly contact or direct benefit diya ja sake ek common man ko.

[@MrSalmanNathani]

Yes land reforms

[@Mregg110]

He have hindu fobia and hatred

[@joydeepmukherjee3889]

Bhai iski baton ko seriously mat lo .pagal hai yhea...aur acha hai aise aur pagal whan par ho to..😅😅

[@hassaanvault]

I don’t know if I should laugh or be sad; when a comedian had to give a disclaimer so that he couldn’t get arrested to speak his mind or host someone who is speaking their minds …. SO MUCH FREEDOM OF THOUGHT AND SPEECH.

[@rajsinghji-84]

Who was the comic here?

[@am_ac]

This finance guy not only reads books but also smokes some amazing stuffs. You lost me in the podcast moment he said, "Partition hinduon ne karwayi.."😂 Jinnah is hysterically laughing somewhere..

[@electronicsnoob]

Leeeo ye bhi hmari galti h 😂😂

[@MRBEYG]

i am against partition of India but it is a fact that Nehru is equally responsible for partition. just read more history and you will realize.

[@am_ac]

@@MRBEYG absolutely, every nationalist and educated Indian would agree with you, why else u think the current generation has a rampant dislike for Nehru, his policies and his pathetic great grandson Rahul Gandhi.. my hatred for the troika of Nehru, Jinnah and Gandhi holds no ends, my grandparents had to migrate from Shikarpur because of the whims and fancies of a few selected and elected b@$tards.

[@swapnilp5774]

I guess he has a,stall of second hand books. Lakhon ki books kharidke 1.5 guna me bechta hoga. Padhta nahi hoga.

[@swapnilp5774]

@@MRBEYG Thanks to Jinnah and Nehru then.

[@alexander_6344]

Such an enlightened person. The one and only candid Shabber Zaidi. He's got no chills!!

[@MrAhmed-dx5hw]

This should've not been an economy podcast instead should've been a history podcast.

[@vaibhavgeek]

Yeh interview dekh ke samajh aa gaya ki kyu Pakistan ki halat aisi hai 😂 Yeh toh typical dining table uncle lag rhe not a official having any responsibility.

[@anubhavsingh6436]

💯💯

[@murtazashoaib7358]

Well, he's not an official with any responsibility

[@vaibhavgeek]

He was chairman of federal reserve board. Check out interview of raghuram rajan who is ex head of RBI. He will never make such blanket statements, much more nuanced.

[@Ramostpak]

@@vaibhavgeekhe was chariman of income tax authority FBR not state bank governor.

[@Tattvam_asi]

😂😂😂😂

[@utkarshdwivedi6600]

I watched whole podcast just to understand mindset of Pakistani elite it's no different than Indian elite of 80s-90s similarities are very shuttle that for few minutes I thought I am listening to a lutyens guy. Anyway let me clarify to point he mentioned that" gorey ne hukumat musalman se Li" for that sir 1700s was end of Muslim elites in India especially in northern India & 90% Muslim elite was concentrated in Lahore,Delhi and Lucknow & rest of all region was dominated by Hindus & that is based on facts I don't know where he get his data & what books he read i suggest all my pak frnds to go & read who control most businesses in all indian cities in pre partition era believe number will shock you even in frontiers.

[@syedmuhammadfaheem8662]

You misunderstood his point. He is talking about the landowners and landlords. Jageerdars were mostly muslims. Businessmen and other professionals were hindus no doubt.

[@mayankjaiswal3738]

@@syedmuhammadfaheem8662 na bhai there were landlords hindu also. But after 1947 they lost all the lands.

[@utkarshdwivedi6600]

@@mayankjaiswal3738 here in India best thing Nehru ji did is land reforms & today's thing holding us our land reforms same with China they also need land reforms.

[@mayankjaiswal3738]

@@utkarshdwivedi6600 we need land, labour and agriculture reforms immediately

[@jojoexperience]

In the first 15-20 minutes I understood his intelligence level and how hard to laugh at this comedic show 😂😂😂

[@mohitsinghtel]

They cant keep Religion out of anything , They mix religion With finance , Food , Culture , Money , Land , Women , Children , Nature .. everything.

