कहां Jagjit Singh... कहां Pankaj Udhas ! | Anurradha Prasad

[@sukhvinder13]

I liked Pankaj Udhas quite a lot, but am surprised at what he said about Jagjit ji, Jagjit Singh is the uncrowned Emperor of ghazals who is unparalleled and will always remain unparalleled. Nobody can even compare to him. He is a different league altogether. Ghazals and Jagjit ji are synonyms with each other.

[@AAA-f8r]

Who is The Best Pankaj Udhas. or Jgjit Singh.... The question is wrong... Both are maestro in Ghazal world.

[@imranmohiuddin273]

Exactly right.

[@imranmohiuddin273]

Don't compare potatoes with 🍅 tomatoes.

[@ashutoshs3189]

I've heard all the songs of 80s and 90s albums of pankaj udhasji he's my all time favorite playback singer 👌👌👌👌👌

[@AjayKumar-tx6mj]

Jagjit Singh Ji is Greatest Ghazal Singer For Ever

[@someshpanigrahi378]

Pankaj Udhas is not even 5% of what Jagjit Singh was in terms of skills and selection of poetry. Jagjit was a maestro; had a great hold on Hindustani classical. Most of the so called ghazals of Pankaj Udhas are not ghazals but typical Bollywood styled geets. Those who know ghazals, don't even consider him as a ghazal singer.

[@vighneshshirdhonkar2592]

Exactly ❤️

[@vighneshshirdhonkar2592]

Even the lovers of Begum Akhtar, KL Sehgal and Mehdi Hassan also don't consider Jagjit Chitra as the ghazal singers. But Jagjit Ji has one vibe and those who know the value of ghazals will consider him as the Ghazal singer ❤️

[@sachinhsoni]

@@vighneshshirdhonkar2592 kzbin.info/www/bejne/pJbQnmBvqLijotk

[@sharadnannaware9540]

That's true... जगजीत सिंग जी को ही ज्यादा सूनते है लोग...जगजीत जी अपने संगीत के करियर मे हमेशा उच्च स्थान पर कायम और कामयाब रहे है...शास्त्रीय संगीत मे पंकज उधास जी का नाम भी कहीं नहीं आता...पर जगजीत सिंग जी के नाम का जिक्र गीत गायन , गझल गायन , भजन गायन और शास्त्रीय संगीत मे भी सन्मान से किया जाता है.

[@musicallypeaceful7676]

@@vighneshshirdhonkar2592 Mehdi was not even dust of Ghazal maestro Jagjit Singh's shoes. Kl saigal was the pioneer of indian playback

[@karanatwal8546]

Ghazal ko Jana jata hai india meh to uska credit jagjit singh ko jata hai , wo to swarg se aye Ik gandharv the unki awaz meh Daviye sanmohan tha wo ik devdhut the wo aye the chale gye, nida Fazli sahab ne ik bar kaha tha jagjit singh ik awaz meh mere Allah ki awaz khunj ti thi , unki awaz ik ibadat thi unki awaaz Kai rote hue chehron ko Hansa deti thi aur Kai hanste hue chehre ko rula deti thi, unki awaaz ek Mohabbat ka paigam thi ❤🌹😭

[@999999751]

This gentleman truly lives in fool's paradise ! He is like Krishan Kumar who was better known as brother of Gulshan Kumar ! This so called singer was cheaper version of Jagjit singh for music companies whom Jagjit don't sing or sung very rarely !

[@rajeshchopra2565]

I am shocked at Pankaj Udhas's remark about Jagjit Singh ji...Jagjit Singh is. Inimitable and a classically trained singer and exceptional composer...There can be no comparison between the two of them...In fact in one of the interviews when Asha Bhosleji was asked to rate singing of Pankaj Udhas she said she listens to only a few ghazal exponents such as Begum Akhtar...Mehdi Hasan sahab...GhulamAli and Jagjit Singh. Today I have lost respect which I had for Pankaj Udhas

[@sohailsohail7478]

Pankaj udhas is the name of time but jagjit singh is the of era

[@smartmd4278]

Don’t compare jagjit Singh and pankaj Udhas and ashiqui movies songs were chaapa of Pakistani Songs.

[@imranmohiuddin273]

Exactly right, don't mix potatoes with tomatoes

[@vinitagarwal2064]

Hahaha 😅ye much aur masoor ki daal. Kahan The Jagjit Saab aur kahan ye one faceted joker

[@jaymataji99245]

Abbey he is also best singer

[@singermohdsahilofficial9611]

Miss u jagjit singh ji ❤❤❤❤❤

[@musicallypeaceful7676]

Lol Pankaj Udhas not even dust of Ghazal maestro Jagjit Singh

[@vighneshshirdhonkar2592]

Jagjit Ji is my fvt and literally he carried out the legacy of Ghazals. Though his range is limited and his choice is, but Pankaj Sir you have literally arrogantly discussed about Jagjit Ji. Your ghazals are typically a limited Bollywood Style songs. So sir do plz learn the value of Ghazals first ❤️

[@prashantsagar2155]

You are right..

