Karl Marx in poetry of Iqbal | کارل مارکس کا ذکر اقبال کی شاعری میں

[@muhammadrafique8377]

واہ! کیا بات ہے. بہت ہی خوبصورت اندازبیاں. اب اندازہ ہو رہا ہے علامہ اقبال کس پاۓکے شاعر تھے.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Shukriya

[@aneelahmed8896]

❤❤❤ ماشاء اللہ بہت ہی عمدہ تیری بتاتے ہیں اور اپ بہت ہی اچھا ترجمہ کرکے میں سمجھاتے ہیں اپ کی اسان اور نفیس اردو میں باتوں کو موتی نے پروتے ہیں

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Shukriya

[@sameerkhan1078]

Next level MashAllah

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@englishlanguageandliteratu6833]

Through you, we get to know Iqbal.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Honored

[@MuhammadAhmad-zb5zq]

​@@khurramellahiofficial Sir I think that we will never be able to find a perfect economic system in this world instead of introducing new economic system humans have to do self accountablity and they should made belief that Greed is more immoral then a murder .They will introduce their own system so i think that's more then a psychological and a moral issue then an economic issue .

[@MuhammadAhmad-zb5zq]

​@@khurramellahiofficialThe world says: "You have needs -- satisfy them. You have as much right as the rich and the mighty. Don't hesitate to satisfy your needs; indeed, expand your needs and demand more." This is the worldly doctrine of today. And they believe that this is freedom. The result for the rich is isolation and suicide, for the poor, envy and murder. Fyodor Dostoyevsky, The Brothers Karamazov

[@Daniyal-khan-swati]

بہت اعلی انداز سے آپ نے یہ سارا مقدمہ سمجھایا ❤️

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@inventor7868]

Very Nice Explanation.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@MuhammadFarooq-u4y1b]

اللہ آپکو محفوظ رکھے اور صحت عطاء فرمائے❤

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Ameen

[@mianzark4751]

Thank You for this amazing video. I request you to kindly make a series on books recommendation, from beginner to advance level (like a syllabus), so that we can get start with journey of knowledge. This will make easy for us to approach subjects like philosophy, poetry etc.

[@IfraJaved_Official]

Amazingly described .

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@AinulhaqKakar]

اسلام علیکم ورحمتہ اللہ وبرکاتہ ماشاءاللہ بارک اللہ اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کے عمر و علم و اولاد و رزق و عزت میں برکت عطا فرمائے آمین خرم الہی بھائی درخواست ہے کہ ھم سب مسلمان اور اہل پاکستان بلکہ پوری برصغیر کے انسان اس امر میں لاعلم ہیں ،، کہ سب مسلمان یا انسانیت کے پیروکار کہ سب انسان انسانیت کے حقوق میں برابر کا حق رکھتا ہے ،،، بلکل ،، اللہ تعالیٰ نے سب انسانوں کو پاک فطرت پیدا کیا ہے اور اس کے بعد ماں باپ کے عادت اور ھیدایت پر ایک دوسرے سے مختلف ہوتے ہیں رہ گئی معاشرے میں انیس اور بیس کی زندگی یعنی اچھی اور پیکی زندگی ،، یہ ھر انسان اپنی نیت و عادت اور محنت کی مطابق اس دنیا میں بھی زندگی میٹھی اور پیکی زندگی جیتے اور گزارنے ہیں اور روز آخرت میں بھی اپنی نیت و عادت اور عبادت کے مطابق اجر و مقام ملتے ہیں اور بقایہ سب انسان عزت و احترام و محبت و احساسات زندگی کے حقوق میں برابر اسلام نے حق دیا ہوا ہے ،،، واللہ اعلم

[@arsalanmubarak5643]

MashAllah bouhat acha kaam kr rahy aap Allah pak kamyab kary...

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Ameen, thank you

[@aliraza-soomro]

This friend's lecture is truly excellent and worth listening to. So far, if you look at mainstream media or KZbin channels, you will see debates among clerics from different sects discussing and explaining Sharia. However, no one really talks about economic and social issues to this extent. There should be more lectures like this, so that society can see the other aspects of social life and find a way toward their resolution.

