Doctor Who "Rogue" Reaction

Question of the day:
Do you think we will see Rogue again, and if so, when?
If you're new:
I do reactions to things I enjoy kinda sporadically.
Hope you enjoy :)
Disclaimer:
I do not own the rights to this song, video, audio, or pictures, nor do I use it for my own personal gain. All rights belong to the owner.
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use.
This video/film is for the entertainment of you. Don’t try anything that may get you hurt!

[@JustSoShayla]

Hello girl scouts, it’s time for “Pinned Comment Post Post Ramblings from Future Shayla” - As per the after-show ramblings, I’m currently on vacation so a short lil message today. Loved Rogue, loved the fun adventure, almost D&D lite. Happy Pride everyone! Again, I have had zero copyright issues and I waited a few days before publishing so if this video goes down I will do my best to get it back ASAP, thank you for your potential patience.

[@Domino2097]

enjoy your holiday

[@youknow227]

You might have been confused by the extra face at 4:15 We're all confused, don't worry

[@alwillcox]

​@@youknow227Well... We know who it is (Richard E. Grant's Scream of the Shalka Doctor). What we're confused about is why he's there.

[@davidjrandall1979]

@@youknow227 That was Richard E Grant who played the Doctor in the animated Scream of the Shalka series

[@youknow227]

@@davidjrandall1979 Yeah, I probably should have explained exactly why everyone's confused

[@Land967]

Saw an article in the newspapers saying this was a "historic first same-sex kiss on Doctor Who" clearly they didn't watch the 9th doctor and Captain Jack.

[@bentertainmentproductions8451]

Or 11 and Rory.

[@Alfwin]

Or Vastra and Jenny. Or Bill and Heather. Pretty sure there were a few others, too; this was more like an "historic _seventh_ same-sex kiss on Doctor Who".

[@wendyheatherwood]

It's the "Disney's First Gay Character" effect leaking over.

[@ihateunicorns867]

It was the first time The Doctor romantically kissed a person of the same sex. Captain Jack kissed him and Rose goodbye. This one was a proper romantic kiss.

[@gohanmoreno7]

@@ihateunicorns867 Exactly, is the first time that The Doctor himslef had kissed someone of the same sex romantically, for Rory it was just pure playing like Bugs Bunny and Vastra and Jenny or Bill and Heather they are not The Doctor, but now with Rougue there is the first time that The Doctor have a gay and romantic kiss in scene.

[@SejhaIsHere]

"I want this to be happy, but its doctor who" truer words never spoken

[@Jackson-yr7jp]

What are we dead naming tv shows now 😂

[@_hollowsky]

@@Jackson-yr7jp But it's still called Doctor Who

[@Jackson-yr7jp]

@@_hollowsky i know thats my point

[@Joey15811]

Its not doctor who. Its doctor Eric 😂

[@davidjrandall1979]

With Rogue saying "Find me" I'm sure we'll be seeing him again. Hopefully he'll become a recurring character in a River Song kind of way

[@rickysfilmreviews3825]

Yeah. I thought that too with the Doctor’s daughter.. 😂

[@cooluncle4242]

You are probably right but unless I misunderstood the ending wasn't he sent away to the same place as the cos playing aliens who I assume would kill him. I do believe he'll be back in the future, similar to the River Song storyline. While I'm not a fan of the Doctor being romantically involved, I'd rather it be with someone who isn't a companion

[@sheridan5175]

@@cooluncle4242 eh. he's still got that gun.

[@charg1nmalaz0r51]

@@sheridan5175 that he never bothered to use all episode

[@shinichi4476]

@@charg1nmalaz0r51because the doctor said “no killing” and Rogue was smitten

[@IceMetalPunk]

When Rogue pushed Ruby off, the transporter said "matter transfer". It had already registered 6 people, it needed to be 6 people, so it had to be a swap; he couldn't just move her away.

[@TastySalamanders]

8:43 If it helps - the triform device only had a maximum of 6, which the Doctor explained after they realised there was more than one chuldur (after the dance but before the wedding). There were 5 chuldur + Ruby trapped by the device so the device was at maximum capacity. Rogue going in overloaded it to 7 allowing Ruby to get pushed out.

[@thombruce]

Yeah, and it's a bit crackly but if you listen to what the triform says when Rogue switches with Ruby it says something like... "matter exchanged, mass locked at six". So not only was six the maximum capacity, it was also locked in at that capacity once reached. It's a little bit contrived, but it works for the story and how it works is all there in the text of the episode.

[@alexsimpkin5620]

4:16 I love how this episode just casually confirmed that Scream of the Shalka is still canon. As the Richard E Grant's Ninth Doctor is shown amongst the other Doctors.

[@ihateunicorns867]

Either that or there was a major plot twist with The Great Intelligence we were unaware of.