[@akxn2162]

​@@mohitsinghtelha lodu as if u can

[@piyushdas079]

without religion they are second class hindus@@mohitsinghtel

[@nYcbOyrameez]

@@piyushdas079 thats a Pakistani issue, not a religious issue. If it was mainly because of religion then other Muslim countries would have similar issues but clearly most Middle Eastern Muslim countries don't have issues integrating religion in their society.

[@SurajGupta_3D]

Only because those gulf countries had oil and never really had to face challenging situations....their money solved most of their problems...not look at today's Saudi Arabia and UAE they're becoming more modern and westernised cause oil is running out ​@@nYcbOyrameez

[@darthvader56]

Reading these comments give us a glimpse of why the Pakistani society is the way it is. The majority of the public has no political, historical and intellectual acument. In order to fix anything, we need historical context.

[@Journo5810]

What Shabbar sahab is saying is very deep.. Economic historian, Judaism, New York, wall street.. I hope samjhne walo ko samjh aye.

[@asadalisheikh110]

A huge issue about property phenomenon is buying some property in the hope of selling at greater price. And in that hope people buy property at every price because it's price will rise. This is how genuine buyer remains deprived of making any home. The major property thus gets concentrated in the hands of people with ill-gotten and untaxed / undeclared wealth.

[@Health-Blitz]

*He says Punjab, U.P, Bihar Mein Hindu Landlord Nahi Tha* 😂😂 *Arey Chacha, Kaunsi Daaru Peekar Aaye Ho Aaj* 😅🤗🤭

[@adnanaslam5858]

He means mostly Hindus were business and professional people but muslims were majority landlords. Offcourse Hindus were also but comparative to muslims they were less.

[@whomraja1704]

@@adnanaslam5858nawabs and landlords took loans from Hindus and survived

[@Mregg110]

@@adnanaslam5858ghanta 😂 delhi ka mughal chod diya jaye to poore india me sirf hindu hi jamin dar tha aur abhi bhi hai ye tum Jo converted muslim ho wo shudar kaum se ho jinke pass kuch nahi tha aaj bhi kuch nahi hai 😂

[@SATWIKRAJ-x3b]

​@@Mregg110even Lahore ke majority of property own by hindus😂😂

[@legendaryhound5261]

​@@Mregg110abe konsa daru peeta ha...Muslim Nawabs in each state were landlords, jin ki zameen har state specifically Punjab mein rehti thi.... especially in Pakistan side...han kuch Sikh Landlords they...lekin Punjabis were mostly muslims and un ki Punjab ke ird gird mostly zameenein hoti thi

[@Ali47_tech]

This is the first time Junaid Akram has mentioned disclaimer before start of this podcast. By far one of the most interesting and knowledgeable program. Shabbar sb has knowledge of both religion and economics. He should be utilized by current establishment to grow our economy, he can even take part in revising and Improving our education system.

[@orissa72]

And imagine has has thorough knowledge of economics and religion as well like every Pakistani. His services should be preferred not just by Pakistan but Arabs as well.

[@rajsinghji-84]

And he should be made the next Prophet as well even if Islam doesn’t recognise that. 🤣🤣 He is so hell bound to make Muslims suffer at least in Pakistan.

[@Ali47_tech]

@rajbaniwal3236 actually I don't understand why Hindus comment on Islam. I as Muslim respect all religions as it is person's personal choice. I suggest you should mind your own business and don't comment on any religion. Everyone is free to practice what he or she feels / thinks is the best religion. For me Islam is the best religion and that is the end.

