Killer Cases: Girlfriend Brutally Murders Lawyer Boyfriend and Claimed ‘Self-Defense’

[@emilylitchko9414]

Ahahahhahahaha she thought she was getting a new trial and gonna get less time but they gave her MORE. Omg chefs kiss perfection!

[@mrdarkcurvo]

Really

[@latenight6750]

She’s sitting there, thinking about that the whole time😂

[@vivianaestremera5381]

Yup! That dancing and singing when it just happened says everything anyone needs to know about her

[@andreabosley1669]

​@@vivianaestremera5381reminds me of Jodi Aries dancing and singing.

[@tonysolar284]

😙👌

[@jen9015]

You can't tell people you're going to kill your BF and then claim it was self defense

[@jmc8626]

Purely idiotic on her behalf

[@Teri_B.]

@@jmc8626 Yes, it was. They keep claiming she's a very bright, intelligent, young woman, but I haven't seen any evidence to back up that claim. 🚫🤓

[@awshortclips]

@@Teri_B. Pretty much. She actually offered up the "He was still alive and suffering so I mercy-killed him" as a rational statement.

[@Teri_B.]

@@awshortclips That was crazy. 🙃 She's definitely her own worst enemy. I'm glad she'll be locked up for good. 🙏🏼💞

[@EmilyFShockley]

The 911 call - - "I killed my boyfriend in self defense..." Right. . . . ..

[@SusanTrelease]

Just because Shayna claimed Ryan said a number of mean things, does NOT mean he actually said ANY of those things. She is a chronic, self-centered liar.

[@DawnRoache-y9n]

I honestly think 🤔 those were her OWN insecurities.

[@ChoppingtonOtter]

They don't come over as speech someone would actually say. The stuff she claims he said about orgasms does not sound like anyones speech pattern and even sounds like a fabrication.

[@StressBurger]

you also shouldnt kill people even if they do say mean things

[@jacquelenevonweyhe-o1y]

OMG I just assumed he said those things but your so right he probably didn’t all of his texts were so kind if he had texted her nasty messages her attorney would have read them thank you so much for that input

[@annmc-t7p]

My thoughts EXACTLY. I think she was verbalizing what she deep down thought about herself, or what she perceived that others thought of her. This one's bizarre.

[@guygeezer1468]

"I killed my boyfriend in self defense.." Not only was the murder premeditated, so was the coverup.

[@jenniferbond7073]

Who says that anyway? That sounds sooo unnatural if you were actually trying to protect yourself.

[@cheriebrais6913]

😊

[@grasmi]

Premeditated, but not very well…

[@rasitaherian3121]

Girls and guys if your boyfriend or girlfriend wants to move on just let them go! You will find another person. Life is so precious.

[@PresidentialRel]

Leave insecure people alone, she was jealous his new girlfriend was beautiful and she's only a 6 at best

[@AllenBurbank-z1c]

100% agree with you

[@grogu411]

I agree move on. But not everyone finds somebody. Some people die alone.

[@cheriebrais6913]

So very true

[@ava9xx3js9j]

Yes but I do feel bad for long time partners that are left with nothing after dedicating many years to their partner and ignoring their own needs for that person. If it’s short time partners makes sense to just let go. But this is why marriage when ends all property is split and I think it’s fair even if the wife is the attorney or doctor or whatever.

[@subrosa4792]

“So you shot him again instead of calling 911?”

[@michael5654]

"Yeah, a couple times!" lmao

[@mjthemoviecritic7426]

That part! That was horrible to hear and the shock that she repeated it😢

[@garciagarcia4390]

And she thought that made perfect sense 🥴🥴🥴

[@junehanzawa5165]

​@@garciagarcia4390 It made perfect sense -- make sure he can't testify. 😂

[@PatrycjaNazir]

😢😢😢😢​@@michael5654

[@Therezumee92]

His sisters Teddy bear broke my heart. Very powerful moment for sure.

[@ashleexanna]

That..got me crying. Heartbreaking.

[@DarthStoned420]

Me too i broke down

[@greenman6141]

I thought it was deeply creepy, unhealthy and manipulative.

[@AndyT-np8mm]

@@Therezumee92 I didn't really understand. Did she say the bear was stuffed with cotton from his shirts?

[@cats1900]

I think the bear was made from his shirt.​@@AndyT-np8mm

[@Tranger1994]

I hated reading/watching cases like this where these abusive, murdering, POS try to paint the dead victims as some kind of monster. Makes me sick to my stomach because a dead person can't defend themselves.

[@belindaalexandriasyevens-smith]

Absolutely, she makes me sick girl

[@DJRenee]

It only matters when you know they are COMPLETELY LYING ON A INNOCENT VICTIM OF THEIR DEADLY ACTIONS.

