I honestly thought hiyyih had more lines since she stood out too me the most maybe it's because vocal tone is so beautiful and unique she sounded so good. Youngeun, hikaru and dayeon obviously suited the concept the best. Chaehyun also sounded so good in the prechrous.
@daviddiesviantara42775 ай бұрын
it's surprising xiaoting just have a few lines but have a strong stage presence as long as the performances is going
@Nicolas-cf2ng5 ай бұрын
Kep1er did so well on this cover, it was a first step as 7 members and I'm happy that they were able to get other people's attention.
@clxrisq5 ай бұрын
i thought youngeun had the most lines when i first watched because she was just so eye catching
@Thing1G5 ай бұрын
Guys, Xiaoting doesn't have a lot of lined, but she has good center time, so it's okay
@loulovesive5 ай бұрын
Hiyyih and chaehyun prechorus in this is just too good and underrated 😢😢😢
@Winfelx5 ай бұрын
Dayeon devouring as always, this song stands out a lot, it fully deserves to have debuted on Kep1er.
@timmy53055 ай бұрын
Dayeon hikaru n youngeun really suit this kind of concept❤
@aouboomsail5 ай бұрын
I honestly think Xiaoting deserves her less lines here since she's always pushed as main dancer and center of the group and always on the top in terms of line distribution in their song. Let others shine like Hiyyih and Yujin
@kisakanae085 ай бұрын
For anyone complaining - Ting was top 2 for Shooting Star & Galileo line distribution, is pushed as the 2nd center of the group, pushed as a main dancer, pushed as the visual of the group - For the last 2 KR/JP comebacks was 1st in distribution for Last Carnival, 1st in Tropical Light, 2nd in line distribution for Love on Lock, was 3rd for Straight Line, got 20 seconds in FFYH, Grand Prix & The Door, 22 seconds in Curious, and never dropped below 15 seconds in the other songs - excluding Double Up where she got 13. Got the intro with the center in KCon Japan 2024, got the intro for the VCR for KCon LA 2024, got the intro for 2023 MAMA, had a huge collab with other idols for 2023 MAMA, got a Chinese OST feature, and guested on Running Man China, the biggest variety show in China (I heard they requested her). She deserved ALL of that bc she’s amazing and has insane charisma and talent. Everything she’s received is completely deserved due to her talent & hard work. This isn’t saying she shouldn’t have had those opportunities bc she SHOULD. But to act as if she’s some poor mistreated victim because she came last in THIS cover when realistically she’s one of the most pushed members in Kep1er (not during debut I’ll give you that) - but within 2023/2024 is insanity. Please learn give & take - and realize that this group can’t turn into “Ting & friends” - and that sometimes Ting will come in the bottom/last and that’s fine because she has many many other performances in the top 3 of line distribution & she’s pushed in many other ways. Let’s not act like some random KCon cover is the end of the world for Ting. Let’s feel bad for Yujin actually, bc this is the 1st song she hasn’t been paid dust in and it’s a COVER.
@SanaIsGay-KpopContent5 ай бұрын
This is a weird comment, should she be in the top for every song? No but regardless of how well well off she's been in the recent title tracks, she still consistently gets paid dust on a lot of bsides and most covers. She's not a victim but one or two good distributions DOES NOT justify her getting embarrassingly few lines elsewhere. There shouldn't be any "give and take", everyone should always get a fair shake, never should only 1 member get less than 10 seconds. Fans should be complaining no matter which member it is, we want fairness, don't silence them.
@MooKrob99355 ай бұрын
No hate but your information collecting is so good, good job. I cant do it to my bias like you😂
@ferliya21915 ай бұрын
THANK YOU
@alejmora5 ай бұрын
On top of that Xiaoting was covering mostly Felix lines who has the less lines in the original version (~8%). Xiaoting did a fantastic job because Felix's low register is insane. Stray Kids has 8 members so for OT7 they had to make changes trying to maintain the choreography as close as possible to the original. Let us the same tired and annoying "fair distribution" discussion for other occasion.
