BTOB 비투비 | 'Wind And Wish' Album Listen/Reaction!!!

[@ravishupadhyaya4024]

Hyunsik and minhyuk compose and produce about 70-80% their discography

[@nxxw1274]

And ilhoon mostly too

[@ravishupadhyaya4024]

@@nxxw1274 yes Ilhoon too but I thought till he does a guide he would be overwhelmed so I didn't mentioned him

[@nxxw1274]

@@ravishupadhyaya4024 @Ravish Upadhyaya it's fine but since you said discography it's mostly ilhoon and Hyunsik then only when he left did he stopped making music for BTOB, but it's okay he'll find out soon anyway.

[@Andaeriel]

Oh the composers: They composers within the group are Hyunsik, and Minhyuk. In some songs Hyunsik even played piano, and guitars on his own. In this album: 1. Wind and Wish produce by Hyunsik 2. Heaven produce by Minhyuk 3. Day and Night produce by Hyunsik 4. Moon ride produce by Minhyuk 5. Your Love produce by Hyunsik

[@moodz_melody]

And ilhoon 1004 😂

[@Andaeriel]

@@moodz_melody true. I'm debating whether to put him or not in case it makes the reactor get confused lol

[@moodz_melody]

@@Andaeriel yeah but its better than he finds out much later and gets confuse then 😂

[@LufiYuwanaMursita]

Their concert is usually with live band. You could imagine how good it is, combined with their vocals.

[@justpat2316]

Oh yeah the live band is always better and with their Top Tier Vocals Too!!

[@amgkim6161]

This album produced by Hyunsik and Minhyuk. Most of their songs written by them.😊 And Peniel and Minhyuk write their own rap line, too!

[@far1542]

Promise me you will not regret to check Be Together album pleasee!! It's a full album and be ready for the vocal heaven

[@milody7879]

Up up please 🙏🏼 💙

[@lorainejanneflores9391]

Yes pleaaaaaase 🥺🥺🥺

[@Ipanicious_]

Yes.. Be Together Album pleaseee!!!

[@rai.official23]

up

[@avier6700]

Be together album pleaseeeee

[@melorieeeeeeee]

Gibson: Who's their producers? Me: Themselves 😂 I'll be there to accompany you doing a BTOB'S discography journey, keep it up!!

[@sixteenskies]

you know what’s crazy? btob hasn’t done any touring at all! they participate in kpop festivals around the world but no solo concerts of their own outside of korea yet! isn’t that insane?? we’re all hoping, now that they’re more known globally (and just recently too can u believe that 😂), that they’re finalllyy going on a world tour. fingers crossed!! ps: they’re actually pretty well-known in korea but pretty invisible in the international scene up until they (at least those who weren’t at the military at the time) participated in a survival show called ‘kingdom: legendary war’. since then they’ve been steadily gaining more and more fans internationally! just like me lmaoo if you’re interested in survival shows, i heavily recommend that. they don’t win but they won over everyone’s hearts with both talent and charm~ srsly it was so fun watching the other idols fanboy over them 😂 thanks for reacting to the album so quickly! i enjoyed it a lot!!

[@mirraarrim3155]

Yeahh no tour yet, but so happy that they make a mini concert/fanmeet concert at my country before 💙 they just started to get recognition outside of Korea at least for the max rn to be compared few years back then. Let's go Globally !!!

[@todaytoo_]

it's always so fun seeing people spiral into btob because that's like melodys' usual mood but at the same time it's like we've gotten used to them slaying and sounding like heaven everytime. i also particularly liked the comment when you were reacting to day & night - they ARE grown-ass men who can sing about wanting to be with someone without it being cringey. like, no hate nor offense to any of the younger groups of 4th gen (as a stan of some 4th gen groups myself i fee like i can /joke/ about this), but when 18 y/o kids are singing "i want to do everything with you" i'm like....... "yeah, like what? your homework?" (again, i'm fully aware that 18 is not 15, but as someone who left that age behind a while ago it kinda feels like it, yknow)

[@justpat2316]

I total agree. It doesn’t mean the same coming from the Toddlers😂😂

[@enjenettegBTOBandINFINITE]

If you think Moon ride is dangerous to you, wait till you listen to other songs like guitar, whiskey and dance with me 😂

[@sulistyowati3939]

up

[@tiehecute4830]

Up

[@ladybuhat7129]

up!