[@annc.3908]

The major take away is how the bull they spewed about his ‘words’ to her made her have to respond in murder? Bs. Words are words. He probably didn’t even say any of the bs anyway but IF he did words do not equal death. Amazing how these criminals and their lawyers always have some bs to put in the case to embarrass the victims. Lawyers should be disbarred for saying bs.

[@evalovett]

Especially since they KNOW what they did was wrong. They have a full grasp on what is wrong and they do it anyways

[@MyHome7_Carla]

It has to be so crushing for the family to hear all that. Even they were lies.

[@aprilparlor2918]

How the 911 operator called it out. “He threw you into the the couch but you don’t have injuries.” And “so you shot him instead of calling 911.” She immediately knew she was full of it.

[@vjw227]

Her mom saying her child’s life has also been taken?…. She threw it away thinking she could kill someone and get away with it

[@jewels3895]

Like mother like daughter

[@PatrycjaNazir]

​@jewels3895. 😅😅

[@haintedhouse2990]

@@jewels3895 agree. favorite quote from mom: "my daughter is not a murderer" uh yeah she kinda is

[@jacquelenevonweyhe-o1y]

I love how you repeated what the mother said that her daughters life was also taken It was not also taken she gave it away by her heinous murdering act of pure evil She gave away her freedom

[@UnprofessionalGriefer]

And the mom had nothing to say to the ACTUAL victims of the crime, Ryan and his family. She's a piece of work like her daughter is

[@Kthb80]

if you take someone’s life, it should be life, not 20-50 years..

[@YaLittleFriend]

Exactly.

[@dingus6317]

women get shorter sentences for some reason

[@sierragivenchy9526]

@@dingus6317she got sentenced to more time after her second trial, as she should have been

[@marcovdabeast]

Ya seriously it costs money to keep them in there by us taxpayers 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@QuilaGee]

Should have been two life sentences since he was a kid.

[@Christimony222]

She is the type of woman all sane mothers and sisters warn the men of their lives about.

[@cathyprosser1050]

Yes, definitely

[@DJRenee]

Yep

[@blueaquarius1505]

💯

[@playboyCrew]

Which type of men?

[@cindy4628]

​@@playboyCrewOP says "men in their lives" --that just means any man they care about (brother, cousins, friends) they will warn them about how crazy women exist and to not get lost in the sauce

[@Sloanmatthews]

Imagine being Audrey…forever tied to this story. Never even met the poor guy and had to take the stand at trial.

[@DJRenee]

That totally sucks. And entertaining the thought that she was one who probably got him killed that particular night

[@PC4ever]

@@DJRenee No, she didn't get him killed, w/or w/out this new girl, he was going to die either way bec his ex is insane.

[@Katiee0592]

@@PC4ever Your comment makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. She did get him killed (not the words I’d use, but the point gets across). It was the idea of him being with the Kentucky girl, specifically, and his interest in her, not someone else, that pushed the crazy ex-gf to become jealous, irrational and murder him. It would have been and could have been any girl, but it wasn’t. It was this girl. Idk how you could think anything different. She had an image of her downloaded to her computer, and they were going on a date the night she took his life. She wasn’t going to let that date take place, with her. No “would haves” about it. This is what happened.

[@mushypeasplease8872]

​@@Katiee0592 your statement makes no sense. In fact it's way off base. It's the statement a perpetrator would make, or at least someone who accepts and inhabits the justifying paradigm of the perpetrator. It's a victim blaming statement and why you can't see that is incredible. You're one step away from saying he got himself killed by choosing that different woman. The only person who got this guy killed is the murderer.

[@euphorbia1581]

@@DJRenee No, she's not the reason he got murder. If not for her, it would have been another one

[@bamaQT99]

I am so tired of people using mental illness as an excuse. BPD is not an excuse.

[@FiladelfiaNow]

This lawyer sets a dangarous precedent trying to justify lack of emotional control. He says that given her break up and jealousy she was entitled lawfully to end this man and she should not be prosecuted...

[@Birdrobin15]

I agree, worked with people with BPD for years abd they normally hurt themselves

[@DaVinciCosmeticsUSA]

me too

[@electrickrain]

Gtfoh. Stop acting like you're some mental health expert. Apparently her illness affected her deeply enough to cause this.

[@sophside9931]

Agreed. I’m tired of it. Any mental health issue is also not an excuse for any type of abusive behaviour.

[@sunnirv]

7:50 “ so you shot him a couple of more times instead of calling 911” she’s like yea self defense. Like what?! Insane. 😂

[@jykirachanelle2599]

so funny

[@capo4ever334]

Amazing she had originally gotten 40 years and then had a retrial and got life without parole 😂😂😂😂 should have just begged for them to not retry 😂😂😂😂

[@joebloggs1317]

For me, life is better than forty years, I could imagine nothing worse than being released at 60-70 years old with nothing, that would be worse than spending the rest of her life in jail.

[@SehamAdam-fu1cu]

She put the judge through the nigmare of seeing her again. She should get multiple life sentences. She's evil.

