【東方】Bad Apple!! ＰＶ【影絵】

sm8628149

[@tinysoulz]

lyrics: *about depression, loss of self worth, trying to feel nothing, existential crisis* me: *vibing*

[@nickelodeonwho8555]

We be vibin' hard tho U_U [ Edit : Holy crap why y'all liking my comment I- ] [ Edit 2: If you see this have a good day lmao ] [ Edit : 3 ...... how tf is this comment up to 800 likes?? ]

[@crystallizedmoonlight216]

Yeah

[@yo1103]

U-U

[@thatoneperson7127]

@@yo1103 uwu

[@diamondisland2023]

*sir vibesalot*

[@lucasfornazieri4438]

Newton after the apple falls on his head:

[@omp199]

I want to see the parallel universe in which Newton devised the world of Touhou in the 17th century and ZUN discovered the law of universal gravitation in the 1990s.

[@karuse763]

Newton before he was 23 must be so depressing, after that his fate became a girl

[@silver17yearsago66]

Fun fact that's completely made up an apple never actually fell on his head

[@ririthesilly]

@@silver17yearsago66 oh ok

[@thischannelisnolongeractiv3092]

If Isaac Newton didn't invent gravity, this video wouldn't exist.

[@MrNatsumi31]

play this in my funeral, if i don't wake up to sing i'm really dead

[@SkyViper202]

funni comment

[@Lavender_wot]

mine too

[@lurbrad4037]

@Lavender_wot SAME GURL

[@beRiy..]

｢5年後に帰ってくる気がする｣と6年前コメントした当時小学生の自分へ。本当に帰ってきましたよ。 また10年後も戻ってくるだろうな。

[@monyumento37]

おかえり^^

[@utaonepieceedits]

13 years later, and these transitions are STILL smoother than my Wi-Fi.

[@HyperVanilo]

Thanks to Anira, the animator

[@user-li9qc9bc8o]

SoftBank Air？

[@onyxfinger7431]

comment posted : 13 days before this reply and 13 years after the song :/ :)

[@Libops]

These jokes are becoming less and less funny.

[@HyperVanilo]

@@Libops I believe people have said that years and years ago

[@softnoobgirl73]

12 year old me using all the PowerPoint transitions like

[@AceDetectiveKirigiri]

Best comment

[@moiraisstarstruck_]

How do i like? Don't wanna ruin it

[@molls8889]

Loll dont forget kinemaster

[@rredy]

Best comment

[@synexiasaturnds727yearsago7]

I *am* that 12 year old! Not in age though.

[@user-ye4lv7cb8k]

結局俺たちはここに戻ってくるんだよな。また会おうぜ

[@humayuna-vz7se]

プロセカから来た人もいそうｗ

[@user-vo5dm4re7b]

原点(?)にして頂点

[@splittypoo]

hi

[@user-vi6gd7tj8y]

ただいま^ ^

[@user-zb8vy1dy5b]

もはや呼吸

[@hh-gu6dk]

これPV作ってなんの情報も無く消えていったの伝説って感じで好き

[@judilynlebrilla3259]

The moral lesson is: “dont throw an apple in the sky cause then a witch will pick it up and you’ll accidentally start a music video”

[@smayds]

I've spent the last twelve years throwing apples at the sky, and no music videos have shown up so far. I'll keep trying!

[@WednesdayMan]

@@smayds you must be really unlucky, cause I threw an apple in the air once and an entire music video happened.

[@vanyacallista7092]

*aggressively throws an apple in the sky*

[@idkwhattoputhere8753]

@@smayds the apple must be bad for it to work

[@user-mq4qq9fi6m]

oh no help i accidentaly throwed a apple at the sky oh no i can feel something hap

[@kotokoto963]

久しぶりに聞きに来て思ったんだけど14年前のMMDで髪の毛とか飾りがバグって暴れたりしてないのスゴすぎじゃない？

[@user-sj6zz9zx6c]

分かる〜 こんな神曲＆MV(？)なのに何で一切の興味を無くしてしまったのか不思議だわ これからもよろしく東方

[@soho4769]

これMMDまだ無い時代です……

[@2890skw]

！？

[@user-sj6zz9zx6c]

@@soho4769 まじか.....

[@kotokoto963]

@@soho4769 え、これどうやって動かしてるんですか…？

[@user-co4fv9xl9f]

お　か　え　り　な　さ　い　平　成　3 6 年　へ　。

[@user-xq4yy5tx9c]

どっかのえーりんコメで聞いたことあるな

[@gracedalabajan]

Japan: Bad apple China: Little Apple America: IOS 9.3

[@user-xi4xv4kp5h]

はいパクリ乙

[@reimen531]

笑笑

[@user-xi4xv4kp5h]

@Tania Sauz はいパクリ乙

[@andrewsatorius4210]

ios ⑨.3

[@reimen531]

@@andrewsatorius4210 ナイス！(nice!)