[@mayankindian3750]

​@@Ali47_tech islam bana kha tha bhai islam Arabs ka culture continuation Hai thik hai or ye hakikat hai

[@Ali47_tech]

@mayankindian3750 that is not true. Islam is true religion. Muslims at the moment are not true reflection of Islam. We have to improve a lot and educate ourselves to be stronger and then only will be true reflection of Islam. But pls don't judge Muslims and other religions are almost the same, only difference is other religions are spreading false news and hatred which has to be stopped

[@humsarisindh]

Thanks Junaid اکرم for inviting Mr. Zaidi

[@Journo5810]

Shabbar sahab is best example of deen aur duniya me kaise tarakki karey intellectually.❤

[@baazinews1027]

*The Most Read Person' in Paksitan Says, '' West Paksitan, Hindu Ki Inferiority Complex Ka Nateeja Hai* '' 🤣🤣 *Mazaa Aagya Bhaii Aaj Toh, Happy Diwali Chacha HarrahmZaidi* 😀😃

[@madanpunekar1406]

Jinnah kabr me let kar soch raha hoga ki main tu youthiya hoon phir 😂

[@vardhamanpatil1539]

Please let me know who came from Afghanistan 2000- 3000 years ago.. Your guest's knowledge of history is Zilch..

[@AmongUs-ku3yp]

Seriously 😂😂😂 i think you are just mad

[@vardhamanpatil1539]

@@japneetsingh6637 I think Alexander wasn't Afghani.. Secondly, after initial success he was defeated in the north west part of India..he never ruled India..

[@muhammadali-pu2wg]

Abdali, ghori, mughals they came from west

[@vardhamanpatil1539]

@@muhammadali-pu2wg Shafar Jaidi is talking about invasions 2000-3000 year ago... Islam is 1400 year old religion.. how can Muslim invasions take place 2000-3000 year ago..?

[@Trilok_world]

​​@@vardhamanpatil1539bhai chhodo inhe inki knowledge islam se lekar islam me hi khatam ho jati hai, isne Logic or sence ki iksha mat hi rakho

[@sakshamsamadhiya3678]

Happy Diwali Bhai India ke taraf se, may you reach all the height of success and may the relations of India and Pak get better and hope that in some years we'll be able to celebrate the festival of lights together, cheers 🥂

[@zeeshanahmed7390]

Thanks

[@a-km9xq]

Happy Diwali fellow Indian ❤❤

[@bharatmaa7826]

But , you are a kafir

[@footballworld2023]

Happy diwali to my 🇮🇳 bros and sis from 🇵🇰

[@Murtaza_Ibn_Adam]

Happy Diwali love from Pakistan 🇵🇰 ap log Sach me humse bhot agay ho har field mein Dua karo Humhri country bhi success Kary

[@srajsprasad6146]

In total conversations about perfume is only correct

[@DalitisHebrewnotHindu]

Dear Friends, In order to be a CA, you need to do Economics to a small degree . For all those who dont know, The study of economics includes the study of economic history of civilization. Without economics there is no reason for a region or society to exist . So economic survival is a must , that which depends on the flora and fauna, geography, geology,& climate of a land. The control of this economics is called power . The official administration of these economics by men is called accounting and in the modern world their titles are Chartered Accountants.

[@yuribaloch224]

❤❤❤ Only emotions can describe what are you doing for the Nation.

[@hyousufzai17]

It's fun to learn history from a finance guy xD

[@bilal59446]

history is morphed by economic situations. Whenever u study an economy spatially or temporaly, you need to acquaint urself firstly with the context, which essentially is history. The French Revolution, and Russian Revolution that we like to talk about a lot, the core enablers of those so called revolutions was the economic turmoil "shortage of food/bread" in both France and Russia due to bad economic situation. One empire attacks another empire !!! why ??? to gain more money/eonomy. Every aspect of today's life can easily be traced back to the context of history, so we can learn from it.

[@Atq0273]

Chutiya buddhe ko ptq kuch nahi hai, delhi se 25miles pe international border bta raha hai, bsdk talwar k darr se salwar pehne ho tum log.. aur nehru jinnah yeh sab politicians hai leader nahi… jinnah ne khud accept kia tha pakistan bnana uska sabde bda jinnaah tha

[@gqptyu]

"There were no zamindar among Hindus" - LMAO

[@Atq0273]

Uncle ki BKL button--->

[@silvershroud6263]

Its all made up history 😅

[@saqibmalik6589]

Such podasts should be promoted. I fear this will not have less viewership than Junaid's typical commentary videos.