@clubpengz5 ай бұрын
we need more keplians like you LMAO, i wish the fandom would just stop fighting and appreciate all 9 members because theyre all so amazing and talented
@meghancolaa5 ай бұрын
I loved Chaehyun's part in the pre-chorus
@sacredleaf_7275 ай бұрын
hiyyih slayyyyyy🔥
@lemonmares5 ай бұрын
chaehyun deliver her part beautifully
@Moonlighteverafter5 ай бұрын
Dayeon ate
@gowongodmom48515 ай бұрын
The more I read the comments the more I remember as a Kep1ian myself I indeed hate this fandom
@brianj4395 ай бұрын
0:56 Youngeun sounds so good here.
@tnuraai5 ай бұрын
dayeon slay
@brinsssicyrine28655 ай бұрын
Can everyone stop complaining a bit ? Your favorite can't always have many lines in every cover, every song, every stage. I can't believe we still have these discussions even after the girls resigning. Let's support kep1er and try not to make the same mistakes with the fan war and individual stan. Xiaoting is my bias, alongside Yujin. Xiaoting is 1st in line distribution in Galileo and has the most lines in the sub unit, she is 2nd in last comeback Shooting Star, she is always included in dance breaks and she has a lot of center time and screen exposure. This is just a cover. She is 3rd also in the whole last album distribution so stop being picky and let's all be positive and support kep1er, maybe they only extended for 6 months.
@fr-bc3zu5 ай бұрын
I think you don't know your bias well enough hah. Just a correction that XT isn't "always" in the dance breaks, in fact for the TT's she basically only in the Up dance break, but they do include her more often in dance breaks for special events like the award ceremonies.
@sxchiaki5 ай бұрын
@@brinsssicyrine2865 no one asked for xiaoting to have many lines or be the first? it's just strange that all members but her have somewhat equal lines/seconds and xiaoting sings her first (and only) full one near the end of the song. they are 7 now but one member still somehow gets less than 10 seconds? that's strange to me and if there was another member who had less than 10 seconds, i would write the same about her too, so that's not something only xiaoting related, just the thing that i don't understand about this particular distribution.
@gianghichau57655 ай бұрын
@@sxchiaki I absolutely agree with you
@itskyuri26045 ай бұрын
1:59 chaehyun part, not dayeon
@alejmora5 ай бұрын
Thanks, I was waiting for this
@dcrvln2645 ай бұрын
Honestly xiaoting got the iconic parts everyone remembers of this song so i dont see it was a bad thing
@Kimminwinter5 ай бұрын
OMG xiaoting deep voice in Felix part😭❤️🔥❤️🔥
@kimdayeon43075 ай бұрын
1:59 is chaehyunnnn part "right now"😊
@Teaghan_084 ай бұрын
The ld makes sense cuz the song (js like a lot of skz songs) consists of a lot of rap
@erob94465 ай бұрын
Youngeun deserved more line for this. This concept fits her so much!
@y0ruu5 ай бұрын
I LOVE IT ❤❤
@itskyuri26045 ай бұрын
Sometimes some xiaoting fans(several individuals) really make me sick because they always want to be number 1 in everything (in terms of grazing into the negative). Even though there are still other members who have clear positions in the group, whether in vocals, dance, rap or center
@yudaland26635 ай бұрын
Yujin ❤❤❤
@adeaziz45905 ай бұрын
Wdada 7 ver pliss
@SanaIsGay-KpopContent5 ай бұрын
Xiaoting would have fit a lot of the singing lines in this song and she can rap too which wakeone seems to have forgotten-
@ancermet47545 ай бұрын
Hikaru and Dayeon are the official rappers so don’t expect anyone else to get rap lines as much as them
@SanaIsGay-KpopContent5 ай бұрын
@@ancermet4754 Obviously? Doesn't mean other members shouldn't get lines.