[@MrWizHq]

This is a 2009 fan-made clip based on a fan-made storyboard for a fan-made remix of a music theme from a game made by a single man.

[@MinhLe-th7iz]

Sometimes one man can create an empire himself

[@Insvaer]

Whats the game?

[@mfirdanhb]

@@MinhLe-th7iz ask Scott with his games he is still ain't done yet

[@poop_schmoop]

touhou's fanbase is absolutely insane

[@humanman2358]

@@mfirdanhb I recommend asking yanderedev

[@kinoko1215]

ほんの数時間前のコメントがあるのを見ると、こんなふうにずっと愛されてきたんだなぁってホワホワする。 投稿された年に私はまだ生まれてなかったけど、小学校の中学年くらいで東方にどっぷりハマった。 早い時期に出会わせてくれてありがとう世界。

[@dawdam4352]

2034年の私: 子供たちよ、さあ、『バッド・アップル』を 30 回見る時間だ

[@kazamachi3]

わーいパパ早く早く〜

[@TsukasaYugi-kd4bf]

yeppieee

[@yottyan_JPN]

私たちはそんな世界になるのを望んでいた、それも「彼女」がいればの話だがな。

[@dog3983]

Bad Apple in a nutshell: Things turning into other things

[@CalciumEaterSupreme]

The drop of water is a girl do is a shard of glass and a petal

[@POOPNUGGET19]

Pain

[@thebokchoy6854]

touhou x transformers crossover confirmed

[@somegoodsoup7008]

@@POOPNUGGET19 peko

[@CrucifiedReimu]

Object turn into human, human turn into object

[@brianriddle8389]

It's crazy that this video is a decade old, black & white, 360p, and still this smooth.

[@Tristanimator_]

Just realised it was 360p lol, it looks like 720

[@DyzioThingsGang]

​@@Tristanimator_ this video isnt widescreen, its 4:3 aspect ratio meaning that the pixels will be less spread out and therefore the video will look less "pixelated" its kind of like normal where the more you zoom in on an image the more low quality it looks, the same goes for this

[@That8Ball]

2 decades, we are in 2021

[@Tristanimator_]

@@That8Ball and when was this video uploaded?

[@shabnumkhan8534]

@@That8Ball ah yes, Mafs

[@user-si1xd7gv7n]

ニコニコが復活したら、真っ先にコレの本家と字コンテを見に行きたい

[@user-coys174]

ニコニコにbad apple聞きにいったら閉鎖してた自分が通ります まじで定期的に聴きたくなるよね

[@kouseinomoto7940]

当時大学生で東方の同人描いてた。時代は変わり今は仕事で動画作ってるけど、当時わからなかった編集のエグさがビンビンに伝わってくる。。。。 CGもそうだけど編集もえっぐいぞこれ・・・

[@uncleal6172]

11 years later and this shits still a bop

[@HyperVanilo]

Bad Apple timeline Original Bad Apple: 1998 Alstroemeria version: 2007 Storyboard: 2008 Shadow animation: 2009

[@aye6173]

@@HyperVanilo i did expect this video to take a lot of time but im still impressed, that's a lot of work

[@HyperVanilo]

@@aye6173 Thanks to Junya Ota aka ZUN, the creator of Touhou and the composer of the 1998 Bad Apple, we have good music video like this.

[@serafin3351]

@@HyperVanilo colored animation year:???

[@Kanzeons]

on god

[@Vivrian]

Everyone: “the music is very artistic and amazing.” Me: what did the apple do?

[@engineergaming5989]

"who is your apple, and what does he do" Arnold shwarzenegger, kindergarten cop

[@the_honored_one_06]

The singer is the "Bad Apple" the song is about how they want to change their ways and change their heart from "black" to "white" supposedly meaning to become a good person

[@edcz_builds]

Did you ever heard of Bible?

[@sauronmordor7494]

yes

[@evil_weevil]

Bad apple’s an expression. I think it means something like: someone corrupt out of a group of people or something like that.

[@user-gx9mq5sg9x]

今でもすごいなこのぬるぬる動くの

[@user-ro1st2zd4g]

14年前なのに最近のコメントで溢れかえるの見るとやっぱ愛せれてるんやなぁー

[@pico-991]

14年前の動画なのに一日前なの親近感湧いていいね

[@Takenokokinoko-sabu]

それなぁ

[@f-iy5qj]

今ニコニコがダウンしてるからニコニコ民が流れて来てるのもあるかもね。

[@Straykidssecondfather]

Dude it’s insane that this was my childhood! I loved this song

[@missmidnight3285]

Jokes aside, this song is nostalgia

[@supersto5459]

Just about to say that, it sounds so familiar but I’ve only just found it

[@timetraveler9272]

I've never heard that music before...