[@rhoodj]

😢😮😢

[@michellesum7173]

@@joebloggs1317 yeah, that’s depressing. No money, no children, no husband and parents are really old or have passed away due to old age. 40 years is a really long time

[@joebloggs1317]

@@michellesum7173 watched a few documentaries re life terms for children, a law was passed preventing the practice and children already sentenced would have a hearing and a reduction of time to serve. This one lad had his reduced to 55 years, 55, he was 15 at the time of the offence, nobody died. Absolutely tragic.

[@JessLBreen]

37:30 I think it's VERY strange she begins crying and laying her head straight down into her young male attorney's lap! She begs for all male attention!

[@cathyprosser1050]

That was quite sickening but just one of many positions she regularly took with men, in my opinion. Not since Jodi Arias have I found a defendant so utterly depraved as this gal.

[@clarissathompson0103]

Absolutely uncomfortable and shows how immature she is doing that before the verdict was even read.

[@ronniemead805]

@@cathyprosser1050 Sadly most of the people you come across daily are just as depraved.

[@tippy81]

She may have thought she could get another lawyer BF

[@k12660]

I would be very interested to know what her parents are like/ how she was raised.

[@stormyskyz4251]

This girl is an absolute monster omg. I feel so sad for his family to have sat through her lies.

[@DJRenee]

Literally. Her family had to know she is NUTS!

[@subrosa4792]

Is she the one who wore the “Survivor” T-shirt, or was that Jodi Arias? It was one of the crazy boyfriend killers that sings in the interrogation room. I get them mixed up.

[@dink_diggler]

She's nuts!

[@vivianaestremera5381]

@@subrosa4792definitely Jodi

[@yettawilliams5294]

@@subrosa4792 that was Jodi

[@chickensdone1]

The judge’s face when the defense lawyer was talking was funny He looked like he was thinking “Wtf am I listening to?”

[@InChristWeTrust999]

There is no deeper disrespect than to murder someone in cold blood and then act like the victim and blame the actual victim. Her case was so flimsy that they had to rely on the fact he was ‘sending mixed signals’ in a court of law. As if that’s a plausible excuse to murder someone. Absolutely laughable. She killed him and then disgraced his name with lies.

[@DJRenee]

He didn't have a healthy fear of how CRAZY THIS GIRL WAS

[@1anythingandeverything]

same as travis

[@CherryGryffon]

That's just it. She WASN'T. Not to anyone around her, anyway. She was a pretty average girl with a dose of grandiosity about herself.

[@AJLinthe5D]

​@@CherryGryffonShe was. She had at least one personality disorder. She acts really crazy. Just look at her when she's in the police station singing and dancing.

[@Kindkaly23]

@@AJLinthe5D Exactly. Just like Jodi. Remember she was doing hand stands in the interrogation room? I’ll never forget it smfh

[@LB-kh4jd]

These are my favorite true crime docs now- awesome editing and info

[@kellyriddell5014]

@LB-kh4jd I like that they interview the defense and prosecution, so we get insight into both of their strategies.

[@boobookitty1441]

This is one of the interrogations I watch the most .. bc nobody even talks to her after she asks for a lawyer but she just tells all to anyone that will listen 🤯

[@blue8493]

Apparently for 3 hours on video says her attorney- maybe not as "smart" as they say, eh?

[@Kindkaly23]

They should never let the convicted suspects family speak. It’s so insulting to the families/victims. Unless they’re taking the stand to apologize on behalf of their family they need to just be quiet. Period.

[@haintedhouse2990]

agree. even though it gives insight to where the convicted got their crazy. favorite quote from Shayna's mom: "my daughter is not a murderer" uh yeah she kinda is.

[@perrytree01]

Exactly this! Totally agree!

[@112233JORDAN]

How would you feel about this if the suspect were actually innocent? What if it were you and you were innocent. Would you not want people who know you best to give the jury a better understanding of who you are? You are supposed to be given the presumption of innocence during the trial.

[@haintedhouse2990]

@@112233JORDAN your comparison doesn't apply. Shayna admitted to killing him waay before the trial. nobody was entertaining the idea of her innocence.

[@mariashbay4247]

When she is testifying about Ryan telling her she was f'd up because of molestation when she was younger, you could tell she was lying. It was written all over her face. She deserves to be locked up for life!

[@UTAHtheN0bleBirthright-]

I don't read facial expressions very accurately, but I did think her words and intonation seemed off..seemed like she was voicing her own thoughts about herself. He very well could have been saying cruel words to her to get her to leave. Maybe just not those exact words. Her testimony just seemed off somehow. 😔

[@ebony9999]

Absolutely making it up as she went

[@115dancingqueen]

Shades of Amber Heard

[@maryoleary5044]

@@ebony9999 vile comment

[@phyllissowhat]

It is disgusting that Shayna tried to disparage Ryan even in his death for her gain. That is a true sociopath.

