Who Do I Choose? | Mafia ft. Timothy DeLaGhetto, Gina Darling & Steve Greene

After our April Fools Mafia ... let's play a real game!
#mafia #partygame
Subscribe ➜ bit.ly/JoinJKPFam
🎲 Game Rules ♟
icebreakeridea...
Follow our Guests!
Steve Greene: www.instagram....
Timothy DeLaGhetto: www.instagram....
Gina Darling: www.instagram....
Editor: www.antoineband...
Cast:
Tiff
Bart
Nikki
Casey
Josh
Julia
Joe
Nadeem
Antoine
Steve
Gina
Timothy
Brandon
***
FOLLOW THE CREW:
• Joe Jo: / theuncochin
• Bart & Geo Kwan: / bartkwan
• Casey Chan: / tiffandcase
• Brandon Choi: / bchoii
• Julia Chow: / xblueapplez
• Tiffany Del Real: / tiffandcase
• Josh Osei: / dubhalo
• Nikki Limo: / trickniks
• Michael Chiu: / michael.p.chiu
• Antoine Bandele: antoinebandele...
• Nelson Nguyen: / nelson_ftw
• Ryan Hasegawa: / ryanhasegawa
• Sean D. Nguyen: / seandnguyen
• Patrick Parado: / action.pat
• Kyle Pham: / kpham12992
• Can Nguyen: / can.poreotics
• Byron Montilla: / byronvids
***
SUBSCRIBE TO THESE CHANNELS TOO:
• JUST KIDDING FILMS: / justkiddingfilms
• JUST KIDDING NEWS: / justkiddingnews
• JUST KIDDING GAMER: / justkiddinggamer
FOLLOW AND LIKE US HERE:
• INSTAGRAM: / jkfilms
• FACEBOOK: / justkiddingfilms
• TWITTER: / jkfilms
• MERCHANDISE: justkiddingfilm...

[@TheMate986]

This is what I gathered from this game: 1. Julia has improved but plays better as Mafia than Civilian because she usually accuses the wrong people 2. Joe has lost his place as the best player, he hasn’t played up to his standards in a long time and this game he ruined it 3. Antoine is now possibly on the throne as the best player

[@shanen28]

Antoine and Byron best Civilian player

[@dianarosecline]

Qendrim Sadiku - agreed.. I love joe but he really f*cked up his time, and Antonie has been doing really good lately.

[@bestfrien5557]

I disagree with antoine being the best player because what really messed everything up is when he dominated over the convos when others were being suspected ex when Gina accused Julia and just pushed on joe and since Joe knew he was good and didnt wanna die it just led to both of them accusing eachother helping mafia

[@bestfrien5557]

@@mazdak500 I am not talking about that I am stating reasons why I disagree with the best player thing

[@josha4762]

Joe is only good at mafia duh

[@shxtou]

when joe said "I am 100% Antoine and Casey" I lost my shit

[@KasheYan15]

I feel like the april fools game just confused tim on how to play cop 😅

[@DatsFamily]

KasheMoneyRemix 1000%

[@ohhhh]

Yeah totally should of played a warm up

[@aing1481]

he was waiting for the other cops to help him

[@ReenaUtubez]

i think he thought that as a cop he was suppose to kill people

[@tamraarmstrong1433]

Lol

[@AntoineBandele]

All right ... ya'll know I love this game so here is my personal perspective (I'm very salty the town didn't win this one, lol). From the jump, as I said in the game, I wanted to turn my attention onto one side of the room. In a previous game, when I was a town member, I remember turning my attention to too many other people and getting distracted. So for this one I held my attention on Nikki's couch. Nikki's tell was very subtle. Her wake up was very unusual to me (funny, because he strategy is to watch other's waking up), and in the round with the first kill she didn't look around the room like she usually does (which to me, made her seem like she knew who was going to be killed). So I was very elated when she pulled out her Mafia card. Now with Joe ... As one commentor, Bz Bone, pointed out (and I think he/she summed it up best): "Joe is seeing a lot of his mafia moves in Antoine that he automatically thinks he's mafia." Our ultimate downfall was our respect for one another in the game (or at least my respect for him). Of all the players, Joe (and Geo when she plays) is the one I always look out for most of these deception-type games. Throughout the game he kept making subtle jabs at me as being a mafia, which made me believe *he* was mafia. He made comments like "Good job, Antoine" or "You're trying throwing me under the bus. I see what you're doing" etc, etc. Despite those comments, I stuck with Nikki who I felt was a better bet, but with each round Joe climbed higher and higher on my list. And what really got me throughout the game was that I thought Joe was going to get away with being mafia. And as someone who is super competitive in the game I didn't want that to happen, especially because he's such a good player. So throughout the last rounds I was fixated on Joe. And I, admittedly, wanted to play the game better than he did (without ever considering that he might be a civilian). I thought all his comments against me throughout the game was him playing mafia and trying to frame/pin things on me. And the more he did it, the more I honed in on him being mafia. What sucks is that in the last round I picked out both Julia and Steve as our next picks at the very start of the final day (thinking that Joe was for sure a mafia at the point). Had we not got into it like we did, I feel like the town could have won. Gina had pointed out Julia and I started noticing how much Julia was doing with her face. Also, Steve being quiet (which I also pointed out) felt strange because, like Joe, Steve has a lot of love for the game. So it was weird that he had no real fight for the town and was very laid back. But again, it all circled back to my attention being locked in on Joe. It also didn't help that Joe seemed to be siding with Julia, who he seemed to trust in the end and who I suspected was mafia (on rewatch I didn't realize how close I turned my face to her because I knew it was her in the night). Ultimately, that didn't help my own trust with Joe. What's more, him putting me with Casey and saying I was teaming with him also was a red flag for me when we hadn't even been looking at each other or talking to each other until that last round. But on the flip side one has to look from Joe's perspective. I don't know what Joe thinks of me as a player. But I never considered at any point that he legit thought I was mafia and that he wasn't throwing me under the bus, but making valid accusations (I thought he was playing into it to hard). Seeing it from his eyes I can see how he thought me as mafia (though I would have thought that the Nikki kill would have earned his trust. Even if I was mafia I would not have thrown Nikki under the bus at that point). The town was right there with the win ... it's just that me and Casey couldn't get past that Joe wall. And for us to win the game we needed to be on the exact voting wavelength with Joe. As some of you have pointed out, I definitely got a bit too heated and aggressive at points but that's all coming from a passion for the game (and is how I hope others play as well). I know we're playing with a lot of entertainers and comedians but I'm always trying to play the game straight up whenever I can. As the old adage goes, hindsight is 20/20. It's easy for me to say I shouldn't have chosen Joe at the end but I'd be lying if I said I wouldn't have played the same way if given a second chance. But if Joe and I could have saw eye-to-eye for even a second we could have pulled out Julia and Steve, which is the way the tides were shifting to. It was a tough game but, for me, it was a good one. Very entertaining and engaging. I'm an unapologetic tryhard. (Try out Roles Hidden. It really gives the impression of real gameplay). ​