[@idkanymorelol4115]

What

[@mikaroni_and_cheez]

Yeah this song is one of the ones that I've listened to probably hundreds of times. I've made it a part of me, and it's fueled some of my art.

[@yukinomomosaki]

good memories, I remember a few years ago I was into Vocaloid and saw this then became a Touhou fan!

[@saihara4454]

me: i wonder what they are saying turns on subtitles [Music] me: damn that's deep

[@Zedryx69]

The actual lyrics are too deep though. Just like with rolling girl.

[@noname420]

@@Zedryx69 Yup...

[@Desk-O-lorido]

[music] Understandable have a great day

[@Official_Neneko]

Yeah, real deep

[@pianohelper8873]

Lol this is hilarious

[@suna.return]

最初のてってってっ、てててててっ が異常に好き

[@hakutaka-love]

いっしょに1億再生にさせようとする同志いない？

[@Kabozirou]

仲間ほんとに1億行かせたい

[@Shiroururi]

同志です！

[@user-jz3nw4rz6g]

はーい！

[@virtual484]

ミク先輩を愛でてます

[@destroytheworldforfreedom912]

あと100万で9000万再生や 1億もそう遠くない

[@MOTAHS1]

Example of a song that ages but never gets old.

[@noelle4967]

@Señor RandomPerson295 why are you replying to all the comments

[@14hakanamirudzaky72]

Like a unvaccinated kid

[@saber3510]

@RandomPerson295 [Folk, AHHH nue.] can you reply to me?

[@qweenbeety]

I can agree 0-0

[@Undice]

Yep

[@StyxVXI]

Me: Turns on captions Captions: [music]

[@HyperVanilo]

Jokes aside, other video has subtitle or you could just listen to English version.

[@Seamens]

[Music]

[@ahuman308]

damn right they are-

[@berserkenjoyer8931]

@@HyperVanilo japanese >english

[@imgamingindonesia7373]

3 seconds last: "you"

[@kettel-gr4yz]

この曲を聴いて作曲家になろうと決めました ほんとに大好きな曲で自分の人生にもいい影響だったし、これからも永遠に聞く曲です なんなら来世も聞きます

[@f-iy5qj]

みんなニコニコがダウンしてるからこっち観にきてるのかw 早く復旧すればいいね〜

[@yantelas7828]

Animator: How many cool transitions between characters you need ? Producer: Yes

[@HyperVanilo]

Jokes aside, only one guy worked on this

[@chriisok]

The guy who made probaly took a while because it’s long

[@zacaridos1299]

@@HyperVanilo holy shit, i didn't know.

[@HyperVanilo]

@@zacaridos1299 And this animator, Anira, didn't do it blindly. There is a concept video created by a guy named Mμ, he asked the internet to make an animation out of his concept video and one of them is what you're watching right now.

[@blocky2394]

@@HyperVanilo can leave a link to video I can't find it

[@juicycarrot6589]

So you telling me this whole thing started because of an apple? Yes.

[@yuukanee]

And end in apple

[@VlidOnTheLead]

Yes, and if you're gonna throw an apple in the sky. You will see a witch in the sky. I'm gonna be viral about a video a witch being real ahh!!!!!

[@theguywithoutabrain]

Somebody gets depression by eating a bad apple. It tastes terrible

[@pongers5895]

Littering is bad kids

[@HY-if9ct]

@@VlidOnTheLead y would that be a viral

[@user-wc2uv1fo4s]

ニコニコ治ったらまたみんなで巡礼しようぜ！！！

[@user-on4ig1zy3m]

諸君、私は東方が好きだ　　　　　　　　　　　諸君、私は東方が好きだ　　　　　　　　　　　諸君、私は東方が大好きだ！！

[@icchi_10_R]

時代を感じさせない名曲

[@omegazombie900]

🍎⭐ awesome

[@user-oo1jb7hy3m]

👍

[@Aaron.2012]

Does anybody know what this guy is saying because I don't speak Spanish or whatever

[@mysweetlittle1mathew795]

@@Aaron.2012 he saying Japanese not Español

[@shadyomar8931]

@@Aaron.2012 they said "a timeless masterpiece"

[@TheKing72.]

So how many transitions do you want This guy: yes

[@HyperVanilo]

The guy who made the storyboard want it like that anyway

[@tommycaca1845]

@Xxgamer timxX n

[@electric9049]

@@tommycaca1845 n

[@MrVictor1227]

@@tommycaca1845 igga

[@tommycaca1845]

@@MrVictor1227 ?

[@7th_editing_room]

どんなに二次創作作られても14年前に鬼発注から作られた神受注は越えられる気がしない。 あにら氏に感謝

[@user-gi2ur3vu4i]

この曲はいつ聞いても神曲

[@random_user6956]

Reimu: *Throws apple in air* Marisa: And I took that (personally)

[@Hiroshi_Toshiro]

The Apple From Snow White😂😂😂

[@Zedryx69]

@@Hiroshi_Toshiro shush.