[@zvimur]

@@ihateunicorns867 or..... "The Curse of Fatal Death"?😈😆

[@ihateunicorns867]

@@zvimur It certainly would have put a twist in the episode if we saw Rowan Atkinson's face floating up there.

[@ihateunicorns867]

Got major Girl in the Fireplace vibes from this episode.

[@IceMetalPunk]

"I snogged Madame de Rogueador!" 😁

[@lucia7247]

Agreed and I love it!!

[@zvimur]

6:58, Ruby (like Clara) is the Lisa Simpson of the show... "too smart for her own good".

[@cargo71]

That was clever... Yes. I´m afraid Ruby won´t end well, unless she has a hell of a guardian angel...

[@jasonmarbach]

I loved this episode SO much. D&D! Wonka (after Ncuti has spoken about how he manifested this role after told his agent he wanted to either play the Doctor or Willy Wonka)! Richard E. Grant’s canonization! Jonathan Groff and Ncuti having more chemistry than a technical college! Millie being wonderful and iconic as always. The representation! Happy pride! Hope the chuds cry themselves to sleep 🥰

[@LondonCelt]

I'm loving Ncuti more with each episode, he just is the Doctor isn't he?! Millie also does such an amazing job, I have a feeling we're not ready for the 2 part finale.

[@Alfwin]

This episode was so much fun! And, as you say, an awesome episode to kick off Pride Month - love to see it! Rogue was a fun character, and had great chemistry with the Doctor; I certainly hope we see him again! I think the reason Rogue was able to free Ruby from the trap was that it had a _maximum_ capacity of six, so him entering the trap overrode her position in it. Had there been only five people in the trap, Rogue entering it wouldn't have been enough to free Ruby. I love the scene at the end, where Ruby basically tells the Doctor, "I'm not gonna let you not let yourself grieve". Friends don't let friends stifle their emotions in unhealthy ways! (Also, RIP William Russell, the first ever Doctor Who companion)

[@MichaelJohnson-kq7qg]

Yes. It says: "Matter exchange. Trap locked at six". Earlier, they set the trap limit to 6, he couldn't turn the trap off, but he could change WHICH six it was.

[@mrgadd]

What if rogue is the one who waits? Since he is waiting for the doctor to find him!?!?

[@Kn1ghton]

This episode was beautiful. I teared up when I saw the kiss scene at the end. Being able to see myself in my childhood hero brings me so much joy and happiness. This show means the world to me.

[@jasonmarbach]

Happy pride! ❤️❤️❤️

[@db7541]

It was awful. There was no plot, the bird people were so nothingy they may as well not have been there, Ruby was given almost nothing to do, and the Doctor was suddenly uncontrollably attracted to a random bloke he only just met. In 26 seasons the Doctor was presented as aromantic and asexual, then it went to America for the film in 1996 and it never recovered. Since then we’ve had him be interested in Grace, Rose, Joan, Clara, River and now Rogue, and all of them are utterly out of character except maybe River and certainly Joan Redfern because he actually was human in that episode so that made sense. But otherwise it’s unbearable, the idea a 2000+ year old TimeLord is attracted to a man in his 30s is like a 70 year old hitting on a 6 year old in terms of life experience, these people are like children compared to him. But RTD will push his LGBT propaganda into DW to the destruction of all.

[@Kn1ghton]

@@db7541 very sad… anyway

[@cairothetiefling_]

I am so excited to see your reaction to this incredible episode- the drama, the chaos, the tension both good and bad, and naturally the doctor’s tension with rogue and their banter. ❤

[@JackBarrugon]

Shayla in her regency outfit - looks good! But Shayla in battle mode, that we would all like to see!

[@houseofsledge6891]

You remain epic! Thank you for what you do here. Liked and shared.

[@seanred2977]

This episode was such a 'let's see how many random things we can throw in' episode, but in true DW fashion, in somehow still worked. Great scenes between The Doctor and Rogue. He's almost definitely coming back. My guess is we'll see him at Christmas or next series at the earliest.

[@hollibean5007]

Great reaction, Thanks :) outfit is fab and I really like the themed title cards,well done .

[@artemisSystem]

i think "Just Rogue?" might be my favourite line in all of doctor who now

[@SmazSolaire]

Another great reaction and fantastic shirt to go with it!

[@kerouac.jackson]

Rogue asking the Doctor whether he was capable of sacrificing his friend to save the world or not makes me think that maybe that was how he lost his previous friend/partner. Maybe he sacrificed himself out of guilt for having done that in the past? Just a guess, though.

[@kivimik]

Ruby introduced OK two and a half decades early: first appearance of the word was in 1839.

[@boghag]

That's the first reported appearance. It could easily be a little bit older. And the only one who picked it up was "Emily Beckett", a Chuldur.