[@khadijaahmed5494]

Jazakallah khairan katheera Bhai Allah humma barik

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@waseemijaz4087]

Bohat khoob, very well explained. Keep it up

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@ProgressivePakistan1]

شاندار ویڈیو ۔ نسان دوستی کے فلسفوں کا فروغ جاری رکھیے ۔

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Shukriya

[@LiaqatAli-zd5uv]

Bohat khub ❤❤❤

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@shahidakarimullah2485]

May Allah bless you. This is true dissemination of Islam

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Ameen, thanks

[@IbrarMuhammad-s6z]

❤ MashahAllah❤ Bravo 💯✌️

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@mdalimasoomi786]

Masha Allah ❤️❤❤

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@mdalimasoomi786]

@khurramellahiofficial jazakallah khair ❤️🌹

[@Wordsforproves]

Sir great work ❤❤❤ Iqbal is my favorite poet

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@KnowledgeIsPower-nt1mq]

Sir okara cantt auditorium میں جب آپ کے لفظوں نے مجھے جکڑ دیا تھا آج اس سے آپ نے مجھے آزاد کر دیا۔ بہت شکریہ

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Now here is some deep message. But thank you for dropping your words

[@ameertaimoor5220]

@@khurramellahiofficial 😇

[@smilelife3643]

smjh ni i.

[@mehndiflair7204]

You ignited the desire to resd philosphy, inshallah start the journey.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

That’s great to know

[@Wisdomdigger101]

Yes Khurram Bhai. Open my mind, expand it so I can understand how manipulative all this has been and we could only sit and watch and be sad on this reality that you present. Masha Allah. Thanks again for enlightenment and vision. You need to go more hardcore and shake us out of our misery.

[@MasroorBandraCompassion]

Bahut khoob what's a good analyce❤

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@hanzala_afandi]

Great insights in the video. Some people misquote "religion is the opium of masses" just to criticize religion but Marx (as you pointed out) said this about capitalist propaganda and how they propagate this in the prolitariets. Great lecture ❤❤

[@syedhamzaali6677]

Iqbal (r.a) chose to burn the verses of his youth, knowing that true insight requires the sacrifice of early passions, that the soul must first refine itself to channel the deeper currents of wisdom and thought. #KhurramEllahiOfficial❤ I'm grateful for the unveiling of Iqbal’s profound insights

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you so much

[@fawadfayaz7734]

U r library are getting better day by day ❤😮

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@amanfatima3085]

​@@khurramellahiofficialYes it's looks like a rainbow 🌈

[@rtrt3607]

Mashallah sir

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@iqbaljaved2739]

Great efforts

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@fazarnan9616]

Masallah ❤

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@WAQeE135]

Nice Video Brorher Can You Please Recommend.e Some Books. Like How Can We Proceed For The Revolution.

[@ImranAhmed-oz3kk]

بھائی میرے۔۔۔۔۔۔اللہ تعالیٰ کی مشیت کے خلاف ہے۔ تمام انسانوں کا برابر ہونا۔۔۔۔۔۔

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Even economically? We aren’t equal in terms of knowledge, conscious scale etc, But even economically we can’t be equal?

[@saadrasoolarain]

bhai plzz jalib per ke poetry describe kryn..

[@muhamnmadmehrab]

Sir please upload video on daily basis

[@thinkagain2229]

❤ I support your demand

[@khurramellahiofficial]

I would surely try to

[@LaLBuxKhoso-r8l]

Good idea

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@mebboobaslam1899]

Salam Khurrum Sahib...great talk and awesome effort to bring Iqbal and other great thinkers like Karl Marx to our attention. This is my first time listening to your post. And I not quite sure that what is your ultimate objective. If you please allow me, I think that given the current abject conditions of Muslims in the world and particularly in Pakistan, people like you and Turkish economist like Almir Colan must work toward formulating a practical framework for an Islamic ecomics/comnerce framework that in my opinion is a great combination of Capitalism and socialism. For example, Quran identifies the distribution of wealth as purely a divine prerogative and thus such claasification based on wealth in the society is not unnatural. However, on the other hand, Islam teaches that such wealth is given as a trust to us and it must have a due share for the poor and needy and no amount of exploitation is permissible. This is where, in my opinion, the Islamic teachings bridge the gap between the Capitalusm and socialiam...which is more practical and realistic approach. What do you think?

[@bdullah.1]

Kindly Answer this Question as you are the most relevant person to answer it in my mind. خودی کو کر بلند اتنا کہ ہر تقدیر سے پہلے خدا بندے سے خود پوچھے بتا تیری رضا کیا ہے The above mentioned stanzas of Iqbal poetry have been criticized by so many clerics and scholars. I hope that you know it. I don't want to mention them but their objection with the stanza is that how can God himself ask the person of higher خودی to write his faith with the person's willingness. They said is God so bound to do this? They said how can Iqbal say that? They compare it with blasphemy and say that this is against the philosophy of Islam. If you are reading it you're requested to kindly make a special video on it including all other stanzas of Iqbal of the same context. Jazakallah.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Please watch this kzbin.info/www/bejne/g3qwaIiNbt-Hd5Isi=2QbnK82dqDfXqiEn