[@nikfontov752]

@@Zedryx69 stfu getting offended at everything huh

[@crimcram]

@@nikfontov752 He might be Joking by saying "Shush" so that Snow white wouldn't know that the witch is actually Marisa from Touhou

[@qwernis5651]

I WANTED TO WRITE THAT

[@nazlsl5634]

in class: an apple fell on newton's head *the exam:*

[@nazlsl5634]

@RandomPerson295 [Folk, AHHH nue.] lol

[@landongaming2024]

@RandomPerson295 yeah bro that crap aint for us

[@polorchen1592]

Duygularımı anlatın

[@maryvalerio1853]

So they are singing a song so catchy but so dark in English? Huh.

[@AnikethK3]

Made your like count 1k

[@hajimehara]

マジでいつ聞いてもいろんな感情が湧き出てくる、いつまでも語り継がれてほしい

[@user-fk4tl1qv8c]

東方あんまわからんけどこのPVは心惹かれるｳｳ😮

[@HyperVanilo]

The original Bad Apple is from Touhou Gensokyo, released in August 1998.

[@marikuma88]

11 years later and these transitions are still smoother than my life

[@HyperVanilo]

Thanks to Anira, the animator

[@recmonika9751]

Emo mode on

[@cursedemperor9600]

@@recmonika9751 I can’t turn it off help!!! 😭

[@anormalcorpus4804]

Indeed

[@recmonika9751]

@@cursedemperor9600 go to the nearest hospital they will help you

[@Megz_X4]

One thing I learned from this video... Is that these girls really like to drop things.

[@phaseeohone5292]

Esp beat

[@jakob9323]

Yeah what's the deal with that

[@shazlink35]

How small are they at the end

[@DSX1]

@@yuuji3795 I REBUKE THEE SATAN

[@rotaryballer]

and those things like to turn into other girls

[@nekoojisan]

ニコニコ動画のサーバーがダウンと聞いて、昔熱心に聞いてた曲を聴きに来ました。 色々アップされてましたが、こちらの動画が安心して再生できました。 早期の復旧お祈りいたします。

[@kenami3286]

14年前の人も今見てる人もこれから見る人もみんな同じようにこの曲に酔いしれていくんだろうなあ、

[@vanvunong1118]

Twelve years has passed and i'm still waiting for next masterpiece: "Good apple"

[@nikoxykittehs]

This was made in 2014 Are you from the future?

[@kawaokiddo9953]

@@nikoxykittehs this was made in 2009 lol

[@kok011]

@@nikoxykittehs yes they are from the future

[@trungkien2592]

@Charles Michiru Gallo hmmmmmmmm

[@danielblanchette8593]

Someone did it the beginning is the same but it gets better kzbin.info/www/bejne/oZeYloifoN6Lj6M

[@JmonsterNEO]

To think that this all started with one guy saying “I have this story board for a MV but I can’t animate, I’m giving permission for anyone to use this”

[@kingtiger6113]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/aX7EmIyDid6Lpbc

[@mikemodern9491]

Yeah

[@HyperVanilo]

The storyboard created by Mμ

[@chrissyk6653]

what?? Didn't know about that. Fill me please xD

[@nohumanity6620]

Ñ

[@user-gl9vz4qd5k]

ほんとにあの字コンテからこのような作品が生まれるなんてすごすぎる

[@user-pu6mj4vb7b]

影だけで誰かわかる東方のキャラデザ秀逸過ぎる。

[@thishandleis]

13 years gone, and this is still one of the most impressive animations on the internet

[@HyperVanilo]

Thanks to these guys OG Bad Apple: Jun'ya Ota Storyboarder: Mμ Animator: Anira Lyrics: Haruka Singer: Nomico Arranger: Masayoshi Minoshima

[@PanD0rado]

@@HyperVanilo only Anira animated it 🙄

[@HyperVanilo]

@@PanD0rado I know, too lazy to type it

[@chantag9517]

what makes it more impressive? the Hundreds of HUNDREDS of *RECREATION METHODS* of the video itself!!! some recreate the music as well, but its usually just the video part.

[@Jaie55]

Yeah... time flies

[@SimplyDuker]

To make this music video even more legendary, is how many people creatively recreated it using hundreds-thousands of methods. This is not even a meme anymore, this is a certified internet artifact. Hope we keep this (and other versions) somewhere safe in case humanity goes extinct and aliens eventually arrive on this planet.

[@HyperVanilo]

Thanks to these guys this video exist OG Bad Apple: Jun'ya Ota Storyboarder: Mμ Animator: Anira Lyrics: Haruka Singer: Nomico Arranger: Masayoshi Minoshima

[@SimplyDuker]

@@HyperVanilo Yes.