[@P5YcHoKiLLa]

1:09 Torchwood OG's Holla ! 2:33 Let's face it, He's Captain Jack (A Torchwood revival would do so well on Disney+)

[@mpg272727]

Richard E. Grant is the Doctor. That's it. That's the comment.

[@jamesfield1674]

IKR so awesome imagine if Rowan Atkinson face was there too and many more ;)

[@Newbunkle]

Your intros have been fab this season. 👍

[@JesseTaylor-de4pm]

It maxes out at 6 so when Rogue jumped on it would of destabilised it allowing him to be able to push Ruby off but not get off in time before it restabilised as there was now 6 8:34

[@Jim_The_Fish]

Shalka Vs The Great Intelligence It’s just an episode of Richard E Grant arguing with himself in a mirror

[@MichaelJohnson-kq7qg]

I'd 100% watch that, though.

[@jamesfield1674]

So stoked to see Richard E Grant in face lineup of Doctors

[@Pilcro]

We'd better see Rogue again qwqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqqq

[@angelarts]

Why could Rogue push Ruby off the trap? The capacity was 6 only, so the moment Rogue stepped into the triangle it became 7, and the trap temporarily couldn't bind everyone in it. But he pushed Ruby off quick enough that it locked back onto him once she left the tringle and it became 6 again. (Part of me wondered why they couldn't have just put a human-weighing object in there, but I guess it's because the Chuldur would be able to anticipate it and risk them leaving the trap as they were placing the dummy weight onto it.) Not the most "reliable" trap, but remember that the Doctor had to "hack" it to go from capacity 1 to 6, so speaking as a software engineer myself, I can buy that.

[@ben-tendo]

Two left, but with a Tales from the TARDIS special inbetween.

[@csk7769]

feel like the logic on the triform's p clear, it's set to a specific load, so it's not like you can't interact with it from the outside, so long as you replace the set amount of targets

[@ElisaH_DarklyiShine]

Alot of people miss when the trap says "matter exchange" when rogue takes ruby place so I think u can only get the person off the mat if someone takes the spot

[@jazi.p8900]

I called it as soon as they starting flirting that Rogue would be the hero by the end and sacrifice himself. But man did they give us all of it before hand. Absolutely loved it. The ring moment at the end was top tier. Possibly my favourite episode so far purely because it was somewhat classic DW villain, fun, emotional moments. I want more of Mr Groff, his and The Doctors chemistry was 🎉 giving Jack/River Esk chemistry.

[@IsiahBradley]

THANKS for this!!!!

[@SeeJay81]

My take on the logic is that it could hold up to six so you can keep adding, but once there's already six, you can only add if you displace someone else.

[@classicwhotv]

Yes new vid

[@classicwhotv]

First as well❤

[@johnhudson9167]

Great costume, looking good 👍

[@JesseTaylor-de4pm]

It maxes out at 6 so when Rogue jumped on it would of destabilised it allowing him to be able to push Ruby off but not get off in time before it restabilised as there was now 6

[@RenatoGPadilla]

You know what this episode made me realize? This season is a LOT like Series One. Space Babies - First trip to space for Ruby with the Doctor having the same shot as 9 and Rose and the whole infinite wi-fi joke. 73 Yards - gave me "The Girl Who Waited" Vibes, but it also feels like a bit more fucked up "Father's Day"... And then there's this, with Rogue being the new Jack Harkness, since they're probably never getting John Barrowman again, except this time, the Doctor flirts back. (Even down to the cooler-looking ship and the furniture quips!) Also, WOW they acknowledged the placeholder Doctor from the comics before the Show came back... Respect. The needle drops were fun too! I caught some Billie Eilish and some Gaga myself! "We are gonna Cosplay this planet to DEATH!" is gonna be EVERYWHERE this Con Season... Side-Note: Have you noticed how the old lady that keeps showing up is always a Motherly figure? Aside from being the neighbor and the hiker, she was the nurse robot in "Boom!", the mother of Lindy in "Dot and Bubble" and now a Lord's mother... I THINK she might be Ruby's Mom keeping an eye on her... But then, what about "Never seen a TARDIS before"? Maybe Susan? Romana? A Guardian of sorts or The Rani? I have SO many questions! (Side-Side-Note: NOBODY tell Yaz and Jack that the Doctor actually started flirting with a gay man the second they were left alone or they will start KILLING PEOPLE. They pined for SO LONG!) Edit: Just unpaused. YOUR OUTFIT IS SO CUTE!