[@shaktikohli953]

Well said n analyzed

[@sukhvinder13]

Who says Jagjit Ji’s range is limited. He had such a vast range. He even sang classical and took alaap’s like a piece of cake. His voice was deep, came from his soul and was absolutely mesmerising. Pankaj Udhas’s voice was just sweet and flat, no emotions or depth or variation.

[@vighneshshirdhonkar2592]

@@sukhvinder13 as per Pankaj ji, he is limited. But as per us, he was a gem sir

[@vighneshshirdhonkar2592]

@@sukhvinder13 The way Jagjit Ji used to sing classical, bhajans, ghazals, and the way he used to joke during his concerts was just a next level ❤️

[@sharadnannaware9540]

पंकज उधास जी का ये बयान सुनकर थोडा दुःख हूवा .. असल मे जगजीत सिंग जी के गायन का दायरा बहुत बडा है...गझल , गीत , भजन और शास्त्रीय संगीत मे भी जगजीत सिंग जी ने बहुत बडा योगदान दिया है ...उनकी मखमली आवाज ही काफी है दिल को सम्मोहित करने के लिये...गझल का नाम सुनते ही जैसे ' मिर्झा गालिब ' याद आते है वैसे ही ' जगजीत सिंग ' भी याद आते है...आज भी जगजीत जी के कुनबे मे करोडो दिवाने लोग हैं जो उनके गीत गझल गाकर खुद को गौरवान्वीत महसुस करते है....💐🙏 विविध रागो का आलाप जगजीत जी बडी ही आसानी से लेते है वो कर पाना और किसी गायक के बस की बात नहीं...जगजीत सिंग जी ने अपने गायन और संगीत से जग को जीत लिया है... जगजीत जी हर अंदाज मे गा लेते थे परंतु पंकज उधास जी नहीं.. 💐🙏

[@shaktikohli953]

Well said

[@mangeshkhose4253]

जगजीत सिंह जी की पंकज उदास के साथ तुलना करना ही गलत है, एक वह इंसान हैं जिसने हजारों गजलों और गीतों को संगीतबद्ध किया है और उसे खुद गाया है और दूसरा वह जिसने चंद फिल्मों में थोड़े से गाने गाए है जिन्हे आप ग़ज़ल भी नहीं कह सकते, जगजीत जी ने गज़ल को एक ऐसे मकाम तक पहुंचाया है जो की अब तक कोई भी बड़ा ग़ज़ल गायक नहीं कर पाया. बस इतना कहना चाहता हूं की सूरज और १०० वॉट के बल्ब की तुलना कभी हो ही नहीं सकती.

[@imranmohiuddin273]

Will remain in our hearts ❤ forever.

[@naveenbinwal7422]

सब बकवास कर गए पंकज जी, एंकर ने सही बताया है कि ग़ज़ल को जन जन तक पहुंचाना सिर्फ जगजीत जी का काम है। वैसे भी उन्होंने गायकी के हर हिस्से को पहचाना हैं। बाकि आपकी जगह उनसे ये सवाल पूछा जाता तो वो खुद ही मना कर देते कि ये कहते हुए कि जगजीत सिंह कोई तोप थोड़े ही है। महान वो होता है जो सामने वाले को बड़ा बताए। आपकी तरह नहीं। आपके लिए सिर्फ इतना ही 👎

[@imranmohiuddin273]

Exactly right he made ghazal common for ordinary people.

[@amsinghg5703]

Jagjit Singh is beyond comparison. Pankaj Udhas is not even the dust under his feet. Anyone who is even asking this question does not have any idea about music or sensitivity. Pankaj Udhas sang only about Sharaab, Ghungroo etc and degraded ghazal and classical music. He had a few hits in the 80's and 90's but his body of work is dust before Jagjit Singh

[@VikramSingh-fz3bl]

Jagjit singh sahab ke pair ki dhool bhi nhi hai pankaj udas

[@bapirajsinger4512]

Pankaj ji ki baat se mai thodi si asamarth hun kyunki jagjit ji gayaki ki har kheshtra me mahir the jagjit ji ki voice copy bhi nhi hua aaj tak aur na hoga jagjit ji ka naam ghazal ki duniya me bahat izzat se liya liya gaya hai ilya jaayega miss you jagjit ji🙏🙏🙏

[@pavanpakar3571]

How innocent you are Pankaj g. It's like you know nothing about Jagjit singh. We respect you a lot, but you are nowhere near to Jagjit singh whether it's technicalities of singing or popularity.