[@SOHBAT-E-SHEIKH]

My dear brother, this stanza is actually the translation of hadees e Rasool S.A.W , (sahi Bukhari) جب مومنوں کو جنت میں ڈال دیا جائے گا ، اللہ تعالیٰ اُن سے کہے گا ، اے جنّت میں رہنے والو میں اب تمہیں سب سے عظیم چیز دینے لگا ہوں ۔ پونچھے گے کیا ، جواب ہوگا میں آپ کو اپنی رضا دینے لگا ہوں ۔ Allama Iqbal, also wanted to see his existing generation in jannat , where they would be given Raza e tala . Hope you understood.

[@bdullah.1]

Jazakallah

[@mohammedilyas7792]

ما شاء الله

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Shukriya

[@vikshitdu]

Zabardast

[@M.Noorullah]

Sir I want to learn philosophy please guide me and mention some books ❤ please sir g

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Story of philosophy by Will Durant

[@M.Noorullah]

@@khurramellahiofficial Allah pak bless you.Ameen

[@Ghdhdh233]

​@@M.NoorullahSophie world, western philosophy b Russell ,Story of philosophy, pleasure of philosophical

[@paramjitvirk7052]

Fantastic

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@abidattari2438]

Khurram bain ... excellent...but a request to make a podcast with beloved of mine and as well as ur Sir Ahmad Javed about philosophy of history including heagls dialecticalism....love u ... From occupied Kashmir India

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you I will surely try to request and record a podcast with my Master also

[@khurramellahiofficial]

I will surely try to record one with Master Ahmed Javed sb Thank you for kind words

[@shakeel_developer-f7x]

Sir ap jesa banane k Liye kese parhna pare ga kia parhna pare ga kese start kare journey?

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Start from anywhere today. Read everyday. Make notes. Enjoy the universe. And this journey shall be completed with happy mind.

[@shakeel_developer-f7x]

@@khurramellahiofficial sir Aetheist na ban jao

[@khurramellahiofficial]

@@shakeel_developer-f7x your faith is so weak?

[@shakeel_developer-f7x]

@@khurramellahiofficial sir bas Kuch Aetheists k questions parh kar pareshan hojata hoo

[@khurramellahiofficial]

@@shakeel_developer-f7x so the solution is not to read and close the eyes?

[@syedbilal9965]

brother kya ap koi books recommend karskte hy? islamic philosopher thinkers pay jo ho. to start with .aur app unpay videos banaye app sab philosophers ki bat krty hy Islamic philospers ki b ap ab ek series start kry kyu ki abi bht sab chezay unkay khilaf boli aur banai jarhi hy khass kr imam gazali k khilaf. app ibne rushud ,al farabi ,ibne sina gazali ibne khaldun etc pay videos banaye❤️

[@englishlanguageandliteratu6833]

یہ عمارات و مقابر یہ فصیلیں یہ حصار مطلق الحکم شہنشاہوں کی عظمت کے ستوں سینۂ دہر کے ناسور ہیں کہنہ ناسور جذب ہے ان میں ترے اور مرے اجداد کا خوں ساحر لدھیانوی کا یہ شعر بھی مارکسزم کی طرف اشارہ کرتا ہے۔

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Beautiful thought

[@ameertaimoor5220]

G bilkul q k Sahir Ludhianvi bhi Left Wing thought k Danish war writer the . Left Wing Sara socialist or inqilabi hai.

[@rtrt3607]

Nice sir

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@multandigital7152]

mashallah

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@nosheensadiq9289]

The desire to know the titles of all the books in the back and on his table📚🌹

[@rashidahmed2572]

Nicely explained. Marks could has been the greatest reformer if he could gain faith.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thank you

[@waqarahmed9503]

Asr-e-Hazir Malak-Ul-Mout Hai Tera, Jis Ne Qabz Ki Rooh Teri De Ke Tujhe Fikr-e-Muash

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Wah

[@ارحم-علی]

So what's the solution? If not capitalism nor communism? Allama Iqbal ne ye bhi bataya hoga, Kindly wo balance nizam bhi batae?

[@noshadar]

Islam

[@AhsanUllah-h7z]

I like you very much sir,

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@muhammadsohail9272]

سر مجھے اقبال کو پڑھنے میں دلچسپی پیدا ہو گیا ہے آپ کو سن کے۔ سر ایک سوال ہے یہاں کے سستے لبرلز کو اقبال سے کیا تکلیف ہے ہر وقت اقبال پہ تنقید کرتے رہتے ہیں۔ کیا انہیں یہ اشعار نظر نہیں آتے ؟

[@khurramellahiofficial]

They don’t want to appreciate him. Simply. There is a lot of bias for him.