@HinataHyuga-hm6jf5 ай бұрын
Xiaoting can't sing be thankful she got the looks
@SanaIsGay-KpopContent5 ай бұрын
@@HinataHyuga-hm6jf She's literally one of the best of the group lmao, watch her covers, behind the scenes recordings or even performances on gp999 although theyre dated now
@ffyheartsurf5 ай бұрын
She can't rap or sing lol and the group already have better rappers Dayeon and Hikaru
@Ponerse_las_pilas5 ай бұрын
xiaoting slay🎉❤
@KingWin01145 ай бұрын
The fandom has already broken apart with this toxicity over line distribution... Let's fight for the success for all of them... Instead of doing this all the time
@2Blu25 ай бұрын
Ngl i thought xiaoting was much higher But this is a rap based song so ofc the rap line will get the most lines lol and the chorus was literally empty n xiaoting got on, if it had lines she def would've been much higher
@Yousofatube5 ай бұрын
Rap based song with two lil raps? Dayeon and Youngeun usually have lines so, its not because of a “rap based” song (cause it isn’t even a rap based song)
@Lena-i6b3d5 ай бұрын
Where’s mashiro and yeseo
@Xqxzci5 ай бұрын
They left the group
@Lena-i6b3d5 ай бұрын
@@Xqxzci oh no
@bernardsih59875 ай бұрын
Mashiro and Yeseo left Kep1er after Japan concert on mid July 2024 and went back to 143 Entertainment and will re-debut as Madein.
@Xqxzci5 ай бұрын
@@Lena-i6b3d um yes
@Kep1er_OT85 ай бұрын
Dayeon finally getting 1st place again
@no45285 ай бұрын
Lmfao & some mfs still have problems whenever she has more lines 💀 this is like the 1st time she's 1st again after a long time
@Kep1er_OT85 ай бұрын
@@no4528 I will never understand the complaints with dayeons lines 😭
@holasoyyo18485 ай бұрын
@@Kep1er_OT8 Come on, she's the third member with the most lines overall, only behind Chaehyun and Youngeun, it's not about first place, I don't complain about her lines, but let's be serious, she always has a good amount of lines, so it's not like she is being mistreated
@Kep1er_OT85 ай бұрын
@@holasoyyo1848 I'm not saying she is mistreated, I'm saying the complaints about her lines are unjustified, she's an all rounder along with youngeun and gets a fair amount of lines imo
@levitatingstan652614 күн бұрын
@@holasoyyo1848so? It just make sense for her to have lines☠️ she’s the 3rd best singer, second main rapper and main dancer so she gets center time, she and youngeun make up for A LOT of overall lack of talent in the group so I don’t see why fans blame her as if she’s the one holding other members from taking vocal lessons
@hamstatouille5 ай бұрын
bruh what happened to Xiaoting lines? First her lines got significantly reduced in their latest album and now she doesn't even get 10s in an OT7 cover stage 💀 I miss when she got 30s in Mr Mr last year 😭
@Lucas-jw4fy5 ай бұрын
@@hamstatouille her lines in Kep1going on are okay for being a sub-vocalist, and this is just a cover lmao
@kisakanae085 ай бұрын
What are you talking about? Ting was top 2 for Shooting Star line distribution, she got 20 seconds in FFYH, 22 seconds in Curious, was 1st in distribution for Last Carnival, and never dropped below 15 seconds in the other songs - excluding Double Up where she got 13. For a sub vocal who is pushed as the visual, a main dancer, and the 2nd center of the group - there’s legit nothing to complain about if it’s only every few covers/bsides it’s not as perfect as you want it to be.
@antonellaromero_upc15645 ай бұрын
She has great screen time tho
@ahnyeongyu_225 ай бұрын
She's a Sub-Vocalist and has Center at the end while Chaehyun is Center?