[@sunnybarua6028]

It'll be a good thing if the podcast doesn't get views, because this so called Economist analysis is laughable, he only has hyperboles to offer.

[@SATWIKRAJ-x3b]

​@@sunnybarua6028he is just an hinduphobic with jihadi mindset

[@ibtahamukhtar]

Atleast he is doing better than running 😂

[@liebedich7680]

This was a "Mazedar" podcast, giving a birds' eye view in the mechanics of Pakistani mindset, especially of the elites.

[@ahsan.06]

The way Sir Shabbar explained the historic arab trade route was phenomenal. Couldn't have understood that better. While watching the podcast I opened the map in my diary and matched the exact route he was mentioning to. No surprise as he reads a lot. Has good knowledge of history alongwith economy. Those in the comment section shaming him for talking about history and religion being a professional accountant and economist need to reflect about their own knowledge. Almost all the points he raised regarding hinduism, judaism and indo-pak can be verified from relevant sources.

[@FaizanAnwar-j9o]

Pakistan is facing an economic crisis and people are blaming Jinnah sb for having a country for Muslims after ruining this country. I am 18 years old and you know what I feel when people teases me by saying pakistan is a country of beggars . Whole world is enjoying and laughing on us and waiting for the time when pakistan will collapse 😢😢 How painful is this for me 😢

[@mirfanali1937]

Listening to Shabbar Bhai has always been a delight.

[@Health-Blitz]

*Uncle is highly mistaken, because it was Lord Rothszchild's who laid the foundation for the creation of Israel through the Balfour Declaration*

[@tahir4163]

Babay ki Evolution hogi phe pata lagay ga isko. phr jab yea marnay wala hoga uskay 10 min phlay isko pata lagay ga.

[@namansinghnegi8931]

Uncle is not even a good accountant. He was chairman FBR at the time of Imran Khan. Rothschild initially wanted the state of Israel to be somewhere else but agreed afterwards.

[@SulemanAbbas-jp3im]

He has mistaken rothscild for some one else... I don't agree with him over various matters but his work in siut hospital has been very significNt

[@Asiandramas99]

Are bhai disagreement was about the loction of israel not creating of Israel… thik se to sun lo pehle

[@kuku6116]

Disagreement was on location of Israel not Creation.

[@f2ajack]

There should be another podcast to discuss only spirituality and religion with Shabbar Zaidi. He can really enlighten our thoughts. Excellent show again.

[@Journo5810]

Exactly.

[@faizanbhat7608]

1:09:32 1:14:48 Junaid bhai k sarr k upar se ja rahi hain yeh sb baate 🤌😂

[@Phone_Review_Channel]

Shabbir Zaidi displays Pakistan's intellectual depth. He attributes the current challenges faced by Pakistan to what he describes as a 'Hindu Inferiority Complex.'

[@Tattvam_asi]

Exactly 😂😂😂

[@indmusiclover]

I dont agree on some of things the guest said: removal of zamindarism did not "just" happen. Kudos to Nehru and his team for that. Also the fact that Jinnah and his team didnt speak against zamindarism paid off initially to the formation of the country but cost them later. BTW there were tons of "hindu" zamindars even pre and post 47 - Gandhijis famous battle in champaran Bihar is an example. Typical hierarchy was brits on top ; indian zamindars under them ; common indians at the bottom and crushed paying through their nose as rubbish taxes. Also not sure every hindu had this "inferiority complex". Did the muslims have or had a "superiority complex"??? All the Indians today I am sure feel they are part of the new country working their way up just like most others!

[@sujit_jadhav]

After hearing Pakistan’s “intellectual”, I don’t need to do any study about why Pakistani economy is where it is right now. 😂 😂😂 Pakistan is bankrupt not only economically but also intellectually. . 😂😂😂

[@psprasad6738]

This guy has not evolved from his Mussalman mindset.