[@xintheshower]

i love reading your comments after the game. i also wish the after game chat lasted longer, i love hearing what people were thinking after the game. i always watch roles hidden first and i was right there with you voting for Nikki. also how hard Joe wanted Julia and/or Gina to vote for Tim made me suspect Joe as well. Agree with you about Julias face being weird and Steve being quiet, but there was just something off about Joe! I would have voted for Joe before Steve and Julia as well. You're not alone. I hope you're in the third game that was played this day, and I hope you and Steve are mafia together.

[@makkaucbkia9640]

Antoine Bandele You typed so much but the only wrong thing you said in your comment is that “He’s such a good player”. No, he really isn’t. Not when it comes to mafia. And the sooner he realises this the better. Him on his mafia gameplay high horse has really been a problem, initially to himself but now a problem for everybody. Because more often than not he is civilian and he always causes the town to lose. I don’t like anyone in particular including you so I’m not trying to be biased when I say this but objectively the people good in mafia are really you, Byron, Gina and NOW Geo.

[@123454321lucky43]

I watch all your content keep it up

[@xintheshower]

@KURAISHA yea on barts vlog he said they played a third game

[@arianebenina9577]

You played a really good game, Antoine! You were being perceptive, and you systematically made sense. It was painful to see the civillians didn't try their best because for a fact the two important roles were gone in an instant (cop and nurse), but to see you even more hyped up to catch the mafia really made me realize that you were trying your best and made sense that you were a civillian; which i was so frustrated as to why nobody saw that you were actually not mafia. Joe was all over the place, and i dont know why he didn't get your trust after proving that Nikki was indeed the mafia because at that point of the game, mafias were already winning with 2 important roles gone. But I really hope that you play in future mafias game, because oh boy, you are indeed a really good player Antoine!

[@55CINCO55]

I always knew Antoine was the best mafia player since the first game he played.

[@chanchaiken5522]

Yes , he's in the top 3 with bart and joe

[@purebird8774]

Instacry Byron was also real good

[@AMinneYme]

@@chanchaiken5522 joe's been slipping tho

[@hanzifaction]

He's a smart dude. Very strategic. I thought Joe was the best, but he gets too emotional and picks the wrong person. Before it was Ant and now it's Antoine.

[@ironman34561]

@@chanchaiken5522 I think Antoine, Bart and Byron

[@oiwow1409]

Antoine and Byron would be such a good mafia team

[@igetlazy]

Well Byron is leaving JK to teach English in Japan. It's on Joe's IG post

[@andyhernandez2802]

Oi Wow Byron’s trash

[@ymaniclare2073]

100% agree they always have good defenses for themselves and strategizing wether their mafia,civilian,cop or nurse 👏🏾bravo to Antoine👏🏾 for this game

[@teeejjohn8115]

nah antoine steve and joe

[@5h4Lu]

i wish this could be possible but byrons left jk (on a positive note)

[@HPGLUCKY1]

Antoine played well and could of won it for civilian but joe messed it up sadly by accusing Antoine I would like to see Tim again but explain to him how mafia works

[@roshill2010]

He thought it was a episode of send Foodz and used a buffet of characters. :P

[@ronbintscatco]

But it didn't matter what Joe did b/c they sided with Antoine, no? didn't Antoine mess it up by going so hard on Nikki & Joe, allying w/ Steve from the beginning which took suspicion off him, & diverting attention from Julia to Joe when Gina was on her before the pivotal round. To me, *Antoine being wrong about Joe, but going so hard on it, was the deciding factor in the game.* He tried to blame it on the way Joe played as civilian, but, as civilian, he's been playing like Ant for awhile now; where he reacts at whoever suspects him or teams up.

[@Username-vl3qb]

Nah. As much as joe stuffed up, antoine was already firm on believing joe was mafia for a long time. Either it was definitely gonna be joe or antoine voted out. No way civilian could've won.

[@GerdTerd]

Joe decided Antoine was mafia after he pushed on Nikki the whole start of the game... wtf?? He was absolutely cleared after Nikki was voted off as mafia

[@AntoineBandele]

"Didn't Antoine mess it up by going so hard on Nikki & Joe, allying w/ Steve" I never allied with Steve. Nikki tried to put that narrative out there for the town but I shot that down right away and Steve also denied we had any kind of alliance. Steve was on my list at the very end. At the start of the last day I specifically said the difficulty was between Julia and Steve. The only reason they weren't #1 and #2 on the list is because Joe was acting very suspicious and inconsistent to me during the second half of the game.