[@ayf9867]

Totally agree ☺️👍🏻

[@mirraarrim3155]

Haha omg totally😂

[@ScriptedLife960]

BTOB is a self producing group Hyunsik did Wind and Wish, Day & Night and Your Love Minhyuk did Heaven and Moon Ride And they have their co-producers helping them as well.

[@Andaeriel]

Name Pronunciations: 1. Eunkwang: Enkwang 2. Minhyuk: Minhyeok (actually just o but eo give easier way to describe what kind of o sound is this) 3. Changsub: Changseob (with a not ae, if you get my point lmao) 4. Hyunsik: Hyeonsik 5. Peniel: Peniel 6. Sungjae: SeongJae 7. BTOB: Bee-To-Bee Thank you in your effort to learn about them.. All their songs is vocal heaven indeed. If you interested, their japanese discography is great as well. My fave is LUV, it's a really complex and difficult song with layers of vocal+vocal, vocal+rap, 3 vocals, 2 vocals+rap at the same time and craaazy adlibs.

[@sa_yanchifuyu]

Same! I luv luv😂!

[@nandinisaric1641]

Bravo

[@jerrie2u]

Epic levels of talent at play here! 🤯😵🤯

[@42donz]

You becoming one of my fav reactor deym I sit with you for 27 minutes without skipping a seconds. Its cracked me when you said they sings like the rent is due tommorow, hearing them singing for decades but still they give me goosebumps everytime they sing.

[@justpat2316]

Lol Thank You. They Sing with So Much Passion. God I love it.

[@Ahoney2007]

Love your reaction to BTOB. Last year they produced their 3rd full album Be Together. If you have time pls listen to it. Have a good rest. 😊

[@alfiwahyuningrum7314]

You won't regret getting to know BTOB. They have this positive vibe that will somehow gives you warmth and joy 😊 Thank you

[@ravishupadhyaya4024]

Hyunsik is also called father of BTOB music

[@havecourageandbekind2809]

I wonder what your reaction is to Guitar and Whiskey if that's your reaction to Moon Ride 😆 They're king of adlibs indeed! It took me years to find out who's doing the adlibs as their range is out of this world. My fave is Eunkwang when it comes to adlibs but everyone can pretty much go up up there lol.

[@denissepati4922]

I'm rewatching all of your BTOB reactions because you feel like a friend that I listen, and enjoy the songs with! I'm rewatching because I'll be attending BTOB's concert in our country and I wanted to refresh myself with the lyrics. Then you mentioned you want their concert and concerts will be bangin' with their songs..... it made me squeal with excitement hahaha

[@nhelmynursepta2834]

Omg thank you! I'm waiting for this! no skip album yes TRUE! 💙🍀

[@milody7879]

Well , you definitely need to React WHISKEY, Dance With Me and Guitar 🔥🔥🔥

[@bryama2129]

You forgot Rock and hip hop

[@willbe165able]

They all doing their music all by themselves they do all of it I am so proud of them

[@ftimahtahir]

fun fact: Changsub and Key literally friends and often go out together as they are 91-liners

[@CA-hp9ir]

I think you will love all the songs in Changsub’s solo album. Man, that album made him my bias-wrecker

[@kennettemariegagtan8798]

15:03 Next reaction "BE TOGETHER' album pls

[@jpegbtob]

wait till he discovers 'be together' album and the rest of btob's discography.... we gonna see him go crazy for a whole hour 😂 thanks for discovering and reacting to btob's music! appreciate it a lot when btob earns more international fans 💙

[@justpat2316]

Lol Thank You. People keep telling me about That "Be Together" Album. Im Scared lol

[@erikac2720]

on their official channel they show the recording of some songs. last album we got to see the recording of The song, produced by Hyunsik, and Blooming day by Minhyuk. its to good to see their different styles of producing and how professional and detailed they are. I love those videos. I believe that for WAW they should post in a few weeks .