[@SHIVAMYadav-pw5uz]

Thanks 🙏 to social media.....now we indian can hear and understand the Pakistani intellectuals mindset .....I don't think Pakistan deserve our hate.....they are their own victims......

[@ghazanfarhussain5032]

Thanks for 🎉 listening to Pakistani intellectuals 11:11

[@seshagirivemuri6503]

The real reason for Pakistan's economic failure is India hate. Everything they do should be opposite to what India does.If India is friendly with USSR,it went into USA camp. From 1400s muslims were ruling class or close to rulers. They always had preferential treatment and habituated to easy life. After Partition, for proving they are better than India, they always looked for shortcuts for making money.In the initial days, they lived off money from USA and UK. Then, Afghanistan issue paid them from 78 to 2019. Since then, their downfall started. From 2010, CPEC and China paid them for ten years. Chinese funds were 90 percent commercial loans, uneconomical for infrastructure projects and today, they owe 50 billion principle and another 50 billion in interest and can never pay back. Also 23 defaults to IMF made Pakistan untrustworthy. Overall, Pakistan never learnt to put it's head down and work and always looked for easy Pakistan rulers subjects relationship continues this Mughal mindset, whereas Indian politicians wanted to serve the population.

[@saqibkaleem2285]

One of the finest podcast Shabbar Sahab is the true Asset of pakistan, Thankyou Junaid bhai for informative podcast

[@TheSilentNoise.]

Very interesting podcast. Thanks for inviting him. Learned a lot!

[@umairali11k]

When Junaid bhai has to think again and again how to counter question because of strong grip of Sir Shabbar on deep understanding of economics, history, geography and religions. What a great intellect is Mr Shabbar Zaidi purely a gem hats off to you Sir.

[@muhammadali-pu2wg]

Rock and roll. Netflix k episodes 😅😅

[@SATWIKRAJ-x3b]

Lol he is just an idiot

[@ibtahamukhtar]

​​​@@muhammadali-pu2wghaha same ...aur har dusri bat pa shabar sb NAHI kehrahay ty..that was epic..yeh banda abhi wahan tak nahi pocha ...jisko bulaya hua tha isnay.... aj mujhay hua andaza k ... he just sounds smart and intellectual... sahab ko samjhna hoga har jaga wanna be millennial or gen z wala touch nahi chalayga

[@muhammadali-pu2wg]

@@ibtahamukhtar Bhai ye baat K har jgha jahan koi ham Umar ajae .,tou kahen k pehlay Gen Z ko ye chz smjhaen wo chz smjhaen. Shabar sahb na bataya k phele boomers SA you seekh lo Gen X y walon 😝😂

[@Zeno_334]

That this man is the ex-head of Pakistan's federal bureau or revenue and a respected intellectual explains everything about the cesspool that is Pakistan.

[@UsmanKhan-sf4wq]

Junaid bhai, I don't think I've listened to anything more meaningful then this ever before

[@AmongUs-ku3yp]

OMG bhot hi knowledgeable and informative ❤❤✌🏼

[@saurabhchandras6945]

Brits did NOT conquer India from Muslims they conquered it from the Marathas. The Marathas were the biggest power in India post-1920s. They even installed several Mughal puppet rulers in Delhi. Secondly, Congress was firmly against the creation of Pakistan. This included Nehru of course. The idea of Pakistan was of the West and they helped employ Jinaah in the 1940s to create Pakistan (an entity that could be controlled easily). Basically, a satellite state of the west. Shabbar Zaidi hasn't read the history properly it seems.