[@badking5506]

Poems ky lyrics bhi add karty toh acha hota

[@khurramellahiofficial]

We have started adding in latest video

[@nadeemmushtaq9653]

Assalamualaikum Ap kay video's se Aisa lagta hai ki IQBAL ZINDA HAI (DAMAT BARKAT)

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@abdulrahmanahmad1794]

Sir what was iqbal’s view on evolution and Darwin?

[@khurramellahiofficial]

You might like to see this kzbin.info/www/bejne/hnfWoqRposmSaqcsi=GHh35sWT93xiiq-k

[@Hussaini14]

Iqbal r,a was true legend❤

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Indeed

[@informativeworld3103]

❤

[@surehbadshah221]

sir kindly read the two paragraphs after that phrase "religion is the opium of the masses ".karl marx used these words in a positive sense. at that time opium was used as a medecine, not as a drug.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Dear I think you are mistaken here. He took religion as an obstacle in way of revolution, rest I tried to convey in video. He thought that religion makes people passive for the revolution and they love their misery and try to find reward in world here after.

[@surehbadshah221]

@@khurramellahiofficial Sir here are the 3 paragraphs of the book titled "critique of Hegel's' phiosophy of right." which was written in 1843. The foundation of irreligious criticism is: Man makes religion, religion does not make man. Religion is, indeed, the self-consciousness and self-esteem of man who has either not yet won through to himself, or has already lost himself again. But man is no abstract being squatting outside the world. Man is the world of man - state, society. This state and this society produce religion, which is an inverted consciousness of the world, because they are an inverted world. Religion is the general theory of this world, its encyclopaedic compendium, its logic in popular form, its spiritual point d'honneur, its enthusiasm, its moral sanction, its solemn complement, and its universal basis of consolation and justification. It is the fantastic realization of the human essence since the human essence has not acquired any true reality. The struggle against religion is, therefore, indirectly the struggle against that world whose spiritual aroma is religion. Religious suffering is, at one and the same time, the expression of real suffering and a protest against real suffering. Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the heart of a heartless world, and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people. The abolition of religion as the illusory happiness of the people is the demand for their real happiness. To call on them to give up their illusions about their condition is to call on them to give up a condition that requires illusions. The criticism of religion is, therefore, in embryo, the criticism of that vale of tears of which religion is the halo..

[@surehbadshah221]

Any revolution that detached a man, or a state from a religion is not acceptable.

[@ameertaimoor5220]

@@khurramellahiofficial right n true..

[@abdulsalam-qi4ry]

خوب

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@haseebmahad6146]

I've a question. Claiming that religion is discovered by rich people for poor people, which contradict the historical background of our Prophet (SAW) and Sahabah and even other prophets that came. They lead a very simple life. I think we perceive religion wrong that it makes you poor but rather it makes you rich in every aspect of life.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Certainly that was claim of Marx. Look what Iqbal considers Islam as kzbin.info/www/bejne/pYGoi6ythJl3oqcsi=AtGZHmxqmXOZFzeS

[@syedehteshamhussain8816]

ماشاءاللہ بیٹا آپ نے علامہ اقبال کو بہت گہرائی کے ساتھ پڑھا اور خوب تبصرے کرتے ہیں، کیا آپ نے علم کے شہر کے دروازے پہ بھی دستک دی، نحج البلاغہ کے خطبات پڑھنے کی زحمت کی، کبھی توفیق ہو تو ایک دفعہ ضرور با غور مولا علی کے خطبات پڑھیں، دنیا کے سارے فلسفی اور دانشور پست اور بونے نظر آیئں گے۔

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Indeed no philosophy can match that. No one.

[@حسنکاظمی-ش3ح]

میں بچپن سے ہی سوشلسٹ تھا میں نے بارہا مزہب کو اپنا لباس بنانے کی کوشش کی لیکن مزہبی تفریق نے میرے اس لباس کو چھلنی کر دیا میں نے دوبارہ کوشش کی کہ میں شاہد میں غلط ہوں سو پھر اٹھا اور پھر سے توبہ کی اور پھر سے مزہبی رسومات کو نبھانا چاہا لیکن مجھ سے یہ نہ ہو سکا۔۔۔پھر جب میری عمر تیس برس کے برابر ہوئی تو مجھے سوشلزم کا پتا چلا۔ایسا لگا جیسے میرے سارے سوالوں کا جواب مجھے مل گیا۔۔لیکن وقت کے ساتھ ساتھ مجھے یہ محسوس ہونے لگا کہ میں دن بدن اکیلا ہوتے جا رہا ہوں۔۔مجھے انسان کی انفرادی تنہائی نے جکڑ لیا۔۔۔آج میں دنیا سے الگ تھلگ پڑا ہوا ہوں اور کوئی مجھے پوچھ کر راضی نہیں۔۔۔میرے دوست بھی مجھے چھوڑ کر چلے گئے میرے اپنوں نے مجھے خود سے دور کر دیا۔۔میں سمجھتا تھا کہ سوشلسٹ لوگ مجھے حوصلہ دیں گے میرے آنسو پہونچیں گے۔۔میرے درد کا مداوا کریں گے ۔۔۔۔ اب مجھے لگتا ہے کہ میں کسی فوج کا حصہ بن جاؤں اور کسی بارڈر پر عزت کی موت مر جاؤں😢