@tiihnniie5 ай бұрын
💜💜💜 💜💜💜 💜🤍🤍
@albertshares16545 ай бұрын
XT may get the least lines, but during the performance it didn’t seem so. That shows how strong her stage presence is. I am a proud Tingfen ❤
@amayaclark91475 ай бұрын
Xiaoting lines are getting less and less
@Lucas-jw4fy5 ай бұрын
She is one of the weakest vocalist lmao
@andrewsgama24315 ай бұрын
rest easy man, she spent two comebacks in the top 3 of the line distribution
@Cryforme-5 ай бұрын
She got a lot of lines in their last 2 cbs & Jp one too 😭 Some of her lines could have been given to other members too If anything her lines her increasing
@Lucas-jw4fy5 ай бұрын
@@Cryforme- yeah, and this is jusy a cover
@kisakanae085 ай бұрын
@@andrewsgama2431she was literally top 2 for line distribution in Shooting Star & Galileo. I’m all for saying “she could’ve fit more parts” or “I wanted to hear more from her” but acting as if she’s poor and mistreated and not been at the top of line distribution and center time consistently for the past few title tracks is insanity
@sxchiaki5 ай бұрын
why is xiaoting getting so less lines in their ot7 covers when in fact she should've got more, no? w1 wtf
@peruball25895 ай бұрын
@ana-bw8zhhikaru is the worst vocalist in kep1er and she got lines
@lisaicanmeow51575 ай бұрын
@@peruball2589 her lines are all rap
@peruball25895 ай бұрын
@ana-bw8zh xiaoting can rap too lol
@autumn86585 ай бұрын
i’ve never even seen Xiaoting rap before, because she sings in their songs
@hamstatouille5 ай бұрын
@@autumn8658 she rapped in her very first stage "Rumor" in GP999
@partiya_vaginodictatury_Aliyi5 ай бұрын
yeah this distribution is bad, glad Ting got lot's of center and killing parts also, I understand why people are complaining a lot about this or other Kepler's performances on this kcon, distribution were super shity, and both Yujin and Xiaoting were heavily mistreated I also don't see why it's a bad thing to demand more lines for those members who get less lines, it's normal for fans to want more spotlight for everyone and keeps companies on their toes, and it's not an attack on a group being a fan doesn't mean to always stay positively supportive, sometimes you can be angrily supportive
@liuweian16535 ай бұрын
I hate those kind of words like “this is just a cover”“this is not the title track”. Let's be honest even its ok about Xiaoting‘s center time in this cover. How about lvly and back to the city ot7 version?How about she got the least line in Problem and many ohter tracks in the first full album.And wk1 pushed Xiaoting so much in 2023/24? Actually other girls got even harder pushed. From all these frustrating discussion we choose to give more love to Xiaoting herself. Because seems other girls already got you guys’ love🙂
@AddictedtoKep1er5 ай бұрын
Xiaoting Center is really insane even she got less line
@pikapikadee5 ай бұрын
Xiaoting stan is the one who always play like a victim, being greedy, and forgot that her bias pushed by the company more and more
@katykim5 ай бұрын
Please as if hiyyih stans are main ones. Xiaoting is one of the most popular members and the only ones who fits center
@kisakanae085 ай бұрын
@@katykimChaehyun is Kep1er’s official and confirmed center. Don’t shade other members to “defend” your bias bc Chaehyun is an amazing center and it’s HER JOB- not any other members no matter how talented they are or suit the center for certain songs.
@Luminous_witch5 ай бұрын
@@kisakanae08 lol i guess you didn't watch them since gp999. Then you will know the truth. The efforts which Xiaoting "showed" in every competitions, but in the end the show was rigged.
@MooKrob99355 ай бұрын
@@Luminous_witch the truth is chaehyun is the centre, the official one. No matter what happen she is(or was) the winner and the official center and winner. Again, she is the official winner and center. You said the the show was rigged then what is chaehyun fault? Is because korean fans voted her so it's her fault? I know Xiaoting has a lots of talents and such a great performers but she is not the center or w1 try to push her to be one of but atleast you need to respect chaehyun who is the official center, not writing such a negative comment to her.