[@nimitz1739]

The older I get the more I learned those kind of people are everywhere

[@Truth17John17]

She had those attorneys helping her. Did you ever notice how everyone in court must sware to tell the whole truth and nothing but the truth EXCEPT for the defense attorneys who are encouraged to LIE all over the place?

[@latenight6750]

Deep

[@Indusxstan]

So true!

[@splinterbyrd]

Don't blame him for dumping this little ×××× for Miss Ohio. Can't believe he got mixed up with her in the first place. An exemplary young guy betrayed.

[@dorisoppong8664]

Evil does exist. RIP Ryan 😢

[@RescueAlwaysOfficial]

Ryan himself sounds evil. That said she had zero right to kill him. She should have stayed away from him.

[@Reicqadonna]

Girl… just go to jail and hush. Smh

[@GrandPapi95]

Right

[@LadyAtheOnly]

Forreal.

[@wendysmobilehomesweethome423]

Best comment ever! And so appropriate!

[@subrosa4792]

Didn’t she marry a trans person in the prison? Like they were both together in the prison and shackin’ up? She’s desperate for attention and affection.

[@bringthepayne7561]

​@@subrosa4792Really.....

[@MimiMkenya]

The judge's face: 😒😒😒😒 Yea your honour, same.

[@domingas.teca0695]

34:37 😂😂😂 he doesn’t believe it, the Judge has to be more convinced

[@j.b.l.0-f3z]

I cried seeing his sister up there on the stand with the teddy bear made out of her brothers shirt. 😢

[@micheleevans4056]

When this first happened and was reported by the news, I thought she was manipulating and if she couldn't have him; she wanted no one to have him. She was by no means crazy, she was selfish and jealous.

[@HeyyallitsHope_]

Her face gives her away everytime lol especially when she saying bc of her passed that he didn’t love her and that no one would ever love her she glances to the jury to see how they reacted 🤦🏼‍♀️

[@QuilaGee]

I caught that

[@phoenixmerridian9119]

she' cant button up her shirt either

[@jeanicebarnett4130]

She was still so safistacated about herself I never once saw any remorse from her.

[@vj8406]

Justice was served. Life without parole.

[@chrissyellem7397]

I like how the judge doesn't believe a word of the defense lol

[@ston9y]

Oh my goodness I did not expect that picture of him laying there rest in peace that is so sad..

[@TamiTribbiani-im1go]

I don't think that was suppose to be shown, someone screwed up. But it was horrible!

[@bekahe4433]

​@@TamiTribbiani-im1goI think you're right because all the other crime scene photos of his body were censored.

[@devdevelo]

The judge is unable to hide that he's thoroughly amused.

[@PresidentialRel]

They're calling her beautiful but she's a solid 6 . The pedestal yt girls are put on is laughable 😭

[@iyadsubh]

This is the first thing I got when I saw the judge.

[@ChoppingtonOtter]

​@@PresidentialRelA 6 in the posed photographs but nowhere near a 6 in real life.

[@PresidentialRel]

@@ChoppingtonOtter right probably a 3-4 at best

[@BaldGym]

@@PresidentialRel she is beautiful....

[@decemberkat]

How crazy to say or think like Shayna! It’s bone chilling to hear her say “I gave him the nose job he wanted” and how she claims she had to finish him off to help him! I really hope she never gets out! What a psychopath!

[@summerdrye4030]

You should watch her full interrogation on here. Super crazy and she acts like a way to happy lunatic rather than someone who just killed her BF of over a year. She’s definitely Jodi Arias 2.0

[@DJRenee]

​@@summerdrye4030I think I'm more scared of this girl than Jodi.

[@robynpopescu3180]

Agree!

[@MissouriBirds]

That was insane and I have no idea why she said that. It seems like the entire time she was acting crazy in that interrogation room, and possibly saying things out of outright anger in order to justify her actions. She hated him. Very sad story.

[@miogi0072]

She is going to get out...in a body bag.

[@jille659]

This is so terrible for him. My Condolences to his Family and Friends 🙏🏼🙏🏼. May he Rest Peacefully 🕯️🕊️

[@KathleenRushing-po4hg]

Amen

[@Michelle-qq4sd]

I keep hearing “Miss Hubris” and it fits.

[@vasily2022]

Her mother giving her statement at the end showed where she got her crocodile tears and egocentrism from.

[@buslady3705]

Her mother doesn't want to see her go to prison, but there is no way she is not aware of how dangerous her daughter's mental condition is. If released, she would kill again.

[@franceswray8340]

I love the judges face, he really isn't buying any of it.

[@Vivere17]

I love these kinds of documentaries and I love this channel. Gives us a look inside cases some of us haven’t even heard of.

[@applejuicejunkie316]

They've explored this case multiple times. It's time for some new cases.

[@marsharowaihy6725]

Oh, I’ve heard about this ! Big case

[@Vivere17]

Agreed !