[@preettyE]

I like how Antoine doesn't let Joe intimidate him

[@carlwilliamkullenberg1304]

and in return antoine intimidated everyone else and made them miss steve cuse he wasnt on antoines "list"

[@AntoineBandele]

Steve was on my list. I kept flipping him and Julia on the last day. The only issue was trusting Joe in the last round. My eyes were always on Julia and Steve. I didn't intimidate anyone. Casey simply agreed with me and of course Julia and Steve went along with it because their Mafia. There was no one to "intimidate."

[@makkaucbkia9640]

I LOVE that

[@darklight9063]

@@carlwilliamkullenberg1304 he was on his list

[@movingforward9555]

And now he is sadly fired. 🤣 Nah, but he does get too intense man, isn't that Joe's thing.

[@snsdredvelvet2755]

We need to bring back Tim. Once he perfects his gameplay he’s gonna be THE BEST player there is 100%. Bring him back

[@krndevil313]

Faxxxx

[@JustKiddingParty]

He’ll be back in a future Mafia very soon, don’t you worry. 😉

[@ShankaraOm]

true, even without knowing the game he was super fun with his interventions

[@xintheshower]

they played three mafia games this day :)

[@ryanho5378]

Yeah but 2nd best joemalia will always be the best

[@tomaaalmbark41]

I feel betrayed that they play mafia sometimes without recording it 😂

[@g.h3874]

Lmfao saaaaame we might have missed great games 😭😂

[@BakaBoiGaming]

And yet all but 2 never improve

[@BakaBoiGaming]

@Allen Silva Joe= improved? Tiff=improved you sure about that

[@BakaBoiGaming]

@Allen Silva in that sense then Josh has improved as well

[@eltina21]

Antoine is trying to get the town to work as a team but the rest of the civilians are playing for themselves. I was really disappointed in Joe this round

[@krndevil313]

eltina21 he had that one initial catch when he said Steve and Nikki were working together but fucked up when he started accusing Casey and Antoine lol

[@ronbintscatco]

i think he actually hurt his team... at the key moment, Gina was on Julia, but Antoine dominated the convo & turned everything back to Joe. B/c he was so adamant on Joe, it caused Joe to question him. And he allied with Steve, a mafia, from the beginning which got Steve off the rest of the town's radar.

[@sarapas]

@@ronbintscatco I can totally see why Antoine was on Joe. Joe defended Nikki hardcore and kept attacking only Antoine. Joe was extremely annoying this game. He also pushed Julia to kill off Tim.

[@shabnajchowdhury9814]

Joe almost always fucks up the game by passionately believing a civilian is mafia lol

[@Dtzeo503]

Yeah this game is all about teamwork

[@sportsfame99]

Antoine and byron in a game together would be dope. Cuz theyre both methodical

[@97bubbletea]

probably not possible or rare occasion cuz Apparently BYRON is moving to Japan to teach

[@arraikcruor6407]

@@97bubbletea Is he Japanese? I thought he was philipino or something. Also what is he teaching?

[@ororod2132]

The game would only last 20 minutes, tops...😂....add Julia's boyfriend....10. 😂😂😂

[@97bubbletea]

@@arraikcruor6407 hahah yah he isnt Japanese but he took courses

[@NIVSTERTV]

I think Byron will be teaching English

[@a.c.8524]

56:46 is no one gonna talk about this tragedy?? Poor Bart 😂

[@GlynettePeralta]

Omg poor bart! ☹️😂☹️

[@preettyE]

Lmaoooo

[@Go21place]

Lmaoooo

[@deependuajish]

Lol didn't even notice

[@kristkotini4358]

LOL didnt even notice 😂😂

[@dmitriantonio3842]

this had to be the worst game joe has ever played jesus christ 🤦‍♂️

[@tiptipzz]

dmitri antonio idk man that game where he accuses ant and Casey and goes into a rage fit was pretty bad lol

[@AM-ij4mv]

Yes he has a tendency to freaking throw the game off sometimes when he gets all pumped up when they think he’s mafia and he gets confident and cocky with it like he’s trying to prove something.

[@misteryace21]

@@tiptipzz i hated that so much, he didnt even let ant speak & pointed out so much bullshit

[@olivetruman8]

Tiff says it gets old that Josh always suspects Julia, but she always suspects Casey. More often than Josh suspects Julia and usually Julia suspects Josh first. Great video regardless 😂👍

[@johnnydari7091]

Chill

[@angelosorio1645]

True

[@johnnydari7091]

Its just a game like ur taking it too seriously lol

[@lammergeier100]

@@johnnydari7091 sit down my nigga

[@sushisaxophone]

Johnny Dari I think you need to chill

[@XaViEr3520]

Tiff - josh blamining julia gets old Tiff - why didn’t they put Casey in the chopping block 🤷🏽‍♀️ Me - 😑 again tiff, that’s gets old 😑

[@MLGm0nk3ys]

LMAO DEADASS

[@jojoe4394]

Antoine is so Smart, and has great intuition

[@kellyy2399]

Joe Atkinson well where did his intuition get him in the last round 😂

[@niki7876]

@@kellyy2399 To be fair Joe played a terrible game and was hella suspicious

[@knickknackpattiwhack5459]

Would’ve got them further than if they listened to Nicki... oh wait

[@chanik3872]

who didn't explain the roles to tim like you guys did him dirty he actually looked confused after he got killed and tiff had to explain the basics to him

[@BakaBoiGaming]

He even said they didn't tell him nothing in the Joke video(Which I thought was a joke) but when he kept repeating it, I realized they didn't do this right

[@Splendidjosh]

If you were rooting for Town this game was hard to watch lol and poor Tim like he really didn't know what he was doing

[@Splendidjosh]

@Teddy Li oh for sure Joe ruined the game. Antoine had great reads and even Gina had a read on Julia and Casey had a read on Steve which woulda helped Antoine but Joe was playing dumb

[@99Drema99]

@@Splendidjosh you said it best. I have no idea what he's been doing these last games. Yes it's easier to pick up signs when you're an outsider but the fact everyone said Steve and Nikki were working together. Any alpha personality would stick with that decision. He went from that to pointing fingers at the people that point him out. That's childlike. The objective is to win, if you had that initial hunch and it's obvious you're right stick with it. He was all over the place this game and could have won easily if he took his ego out of this game.