[@tammy4293]

They have a vocal sub-unit called BTOB Blue, I recommend you check out their 2 performances on Immortal songs, I personally prefer vocal focused performances, and I think their immortal song have maybe one of the best vocals I ever heard

[@lilshmet4167]

Yess the BTOB Immortal songs performances are top tier and honestly unrivaled

[@maryparra40]

I enjoyed your reaction ❤Thank yo so much

[@katherinetu345]

Thx for the reactionnnn I really enjoyed it and it’s so nice to see a new Melody! 💙I would really recommend checking out the Brother Act album too, that one really showcased their versatility and is one of my fav albums of all time!

[@katherinetu345]

Especially the song “Finale” (which was also in Killing Voice) and that was my fav song hands down

[@fernvar7834]

Their concert is very good!!❤❤❤ I cried cause their soul voice.

[@luvioluv1367]

You must react all of their mv and album. You won't regret it

[@jolie0921]

Honestly Moon Ride is my favorite and when you were like Changsub in this is so good I was like YES I THOUGHT THE SAME THING WHEN IT CAME OUT! It’s fits his voice so well. I found your recent reaction to BTOB so I’ve been going through the playlist to watch all your reactions. Thank you for making them!

[@melo_diiiiii]

Btw changsub and key are close friends 😊 looking forward to more btob reactions from youuu 💙

[@stuckwbtob]

Please, continue with your BTOB journey, I'm living for it! Thank you so much, you will not regret getting to know our boys

[@combini65]

It's true that the members are the primary songwriters but they do work with their regular producers like AFTRSHOK or MosPick. I'd think Hyunsik is slightly more involved in the arrangements/instrumentation aspects than Minhyuk (on his solo album Rendezvous he did basically all the work himself, including playing instruments). For example, Hyunsik is credited for the arrangement for Day & Night, while Moonride was arranged by AFTRSHOK and another producer. I second the recommendation of Daemelro for lyric videos, they have more accurate parts and also detailed credits!

[@tammytammytamtam]

once you've been immersed to BTOB's music, you're trapped for eternity just like what happened to all of us melodies. You'll get your standards so high that you won't find anything like their vocals and music. You ain't going nowhere now!! LOL

[@B12321]

Thanks for the reaction! I LOVE your reactions to BTOB! Please do as many reactions as possible lol Be Together + live stages next? Wind And Wish & Be Together are completely produced by Hyunsik and Minhyuk! Their albums are like beautiful+sexy (or more like kinda naughty lol, but shhhhhhh, only Melody knows those b-sides lol, we kinda gatekeeping lmao). But do not skip their previous songs, they are SO good, everything is so good to the point idk what to recommend you lmao, you'll get there!💙

[@pauline280]

Thank you for reacting to them❤. You are so funny😂😂

[@sophiayan7466]

They actually composed this album on themselves 😢😢😢. Wnw day n night your love are composed by HYUNSIK, heaven and moon ride are composed by minhyuk.

[@오마이뎨뎨]

I recently read a tweet on Twitter saying it was annoying to see melody toot our own horns about their top tier vocals and you just reminded me we don’t do it enough. So thank you for your amazing reactions.. I know tons of kmels found you recently and I’ve only seen good comments so keep doing you baby melody!

[@alfiwahyuningrum7314]

Genuine question here: Does "toot our own horns" mean something like "bragging"? Cause if it does then those people are so mean. One of the reasons I decided to call myself a Melody is because Melodies are busy minding our own business. When I saw a post about " List of (good quality in Idol)", many other fandoms kinda like "protest" when their faves don't get mentioned in that person PERSONAL list. However, I RARELY witness any Melody engage in such act. Woaaaah, I got trigerred so bad😅😅 We're just hyping our fave, BTOB, in BTOB's relates video😅

[@오마이뎨뎨]

@@alfiwahyuningrum7314 would you believe me if I told you it was a melody who said that? She basically said that she knows btob is good but she hated it when we (Melodie’s) were always saying they’re top tier singers and that they’re good singers… like I basically joined Twitter to find people who loved btob and basically share the same love for their talents and their singing? Isn’t that what fans do? Adore them for their good singing? Lol still mind boggled about this whole situation but his reaction proved that I just need to appreciate them more