[@Mregg110]

Inko samjake koi fayda nahi ye sab converted garib muslim Inko muslim superiority sikhayi jati hai sach se door ka wasta nahi

[@SATWIKRAJ-x3b]

Inme dimag kaha hai 😂😂😂

[@mubeenamjad3619]

At #23:30 he says to make india open the borders with Pakistan and let afghan go to india sell opium we take tax 😂

[@K-SHABAB]

😂 sahi bola usna

[@Mregg110]

Pakistani punjabi ka pichwada fat jata hai taliban se 😂

[@mubeenamjad3619]

@@K-SHABAB i agree 😂

[@K-SHABAB]

@@mubeenamjad3619 yap thx😹

[@K-SHABAB]

@@mubeenamjad3619 wo tax government ka pass nahi particular people's k pass jay ga 🤗

[@newyorkavirex]

Bhai leraha hai junaid bhai ki. Junaid is digesting it. No ego. just a learning curve on steroids.

[@John_O_Connor]

- Question: economy - Answer: Tsar of Russia/ Partition Mr. Shabbar should stick to one book at a time!

[@prashantp2029]

23:11 This guy is basically suggesting that partion was outcome of Hindu jealousy and inferiority complex against Muslims and Hindus were so coward that they divided India...and put all the Marshall Muslim quom on the western borders to safeguard themselves from western invaders likes of Afghan and etc.... There is a great "kahawat" for such gentlemen...."lande ka historian" 😂😂 bc.....this is exactly the Lal Toppee mindset but repackaged with less chumtiyapa

[@bechansingh1560]

A person who believes Muhammad as prophet can believe anything.

[@coolboy1315]

This is my 2nd talkshow straight in a night of shabbar sb… One thing I learned is the importance of book reading… if one cant read than atleast listen to those who read alot and have written books. Way better than seasonal so called motivational speakers What a views and knowledge shared.. 👏

[@SHAHIDBADAR]

Great to see shabbar zaidi on ur podcast, we've worked for so long with shabbar sahb in PWC. Great man ❤ Looking forward to watch the podcast

[@martin96991]

Watching from INDIA and must say shabbar zaidi seems a genuine knowledgeable guy who talked on facts.

[@rogermilla2358]

The British primarily took the Subcontinent from Marathas and Sikhs when they arrived (and in any case the Mughals had basically shrunk down to Delhi in the decades following Aurangzeb) - the few remaining Muslim Kingdoms basically existed at their benevolence by that point lmao.

[@chungfromchina9307]

Wah ji wah ,one of the finest geopolitical minds in the world ,I hope Pakistan takes his advice seriously

[@rajsinghji-84]

I just can’t find even a single “positive” comment here for this guest. That guy is an idiot.

[@harshwardhansinghshekhawat9262]

Bro said British took land from muslims. Someone teach him about the maratha Empire. The empires in the south of india. A 13 year old Indian kid knows more history. The issue with Pakistan is taking history lessons from a economist. They know about everything except their field.

[@harshitgarg3436]

oh bhai, as much as pride I have in maratha empire, it is a bitter pill for me to accept british took land from muslims the most. Marathas were busy fighting traitors within while brits started their empire from Bengal which was under muslims. they spread towards eastern south and northern west, and by the time they went for marathas, marathas were themselves in shaby state and nobody wanted to support them as marathas didnt support them in their times.

[@vrindabolinjkar3861]

​@@harshitgarg3436the Mughals's rule was only within Delhi city.. maratha rule has spread ...we say " atke ke par Zenda" i.e. they had captured Attock which is in Pakistan now ..

[@harshitgarg3436]

@@vrindabolinjkar3861 bhai mere i said muslim rulers, not mughals. Mughals ke decline se hi toh mughal ke commanders ne charge le liye tha. British ne bengal kisse liya tha? Nawab of bengal siraj ud daulla se after mir jaffar betrayed him. Where was Tipu Sultan when he fought British? Hyderabad. Britishers ne Awadh (uttar pradesh) kisse lia? Wajid ali shah. Delhi toh tha hi bahadur shah II ke under. Maratha empire jab peak pe tha tab aaye hi nahi thay british, tab french aur dutch thay.

[@SATWIKRAJ-x3b]

​@@harshitgarg3436lol just look at empire before Britishers took land

[@harshitgarg3436]

@@SATWIKRAJ-x3b bhai maratha aur rajput west aur middle india mei thay, baaki saara india muslims ke paas tha.