[@arraikcruor6407]

@@99Drema99 Yeah he gets emotional more often now. Before he used to be less emotional and more methodical. Probably seems that way because everyone's gameplay improved significantly since they began the mafia game.

[@BleachRush]

i don't know why i always root for civilians.. its somehow implemented in my head that Civilians should win

[@tiptipzz]

Antoine was ON POINT but joe threw him off with his accusations

[@blackwidowbrigade5042]

Antoine accused Joe first so no

[@sirmaam3873]

Antoine was on the right track

[@ororod2132]

3:02 I love that STEVE and NIKKI are Mafia together! 😂💚💚

[@leannabayhonan5264]

Ik right

[@makaylaann1118]

You mean NIKKI and STEVE?

[@natyki]

I feel like they should’ve explained the roles better to Tim. It really can get confusing on your role if you haven’t ever played before. But I enjoy having Antoine on mafia, he has been great the past games.

[@g.h3874]

Especially since he only played the fake mafia

[@elielelwy]

Seriously like why would they film a whole hour video when one player doesn’t know half of what’s going on lmao it’s stupid and a waste of time?? Tim showed potential but JKP let him down by inviting him and not fully explaining all the roles

[@arraikcruor6407]

@@elielelwy they have done that before as well with new people. They just explain the basics. They need to go through mock play before doing the actual game with new people.

[@dburn4643]

@@arraikcruor6407 Up to the guest themselves to understand what's going on before they start filming so they don't make themselves look like an idiot.

[@misteryace21]

@@dburn4643 they can only do so much with the basic rules of the games, since playing irl can be completely different. The way I've played mafia w/ different groups of people is all different strategies & since the crew know the way they play, the new guest can get really confused, so a warm up game woulda been better

[@crischernyy6569]

They say that the Josh and Julia bit gets old but when Josh suspects Julia it’s more than not right that she’s mafia so 🙄

[@tigress_witchlingdagger5851]

It is an old bit but truth be told that can snuff out each other. In multiple games Josh has called Julia out on when she's lying and so has she and she is stronger with her conviction then he is

[@ecxo3126]

tiff also says it gets old but tiff ALWAYS suspects casey when hes literally not doing anything. even when she was dead she STILL accused casey. smh

[@ohhhh]

@@ecxo3126 lmao

[@pittayayas]

@@ecxo3126 Its like the saying ''said the kettle to the pot'' because Josh ALWAYS suspect Julia and she happens to be mafia this once

[@eduardodiaz914]

H P you definitely don’t watch these videos if you say it was just this once lmfao

[@xaving6450]

I usually love Joe but tbh this felt a little hard to watch.. which is a pity :/ Best parts were dead box! ANTOINE WAS INCREDIBLE THO BRING HIM BACK EVERY MAFIA!! Hes killing it!!

[@Tongys]

Im so glad mafia went back to back. Even though yesterday didn't really count, it was still entertaining and quite a long game. And this one is over an hour!!! Thank you JK, you know how to keep us satisfied and happy.

[@yowhat3013]

Joe is slowly turning into a terrible player IMO lmao

[@ironman34561]

Yeah, too much ego in the way

[@AbsoluteFunction]

Or everyone else is getting better so it makes him look like hes getting worse. Antoine is pretty smart though so he just naturally makes everyone else look like peons.

[@solparadox]

I think Joe has always been a better mafia player.

[@tammil8242]

I feel because Joe was better than the others for so long that as everyone has progressed and stepped up their game it's thrown him off

[@makkaucbkia9640]

solparadox He has never been good at this game.

[@KasheYan15]

Lol joe has been pretty wrong lately in the past few mafias

[@GlynettePeralta]

KasheMoneyRemix ikr? ☹️

[@caitlinbrennan9039]

He's not that good at Mafia

[@louisvigirl3]

KasheMoneyRemix it’s cuz joe doesn’t think Julia can do any wrong and she’s always guilty and he fails at it

[@ontherun1957]

joe took no blame for killing tim and instead blamed it on tim for not knowing how to play the game. joe needs to calm down and stop pressuring other players into voting. let them play their own game! vote joe out!!!

[@makkaucbkia9640]

OnTheRun When joe makes a mistake, he blames the other person never himself.

[@followthewhiterabbit8561]

I think Joe is a liabitlity for JKPARTY. I say kick him out. I know he's one of the OG's but sometimes in order to survive and move in a better direction, sacrifices need to be made. OUT WITH THE OLD, IN WITH THE NEW. TAKE JOE OFF.

[@PrincessRiners]

dannnnnnnggg antoine has easily become one of the best mafia players LOL wow

[@55CINCO55]

I knew he was the best the first game he played.

[@mikeellsworth396]

which is why everyone is so suspicious of him

[@g.h3874]

Antoine and Julia are up there for sure

[@karinacarmenn]

joe, sweetie, you really messed up this game. it was so hard to watch him be so wrong

[@samstergunsmoke8645]

Mafia (especially Julia) played great but the civilians were so dumb for killing Tim. What "high level" move do you expect from a guy who's just playing for the first time? It's obvious he didn't know what he was doing, and even when he came out as cop (you could tell that time it was actually sincere) no one challenged him on it, so he was telling the truth. I watched the roles hidden version and even there you could tell there was no way that Tim was mafia.