[@norianggok1684]

@@오마이뎨뎨 I think that she/he is not a melody but a toxic fans or antis that pretend to be melody.. Bcs if she/he is truly melody she/he will proudly bragging abt the beats singing abilities like us

[@glenn6791]

Thank you for another good reaction to some BTOB songs.They really are amazing singers and make it a point to give only the best music for their listeners. In fact, they don't want to release a song that's half heartedly done..they feel that it isn't right. They make sure that their songs would match the expectation of the audience. WIND AND WISH Album is really so good..simple yet complicated at the same time..cool vibes and easy listening type of music but very full. About the lyric videos, in Heaven, the mistake was the last part..that ending line was Sungjae and not Minhyuk. Whenever you need lyric vids for BTOB songs, kindly look for the ones made by DAEMELRO coz it's accurate and informative at the same time. It has english translations plus info abut the lyricist, composer & producer of the song. Well, the composer/producer line in BTOB are Hyunsik and Minhyuk. While Changsub is the one with a heavenly voice..he is also known as the intro fairy coz his voice fits being the intro of their songs. It's ok to compare them to SHINee..they are good. They are their seniors and BTOB loves their songs. In fact, Changsub is friends with Key, was with him during enlistment and been good friends ever since. If you're planning for another album reaction, may I suggest you react to their BE TOGETHER Album? It's released Feb of last year has 13 tracks and it's a no-skip album. I promise you that your ears would melt from all the adlibs and harmonies you'll hear. Plus there are tracks there with dance, rock and sexy vibes that you would enjoy. Be waiting for more BTOB content from you..thank you so much for loving our Beats.

[@2whitie]

This album is fantastic! Each song has its own unique flavor. Love them so much!

[@lusitj8597]

They produce it themselves, BTOB is mysic and we are proud Melody

[@myne-zo1rh]

Please react to their Be Together album.. it is soo good..

[@airiesmelody]

The moon ride song was composed by minhyuk. my fav song that composed by minyuk is climax, bro i cant stop crying ! eunkwang also almost cry while singing the song live!

[@rytova_ar]

Can't wait for you to know their personalities and the atmosphere they have

[@0325bsp]

im glad you checked out the album! can’t wait to see more btob content :)

[@estylim]

If you liked Moon Ride, watch their BOTB 4U's Tension Live Stage ;D

[@milody7879]

Please please please 🙏🏼 next is BE TOGETHER album. Is even better 😭😭😭👏🏻🙏🏼🔥

[@alskdjfhg0987]

Changsub voice= Heaven😭

[@jonhloydsebute7772]

they produce all of their songs specially the most recents. you need to react to their recording videos

[@pnlsprkls]

they are their own producers! ^^ that makes me proud as a melody 😆 they know each of their vocal colors, take advantage of them then make masterpieces ike this ✨️

[@허타람찌님귀엽구만]

5:19 It supposed to be Sungjae 7:26 also supposed to be Sungjae Eunkwang pronouce as "en-kwang" Changsub pronouce as "chang-sub" This album fully compossed by the members Wind and Wish, Day & Night, Your Love (Hyunsik) Heaven, Moon Ride (Minhyuk) Day & Night is a fan song At yourlove the one who do adlibs that going crazy at the back is Eunkwang But near end part mostly their vocal line

[@Ong9311]

Now now... dont be surprised...... so here it is.... Key and Changsub are friends. Hahahahahaha! Man of culture you are! Shinee, yes!

[@bryama2129]

If you have time please react to btob dance practice for wind and wish...you gonna love how caotic they are and you gonna get extra live vocals And please next album reaction will be Be Together or Brother act

[@42b4e6_slowblue_na]

아 영상 두 개 연속으로 봤더니 리액션 감칠맛 어쩔거야...ㅠㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@indriaarl]

I enjoyed it so much the way you react to them like you describe it well such as they sounds like heaven and an adlib king, I totally agree with that. And you know, you got all of my support if you want to dive deep into them, if you need some suggestions where to start, I highly recommend you to try listen to Be Together Album, that was very very masterpiece. Thank you so much! Oh also, their performance in Immortal Song, like all of their performance on that show, it's a must to watch!