[@SHIVAMYadav-pw5uz]

This economist is Expert in shayari, Qur'an, Hinduism, partition, geopolitics, bibliophile,....the only thing he lacks is economy ....

[@BILALQURASIHI]

One of the best podcast i have watched. If we bring merit in our system and appoint such person that it deserve, pakistan will grow drastically faster than any other country because of the uncapped potential it has.

[@SamarNiaz29]

Looking at most of the comments I just want to say: Dear Neighbours, Thank you for 76 yrs of your continuous interest (obsession) in us. It’s quite exemplary, unprecedented, and not generally observed among other countries.

[@stolensoul6857]

Junaid bhai thank you for bringing Shabbar Saheb to your podcast, he always educates us. I request you to kindly invite Qaiser Bangali saheb too.

[@percyzaiwala1370]

Also : Please do Invite Pervez Hoodboy & if any Pakistani is interested in learning Spot-on Pakistani History - Before & after partition, the authority on this subject is Mr. Ishtiaq Ahmed.

[@bharatmaa7826]

Knowledge of this madrasha chhap is great 👍.

[@Mregg110]

Hindufobiq hqi in me ye bolta hai indiq me vcr car nahi the flat nahi the 1980 me lol mai 1992 me born hu mere ghar me 1985 me tv vcr fridge car sab tha ye whats app university ka gyan de raha mughal uzbekistan se aaya ye khudko mughal samaj raha ye khud converted hai arrogant or isko lag raha hamne raaj kiya 😂

[@divyanshrana1925]

@@Mregg110best part bolta hai Hindu inferiority complex jabki khud alag hona chahte they 😂 They hate their hindu identity

[@shehreyartaqvi8338]

He is an agnostic as mentioned by him. Har baat me fatwa lekr nahi ajaya kro baat ko samaj liya kro kis context me bola jaraha hai.

[@mpqw]

​@@shehreyartaqvi8338he talked less about money more about Quran. Calling himself Agnostic will not make him one.

[@debrad.castleberry2457]

Mandirchap paje*t

[@lahortour]

Pakistan ku lgta ha k wo dunia se zada smjdar ha...

[@girjesh0]

SIR JI 🙏🏻🙏🏻. MR.SHABAAR ZAIDI SIR JI KI EK EK BAAT BILKUL SAHI HAI. I TOTALLY AGREED WITH ZAIDI JI 🙏🏻🙏🏻🇮🇳🇮🇳🙏🏻🙏🏻.

[@Tattvam_asi]

1:13:18 only sensible baat during whole podcast 😂😂😂

[@tariqsonzia]

Shabbar sb, u r right but Hindus of India are fan of gold. Yes actual problem is we Muslims are beyond to education.

[@Mregg110]

Madarsachap ab gold se bhi nafrat 😂 tumhara arbi religion hate ke alawa kuch sikhata nahi tum sab forcefully converted ho

[@siddharth0401]

Happy diwali, I hv just finished diwali celebrations, but can't wait to complete this podcast

[@delinewine]

same! second best part of today!

[@Zzzxxxxx959]

Dnt waste your time

[@mmalik9616]

Good Interview but it felt like Junaid bhai wasn’t prepared… Please have more podcasts like this!

[@RickSilva-h4j]

All answered incorrectly

[@mianwamiq4844]

شبر صاحب روحانیت کی طرف جا رہے ہیں۔ قرآن کد مطالعہ کرتے ہیں ۔ اللہ ان کی زندگی میں برکت دیں ۔

[@mrdead7412]

I don’t know why people are hating on him but he’s right on so many points regarding history of Pakistan and economic challenges. He sounds annoying but isn’t.

[@UJJWAL...]