[@matt4735]

It's easy to see this from an outside perspective, but it's completely different when ur playing the game. There's no stress for viewers playing along, because if we're wrong on what we think nothing bad happens. But when ur choices on what u do actually affect the game and who survives in it, it's much more difficult to choose.

[@calumbowie5476]

Wdym Julia is a complete dimwit she wasn't gonna vote Tim out until Brandon basically forced her into it by giving her a million chances and she could have won the game by simply not voting for Nikki she's literally dumb as a rock

[@busboy8887]

@@calumbowie5476 are you stupid? Of course Julia was going to vote anyway no matter what anyone said because she's mafia and wants any civilian dead. She was just playing an extreme innocent card which made her look really good.

[@calumbowie5476]

@@busboy8887 nah dumbass it only looks that way because Brandon basically gave her 10 chances to change her mind, if he had done that normally she wouldn't have had enough time to change her mind if he had done the 5 second count down. Ppl think she was just pretending to be indecisive so nobody would suspect her as mafia but if that were the case she wouldn't have let it go on for that long because she would expect Brandon to cut it off after like 5secs. But he didn't and gave Joe enough time to change her mind but he shouldn't have had to because obviously mafia would want to vote out Tim. Julia is literally just a dumb fuck who has no idea what's going on it's not an act

[@milksop5653]

calum bowie brandon wasn’t really forcing julia to change her mind. julia was being difficult and not making a clear decision. if anything, joe was forcing julia to vote tim out

[@schaalaydarus9046]

1. Joe took Antoine’s accusation too personal. He was too eager to prove Josh wrong & even made Julia vote for Tim. 2. Antoine is really great at this game even since the first time he played. It did make sense that he wanted to concentrate on one side of the couches first. 3. Please get Byron to play too. He is also very great in Mafia.

[@shakthigakanthasamy8054]

ikr like he just wanted to clear all the suspicion on one side then move on to the other side. Also how likely is it for more than 1 person to be mafia out fo the three he wasn't watching? Nikki's attack on that was pretty bad because Antoine was nearly guaranteed to find one mafia amongst the people he was watching. (well that is considering how good Antoine is at the game.)

[@TitanUnleashed7]

your first two points only make sense as a spectator but they don’t make sense if you were on the spot in the game

[@diegoortiz3465]

Joe was sooo bad in this game

[@pepper6270]

Its cause he gambled $20 xD

[@steelmill7016]

Joe has been terrible lately in mafia. He gets too emotional and cant think straight

[@SumTingWong8]

Yeah, he is not himself Someone please give him a snickers

[@tammas1728]

Antoine was ok in the start but in the end he lost it. Antoine never considers other possibilities and it ruins it all the time. Nobody even considers Julia even though she always plays innocent and actually accuses when she’s civilian

[@jorgelopez-px9gr]

@@tammas1728 you couldn't be more wrong especially in this game, joe was mostly the one who derailed the game by his accusations, in fact, almost every move he made was wrong & on top of that he brought attention to himself by trying to call out antoine who was clearly being the best player for civilians; he got played, again, by nikki for a good chunk of the game (he thought she was the cop & didn't vote for her which would've lost the game for them if it weren't for julia & steve votes, later he had the guts to say he called nikki out 🤣) & julia played off of him too so... His ego gets in the way almost every game, i remember the one where he gets emotional with jessica geo & nikki & he basically lost that game by himself too... dont get me wrong i love joe but he needs to humble himself a bit cause a lot of times he feels he's better than he actually is & it just throws him off, is like he thinks his arguments are infallible. Btw antoine did consider julia & steve as mafia especially near the end, he pointed out julia facial expressions & he brought up steves neutrality too. Top 3 in this game for me: Antoine(light years ahead of everyone on this one), nikki(basically won the game for mafia & once again played everyone like a fiddle, except for antoine 😂), gina (i think julia, maybe involuntarily 🤣, made a good move by killing her cause she was already onto julia & was on the same page with antoine too, it would've given civilians a chance to win it)

[@nope2214__]

joe has been playing mafia bad for a while. Julia and Antoine are amazing players, Julia has gotten so much better and Antoine has consistently showed he's an observant person.

[@ororod2132]

11:07 _Daaaayyyuuummm_ Antoine is on point with Nikki 👀; she's not the only intellectual player in the bunch! 😂😂😂

[@krndevil313]

Antoine always been good at mafia thoo

[@ororod2132]

Yeah but he pin-pointed her tells, faster in this game and didn't let up....that was the impressive part. Him & Nelson (julia's beau) are exceptionally good...even though Antoine dropped the ball a lil at the end.

[@krndevil313]

Ororo D no I agree, and joe is always a toss up, initially he caught Nikki and Steve after that one round which if he stayed on them could’ve swayed the civs but he switched up lol

[@olivetruman8]

Bart is very intellectual too 👍

[@ororod2132]

Oliver Tee - _ehhhhh,_ he has his moments lol

[@roycesato4129]

In a post apocalyptic world, Antoine would be the leader you want to follow. Joe is Shane

[@myriam9938]

Antoine is the real MVP

[@magnifiquealex2807]

Joe was not only way off in this game but also biased as i believe he took it personally when Antoine suspected him as the mafia. We could see this in the end as Joe seemed still pissed at Antoine. Very Sad. Antoine was very humble and kickass in this game, cheers to him.