[@justpat2316]

Thank You and Gotcha

[@cindhytheresia841]

Pat Gibson’s reaction is literally me the first time I discovered btob on 2019 hahaha you instantly become my fav video reactor!

[@angelie912]

You love Shinee...Changsub and Key are close friends cause they served the military together. You can watch several contents with them together.

[@sf7113]

Yes! Everyone deserves to hear BTOB perform live. It's really CRAZY GOOD💙 I went to their 10th anniv concert and the 3 days isn't enough. I will pay 3x the price for that concert! fun fact: Key and Changsub are military buddies💙 im in love with Key too!

[@kel7321]

Tysm for reacting to BTOB!😆💙fun fact: day and night is a fan song and hyunsik asked the engineer to extract melody’s scream from concert and he intended to make the song 3’21 (they debuted on 21/03/2012). they always make little things to show how much they love melodys🫶🏻💙 Oh and they self-produce most of their songs 🙌🏻✨

[@nindylestari2648]

Omg i didnt know this before! Can you tell me where can i get more info about this?

[@kel7321]

@@nindylestari2648 changsub said this in the radio with heize as the host during cb period🫶🏻

[@len5278]

Ty for your reaction.waiting for your reaction to their live performances

[@jollybean5135]

Fun fact: Changsub and Shinee's Key are close friends and served in the military at the same time. You'd have a blast checking out their interactions, theyre HILARIOUS

[@ravishupadhyaya4024]

I suggest you to do a guide for btob

[@ghinanabhila843]

I swear it's worth to watch their concert. Bcs you gonna hear their exact and extra voice that microphone can't catch! The experience is priceless!

[@widya108]

you mentioned about concert, and HELL YEAH! Their concerts were BEYOND AMAZING! You can find their last 2 full concerts (2018 and 2022) here on yt. For 2018 concert, there are "official" videos with good quality sound. For 2022 concert, you have to be patient coz mostly are fancam so the sound quality is so-so, but even then, it still goosebumpy!

[@zikfarah]

Thank you for this album reaction !! Welcome to the melody family! HAHA

[@paulee9413]

Waiting for your other BTOB reaction. Thank you for appreciating my boys specially my Man, Changsub 🎵😍 He's besties with Shinee's Key tho 💙

[@taemabaho07]

You try watch BTOB funny moments compilations 😂 you will know them more better haha, especially during their backstages rest area. They are so noisy! Thanks for your reaction video. 😊

[@justpat2316]

Lol They seem Like It. And Thank You!

[@boated915]

you ult shinee so it only makes sense you like btob… your taste is impeccable haha! kibum from shinee and changsub are actually friends too :)

[@milody7879]

Minhyuk composed Moon Ride and my fav bside on the album 🔥🔥💙

[@許寶加]

I recommend you to listen to the INSIDE album. Trust me, you'll love it.

[@MASHUYUE-jm9zs]

Love B2B and wait for more reactions🎉

[@justpat2316]

Thank You😊

[@rai.official23]

I recommend you check their previous album "Be Together" you will more love this album!

[@aljaw-fa4333]

I’ve watched almost every reaction to btob yet your reaction is the best and the way you express yourself is just so funny I love it 😂 thank you for making my day better 🤍🍀

[@AAADRONEIDAAA]

Suggestion for albums is both Be Together and Brother Act. Be together's songs are chefs kisa and brother act is one I treasure a lot because of its beauty 🥹

[@ra.nanana]

Your reaction is my reaction too ;D

[@snow.white2587]

Once again i love your reaction vid😂 hope you enjoy the other BTOB albums

[@maidaldal]

You make me appreciate their song more. Thank you for reacting and i hope to see more of them from you 😆

[@justpat2316]

Thank You And You Will for Sure!

[@aroobalt]

Btw changsub and key are the bests of besties you can find a live of them together on yt(translated)

[@sophiayan7466]

I recommend you to Check album in this order: new man, feel’eM, brother act, this is us, hour moment, be together (all songs in these albums are nice for me). Some other songs I recommend to check are it’s ok, Wow, Show your love. (Actually I love nearly all their song but these are my favorite)

[@sunnyrainysnowy270]

The group name is pronounced as bee-tu-bee 😄

[@mauisilverlight9358]

I think you'll find that BTOB songs are mostly relaxing and easy listening. I love listening to them while driving or while working. They do have more intense songs but Wind and Wish album songs are all easy listening.