[@DrMuhammadAbrarUmar]

Bhai allma sab jen Islamic scholar ka zikar keya hy kabhi onko bhi mention like Allama anwer sha sab

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Will surely include all those, the journey has just started brother.

[@DrMuhammadAbrarUmar]

@@khurramellahiofficial thank you brother

[@sharifdar9642]

❤❤❤❤

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@imranbasit8276]

Why ع on your T shirt?

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Reflects Ishq and Ilm

[@abdulrehmanaga8740]

I am a Marxist, as usual you describe very well

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks

[@ameertaimoor5220]

Great

[@apeaceofheaven2506]

والله فضل بعضكم على بعض في الرزق کی تشریح بھی دیکھ لی جائے

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Certainly, but we still can appreciate some good thoughts and cherish how Marx stood in front of accumulation of unlimited wealth.

[@apeaceofheaven2506]

@@khurramellahiofficial 💌💌💌

[@MuhammadIqbal-he6nj]

علامہ صاحب نے یہ بھی فرمایا :- گیا دورِ سرمایہ داری گیا دکھا کر تماشا مداری گیا گراں خواب چینی سنبھلنے لگے ہمالہ کے چَشمے ابلنے لگے.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Beautiful reminder

[@salfibrothersfarooqtahir9535]

اگر نطشے اور کارل دونوں قرآن مجید اور سیرت النبی ﷺ کا مطالعہ کرتے تو یقینا وہ اسلام کو اپنی امیدوں سے بڑھ کرپاتے ، ہمارے ہاں مصیبت یہ ہے کہ ہم نے خوف زدہ کمزور اور مصلحت بین مولویوں کی شخصی پالیسیوں کو ہی اسلام سمجھ لیا ہے ، حالانکہ اسلام کی صحیح ترین تعبیر سیرت النبی ﷺ کے ذریعے سے ہی معلوم ہوسکے گی ، جہاں ایک حکمران فاقے کاٹ رہا ہو ، اوراپنی رعایا کے قرض تک اتارنے کی ذمہ داریاں خود ادا کررہا ہو ۔

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Beautifully said

[@Zxcvbnm12345f]

100 percent true

[@worldfamousbiographies4149]

اگر پاکستان میں کسی نے اقبال رح کو پڑھا ہے تو وہ علامہ خادم حسین رضوی ہے ، کمال کی grip تھی اس شخص کی💯

[@safikhan8637]

جناب خادم حسین ( حضرت رضا احمد بریلوی کی نسبت رکھنے سے) رضوی کہلانے والے بریلوی مسلمانوں کی راہنما شخصیت نے جس انداز سے کلام اقبال کو اپنے خطبات میں استعمال کیا ہے ۔ اس کے نتیجے میں اسلامی جذبات ابھار کر پاکستان میں بریلوی حضرات کو سیاسی شعور کو بیدار کیا ہے۔ کاش تحریک لبیک پاکستان کے راہنما اور دونوں صاحبزادگان پاکستان کے بریلوی مسلمانوں کے اسلامی جذبات کو مشتعل کرنے کی بجائے اسلامی تہذیب کیلئے مشعل راہ بنانے میں کامیاب ہو جائیں ۔ ورنہ آگ لگ گئی گھر کو گھر کے ہی چراغ سے۔

[@ameertaimoor5220]

Hahaha.. Iqbal bhi bhot barri film tha or molvi Khadim bhi bhot barra madari tha jisko agencies k j.c.o ranks k ahlkaar Handel krte the. Iqbal k lines jb molvi khadim ki zabani hm sunte hen jin men maghribi dunia pe tanqeed hoti or ye Iqbal un se mutaasir ni hai or 2sri trf jab Iqbal k love letters haseen gori mams ko likhe huay or Europe men ghar banane ki Hasrat or tarrap dekhte hen to hmen dono pe hansi aati hai... Khoub munafiq the ye dono.