[@ale_1067]

Lol tiff says josh always picks Julia but she always picks casey.... hypocrite much 😂

[@busboy8887]

Tiff didn't pick casey this game. She mentioned his name when she died but is wasn't really a full on accusation it was more for just shits and giggles

[@preettyE]

@@busboy8887 she just didn't get a chance. When she got in the deadbox first she said no one else but Casey would have reason to kill her first. I don't blame her though. He really does have resting mafia face

[@g.h3874]

@@preettyE resting mafia face 😭😭😂

[@jkkmane]

ALE_10 do you even know the context of it? Watch the video before you make a dumbass comment.

[@raging_al6392]

I seriously don't know how Casey deals with Tiff's accusations all the time. It has to follow them home the way she acts. 😂😂

[@teslaraiden8514]

@Jenna George although the tide turned this game. The accusations were immediate and Casey went on to be one of the town MVPs. That's why Tiff got killed though. It's an attempt to frame Casey, just didn't work.

[@tigress_witchlingdagger5851]

Did anyone else notice that when Tim got eliminated Julia said "civilian" and not "mafia"?

[@ryanmckay6471]

Yeah and noone else noticed !? I was like wtf . I would have instantly known she was mafia from that point on.. They dont pay attention enough.

[@tigress_witchlingdagger5851]

@@ryanmckay6471 Julia gets big props for her play though. She's gotten better as they've played

[@arraikcruor6407]

Yeah I noticed and Antoine jumped up which made me think he caught her slip. However no one noticed and I thought, 'What a missed opportunity!'

[@stephanya8019]

I am I the only one who caught julia cause she said she feels bad cause she killed two GOOD ROLES but MAFIA killed the nurse and the civilians killed the cop so she kinda admitted she’s mafia I also kinda feel like Gina caught it.

[@BakaBoiGaming]

Yeah lots of mistakes from Mafia but no one alive was busy on Nikki and 😧Joe, honestly even Steve was smiling alot

[@arraikcruor6407]

Yeah she said, 'I hope Tim is a civilian, oh I mean mafia'

[@cole7726]

@@arraikcruor6407 no when she said "I hope Tim is a civilian" she meant as opposed to a role like nurse or cop. Cause then she said "or a mafia" meaning like "better than that, a mafia"

[@evojayy2350]

Biggest “SMH” 🤦🏻‍♂️ to joe this video!

[@denny8548]

Joe need to calm down and analyze the game better. Listen to folks surrounding like Gina mention why Nikki & Steve are so quite in this game and no one took it seriously.

[@DisneyxFan1]

antoine is a tryhard every single game but its not cus he's triggerhappy. hes just smart as hell at either mafia or civilian lmao

[@arraikcruor6407]

He is also a deep thinker because at the end of the video he was still thinking even when the game was over.

[@pnm522]

Tim playing Mafia is the best thing ever 😂😂. Three roles just cause haha.

[@chanchaiken5522]

Thats one of the unique moment in the history of mafia

[@igetlazy]

Tim's the real MVP of that game

[@livelife531]

Damn, Joe wtf happened lol Antoine is the new MVP 💪🏽

[@iamhimman]

im going to say that it wasnt tims fault and i do feel its on julia or who ever didnt explain the game he even said i only got told what it is in 5 minutes... thats damaging to content i was looking forward to see tim actually play how hes meant to but eitherway it was still entertaining but its his first game and it would of been nice to see. hope you guys do another with him

[@deaner6421]

That was kind of dumb to vote josh off first. He wasn't suspicious at all. Especially with the gamble money.

[@GlynettePeralta]

When it was time to vote for Tim, Brandon took a looooong time for everyone to think about ☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️☹️

[@vtag738]

Agreed. Overall, he is a good moderator - but he often does that, and it kinda kills the game.

[@elielelwy]

honestlyyyy he’s been a really sloppy moderator lately lol it’s disappointing

[@shutXit1201]

mudda buttaflies I think he felt bad that it was Tim’s first time and everyone jumped on him while being innocent and an important role. Anyway I think Brandon is always low key on the towns side :)

[@arraikcruor6407]

@@elielelwy Yeah his stories aren't that interesting anymore.

[@rueexxi]

Brandon is still so much better than whoever replaced him a few weeks ago lol I like him he only needs to stick to time.

[@steelmill7016]

Joe has slowly become one of the shiit players in mafia. He acts as if he is soo good but lately he been fuckin up. Antoine, Byron and geo best in mafia. Antoine and byron cause they're really smart and geo cuz no one wants to argue against her. She gets defensive lol

[@lilpicnicattac9207]

"Its crazy how I'm the nurse again, like its wild." Lmfaooooo I love him so fuckin much

[@shabnajchowdhury9814]

Was Joe trolling this whole game? He's usually not THIS bad.

[@ThomasDailey]

Maybe not usually, but he's had plenty of bad games.

[@BakaBoiGaming]

Nah the genuine anger he felt when arguing with Antoine even after finding out he was wrong proved he was just being bad

[@makkaucbkia9640]

I think he’s usually worse. He game he raged and accused ant and Casey? Lol that’s one of the cringest gameplay on this channel.

[@arraikcruor6407]

@@BakaBoiGaming Reminded me of when he killed Jess when he was the hunter. Even when she was civilian he still couldn't let go of the fact that that he was in the wrong. He kept blaming others.

[@ason04]

Antoine is extremely sharp. Very observant.

[@Quzga]

I'd love to have him overall in more videos. Including jk news, he's a good speaker and quite smart.

[@thaothach1]

100% agree

[@GlynettePeralta]

I feel like I should be happy for the Mafias but my heart always goes to the town 🙈😭

[@ororod2132]

39:12 Why did the music sound _wayyyy_ more intense when Nadeem decided to protect Steve; I hollered 😭😭💀

[@ororod2132]

Why was Nadeem labeled "doctor" and not "nurse" 😞

[@ororod2132]

When it started off the screen said "nurse" then when he left it said "doctor"

[@ororod2132]

....and yet B.Choi repeatedly said "nurse" is my point.