[@Thomas-mm8wg]

My favourite version is with "What you know rolling down in the deep" as lyrics. Found that first and noticed now how similiar the original is

[@Shy-Nim]

Btw can I ask why this is a meme and how this started? I was curious

[@HyperVanilo]

@@Shy-Nim People have been playing Bad Apple MV on anything like pregnancy test, Windows Task Manager, Minesweeper etc, that's one of the Bad Apple MV "memes". A guy named Mμ uploaded a video titled 'Bad Apple MV (Someone animate this please!)' on NicoNicoDouga in 2008, then in 2009 Anira uploaded this Bad Apple MV on the same website, which is came out as the more popular picturization than other attempts.

[@user-el5ch4zo6j]

神。この一言に尽きる。

[@user-tg5gd5zi2m]

同じく

[@user-xz8xl4lc1n]

我も

[@Itachime]

2009年。 ニコニコ動画で1000万再生に届こうかとしたときのコメントの流れる速度は本当にすごかった。 私は、おぜうともこうが好きでしたが、咲夜のナイフの弾幕をよく貼っていました。 聞くたびに色あせない当時を思い出します。 私はおじさんになってしまいました。 しかし。若い方々がこの曲を好きでいてくれるのはなんだか、自分事のように嬉しい気持ちになります。

[@herbert-kenumera960]

KZbin: "Oh lemme quickly translate this song for you lads." Song is about existential crisis and depression. KZbin: Ya know its all just [Music].

[@NiqIce]

lol

[@Zedryx69]

Y'know I think youtube was trying to save us from the truth.

[@elyssaleightley2152]

KZbin says no to anime

[@lolwtfgamesfanfics2426]

No no te entendi ni verga nose ingles.jph

[@garfeltrealtbh]

Nah it’s kzbin.info/www/bejne/iJbFnY1tpJyfq5Y

[@BNotInc]

It’s crazy how people are animating this through few pixels at a time at r/Place. Definitely the coolest thing people have done this year.

[@Skribblez_Entertainment]

There's gotta be something cooler.

[@deathbygun551]

Almost done by now, alot of effort

[@Spax_]

it's at like 3:12 right now

[@transientrose]

​We're almost done!!

[@KristinaMoment]

@@Spax_ Literally at the Yin and Yang bit now

[@Amia4649]

私東方と全く知らなくて… でもたまたまユーチューブのおすすめで流れてきて聞いたらすごく感動した曲でした…。私の生まれる前にできた曲なんて今でも思えない曲デス…

[@HyperVanilo]

This is a music video with characters from the bullet hell series Touhou Project with the remix of Bad Apple by Masayoshi Minoshima

[@Amia4649]

​@@HyperVaniloなるほどありがとうございます！

[@user-ok4rc2bc3l]

東方めっちゃオススメなのでぜひ調べてみてください！スマホアプリ沢山あります！

[@user-im3zz6rl7p]

絶対世界が滅んでも残り続ける神曲はこれですね、絶対

[@conradkai9705]

To this day, I still fail to comprehend how this music was made by a violin, horn, and a keyboard.

[@stanleyjiang2244]

But yOu caN heAR tHe dRuMS

[@laxwheat3457]

the power of vibe

[@touhoufan7061]

prismriver sisters?

[@cube-dev1705]

ikr

[@Hazen4247]

@@stanleyjiang2244 I know that is a joke but, don't you get really impressed about how good the keyboard drums sound like? This song is incredible.

[@TtamSteed]

Some people: See a silhouette for 3 seconds, know who that is, what games they've been in, the significance of what they're holding and who they're with, can get meaning from the method of the transition, appreciate how so much lore is referenced in such a short moment. Me: "That one's the frog, I think."

[@auburnt]

@Comrade Unknown Anonymous why do I see you everywhere

[@zsaidmiranda4971]

"hmm yes that is the uhhhh drunk loli yes the drunk loli and thats puppeter"

[@YataTheFifteenth]

kero

[@SirHellNaja]

Me: Yeah, that's the meme girl

[@fadiggle]

Is that the turtle

[@user-yv9hw8rk6p]

10年前に聞いてそれきり聞いてなかったけどやはりここに戻ってきてしまった、原点として頂点だよ、

[@Kabozirou]

きた8888万おめでとう！

[@Chororiiin1010]

めでたい

[@user-pi8wl1is5l]

めでたい

[@virtual484]

ミク先輩を愛でてます

[@ShortHax]

Me feeling the power acting putting transitions on every slide in PowerPoint

[@WatatsukiNoToyohime]

ssht, dont open my cringey memory

[@noblehatterviolet]

why are you everywhere

[@HyperVanilo]

I'm surprised you're recently found this video

[@WatatsukiNoToyohime]

@@HyperVanilo Aye Octo

[@averageYTuser52282]

You're everywhere

[@cyeccyz2]

Why is nobody talking about that guy who made this with apples and carving it

[@faria815]

Once again the pandemic algorithm has brought us together

[@pavanato]

Hello algorithm friends

[@adluzz3216]

oh it is ur reccomends in 2020 too?