[@ahudAr]

Once again i saying to thank you every time your react to the BTOB MV, i hope your ytb is always good 💙🍀💛

[@itawahyu201]

Thank you for your reaction, but it is better if you watch their live performance video. It will make you amaze with their voices more 😊😊

[@Lian-b5k]

Hyunsik is genious.. most of their title songs are made by Hyunsik (or Minhyuk)

[@justpat2316]

Total Geniuses

[@fao_faochannel7475]

When he ask us,.who is the producer of this song, ohhh come on dude they are self producer idol 😎, yesss we proud

[@loreinbatinga4342]

Minhyuk, hyunsik write and produce most of BTOB’s songs. And also, i have to mention Ilhoon, when he was still in the group, he made legendary songs for them too

[@kyrrasaoy4599]

this whole video is a wild ride and i'm all here for it. hahaha. you went from liking their voices to wanting to hear more of their songs to saving up to see them live and, honestly, same. hahaha i'm excited for more of your journey! i especially like their full albums so you might have to get a bottle of water ready with you bcs those are *12* songs. stay safe! 💙

[@justpat2316]

I Feel Like im gonna need a Gallon of Water lol

[@maelopez415]

Hyunsik and minhyuk composed arranged and produce most of their songs

[@ilhoonsquad]

btob producer line: hyunsik, minhyuk and ilhoon hyunsik produced wind and wish, day & night and your love minhyuk produced moon ride and heaven most of their songs are self-made except for the earlier songs in their career :) also love that ur a shawol! great taste!!!💚

[@annabelletsai2804]

They actually make their own music! Heaven and Moon Ride are composed by Minhyuk and the other three are composed by Hyunsik. Also, you are absolutely right cause their live performance is super crazy! I'm also a oversea Melody(Their fandom name) and I'm looking forward to their world wide tours... Hope they do it this year! And Changsub is actually a good friend of Shinee's Key! (They joined the military together)

[@user-ws2zx3om8v]

Thank you for reacting to btob

[@さーもん-j3z]

Thank you for your reaction😌 If you would like to know about their individual talent and personality, I recommend you to check some guide of BTOB✨

[@ayf9867]

there's a guarantee you're gonna listen to good songs only if you go through btob's album, istg there's no skip album of btob. and you're gonna love their live concert, i can't wait till you meet the member name jung ilhoon also, he's one of the composers along with hyunsik and minhyuk, aaaa why am i the one who's excited 😂

[@gloriad.3350]

You and me both! 😅😅working hard for their future concert since they are much better at singing live. 🍀🍀They produced their own album and won't release it unless it passes on Hyunsik standard😊

[@sa_yanchifuyu]

I think i missed out 'moon ride' when i binge this album😃 Seriously thats minhyuk song?! Urgh i thought i cant hear btob song like this after iruna leave!!

[@doublekfitness]

I had so much fun watching this video. Subscribing because I don’t wanna miss your next BTOB album review 😊

[@B12321]

Next time you check out BTOB lyrics videos you can also use videos from "DAEMELRO BTOB English Sub", they're a Melody who also writes who produced and who is doing the ad-libs in the back. Their videos are very well made!💙

[@anggunsausan6738]

Thank you for reacting to BTOB 😍 Oh, just a small note, BTOB should be read as "Be to Be" not "B.T.O.B" 😍 Everyone already said it that BTOB is a self-producing group. Hyunsik are mostly the main person who arranged his own composed songs (so he composed, arranged, and wrote lyrics), meanwhile Minhyuk contributed as the main composer and lyrics writer for his own songs (also writes his own rap parts in 95% of their songs). Oh God, I want to recommend Be Together or Brother Act albums, coz those 2 were the best on its production although other albums are also this great! But I want you to keep these 2 for later 😅 So anyway, i don't know which one should I recommend to you for the next reaction 😅 Maybe their MV? Then continue to their albums.