[@preettyE]

@@ororod2132 the moderator on jkp always says nurse. It doesn't mean anything

[@ororod2132]

It matters lol, I think the editor just made a mistake.

[@fahimahmed8258]

The moderator should've been Mafia for the April fools video

[@Purplesims55555]

That would be hilarious 😂

[@BelanceM]

LMAO. Dude that would have been SO FUNNY! Omg.thats great. Please let them know so they can consider it. Woooow the accusations, the BETRAYAL. This was a beautiful comment/suggestion.

[@iPwnnnn]

This was the best game of mafia! The gameplay was so intense...damn Antoine! Julia was actually pretty obvious with her constant smiles (duping delight).

[@ShiningSeraph]

Anyone catch Nikki's Freudian slip at 19:51? "This is why you shouldn't gamble, kills... kids. Kills? o_O" I was DYING at her reaction at herself, LOL!

[@maluteas]

Dondre Gumbs XD

[@NikeetShah]

Anton gotta be on way more games, dudes too sharp

[@bittytrt]

i love antoine that brilliant man where'd he go to school that man is a god lmfaoo but deadass we need tim to play more mafia he had me weak and Antoine needs to play more too i just like hearing his reasoning no matter what role he is dude Antoine as nurse or cop crazy game

[@nguyen_cogan]

Josh is really good at picking out Julia

[@hootomo]

i mean he always picks her out so of course he's going to be right sometimes

[@travis8592]

Ya they always accuse each other so he shouldn't get any credit for getting it right.

[@meili5689]

Have u watched the other games tho?

[@SikSlayer]

In the end. He was right. AGAIN. But when people like Tiff pick Casey, or Julia picking out wrong people all the time no one says anything. Check the record. He's actually called out more right than wrong, AND he does it early.

[@nguyen_cogan]

@@meili5689 yep

[@rxch2785]

Bro Antoine and Byron on opposite teams would be like an episode of death note between Light and L because of how methodical they are i swear oml.

[@vincentle3954]

When Bart and joe love gambling so much that they start betting on JKP 😂😂😂

[@MordanaRapture]

That wasn't gambling, that was stealing candy from a baby :)

[@thesecond6707]

Nikki used the 'side of the room' defense all game lol

[@shabnajchowdhury9814]

It's kind of dumb that nobody properly explained to Tim how to play the game...

[@sanadj]

Julia bossed this game. Joe is no longer the king. Antoine now sits in the throne.

[@ahnafabdjalil8067]

Joe really lost it lately, he just gets riled up so easily and refuses to listen to other people’s reasoning smh

[@SkylerNZ]

Same goes for Antoine tbh. He wasn't listening to anyone's reasoning but himself. Got way to overconfident just because he got Nikki right.

[@SaintMamba]

@@SkylerNZ nah joe fucked up the game as a civillian. If i was playing i would've thought it was joe too. Didnt even try to listen to Antoine reasoning.

[@A--bq6su]

Brandon ruin the game by waiting for Julia to raise her hand smh

[@lysh9401]

Also another tell steve has is his overreacting when they kill a mafia or kill a good guy Edit: Also antoine was right! if steve was civilian he would've wanted to do more to help

[@Gelfling66]

Tiff jumps on Josh for his "Julia every time?" bit, WHEN HE'S RIGHT BTW, when she's like "but why don't they go for my husband omg waaah". Tsk tsk tsk

[@ikindalikekpop6990]

Steve was playing a bad play. There’s a difference between an observer and a silent person. A civilian would actually put out things they’ve seen and try to help town

[@klarmonte]

Nikki is so good at acting she actually annoyed me SO much this round lol

[@BakaBoiGaming]

Nah

[@FebinThomas0]

Antoine fckin killed it he’s officially on the top tier with joe, bart, and geo when it comes to gameplay

[@caitlinbrennan9039]

I think Geo and him and Byron are best. Bart isn't a good mafia hes too quiet

[@FebinThomas0]

Caitlin Brennan That’s true him and joe used to dominate when they first started. now everyone has stepped up. Bart has very good instincts when he’s a civilian and joe is usually the most dominant player other than this game😂

[@caitlinbrennan9039]

Febin Thomas Yeah I’ve watched every mafia multiple times and trying to remember Bwhen they were amazing Joe was really good at mafia but I think yeah I guess everyone has got better

[@THEsqeed]

Why dont we have bi-weekly mafia videos? Honestly I could watch this everyday but bi-weekly would satisfy lol

[@leoluis43]

It will be very difficult for Antoine to play when he is actually Mafia because now he has to keep up that passion and confidence when talking GL GG XD

[@zdraugnaV]

He has been mafia a couple of times and won (a christmas game and where nelson killed civilians)

[@AM-hz8xv]

Joe's not been on the ball for a lot of games. But good points of this: Loved antoine from the start! Tim just being here for a good time Josh being Josh

[@takyhead]

It’s MAD funny how A LOT of people are hating on Joe. As others had already said, it’s easy for us as the audience, with roles revealed, to judge the players. Let’s see y’all play and we can judge y’all on how well or how bad y’all play. I’m reminded of the numerous times the JK cast have said on JKNews how we, as viewers, can be so judgey and short-sighted. I’m really glad the JK crew have thick skins and can take the stupid comments that we say sometimes. Love y’all JK! 🤟🏽🤟🏽

[@neotechx6114]

No as a joe fan he did horrible like both casey and antoine both agreed that it was steve or julia but he kept attacking antoine beacause of what he was right both times he was very right and Julia herself even played up against Joe saying but Antoine was right he just didn't want to adkwoledge he was wrong he just wanted to be better instead of actually winning the game

[@Heromand]