[@JustMe-px9qy]

Shanya reminds me of Courtney Clenny,Jodi Arias and Molly Martens. They all murdered their boyfriends/husbands and left a path of death and destruction in their wake. And they all claimed to be victims of DV

[@syljm515]

And a hint of Amber Heard

[@lena-mariaglouis-charles7036]

​@@syljm515 Johnny Depp was lucky to escape her wrath. My heart aches for her adopted, innocent baby daughter... and what she might have to endure - before she's old enough to walk away.

[@JustMe-px9qy]

@@syljm515 - Yes. Definitely Amber Heard too

[@syrenisnigh]

meh Travis had it coming idkkk

[@cathyprosser1050]

​@lena-mariaglou 26:24 is-charles7036 I believe that too. If he had stayed, he would not be alive today

[@Ren0799]

Sounds like she mirrored her own internal thoughts about herself onto Ryan claiming he said those things to her. And where are her tears!?? She’s weird, very bizarre.

[@FiladelfiaNow]

Self projecting . Probably that's her inner dialogue

[@FeelinKnitty]

A volatile life because someone text her she was lying and using drugs? 😮

[@PallasAndDove]

😂 To some.

[@frograna1897]

Crazy. My lover started loosing interest in me..I walked away as soon as he showed signs. I don't wanna beg /pitty someone into being into me..

[@laurenwright4273]

Thats what u do when u are emotional stable and healthy. I was always like that till one man then I realized I must not be emotionally ok right then to try to win a man over who isnt putting in the same effort. Irs an eye opener for when u need therapy

[@DiannaPrince2000]

IKR!? She was so desperate. It was pathetic. I most definitely do not want to stay with a guy who doesn't want to be with me. I was almost embarrassed for her. Pyureates!!

[@DiannaPrince2000]

​@@laurenwright4273 I agree.

[@jessicajamesspeaks]

I used to beg guys for attention and affection and it got me absolutely nowhere! Shayna Hubers is where she belongs! It took me until my 30s to realize that there are plenty of men out there! Just can’t chase or beg them 🤷🏽‍♀️

[@pandroidigital]

Losing

[@backuptrick4477]

She's constantly looking at the jury to see if they're buying her lies.😂😂

[@meighanrupert1439]

Gives Amber Heard vibes…

[@Emy53]

Ryan wasn't an abuser. Shayna was a jealous phyco. I hate when the law allows to use the mental defense when clearly, she was in her right mind, and shot him because she was jealous and felt she was losing him.

[@l.w.paradis2108]

Oh yes he was. It's in court documents that are easy to find. The poor guy needed rehab but was afraid to get help because of his job.

[@stopthephilosophicalzombie9017]

I think you mean psycho.

[@l.w.paradis2108]

@brigittabalog5226 He needed rehab. He wanted to get better but was afraid to get therapy because of his job. It had nothing to do with her. She did all his cooking and cleaning. His guns and ammo were on display everywhere. She needed to shudder at the stuff he was saying to her and run away, not toward. She was truly crazy. It's all public, in court documents. These people want to pretend she's another Jody Arias and punish Jody again. Or Amber Heard. Spinning it that way gets clicks. 💰💰💰

[@l.w.paradis2108]

@brigittabalog5226 If you ever read the sick stuff he texted her (and afterwards, she went right back to serving him, instead of straight out of town for a vacation, then a trip to a psychiatrist), you'd see the real picture. I've known troubled women, but no one who would put up with what she did from a boyfriend. He had literally unbearable job pressures and was always on some drugs, not all of which were prescribed. That's what he was trapped by.

[@KathleenHopper-o3j]

Even if i didn't know Shayna killed someone i still wouldn't like her.🙄

[@rr2402]

Her dance at interrogation was chilling to say the least

[@Oceaneyes-eh6vs]

Ashley has always had the scariest look about her.

[@DawgMama]

I bet he rolls over in his grave EVERY time she is referred to as "his girlfriend". Ole girl was not his gf. She was a hit it who refused to let him quit it.

[@marsupreme900]

Facts bro u kno once a dude say u deserve better you already know he off her

[@Danny-td1ht]

🤣

[@fluminesesoc]

Yup.She was not his type at all .Smashing just gave him something to do until he got bored of her and wanted a beauty pageant winner.

[@Drippppppppp]

And you know she was willing to do anything 😂😂😂 wild

[@beepbopboop7727]

He was an ex. Simple as that.

[@ChrundleTGreat]

Hearing two attorneys talk about concrete when they know nothing about how concrete is made is hilarious.

[@devan3059]

I wanted to ask the Home Depot employee, did you see her purchase the one she was looking for? Did someone help her load it into her car? I would talk to the parking lot employees

[@atira-lumenamusical-artist4863]

I think I caught them at the end saying about her using soil aswell so maybe the mixture of both the soil and fine grain concrete mix gave a different texture.