[@ranjandebnathranjmusicalgr3640]

Pankaj Udhas is popular but no match to Ghazal Mestro Jagjit Singh Ji.

[@singermohdsahilofficial9611]

Mai jagjit ji ko bohot zada Miss ke raha hu

[@singermohdsahilofficial9611]

Jagjit singh ji bohot acha singer tha

[@scienceexplained809]

He is wrong or maybe misguided. He lost much of his respect in the eyes of me by calling himself as the identity of ghazals because I still remember I started listening ghazals due to Jagjit Singh ji, and I started listening to him so late. Jagjit Singh ji was a senior to him and far above him. He should have never given such a ludicrous statement about Jagjit Singh ji.

[@vighneshshirdhonkar2592]

And anchor has said correctly that Pankaj Udhar has sung for the masses and Jagjit Ji sung for the classes

[@prashantsagar2155]

सबका कमेन्ट पढ्ने के वाद मै ईश नतिजे पे पहुचा हु कि सिर्फ चार गजले गाकर कोइ गजल गायक नहि बनता । RIP पन्कज । कोइ किसिको यसेही पध्म भूषण नहि देता ।कहाँ हरिद्वार कहाँ मल्द्वार ।

[@imranmohiuddin273]

Immortal

[@sankarchoudhury1972]

Pankaj Udhas @ foolish arogant made himself a laughing stuff by trying to be at the level of Sh Jagjit Ji

[@sigmasfact2320]

शहर में तेरे करके वफाएं हम तो हुए बदनाम, किस्सा ये अपना किसको सुनाएं हम तो हुए बदनाम

[@mangeshkhose4253]

I don't consider Pankaj as clasical singer & Ghazal singer.

[@satyendrasinghbhadauriya]

ये बेरोजगार बौड़म के कोई सुनता पूछता नहीं इसलिए जलन बदतमीजी दुष्टता मक्कारी ईर्ष्या में भरा रहता है।

[@aligamingandvlog6727]

Ap range ki bat krty ha to ustad Mehdi Hassan ki voice range b boht limlted thi but his ghazal singing is matchless.....

[@weleloog8138]

First of all ghazal singing is not papuler music as compared to filmi music Ghazal music listeners are very limited "ba zoaq logon ki choice" Some singers special voice for ghazals singing and one of them jagjit singh after Mehdi Hassan and ghulam Ali... Classical impressions of some urdu words just like"neend"or "nhi" "khatam on jagjit singh" Live Concert's singing will tell you that what is ghazal singing than recording

[@singermohdsahilofficial9611]

No pankaj udas srif jagjit singh ji bs

[@baldevthakkar8975]

Raja bhoj ( jagjit ji )🙏🏼 roj sunta hu🙏🏼 Gango telii ( pankaj )👎🏻 Khabhi nahi sunaa 😇 Faltu bakvas, besura

[@imranmohiuddin273]

Irreplaceable

[@headhunter907]

Pankaj udas ko kuch nhi aata.....usse accha ghazal mai gaata hu

[@imranmohiuddin273]

Pankaj udhas was godgifted.

[@sohailsohail7478]

Sir pankaj udhas sirf ghazal singer hai but jagjit singh is not a ghazal singer well know classical ustad

[@subhashgaur6855]

चिटठी आयी है,,जिस दिन से जुदा बो हमसे हुये,, ,,,एक तरफ उसका घर,,,,,चांदी जैसा रंग है तेरा,,,,निकलो ना बेनकाब,,, थोड़ी थोड़ी पिया करो,,,ऐसी बहुत है जो हर कोई आज भी सुनता है,,जगजीत जी की बस एक ही याद है,,चिट्ठी न कोई संदेश,,बस,,,

[@subhashgaur6855]

बिल्कुल सही कह रहे है,,,पंकज जी,,जगजीत सिंह जी से ज्यादा पॉपुलर है,,,

[@wethepeople2067]

😂😂

[@sukhvinder13]

😁😁😁😁din mein sapna dekhte hou

[@shivkumaragarwal8425]

Pankaj Udhas was better ghazal singer.

[@baldevthakkar8975]

Raja bhoj ( jagjit ji )🙏🏼 roj sunta hu🙏🏼 Gango telii ( pankaj )👎🏻 Khabhi nahi sunaa 😇 Faltu bakvas, besura