((IMO)) the ranking for best players in mafia after this game 1- Byron ... no need to explain 2-Antoine (he's up there with Byron but i think Byron can persuade the team better) 3-Bart,Steve (Logical , great at defending themselves, can persuade the team ) 5- Nikki, Joe, Geo (Logical , but also too emotional) the above can play both sides well 8-Gina can play Cop really well, Julia can be a great mafia but not the Civilian team because of her personality. 10-Tiff, Casey, Josh

[@busboy8887]

I agree for the most part except that I would put Geo, Antoine, Byron, and don't forget Nelson (Julia's bf) all at the top. Also, I don't think Tiff, Casey, and Josh are that bad at all. Casey always teams up with the right people at the right time, Tiff has definitely improved but we don't get to see her play much because she's more often than not killed first, and Josh seems to only call out Julia when she actually is mafia (along with other people too) I think Joe is really sinking in the last games because the last few games he's been getting really angry over something he is wrong about and calling out people with no evidence. Just my two sense

[@Heromand]

@@busboy8887 Yup i fucked up Geo is with Bart and Steve. For sure Geo is Awesome she has some 200 IQ gameplays but not consistent. As for Nelson (Julia's bf) i think we have only seen one gameplay from him so i didn't have enough info on him although the game he played was great (he might be super lucky or Genius who knows). And I don't think that Tiff, Casey and Josh are bad, they can read some players but the mafia can easily use their votes for their advantage. :)

[@lizardking1552]

I dont think youre giving Josh enough credit..he has good intuition and reasoning most of the time but because of his personality he can never get his points across. When he does, its written off as 'Josh being Josh' hes better than Steve for sure.

[@SumTingWong8]

Emotional Joe is too high on that list

[@caarlyli]

everyone is saying that joe played a bad game (which he did) but isn't it kinda unfair since we were watching this w/ roles revealed? i'm sure if we were watching it w/ hidden roles, it would be so much harder to pinpoint everyone

[@makkaucbkia9640]

Carly If you can think you’d know it’s NOT just about the gameplay. I think the biggest problem about him is his mindset and his attitude. Notice how not many people pinpoint him picking the wrong person as mafia? Because sure, most people can be wrong on that. But him? It’s always more about his pride his rage and the way he treats people when he calls them out. And when he’s wrong he acts innocent. The way he jumps on people too. Remember Casey? Remember Ant? And now Antoine?

[@sumi2120]

OFF IMAGINE BYRON or BART JOE ANTOINE AS MAFIA YESSSSS THAT A GAME I NEED TO SEE AND GEO OR NIKKI AS EITHER NURSE OR COP

[@JohnDoe-yn7jf]

Joe is traaaashhhh and has been trash for a long, long time. He has such a small beta man, just to prove Josh wrong he got in his feelings. Why people say Joe was the best player when Byron already dethroned all of them when he played and now Antoine has showed his intelligence, his level of reasoning is beyond everyone's. Hands down best player.

[@videos209]

This was the first time I was ever rooting for the town because Antoine's gameplay was so damn good.

[@keisaacepps6235]

That’s hella unfair that they had Tim on the chopping block vote waaaayyyy too long

[@luigiisworld]

What messed Joe up was that Antoine contestd him ,his ego took over and made it all about Antoine 🤣

[@sleepyish1861]

Joe was too in to his feels this game. Like with the whole gambling things, vigorously pressuring Julia to vote out tim & convincing himself that he's mr. right with complete certainty How disappointing. Still fun to watch nonetheless

[@yowhat3013]

No one: Tim as cop: *shakes head* 😞

[@Mr.Lee2345]

They have to really stop their train of thought and rethink other possibilities. Especially joe, lol he’s not my favorite player anymore.

[@Backs3atGaming]

Julia said “I hope you were just civilian” when Tim died... and Niki said “I thought Tim was Nurse” dead giveaways

[@ShiningSeraph]

I was going to comment the nurse comment by Nikki! I'm surprised not many viewers or players caught that, haha.

[@denny8548]

For some reason Brandon stories are much better than Antoine.

[@omnitool1586]

Jeezus, the kid has only moderates once. Give him a break. The reason Brandon does stories better is because he knows the cast better and more personally. But if you look back at Antoine’s moderation skills he was very strong in keeping the game moving along.

[@pandaninjutsu]

How bad did Brandon want to have Tim voted off? Geez

[@Erick-oe8md]

Top 3 best players 1.Geo 2.Antione 3. Julia's boyfriend Dont at me And then there is Joe.. Old king and now not so good yikes

[@shakthigakanthasamy8054]

Right! Nelson did so well for his first time and Antoine is very quickly climbing up the ranks

[@Mayankbhattacharya]

Juliaaaa! God damn she’s got better! Like soo bloody better!

[@THEGSMGSM]

The cast always state how josh is so quick to accuse juila of being mafia but 90% of the time Josh has been right because he knows julia's tells. And the cast need to start realising that and stop shutting him down.

[@etsugin]

The "DeadBox Cam" JK Crew was pretty much our reaction to Joe's accusations this whole game on how he played xD

[@Jasmine-sj6oh]

tim is so entertaining as a special guest, you shouldve just kept him on for the content 😂 and im sorry joe you’ve gotten pretty rusty recently its frustrating to watch

[@krishin11]

Daaaamn i love joe but even bart and tiff pointed out the fact that he hasn't been this wrong in forever. It was an off game for him but still love him

[@Jasond29223]

Pls dont end the video early. More post game discussions!

[@matthewlee2880]

Antoine is a fricking GENIUS! Pure intellect! Hands down the best Mafia player on the whole jk roster, I got to be honest I think Joe is the worst player, he makes the worst decision 80% of the time.

[@tamaraddoan]

antoine and byron in a game together... i would like to see it.