[@ameertaimoor5220]

@@safikhan8637 nice opinion .

[@omarkhan3256]

Your views on Karl Marx are incomplete and misguiding. Marx saw socialism as the next evolutionary stage after capitalism. So capitalism is a prerequisite in Marx's view. This is one of the reasons that socialism failed in the Soviet Union. People who have not read Marx get carried away by the revolutionary spirit and think that Marx's theories are applicable to countries like Pakistan.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

I have to agree with you regarding incomplete but I had no intention of misguiding. The whole video is about how Iqbal looked at Marx in his poem Devil’s Parliament

[@omarkhan3256]

@@khurramellahiofficial I did not mean that you were intentionally misguiding anyone but incomplete information usually has that effect.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

@@omarkhan3256 I am glad that very few are listening with such attention, how you heard and left a note for me to further take care And I will surely work on your suggestion

[@ameertaimoor5220]

@@khurramellahiofficial nice n Great.. ✔💐🙏🌹

[@mhworld7674]

You are refering "ablees ki majlis e shura" it is a dialouge between ablees and his disiple actually deciple is praising karl marks and said aa these word which you arr refeing to Iqbal .look at the answer given by ablees to disple .

[@khurramellahiofficial]

But who wrote that? Iqbal. Moreover , I added other verse from Persian work. That’s purely by Iqbal and not included in Devil’s Parliament

[@ameertaimoor5220]

@@khurramellahiofficial exactly sir. Persian wrotes Iqbal is very bold n different then Hindi Urdu wrotes Iqbal.. I think you should must read the book authored by Professor Syed Nasser Shah sahb.. named.. Kuch Shamen Fikr E Iqbal K Sath. A very fantastic book on Iqbals personality.

[@synonyms97]

I think u r a biggest fan of carl marx

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Oh No. not at all. I just forwarded the view written by Iqbal.

[@DrMuhammadAbrarUmar]

Gharebi ka hal bhi Quran awr hadees mn hy❤

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Indeed

[@Menoff7-d8s]

So what is the solution?>

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Isn’t it great that we know about the problem until we can’t identify the solution

[@laiba_kainat]

بھائ کتابیں انقلاب کیوں کھا جاتی ہیں؟ میری زندگی کا سب سے بڑا سوال

[@laiba_kainat]

بھائ اتنی کتابیں کیسے یاد کیسے رکھ لیتے ہیں آپ

[@khurramellahiofficial]

By spending good time with the books, after a while you can recall the words you read.

[@malikyasir6427]

جس کھیت سے دہکاں کو میسّر نہ ہو روزی اس کھیت کے ہر خوشہِ گندم کو جلا دو

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Khoob

[@malikyasir6427]

ماشاءﷲ بہت خوب سلامت رہیں ​@@khurramellahiofficial

[@amirmuhammed7687]

اپکا منفرد لیکچر بار بار غور و فکر کے ساتھ سمجھنے والا ھے ۔ حبیب جالب نے کہا تھا ۔۔۔۔ حالات وہی ھیں فقیروں کے ۔ دن بدلے ھیں فقط وزیروں کے ۔ موجودہ دور میں میڈیا پاورفل ھے اور وہ جو بھی ڈرامہ دکھا رہا ھے اس میں بڑے عالیشان محلا ت ڈریسذ آعلیٰ کھانے دکھاتے ھیں یہ غریبوں کے ساتھ مذاق اور تماشا ھے ۔

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Wonderfully said

[@ameertaimoor5220]

G bilkul aesa hi hai.

[@Artcodigitalflex]

یہ ابلیس کے ایک مشیر کے مارکس کے متعلق خیالات ہیں جنہیں اقبال بیان کر رہے ہیں

[@Adilrai-iz2bq]

ہنوز اندر جہاں آدم غلام است نظامش خام و کارش ناتمام است غلامِ فقرِ آں گیتی پناہم کہ در دینش ملوکیت حرام است دنیا میں ابھی تک انسان (انسان کا) غلام ہے اس کا نظام (حیات) خام اور اس کا مقصود (حیات) نامکمل ہے۔ میں اس گیتی پناہ صلی اللہ علیہ وسلم کے فقر کا غلام ہوں جس کے دین میں پادشاہت کو حرام قرار دیا گیا ہے۔ اقبال رح

[@syedummad9202]

سوال یہ ہے کہ کیا مارکس نے اسلام( مذہب ) کی مخالفت کی یا یہودی اور عسایت کی؟

[@ameertaimoor5220]

Marx ne sirf 2 mazahib ki akseriat par mushtamil muashra dekha tha Jews n Christians or us ne study n observe bhi sirf unhi 2 religions ko Kia tha.. so us ne mazhab pe jo bhi tabsara Kia ya likha wo sirf inhi 2 mazahib ko samne rakh k Kia.. us ne islam ki mukhalifat ni ki kbhi bhi.