Panjab ko Angrejo ne maharaja ranjeet singh se liya tha 😂😂😂 ye bhai desh k liye important decision le raha tha 😂😂😂

[@princerai5490]

Majority india is under maratha rule at the time British came

[@Arabi-Rasgulle-ka-Gulla]

​@@princerai5490he was saying no hindus were feudal lords in india 😂😂😂😂

[@muhammadali-pu2wg]

​@@Arabi-Rasgulle-ka-Gullanorth india

[@Mregg110]

@@Arabi-Rasgulle-ka-Gullapakistanio ko ek bimari hai hindufobia

[@prashantp2029]

20:31 He says he is very well read still no better than a madarsachaap. When British arrived most of India was under Hindu kingdom Maratha. The way he says wo humare naukar they, it's very derogatory...already choti Hindu bacchiya utthake convert karni wali quom ho...upar se intellectuals ka bolne ka tareeka ye hai....tauba tauba badhe hee ghatiya log ho yaar

[@Captain.Jackk01]

History Ki Ma Behan kar rhe bhai sahab... Engrejo Ne India Maratha Empire se Jeeta k liya tha... Third Battle pf Plasi or Angla Maratha war.... Bhai sahab... Pakistan Ne Is Economist ko History ka Nhi pata to.... Aam Insaan ko kya pata hoga bhai sahab.... Isliye Pakistan ka ye haal hai..History Geography pe bolne se pahle..google to kar lete..3,4 source se verify to kar lete.

[@ahbarahad3203]

He was talking about Delhi sultanate

[@prajwalsingh5714]

​@@ahbarahad3203delhi sultanat is nothing only fairy tales rajputs are the slayer of malechhs of arbian and muslim inveders we fight we muslim inveders till Islam arise in world

[@4971sunny]

I want to say that Shabbar shahab is saying about some plot planning, this idea is already incorporated in India i.e In Noida if you buy a plot you have to build a house else your accusation will be revoked and same size of property will be given to customer in an undeveloped area. So you have to build a house in allotted plot.

[@RanaHanan-us1eo]

Shabbar zaidi sir se dubara is tarhn ki podcast karien , jis me mazeed baten karien , ganji swag thanks

[@MithileshJha-tn3ks]

Happy Diwali,sir has got some valid points,just minor rewordings we dont feel inferior or superior to anyone in the world,yes there are certain groups which we avoid .

[@ashishr268]

Chacha high on weed

[@harshitgarg3436]

it wasnt inferiority but that grudge or sense of injustice because Hindus were the owner of lands and foreign muslim invaders took them from us, later Brits made those invaders and their generations as zamindars making us landless.

[@SATWIKRAJ-x3b]

​@@harshitgarg3436cope spammer

[@nikhildeshmukh6221]

😂😂 andhbhkt spotted

[@MithileshJha-tn3ks]

@@nikhildeshmukh6221 mere bhai i m not bjp supporter,but that's fine you can call me whatever. You might feel inferior to anyone,i don't nor people that I know. That does not mean i consider us perfect we have loads of problems . Learn to discuss and express rather than uttering expletives,you are exposing urself not me.

[@somindrasingh5832]

Learning history from an economist is like watching comedy no wonder Pakistan is in economic crises.

[@ResponsibleCitizen001]

Chacha Bol rhe hai k 2000 3000 saal se koi bhi aake delhi pr kabza kr leta tha. Or ye th inke padhe likhe aadmi ki baate hai 😂

[@vimalsingh2776]

Shi to bol rha … Aryans north west se hi to aye hai

[@xenon7806]

To refute kar chache ko. I love seeing Indians crying in the comments.

[@TheSoccerStar30]

For Pakistan's own sake, they need a radical change in their education, literature and learning material which is churning out intellectuals like this one.

[@duttadebadrito8846]

Every person has his own perception on historical fact but that doesn't mean some one half of his age makes some derogatory word , it's just a reflection of his/her family culture

[@dbodybuilder1]

20:39 he said nehru was lawyer and they were OUR employees and then he went on to say that Britishers took zameen from musalman because hindu was not zameendaar..didnt he know that mughals took over hindus and took there land forcefully and converted them? plz correct me ?? this sounds ridiculous and ignorant