[@gwinnellheald8592]

Ayyy, ive been looking foreward to you watching this one! Loved it. Rogue is a lovely new addition to the whoniverse and Im BEGGING they bring him back before Ncuti regenerates bc their chemistry was off the charts! My only complaint is these episodes (the whole series so far) would benefit from an extra 15 mins per episode to flesh it out. Edit after watching: i think the matter transfer thing means that it trapped up to 6 people but once it went over 6, the 7th person would be able to move, so rogue stepped in but shoved ruby out so he could ensure that she was the one that got out. Its kinda glosses over it for the sake of the emotional beat which makes sense.

[@bobfather7355]

A theory while in the transport they show Ruby's feet stuck to the ground. So when Rogue pushed her outhe was literally stuck there.

[@StephanieMaireFaith]

Did u notice Richard E Grant in the doctor past life's

[@ZeldaKAnderson]

the gate was 6 max so i guess when there was 7 it mightve slightly weakened the stickiness

[@MrNathansdad]

Lol, you know Who too well. It's like you were sitting there when RTD was writing

[@darkphoenix6807]

I just realized “battle mode” meant Dance Battle, not fighting. 😂

[@MrNathansdad]

🫣OMG, yes. Thank you

[@artemisSystem]

oh wow, only 9 episodes this season? gonna be very exciting with the last two then

[@me82sjm]

as a dnd nerd i gotta know if you play?

[@barriehull7076]

"Penultimate finale" does that mean there is/are two finales, sorry, just had to!

[@Dunybrook]

I hate it when they do that. Now we have to find Rogue even though they've set that up as being impossible.

[@cargo71]

I can see Rogue getting away by his own, and blaming the Doctor for not goint to rescue him (pretty much like Jack after The Parting Of The Ways)

[@_leao3459]

kdjdkjdk Simplesmente amo a energia da Shayla 5:06

[@barriehull7076]

Dot off, don't work. Tri whatever off, don't work. Does no technology understand the Doctor.

[@Joker-bl4jy]

YEAH you must be sebastian

[@maniak6496]

Is it just me, or is Shayla becoming gradually more British?

[@kimo4u2]

The woman you keep seeing i presume is Ruby"s mother

[@camhusmj38]

Rule number one is the Doctor Lies per River.

[@robvanriot]

6:03 DID YOU DO A BRITISH ACCENT? How long have you had that up your sleeve!?

[@TheManInTheLongBlackCoat]

I can very much see Rogue being the next Captain Jack. 🫡

[@cooluncle4242]

I guess it's one way to avoid bringing back John Barrowman.

[@steve8510]

REG is canon!

[@joshuajoshua2732]

This is not Dr. Who this is Soap Who.

[@Joker-bl4jy]

you have really weird gestures OMG!!!! and in another universe your name should be sebastian ı think. hahahahaah :DD

[@Joker-bl4jy]

longer hair is better think ? you looks like sebastian seriously !!!

[@youknow227]

6:42 that's what Sesskasays said

[@The-Radio-Demon04]

The episode was pretty good, Other than the Doctor and Rogue Romance part. I'm not interested in watching Gay Guys. If it were a Straight Couple or Lesbians then sure but not Gay Guys. Other than that, It's a pretty solid episode.

[@timothyp8947]

Thought this was a fun episode… Rogue is giving me Capt. Jack vibes to the extent of wondering if that’s who he lost. Total random conjecture on my part 😊

[@danmzungu3427]

I can’t believe you didn’t see the similarities between Captain Jack and rogue

[@torchwood00]

time to say bye to the doctor

[@ACtheLegend]

Many have tried, they're all dust now.

[@joshuaverran9443]

This is not Dr. Who what's Dr. Who is the show that ran from 1963 to 1989.

[@almanediligence9505]

They have been waiting since day one in order to have the first black gay Dr.Who have his first gay kiss on TV.

[@joshuaverran9443]

I absolutely hated the Doctor kissing and having romance this is not Dr. Who.

[@MrNathansdad]

Do you hate River Song?

[@robvanriot]

First time watching the show huh?

[@almanediligence9505]

No, thank you. I'm a black man, and I can't take this anymore 😪! The first black Dr.Who should have been like Black Panther or Shaft!

[@user-mr7pv7qf4o]

Welcome to the cringe 🤣😬

[@shortfry0250]

How?

[@cairothetiefling_]

@@user-mr7pv7qf4owoah you’re so bored you came here to comment your views on gay people on a sci fi show reaction?

[@davidjrandall1979]

Seeing two people who are attracted to each other kiss?

[@adamcarlson2192]

@@davidjrandall1979 Don't you know how cringe it is to be attractive!? /s

[@shortfry0250]

​​@@user-mr7pv7qf4o 🤣🤣 how? Its just people being them selves ahh totally cringe.. grow up

[@almanediligence9505]

The gay loves story is obvious. Everything in this episode was completely predictable and pointless! Dr.Who is fake and emotionally empty 😔 😢😮