[@buslady3705]

​@@devan3059Also, I was thinking, was that the only store around that sold concrete?

[@bogeydope3022]

Killing someone with an OD of coke administered through beer is the dumbest thing i ever heard.

[@ocdrums24]

“My childs life has also been taken” nah. She took it away herself.

[@tracysires2234]

Jodi Arias anyone??

[@musingsofamadman3178]

Exactly!

[@lena-mariaglouis-charles7036]

Yes... they both are manipulative narcissists - empty shells refusing to take "no" for an answer.

[@chrzoc]

The interrogation room shenanigans…first thing I said was “Oh, Hey Jodi” lol

[@brittbrat4977]

I'm glad I'm not the only one who thought of that crazy b****

[@roz805]

She’s a graduate of the Amber Heard School of Phony Testimony

[@kianaovoxo5657]

These murderers think they’re so smart but there’s always 100 holes in their stories.

[@AJLinthe5D]

How arrogant to think they won't get caught. Ashley is a cold fish.

[@ChopOnBraves2025]

I had grad school classes with her. We were in the mental health counseling program. She was a VERY strange, narcissistic person.

[@haintedhouse2990]

so Shayna was in the mental health counseling program - i take it she flunked.

[@ChopOnBraves2025]

@@haintedhouse2990 She was only there from August until October.

[@rileymilan]

😮

[@CesarRetamoza]

Super strange in her text messages too, when you beg someone they lose even more interest...

[@CherryGryffon]

She was very self absorbed, yes. It really started showing in high school (Where I knew her from). She started out just an average bookish girl, plain looking, understated, never really NOT put together but didn't put a lot of work into her appearance it seemed. And then out of nowhere she started GOING for it, dolling herself up, wearing makeup, putting her hair up, dressing more "polished". None of us took it as /too/ weird tho that I know of, because she was an otherwise average upper middle class Kentucky girl.

[@lesflynn4455]

Man she is dead cold. Didn't shed one tear during the whole thing. Something is broken inside her, for sure. If she was free, she could easily kill again.

[@Jackholiday1025]

she did shed tears but of course it was only because she felt bad for himself not because she felt bad for what she did.

[@boldbearings]

"Omg why'd you show the body at 33:35 ?" Go ahead to run that uncensored. Be that channel. 💯

[@susien7323]

I honestly believe that she wanted to be tied to Ryan forever. Just like how Mark Chapman is forever linked to John Lennon. I think Shayna wanted to forever be linked to Ryan. She would’ve never been his type. Desperate and clingy and like she said she was tossed out of the condo and she could’ve walked away, but she did not. Crazy crazy stalker , chick.

[@haintedhouse2990]

yep in every photo of them she's got the psycho smile that says "I've got him now"

[@DJRenee]

​@haintedhouse2990 agreed

[@luanngarcia6435]

Reminds me of Amber Heard, in a wayl. That playing to the audience to gauge their reaction to what she is saying. And trying to use phony domestic violence as an excuse for her over the top behavior.

[@oneofmany7051]

​@@luanngarcia6435I knew she reminded me of someone! Amber Heard would have made sure Johnny Depp ended up like Ryan Poston, too, if given a little more time.

[@AmySarahhh]

@@luanngarcia6435 absolutely! Amber heard and Jodi arias 😶

[@sheaboisvert9077]

They shouldn’t let the parents of a convicted killer talk sorry not sorry

[@Anniew7815]

Interesting that after making the claims about what he said about her being unloveable because she was touched as a child, she looks over and is obviously tryimg to gauge everyone's reaction to see if they're buying it.

[@DJRenee]

I noticed. Sounded like she was projecting her own inner thoughts.

[@Allynavarro2435]

Even she looked uncomfortable 😳 saying that….

[@BrittanyStar]

"he was trying to burgle me!" "they both reached for the gun!" (ROXY HEART - CHICAGO!) 😂 XOXO

[@tundrawomansays694]

Amber Herd redux.

[@antheairenedevilliers1657]

Her statements during interrogation are filled with gleeful malice. She was so pleased with herself!

[@rosshurst5630]

When you tell 911 "I killed someone in self-defense" That's a red flag.

[@felipeacostamunoz1249]

Explain why

[@loversofanimal]

39:42 his father said it best. His kindness got him killed! 😢😢

[@jaykay1074]

Why does she look like she is auditioning for a role in a movie when she is on stand. Nothing she is saying feels genuine it doesn’t even seem like she believes the story.

[@shannontreiber1070]

I believe that everyone deserves a good defense attorney. It’s our system. It’s fair. But I could NOT defend this woman.

[@trizzlehizzle9068]

that basically admits youre a bad lawyer

[@angelasome9044]

I would have to if I was a public DA if the judge said so. Privately? No way. Take your money somewhere else.

[@angelasome9044]

That does not a “bad Lawyer” make. I have morals and scruples, and not interested.