@BabyDanny_5 ай бұрын
@@katykim Why are you dragging Hiyyih fans when this has nothing to do with them? And why discredit Chaehyun? Xiaoting is my 2nd bias and I would never put down the other members just to defend her.
@milkenwood61505 ай бұрын
not xiaoting getting less lines than felix
@SYEJ925 ай бұрын
Xiaoting is back with no lines........
@Luminous_witch5 ай бұрын
Lol everyone can complained when other members :- especially Mashiro and Yeseo got the least lines every time. But when somebody complained about Xiaoting got the most obvious least line, yall said, her stan(s) just playing victim? Wtf!?
@kisakanae085 ай бұрын
@@Luminous_witch maybe because Yeseo/Mashiro/Yujin/Hiyyih have never been top 3 for a title track & aren’t pushed as the 2nd center of the group or as a main dancer, or as the visual, or get as many special stages as Ting gets, or gets featured on OSTs or huge variety shows abroad, and they CONSTANTLY are the bottom 4 - whereas for Ting it’s just this one cover & then a few bsides from like the past 3 KR/JP albums that she’s gotten below on average 15 sec. I KNOW YALL will attempt to flip this and say “so what she doesn’t deserve that?! How is she to blame for that?! Does that mean she can’t get more here?!” and the answer is NO. She deserves everything she’s gotten because she has insane charisma, visuals, and talent. She’s eye catching and she’s a stan attractor. She’s doing her job. The issue is the comments on this video “she’s getting less and less” (untrue), or lamenting that Ting is mistreated (maybe in Korean schedules, yes, but otherwise no). People complain about Yeseo/Mashiro/Yujin/Hiyyih because they get little lines AND aren’t allowed to showcase their skills outside of their songs. Xiaoting has been top 2 line distribution the past two title tracks despite being a sub vocal (because she’s the second center of the group so PERSONALLY I think it’s fair but it’s still a fact), she gets many stages to show off her dance/charisma, she gets a lot of intro time and center time, she’s pushed as the visual, a main dancer, and the 2nd center. The other members who get the least lines don’t have any of that. THAT’S why nobody gets angry when the complaints are for them. But to complain about Ting, who is arguably the MOST pushed member after Chaehyun (Ik yall wanna say Dayeon and if it were Giddy era or before, it would’ve been - but after Giddy it switched to Ting bc ask yourself how many special stages/solo schedules/OSTs/intros/etc has Dayeon had since then AND she’s gotten less than Ting in title tracks) - so yes it feels like her solos are playing victim. True OT9 Tingfens are fine with Ting’s center time in Back Door bc she stood out a lot, and got center for the ending, and got a killing part - even if her lines weren’t long - bc they’re aware of all the other ways Ting is allowed to shine outside of this cover. Only solos seem to be pushing this narrative of “Ting can never be at the bottom even once or it’s mistreatment”.
@JustaregularInsomnia5 ай бұрын
why did xiaoting just get felix's lines 😭
@ryleigh78305 ай бұрын
I'm sad that this is what it takes for Hiyyih to finally have real lines (two members leaving) 🥹
@kisakanae085 ай бұрын
@@ryleigh7830 I just find it hilarious that Xiaoting fans are crying and kicking and screaming and calling this (getting Felix’s lines which includes a lot of center time/a killing part/ending center) mistreatment even after the past two title tracks of Xiaoting being top 2 + pushed more as a center than the official center in both of the past 2 Japanese title tracks + all of her solo stages/collabs/OST/schedules - Yet Hiyyihlights are just sitting here kicking their feet & smiling & whistling that even despite Hiyyih being in the bottom 3 for Shooting Star/Problem/Straight Line/Galileo/Back Door - by God at least she got some real lines. Like Dear Lord who’d have thought we’d grow to see this day.
@ryleigh78305 ай бұрын
@@kisakanae08 Exactly 🥹
@BabyDanny_5 ай бұрын
Usually ggs covering bgs can be a bit iffy but they ate real bad😭