[@pavanato]

@@adluzz3216 yeah

[@kronorii67]

Actually thats why im here

[@Kocha663]

キャラの特徴を捉えてるから影絵でも充分誰か分かるのすげぇ

[@user-vx1px3sx4v]

最高………本当にいつ見ても懐かしいし美しい

[@faker_sh]

The fact this was made a decade ago and still looks smooth af

[@HyperVanilo]

Thanks to Anira, the animator

[@maruftim]

@@HyperVanilo holy shit how many comments you have in here

[@Falunyx]

@@HyperVanilo holy shi- bro your comments

[@HyperVanilo]

@@Falunyx The hell is wrong with my comments? I'm just saying the name of the animator and educating people.

[@luckylaniang5574]

@@HyperVanilonothing is wrong with it, but I would be pretty surprised to see someone with over a thousand comments on a single channel

[@BlazingShadowSword]

Honestly, it's a real testament to the design of these characters, that we can tell them apart by their silhouettes.

[@HyperVanilo]

Name all characters in this video, if you recognize them all

[@BlazingShadowSword]

@@HyperVanilo I can't. I can name the popular ones. Maybe some others. My memory is shit, and I haven't immersed myself in the touhou sinkhole. However, the fact I know characters like Sakuya and Patchouli or even Yuyuko given they don't have any really outstanding features like horns or wings proves my point.

[@twotothehalf3725]

@@HyperVanilo He said he can tell each of them apart, not name them all.

[@harrid14mei]

In order: *Reimu Hakurei Marisa Kirisame Patchouli Knowledge Remilia Scarlet Sakuya Izayoi Flandre Scarlet Youmu Konpaku Yuyuko Saigyouji Komachi Onozuka Eiki Shiki, Yamaxanadu Fujiwara no Mokou Keine Kamishirasawa (human) Keine Kamishirasawa (hakutaku) Eirin Yagokoro Kaguya Houraisan Lunasa Prismriver Merlin Prismriver Lyrica Prismriver Chen Ran Yakumo Tewi Inaba Reisen Udongein Inaba Momiji Inubashiru Sanae Kochiya Hina Kagiyama Kanako Yasaka Suwako Moriya Yukari Yakumo Tenshi Hinanawi Aya Shameimaru Suika Ibuki Alice Margatroid Nitori Kawashiro Yuuka Kazami Elly Reimu Hakurei (PC-98) Marisa Kirisame (PC-98)*

[@harrid14mei]

*Inubashiri A slight typo

[@fspsbm7426]

当時これを見て、 パチュリーが好きになった。 それくらい数秒間の短い中に　 魅力が詰められていて、 指をぐるぐる回しているところは かわいく決めていたり、 本当に目が回っていたりw いろいろイメージが思い浮かぶ。

[@user-xz8xl4lc1n]

わかる自分もパチュリー好きになった

[@shark_azz]

分かるぞおおお！パッチェさん！

[@Anosame3286]

早くニコニコで見てぇ

[@Nordisk11]

I'm not even a Touhou fan but I keep coming back to this song, it's attracted me like a magnet attracting a chunk of iron.

[@Nordisk11]

@Señor RandomPerson295 I'm willing to do that; it's interested me for some time.

[@weirdpersonv]

Same here

[@aihoshinoirl]

Me who became a Touhou fan when this video came out: 😳

[@bethspage7089]

Wtf is Touhou

[@Nordisk11]

@@bethspage7089 Touhou is a bullet hell video game series, the characters shown in the video are from it.

[@tepes4583]

I love just starting 2021 with a good old ass banger.

[@kannatheweeb8836]

same

[@ethandolbear3834]

Quick question, is this version on spotify? I feel like I can't find it.

[@ethandolbear3834]

@Señor RandomPerson295 I knew it D':

[@Kai_Hendrickson]

@@ethandolbear3834 there are other ways to download it tho, had this in my devices for years now, not really using anything like spotify or anything ngl

[@ethandolbear3834]

@@Kai_Hendrickson See that's what I used to do, though now since I'm in college, I get a lovely spotify discount that includes huly and showtime so I'm willing to sacrifice the 7 dollars a month or so. Might just see if I can figure out the local files tool on spotify.

[@user-ct5un7xq7e]

このモノクロがまたいいんだよな…

[@user-xz8xl4lc1n]

黒と白だけなのにキャラクターが分かるの凄すぎる

[@toganium4175]

They did say that good character designs are noticeable when they have good silhouettes.

[@HyperVanilo]

Who?

[@getawayfromme1320]

so that's why i can't tell who anyone is

[@user-tv2qr7uq2z]

Gintama right?