[@angelasome9044]

So, you are a murderer, right? Yes, but…..ok,, I think we are done here. Best wishes.

[@angelasome9044]

Self defense? No, I’m a stalker. Oh. Double good luck.

[@EcecVeron]

This is my first time to see Law&Crime post a picture of a victims dead body. Its so sad to see 😢😢😢

[@SabrinaHanks-vp7ls]

@@EcecVeron I was literally thinking the same thing

[@KaayBeeee]

I think that might have been added in mistakenly? I was shocked, I wish I hadn't seen that

[@hueykraymond]

She said, she gave him the nose job he wanted like wow WTF

[@jjhfcf_metal6259]

It always amazes me how loosely people use the word "beautiful" when referring to women like Ashley McArthur. 😮

[@haintedhouse2990]

same with Jodi Arias - without make-up she looks like Aunt Maria from the roadside taco stand

[@lauriedavis400]

@@haintedhouse2990BUAHAHAA _whaaat?!_ 😆

[@rnempson1]

Not beautiful

[@AJLinthe5D]

​@@haintedhouse2990The peroxide blonde hair helped detract from her face. Many women rely on the bleach for that purpose. As a natural brunette Jodie is quite unattractive.

[@Langley_Ackerman19]

Average more like

[@juliestrom412]

Eighteen months on and off nothing. He wanted to dump her when he knew she was nuts long before the eighteen months. He was a dead man as soon as she set her sights on him. She was a hunter if he didnt comply she would kill. He was a dead man walking for awhile poor guy. 😮

[@DJRenee]

Right. No discernment on his part.

[@thetravelgoods2760]

@@DJReneewhich is crazy, for an attorney!

[@nope_n0pe]

@@thetravelgoods2760 It’s common for people to take on careers doing things they can’t do in their personal life. But I completely understand what you mean… friends say he was just a really nice guy who never wanted to hurt women. He could never say no to her because he thought that would make him mean 🥺

[@laurenwright4273]

​​@@thetravelgoods2760men never take women seriously tbh. If they did, they wouldnt keep jumping in bed with crazy after they see signs

[@crazybillie2498]

It's sad almost like he wrote his own death certificate.. because he reached out to the looney bin. He love looks. Most of those woman or superficial and only think of themselves. Rip i really hate this for his family

[@nimo517]

I’m sick of Borderline Personality Disorder as an insanity defense. Just because we found more than evil as a scientific term, it’s not an excuse.. just like “She killed someone which means she obviously had BPD and we need to find out what caused this! Not who…”

[@Deathstar-Cheeseburger]

Right?! I have so many friends who have BPD. None of them would murder a person. It's a bogus defense.

[@esotericjahanism5251]

Yeah man people with personality disorders aren't delusional or hallucinating. They still know and are aware they are doing something against the law and is viewed as wrong by society.

[@Loyale1229]

I have BPD and have neverrrr thought of hurting anyone else… It’s quite the opposite, people with BPD self harm…

[@jessicabullington8616]

I have it and I'm tired of the stigma. It's so hurtful to borderline people

[@nimo517]

I’m a recovering addict 3.5 years almost 4 sober, after using 40% of my life… When I hear the term addiction thrown around, like “he’s addicted to video games” and ruins the meaning What’s it like..? Sorry but I’m so interested

[@assassinspoiler3488]

He tried to get her out of his life she wasn't gonna leave him a lone poor guy she needs put away for life

[@bfreeinjesus2323]

Ryan was an absolutely handsome and professional young man! Justice was served to his murderer! RIP Ryan!

[@hellokeroppi5406]

He threw me across the room but no injuries. Yea. Guilty.

[@antiquesrestoration3874]

She's clearly a liar and not a very good one at that.

[@sistahspeaks9816]

After the threat is eliminated you stop,she turned it into murder soon as she took that second shot.

[@stopthephilosophicalzombie9017]

He was never a threat.

[@novawallenda7848]

"I gave him the nose job he always wanted" she's definitely getting GUILTY

[@PrimeCrimeWatch]

This video is very useful for those exploring this subject, thank you!

[@rockseaH2O]

When Ashley was being interviewed, she said “she(Taylor) was a strange girl” not ‘is’ but *WAS* I can’t believe no one caught that

[@devan3059]

I caught that too!!!

[@ooulalah4333]

She had the beauty of youth, nothing more

[@kenw2225]

Meh, she's attractive for an inmate. Probably gets lots of dude money placed on the acct.

[@bruppee11]

Shayna is nuts. I remember my best friend was in a cell with her at the jail in newport and she would brag about killing him and read her letters from her fans to everyone in the cell as if she were a celebrity. She would tell anyone in there bc she thought she was cool and famous.

[@meredithcoleman446]

Seriously?

[@Woodburnworks]

^

[@bbe3034]

And Shayna is absolutely guilty of murdering her boyfriend!!