[@syedummad9202]

@@ameertaimoor5220 💯 اور یہ بات ہم پاکستانیوں کو معلوم نہیں۔

[@ameertaimoor5220]

@@syedummad9202 hahaha or hm Pakistani ko zrurat bhi ni hoti aesi koi zehmat krne ki.. yahan bas koi langraa.. chibba mulwanrraan jo shosha chorr de kisi k khilaf wohi maloom hota sab ko.

[@syedummad9202]

@@ameertaimoor5220 مولوی تو ٹھیک لوگ نہیں ہیں۔ یہ شیطان ہیں ہر وقت فساد پھیلاتے ہیں۔ ان سے کوئی خیر کی امید نہیں۔

[@High_101]

بنیادی طور پر مذہب کی مخالفت کی۔ خود وہ یہودی خاندان سے تھا

[@MuhammadNasirButt-s6u]

دستِ دولت آفریں کو مزد یوں مِلتی رہی اہلِ ثروت جیسے دیتے ہیں غریبوں کو زکات

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Thanks for sharing

[@mohdashraffsufi8599]

That is trove islam

[@khanfarzan7883]

Mirza ghalib samjhao

[@hisham.najam6]

Samjhao nahi SAMJAIN. ادب کا دامن نا چھوڑیں۔

[@MuhammadRafique-fe4kr]

Lots of contradictory thoughts are found in iqbals poetry. He was impressed by every crazy man.

[@syedbilal9965]

haha crazy really

[@khurramellahiofficial]

How lovely it is that he was giving chance to each river, each man, each school to reach his mind. Cherishing and praising all those are not dwarf.

[@hisham.najam6]

اگر ان پاگلوں کو پڑھ کر اقبال اقبال بنے ہیں تو ہمیں ان پاگلوں کو دنیا میں ہی رہنے دو۔ ان عقلمندوں (بونوں) کی بوسیدہ اور نفرت سے بھری ہوئی دنیا ان ہی کو مبارک ہو۔۔۔۔۔

[@ameertaimoor5220]

Exactly you said right n true the poor poet was very contradict n diverted n different in his thoughts at different time .. every poet describes the things those are impress him in that time of creation .. so if you see the Iqbal in the prospective of a poet n creative artist you will never allege him n will never look him as a Holy Ox.

[@ameertaimoor5220]

@@syedbilal9965 ✔🤗🤣

[@Tower-3b]

اپ کو بتائیں گے کہ او جی بڑی زبردست تھیوری پیش کی اس نے بڑا زبردست ایک نظریہ پیش کیا اس نے یہ نظریہ یہ تھیوری اسلام بھی پیش کرتا ہے اسلام اس سے کہیں زیادہ بہترین انداز میں زندگی گزارنے کا طریقہ سکھاتا ہے

[@ManzoorAhmadRather-w8n]

فضل،الرحمن،،طارق،جمیل،مفتی،نعیم،رضوی،،جیسے،خدا،پرست،نہں، تھا،مارکس کو غریبوں، کی،فکر،تھی

[@BushraFarheen-ve8md]

😂😂 Marxism is totally failed nowadays 😂 ریاستی جبر کی طرف لے جاتا ہے۔ جب ریاست ہر چیز کی مالک ہو تو وہ آسانی سے انفرادی آزادیوں کو دبا سکتی ہے، متکبرانہ برتاؤ کر سکتی ہے اور وسائل کو غلط طریقے سے تقسیم کر سکتی ہے

[@ameertaimoor5220]

Beshakk

[@GhulamMuhammad-vh8up]

Nice said

[@kamranahmad3838]

رب دی تباہ کہ کارل مارکس ہم یہودی وو او چاچی یورپ کی سرمایہ دارنہ نظام ہم یہود جوڑ کڑے وو۔

[@DrMuhammadAbrarUmar]

Shame on your immature thinking

[@FarooqFarhat]

Karl Marx was a Economic, Social & Political Philosopher not a Islamic preecher

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Yes he was never one. But Iqbal in his all life had the courage to appreciate work of great men

[@ameertaimoor5220]

@@khurramellahiofficial right n true

[@PakistaniKitaabghar]

​@@khurramellahiofficial میں بھی اپ نے ایمانداری سے بات نہیں کی یا علامہ اقبال نے بیماری کی تھی کہ جس کا کریڈٹ کال مارکس سے کسی نبی یا کسی مسلمان رہنما سے ملا دیا

[@DEEVAAR]

ھے جن کو بادشاہی بھی حکمرانوں سے کہہ دو

[@irshadahmed957]

Hyper-institutionalized hyper-organized and hyper-normative interpretation of religion works to perpetuate social injustice and aid capitalist exploitation.