[@HyperVanilo]

@@getawayfromme1320 That's because you never see any Touhou characters before

[@cosmix4460]

yep

[@flamingtorrent2109]

I’m sure every animator strives to have transitions as smooth as this even 11 years later

[@HyperVanilo]

If they can make Anira, the animator, spill all of his secrets.

[@meshie7631]

I'm trying to remake this I thought getting the transitions would be really easy, but no. I just gave up doing transitions all together xD

[@godbroccoli11]

I thought makes 3D animations as smooth as this was easy for animators, yet again, I’ve never animated before, so I’m most definitely wrong

[@dyeh_2691]

Lol im the 420th like

[@pozkitt2326]

@Mana WataI'm kinda confused as where and how is the creator, Anira . Why will he/she has never been surfaced or known to us for this more than decades 🤔.The video left so much history and one of the greatest pride to Touhou fans

[@Harpiaharpyi457oug]

どうしてこの曲がこんな人気なのか分からなかったけど何回か聴いて分かりました。東方BGM全般に言えることではありますが、癖になるリズムがあって純粋に良い曲。影絵のクオリティも高い。 こりゃ、人気になるしかないですな〜。

[@user-qe1hz8cp5q]

久々に聞いたら神曲過ぎて泣きそうになった

[@InsanityLMAO]

Even after 13 years, people still come to this video every day. The transitions are legendary. What a masterpiece.

[@HyperVanilo]

Thanks to these guys this video exist OG Bad Apple: Jun'ya Ota Storyboarder: Mμ Animator: Anira Lyrics: Haruka Singer: Nomico Arranger: Masayoshi Minoshima

[@Pomkimycat]

fr

[@miuzukifox4970]

For 🥲

[@monikamuller9775]

Yes! :D

[@ruanulisses6650]

Wish I knew about this video and the Touhou universe in general way earlier than I did, I mean Im trying to understand all information yet, wish I knew it years ago to enjoy it more as something that lengendary

[@alexmobileswitchguy1016]

"So how many transitions do you want ?" This guy: *yes*

[@HyperVanilo]

Jokes aside, this MV exist thanks to these guys: Storyboarder: Mμ Animator: Anira

[@alexmobileswitchguy1016]

@cirno fumo *chonk cirno* *bottom text*

[@samuelaguilar1537]

@@alexmobileswitchguy1016 Top text

[@antoniolee7817]

@@samuelaguilar1537 middle text

[@thegiantenemyspider1]

My friend playing this shit innrobloc fnf: "lol vad ez song"

[@user-vs4bj3qd7q]

小学生の時に初めて見て､そこから色々なパロディを見て、それでもやはりここに戻ってきてを繰り返していた私ももう二十歳です。 この世界に引きずり込んでくれてありがとう。

[@user-xp8ih9kc4y]

頼む…頼むからこの曲はこれからもあの頃を思い出させる曲であってくれ…

[@A_ARAFAT]

Even 16 years later, this animation still feels very S M O O T H

[@professorracc.9780]

This is from 2007? Oh my god no wonder why everyone says the animation is impressive it's so like smooth and with good physics

[@YuutaTogashi0707]

@@professorracc.9780 The song is from 2007 but the animation 2009

[@avaakins_uc]

@A_ARAFAT you mean 13 years not 16

[@janelantestaverde2018]

Well that's because nothing about the smoothness of animations such as this one has changed in the last 16 years ._.

[@MaxLai_0104]

@@janelantestaverde2018They were animating this pre-Windows 8. Think about that.

[@mina-jx4mg]

14年前でもみんなに愛されている動画

[@virtual484]

人の努力を笑ったこと 自分は努力しなかったこと 大切なとき手を抜いたこと 最後の最後で諦めたこと

[@Raysenel]

The dude who created this is just a pure genius. Its art didn't get old the slightlest, but got better just like a fine wine.

[@HyperVanilo]

Thanks to Anira, the animator

[@NoOneLikesThisName]

it aged really well and stood the test of time

[@MayBshy]

Why Screen white black?

[@MayBshy]

Why no full color

[@HyperVanilo]

@@MayBshy Because of the song's lyrics. Watch this Bad Apple analysis video kzbin.info/www/bejne/bIK8ZZihlshklbM

[@BagelNosed3DSuser]

This is smoother than the school gym’s floor when we do push-ups

[@HyperVanilo]

Thanks to Anira, the animator

[@hailcheeze]

i imagine you guys doing jumping jacks and then turning into ballerinas

[@jimmy_os]

Planks* I swear my feet slip every 3 seconds

[@auhsojacosta1672]

Seriously, what the hell is wrong with schools that overwax their floors, this is a problem that is sometimes seen in schools from where I am, in one instance 7 students fell down from slipping on slippery floor in ONE DAY.