[@cathyprosser1050]

Doesn't surprise me much. She's that degree of depraved

[@DJRenee]

😮😮😮😮

[@loolablackshot7607]

The face of the judge listening to the lawyer almost felling asleep 😂

[@Chris-wn9hi]

The first case reinforces the need to keep guns locked up, or at least not laying around when having a heated argument with an unstable person.

[@rskandari]

We don't know where the gun was. You are buying her version of the story.

[@gargoylegirl247]

33:33 Wasn't expecting that! Wonder why that wasn't blurred out like the other pics.

[@CC-or9gd]

Omg me neither !!!

[@janicescott6569]

I wasn’t either buy maybe to drive home the fact of how this innocent man was brutally murdered in cold blood. It was shocking though because we weren’t expecting it and then there it was and so graphic.

[@aprilcaricchio4309]

So incredibly sad

[@Bunnygio]

omg me neither I was like “oops??”

[@supernovahm1178]

I was assuming that was AI generated - why does he have ECG electrodes on his back?

[@dietdrpepper15]

“She WAS a great girl”. Ashley done messed UP.

[@shannontreiber1070]

IGuessing that’s why she freaked out when she found out he was talking to an actual beauty Queen. She is a pretty girl-but felt competition with this new girl. Her ego got to her.

[@Prismalpink]

Never tell anyone you’re leaving and just ghost them. Move away as far as possible.

[@robertawestbrooks9531]

😮😮this girl has big holes in her story. She's a bad lier, and deserves jail time. A wasted life, for such a young handsome young man 😢😢

[@ny4trn515]

Her mom tried to cry so bad on the stand but couldn’t

[@iamfeliciarenee7331]

I am so heartbroken for the sister and family! 😢

[@Ambular_Amber05]

Didn’t she say that he picked her up and set her outside his apartment and she wanted back in to get her things? If that were the case, if she were truly that terrified for her life, you’d think she would have left at that point and came back for her things when she had someone with her and could protect her. 🤔

[@ronniemead805]

I just cannot wrap my head around a woman that young and beautiful and talented and in University loosing it to this extend over this one guy; when there are dozens more bigger and better fishes in the sea. Ladies don't love anyone more than you love yourself, enough to throw your life away over them.

[@scienceman1837]

@@ronniemead805 did you even watch the video?

[@sarahkatherine8303]

@@ronniemead805 when you put it that way, you make her sound like a victim instead of the violent and narcissistic psychopath she is. And you make him sound like he was unworthy of her, when there was NO signs that he abused her and every sign that she falsely accused and abused him in multiple ways. Very twisted. Honestly your perspective exemplifies the consequences of the toxic “me too” movement and it is scary to see. She didn’t “throw away her life” so much as the “threw away” the life of her innocent victim. She still lives comfortable prison, where they allow these monsters to take crocheting, art, and baking classes, play basketball, get married, etc. Her victim had his life taken from him.

[@ronniemead805]

@@sarahkatherine8303 Very well said and I agree; but I was NOT speaking about this violent woman specifically; but all women in general. I guess I put it wrongly. Sorry.

[@rustyblade5845]

@@ronniemead805 So what's did he do to deserve that ? You couldn't just say there are plenty more fish in the sea ? Your as bad as her IMO.

[@Ummkulthum1998]

Did they just show us the dead person???

[@Gulag00]

33:32 think so

[@Carab3671]

Yeah, awful

[@FiladelfiaNow]

​@@Carab3671seek help

[@johns.1508]

@@Carab3671 why is it awful?

[@WhyDoYouCare6503]

I feel sorry for the family of the victim especially his Mother🥹🥹🥹💔💔💔 Heart wrenching.💔💔💔😢😢😢

[@dae4444]

Her acting on the stand was so hard to watch! Cringe!

[@ebg3624]

Her interrogation video is insane

[@myadoua06]

Aww his sisters testimony made me cry so much. She is a stalker who lost it when he didn’t want her anymore. Can’t believe the defense tried to use the mental excuse. You could tell she was evil, calculated and manipulative.

[@EldePHX]

His sister was fake crying not sincere at all.

[@PallasAndDove]

Ummmm Law & Crime? Ummmm You do know that the bloody dead body of the victim is in full view?? No warning or nothing. WTF

[@ElleMayeslife]

I can’t believe the picture of him shot dead was flashed on my screen…super sad 😞

[@spamtownhamilton6200]

Yeah I was not ready for that.. As many times as I've seen this crime covered, I've never seen an actual pic and always imagined him sat at a dinner table from the way Shayna's story goes. Poor Ryan, it especially kills me hearing his sweet, warm siblings testify. RIP 💔

[@lesflynn4455]

I don't think they meant to do that. The unpixellated shot slipped through the cracks.

[@Berylliyum]

Yeah, I had to do a double take... even thought for a second it had to be fake, but didn't know.