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Now this comment made me learn something. Thank you

[@funcorner9003]

ager koshish dekni he tu Hazrat salman farsi ko dekle ghulam tha faris se aya tha majosi se masihi bana pir muslaman bana , Hazrat bilal ko dekle ghulam tha, zarori ye he ke jb tk is door me kissi wali ka daman nai tamme ge tu alone ap kuch nai kersakte hum batte bht kerte he per tarika nai apnatte,

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Rightly said

[@Khurram3663-rf2du]

Karl marx mason tha . But I accept this word karl marx sympathy for poor peoples

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Indeed

[@Syedhussain-eo2zr]

10prsent ameer ni blky zalim 90prsent muzloom pr raj kr rahy hain

[@ghulamhaider2401]

جی 38 ہجری میں اسلام کی قوت محرکہ کو دین سے نکال تقدیر کے جبر کا لیبل لگا کر لوگون کو سلا دیا ۔

[@QasimAli-mm9pi]

Do work & work & work u will rich

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Then you don’t understand capitalism. Working will motivate solve the problem One having capital will always have the edge. Do read about economic systems in detail. Especially regarding the critic on capitalism

[@PakistaniKitaabghar]

بھائی جان علامہ اقبال کے سنڈروم سے بھی نکل کے دنیا دیکھیے جو دوسروں نے بڑے کام کیے اس کو بھی اپ کریڈٹ ہر چیز کا اسلام ہی مسلمانوں کو دے دیتے ہو

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Would you please take a Quick Look of other videos on this channel , from Zeno, Goethe, Comte, Einstein, Sartre, Orwell , Huxley, Wordsworth etc that we made so people may read text of other thinkers.

[@azizhakim5480]

Iqbal wrote these things in poetry. He did not write even any single article to support communism which he should have written. A message in poetry is not so much strong!

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Iqbal established his major ideas in poetry and remaining in reconstruction. Where else to find his thought? He is a poet philosopher

[@azizhakim5480]

Salam Sir, you discussed "Karl Marx's mention in Iqbal's poetry and Iqbal tributes to him". Indeed, I respect your ideas. Yet, you should not forget that Iqbal was also a political figure who presented the idea of a soverign state(s) for the muslims of india within the British rule or without it, diverting from his own famous ideas of Panislamism and Millati Vahida across the world (Har mulki mulki maast k mulki khodai maast) as he says: Aik hon Muslim Haram ke pasbani k leai,,, Neel k sahil si likar tabakhaki Kashghar. And due to our this regional nationalism and the lack of the ideas of Millati Vahidah across the world, today we are just weeping for the victims of Gaza and can practically do nothing for the children and women facing atrocities and brutalities at the hands of Israeli army. Moreover, as a political figure, being a prominant figure, philosopher, great poet Iqbal did not do enough efforts what should have been expected from him. In my opinion, the muslim was the master of the whole British India, but we lost half Punjab province and half Bengal province to India/Hindus, though these areas were a part of the Muslim India. I think the muslim leaders were not as strong as the Hindu leaders were who got education and educational institutions for their nation/hindus and ultimately succeeded in pushing the muslims into the West depriving them of half Punjab, half Bengal, Haiderabad (Dakan), Gordaspoor, Kashmir and many other areas. Our leaders could establish only a single college at Aligar and that's all. The reconstruction of religious thoughts in Islam by Allama Iqbal speaks of his high approach and intellect, yet very few educated people can read and understand it. Accept my sincere apology for any inconvenience.

[@ameertaimoor5220]

@@azizhakim5480 nice views .. but now a day's the founder of Ali Garrh institute of Education the Great Sir Syed Ahmed Shah Khan Bahadur is also not Muslim n heniously Qadiani kafir near n according the extremist short minded short hearted Langriralogist theocrats mullas of tehreek e Langrra program . Even the people's of Pakistan inspired by these bloody n ignorant mullaans are nof accepting the currency note of 75 rupe with the pic of Sir Syed Ahmed Shah Khan Bahadur. No body take the pain to do research whether mulla told us true or lie .

[@Artcodigitalflex]

کمیونزم کا تجربہ ناکام ہوچکا ہو ابلیسی سرمایہ داری نظام کا اصل مقابلہ اسلام سے ہے

[@khurramellahiofficial]

Well said