[@artos9406]

how can a weeb do one proper push up? from the weebs I know they can't

[@yd.815]

ニコニコ復活したらまた見に来るんだろうなーって思いながら見てる

[@user-lm9bi5xj2h]

やっぱこの曲の色んなmmd見るけど、ほとんどが5年位前～最近のなのに14年前で圧倒的な動きのぬるぬると違和感ない動き、映像の綺麗さとセンスのよさが凄すぎる、どこ見ても綺麗だけど、フランの羽の動きとか、妖夢の刀の振りろ納刀とか1:59の入れ替わるとことか、2:05のもみじとかイチョウにもにゅうってなるのがホント好きだし、2番の歌詞がくるわけじゃないのにそれを気にさせないほど映像が神ってことがわかる、葉っぱの形に変わるっていうセンスもやばいんだよなあ、個人的にだけど、2:31の天子の手を横に振る？動きがほんと好き、3:28の名前わからんけど八卦炉のマークに変わるの天才、キャラが切り替わる時も違和感なさすぎだし、聞かなくなったころにふと思い出してここに来る、そして映像もそうだけど曲も神、3:00の変わるとこ好き、1:24でちょっと静かになるの好きすぎる、歌詞も死ぬほどいい、影絵ならではの白黒が生かされる、黒にする、白になる、白く変われる、白くなれっていう歌詞がめっちゃ好き、個人的に、流れてく 時の中ででも 気だるさが ほらくるくる廻って、人のことなど知りもしないわ、悲しむなんて疲れるだけよ、重い目蓋を開けたのならば、が特に好き、あと無機質でもないけど人間味が溢れすぎない声がめっちゃ好き、色んな作品に出会うけど、結局東方に戻ってくるんだよね～、、

[@Arc_Sp3cimen]

Lesson Learned: Every object is just a smaller human

[@imnotcreativeenoughtothink170]

lol

[@boknboknbokn]

Yep

[@humanman2358]

What if.. every small object is just a small human?

[@Arc_Sp3cimen]

@@humanman2358 then humanity will be watching us.. always

[@epiccow288]

Most people in this video are not human. Most are various youkai, as well as 3 humans.

[@kaiwang4958]

for all the people that can't understand the lyrics, here's a wonderful english translation provided by the captions: [Music]

[@HyperVanilo]

Jokes aside, other video has subtitle or you could just listen to English version

[@taro6266]

Thank you very much captions,we will love you till the end!

[@thischannelisnolongeractiv3092]

Great for deaf people

[@Hopedeeznutz]

Bruh why i see everywhere in the pfp is sans, the megalovania memes is dead

[@Hopedeeznutz]

@@HyperVanilo ikr English version is much easier to understand the lyrics but this version is better in my opinion

[@user-uz2wb1nc1i]

昔はこの作品を見て数人のキャラしか分からなかったのに今じゃ全員わかってる不思議だなぁ 少なくとも私の東方生活の基盤だった

[@user-vm9be6jz6k]

わぁ、これは思ってたよりもすごくカッコいい！この歌大好きだな:3

[@user-jg8xb1ri1v]

東方旧作batAppleはいい曲だ

[@Groiny]

"How many transitions should we add?" Editors: Yes

[@BuddinGHP]

Also editors : *MORE.*

[@szeth5287]

KZbin:no

[@tysondennis1016]

MOAR TRANSITIONS!

[@zideous]

Literally stolen from another bad apple video

[@CANALDEDRD]

Direted by Ang Lee

[@LilacJuvia]

Auto generated subtitles: [music] Deaf people: they groovin'

[@HyperVanilo]

Jokes aside, other video has subtitle or you could just listen to English version

[@0temeal425]

this made me exhale out of my nose harder than usual, so congrats

[@kittigirl143]

@@HyperVanilo r/wooosh sorry

[@killerqueenisthebeststando4381]

@@kittigirl143 he said jokes aside

[@CuttleFishThatLoveDiving]

@@kittigirl143 dum dum

[@masa_desu]

ガチで突発的に聴きたくなるんよなあ

[@user-amamizu]

360pを感じさせないデザインになってるの好きすぎる。

[@cainiwakura]

11 years old video. And people still commenting in this video like everyday. Edit: 6.8k likes, MOMMMM I'M FAMOUS

[@longlivethe9989]

well, the current commenting speed is quite low compared to what it was at peak popularity

[@aradorjacr2267]

ну так песня огонь

[@sophieNuke55]

å

[@Im-zp7tu]

I grew up with touhou music

[@joefly1298]

yes

[@ZeepTheWocky]

Wether you're a Touhou fan or not, we can all agree that this is a bop.

[@Starii_64]

Yeah I literally know nothing about touhou I just found out about this song through memes

[@Silvraya]

What is touhou?

[@ZeepTheWocky]

@@Silvraya Where this song came from. Don't get too attached, because the fandom is a huge hazard.

[@Arbiter_XVI]

@@ZeepTheWocky lmao

[@krueger7501]

Touhou is literally hell...